Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
No
Date
Office Notes,
reports, orders or
proceedings or
directions and
Registrar’s order
with Signatures
COURT’S OR JUDGES’S ORDERS
BA1 No. 2276 of 2025
H o n ’ b l e A l o k M a h r a , J.
Ms. Priyanka Agarwal, Advocat e for
t he applicant .
Mr. V.S. Pal, A.G.A. for t he St at e of
Ut t arakhand.
2.
The applicant – Mohd. Shehbaz, w ho is
in j udicial cust ody in connect ion wit h
FI R/ Case Crim e No. 0221 of 2025, under
Sect ions 8/ 22 r/ w Sect ion 29 of NDPS Act ,
regist ered at Police St at ion- Kashipur ,
Dist rict Udham Singh Nagar , has sought his
release on bail.
3.
I n t his case, applicant has been m ade
an accused under Sect ions 8 and 22 of
NDPS Act r ead wit h Sect ion 29 of NDPS Act .
One Anas was allegedly arr est ed wit h an
alleged cont raband of 2400 capsules of
t ram adole and dicylom ine HCL capsules.
Anas adm it t ed before t he Police t hat t he
alleged r ecovered cont raband belongs t o his
brot her Mohd. Sham eem , who has t old him
t o carry t his cart on and deliver it near a
banquet hall w her e delivery could be
affect ed. Mohd. Sham i was arrest ed on t he
confessional st at em ent of Anas and Mohd.
Sham i confessed befor e t he Police t hat he
pur chased t he alleged cont raband from t he
present applicant , who was sit t ing in t he
m edical shop, w hich was r egist er ed in t he
nam e of brot her of t he applicant .
4.
Lear ned counsel for t he applicant
would subm it t hat applicant has falsely been
im plicat ed in t he case; t hat no cont raband
was r ecovered from t he m edical st ore; t hat
not even a single sam ple relat ing t o t he
bat ch num ber of t he r ecov er ed cont raband
was r ecovered from t he m edical st ore; t hat
applicant could not be m ade an accused
only on t he basis of t he confessional
st at em ent of t he anot her co- accused. Thus,
t he applicant is ent it led t o be r eleased on
bail. To support her case, lear ned counsel
has placed r eliance upon a j udgm ent passed
by Hon’ble Apex Court in t he case of Tofan
Singh Vs. St at e of Tam il Nadu, ( 2021) 4
SCC 1. For ready reference, paragraph nos.
155, 158.1 and 158.2 of t he aforesaid
j udgem ent ar e ext ract ed hereinbelow: “ 155. Thus, t o arr ive at t he conclusion t hat a
confessional st at em ent m ade before an
officer designat ed under Sect ion 42 or
Sect ion 53 can be t he basis t o convict a
person under t he NDPS Act , wit hout any non
obst ant e clause doing away wit h Sect ion 25
of t he Evidence Act , and w it hout any
safeguards, would be a direct infr ingem ent of
t he const it ut ional guarant ees cont ained in
Art icles 14, 20( 3) and 21 of t he Const it ut ion
of I ndia.
158.1. That t he officers who are invest ed
wit h powers under Sect ion 53 of t he NDPS
Act are “ police officers” wit hin t he m eaning of
Sect ion 25 of t he Evidence Act , as a result of
which any confessional st at em ent m ade t o
t hem would be barred under t he provisions of
Sect ion 25 of t he Evidence Act , and cannot
be t aken int o account in order t o convict an
accused under t he NDPS Act .
158.2. That a st at em ent recorded under
Sect ion 67 of t he NDPS Act cannot be used as
a confessional st at em ent in t he t r ial of an
offence under t he NDPS Act .”
5.
On t his basis, learned counsel for t he
applicant would subm it t hat applicant has
been m ade an accused only on t he
confessional st at em ent of Anas, w ho was
allegedly
arrest ed
wit h
t he
alleged
cont raband and no cont raband as such has
been recover ed fr om t he applicant . Lear ned
counsel for t he applicant would furt her
subm it t hat against t he colum n of ‘grounds
of arrest ’, only t he ‘reasons of arrest ’ have
been m ent ioned. Lear ned counsel would
furt her subm it t hat ‘reasons of arr est ’ are
differ ent from ‘gr ounds of arr est ’, as has
been m ent ioned in t he j udgm ent passed by
Hon’ble Apex Court in t he case of Prabir
Purkayast ha Vs. St at e ( NCT of Delhi) ,
( 2024) 8 SCC 254. For ready r eference,
paragraph no.48 of t he afor esaid j udgem ent
is ext ract ed hereinbelow: “ 48. I t m ay be reit erat ed at t he cost of
repet it ion t hat t here is a significant difference
in t he phrase “ reasons for arrest ” and
“ grounds of arrest ” . The “ reasons for arrest ”
as indicat ed in t he arrest m em o are purely
form al param et ers viz. t o prevent t he
accused person from com m it t ing any fur t her
offence; for proper invest igat ion of t he
offence; t o prevent t he accused person from
causing t he evidence of t he offence t o
disappear or t am per ing wit h such evidence in
any m anner; t o prevent t he arrest ed person
for m aking inducem ent , t hreat or prom ise t o
any person acquaint ed wit h t he fact s of t he
case so as t o dissuade him from disclosing
such fact s t o t he court or t o t he invest igat ing
officer. These reasons would com m only apply
t o any person arrest ed on charge of a crim e
whereas t he “ grounds of arrest ” would be
required t o cont ain all such det ails in hand of
t he invest igat ing officer which necessit at ed
t he arrest of t he accused. Sim ult aneously,
t he grounds of arrest inform ed in wr it ing
m ust convey t o t he arrest ed accused all basic
fact s on which he was being arrest ed so as t o
provide him an opport unit y of defending
him self against cust odial rem and and t o seek
bail. Thus, t he “ grounds of arrest ” would
invar iably be personal t o t he accused and
cannot be equat ed w it h t he “ reasons of
arrest ” which are general in nat ure.”
Lear ned St at e Counsel, on t he ot her
6.
hand, has v ehem ent ly opposed t he bail
applicat ion. I t is furt her subm it t ed t hat
t her e was m oney t rail bet w een Mohd.
Sham i and Mohd. Shehbaz.
7.
To t his, learned counsel for t he
applicant would argue t hat t he am ount of
t ransact ion does not m at ch wit h t he cost of
t he propert y, as per t he FI R.
8.
Hear d learned counsel for t he part ies
and per used t he r ecord.
9.
Considering t he subm ission of lear ned
counsel for t he part ies and also considering
t he fact t hat applicant has no previous
crim inal hist ory and no r ecov ery w as m ade
from him and he was m ade t he accused
only on t he confessional st at em ent of t he
co- accused, wit hout expr essing any opinion,
as t o t he final m erit s of t he case, t his Court
is of t he view t hat t he applicant deserv es
bail at t his st age.
10.
The bail applicat ion is allowed.
11. Let t he applicant be r eleased on bail,
on execut ing personal bond and furnishing
t wo reliable suret ies, each of like am ount , t o
t he sat isfact ion of Court concer ned.
( A l o k M a h r a , J.)
19.05.2026
Uj j wal
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review