Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:3441-DB
Re se r v e d
I N TH E H I GH COURT OF UTTA RA K H A N D
A T N A I N I TA L
H ON ’ BLE TH E CH I EF JUSTI CE SRI M A N OJ K UM A R GUPTA
AND
H ON ’ BLE SRI JUSTI CE SUBH A SH UPA D H YA Y
JUD GM EN T RESERVED ON : 3 0 .0 4 .2 0 2 6
JUD GM EN T PRON OUN CED ON : 0 7 .0 5 .2 0 2 6
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / B) N o . 9 3 5 OF 2 0 2 5 ( 1 ) _
Vineet a and ot hers
…….Pet it ioners
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / S) N o . 3 1 3 4 OF 2 0 1 9 ( 2 )
Mot herhood Ayurveda Medical College, Roorkee
...Pet it ioner
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / S) N o . 3 1 3 6 OF 2 0 1 9 ( 3 )
Om Ayrveda Medical College, Hospit al and Research Cent re,
Dist rict - Haridwar.
...Pet it ioner
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / S) N o . 3 1 4 0 OF 2 0 1 9 ( 4 )
Ut t aranchal Ayurvedic Medical College, Dehradun.
...Pet it ioner
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / S) N o . 3 1 6 1 OF 2 0 1 9 ( 5 )
Sm t . Manj ira Devi Ayurvedic Medical College and Hospit al,
Ut t arkashi.
...Pet it ioner
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / S) N o . 3 1 6 7 OF 2 0 1 9 ( 6 )
Shivalik I nst it ut e of Ayurveda and Research, Dehradun.
...Pet it ioner
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / S) N o . 2 0 7 OF 2 0 2 1 ( 7 )
Quadra I nst it ut e of Ayurveda
...Pet it ioner
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / S) N o . 4 6 1 OF 2 0 2 1 ( 8 )
Doon I nst it ut e of Medical Sciences.
...Pet it ioner
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / B) N o . 8 4 1 OF 2 0 2 5 ( 9 )
Hassanul Haque and ot hers.
...Pet it ioners
2026:UHC:3441-DB
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / B) N o . 1 0 5 3 OF 2 0 2 5 ( 1 0 )
Sat ya Dev and ot hers.
...Pet it ioners
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / B) N o . 1 0 5 7 OF 2 0 2 5 ( 1 1 )
Farha Khan and ot hers.
...Pet it ioners
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
&
W RI T PETI TI ON ( M / B) N o . 1 0 6 4 OF 2 0 2 5 ( 1 2 )
Mohd. Suaib and ot hers
...Pet it ioners
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers
…Respondent s
Counsel for t he pet it ioners
:
Sri Yogesh Pacholia, Sri Tilak Ram , Sri
Navneet Kaushik, Sri Niranj an Bhat t
and Sri Adit ya Singh, learned counsel.
Counsel for t he r espondent s
:
Sri J.C. Pandey, lear ned St anding
Counsel wit h Sri M.S. Bisht , learned
Brief Holder for t he St at e.
Sri Raj esh Sharm a, Sri Saurav
Adhikari, Sri Manoj Kum ar, learned
St anding Counsel for t he Union of
I ndia.
Sri Krishan Mohan Joshi, Advocat e,
holding brief of Sri V.K. Kaparuwan,
learned St anding Counsel for t he
Union of I ndia.
Sri Sandeep Kot hari, learned counsel
for Ut t arakhand Ayurv eda Universit y.
Sri Ram j i Srivast ava, learned counsel
for Nat ional Com m ission for I ndian
Syst em of Medicine.
JUD GM EN T : ( Pe r Sr i M a n o j K u m a r Gu p t a , C.J.)
1.
A com m on quest ion which arises for considerat ion in
t he present bat ch of writ pet it ions is whet her t he adm issions
grant ed t o st udent s in AYUSH undergraduat e courses during
t he academ ic year 2019- 20 by various privat e colleges,
bypassing t he counseling process based on t he result of
Nat ional
Eligibilit y- cum - Ent rance
Test
( NEET) ,
could
be
2026:UHC:3441-DB
regularized; and whet her t he provisional regist rat ion grant ed
t o t he st udent s by t he Universit y on basis of int erim orders
passed in writ pet it ions filed by t he colleges / st udent s can be
held t o be valid, so as t o ent it le such st udent s, who have
pursued t heir courses for all t hese years, t o appear in t he final
exam inat ions,
and
in
cases
where
t hey
have
already
appeared, t o have t heir result s declared.
2.
Broadly, t here are t wo set s of writ pet it ions.
The one is by t he individual colleges, wherein t he colleges
have eit her challenged t he Not ificat ion dat ed 03.01.2019
issued by t he Governm ent of I ndia, Minist ry of Ayurveda,
Yoga and Nat uropat hy, Unani, Siddha and Hom eopat hy
( AYUSH) providing t hat all adm issions in AYUSH courses
shall m andat orily be m ade t hrough t he m erit list of NEET
( UG) - 2019, in view of t he am endm ent s m ade in t he
Regulat ions by t he Cent ral Council of I ndian Medicine wit h
t he previous sanct ion
of
t he Cent ral
Governm ent
by
Not ificat ion dat ed 7 t h Decem ber, 2018, or have sought a
m andam us t o perm it such st udent s t o appear in t he
professional exam inat ions in different years.
3.
The ot her set of pet it ions is by t he st udent s
seeking a m andam us t o t he respondent s t o declare t heir
result s of t he final exam inat ion of B.A.M.S. course and/ or
to
perm it
t hem
to
appear
in
different
professional
2026:UHC:3441-DB
exam inat ions, t hereby, enabling t hem t o com plet e t heir
B.A.M.S. course, and / or t o declare t heir result s and issue
m arksheet s t o t hem and / or t o quash t he order passed by
t he Universit y cancelling t heir t em porary regist rat ion for
t he course.
4.
I n som e cases, int erlocut ory applicat ions have
also been filed seeking different reliefs which, in pit h and
subst ance,
are essent ially
for
grant
of
perm ission
to
com plet e different st ages of t he course.
5.
The brief fact s are t hat by Not ificat ion dat ed
07.12.2018,
t he
Cent ral
Council
of
I ndian
Medicine
int roduced t he I ndian Medicine Cent ral Council ( Minim um
St andards of Educat ion in I ndian Medicine) Am endm ent
Regulat ions, 2018.
By Regulat ion 2( d) , it was provided
t hat t here shall be a uniform ent rance exam inat ion for all
m edical inst it ut ions for adm ission t o undergraduat e courses
in each academ ic year, t o be conduct ed by an aut horit y
designat ed
by
t he
Cent ral
Governm ent .
The
said
Regulat ions were challenged by various colleges before t he
Punj ab and Haryana High Court .
dism issed
by
j udgm ent
dat e
The writ pet it ions were
18.12.2019.
Aggrieved
t hereby, t he colleges filed Special Leave Pet it ions before
t he Suprem e Court .
The Suprem e Court
decided t he
cont roversy by j udgm ent dat ed 20.02.2020 in Un i o n o f
2026:UHC:3441-DB
I ndia
v s.
Fe d e r a t i o n
of
Se l f - Fi n a n ce d
Ay u r v ed ic
Co l l e g e s Pu n j a b a n d o t h e r s, report ed in ( 2 0 2 0 ) 1 2 SCC
115.
The Suprem e Court held t hat Sect ion 22 of t he
I ndian
Medicines
em powers
t he
Cent ral
Cent ral
Council
Council
to
Act ,
1970,
prescribe
which
m inim um
st andards of educat ion in I ndian Medicine, is wide enough
t o enable t he Council t o provide for NEET exam inat ion and,
accordingly, t he am endm ent s m ade in t he Regulat ions,
m aking
provisions
for
adm ission
t hrough
NEET
exam inat ion, were upheld. While so holding, t he Suprem e
Court , considering t he fact t hat a large num ber of seat s had
rem ained vacant in various privat e colleges, even aft er final
round of counseling, and t hat t he colleges had adm it t ed
st udent s on t he st rengt h of int erim orders passed by t he
High Court s, perm it t ed such st udent s t o pursue t heir
courses, provided t hey were adm it t ed prior t o t he last dat e
of adm ission i.e. 15 t h Oct ober, 2019.
The Suprem e Court
clarified t hat t he relaxat ion grant ed by it was a one- t im e
m easure and would not be t reat ed as a precedent . The
relevant observat ions, m ade in t his behalf in Paragraph- 15
are as follows:
“ 15. …..However, , in view of adm ission of a large
num ber
of
st udent s t o
t he AYUSH Under
Graduat e
courses for t he year 2019- 2020 on t he st rengt h of int erim
2026:UHC:3441-DB
orders passed by t he High Court s, we direct t hat t he
st udent s m ay be perm it t ed t o cont inue provided t hat t hey
were adm it t ed prior t o t he last dat e of adm ission i.e. 15 t h
Oct ober, 2019. The said direct ion is also applicable t o
st udent s adm it t ed t o Post Graduat e courses before 31 st
Oct ober, 2019. This is a one- t im e exercise which is
perm it t ed
in
view
of
t he
peculiar
circum st ances.
Therefore, t his order shall not be t reat ed as a precedent .”
6.
I t is not ewort hy t hat in t he writ pet it ions, filed by
t he colleges, separat e int erim orders have been passed on
different dat es in ident ical t erm s. For ready reference, t he
operat ive part of t he int erim order passed in WPMS No.
3134 of 2019 t it led ‘Mot herhood Ayurveda Medical College
Roorkee vs. St at e of Ut t arakhand and ot hers’ is quot ed
below: -
“ 8. I n view of t hese fact s, t his Court is also inclined t o
grant a sim ilar prot ect ion t o t he pet it ioner. The pet it ioner
shall be perm it t ed t o adm it t he st udent s in t he ongoing
counselling for t he academ ic year 2019- 20 wit h t he
following condit ions: ( i) . I n case in t he pet it ioner’s college seat s have
rem ained unfilled aft er t he NEET qualified st udent s
have m ade t heir choices and if seat s rem ain
unfilled,
due t o
t he non
availabilit y
of
NEET
qualified candidat es, such candidat es w ho have t he
m inim um
courses
qualificat ion
( BAMS,
BHMS
to
undergo
and
t he
BUMS) ,
perm it t ed t o t ake part in t he counselling.
AYUSH
shall
be
2026:UHC:3441-DB
( ii) . I t is furt her m ade clear t hat such st udent s
who have been adm it t ed in t he pet it ioner’s college
and who have not qualified t he NEET exam inat ion,
t heir adm ission shall be provisional in nat ure and
depend upon t he final det erm inat ion in t he writ
pet it ion.
( iii) . I t is furt her m ade clear t hat t hese st udent s
shall only be adm it t ed as per t heir relat ive m erit .
I n ot her words, t he m ore m erit orious candidat e
shall be given preference. ”
7.
The
subm ission
of
learned
counsel
for
t he
pet it ioners is t hat t he st udent s were adm it t ed t o B.A.M.S.
courses in academ ic year 2019- 20 on basis of int erim
orders passed in various writ pet it ions filed by t he colleges.
Alt hough, t he int erim orders st ipulat ed t hat t he adm issions
would be provisional and would depend upon t he final
out com e of t he writ pet it ions, but now, in view of t he order
of t he Hon’ble Suprem e Court in Fe d e r a t i o n o f Se l f Fi n a n ce d
Ay u r v ed ic
Co l l e g e s,
Pu n j a b
an d
ot h er s
( supra) , t he said adm issions st and regularized. I t
is,
t herefore, prayed t hat t he writ pet it ions be allowed and t he
Universit y be direct ed t o t reat t he adm issions as regular
and declare t he result of t he st udent s.
8.
Sri Sandeep Kot hari, learned counsel, appearing
on behalf of t he Universit y, does not disput e t hat t he
st udent s, who have preferred different writ pet it ions before
t his Court , are t hose who were adm it t ed by t he colleges in
2026:UHC:3441-DB
pursuance of int erim orders passed in t he writ pet it ions
filed by t hem and possessed t he m inim um qualificat ion for
adm ission t o AYUSH courses.
Thus, alt hough t hese
st udent s were adm it t ed direct ly by t he colleges wit hout
undergoing t he process of counseling, in view of t he order
of t he Suprem e Court grant ing one- t im e relaxat ion in
respect of adm issions m ade before 15.10.2019, t hey would
st and regularized.
Consequent ly, t he Universit y is obliged
t o declare t heir result s and / or perm it t hem t o appear in
any back exam inat ion, if scheduled in fut ure, provided
t here is no ot her im pedim ent .
9.
I n som e of t he cases, count er- affidavit s have
been filed by t he Universit y, in which it has not been denied
t hat t he st udent s were adm it t ed by t he colleges before
15.10.2019, t he last dat e prescribed in t his behalf, on basis
of t he int erim orders passed in favour of t he colleges in
different writ pet it ions. However, in WPMS No. 207 of 2021
t it led
“ Quadra
I nst it ut e
of
Ayurveda
vs.
St at e
of
Ut t arakhand ot hers” , it is cont ended t hat in t he said case,
int erim order was passed for t he first t im e on 3 rd February,
2021 perm it t ing t he College t o t ake adm ission of four
st udent s provisionally and, t herefore, t he st udent s of t he
said college are not ent it led t o t he benefit of t he order of
t he Suprem e Court .
2026:UHC:3441-DB
10.
In
order
to
appreciat e
t he
subm ission,
we
hereunder reproduce t he operat ive part of t he int erim order
dat ed 03.02.2021 passed in WPMS No. 207 of 2021: “ 9. I n t he m eant im e, Ut t arakhand Ayurveda Universit y is
direct ed t o provisionally perm it t he 4 st udent s adm it t ed
by t he pet it ioner College during academ ic session 201920 t o appear in t he first professional exam inat ion, which
is scheduled t o be held in t he m ont h of March, 2021. This,
however, will be subj ect t o pet it ioner deposit ing a sum of
₹ 1,00,000/- wit h t he Universit y, wit hin t wo weeks from
t oday. ”
11.
I t is not disput ed before us t hat t he I nst it ut e had
deposit ed Rs. 1 lac wit h t he Universit y in t erm s of t he
above order.
I t is also not disput ed t hat all t he four
st udent s of t he College, in respect of whom t he int erim
order was passed, were adm it t ed prior t o t he last dat e of
adm ission, i.e. 15.10.2019. The st udent s have appeared in
professional exam inat ions held during t hese years on t he
st rengt h of t he int erim order.
I n such circum st ances, we
are not inclined t o different iat e t he cases of said st udent s
from t hat of ot her st udent s of t he sam e academ ic year and
hold t hat t hey would also be ent it led t o t he benefit of onet im e relaxat ion grant ed by t he Hon’ble Suprem e Court .
12.
Thus, while t he challenge t o t he am endm ent
m ade in t he Regulat ions and t he Not ificat ion issued by t he
Cent ral Governm ent for m aking adm issions t hrough t he
2026:UHC:3441-DB
process of counseling fails, t he st udent s adm it t ed on t he
st rengt h of int erim orders on or before 15.10.2019 are held
ent it led t o declarat ion of t heir result s and / or t o appear in
any back paper exam inat ion.
I t is ordered accordingly.
The Universit y shall t reat t he adm issions as regular and
declare t he result of t he st udent s and also perm it t hem t o
appear in t he back paper exam inat ion, if any, in accordance
wit h law.
13.
The writ pet it ions st and disposed of accordingly.
14.
Pending applicat ion, if any, also st ands disposed
of accordingly.
_____________________
M A N OJ KUM A R GUPTA , C.J.
___________________
SUBH A SH UPA D H YA Y, J.
Dt :
7 t h May, 2026
Rat hour
PRAVINDRA
SINGH RATHOUR
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH
COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=23699ccc2fd40ad81b6fd13323779d9e3aeb1097d
17dbb53d481cabd25946eed, postalCode=263001,
st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=1F65499E931DF71CDAF92A40CC6179B8E0
10331BA695239171F906FD5C45C4E8, cn=PRAVINDRA
SINGH RATHOUR
Date: 2026.05.07 10:51:28 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review