Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
10.9.2026
Court No.34
Sl. No.7
sg
CRR 4203 of 2024
With
CRAN 1 of 2024
In the matter of : Moumita Sarkar
Mr. Abhijit Chakraborty
Mr. Dipayan Kundu
1.
…for the petitioner.
…for the O.P./husband.
The instant revisional application has been filed under
Section 482 of CR.P.C. corresponding to
seeking an enhancement
Section 528 of BNS,
of interim maintenance against
an order dated 5th August, 2023 by the learned District and
Sessions Judge, Hooghly in Criminal Revision No. 51 of 2023 in
connection with the Misc. Case No.34 of 2018 under Section 125
of Cr.P.C..
2. The factual matrix as can be found from the materials on
record is that the parties got married on December 7, 2004
observing Hindu Rights and Customs and the said marriage was
duly registered and they were blessed with a male child on April
18, 2011. Thereafter dispute arose between the parties in
connection with their matrimonial relations as a result the present
petitioner and her minor son compelled to leave the house of the
opposite party no.1 in the year 2016 on the ground of physical
and mental torture by him. The Misc. Case no. 5 of 2018 was filed
under Section 12 of PWDV Act by the petitioner with interim relief
and
the Learned Judicial Magistrate Hooghly, Sadar vide order
dated May 1st, 2018 granted order of residence and the petitioner
since then entered into the ground floor of the building with the
assistance of the Baranagar Police and is residing at the house of
the opposite party no.1 with her minor son.
3. It is her specific contention that the opposite party no.2 did not
spend a single penny for her and only provided some amount
towards school fees for the minor child. The present petitioner has
averred that the amount as received towards maintenance was
not sufficient for her maintenance and she had to borrow money
from her parents who are retired government employees.
4. The opposite party no.2 thereafter filed Mat Suit before the
learned Additional District Judge, Barrackpore under Hindu
Marriage Act, 1954 praying for dissolution of marriage on the
ground of cruelty and desertion, where present petitioner filed
one application for interim maintenance under Section 24 of the
Hindu Marriage Act.
The further contention made on behalf of
the petitioner that the husband never furnished the bank
statement despite specific direction by the learned Trial Court.
Having no other alternative the present petitioner filed an
application under Section 125 of CR.P.C. on December 1, 2018
before the learned Judicial Magistrate, Hooghly praying for Rs.
2,00,000/- per month
maintenance
as maintenance
and an interim
of Rs. 1,25,000/- per month other than litigation
cost.
5. Petitioner also filed an application under Section 12 of the
Domestic
Violence
Act
before
the
Learned
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate which was later on transferred before the Learned
Judicial Magistrate, 5th Court, Chinsurah, Hooghly where an
amount of interim order of maintenance to the tune of Rs.
10,000/- per month was allowed to be paid on 1.5.2018 . The
revisional application was filed by the petitioner against the said
order for enhancement of the amount and the Learned Court
enhanced such amount from Rs 10.000/- to 13,000/-.
6. The petitioner preferred another revisional application assailing
such order before the Learned District and Session Judge Hooghly
whereby
the
order
of
Learned
Magistrate
passed
in
the
proceeding under Section 125 Cr.P.C - was affirmed. A criminal
revisional application being CRR 1166 of 2022 was filed against
such order before this court and the Learned Co-ordinate Bench
directed the parties to file the Affidavit of assets before the
Learned Trial Court.
7. In terms of such direction the parties filed their respective
Affidavit and the Learned Court considering the facts and
circumstances of the case enhanced such amount of monthly
maintenance up to Rs. 15,000/- per month on December 29,
2022.
8. The materials on record further reveals that petitioner was
already favoured with the interim relief of Rs. 13,000/- per
month as ordered by in a proceeding under PWDV Act and Rs.
10,000/- by the order dated May 1st, 2018 which was Rs.
13,000/- per month vide order dated December 29, 2022 later on
enhanced to Rs 15,000/- . Despite such order the present
opposite party/husband failed and neglected to comply with the
order by paying monthly maintenance and paid according to his
whims and caprice resulting accumulation of
Rs. 1,72,000
towards outstanding dues as on 31.8.2026.
9. Learned advocate representing the petitioner submits that the
opposite party no.1 filed affidavit of assets without giving any
bank details
which was objecteds because filing of
bank
statement is mandatory pursuant to the judgement delivered by
the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rajnesh Vs. Neha .It is further
alleged that the opposite party
has
sufficient income and is
running cable business and two broad brand services having 100
lines approximately and the amount of maintenance granted in
favour of the petitioner are not in accordance with the status of
the opposite party no.1.
10. That apart learned Court while passing the order of
maintenance did not consider the amount of litigation costs.
Accordingly prayed for enhancement of the maintenance and also
for passing appropriate order directing the respondent to pay
outstanding dues in her favour.
11.
other
Learned advocate representing the opposite party, on the
hand,
raises
objection
and
deny
the
maintenance as claimed to be due and payable.
amount
of
However, it
appears that in utter negligence to the order passed by this Court
on September 9, 2026 directing the husband to submit a chart
showing the actual payment he has not placed any written
instruction
from
his
client.
Learned
advocate
failed
to
substantiate the amount actually paid in connection with the
proceeding or the dispute raised on behalf of the petitioner.
Before the Learned Court also he did not filed the Bank statement
despite specific direction.
12. Therefore
Court is of the considered view that the husband
since the inception of the proceeding initiated was
reluctant to
disclose his actual income which being his personal knowledge he
is bound to disclose and should come before the court in clean
hand otherwise an adverse inference can be drawn against him
that he intended to suppress his actual income.
Since the
income of the husband to be decided by the Learned Court at the
time of final hearing of the proceeding while deciding the
entitlement of the petitioner /wife to claim maintenance at the
time of hearing of the case after assessing the evidences to be
adduced by the parties.
13. The order passed on 1st August, 2023 by the learned
Sessions Judge, Hooghly reflects that an amount of Rs. 15,000/per month was allowed for the time being as interim order of
maintenance as an objection was raised regarding the income as
alleged by the petitioner by the husband. This Court is also of
the view that the petitioner has filed several litigations as well as
maintenance application in different proceedings which being
clubbed together would of Rs. 13,000 + Rs. 15,000. In terms of
the observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rajnish Vs.
Neha the objective of granting interim/permanent maintenance is
to ensure
that the dependent spouse is not reduced to
destitution
or vagrancy on account of the failure to of the
marriage and not as a punishment to other spouse .It was also
observed that where successive claims for maintenance
made
by a party under
different
are
statutes ,the court would
consider an adjustment or set off , of the amount awarded in
the previous
proceedings ,while determining
whether any
further amount is to be awarded in the subsequent proceeding .
14. In this case on consideration this court is of the view that
an amount of Rs. 15,000/- is to be paid by the husband as lastly
directed in connection of under Section 125 proceeding The
husband has failed to follow the direction passed by this court
and further did not filed the bank statement. The amount
towards maintenance was earlier enhanced from Rs 10.000/- to
Rs 15000/- and such order was never challenged.
15. Considering the entire factual scenario coupled with the fact
that the husband has deliberately tried to suppress his actual
income when the wife is continuously challenging the quantum of
maintenance alleging more income of the husband, this court is
of the view that the interim order passed by the Learned court is
required to be modified to the extent the amount of maintenance
granted in favour of the petitioner.
16. Accordingly husband is directed to pay Rs. 20,000/- per
month per month as interim maintenance so long the final
amount is not determined however such excess amount of Rs.
5,000/- to be paid from the passing of this order .
17.
From the chart placed before this Court, an outstanding
amount of Rs. 1,72,000/- can be found to be due and payable for
which an execution case has been filed . This court gives an
opportunity to clear the dues so accumulated till passing of this
order at the rate of Rs. 15000/- per month in the following
manner;18. The husband is directed pay the outstanding amount in four
installments and first of such amount to be paid will be of Rs.
50,000/- by 30th September, 2026 along with the current amount
of Rs. 20,000/- . The second installment to be paid by 14
October, 2026 of the same amount (Rs. 20,000/- plus Rs.
50,000/-) and the rest amount to be paid in between November
30th
and 31st December, 2026.
19. The petitioner is directed not to proceed with the execution
case further in the event the husband comply with the order as
directed in default the Learned Magistrate will proceed with the
execution case in accordance with law.
The amount of litigation costs prayed for is not considered as of
now the same will be decided by the learned Trial Court at the
time of final hearing.
20. According this revisional application stands allowed in part.
21. All parties shall act on the server copy of this order duly
downloaded from the official website of this Hon’ble High Court.
[Chaitali Chatterjee (Das), J.]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review