Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026 & CM APPL. 331/2026
MR. ABHIMANYU PRAKASH & ORS.
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Samrat Nigam, Sr. Adv.
with Mr. Akshay Srivastava, Ms. Krati
Tiwari and Ms. Arpita Khanna, Advs.
versus
FERRERO S.P.A & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Pravin Anand, Ms. Vaishali
R. Mittal and Mr. Shivang Sharma, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
JUDGMENT(ORAL)
06.01.2026
%
C.HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
This appeal assails judgment dated 19 November 2025 and
order dated 8 December 2025 passed by a learned Single Judge of this
Court in CS (Comm) 65/2023, to a limited extent.
2.
We have heard Mr. Samrat Nigam, learned Senior Counsel for
the appellants and Mr. Pravin Anand, learned Counsel for the
respondents, at some length.
3.
The proceedings emanate from a suit instituted by the
respondents against the appellants seeking a decree of a permanent
injunction, restraining the appellants from infringing the respondents’
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
registered trademarks.
4.
Paras 2 and 3 of the impugned judgment dated 19 November
2025 set out the dispute in conspectus:
“2.
Plaintiffs have filed the present suit seeking a decree of
permanent injunction restraining the Defendants from, inter alia,
infringing the Plaintiffs' registered trademarks, including
‘
'
['NUTELLA
glass
jars']
'NUTELLA/
' and distinctive labels associated with the mark
'NUTELLA', passing off counterfeit goods under the identical
mark along with other ancillary reliefs and for damages and costs.
3.
The facts which have come on record reveal that Defendant
Nos. 1 to 3 are manufacturers and sellers of empty NUTELLA
glass jars which is a near identical copy of the original Nutella jar.
Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 state that the impugned NUTELLA glass
jars manufactured by them is referred to as Nutella jar in their
industry and the said Defendants were offering these glass jars on
their website as NUTELLA glass jars. Defendant No. 4 admits
offering the impugned NUTELLA glass jars for sale on its own
website and third-party e-commerce websites as NUTELLA glass
jars.”
5.
We need not enter into the niceties of the dispute, as the learned
Single Judge ultimately deemed it appropriate to summarily decree the
suit in terms of Order XIII-A of the Code of Civil Procedure,1908.
While doing so, the learned Single Judge has noted, in paras 15 to 18
of the order dated 19 November 2025, as under:
“15. The Plaintiffs are the registered proprietors of NUTELLA
trademarks including NUTELLA jar across various territories
around the world and have obtained registration under various
Classes. The products of the Plaintiffs under the distinctive and
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
proprietary NUTELLA,
trademarks and brand NUTELLA are made available for
sale throughout India in different sizes, i.e. 180 ml, 350 ml and 750
ml.
16.
Defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 are manufacturers and sellers of
empty glass jars in 180 ml, 350 ml and 650 ml sizes which are
. The
deceptively similar to the Plaintiffs’ Nutella jar
Defendants were manufacturing the said impugned NUTELLA
glass jar without any authorisation from the Plaintiffs, and offering
the product for sale through their respective websites and online
platforms.
17.
In these facts, when the Plaintiffs filed the present suit, vide
order dated 06.02.2023, as also modified on 08.02.2023,
Coordinate Bench of this Court granted an ex-parte ad-interim
injunction restraining the Defendants from dealing with the
impugned 'NUTELLA glass jars'. Vide order dated 06.02.2023, the
Court also appointed three Local Commissioners to inventorize
and seize infringing material found at the premises of Defendant
Nos. 1 to 3.”
18.
The said injunction order dated 06.02.2023 was not
contested and in fact Defendants consented to its confirmation on
12.08.2025. As noted above, the injunction order was made
absolute on 12.08.2025.”
(Emphasis supplied)
6.
The learned Single Judge has ultimately awarded costs and has
further directed, apropos the seized jars, as under:
“39. In addition, since the impugned 3,05,916 jars seized from
location 18 and 09 jars seized from location 29 have been held to
be infringing, Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 shall handover all these seized
jars to the Plaintiff within two (2) weeks. The Plaintiff will be at
liberty to use these glass jars as it deems fit for its own use. In case,
the Plaintiff does not wish to use the jars for its own products for
retail selling, it may consider using these jars for filling up its
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
products and donating to NGOs who feed the poor, as a part of its
CSR ['Corporate Social Responsibility'] initiative. The value of the
seized jars has been assessed by the Plaintiff as Rs. 62.84 lakhs and
this handover of inventory results in losses to the Defendant Nos. 1
to 3 as well will act as deterrent against the Defendant Nos. 1 to 3.
The Defendants will destroy all the other packaging material found
and seized at the aforesaid premises, during the local commission,
in the presence of the representative of the Plaintiff within four (4)
weeks.”
(Emphasis supplied)
7.
We may also reproduce, in this context, paras 30 to 37 of the
order dated 19 November 2025, thus:
“30. The Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 have not filed any evidence with
their written statement to substantiate their plea that the empty
glass jars are generically referred to as Nutella jars in the
manufacturing industry and that Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 bonafide
manufactured the said impugned NUTELLA glass jar without
knowledge of the Plaintiff's proprietary rights in the shape of the
glass jar.
31.
This Court therefore finds no merit m the submission of the
Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 that they are the first-time innocent
infringer. Keeping in view the scale of operations of the Defendant
Nos. 1 to 3 and especially their reference to the glass jars as
NUTELLA jars on their website also shows that they are conscious
about the goodwill and reputation of the Plaintiff's registered
shape mark for the glass jar.
32.
The Plaintiff has pleaded that its Nutella products have
been available in the Indian market since 2009 and keeping in view
the considerable market presence of the Plaintiffs ' products in
India, the submission of the Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 that they were
unaware about the Plaintiffs ' proprietary rights in the shape mark
for the jar fails to persuade this Court. The Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 's
submission that there are other manufacturers in the industry who
manufacture identical infringing jars would not justify the
Defendants infringing actions. In these facts, this Court finds that
the Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 are first-time knowing infringers.
33.
The Plaintiff has contended that the seized goods (empty
glass jars) from location no. 2 bear an embossing (E20 O A) and
counterfeit products seized in CS(COMM) 43/2021 and
CS(COMM) 917/2022 also had the same embossing (E20 O A).
However, this pleading by itself is not sufficient to connect the
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 herein with the defendants of the other suits.
The Plaintiff, in this suit, has not placed on record any further
documents to show that Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 were involved in the
sale of the finished counterfeit products sold in the impugned glass
jars along with the defendants of the other suits. Defendant Nos. 1
to 3 have stated that this embossing (E20 O A) was done at the
instance of its customer. Plaintiff has elected not to pursue the said
customer in these proceedings. In these facts this Court is unable to
draw any further adverse inference against Defendant Nos. 1 to 3.
34.
This Court finds no material on record to bold that
Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 have colluded with third parties to sell
counterfeit products of NUTELLA. There is also no iota of
evidence in this suit with respect to any sale of counterfeit finished
products by Defendant Nos. 1 to 3. Therefore, the claim of the
Plaintiff in its written note for damages for Rs. 53.3 crores on an
imaginary value of finished counterfeit products of Rs. 533.10
crores is not tenable. In any event, no such pleading was made in
the application.
35.
The undisputed reports of the Local Commissioners and the
documents filed by the Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 itself provide a
reasonable basis to make an assessment for the average turnover of
the empty glass jars which the said Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 had from
October 20207 till February 2023. And, by applying the Rule 20 of
the IPD Rules, an assessment of the profit margin can be made.
36.
The contention of the Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 that they are
first-time innocent infringers in terms of the Koninlijke Philips1
(supra) judgment, appears not to be true to this Court, instead this
Court in view of the said judgement finds that the Defendant Nos.
1 to 3 are first-time knowing infringer.
37.
There is no other known case of infringement shown by the
Plaintiffs against the Defendant Nos. 1 to 3. The Defendant Nos. 1
to 3 have also elected to consent to the decree of permanent
injunction and not compelled the Plaintiffs to go through trial.
Keeping in view all these facts, this Court is of the considered
opinion that Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 are liable to be injuncted
permanently, to pay partial legal costs to the Plaintiff as well as the
permanent seizure of the inventory of impugned goods made by the
Local Commissioners to handover to the Plaintiff, in terms of the
aforesaid judgment Koninlijke Philips (supra). Therefore, this
Court is not undertaking an assessment of the turnover value of the
empty glass jars manufactured by the Defendants between October
2020 and February 2023.”
1 Koninlijke Philips and Ors. v. Amazestore and Ors. 2019 SCC OnLine Del 8198
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
8.
The appellants, thereafter, moved IA 30639/2025 seeking
modification of the aforenoted judgment dated 19 November 2025.
9.
The said application stands decided by order dated 8 December
2025, which is also subject matter of challenge before us. In the said
order, the learned Single Judge has recorded the statement of the
learned Counsel for the appellants that they had no objection to
payment of legal costs as directed by the learned Single Judge.
However, apropos the direction to release the seized jars to the
respondents, the appellants sought to contend that the jars were
ordinary glass jars which could be used for several other purposes
such as packing of honey, jams, pickles etc which would not, in any
way, prejudice the respondents.
This submission has apparently not found favour with the
10.
learned Single Judge, who did not choose to modify her earlier
judgment.
11.
Accordingly, by order dated 8 December 2025, the learned
Single Judge has dismissed IA 30639/2025.
12.
The appellants are in appeal before us against the aforesaid
orders.
13.
Mr. Pravin Anand has fairly undertaken that, in case the jars are
released to the respondents, they would destroy the jars in accordance
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
with Section 135(1)2 of the Trade Marks Act and do not intend to put
them to any commercial purpose.
14.
Mr. Nigam, however, submits that there is no positive finding in
the judgment dated 19 November 2025 to the extent that the jars in
question were infringing jars. In fact, he has placed reliance on paras
33 and 34 to contend that the learned Single Judge has found the
appellants not to be infringers. In such circumstances, he submits that
there is no justification in releasing the seized jars to the respondents
especially as the appellants had categorically stated that they were
willing to use the jars for other purposes such as packing of honey,
pickles etc. He submits that destroying the jars would serve no public
purpose whatsoever.
15.
We are unable to agree with Mr. Nigam in his contention that
there is no finding in the judgment dated 19 November 2025 to the
effect that the jars which were seized by the local Commissioner were
infringing jars. In fact, the paragraphs from the judgment dated 19
November 2025, extracted supra, not only hold that the jars were
infringing but also treat the appellants as knowing infringers.
16.
These findings, in our view, are not open to contest any further
by the appellants in view of their themselves having taken a stand
before the learned Single Judge in IA 30639/2025 that they were
contesting the earlier judgment dated 19 November 2025 only to the
2 135.
Relief in suits for infringement or for passing off. –
(1)
The relief which a court may grant in any suit for infringement or for passing off referred
to in Section 134 includes injunction (subject to such terms, if any, as the court thinks fit) and at the
option of the plaintiff, either damages or an account of profits, together with or without any order
for the delivery-up of the infringing labels and marks for destruction or erasure.
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
extent it directed release of the seized jars to the respondents. The
findings in the judgement dated 19 November 2025 have, therefore,
attained finality.
17.
Once the jars are held to be infringing, the sequitur which
follows from Section 28(1)3 read with Section 135(1) of the Trade
Marks Act is inexorable. We have noted that, even in the opening
paragraphs of the judgment dated 19 November 2025, the respondents
were asserting their right in the bottle itself as a registered trademark.
The learned Single Judge has noted this contention.
18.
Section 28(1) of the Trade Marks Act grants, to every proprietor
of a registered trademark, two rights.
19.
The first right is the right to exclusive use of the trademark for
the goods or services in respect of which the mark is registered.
20.
The second right is to obtain relief against infringement as
provided in the Trade Marks Act. Section 135 of the Trade Marks Act
deals with the reliefs available in cases of infringement and Section
135(1) includes, among the reliefs, delivery up of the infringing goods
to the plaintiff for the purposes of erasure or destruction.
21.
The respondents had, in prayer (vii) of the plaint, specifically
prayed that the infringing goods be delivered up to them for the
3 28.
Rights conferred by registration. –
(1)
Subject to the other provisions of this Act, the registration of a trade mark shall, if valid,
give to the registered proprietor of the trade mark the exclusive right to the use of the trade mark in
relation to the goods or services in respect of which the trade mark is registered and to obtain relief
in respect of infringement of the trade mark in the manner provided by this Act.
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
purposes of destruction.
22.
In that view of the matter, we do not find any merit in the
appellants’ contest to the direction of the learned Single Judge to
release the seized jars to the respondents. However, we are of the
view that, given the mandate of Section 135(1) of the Trade Marks
Act, the bottles could have been directed to be handed over to the
respondent only for the purposes of destruction, and not for being put
to any other use.
23.
On this aspect, Mr. Anand, as we have already noted, has fairly
stated that the respondents would destroy the jars.
24.
Accordingly, we modify the impugned orders to the limited
extent that the jars, on being released to the respondents, would be
destroyed by the respondents and would not be put by the respondents
to any other use, commercial or otherwise.
25.
The appellants would also be entitled to have a representative
present when the destruction of the jars takes place. For this purpose,
let the destruction of the jars take place on 17 January 2026 at 11 am.
26.
The appeal stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J
JANUARY 6, 2026/AR
RFA(OS)(COMM) 1/2026
KUMAR
19:16:17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review