The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
29. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is of the considered view that no question of law, much less any substantial questions of law is involved in this 2nd appeal.
30. This Court finds no merits in this 2nd appeal which is hereby dismissed.
31. Pending Interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as not pressed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:685
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
S. A. No. 367 of 2018
1. Mostt. Fulwanti, aged about 70 years wife of Late Bishun Mahto.
(Deleted vide order dated 06.08.2024)
2. Reena Devi, aged about 42 years daughter of Late Bishun Mahto,
wife of Ashok Yadav, resident of Village-Chandrodih, P.O., P.S.
& District-Koderma.
3. Chuna Devi, aged about 45 years daughter of late Bishun Mahto,
wife of Rajkumar Raut, resident of Vill. & P.O.- Lokai, P.S. &
District-Koderma.
4. Krishnadeo Yadav @ Krishnadeo Mahto, aged about 52 years, son
of Late Bishun Mahto.
5. Ram Narain Yadav @ Ram Narain Mahto, aged about 43 years
son of Late Bishun Mahto.
No. 1, 4 and 5 resident of Village & P.O. Kheshmi Devipur, P.S.Markacho, District-Koderma.
…
…
Defendants/Appellants/Appellants
Versus
Kameshwar Yadav, son of Late Lekho Yadav, resident of VillageKheshmi Devipur, P.O. & P.S.- Markacho, District-Koderma.
… …
Plaintiff/Respondent/Respondent
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellants
: Mr. Amar Kumar Sinha, Advocate
: Mr. Md. Abdul Wahab, Advocate
For the Respondents
: None
--13/12.01.2026
1.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellants.
2.
This second appeal has been filed against the judgment dated
25.07.2018 (decree signed on 03.08.2018) passed by learned District
Judge-II, Koderma in Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2013 affirming the
judgment dated 28.02.2013 (decree signed on 08.03.2013) passed by
learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division)-I, Koderma in Partition Suit No. 16
of 2003.
3.
The partition suit was partly decreed in favour of plaintiff by
the learned trial court and the judgment and decree passed in partition
suit was affirmed by the learned 1st appellate court. Consequently, the
defendants are the appellants before this Court.
2026:JHHC:685
4.
The partition suit was filed for passing a preliminary decree of
partition to the extent of plaintiff’s half share in the Schedule-A
properties and for carving out a separate taktha appointing a Survey
Knowing Pleader Commissioner.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the suit
was filed seeking partition and the partition suit was partly decreed in
favour of the plaintiff and partly dismissed with respect to a portion of
the suit property which was already sold by the grand-father of the
plaintiff namely Bhikhi Mahto under Khata No. 201 and 202 in village
Devipur, District- Koderma.
6.
While giving the genealogy, the learned counsel for the
appellants has submitted that Bhikhi Mahto was a common ancestor of
his two sons namely Lekho Mahto and Bishun Mahto; Lekho Mahto
had one son namely Kameshwar Mahto (Kameshwar Yadav) who was
the plaintiff in the case. The descendants/legal heirs of Bishun Mahto
were the defendants. Bishun Mahto had two sons namely Kishundeo
Mahto and Ram Narayan Mahto. (1) Mostt. Phulwanti, W/o: Bishun
Mahto (2) Rina Devi D/o: Late Bishun Mahto (3) Chuna Devi D/o:
Late Bishun Mahto (4) Kishundeo Mahto S/o: Bishun Mahto and (5)
Ram Narayan Mahto S/o: Bishun Mahto were the defendants in the
case.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the
judgment passed by both the courts are perverse inasmuch as the
memorandum of partition deed i.e. Exhibit-G has not been properly
considered. The learned counsel for the appellants has referred to the
proposed substantial question of law No. B which is quoted as under:
“Whether the finding of learned courts below on issue of
previous partition is perverse on the face of Exhibit-G the
memorandum of partition and admission of P.W.6 (Plaintiff)
made in paragraph 13 and 20 of his cross examination?”
8.
Learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the appeal
be admitted on the aforesaid substantial question of law and notice be
issued. The learned counsel for the appellants has also submitted that
the plaint was amended in the year 2011 and the principle of relate
2026:JHHC:685
back with respect to the pleadings would apply and the trial court has
failed to properly appreciate the pleadings and the evidence placed on
record.
9.
The learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the
genealogy pointed out as above is not in dispute.
10.
After hearing the learned counsel for the appellants, this Court
finds that the plaintiff (respondent herein) had filed the suit for
partition claiming ½ share in schedule A property.
11.
The specific case of the plaintiff was that one Bhikhi Mahto
was common ancestor of both the parties and the properties mentioned
in Schedule -A i.e. land of Khata no. 201 & 202 were having different
plots. Some of the properties were ancestral properties of said Bhikhi
Mahto and the rest were acquired by the plaintiff.
12.
It was stated that Bhikhi Mahto died about 22 years ago leaving
behind him two sons, namely, Bishun Yadav and Lekho Yadav who
jointly succeeded Bhikhi Mahto and came in joint possession of the
suit property and the father of the plaintiff, Lekho Mahto, died leaving
one son, the plaintiff. Similarly, Bishun Mahto died leaving behind
two sons namely Kishundeo Mahto and Ram Narayan Mahto.
13.
It was the case that plaintiff’s father Lekho Mahto died just
after death of Bikhi Mahto in state of jointness with his brother Bishun
Mahto, who was defendant No.1. It was further stated that the plaintiff
was minor and Bishun became Karta of the family and was managing
the family properties. In spite of demand by the plaintiff, the
defendants were not furnishing the accounts of the produce of the suit
land and ultimately when the plaintiff demanded partition, the
defendants denied the same.
14.
The defendants appeared and filed their written statement
stating therein that the suit was bad for previous partition, misjoinder
and non-joinder of necessary parties etc. It was asserted that khata no.
201 was self-acquired property of Bhikhi Mahto and was sold to Smt.
Fulwanti Devi by virtue of registered sale deed and she was put in
possession and her name was also mutated in the revenue records.
2026:JHHC:685
Bhikhi Mahto had also sold another property in khata no. 202 to Indo
Dhobi through a registered sale deed, who was in possession over 71
decimals land.
15.
It was also contended that genealogy of the plaint was
incomplete and the plaintiff and defendant do not constitute joint
family. Bhikhi Mahto was not the owner or in possession of all the
suit land mentioned in Schedule A. Rather, it was stated that none of
the property was the ancestral property of Bhikhi Mahto.
16.
It was asserted that plaintiff Kameshwar Yadav has no male
issue and he had only daughter and had no earning and he was being
maintained by defendant Bishun Mahto.
17.
It was further asserted that the plaintiff Kamweshwar Yadav
demanded partition in the year 1980 with respect to land falling under
khata Nos. 41 and 36 of village Kusmai and khata No. 201 of village
Devipur on which Bhikhi Mahto partitioned the land. The land of
khata Nos. 36 and 41 of village Kusmai was allotted in the share of
plaintiff Kameshwar Yadav and other lands of village Devipur bearing
khata No. 201 was allotted in the share of Bishun Yadav. The partition
was held in presence of the family members of Bishun Yadav and
Kameshwar Yadav. The land of village Kusmai was valuable so the
plaintiff gladly accepted it and both parties came in possession of their
allotted share. Thereafter, a memorandum of partition was prepared in
the year 1983 (added through amendment).
18.
It was further asserted that Lekho Mahto, father of the plaintiff
died in the year 1966 -67 and Bhikhi Mahto had died in the year 1982.
During the pendency of the suit defendant no. 1 Bishun Mahto expired
and his wife Fulwanti Devi appeared and adopted the written
statement filed by Bishun Mahto and also filed written statement on
her behalf.
19.
The learned trial court had framed the following issues for
consideration:i.
ii.
Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form?
Have the plaintiff valid cause of action for the suit?
2026:JHHC:685
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
20.
Whether the suit is barred by law of limitation, adverse
possession, waiver and estoppel?
Whether the suit suffers from non-joinder of necessary
parties?
Whether there is the unity of title or unity of possession
between the parties with respect to the suit properties as
mentioned in Schedule – A in the plaint?
Whether the suit property are joint and undivided between
the parties and same is liable to be partitioned as per the
share claimed?
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief or reliefs as
sought for by him and is entitled for the cost of the suit?
Both the parties had led oral and documentary evidences before
the court.
21.
Exhibit-G, which is the bone of contention as raised by the
learned counsel for the appellants during the course of hearing, was
the memorandum of partition said to have been prepared on
15.01.1983.
22.
The learned trial court considered the issue No.(v) and (vi)
together which essentially related as to there was the unity of title or
unity of possession amongst the parties with respect to the suit
properties and whether the suit property are joint and undivided
between the parties and is liable to be partitioned as per the share
claimed. The learned trial court after considering the materials on
record and also discussing the memorandum of partition, which was
brought for the first time after the death of defendant No.1, has
ultimately held that there was no partition in the year 1980, nor the
memorandum of partition was prepared in the year 1983 and held that
there was unity of title and unity of possession with respect to the suit
property except to the land which was already sold by Bhikhi Mahto.
23.
The ultimate findings of the learned trial court in connection
with partition in the year 1980 and the memorandum of partition of
the year 1983 (Exhibit-G) has been recorded in paragraph 18 of the
trial court’s judgment which is quoted as under:“18. Having gone through the above discussion I find that no
partition held in the year 1980 nor memorandum of partition
2026:JHHC:685
prepared in the year 1983 by both parties because if there was
existence of memorandum of partition in between the parties
then the defendant might have incorporated it in his W.S. filed
in the year 2004. Also signature of plaintiff on deposition does
not matches with the signature of plaintiff over memorandum
of partition vide Exhibit-G. No where plaintiff Kameshwar
Yadav has admitted his signature our memorandum of
partition. The defendant has failed to file original sale deed
said tobe paid its consideration money by Late Bhikhi Mahto
and purchased in the name of plaintiff Kameshwar Yadav of
land of mauza Kushmai Khata no. 36 & 41.D.W.3 Bhuneshar
Yadav Fufera Bhai of defendant no.3 Bishun Yadav has stated
vide para-26 that the plaintiff Kameshwar Mahto resides at
native home Khesmi Devipur contradicting the statement of
defendant that after partition the plaintiff has been living at
Kushmai on his valuable share allotted to him by his grandfather in the year 1980. It is also clear that Late Bhikhi Mahto
has sold 3.49 acre land to Fulwanti Devi in the year 1977
under khata no.201 and also 16 decimal to Began Singh in the
year 1982 under khata no.201and 71 decimal land to Babulal,
Kali Dhobi and Mahendra Dhobi in the year 1981 under
khata no.202 out of his self acquired property vide Ext.A/1,
Ext.A/4 and Ext.A available on record in interest of his family
member described in the recital of aforesaid deeds and after
his death his both sons plaintiff Kameshwar Mahto and
defendant Bishun Yadav became owner of his left property.
There has been unity of title and unity of possession of both
parties over the remaining land. The properties which
succeeded by plaintiff and defendant is joint and undivided.
The plaintiff has half share on remaining land mentioned in
Schedule -A of the plaint (except already sold by Late Bhikhi
Mahto). Accordingly, both issues are decided in favour of the
plaintiff.”
24.
The learned 1st appellate court has framed the following points
for determination: i.
ii.
Whether there is unity of title and unity of possession
between the parties with respect to the suit land?
Whether the properties in the name of the common
ancestor of the parties, namely Bhikhi Mahto was
partitioned during his life-time in the year 1980 and
thereafter on 15.1.83, a memorandum of partition was
prepared, bearing signature of the plaintiff?
2026:JHHC:685
iii.
25.
Whether the judgement & decree of the Court is liable to
be set aside?
So far as learned 1st appellate court is concerned, a detailed
discussion has been made in paragraph 27 in connection with
memorandum of partition dated 15.01.1983 and the learned 1st
appellate court after discussing the materials on record and considering
the totality of the circumstances held that no reliance can be placed on
memorandum of partition (Ext. G.). The discussion is quoted as under:“27. The defendants have filed a memorandum of partition dt.
15.1.83 (Ext, G). I perused the Ext. G and found that it is
written on plain paper on which signatures of Kameshwar
Yadav and Bishun Mahto as well as signatures of the
witnesses. Bala Ram. Raj Kumar Singh Saryu Mahto,
Baleshwar Yadav, Sheo Kumar Yadav. Bhuneshwar Yadav are
shown without date, and the maker of the deed is one Somar
Singh. However, his signature is missing thereon. It is
pertinent to note that in the W.S of the deceased defendant no.
1 who is son of the common ancestor initially the plea
regarding memorandum of partition was not taken however,
after the death of original defendant no. 1 when his wife and
two daughters became the parties as substituted defendants,
the wife of the deceased defendant no. 1, for first time taken
the plea in her W.S. that the suit is bad for previous partition
between Kameshwar Yadav and Bishun Mahto, the original
defendant no. 1 in the year 1983 in presence of respectable
persons of the village and prior to it, it was pleading of the
defendant that the suit land was orally partitioned during the
life-time of common ancestor in the year 1980. However,
defendant nos. 1 & 2 who had fled a joint W.S with the
deceased defendant no. 1 and the substituted defendant
amended their pleading vide order dt. 7.7.11 after about 8
years of the filing of the suit, and they introduced the pleading
that a memorandum of partition was prepared in the year
1983. It is relevant to mention here that the original defendant
no. 1 who is signatory of memorandum of partition, in his
deposition has not stated anything about the same rather at
para 38 of his cross examination he admitted that he cannot
produce any paper regarding partition of the suit land. The
defendants have failed to explain as to why such important
document was withheld by the original defendant no. 1
whereas, it has come in the evidence that after the death of the
common ancestor, he became the Karta of the family and as
per the defendant's case, the memorandum of partition was
2026:JHHC:685
executed in his presence. Furthermore, the plaintiff who is
also shown as one of the signatories of the memorandum of
partition, was not confronted with the said memorandum of
partition during his cross-examination and he was not asked
to admit or deny his signature on it. The defendants have not
produced the maker/scribe of the memorandum of partition as
witness in this case whereas, the memorandum of partition
suggests that one Somar Singh was the scribe of the
memorandum of partition and the defendants have put their
signatures in his presence. It is quite surprising and for the
reason best known to defendants, the signature of the scribe of
the memorandum of partition is not present. Although, the
defendant has examined one of the witnesses of the
memorandum of partition (DW3), who has proved his
signature but in the totality of the circumstances, no reliance
can be placed on memorandum of partition (Ext. G.)”
26.
This Court finds that both the learned courts have taken into
consideration the memorandum of partition (Exhibit-G) and have cited
sound reasons for coming to a conclusion that no reliance could be
placed on the memorandum of partition (Exhibit-G). Further learned
1st appellate court has also taken into consideration in paragraph 28 of
its judgment that barring the rent receipts with respect to the property
which was sold in favour of the wife of the original defendant no. 1,
no document regarding possession of the defendants over rest of the
land of suit land was filed. It was also recorded that it was an admitted
fact that the parties were separate in mess and residence and the
plaintiff had pleaded that the parties were cultivating as per their
convenience. The other materials placed on record were also taken
into consideration by the learned 1st appellate court and ultimately it
was held that there was no previous partition and the learned 1 st
appellate court has ultimately upheld the judgment passed by the
learned trial court and dismissed the appeal.
27.
Upon going through the judgment of both the learned courts,
this Court is of the view that there is no perversity in the matter of
appreciation of materials on record while coming to a finding that
there was no previous partition. This Court also finds that the learned
courts have not committed any perversity while appreciating Exhibit-
2026:JHHC:685
G which was just one of the materials for consideration with respect to
alleged previous partition.
28.
The learned court ultimately held that the plaintiff was entitled
to ½ share of the suit property except to the extent the property
already sold by the grand father of the plaintiff from his self-acquired
property.
29.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is
of the considered view that no question of law, much less any
substantial questions of law is involved in this 2nd appeal.
30.
This Court finds no merits in this 2nd appeal which is hereby
dismissed.
31.
Pending Interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as not
pressed.
32.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the concerned
courts through “Fax/e-mail”.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
12.01.2026
Rakesh/Uploaded on:-20.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review