Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
#
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
CNR No. DLHC010802372025
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025 & I.A. 26239/2025
MORTH THROUGH EE NH DIVISION AURANGABAD
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. A.P. Singh, Mr. Naman
Saraswat, Mr. Vikas Soni, Advs.
versus
M S STATE CONSTRUCTION INTEGRATED WORKS
GANGAMAI INDUSTRIES AND CONSTRUCTIONS LTD
JOINT VENTURE
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Kaustubh Sinha, Mr. Bishva
bandhu Kumar, Ms. Surbhi
Mehta, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
%
JUDGMENT(ORAL)
17.09.2026
1.
The present appeal arises from the Arbitral Tribunal’s order
dated 08.08.2025 restraining the Appellant from invoking Performance
Bank Guarantee and from acting upon its notice of intention to
terminate dated 13.06.2025 issued under Article 23.1.2 of the EPC
(Engineering, Procurement, and Construction) Agreement1 dated
09.05.2018.
2.
Apparently, the present dispute arises out of a EPC contract
concerning rehabilitation/upgradation of approximately 31.918 km of
NH-752H for a contract price of about Rs.153.59 crore, floated by the
Appellant and awarded to the Respondent, wherein the appointed date
under the contract was 30.06.2018 and the Scheduled Completion Date
“EPCA” hereinafter
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
was relied upon the Respondent was 22.12.2019.
3.
The Respondent has relied upon a recommendation for
provisional completion dated 29.09.2021, stated to be effective from
10.08.2021, and extension of time granted on account of right of way
related issues, whereas the Appellant relies upon 22 Non-Conformity
Report2 issued between June 2019 and April 2021 and subsequent
payment investigations which identified 66 defective panels in 2024,
allegedly increasing to 259 by June 2025, with defects including
cracking of PQC panels.
4.
Following several directions for rectification issued between
December 2024 and March 2025, dispute arose when the Appellant
initiated risk and cost rectification estimated at approximately Rs.20.84
crores and thereafter issued the Notice of Intention to Terminate dated
13.06.2025, leading to constituting the Arbitral Tribunal for resolution
of dispute between the parties.
5.
By way of the impugned order, the Tribunal has pending
adjudication of rights & liabilities of the parties, restrained the
Appellant from giving effect to that notice.
6.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant submits that the Tribunal
wrongly restrained the Notice of Intention to Terminate dated
13.06.2025 despite material showing continuing pavement defects,
including an increase from 66 defective panels in 2024 to 259 by June
“NCR” hereinafter
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
2025, and failed to appreciate that the Respondent’s PCOD/EOT did
not extinguish its independent obligations regarding quality,
workmanship and rectification under Article 11.
7.
It is submitted that the defects concern defective EPC work, and
not merely routine maintenance under Article 14 and that disputed
issues regarding attribution of defects, adequacy of rectification and
compliance with Article 23.1.2 could not effectively be finally
determined at the Section 17 stage.
8.
Per contra, learned Counsel for the Respondent submits that the
arbitration is already at its final stage, with pleadings and evidence
complete and arguments on the claims concluded, and therefore the
Appellant’s attempt to terminate the EPC Agreement at this stage would
prejudice the pending adjudication.
9.
It is contended that the project was substantially completed, and
about 94–95% physically and over 90% financially stands executed.
Additionally, all Schedule-K tests were successfully completed, and the
Authority’s Engineer repeatedly recommended issuance of PCOD.
10.
It is submitted that delays were attributable to Authority such as
ROW, land acquisition, HT-line shifting, forest clearance and local
issues, which were themselves recognised through four EOTs up to
30.09.2021.
11.
According to learned Counsel for Respondent, the defects relied
upon in the termination notice is a unilateral 2024 assessment
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
inconsistent with the earlier PCOD recommendation and are, in any
event, matters falling within the maintenance regime under Article 14.
12.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent submits that Article 23.1.2
does not make the contract freely determinable, since termination is
conditional upon an established Contractor Default and compliance
with the contractual notice-and-cure mechanism. Hence, as per him,
when the existence of such default itself is under adjudication, the
Authority cannot bypass the arbitral process by terminating the contract
and invoking consequential remedies such as bank guarantees.
13.
I have heard both the parties and perused the record.
14.
I do not wish to burden this judgment with a detailed explanation
of the scope of interference under Section 37(2)(b) of the Act.
Therefore, keeping in mind the narrow scope of interference available,
I shall deal with the issues which arise for consideration in this matter.
15.
The dispute pertains to the termination of the EPC contract and
invocation of the performance bank guarantee.
16.
Thus, keeping in mind the narrow scope of interference available
under Section 37(2)(b), the only issue that arises for consideration
before me is whether the arbitral tribunal erred in restraining
determination of the agreement and invocation of the performance bank
guarantee.
17.
Before commencing, it would be in the best interest to go through
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
the findings of the arbitral tribunal with regard to the aforesaid issue.
18.
Accordingly, the findings of
the arbitral
Tribunal can be
summarised into following points.
i.
Appellant’s Engineer had recommended PCOD on 29.09.2021
after recording compliance with contractual requirements and
Schedule-K tests.
ii.
The highway had remained open to traffic for years and the
Respondent had already rectified a large number of distressed
panels.
iii.
Only 66 panels were initially identified as pending and even the
later figure of 259 constituted about 1.5% of total panels.
iv.
No part of the road had been closed or subjected to speed
restrictions and some balance works were prima facie affected
by ROW, local obstructions and issues attributable to Appellant.
v.
The Tribunal also relied on Clause 26.3.5, which according to
Tribunal keeps the Agreement and parties’ rights and obligations
in force pending the arbitral award.
vi.
That the Authority could still carry out repairs at the
Respondent’s risk and cost under Clauses 11.13.2/17.4 without
terminating the contract.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
vii.
Termination and invocation of bank guarantees were considered
unnecessary and potentially prejudicial to the pending
arbitration, while permitting the Authority to proceed with
rectification works.
19.
Having recognized the findings of the arbitral tribunal, since the
present dispute involves termination and invocation of the bank
guarantee, it would be logical for this Court to explore the contractual
procedure under the subject contract.
20.
According to this Court, this would aid in identifying whether the
contract is determinable and whether it permits invocation of the bank
guarantee in the particular circumstances.
21.
The relevant provisions of the EPC Agreement dated 09.05.2018
can be identified as follows:
“10.5 Extension of time for completion
10.5.1 Without prejudice to any other provision of this Agreement
for and in respect of extension of time, the Contractor shall be
entitled to extension of time in the Project Completion Schedule (the
"Time Extension") to the extent that completion of any Project
Milestone is or will be delayed by any of the following, namely:
(a) delay in providing the Right of Way, environmental
clearances or approval of railway authorities, specified in
Clause 4.1.4;
(b) Change of Scope (unless an adjustment to the Scheduled
Completion Date has been agreed under Article 13);
(c) occurrence of a Force Majeure Event;
(d) any delay, impediment or prevention caused by or
attributable to the Authority, the Authority's personnel or the
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
Authority's other contractors on the Site; and
(e) any other cause or delay which entitles the Contractor to
Time Extension in accordance with the provisions of this
Agreement.
10.5.2 The Contractor shall, no later than 15 (fifteen) business days
from the occurrence of an event or circumstance specified in Clause
l 0.5.1, inform the Authority's Engineer by notice in writing, with a
copy to the Authority, stating in reasonable detail with supporting
particulars, the event or circumstances giving rise to the claim for
Time Extension in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement.
Provided that the period of 15 (fifteen) business days shall be
calculated from the date on which the Contractor became aware, or
should have become aware, of the occurrence of such an event or
circumstance.
Provided further that notwithstanding anything to the contrary
contained in this Agreement, Time Extension shall be due and
applicable only for the Works which are affected by the aforesaid
events or circumstances and shall not in any manner affect the
Project Completion Schedule for and in respect of the Works which
are not affected hereunder.
10.5.3 In the event of the failure of the Contractor to issue to the
Authority’s Engineer a notice in accordance with the provisions of
Clause 10.5.2 within the time specified therein, the Contractor shall
not be entitled to any Time Extension and shall forfeit its right for
any such claims in future. For the avoidance of doubt, in the event
of failure of the Contractor to issue notice as specified in this clause
10.5.3, the Authority shall be discharged from all liability in
connection with the claim.
10.5.4 The Authority's Engineer shall, on receipt of the claim in
accordance with the provisions of Clause 10.5.2, examine the claim
expeditiously within the time frame specified herein. In the event the
Authority's Engineer requires any clarifications to examine the
claim, the Authority's Engineer shall seek the same within 15
(fifteen) days from the date of receiving the claim. The Contractor
shall, on receipt of the communication of the Authority's Engineer
requesting for clarification, furnish the same to the Authority's
Engineer within 10 (ten) days thereof. The Authority's Engineer
shall, within a period of 60 (sixty) days from the date of receipt of
such clarifications, forward in writing to the Contractor its
determination of Time Extension.
Provided· that when determining each extension of time under this
Clause 10.5, the Authority's Engineer shall review previous
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
determinations and may increase, but shall not decrease, the total
Time Extension.
10.5.5 If the event or circumstance giving rise to the notice has a
continuing effect:
(a) a fully detailed claim shall be considered as interim;
(b) the Contractor shall, no later than 10 (ten) days after the
close of each month, send. further interim claims specifying the
accumulated delay, the extension of time claimed, and such
further particulars as the Authority’s Engineer may reasonably
require; and
(c) the Contractor shall send a final claim within 30 (thirty) days
after the effect of the event or the circumstance ceases.
Upon receipt of the claim hereunder, the Authority's Engineer shall
examine the same in accordance with the provisions of Clause
10.5.4 within a period of 60 (sixty) days of the receipt thereof.
ARTICLE 11
QUALITY ASSURANCE, MONITORING AND SUPERVISION
11.1
Quality of Materials and workmanship
The Contractor shall ensure that the Construction, Materials and
workmanship are in accordance with the requirements specified in
this Agreement, Specifications and Standards and Good Industry
Practice.
11.2
Quality control system
11.2.1 The Contractor shall establish a quality control mechanism
to ensure compliance with the provisions of this Agreement (the
“Quality Assurance Plan” or “QAP”).
11.2.2 The Contractor shall, within 30 (thirty) days of the
Appointed Date, submit to the Authority’s Engineer its Quality
Assurance Plan which shall include the following:
(a) organisation, duties and responsibilities, procedures,
inspections and documentation;
(b) quality control mechanism including sampling and
testing of Materials, test frequencies, standards, acceptance
criteria, testing facilities, reporting, recording and
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
interpretation of test results, approvals, check list for site
activities, and proforma for testing and calibration in
accordance with the Specifications for Road and Bridge
Works issued by MORTH, relevant IRC specifications and
Good Industry Practice; and
(c) internal quality audit system.
The Authority’s Engineer shall convey its comments to the
Contractor within a period of 21 (twenty-one) days of receipt of the
QAP stating the modifications, if any, required, and the Contractor
shall incorporate those in the QAP to the extent required for
conforming with the provisions of this Clause 11.2.
11.2.3 The Contractor shall procure all documents, apparatus and
instruments, fuel, consumables, water, electricity, labour, Materials,
samples, and qualified personnel as are necessary for examining
and testing the Project Assets and workmanship in accordance with
the Quality Assurance Plan.
11.2.4 The cost of testing of Construction, Materials and
workmanship under this Article 11 shall be borne by the Contractor.
11.3.
Methodology
The Contractor shall, at least 15 (fifteen) days prior to the
commencement of the construction, submit to the Authority's
Engineer for review the methodology proposed to be adopted for
executing the Works, giving details of equipment to be deployed,
traffic management and measures for ensuring safety. The
Authority's Engineer shall complete the review and convey its
comments to the Contractor within a period of 10 (ten) days from
the date of receipt of the proposed methodology from the Contractor.
11.4. Inspection and technical audit by the Authority
The Authority or any representative authorised by the Authority in
this behalf may inspect and review the progress and quality of the
construction of Project Highway and issue appropriate directions to
the Authority's Engineer and the Contractor for taking remedial
action in the event the Works are not in accordance with the
provisions of this Agreement.
11.5 External technical audit
At any time during construction, the Authority may appoint an
external technical auditor to conduct an audit of the quality of the
Works. The findings of the audit, to the extent accepted by the
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
Authority, shall be notified to the Contractor and the Authority’s
Engineer for taking remedial action in accordance with this
Agreement. The Contractor shall provide all assistance as may be
required by the auditor in the conduct of its audit hereunder.
Notwithstanding anything contained in this Clause 11.5, the external
technical audit shall not affect any obligations of the Contractor or
the Authority's Engineer under this Agreement.
11.6 Inspection of construction records
The Authority shall have the right to inspect the records of the
Contractor relating to the Works.
11.7 Monthly progress reports
During the Construction Period, the Contractor shall, no later than
10 (ten) days after the close of each month, furnish. to the Authority
and the Authority's Engineer a monthly report on progress of the
Works and shall promptly give such other relevant information as
may be required by the Authority's Engineer.
11.8 Inspection
11.8.1 The Authority’s Engineer and its authorised representative
shall at all reasonable times:
(a) have full access to all parts of the Site and to all places
from which natural Materials are being obtained for use in
the Works; and
(b) during production, manufacture and construction at the
Site and at the place of production, be entitled to examine,
inspect, measure and test the Materials and workmanship,
and to check the progress of manufacture of Materials.
11.8.2 The Contractor shall give the Authority's Engineer and its
authorised agents access, facilities and safety equipment for
carrying out their obligations under this Agreement.
11.8.3 The Authority’s Engineer shall submit a monthly inspection
report (the “Inspection Report”) to the Authority and the Contractor
bringing out the results of inspections and the remedial action taken
by the Contractor in respect of Defects or deficiencies. For the
avoidance of doubt, such inspection or submission of Inspection
Report by the Authority's Engineer shall not relieve or absolve the
Contractor of its obligations and liabilities under this Agreement in
any manner whatsoever.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
11.9
Samples
The Contractor shall submit the following samples of Materials and
relevant information to the Authority's Engineer for preconstruction review:
(a)
manufacturer's test reports and standard samples of
manufactured Materials; and
(b)
samples of such other Materials as the Authority's
Engineer may require.
11.10 Tests
11.10.1
For determining that the Works conform to the
Specifications and Standards, the Authority's Engineer shall require
the Contractor to carry out or cause to be carried out tests, at such
time and frequency and in such manner as specified in this
Agreement, and in accordance with Good Industry Practice for
quality assurance. The test checks by the Authority's Engineer shall
comprise at least 20 (twenty) percent of the quantity or number of
tests prescribed for each category or type of test for quality control
by the Contractor.
11.10.2
In the event that results of any tests conducted under
this Clause 11.10 establish any Defects or deficiencies in the Works,
the Contractor shall carry out remedial measures and furnish a
report to the Authority's Engineer in this behalf. The Authority's
Engineer shall require the Contractor to carry out or cause to be
carried out tests to determine that such remedial measures have
brought the Works into compliance with the Specifications and
Standards, and the procedure shall be repeated until such Works
conform to the Specifications and Standards. For the avoidance of
doubt, the cost of such tests and remedial measures in pursuance
thereof shall be solely borne by the Contractor.
11.11 Examination of work before covering up
In respect of the work which the Authority’s Engineer is
entitled to examine, inspect, measure and/or test before it is covered
up or put out of view or any part of the work is placed thereon, the
Contractor shall give notice to the Authority's Engineer whenever
any such work is ready and before it is covered up. The Authority's
Engineer shall then either carry out the examination, inspection or
testing without unreasonable delay, or promptly give notice to the
Contractor that the Authority's Engineer does not require to do so.
Provided, however, that if any work is of a continuous nature where
it is not possible or prudent to keep it uncovered or incomplete, the
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
Contractor shall notify the schedule of carrying out such work to
give sufficient opportunity, not being less than 3 (three) business
days' notice, to the Authority's Engineer to conduct its inspection,
measurement or test while the work is continuing. Provided further
that in the event the Contractor receives no response from the
Authority's Engineer within a period of 3 (three) business days from
the date on which the Contractor's notice hereunder is delivered to
the Authority's Engineer, the Contractor shall be entitled to assume
that the Authority's Engineer would not undertake the said
inspection.
11.12 Rejection
If, as a result of an examination, inspection, measurement or
testing, any Plant, Materials, design or workmanship is found to be
defective or otherwise not in accordance with the provisions of this
Agreement, the Authority's Engineer shall reject the Plant,
Materials, design or workmanship by giving notice to the
Contractor, with reasons. The Contractor shall then promptly make
good the Defect and ensure that the rejected item complies with the
requirements of this Agreement.
If the Authority's Engineer requires the Plant, Materials,
design or workmanship to be retested, the tests shall be repeated
under the same terms and conditions, as applicable in each case. If
the rejection and retesting cause the Authority to incur any
additional costs, such cost shall be recoverable by the Authority
from the Contractor; and may be deducted by the Authority from any
monies due to be paid to the Contractor.
11.13 Remedial work
11.13.1 Notwithstanding any previous test or certification, the
Authority's Engineer may instruct the Contractor to:
(a)
remove from the Site and replace any Plant or
Materials which are not in accordance with the provisions
of this Agreement;
( b)
remove and re-execute any work which is not in
accordance with the provisions of this Agreement and the
Specification and Standards; and
(c)
execute any work which is urgently required for the
safety of the Project Highway, whether because of an
accident, unforeseeable event or otherwise; provided that in
case of any work required on account of a Force Majeure
Event, the provisions of Clause 21.6 shall apply.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
11.13.2
If the Contractor fails to comply with the instructions
issued by the Authority's Engineer under Clause 11.13.1, within the
time specified in the Authority's Engineer's notice or as mutually
agreed, the Authority's Engineer may advise the Authority to have
the work executed by another agency. The cost so incurred by the
Authority for undertaking such work shall, without prejudice to the
rights of the Authority to recover Damages in accordance with the
provisions of this Agreement, be recoverable from the Contractor
and may be deducted by the Authority from any monies due to be
paid to the Contractor.
11.14 Delays during construction
Without prejudice to the provisions of Clause 10.3.2, in the
event the Contractor does not achieve any of the Project Milestones
or the Authority's Engineer shall have reasonably determined that
the rate of progress of Works is such that Completion of the Project
Highway is not likely to be achieved by the end of the Scheduled
Completion Date, it shall notify the same to the Contractor, and the
Contractor shall, within 15 (fifteen) days of such notice, by a
communication inform the Authority's Engineer in reasonable detail
about the steps it proposes to take to expedite progress and the
period within which it shall achieve the Project Completion Date.
11.15 Quality control records and Documents
The Contractor shall hand over to the Authority's Engineer a copy
of all its quality control records and documents before the
Completion Certificate is issued pursuant to Clause 12.2.
11.16 Video recording
During the Construction Period, the Contractor shall
provide to the Authority for every calendar quarter, a video
recording, which will be compiled into a 3 (three)-hour compact disc
or digital video disc, as the case may be, covering the status and
progress of Works in that quarter. The video recording shall be
provided to the Authority no later than 15 (fifteen) days after the
close of each quarter after the Appointed Date.
11.17 Suspension of unsafe Construction Works
11.17.1
Upon recommendation of the Authority's Engineer to
this effect, the Authority may by notice require the Contractor to
suspend forthwith the whole or any part of the Works if, in the
reasonable opinion of the Authority's Engineer, such work threatens
the safety of the Users and pedestrians.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
11.17.2
The Contractor shall, pursuant to the notice under
Clause 11.17.1, suspend the Works or any part thereof for such time
and in such manner as may be specified by the Authority and
thereupon carry out remedial measures to secure the safety of
suspended works, the Users and pedestrians. The Contractor may
by notice require the Authority's Engineer to inspect such remedial
measures forthwith and make a report to the Authority
recommending whether or not the suspension hereunder may be
revoked. Upon receiving the recommendations of the Authority's
Engineer, the Authority shall either revoke such suspension or
instruct the Contractor to carry out such other and further remedial
measures as may be necessary in the reasonable opinion of the
Authority, and the procedure set forth in this Clause 11.17 shall be
repeated until the suspension hereunder is revoked.
11.17.3
Subject to the provisions of Clause 21.6, all
reasonable costs incurred for maintaining and protecting the Works
or part thereof during the period of suspension (the "Preservation
Costs"), shall be borne by the Contractor; provided that if the
suspension has occurred as a result of any breach of this Agreement
by the Authority, the Preservation Costs shall be borne by the
Authority.
11.17.4
If suspension of Works is for reasons not attributable
to the Contractor, the Authority's Engineer shall determine any Time
Extension to which the Contractor is reasonably entitled.
Article 12
Completion Certificate
12.2
Provisional Certificate
12.2.5 No Provisional Certificate shall be issued under the
provisions of this Clause 12.2 until the Contractor has submitted
valid claims for payment of at least 80% (eighty per cent) of the
amount arrived at after reducing the lump sum price specified in
Clause 19.1.1 by the amount attributable to works which have been
withdrawn under the provisions of Clause 8.3.3. For the avoidance
of doubt and by way of illustration, the Parties agree that if the
Contract Price specified in Clause 19.1.1 is Rs. 105 cr. (Rs. one
hundred and five crore) and the works withdrawn under Clause
8.3.3 have a value of Rs. 5 cr. (Rs. five crore), a Provisional
Certificate shall not be issued until valid claims for payment of an
amount of Rs. 80 cr. (Rs. eighty crore) have been submitted by the
Contractor in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement. It
is further agreed that all price adjustments made in pursuance of
Clause 19.10 shall not be reckoned for computation of the claims for
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
payments referred to in Clause 12.2.5.
ARTICLE 14-ΜΑΙΝΤΕΝΑNCE
14.1
Maintenance obligations of the Contractor
14.1.1 The Contractor shall maintain the Project Highway for a
period of 4 (four) years commencing from the date of the Provisional
Certificate (the "Maintenance Period"). For the performance of its
Maintenance obligations, the contractor shall be paid 0.25% of the
Contract Price for the first year and 0.5%, 0.75%, 1% of the
Contract Price for the second, third and fourth year respectively in
case of road projects. But in case of stand alone Bridge / structure
work, the contractor shall be paid 0.25%, 0.5%, 0.5% and 0.5% of
the Contract Price for the first, second, third and fourth year
respectively. Amount shall be, inclusive of all taxes. The amount
payable for maintenance shall be adjusted to reflect any increase or
decrease arising out of variation in WPI to be determined in
accordance with the provisions of Clause 19.12. For the avoidance
of doubt, it is agreed that in the event no Provisional Certificate is
issued, the Maintenance Period shall commence from the date of the
Completion Certificate. It is further agreed that the Contract Price
hereunder shall be reckoned with reference to the amount specified
in Clause 19.1.1, which shall be adjusted to the extent of Change of
Scope and the works withdrawn under the provisions of Clause
8.3.3, but shall not include any price adjustments in pursuance of
Clause 19.10.
ARTICLE 17-DEFECTS LIABILITY
17.1 Defects Liability Period
17.1.1 The Contractor shall be responsible for all the Defects and
deficiencies, except usual wear and tear in the Project Highway or
any Section thereof, till the expiry of a period of 4 (four) years
commencing from the date of Provisional Certificate (the "Defects
Liability Period"). Provided that the Defects Liability Period shall
in no case be less than 48 (forty eight) months from the date of
Completion Certificate for and in respect of works for which Time
Extension was granted. Provided further that in the event no
Provisional Certificate is issued, the Defects Liability Period shall
commence from the date of the Completion Certificate. For the
avoidance of doubt, any repairs or restoration on account of usual
wear or tear in the Project Highway or any Section thereof shall
form a part of the Maintenance obligations of the Contractor as
specified in Article 14.
17.1.2 Deleted.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
17.2 Remedying Defects
Save and except as provided in Clause 14.1.2, the Contractor shall
repair or rectify all Defects and deficiencies observed by the
Authority's Engineer during the Defects Liability Period within a
period of 15 (fifteen) days from the date of notice issued by the
Authority's Engineer in this behalf, or within such reasonable period
as may be determined by the Authority's Engineer at the request of
the Contractor, in accordance with Good Industry Practice.
17.3 Cost of remedying Defects
For the avoidance of doubt, any repair or rectification undertaken
in accordance with the provisions of Clause 17.2, including any
additional testing, shall be carried out by the Contractor at its own
risk and cost, to the extent that such rectification or repair is
attributable to:
(a)
the design of the Project;
( b)
Plant, Materials or workmanship not being in
accordance with this Agreement and the Specifications and
Standards;
(c)
improper maintenance during construction of the
Project Highway by the Contractor; and/or
(d)
failure by the Contractor to comply with any other
obligation under this Agreement.
17.4
Contractor's failure to rectify Defects
In the event that the Contractor fails to repair or rectify such
Defect or deficiency within the period specified in Clause 17.2, the
Authority shall be entitled to get the same repaired, rectified or
remedied at the Contractor's cost so as to make the Project Highway
conform to the Specifications and Standards and the provisions of
this Agreement. All costs consequent thereon shall, after due
consultation with the Authority and the Contractor, be determined
by the Authority's Engineer. The cost so determined and an amount
equal to twenty percent of the cost as Damages shall be recoverable
by the Authority from the Contractor and may be deducted by the
Authority from any monies due to the Contractor.
17.5
Contractor to search cause
17.5.1 The Authority's Engineer may instruct the Contractor to
examine the cause of any Defect in the Works or part thereof before
the expiry of the Defects Liability Period.
17.5.2 In the event any Defect identified under Clause 17.5.1 is
attributable to the Contractor, the Contractor shall rectify such
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
Defect within the period specified by the Authority's Engineer, and
shall bear the cost of the examination and rectification of such
Defect.
17.5.3 In the event such Defect is not attributable to the Contractor,
the Authority's Engineer shall, after due consultation with the
Authority and the Contractor, determine the costs incurred by the
Contractor on such examination and notify the same to the
Contractor, with a copy to the Authority, and the Contractor shall
be entitled to payment of such costs by the Authority.
17.6. Extension of Defects Liability Period
The Defects Liability Period shall be deemed to be extended till the
identified Defects under Clause 17.2 have been remedied.
ARTICLE 23-TERMINATION
23.1 Termination for Contractor Default
23.1.1 Save as otherwise provided in this Agreement, in the event
that any of the defaults specified below shall have occurred, and the
Contractor fails to cure the default within the Cure Period set forth
below, or where no Cure Period is specified, then within a Cure
Period of 60 (sixty) days, the Contractor shall be deemed to be in
default of this Agreement (the "Contractor Default"), unless the
default has occurred solely as a result of any breach of this
Agreement by the Authority or due to Force Majeure. The defaults
referred to herein shall include:
(a) the Contractor fails to provide, extend or replenish, as
the case may be, the Performance Security in accordance
with this Agreement;
(b) subsequent to the replenishment or furnishing of fresh
Performance Security in accordance with Clause 7.3, the
Contractor fails to cure, within a Cure Period of 30 (thirty)
days, the Contractor Default for which the whole or part of
the Performance Security was appropriated;
(c) the Contractor does not achieve the latest outstanding
Project Milestone due in accordance with the provisions of
Schedule-J, subject to any Time Extension, and continues to
be in default for 45 (forty five) days;
(d) the Contractor abandons or manifests intention to
abandon the construction or Maintenance of the Project
Highway without the prior written consent of the Authority;
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
(e) the Contractor fails to proceed with the Works in
accordance with the provisions of Clause 10.1 or stops
Works and/or the Maintenance for 30 (thirty) days without
reflecting the same in the current programme and such
stoppage has not been authorised by the Authority's
Engineer;
(f) the Project Completion Date does not occur within the
period specified in Schedule-J for the Scheduled Completion
Date, or any extension thereof;
(g) failure to complete the Punch List items within the
periods stipulated therefor in Clause 12.2.1;
(h) the Contractor fails to rectify any Defect, the nonrectification of which shall have a Material Adverse Effect
on the Project, within the time specified in this Agreement or
as directed by the Authority's Engineer;
(i) the Contractor subcontracts the Works or any part thereof
in violation of this Agreement or assigns any part of the
Works or the Maintenance without the prior approval of the
Authority;
(j) the Contractor creates any Encumbrance in breach of this
Agreement;
(k) an execution levied on any of the assets of the Contractor
has caused a Material Adverse Effect;
(1) the Contractor is adjudged bankrupt or insolvent, or if a
trustee or receiver is appointed for the Contractor or for the
whole or material part of its assets that has a material
bearing on the Project;
(m) the Contractor has been, or is in the process of being
liquidated, dissolved, wound-up, amalgamated or
reconstituted in a manner that would cause, in the
reasonable opinion of the Authority, a Material Adverse
Effect;
(n) a resolution for winding up of the Contractor is passed,
or any petition for winding up of the Contractor is admitted
by a Court of competent jurisdiction and a provisional
liquidator or receiver is appointed and such order has not
been set aside within 90 (ninety) days of the date thereof or
the Contractor is ordered to be wound up by Court except
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
for the purpose of amalgamation or reconstruction;
provided that, as part of such amalgamation or
reconstruction, the entire property, assets and undertaking
of the Contractor are transferred to the amalgamated or
reconstructed entity and that the amalgamated or
reconstructed entity has unconditionally assumed the
obligations of the Contractor under this Agreement; and
provided that:
(i) the amalgamated or reconstructed entity has the
capability and experience necessary for the
performance of its obligations under this Agreement;
and
(ii) the amalgamated or reconstructed entity has the
financial standing to perform its obligations under
this Agreement and has a credit worthiness at least
as good as that of the Contractor as at the Appointed
Date;
(o) any representation or warranty of the Contractor herein
contained which is, as of the date hereof, found to be
materially false or the Contractor is at any time hereafter
found to be in breach thereof;
(p) the Contractor submits to the Authority any statement,
notice or other document, in written or electronic form,
which has a material effect. on the Authority's rights,
obligations or interests and which is false in material
particulars;
(q) the Contractor has failed to fulfil any obligation, for
which failure Termination has been specified in this
Agreement; or
(r) the Contractor commits a default in complying with any
other provision of this Agreement if such a default causes a
Material Adverse Effect on the Project or on the Authority.
23 .1.2 Without prejudice to any other rights or remedies
which the Authority may have under this Agreement, upon
occurrence of a Contractor Default, the Authority shall be
entitled to terminate this Agreement by issuing a
Termination Notice to the Contractor; provided that before
issuing the Termination Notice, the Authority shall by a
notice inform the Contractor of its intention to issue such
Termination Notice and grant 15 (fifteen) days to the
Contractor to make a representation, and may after the
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
expiry of such 15 (fifteen) days, whether or not it is in receipt
of such representation, issue the Termination Notice.
26.3 Arbitration
26.3.5 This Agreement and the rights and obligations of the
Parties shall remain in full force and effect, pending the A
ward in any arbitration proceedings hereunder.”
22.
Thus, it could be understood from a facial reading of the
aforesaid provisions of the contract that Article 11 and Article 17
determines the Respondent’s responsibility when there is defective
work and also provides for the Appellant’s remedies if the defective
work is not rectified. Article 23 determines when the non-rectification
of the defective work can justify termination of the subject agreement.
23.
Article 11.13.1 applicable during execution of the work and
Article 17.1.1, which is applicable for defect liability period, stipulates
the Respondent’s responsibility for defects and deficiencies in the
project.
24.
The most significant clause, is Article 11.13.2 and 17.4. It
stipulates an express remedy for the Appellant i.e. if the Respondent
fails to rectify the defect within the periods specified under clause
11.13.2 and 17.2 respectively, the Appellant can engage another agency
to carry out the rectification at the Respondent’s cost. However, the
Appellant’s engineer must determine the consequential costs after due
consultation with the authority and the contractor.
25.
The arbitral tribunal has also separated the Appellant's right to
rectify the defects from its right to terminate the agreement.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
26.
The Supreme Court in K.S. Manjunath v. Moorasavirappa3,
distinguished contracts that are inherently revocable or terminable
without cause from contracts terminable upon specified breach, notice
and opportunity to cure.
27.
Having gone through Article 23 of the EPC agreement, the
present agreement is a contract terminable both for cause and for
convenience. Article 23.3 stipulates “Notwithstanding anything stated
hereinabove, the Authority may terminate this Agreement for
convenience.”
28.
In Manjunath (supra), the Supreme Court laid out five categories
of contracts.
“64.
In this backdrop, it would be useful to advert to the
classification set out in A. Murugan (supra), wherein the Madras
High Court categorised contracts into five broad classes
depending on their ease of determinability. Out of those, the first
two i.e., (i) contracts inherently revocable such as licences and
partnerships at will, and (ii) contracts terminable unilaterally on
a “without-cause” basis, were held to be determinable in nature.
The remaining classes, namely, (iii) contracts terminable for
cause without provision for cure, (iv) contracts terminable for
cause with notice and opportunity to cure, and (v) contracts
without a termination clause but terminable only for breach of a
condition, were all held not determinable in nature.”
29.
It is prima facie made out that the subject agreement has the
features of both Category(ii) and (iv) as Article 23.3 provides a without
cause termination right to the Appellant, while Article 23.1 provides
(2025 INSC 1298)
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
conditional termination for default.
30.
Since the impugned Notice dated 13.06.2025 invokes Article
23.1.2, not Article 23.3, the Appellant cannot justify its proposed
termination for Default merely by relying to its separate power to
terminate for convenience.
31.
As per para 17 of the impugned order, the Tribunal has recorded
(i) successful completion tests, (ii) the PCOD recommendation, (iii)
earlier compliance reports, (iv) substantial rectification of distressed
panels and disputed technical findings.
32.
The determination of Default under Article 23.1.1(h) requires
examination which the tribunal has done on its level, and ruled in favor
of the Respondents by preserving the rights as in the agreement pending
the arbitration.
33.
Even though this Court may want to substitute its finding,
However, on the basis of material placed on record, the Tribunal has
examined the above mentioned circumstances in para 17 and then laid
out its finding.
34.
Thus, the Appellant is not able to make out a prima facie case in
his favour.
35.
The second facet of the Appellant's prayer before the Learned
Arbitral Tribunal was the invocation of the bank guarantee. The learned
Arbitral Tribunal has restrained the invocation of the bank guarantee.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
36.
The law pertaining to the invocation and encashment of an
unconditional bank guarantee is equally well settled.
37.
An unconditional bank guarantee, no doubt, constitutes an
independent contract between the bank and the beneficiary. The
Supreme Court has held in multiple cases that it must be honoured
according to its terms.
38.
Interference with the invocation and encashment of a bank
guarantee is allowed only in exceptional cases of fraud of an egregious
nature or special equities in the form of irrecoverable injustice of such
a kind that restitution is impossible.
39.
The supreme Court in U.P. State Sugar Corporation v. Sumac
International Ltd.4 held as follows on injunctions granting invocation
of unconditional bank guarantee.
“12. The law relating to invocation of such bank guarantees is by
now well settled. When in the course of commercial dealings an
unconditional bank guarantee is given or accepted, the beneficiary
is entitled to realize such a bank guarantee in terms thereof
irrespective of any pending disputes. The bank giving such a
guarantee is bound to honour it as per its terms irrespective of any
dispute raised by its customer. The very purpose of giving such a
bank guarantee would otherwise be defeated. The courts should,
therefore, be slow in granting an injunction to restrain the
realization of such a bank guarantee. The courts have carved out
only two exceptions. A fraud in connection with such a bank
guarantee would vitiate the very foundation of such a bank
guarantee. Hence if there is such a fraud of which the beneficiary
seeks to take advantage, he can be restrained from doing so. The
second exception relates to cases where allowing the encashment of
(1997) 1 SCC 568
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
an unconditional bank guarantee would result in irretrievable harm
or injustice to one of the parties concerned. Since in most cases
payment of money under such a bank guarantee would adversely
affect the bank and its customer at whose instance the guarantee is
given, the harm or injustice contemplated under this head must be
of such an exceptional and irretrievable nature as would override
the terms of the guarantee and the adverse effect of such an
injunction on commercial dealings in the country. The two grounds
are not necessarily connected, though both may coexist in some
cases. In the case of U.P. Coop. Federation Ltd. v. Singh
Consultants and Engineers (P) Ltd. [(1988) 1 SCC 174] which was
the case of a works contract where the performance guarantee given
under the contract was sought to be invoked, this Court, after
referring extensively to English and Indian cases on the subject, said
that the guarantee must be honoured in accordance with its terms.
The bank which gives the guarantee is not concerned in the least
with the relations between the supplier and the customer; nor with
the question whether the supplier has performed his contractual
obligation or not, nor with the question whether the supplier is in
default or not. The bank must pay according to the tenor of its
guarantee on demand without proof or condition. There are only two
exceptions to this rule. The first exception is a case when there is a
clear fraud of which the bank has notice. The fraud must be of an
egregious nature such as to vitiate the entire underlying transaction.
Explaining the kind of fraud that may absolve a bank from
honouring its guarantee, this Court in the above case quoted with
approval the observations of Sir John Donaldson, M.R. in Bolivinter
Oil SA v. Chase Manhattan Bank [(1984) 1 All ER 351] (All ER at
p. 352): (at SCC p. 197)
“The wholly exceptional case where an injunction may be
granted is where it is proved that the bank knows that any
demand for payment already made or which may thereafter be
made will clearly be fraudulent. But the evidence must be clear
both as to the fact of fraud and as to the bank's knowledge. It
would certainly not normally be sufficient that this rests on the
uncorroborated statement of the customer, for irreparable
damage can be done to a bank's credit in the relatively brief time
which must elapse between the granting of such an injunction
and an application by the bank to have it charged.”
This Court set aside an injunction granted by the High Court to
restrain the realisation of the bank guarantee.”
40.
It is an admitted fact that, in the present case, no fraud, let alone
one of an egregious nature, in the execution or invocation of the
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
performance bank guarantee has been pleaded by the Respondent.
41.
Additionally, the nature of the bank guarantee is also undisputed
here.
42.
The Arbitral Tribunal in Para 7.22 holds the following:
“7.22. Termination of Contract at this stage (i) may frustrate the
arbitral process where all the issues of quality of construction and
for delay in execution of balance items of works leading to nonrecording PCOD by the Respondent are sub-judice, and (ii)
invocation of bank guarantees can be compensated in financial
terms, but the Claimant will suffer irreparable reputational injury
which cannot be compensated in financial terms.”
43.
Thus, Tribunal expressly acknowledges that invocation of bank
guarantees is financially compensable. However,
its finding of
irreparable injury relies on reputational damage associated with
termination.
44.
The only question which arises for consideration before this
Court is can the arbitral tribunal justify invocation and encashment of a
performance bank guarantee on the ground of irreparable reputational
injury.
45.
The Tribunal expressly acknowledges that invocation of bank
guarantees is financially compensable. Its finding of irreparable injury
concerns reputational damage associated with termination, rather than
any demonstrated irretrievable harm arising specifically from
encashment.
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
46.
The law pertaining to irreversible justice is also clear, the
Supreme Court in multiple decisions have held that the second
exception applies only where the injury is exceptional, genuine,
immediate and effectively irreversible, such that even if the contractor
ultimately succeeds, restitution or reimbursement would be practically
impossible.
47.
Therefore, a mere finding that invocation of a Performance Bank
Guarantee would harm the Respondent’s reputation does not satisfy the
test unless the Tribunal further records and justifies why such harm is
incapable of being remedied or compensated subsequently or an
exceptional situation is identified.
48.
In the absence of such findings, the restraint is unable to sustain.
49.
For the aforesaid reasons, the appeal is partly allowed to the
extent that stay on invocation on performance bank guarantee is set
aside.
50.
The appeal stands partly allowed in the aforesaid terms.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J
SEPTEMBER 17, 2026/at/pa/gunn
Signed By:ANUBHAV
ARB. A. (COMM.) 60/2025
TRIPATHI
14:37:07
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review