Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
AB No. 8 of 2024
Date of Decision: 16.05.2024
Shri Mostofa SK,
S/o Mofial SK
R/o Lalmati (Kasiripara)
P.O. & P.S. Hallidayganj,
West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
… Applicant(s)
- Versus 1. State of Meghalaya
Represented by the
Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya
Home( Police) Department,
West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
2. Investigating Officer,
Hallidayganj Police Station
West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
…. Respondent(s)/Opposite Parties
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. K. Ch. Gautam, Adv. with
Ms. R. Kharshiing, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA
ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This matter has come up for hearing today on the production
of the case diary by the State/Opposite parties.
2.
Heard Mr. K Ch. Gautam, learned counsel for the applicant
who had briefly narrated the facts of the case to say that the applicant
is apprehending arrest in connection with Hallidayganj P.S. case No.
4 (04) of 2024 under section 302/34 IPC. The case was registered
following an FIR lodged by one Hafizur Rahman on 08.04.2024,
wherein it was stated that he was the brother of the deceased
Hashidur Rahman who was brutally assaulted by a number of people
on 07.04.2024 at a place called Lalmati field, having sustained
serious injuries on his person, the deceased was immediately shifted
to the District Hospital, Hatsngimari where he succumbed to his
injuries the following morning.
3.
The learned counsel has further submitted that the deceased
victim was a habitual offender involved in several crimes like
robbery, burglary and dacoity and on that fateful day, while
committing theft at Lalmati bazaar, he was caught red-handed by the
public who assaulted him.
4.
The applicant on noticing the commotion, approached the
place of occurrence and since he is a prominent local leader and the
former Secretary of the Village Executive Committee (VEC), the
public requested him to take the offender/victim to the police station.
The applicant accordingly took the victim in his car to the police
station. He was accompanied by one Samiul Islam. Thereafter, the
applicant left the police station.
5.
It is also the case of the applicant that on the next day, he was
informed that the victim had succumbed to his injuries at the District
Hospital, however, the applicant maintains that he is not involved in
the assault upon the deceased victim and has no connection with the
incident except to the extent as indicated hereinabove.
6.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the applicant has
reliably learnt that the police are now on the lookout for his arrest
and under such apprehension, this instant application with a prayer
for grant of pre-arrest bail under section 438 Cr.P.C. is preferred
before this Court.
7.
The learned counsel went on to submit that the applicant is a
prominent leader of the area with an influential standing before the
society, he also has no criminal record or antecedent to attract the
attention of the police and therefore, if arrested, his image and
reputation will be tarnished.
8.
It is also the submission of the applicant through his counsel
that in the event this Court is pleased to allow the prayer made in this
petition, he is willing to abide by any conditions imposed and to
furnish adequate security as demanded with the further commitment
that he will not abscond or tamper with evidence and also that he will
cooperate with the investigation as and when required.
9.
The learned counsel has also candidly admitted that the
applicant had moved the Court of the learned Sessions Judge, Tura
with a similar prayer for grant of pre-arrest bail, however, vide order
dated 02.05.2024 in BA No. 57/2024, his application was rejected
and the interim bail passed earlier was vacated.
10.
In support of his contention, the learned counsel has referred
to the case of Ashok Kumar v. State of Union Territory
Chandigarh, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 274, wherein at paragraph 11
and 12 of the same, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as
follows:“11. One good ground which has persuaded us to exercise
our discretion in favour of the appellant is that the appellant
has already joined the investigation. He has cooperated in
the investigation so far.
“12.There is no gainsaying that custodial interrogation is
one of the effective modes of investigating into the alleged
crime. It is equally true that just because custodial
interrogation is not required that by itself may also not be a
ground to release an accused on anticipatory bail if the
offences are of a serious nature. However, a mere assertion
on the part of the State while opposing the plea for
anticipatory bail that custodial interrogation is required
would not be sufficient. The State would have to show or
indicate more than prima facie why the custodial
interrogation of the accused is required for the purpose of
investigation.”
11.
Per contra Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Mr.
E.R. Chyne, learned GA while opposing the prayer made by the
applicant has firstly led this Court to Annexure-II at Page-12 of this
petition, wherein is found the order dated 02.05.2024 passed by the
learned Sessions Judge in BA No. 57/2024 and has submitted that the
learned Sessions Judge after considering the facts and circumstance
of the case and the submission made by the parties and on perusal of
the case diary has observed that the contents of the case diary would
show that there is prima facie case against the petitioner/accused
person, the applicant herein and there are witnesses who have seen
him assaulting the deceased victim with a cricket bat, such
observations being the basis for rejection of the said bail application
of the applicant herein.
12.
The learned AAG has also referred to the case diary
particularly the statement of two eye-witnesses made under section
161 Cr.P.C., who have categorically stated that they have seen the
applicant and the deceased victim arguing in front of the shop of one
of the said witnesses, the applicant, after a heated argument had
taken a cricket bat displayed outside the shop and had assaulted the
deceased victim with the same. Thereafter, the applicant pushed the
deceased victim in his car and drove away. This, according to the
learned AAG is the clinching evidence of the involvement of the
applicant in the assault and subsequent death of the deceased victim.
The nature of the case and the extent of the offence being very
serious and heinous, it would not be proper for the applicant to be
allowed to go on pre-arrest bail.
13.
This Court on consideration of the submission and contentions
of the parties and also on perusal of the petition and the case diary is
inclined to agree with the learned AAG that there is prima facie
evidence to link the applicant to the assault and subsequent death of
the deceased victim.
14.
The main thrust of the argument advanced by the learned
counsel for the applicant is that in this case, this Court had earlier
allowed the applicant to go on interim bail and within such period,
the applicant had fully co-operated with the investigation and was
questioned by the Investigating Officer from time to time, therefore
reliance on Para 11 and 12 of the Ashok Kumar case (supra) is
deemed proper, wherein the Court has observed that if the appellant
has already joined the investigation, the State opposing the plea for
anticipatory bail on the ground that custodial interrogation is
required would not be sufficient. Such proposition being equally
applicable to the case of the applicant herein. However, in the same
breadth the Hon’ble Supreme Court at para-12 has also remarked that
irrespective of whether custodial interrogation is required or not, that
by itself may also not be a ground to release an accused on an
anticipatory bail if the offences are of a serious nature.
15.
At this juncture it would not be out of place to briefly discuss
the scope and ambit of the concept of anticipatory bail. The answer
to this has already been spelt out by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra
reported in (2011) 1 SCC 694, wherein at paragraph 23 and 24 the
observations is as follows:23. The Constitution Bench of this Court in Gurbaksh Singh
Sibbia v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 565 had an occasion
to comprehensively deal with the scope and ambit of the
concept of anticipatory bail. Section 438 Cr.P.C. is an
extraordinary provision where the accused who apprehends
his/her arrest on accusation of having committed a nonbailable offence can be granted bail in anticipation of arrest.
The Constitution Bench's relevant observations are set out as
under:
"21........A wise exercise of judicial power inevitably
takes care of the evil consequences which are likely to flow
out of its intemperate use. Every kind of judicial discretion,
whatever may be the nature of the matter in regard to which
it is required to be exercised, has to be used with due care
and caution. In fact, an awareness of the context in which
the discretion is required to be exercised and of the
reasonably foreseeable consequences of its use, is the hall
mark of a prudent exercise of judicial discretion. One ought
not to make a bugbear of the power to grant anticipatory
bail".
24. Mr. Bhushan referred to a Constitution Bench judgment
in Sibbia's case (supra) to strengthen his argument that no
such embargo has been placed by the said judgment of the
Constitution Bench. He placed heavy reliance on para 15
of Sibbia's case (supra), which reads as under:
"15. Judges have to decide cases as they come before
them, mindful of the need to keep passions and
prejudices out of their decisions. And it will be strange
if, by employing judicial artifices and techniques, we cut
down the discretion so wisely conferred upon the courts,
by devising a formula which will confine the power to
grant anticipatory bail within a strait-jacket. While
laying down cast-iron rules in a matter like granting
anticipatory bail, as the High Court has done, it is apt to
be overlooked that even judges can have but an
imperfect awareness of the needs of new situations. Life
is never static and every situation has to be assessed in
the context of emerging concerns as and when it arises.
Therefore, even if we were to frame a `Code for the
grant of anticipatory bail', which really is the business
of the legislature, it can at best furnish broad guidelines and cannot compel blind adherence. In which case
to grant bail and in which to refuse it is, in the very
nature of things, a matter of discretion. But apart from
the fact that the question is inherently of a kind which
calls for the use of discretion from case to case, the
legislature has, in terms express, relegated the decision
of that question to the discretion of the court, by
providing that it may grant bail "if it thinks fit". The
concern of the courts generally is to preserve their
discretion without meaning to abuse it. It will be strange
if we exhibit concern to stultify the discretion conferred
upon the courts by law."
16.
The above would provide the contour and perhaps the
parameter of what would entail discretionary power to be exercised
by the court, vis-à-vis grant or refusal of anticipatory bail. It cannot
be missed out that while exercising discretionary powers as far as
bail matters are concerned, the court would be guided by the facts
and circumstances of a particular case. This would be best
understood by referring to para 111 of Siddharam Satlingappa
Mhetre case (supra), which is reproduced hereinbelow as:“111. No inflexible guidelines or straitjacket formula can be
provided for grant or refusal of anticipatory bail. We are
clearly of the view that no attempt should be made to provide
rigid and inflexible guidelines in this respect because all
circumstances and situations of future cannot be clearly
visualized for the grant or refusal of anticipatory bail. In
consonance with the legislative intention the grant or refusal
of anticipatory bail should necessarily depend on facts and
circumstances of each case. As aptly observed in the
Constitution Bench decision in Sibbia's case (supra) that the
High Court or the Court of Sessions to exercise their
jurisdiction under section 438 Cr.P.C. by a wise and careful
use of their discretion which by their long training and
experience they are ideally suited to do. In any event, this
is the legislative mandate which we are bound to respect and
honour.”
17.
Again, at para 112 of the Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre case,
the Apex Court had laid down some factors and parameters to be
taken into consideration while dealing with anticipatory bail, which
reads as follows:“112. The following factors and parameters can be taken
into consideration while dealing with the anticipatory bail:
i. The nature and gravity of the accusation and the exact role
of the accused must be properly comprehended before arrest
is made;
ii. The antecedents of the applicant including the fact as to
whether the accused has previously undergone imprisonment
on conviction by a Court in respect of any cognizable
offence;
iii. The possibility of the applicant to flee from justice;
iv. The possibility of the accused's likelihood to repeat
similar or the other offences.
v. Where the accusations have been made only with the
object of injuring or humiliating the applicant by arresting
him or her.
vi. Impact of grant of anticipatory bail particularly in cases
of large magnitude affecting a very large number of people.
vii. The courts must evaluate the entire available material
against the accused very carefully. The court must also
clearly comprehend the exact role of the accused in the case.
The cases in which accused is implicated with the help
of sections 34 and 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 the court
should consider with even greater care and caution because
over implication in the cases is a matter of common
knowledge and concern;
viii. While considering the prayer for grant of anticipatory
bail, a balance has to be struck between two factors namely,
no prejudice should be caused to the free, fair and full
investigation and there should be prevention of harassment,
humiliation and unjustified detention of the accused;
ix. The court to consider reasonable apprehension of
tampering of the witness or apprehension of threat to the
complainant;
x. Frivolity in prosecution should always be considered and
it is only the element of genuineness that shall have to be
considered in the matter of grant of bail and in the event of
there being some doubt as to the genuineness of the
prosecution, in the normal course of events, the accused is
entitled to an order of bail.”
18.
Considering the serious nature of the case in question, this
Court, particularly relying on the said statement of the eye-witnesses,
would opine that prima facie there appears to be evidence linking the
applicant with the alleged assault and subsequent death of the
deceased victim.
19.
Therefore, on overall analysis of the facts and circumstances
of this case, this Court finds that the applicant has not been able to
make out a case for grant of pre-arrest bail.
20.
Consequently, this application is hereby dismissed as devoid
of merits. The interim bail granted is hereby vacated.
21.
The petition is disposed of. No costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
16.05.2024
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review