Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/mohinder-singh-vs-state-of-punjab-and-others-20260406/ · Printed 18 Nov 2026
Civil

Mohinder Singh vs State of Punjab and Others

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Punjab & Haryana High Court
Date
6 April 2026
Case No.
RA-CW 605/2025
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Justice Deepak Sibal, Justice Lapita Banerji
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

32. In the light of aforesaid discussion ussion and the law governing the field, the review application is dismissed in li limine with costs assessed at Rs.20,000/- to be paid to the Poor Patient atient Welfare Fund, PGIMER, Chandigarh, for wasting precious judicial ial tim time and by re-agitating the settled issues ues ag again and again showing scant nt reg regard for authority of law. 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20

33. Con Connected application(s), if any, sshall also stand disposed of accordingly. (DEEPAK SIB

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 IN THE HIGH H COURT OF PUNJAB JAB A AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH RA-CW CW-605 of 2025 in CWP P No No.10001 of 2025 Mohinderr Sing Singh ... ...Applicant/Petitioner Versus State of Punjab unjab and others 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. ...R ...Respondents The date when w the judgment is reserved The date when w the judgment is pronounce ounced The date when w the judgment is uploaded aded Whether ether only operative part of the ju judgment is pronounce nounced or whether the full ll jud judgment is pronounce nounced The delay, delay if any of the pronounceme ncement of full judgment, ment, and reasons thereof 14.01.2026 06.04.2026 08.04.2026 Full Not applicable CORAM : HON’BLE HO MR. JUSTICE DEEP DEEPAK SIBAL HO HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE LAPIT APITA BANERJI Present : Mr. Naresh Kaushal, Advocate and Mr Mr Nitish Kaushal, Advocate, Mr. for the applicant. Mr. Himanshu Raj, Addl. AG,, Punj Mr Punjab and Ms Mandeep Kaur, DAG, Punjab. Ms. unjab. LAPITA BANE ANERJI, J. Thi is an application for review This view oof an order dated December 02, 2025 passed by this Bench in CWP No.10 No.10001 of 2025. Eight grounds have been urged urge by the review applicant/writ writ petitioner for modification/ reviewing of tthe order dated December er 02 02, 2025. The grounds are reproduced d alon along with the submissions made by learned counsel for the review applican plicant on each ground. Thereafter, ter, an analysis and conclusion of this Court on each o of the grounds is noted. 2. Mr Himanshu, Addl. AG, Punjab Mr. unjab appeared on advance notice for assistance nce of the Court and submitted that tthe review application is not maintainable. SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 3. The review applicant, being dis--satisfied with the findings of the Courtt reco recorded in the judgment unde under review has sought for recalling/modifi modification of the same by various rious grounds. The grounds No.1 and 2 in paragra aragraph 5 of the review application are reproduced hereunder: “(I) The petitioner showed no in “(I interest to receive a copy of the 2013 report that was handed ded over to Court by GMADA des despite the fact that his valuable able rights over his land were bei determined pursuant to that being hat rreport. (II) No challenge was laid to tthe report dated August 31, 201 The petitioner cannot bee al 2013. allowed to re-open/re-agitate the said issue after 12 years of the impugned report dated 31. 31.08.2013.” 4. Lea Learned counsel for the review ew app applicant in respect of the said grounds, has pleaded pl and submitted thatt the rreport relied upon by a Coordinate Bench ench while disposing the writ petitio petition being CWP No. 21263 of 2011 as ‘infruct fructuous’ is dated August 31, 2013 which was Saturday and the hearing off the ccase was held on Monday i.e S September 2, 2013. The said report indicatin icating the quantum of released lan land, was not supplied to the petitioner during durin hearing on September 2, 201 2013 and was done before the contempt Court in the year 2024. The petitione titioner was under the impression that entire 16 marlas m of his land was released sed in his favour and was shocked to learn in 2015 that the entirety of disputed ted lan land was mutated in favour of the government. nment. 5. It is the th petitioner’s case that subsequ bsequent to filing of the contempt petition being eing COCP C No.1568 of 2022 thee petiti petitioner for the first time learnt that the structure/house structu situated on 09 marla marlas of land belonging to the petitioner was released. r The action/inaction w was in violation of the order dated Septembe tember 02, 2013 passed in CWP No. No.21263 of 2011 as 01 kanal 01 marla (21 marla marlas) of land was released by the authorities despite the said land being vacant. vacan SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 6. It was w contended that since the lan land of the petitioner was de- notified on n Apr April 21, 2023 and not on Septe eptember 02, 2013 the date of judgment, therefore, there fresh cause of action ion ac accrued in the year 2023 in favour of the petitioner p and the review applic applicant/petitioner could not be non-suited d on the t ground of delay of 12 ye years. Immediately, after the dismissal of the contempt petition on February bruary 19, 2025, the present writ petition was as filed file in March, 2025 by the petitio petitioner. Therefore, the question of delay in filin filing the present writ petitionn does not and could not arise. It was beseeched ched tthat records of the contempt Cou Court should be summoned and perused, from rom which it would transpire that at enti entire 16 marlas of land marked in black colour had been recommendedd to be released. The aforesaid submissions ns have hav been pleaded in paragraph aph 5 of the review application in grounds a,, b, c, d, e and f under ground No.2. 7. Wh hearing the main writ petitio While petition, this Court had considered the submissions issions on behalf of the petitioner/revi er/review applicant with regard to officers’ report eport being handed over to the petition petitioner in 2024 and not in 2013. After considerin sidering the said submissions it had been observed that in the event the petitioner’s petitio argument was accepted pted th the only conclusion it would lead to wass that the petitioner had shown no inte interest to receive a copy of the 2013 report rt that was handed over to the Court ourt bby GMADA despite the fact that his valuable aluable rights were being determined ined ppursuant to that report. Since there was no challenge ch to the officers’ report eport dated August 31, 2013, the petitioner was not n permitted to re-open/re-agitat agitate the issues after 12 years of submission of the th said report. 8. Mr Kaushal has sought to agitate Mr. gitate that the authorities released the vacantt land situated in Khasra No.99/1 /1 adm admeasuring 01 kanal 01 marla (21 marlas) belonging belo to Harjinder Singhh and Swaran Singh sons of Ishar SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 Singh pursuant suant to the officers’ report datedd Aug August 31, 2013 contrary to the directions for re release by the Co-ordinate Bench ench. 9. It is not lost upon the mind ind oof this Court that the said Harjinder Singh and Swaran Singh have not be been made parties in the writ petition and nd by perusing column No.6 under der the heading ‘Set Back’ on page no. 250 off the main m paper book, it cannot be op opined whether such land that was allegedly edly released in their favour was as vaca vacant or not. The area of land that has been recommended to be released in favour of the petitioner is contained in co column No.5 under the heading eading ‘Covered Area’. Learned counsel for or the petitioner has factually sought ought to re-argue the writ petition by referring ng to the t annexures appended to the m main paper book, which is not permissible le in a review petition. 10. Assu Assuming vacant land had been mist mistakenly released in favour of the aforesaid aid persons pe even then, it could nott be contended on behalf of the petitioner that the same should be done in his fa favour, claiming parity based on negative ve discrimination. disc It is a well settled ettled proposition of law that two wrongs cannot annot m make a right. The fact that at the petitioner had been residing with his family amily members since long is noo grou ground for reviewing impugned judgment and di directing de-notification of 07 ma marlas of land in favour of the petitioner and the said argument had been en con considered and rejected by the Bench earlier.. 11. Inc Incorrect pleadings find place in placitum (b) of ground (ii) of paragraph 5 of the review application seeking king to create a misplaced opinion that this Court ourt had noticed that officers’ report dated August 31, 2013 was supplied belated belatedly to the petitioner, before re the contempt Court in 2024. In the paragraph under reference, this Court had oonly noted the contentions of SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 Mr.Kaushal, al, learned lea counsel appearing for the petitioner and after noting his contentions, tions, the same were rejected. 12. At this juncture, it would be appos apposite to refer to paragraph 13 of the judgme udgment under review wherein it has been recorded that “interestingly ly the th learned counsel who repres presented the writ petitioner in CWP No.21263 263 of 2011 also represented the he ppetitioner in the present writ petition, being ing CWP No.10001 of 2025”. The Therefore, the Court found it difficult to o accept acce the contention of the petition etitioner that even though he was unaware off the area of the land sought to be rele released from acquisition in his favour, he showed show no interest to receivee a co copy of 2013 report that was handed over ver to the Court by GMADA, despit despite his valuable rights being determined by the report. The report contai contained the quantum of land proposed to be released. Therefore, the marked arked portion in black in the site plan indicates cates the location of land thatt was covered and sought to be released and nd no not the entirety of the land occupi upied by the petitioner and the quantum of the same is contained in the report of 2013. The petitioner has now sought ht to rrely on a site plan which was as no not placed before it during the hearing off main writ petition. This courtt is als also of the view that material that was availab vailable to the petitioner and not ot plac placed during the hearing of the writ petition on cannot can be produced for the first rst tim time in review. 13. The next two grounds for seekin seeking review are the following observations ns by this Court: “xxx “xx (III The petitioner cannott to (III) today be allowed to take adv advantage of his ignorance espec specially when the land stands util utilized. SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document (IV) The petitioner wants his 07 marlas of land to be (IV rele released, the onus is on him to sshow that there was pucca con construction on the said land nd prior to the report dated 31. 31.08.2013, it is not for the authori thorities to go and assess the age RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 of the said temporary construct truction/cattle shed which are alle alleged to have been constructed ed in the year 1975-76. xx” xxx 14. Lea Learned counsel for the review ew app applicant again sought to argue that as the disputed dispu land admeasuring 07 marlas has not been utilised by the authorities since pucca structures are standing nding thereupon, the same should be released. Reference Ref has been made to Annex nnexure P-16 of the writ petition as well as paragraph parag 23 at page 18, of the paper book. 15. Att Attention of this Court was drawn to the electricity bill dated July 12, 1982 (Annexure P-3) at page 35 of the writ petition and the revenue record ecord/jamabandis for the year 2003-04 04 and 2008-09 at Annexures P-1 and P-2 2 showing sho the land to be ‘gair mu mumkin makan’. The old site plan of Novemb ovember 05, 2011 has also been referr referred to by the learned counsel for the review view aapplicant/petitioner. Based on the he aforesaid documents, it has been contended ended that the construction wass an ol old one and such factum was not controverted verted by the State in their reply. ly. Th Thus, the State failed to bring on record any corroborative co evidence to show how th that the land stood utilised. 16. Ref Reference to the documentss in tthe garb of which the writ petition is sought sough to be re-argued, were docum ocuments relating to 1982, 200304, 2008-09 09 and 2011 all of which were avail available before the Co-ordinate Bench while ile passing pas the order September 02, 20 2013. The Co-ordinate Bench after applying ying it its mind to the facts and evidence idence on record passed the order for releasee of only on the constructed portion of the land of the petitioners from acquisition. n. The said documents were alsoo plac placed before this Court during hearing off the main m writ petition filed in the he yea year 2025. 17. Thi Court after considering all th This the aforesaid submissions of the petitioner ner during du hearing of the main writ ppetition had passed the order SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 dated Decembe cember 02, 2025 which is under rev review. It had called for the original records record pertaining to inclusion of tthe disputed 07 marlas of petitioner’s ’s land in development of residential ntial ccolony for the Economically Weaker Section ection (EWS) in IT City, Sector 101--Alpha Block-D and the same was produced uced by the Chief Administrator, ator, GMADA being personally present in Cour Court. After satisfying itself that at the said land stood utilised for the purpose se of cconstructing residential colony olony for members of EWS in IT City, the said findings fin of facts were recorded in the judgment under review. The learned ed counsel cou for the petitioner is now se seeking to re-argue the entire writ petition ion by filing a review application ion wh which course of action is not available to him in law. 18. The grounds No.5 and 6 for review are set out hereinafter: “xx “xxx (V) The petitioner has vaguely uely pleaded the discrimination vis vis-à-vis another land ownerr w whose 01 marla land was pur purportedly released without prov providing any necessary detail qua such discrimination. (VI) The petitioner has accepted (VI ted the report dated 31.08. 2013 sho showing release of 9 marla off lan land and contempt petition is dism dismissed vide order dated 19.0 19.02.2025 qua remaining 07 ma marlas of land and the petitioner ioner cannot be allowed to reagi agitate the same issue again andd ag again. xx” xxx en reit reiterated that 21 marlas landd has been released in favour of It has been Harjinder Singh and Swaran Singh who we were the petitioners in CWP No.4664 of 201 2012 ‘Harjinder Singh v. State of P Punjab and others’. The said writ petition was wa also decided vide common mon order dated September 02, 2013. The land of the said persons was duly uly re released despite being vacant and being situated situ away from the Phirni irni oof the village whereas the SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 petitioner’s land which touched the Phirni,, thou though eligible for release, was arbitrarily not released. 19. It is i contended that the pleadings ings aat page Nos.16 and 17 of the main writt petition peti on the area of landd rele released to aforesaid persons remained uncontroverted uncon as no reply was fi filed by the respondents to contradict the same and the disposal/closure/ losure/dismissal of the contempt petition could ould not no curtail the remedy available lable to the petitioner of filing of a fresh petition ition under u Article 226 of thee Con Constitution of India. All the aforesaid submissions submi have also been pleaded ded in the review application. 20. As discussed hereinabove, the he peti petitioners did not implead the said Harjinder jinder Singh and Swaran Singh ingh aas parties to the present proceedings. gs. A Assuming that 21 marlas off vaca vacant land out of 07 kanals 01 marla land d had been released by the authoritie horities in favour of said persons, and the factum ctum of such release land had not ot bee been controverted by the State, even then such release r would not or couldd not have affected the outcome of the main writ petition p as negative discriminat imination cannot be the basis for granting relief to the petitioner. Reliance can be placed on Apex Court judgment in “Basawaraj “Ba and another v. Specia ecial Land Acquisition Officer” reported in (2013) (20 14 SCC 81 for such a view taken by this Court. The relevant extract xtract thereof is reproduced hereinafte inafter: “xx “xxx SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 8. It is a settled legal propos oposition that Article 14 of the Con Constitution is not meant to perpet rpetuate illegality or fraud, even by extending the wrong decisions ns m made in other cases. The said pro provision does not envisage negat egative equality but has only a pos positive aspect. Thus, if some othe other similarly situated persons hav been granted some relief/b have lief/benefit inadvertently or by mis mistake, such an order does not confer any legal right on oth to get the same relief as wel others well. If a wrong is committed in an earlier case, it cannot be perp perpetuated. Equality is a trite, whi cannot be claimed in illegal which egality and therefore, cannot be enf enforced by a citizen or Court urt iin negative manner. If any RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 illegality and irregularity has been committed in favour of an ille ind individual or a group of individual duals or a wrong order has been pas passed by a judicial forum, m, oothers cannot invoke the juri jurisdiction of the higher or supe superior court for repeating or mu multiplying the same irregularity ity oor illegality or for passing a sim similarly wrong order. A wrongg ord order/decision in favour of any par particular party does not entitle title any other party to claim ben benefits on the basis of the wrong rong decision. Even otherwise, Art Article 14 cannot be stretched too far for otherwise it would ma functioning of administration make tion impossible. [Emphasis Supplied] xxx xxx” Therefore, e, any wrong committed by the author authorities cannot be perpetuated. 21. B Basawaraj (supra) has beenn rece recently followed by Supreme Court in “Jyos Jyostnamayee Mishra v. State of O Odisha and others” reported in 2025 SCC CC OnLine O SC 117. The relevant vant eextract thereof is reproduced hereinafter: “xx “xxx 31. Another argument was rai raised while referring to two com communications dated 28.06.1999 999 appointing Ms. Jhina Rani Ma Mansingh and Sri Lalatendu Rat Rath as Tracer on promotion, cla claiming to be from the post off Peo Peon, on the basis of which the pet petitioner is claiming violation ion of Article 14, namely the disc discrimination. Suffice to add,, this Court cannot put a stamp on the illegalities committed ed by the department while per perpetuating the same. A litigant ant coming to the Court cannot cla negative discrimination seek claim seeking direction from the Court to the department to act in violat iolation of the law or statutory Rul It is a settled propositionn of law that Article 14 does not Rules. env envisage negative equality. Refere ference for the purpose can be ma to a judgment of this Cou made Court in R. Muthukumar v. The Cha Chairman and Managing Direct irector TANGEDCO. Relevant par thereof is extracted below: para “28. A principle, axio axiomatic in this country's constitutional lore is th that there is no negative equality. In other words, s, if there has been a benefit or advantage conferred on n on one or a set of people, without legal basis or justificat fication, that benefit cannot multiply, or be relied upon as a principle of parity or equality. [Emphasis Supplied] xxx” SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 22. The next two grounds for ascertain certaining the impugned order are as follow: (VII) The present petition is not oonly hit by principle of res(VI jud judicata but also on merit as by tthe report dated 31.08.2013 onl the constructed portion only on of 09 marla land was rec recommended to be released and nd no not entirely of 16 marla. (VIII) The re-location policy is oonly to aid the land owners (VI who constructed houses were whose ere acquired not for the land own owners like the petitioners whos hose constructed houses were exe exempted from the acquisition. 23. It has h been reiterated on behalf alf of petitioner that the main writ petition filed iled in 2025 was not hit by the princ principles of res judicata as the 2013 writ petition petitio was disposed of vide order rder da dated September 02, 2013 ‘as having been n re rendered infructuous’ based ed on the officers’ report dated August 31, 1, 2013 201 that was not handed over tto him in Court making it impossiblee to ch challenge the same in 2013.. Only after the de-notification was effected on n Apr April 21, 2023 and the contempt tempt petition was disposed of in February, 2025, the writ petitioner became me aw aware of the contents of the officers’ report and challenged the samee by filing 2025 writ petition. Therefore, it was w not hit by the principles les of res judicata. It was further reiterated that the th disputed land is in continuity inuity with the structures that were in contiguous ous extension e of village Abadis and should have been released. As the released ased portion marked in black colour olour on the site plan appended to the review petit petition, included the petitioner’s er’s lland, the claim of petitioner was factually ally in accordance with the recomm commendations made vide report dated August gust 31, 2013 and the same sh should have been released. Furthermore,, release re of such land can alsoo be considered, keeping in mind the re-location ation policy which included bound boundary walls, rooms kept for servant, cattle sheds and place earmarked rked for storing of agriculture equipments like ike tractors etc. were included ded in the concept of structures. SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 Therefore,, the ccattle shed of the petitioner is elig eligible for release considering the true letter tter an and spirit of the relocation policy. olicy. 24. It is i not lost upon the mind of this his Court that all the aforesaid argumentss were considered and rejected vide order dated December 02, 2025. This is Court Cou cannot accept the submission ission that a new cause of action has arisen on the th date of notification datedd Apri April 21, 2023 when the same is based on the officers’ of report dated August ust 31 31, 2013, annexures to which clearly indicate dicate that the covered area is 09 kkanals and only that area is recommended to be released. 25. The re-location policy referred erred to by the writ petitioner concerns only the people who were being eing oousted from their place of residence and the same is not applicable for th the people whose constructed houses were ere being bei released from acquisition. tion. T The afore noted view of this Court hass been clearly stated in paragraph graph 16 of the judgment. The petitioner has sought to re-agitate the same issue by filing the present review applicati plication which is impermissible. 26. Att this thi juncture the sequence off event events before the contempt Court also merits ts a di discussion. Vide order dated Aug August 13, 2024, the contempt Court was prima prim facie of the opinion that hat th there was an apparent wilful disobedience nce on the part of the respondents nts by failing to comply with the order of the he Co Co-ordinate Bench dated Septemb ptember 02, 2013 after noting the argumentss for learned counsel for the petitione titioner that only 09 marlas out of 16 marlass had been released by the responden pondents whereas the constructed portion existed xisted over 14 marlas. Consequently uently, the Chief Administrator, GMADA was d directed to remain present in Cou Court on the adjourned date by the Court. On August 23, 2024, learned coun counsel appearing on behalf of alleged contemn ontemnor informed the Court that a Committee headed by the SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 Land Acquisiti quisition Collector, SAS Nagar, ar, D District Town Planner/STP, GMADA and the concerned Divisional Engine ngineer, GMADA would conclude the process ss of cconducting an enquiry regarding rding the delay of 09 years by the authoritiess in im implementation of the order date ted September 02, 2013. The said suggestion estion was accepted and the enquiry quiry report dated September 04, 2024 by thee committee com was placed before the Co Contempt Court. 27. V Vide order dated September er 17, 2024 the contempt Court noted thatt the petitioner p should have been calle called upon to adduce evidence that would prove prov that the structures in quest question over the disputed land existed prior rior to 2013 officers’ report. Thee com committee was directed to look into all thee material/documents mate furnished by the petitioner and consider the relevant lay out ou plan of the sector depictin epicting petitioner’s land before expressing g its op opinion which was to be conveye nveyed by filing a supplementary report. Thereaft ereafter, the Committee afforded ed an oopportunity to the petitioner to appearr before befo it on September 19,, 202 2024 along with all relevant documentss in su support of his contentions. 28. A After hearing the petitioner the Co Committee found no merits in his claim and submitted su a supplementary report to that effect. At that stage, the petitioner oner sought s to re-argue the case se on merits before the contempt Court for it to decide d the area of open space situ situated outside his house. The said line off argu argument was not entertained by the contempt Court and it held that the order rder d dated September 02, 20133 pass passed by the writ Court stood complied with. A Accordingly, the contemptt petiti petition was dismissed as having been rendered ered iinfructuous and the Rules stood discharged. Thereafter, the writ petitioner ioner sought s to re-argue the issues ues set settled by the contempt Court by filing the he ma main writ petition being CWP P No.1 No.10001 of 2025. SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 29. After hearing h the parties and perusing rusing the original record provided by the Chief hief Administrator, A GMADA, being eing ppersonally present in Court, this Bench h had dismissed the writ petitionn with costs, since to the mind of the Court it was a frivolous attempt to agitate gitate the issues after dismissal of his contempt mpt pe petition. After the same stood ood di dismissed the present review application n has b been filed to re-agitate the same issues. 30. To the mind of this Court, thee revie review application is completely misconceived ived and a an abuse of process off law where neither there is any error apparent rent on o the face of the record nor or has there been discovery of any new or importa mportant fact after passing of the or order. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has time and a again reiterated that on a rev review application re-argument on merits is not permissible. The principles es with regard to scope and extent of review are d discussed by a Co-ordinatee Ben Bench of this Court vide order dated January uary 17, 1 2025 in RA-LP-61-2024 in LPA-670-2024 “Dhirender Singh and others othe v. State of Punjab and other others” which are reproduced as under: xxx “xx The principles as regardss th the scope and extent of review juri jurisdiction of the court, have been summarized by the Hon’ble Sup Supreme Court in Kamlesh Verm erma v. Mayawati and others 201 (8) SCC 320 and were reitera iterated by this Court as well, in the case of Columbia Holdingss Pvt Pvt. Ltd. and others v. State of Ha Haryana and others RA-CW-357 357 of 2015. The principles set out as regards scope and exten xtent of review jurisdiction in var various judicial precedents mayy be summarized as follows: A. Exercise of review jurisdi risdiction is called for only in cases where one of the follo following ground exists: (i) SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document When there is discov iscovery of new and important matter or evidence, subje ubject to the fulfillment of the following conditions: a) New matter/evidence disc discovered is of such nature which could change thee jud judgment. RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 b) Such new matter/eviden vidence was not within the knowledge of the party seek seeking review oduced before court even after c) Same could not be produ due diligence (ii) When mistake or error apparent on the face of the record. (iii) When there exists “an “any other sufficient reasons”, which is interpreted ass ana analogous to the aforesaid two grounds. ction is not exercisable on B. The review jurisdiction following grounds: (i) (ii) Only a “patent error error” and not a “mere wrong decision” can be saidd to be an error apparent on the face of record. Review is not mainta intainable unless the material error, manifest on the face of the order, undermines its soundness or results in mis miscarriage of justice. (iii) The error apparent ent on the face of the record should not be an error whi which has to be fished out and searched. If a matter is required ired to be first reheard and then (iv) corrected, it would bee an appeal under the guise of review. (v) A repetition of old and overruled argument is not enough to reopen conclude luded adjudications. The power of revie eview is to be exercised for (vi) "correction of mistake" e" aand not for "substitution of view". Substitution of view would be the province of an appellate court. Merely because a do document which was forming (vii) part of the record wass no not considered at the time of deciding the case cannot not bbe categorized as a mistake or error apparent on the he fa face of record. (viii) A review is by noo m means an appeal in disguise whereby an erroneous us decision is re-heard and corrected but lies only for ppatent error. The mere possibility lity of two views on the subject (ix) cannot be a ground forr rev review. SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 The appreciation of evidence on record is fully (x) within the domain of thee ap appellate court, it cannot be permitted to be advanced in th the review petition. Review is not mainta intainable when the same relief (xi) sought at the time of arguing uing the main matter had been negative. (xii) Failure to argue a po point at the time of hearing of the matter by the court, is als also not a ground for seeking review as it would be a case ase where the existing material was overlooked by counsel el aand not a case of excusable misfortune or mistake. Justice Krishna Iyer, in Northern Jus ern IIndia caterers (India) Ltd. v. Lt. Governor of Delhi 1980 (2) S SCC 167, while highlighting the limited scope of review of judgm udgment observed as under: "A plea for review,, un unless the first judicial view is manifestly distorted, d, is like asking for the moon". In “Shri Ram Sahu ahu (dead) through legal rep representatives and others v. Vinod inod Kumar Rawat and others” rep reported in (2021) 13 Supremee C Court Cases 1, the Hon’ble Ape Court considered the scope Apex cope and ambit of the Court’s pow to review under Section 114 read with Order 47 Rule 1 power of the CPC and held that thee po power to review was not an inh inherent power of the Court. It mus must be conferred by law either spe specifically or by necessary implica plication. A review cannot be an app appeal in disguise. A re-hearingg of the matter is impermissible in law. l It is beyond doubt or disput ispute that the review Court does not sit in appeal over its ownn or order. It only constitutes an exc exception to the general Rule that once a judgment is signed and pronounced it should not bee alt altered. Under Order 47 Rule 1 CP CPC, the Court can review its dec decision on the following grounds: nds: “1. Application for review iew oof judgment:1. Any person considering ering himself aggrieved a) By a decree or order rder from which an appeal is allowed, but from wh which no appeal has been preferred, rder from which no appeal is b) By a decree or order allowed, or SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 c) By a decision on refer reference from a Court of small causes, and who from rom the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due dilig diligence was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the decree ee w was passed or order made, or on account of somee m mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, ord, or for any other sufficient reason, desires to obta obtain a review of the decree passed or order made de aagainst him, may apply for a review of judgmentt to the Court which passed the decree or made the orde order. 2. A party who is not appealing from a decree or order may apply fo for a review of judgment notwithstanding the pen pendency of an appeal by some other party except wher where the ground of such appeal is common to the appl applicant and the appellant, or when being responden ndent he can present to the appellate court the case on which he applies for the review.” The expression “any other suff sufficient reason” has to be inte interpreted in the light of otherr spe specific grounds. An erroneous dec decision/ order cannot be correcte ected in the guise of exercise of pow of review. power (emphasis supplied) xxx xx” 31. No satisfactory explanation could be provided by the learned counsel appearin ppearing for the review applicantt for nnot preferring an appeal from the order under review as the only purpose se for ffiling the review application was to re-argue argue the issues settled by the Co Co-ordinate Bench, Contempt Court and also this t Court. 32. In the light of aforesaid discussion ussion and the law governing the field, the review application is dismissed in li limine with costs assessed at Rs.20,000/- to be paid to the Poor Patient atient Welfare Fund, PGIMER, Chandigarh, for wasting precious judicial ial tim time and by re-agitating the settled issues ues ag again and again showing scant nt reg regard for authority of law. SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RA-CW-605-20 2025 in CWP-10001-20 33. Con Connected application(s), if any, sshall also stand disposed of accordingly. (DEEPAK SIB SIBAL) JUDGE DGE (LA (LAPITA BANERJI) JUDGE APRIL 06,, 2026 Shalini Whether speakin speaking/reasoned: Whether reporta reportable: SHALINI BHATIA 2026.04.08 18:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Ye Yes/No Ye Yes/No

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All P&H HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →