Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
$
!
"
!
%
&'
& (
)* '+&
)
,
!
"
#
RAMESH
MATHAPATI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$
%&'
!
"
$
()'
&%
$
()'
&%)
$
$
%% %
'
&%
& (
$
-2-
$
&%)
$
%(
$$
&%%
*
$
(
'(
$
#
$
$
*
$
+
+
,
-./
012./.34
516.6.34
;<7:=146 79617 %% %
./
7.018617
& ( 59//17 .4
?@ 6-1
77>
./60.86 947
/.66.4: 96
179= !A30 ?012.6@ B$.0/6
D-101?@ 6-1 $.0/6
551>>961
1//.34/
9:9.4/6
6-1
&%)
0>
<7:1
'
9>9?<09:.
551>>961
3<06C"
3<06 7./=.//17 6-1 95519>
A.>17 ?@ 6-1 012./.34 516.6.3410 ?@ =37.A@.4: 6-1 ;<7:=146
3A
8342.86.34
3 %(
&%%
30710
79617
&
-.6695<0 !A30 ?012.6@ E6-1 0.9>
/1461481
59//17
&
&%)
6-1
?@
.4
$
3<06F"
$30 6-1 /9G1 3A 834214.1481
6-1 5906.1/ 901
01A10017 63 9/ 510 6-1.0 094G.4:/ ?1A301 6-1 0.9>
3<06
-3-
6-96
(
-1 A986<9> =960.H 3A 6-1 503/18<6.34 89/1 ./
) %&
83=5>9.4946
-.6695<0
&%& .4 6-1 1214.4: -3<0/
%
H8./1
9>>.G90;<4
<:90
H8./1
D-.>1 6-1
4/518630 3A
94:1 D9/ .4 -./ 3AA.81 -9/ 0181.217 9
8017.?>1 .4A30=96.34 01:907.4: 50159096.34 947 /9>1 3A
/5<0.3</ >.I<30 .4
9/9294
-94.
==17.961>@ -1
/18<017 6D3 5948-9/ 947 6-1019A610 9>34: D.6- -./ /69AA
8347<8617 9 09.7 63 6-1 /9.7 /536 96 &J (& 5 =
<0.4: 6-1
09.7 6-1@ A3<47 A3<0 5>9/6.8 536/ 83469.4.4: 09D =9610.9> 3A
>.I<30 947 9 5>9/6.8 D-.61 83>3<0 894 .4 6-1 3514 5>981
-14 6-1@ D146 4190 6-1 -3</1 94 <4G43D4 510/34 094
9D9@ A03= 6-1 /9.7 -3</1
-3<:- 6-1@ =971 94 9661=56
63 89<:-6 -3>7 -.= -1 1/89517 A03= 6-1 /536
-1019A610
6-1@ D146 .4/.71 6-1 -3</1 947 34 /1908- 6-1@ A3<47 /3=1
61>15-341 ?.>>/ 947
49=1 3A 341
0181.56 >@.4: 34 9 69?>1 D-101.4 6-1
36.09= / 3 947< 97-92 D9/ =146.3417
14I<.0@ 3A 6-1 .4=961/ 3A -3</1 49=1>@ 341
.4A30=17
909?90. -1
% 947 5948-9/ 6-96 6-1 /9.7 -3</1 ?1>34:/ 63
6-1 516.6.3410
36.09= 947 -1 ./ 6-1 341 D-3 094 9D9@
A03= 6-1 /536
/ /<8- 9A610 8347<86.4: 9 /1.K<01 =9-9K90
-4-
.4 6-1 /536 9/ 510
H
% >37:17
83=5>9.46
947 01:./61017 6-1 89/1 9:9.4/6 6-./ 516.6.3410 .4
&%& %%
79617
5<4./-9?>1 <4710
88307.4:>@
) %&
186.34/ (
&%&
A30
0.=1
6-1
3AA1481/
947 ( ! " 3A
% 9A610 8347<86.4: 6-1 .421/6.:96.34 >9.7
8-90:1 /-116 9:9.4/6 6-1 516.6.3410 A30 6-1 9A301=146.3417
3AA1481/ ?1A301 6-1 0.9>
3<06
3 50321 6-1 8-90:1/ >121>>17 9:9.4/6 6-1
988</17 ?1A301 6-1
D.641//1/ 9/
H/ % 63
0.9>
3<06 6-1 503/18<6.34 1H9=.417
% 63
947 =90G17 ' 738<=146/ 9/
' 947 .7146.A.17
=9610.9> 3?;186/ 9/
/ % 63
3D1210 6-1 988</17 41.6-10 1H9=.417 94@ D.641// 430
5037<817 94@ 738<=146/ 34 -./ ?1-9>A
12.71481
6-1
9//1//=146
0.9>
309>
738<=14690@
3<06 8342.8617 6-1 988</17 A30 6-1
3AA1481/ 5<4./-9?>1 <4710
186.34 '( 3A
3A
186.34/ (
3A
947 /14614817 -.= 9/ <4710+
86 947
-5-
!
"#
%
$
& '()((( * $
%
%
)
$
$
(!
+!
,
$
%
$
& '((( *
%
$
)
'
%-
J
::0.1217
?@
6-1
/9.7
;<7:=146
6-1
988</17 516.6.3410 501A10017 94 95519> ?1A301 6-1 $.0/6
551>>961
3<06
3<06 .4
0>
'
&%)
-1 $.0/6
551>>961
9A610 01 9//1//=146 3A 6-1 146.01 12.71481 34
018307 7./=.//17 6-1 95519> A.>17 ?@ 6-1 012./.34 516.6.3410
?@ 834A.0=.4: 6-1 ;<7:=146 3A 8342.86.34 947 =37.A@.4: 6-1
30710 3A /1461481 9/ <4710+
.
%
!+
%
/
%)
!
$
%
"#
)1
+!
-6-
' 2 3 %
%
& '()((( *
%
(!
+!
$
(5
%
& ')((( *
)
%
%-
-9>>14:1 63 6-1 /9=1 ./
'
?1A301 6-./
3<06
1907 >190417 83<4/1> A30 6-1 012./.34 516.6.3410
947 6-1 >190417
01/5347146
.:-
3<06
32104=146
>19710 A30 6-1
5906 A03= <0:.4: /12109> 8346146.34/ >190417
83<4/1>
A30
;<7:=146/
6-1
<4710
516.6.3410
6-./
50.=90.>@
012./.34
510210/.6@ 947 .>>1:9>.6@ /.481 6-1
551>>961
834614617
516.6.34
0.9>
/<AA10/
6-96
A03=
3<06 947 6-1 $.0/6
3<06 :03//>@ 10017 D-.>1 8342.86.4: 6-1 988</17
947 /146148.4: -.= D.6-3<6 955018.96.4: 6-1 12.71481 34
018307 .4 0.:-6 510/5186.21
1 834614717 6-96 ?9/17 34
-7-
6-1 8017.?>1 .4A30=96.34
% 947 -./ /69AA 947 5948-9/
D146 63 6-1 /536
1H8156 /1.K.4: 6-1 /5<0.3</
3D1210
>.I<30 6-1@ 41.6-10 1H9=.417 341
909?90. D-3 501/146 .4
6-1 /536 430 6-1 .4=961/ 3A 6-1 -3</1 D-3 D101 0197.>@
929.>9?>1 96 6-1 /536 947 9>/3 436 3?69.417 94@ 738<=146/
63 50321 6-96 6-1 -3</1 ?1>34:/ 63 6-1 988</17 516.6.3410
A03= D-101
/ % 63
)
901 /1.K17
1 A<06-10 834614717 6-96
6-1
98I<.6617 6-1 988</17 A30 6-1 3AA1481 <4710
3A
0.9>
3<06
186.34 ( ! "
86 A30 6-1 019/34 6-96 6-1 503/18<6.34 -9/ A9.>17 63
50321 6-96 6-1 -3</1 D-101 6-1 /5<0.3</ >.I<30 /1.K17
?1>34:/ 63 6-1 988</17
4 /<8- 8.08<=/69481
3<06 947 $.0/6
3<06 3<:-6 436 63 -921 8342.8617
551>>961
6-1 988</17 A30 6-1 3AA1481 <4710
186.34
'( 3A
186.34 (
6-1
3A
0.9>
88307.4:>@ -1 509@/ 63 9>>3D 6-1
012./.34 516.6.34
%&
>190417
>19710 834614717 6-96 6-1
551>>961
.:0.9>
3<06
32104=146
3<06 947 6-1 $.0/6
3<06 9A610 =16.8<>3</>@ 1H9=.4.4: 6-1 12.71481
-8-
34 018307 -9/ 0.:-6>@ 8342.8617 6-1 988</17 516.6.3410 .4 9
019/3417 ;<7:=146/
%
5948-
1/69?>./-17 6-96 34
1 834614717 6-96 6-1 12.71481 3A
D.641//
) %&
(
8961:30.89>>@
&%& 9>> 3A 6-1= 8347<8617 09.7
34 6-1 -3</1 3A 6-./ 516.6.3410 947 /1.K17 6-1 /5<0.3</
>.I<30 947 709D4
%%
$<06-10
9-9K90 9/ 510 H
6-1
015306
H '
3A
6-1
H8./1
4/518630 1/69?>./-1/ 6-96 6-1 /1.K17 >.I<30 ./ /5<0.3</
>.I<30 947 6-1 /9=1 D9/ 50159017 D.6-3<6 94@ /<8- 29>.7
>.814/1
4 /<8- 8.08<=/69481 6-1
551>>961
0.9>
3<06 947 6-1 $.0/6
3<06 0.:-6>@ 8342.8617 6-1 988</17
88307.4:>@
-1 509@/ 63 7./=.// 6-1 012./.34 516.6.34
%
-921 :.214 =@ 94H.3</ 834/.71096.34 ?36- 34
6-1 /<?=.//.34/ =971 ?@ 6-1 >190417 83<4/1> A30 6-1
01/5186.21 5906.1/ 947 738<=146/ 929.>9?>1 34 018307
%(
/ 83<>7 ?1 :96-1017 A03= 6-1 83=5>9.46 947
36-10 018307/ ?9/17 34 6-1 8017.?>1 .4A30=96.34 0181.217
?@
% 34
) %& &%& 96 9?3<6 &J (& 5 =
-1 9>34: D.6-
-9-
-./ /69AA 947 5948-9/ 8347<8617 09.7 63 6-1 -3</1 3A
988</17 012./.34 516.6.3410 947 /1.K17 6-1 /5<0.3</ >.I<30
/ % 63
%
12.71481 3A
947 709D4
8901A<>
9-9K90 9/ 510 H
1H9=.496.34
3A
H
6-1
% -1 -9/ /69617 6-96 96 6-1 6.=1 3A 09.7 63
6-1 -3</1 3A 988</17 94 <4G43D4 510/34 094 9D9@ A03=
6-1 -3</1
-1019A610 6-1@ A3<47 6-1 .>>.8.6 >.I<30 947 36-10
=9610.9>/ .4 6-1 501=./1/
4 14I<.0@ 3A 341
501/146 96 6-1 /536 -1 .4A30=17
909?90. D-3
% 947 5948-9/ 6-96
6-1 /9.7 -3</1 ?1>34:/ 63 6-1 516.6.3410
36.09= 947 -1 ./
6-1 341 D-3 094 9D9@ A03= 6-1 /536
3D1210 -1 714.17
63 :.21 /6961=146 63
%
/ /<8- -1 ./ 41.6-10 8.617 9/ 9
8-90:1 /-116 D.641// 430 1H9=.417 ?1A301 6-1
%
6-1
3<06
3 73<?6 6-1 /1.K17 >.I<30 D9/ 1H9=.417 ?@
H8./1 4/518630 947 .//<17 9 015306 9/ 510
H ' 947
6-1 /9=1 7./8>3/1/ 6-96 6-1 >.I<30 /1.K17 D9/ /5<0.3</
>.I<30
3D1210 63 8344186 6-1 988</17 .4 6-1 80.=1 6-1
503/18<6.34 -9/ 436 5>9817 94@ 738<=146/ 30 D.641//1/ 30
- 10 -
12.71481 63 /<?/6946.961 6-96 6-1 -3</1 D-101 6-1 /5<0.3</
>.I<30 D9/ /1.K17 ?1>34:/ 63 6-1 988</17
%J
88307.4: 63
% -1 A3<47
0181.56/ 947
61>15-341 ?.>>/ .4 6-1 -3</1 3A 988</17
-3<:- 341
909?90. D-3 501/146 96 6-1 /536 0197.>@ 929.>9?>1 96 6-1
6.=1 3A 9>>1:17 .48.7146 -9/ 436 8.617 9/ 9 8-90:1 /-116
D.641//
34/.710.4:
6-1
/9=1
6-1
0.9>
3<06
-9/
98I<.6617 6-1 988</17 A30 6-1 3AA1481 5<4./-9?>1 <4710
186.34 ( ! " 3A 6-1
481 .6 ./ 503217 6-96 6-1
-3</1 D-101 6-1 /5<0.3</ >.I<30 /1.K17 D9/ 436 ?1>34:/ 63
988</17
6-14 6-1 988</17 894436 ?1 8342.8617 A30 6-1
3AA1481 <4710
186.34 (
3A
86 947
186.34
'( 3A
A30 6-1 /.=5>1 019/34 6-96 6-1 988</17 D9/ 436 89<:-6 -3>7
017 -94717>@ 96 6-1 /536 7<0.4: 6-1 83<0/1 3A 09.7 947
% 947
( 9>/3 436 /69617 6-96 6-1@ -921 .7146.A.17 6-1
988</17 96 6-1 6.=1 3A 09.7 947 6-1@ 89=1 63 G43D 9?3<6
-.= 6-03<:- 341
909?90. D-3 D9/ 436 8.617 9/ 8-90:1
/-116 D.641// 430 1H9=.417 ?1A301 6-1
3<06
- 11 -
%'
$<06-10 .4715147146 5948-9
.4 -./ 803//
1H9=.496.34 -9/ 8>190>@ /69617 6-96 -1 ./ 9 /638G D.641// 63
6-1
H8./1
15906=146
4 -./ 803// 1H9=.496.34 -1 -9/
8961:30.89>>@ /69617 6-96 -1 -9/ :.214 12.71481 .4 /12109>
89/1/
1 /6337 9/ 9 5948- D.641// .4 /12109> 89/1/ 947
977<817 12.71481 34 ?1-9>A 3A 6-1
36-10 5948-9
H8./1
15906=146
-1
6<0417 -3/6.>1 63 6-1 503/18<6.34 89/1
4 /<8- 8.08<=/69481 1H8156 6-1 <483003?309617 61/6.=34@
3A
/ % 947 ( 6-1 3AA.8.9> D.641//1/
43 36-10 01>.9?>1
12.71481 A306-83=.4: 34 018307 63 50321 6-1 8-90:1/
>121>>17 9:9.4/6 6-1 988</17 012./.34 516.6.3410
%
3 73<?6
6-1 12.71481 3A 3AA.8.9> D.641//1/
894436 ?1 7./890717 A30 6-1 019/34 6-96 6-1@ 901 3AA.8.9>/
3D1210
6-1
3<06 -9/ 63 1H9=.41 6-1.0 12.71481 .4 9
:0196 8901 947 89<6.34 947 83003?3096.34 ./ 01I<.017 63 01>@
34 6-1 12.71481 3A 3AA.8.9> D.641//1/ /.481 6-101 901
53//.?.>.6@ 3A A9>/1 .=5>.896.34/ 9/ -1>7 ?@ 6-1
34,?>1
51H
3<06 .4 6-1 89/1 3A
01530617 .4
!
- 12 -
"" #
-9/ -1>7 6-96 B.47117 6-1 12.71481 3A 6-1 3AA.8.9>
D.641//1/ 894436 ?1 7./890717 =101>@ 34 6-1 :03<47 6-96
6-1@ ?1>34: 63 6-1 53>.81 A3081 947 901 1.6-10 .46101/617 .4
6-1 .421/6.:96.4: 30 6-1 503/18<6.4: 9:148@
<6 50<71481
7.86961/ 6-96 6-1.0 12.71481 4117/ 63 ?1 /<?;18617 63 /60.86
/80<6.4@ 947 9/ A90 9/ 53//.?>1 83003?3096.34 3A 6-1.0
12.71481 .4 =9610.9> 5906.8<>90/ /-3<>7 ?1 /3<:-6C
%)
2.1D 6-96
4 /<8- 8.08<=/69481
6-1
0.9>
9= 3A 6-1 834/.71017
3<06 947 6-1 $.0/6
551>>961
3<06
-921 436 503510>@ 955018.9617 6-1 12.71481 34 018307 947
8342.8617 6-1 988</17 34 501/<=56.34 947 9//<=56.34
1481 .4610A101481 .4 6-1 .=5<:417 ;<7:=146/ ./ 89>>17
A30
88307.4:>@
5038117 63 59// 6-1 A3>>3D.4:+
."
-1
0.=.49>
.."
-1 ;<7:=146 3A 8342.86.34 947 30710 3A
12./.34 16.6.34 ./
/1461481 59//17 ?@ 6-1
3 %(
&%%
79617
$$ %
0.9>
&
D-.8- D9/ =37.A.17 ?@ 6-1 $.0/6
3<06 .4
&
&%)
551>>961
- 13 -
3<06
..."
.4
0>
'
&%)
%% %
& ( 901 -101?@ /16 9/.71
-1
012./.34
79617
516.6.3410 988</17
./
98I<.6617 A30 6-1 3AA1481 5<4./-9?>1 <4710
186.34 (
3A 6-1
86 947
186.34
'( 3A
.2"
-1 ?9.> ?347
012./.34
.A 94@
1H18<617 ?@ 6-1
516.6.3410 988</17
/-9>>
/6947
89481>>17
2"
-1 A.41 9=3<46 .A 94@ 7153/.617 ?@ 6-1
012./.34
516.6.3410 988</17
/-9>>
?1
01A<4717 63 -.= 34 7<1 .7146.A.896.34
2."
1:./60@ ./ 7.018617 63 /147 ?98G 6-1
0.9>
3<06 018307/ 9>34: D.6- 9 835@ 3A 6-./
30710 63 6-1 834810417
3<06 A306-D.6-
-*
&
!
)
!
+%
6L0;
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review