Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~33 and 34
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 05.02.2026
%
+
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023, CM APPL. 6558/2026
MOHD SHABBIR
versus
S.K SINGH & ORS.
+
.....Petitioner
.....Respondents
CONT.CAS(C) 8/2024, CM APPL. 7831/2026
PARDEEP KUMAR
versus
SH GYANESH BHARTI & ORS.
Presence:
.....Petitioner
.....Respondents
Mr. Ravish Kumar and Mr. Shivendu Singh, Advocates for
Petitioners in Item Nos.33and 34.
Mr. Niraj Kumar, Sr. Central Govt. Counsel along with Mr.
Praveen, SI, PS Malviya Nagar in Item No.33.
Mr. Kapil Dutta, SC for MCD in Item Nos.33 and 34.
Mr. N. S. Dalal, Ms. Nidhi Dalal, Mr. Alok Kumar and Ms.
Rachana Dalal, Advocates for R-4 in Item Nos.33 and 34.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA
SACHIN DATTA, J. (ORAL)
1.
Vide order dated 13.01.2026, this Court has ordered as under:
“1. The Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) is directed to file a
status report, setting out the present status of the property viz. 318-A/4,
measuring 431 sq. yards, comprised in Khasra No.740/496, in the Abadi
of Lal Dora (1908-1909) of Village Chirag Delhi, New Delhi-110017,
clearly stating the action already taken in respect thereof and future
course of action with regard thereto.
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
2. It shall be specifically disclosed as to whether the entire construction
is unauthorized and if so, whether demolition action is proposed to be
taken with regard to the entire building.
3. Let the aforesaid status report be filed on affidavit within a period of
one week from today.
4. List on 05.02.2026.”
2.
Pursuant to the aforesaid directions, a status report has been filed on
behalf of the MCD, inter alia, stating as under:“4. That pursuant to the aforesaid directions of this Hon'ble Court, so as to
ascertain the present status of the subject property i.e. bearing No. 318A/4, measuring 431 Sq. Yards, comprised in Khasra No.740/496, situated
in the Abadi of Lal Dora (19081909), Village Chirag Delhi, New Delhi, the
same has been again got inspected through area field staff of Building
Department-I of South Zone MCD and also referred to the record
maintained and available with the department.
On inspection and referring to the record, the status in respect of
the subject as ascertained is here as under:
i) As per record, the subject property has been identified as property No.
318, Chirag Delhi, New Delhi, which stands booked for unauthorized
construction vide file No.152/UC/B-I/SZ/2023 dated 25/08/2023 in the
shape of Ground floor and raising columns of First floor, booked vide file
No. 171/UC/BI/SZ/2023 dated 09/10/2023 in the shape Second floor and
Third floor (in continuation of previous booking file No. 152/UC/BI/SZ/2023 dated 25/08/2023) and further booked vide U/c file No.
23/UC/B-I/SZ/2024 dated 07/02/2024 in the shape of Fourth floor (in
continuation of earlier booking No. 171/UC/B-I/SZ/2023 dated
09/10/2023), for taking the necessary demolition action U/S 343/344 of
DMC Act. Upon following due process of law, the necessary demolition
orders also stands passed by the Competent Authority i.e. the AE (Bldg) I
of South Zone vide dated 06/09/2023, 25/10/2023 and 16/02/2024
respectively.
ii) Furthermore, letters dated 31/08/2023, 23/10/2023 and 13/03/2024 u/s
344 (2) of the DMC Act, have also been sent to SHO, PS. Malviya Nagar,
New Delhi with the request that the unauthorized construction in respect of
the subject property be stopped immediately and workmen present at site /
property be removed and construction material including the tools,
machinery, etc. be seized.
iii) Beside this, letters dated 11/09/2023, 23/10/2023 and 13/03/2024 have
also been sent to concerned authorities i.e. BSES and Delhi Jal Board for
disconnection of their electricity and water supply from the subject
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
property.
iv) Similarly, letters dated 04/09/2023, 23/10/2023 and 13/03/2024 have
also been sent to Sub-Registrar with the request not to register the subject
property under the Indian Registration Act, 1908.
v) Apart from this, Prosecution action u/s 466-A of DMC Act, 1957 has
also been initiated against the subject property and a complaint dated
20/08/2024 has also been sent to concerned, SHO PS Malviya Nagar, New
Delhi.
vi) Furthermore, it is also point out here that the sealing proceedings u/s
345-A of DMC Act, 1957 have also been initiated and after following due
process of law, the necessary sealing orders have also been passed by the
Competent Authority i.e, the then Deputy Commissioner of South Zone MCD vide 26/10/2023 and 08/05/2024..
vii)Hence, in light of above, the entire construction as carried out in
respect of the subject property is unauthorized and already stands booked
for taking necessary actions under the relevant provisions of DMC Act1957.
5. That further on referring to the record, it has also been observed that
pursuant to the aforesaid demolition / sealing orders already passed in
respect of the subject property, the Building Department-I of South Zone MCD has also tried / taken / carried out the following necessary demolition
/ sealing action till time:
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
6. That after taking the aforementioned demolition / sealing action, letters
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
dated 05/12/2023, 13/12/2023, 04/01/2024, 25/01/2024, 12/03/2024,
02/05/2024, 01/08/2024, 12/03/2025, 29/09/2025, 21/01/2026 and
29/01/2026 have also been sent to SHO concerned PS Malviya Nagar,
New Delhi with the request to direct the area patrolling staff to keep strict
watch and ward over the subject property so that demolished portion may
not be restored / repaired and the seals affixed by the department may not
be tampered with.
7. That now the department has fixed the further demolition / sealing
action programme in respect of the subject property for 11/02/2026 which
will be taken / carried out, upon availability of police force.”
3.
Mr. Kapil Dutta, learned counsel appearing for the MCD, submits and
undertakes, on instructions, that it shall be ensured that no unauthorized
construction shall be allowed to subsist in respect of the property in
question.
4.
It is assured and undertaken that the requisite demolition action shall
be taken to ensure that all unauthorized construction on the property is
demolished. He further assures that the property shall be inspected at regular
intervals to ensure the same and to also ensure that the premises are not
misused.
5.
He submits that the next round of demolition action (for demolishing
the remaining unauthorized construction) is now scheduled for 11.02.2026.
Let the said action be carried out and taken to its logical conclusion.
6.
The concerned SHO is directed to cooperate with the MCD in this
regard.
7.
There is another aspect of the matter vide orders dated 03.11.2023 and
19.12.2023 passed in CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023, this Court took note of the
allegations on the part of the respondent no.4 (the owner of the concerned
property), to the effect that the petitioner is an extortionist and that the writ
petition bearing WP(C)12350/2023 [in which the order dated 20.09.2023
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
came to be passed by this Court, which is the subject matter of
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023] was filed in pursuance of the mala fide intention
of the petitioner to extort money from the said respondent.
8.
Vide order dated 19.12.2023 passed in CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023, it
was noted of the fact that the respondent no.4 has filed certain audio
recordings and transcripts, wherein the petitioner in CONT.CAS(C)
1614/2023 was allegedly demanding money from the respondent no.4.
9.
Vide order dated 19.12.2023 passed in CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023, it
was ordered as under:“7. Let the entire transcript, case file be looked into by SHO-Malviya
Nagar and give a report including forensic analysis within a period of
eight weeks from today. Thereafter, appropriate action shall be
undertaken.”
10.
Thereafter, a status report has been filed by PS Malviya Nagar,
wherein, it has been stated as under:“5. That in compliance of the Hon'ble Court order, the audio recordings
and video recordings and CCTV footage were obtained from the
respondent No. 4, in a pen drive and the pen drive containing audio
recording and video recording and CCTV footage were deposited at the
Forensic Science Laboratory, Rohini, New Delhi against their receipt No.
SFSLDLH-3298/Phy-(AV)-247/24/P/241/24 dated 15.03.2024 for
examination and its report.
6. That the Forensic Science Laboratory examined the deposited exhibits
and opined vide their examination report dated 31.12.2024 as under: a) On auditory analysis of audio recordings contained in folder
namely "audio" in pen drive marked "Exhibit 1", by critical listening
and subsequent waveform and spectrographic analysis, there was no
indications of any form of alteration by using audio-analyst system.
b) On laboratory examination of audio-video files namely
"MOV00016.avi" and "MOV00017.avi" in the pen drive marked
"Exhibit-1", it was observed that each file contains one identified
video shot. There is no indication of alteration in the identified video
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
shot on the basis of frame-by-frame examination by using Video
Analyst System. On auditory analysis of audio track of audio- video
recording, by critical listening and subsequent waveform and
spectrographic analysis, there was no indications of any form of
alteration in audio recording.
c) On laboratory examination of audio-video file namely, "NVR ch8
main_20231019062424_20231019063625.dav" in the pen drive
marked "Exhibit 1", it was observed that video file is continuous
footage of CCTV recording. There is no indication of alteration in
the CCTV recordings on the basis of frame-by-frame examination by
using Video Analyst System. On auditory analysis of audio track of
audio-video recording, by critical listening and subsequent
waveform and spectrographic analysis, there was no indications of
any form of alteration in audio recording.”
11.
In the circumstances, since the audio recording relied upon by the
respondent no.4 was not found to be tampered with and the same allegedly
substantiates the allegation of the respondent no.4, it is necessary to further
investigate the matter. Accordingly, the concerned SHO is directed to carry
out a thorough investigation, inter alia, taking into account the transcripts
and the respective allegations and counter allegations of the parties.
12.
If considered appropriate, the concerned SHO is directed to register
an FIR and take the matter to its logical conclusion.
13.
No further orders are required to be passed in the present contempt
petitions; the same are, accordingly, disposed of. Pending applications also
stand disposed of.
SACHIN DATTA, J
FEBRUARY 5, 2026/r
Digitally Signed
By:CHINU LUTHRA
19:08:32
CONT.CAS(C) 1614/2023 and Anr.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review