Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Mohammed Ali vs. Ramesh Kumar & Ors.
RSA No. 4241 of 2013
05.06.2026: Present:
Mr Ajay Sharma, Senior Advocate, with Mr
Tarun Brakta, Advocate, for the appellant/nonapplicant.
Mr Sumit Sharma,
respondent/applicants.
Advocate,
for
the
CMP No. 3237 of 2025
The applicants/respondents/plaintiffs have
filed the present application under Section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) for the dismissal of the
appeal. It has been asserted that the applicants/
plaintiffs filed a civil suit for declaration and injunction
against defendant Smt. Anita, which was decreed on
31.12.2010. Anita filed the civil appeal in the Court of
Learned District Judge, Sirmaur. She had already sold
her share in favour of Mohmad Ali through registered
Sale deed No.77 on 10.02.2011. She had lost the right title
and interest in the suit property. The appellant filed an
application under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC for his
impleadment, which was allowed by the learned District
Judge, Sirmour, H.P. However, this application could
not have been entertained in an appeal, which was not
maintainable. The sale transaction was executed in
utter disobedience of the finding of the learned Trial
Court. The impleadment of the appellant in the appeal
was
of
no
avail
because
the
appeal
maintainable.
The
present
appeal
is
was
not
also
not
maintainable; hence, it has been prayed that the appeal
be dismissed.
2.
The application is opposed by filing a reply
denying the contents of the application. It has been
asserted that the lis before the court has to be decided
considering the facts existing on the date of the filing of
the suit. The sale deed was executed after the decree of
the suit. The subsequent purchaser would step into the
shoes of the original defendant. Therefore, it was
prayed that the present application be dismissed.
3.
I have heard Mr Sumit Sharma, learned
counsel for the applicant and Mr Ajay Sharma, learned
Senior Advocate, assisted by Mr Tarun Brakta, learned
counsel for the non-applicants.
4.
Mr Sumit Sharma, learned counsel for the
applicants, submitted that Anita had sold the land on
the date of institution of the appeal. She was not
competent to file the appeal because she had lost her
title. The non-applicant sought the impleadment in the
appeal, which was allowed. However, the appeal was not
maintainable, and the order of impleadment will not
benefit the non-applicant. The present appeal filed by
the non-applicant is also not maintainable. Hence, he
prayed that the present application be allowed and the
appeal filed by the non-applicant be dismissed as not
maintainable.
5.
Mr Ajay Sharma, learned Senior Advocate for
the non-applicant, submitted that the rights and duties
are to be determined as they exist on the date of the
institution of the suit. The sale by Anita Devi would not
have any effect on the pendency of the litigation;
therefore, he prayed that the present application be
dismissed. He relied upon the following judgments in
support of his submissions: Rikhu Dev vs Som Dass AIR 1975 SCC
2159;
Dhurandhar Prasad Singh vs. Jai Prakash
University (2001) 6 SCC 534;
Jaskirat Datwani vs. Vidyvati & Others
(2002) 5 SCC 647; and
Government of Orissa vs. Ashok Transport
Agency & others (2005) 1 SCC 536
6.
I have given a considerable thought to the
submissions made at the bar and have gone through the
records carefully.
7.
It was laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Hukum Chandra v. Nemi Chand Jain, (2019) 13
SCC 363 = 2018 SCC OnLine SC 2812, that rights and
liabilities stand crystallised on the date of institution of
the suit, but the Court can take note of the subsequent
events in appropriate cases. It was observed: “15. The rights of the parties stand crystallised
on the date of institution of the suit. However,
in appropriate cases, the court can take note of
all the subsequent events. Observing that the
court may permit subsequent events being
introduced into the pleadings by way of the
amendment as it would be necessary to do so
for the performance of determining the rule in
controversy for the parties, provided certain
conditions are satisfied, in Om Prakash Gupta v.
Ranbir B. Goyal, 2002 2 SCC 256, it was held as
under: "11. The ordinary rule of civil law is that
the rights of the parties stand crystallised
on the date of the institution of the suit
and, therefore, the decree in a suit should
accord with the rights of the parties as
they stood at the commencement of the
lis. However, the Court has the power to
take note of subsequent events and mould
the relief accordingly subject to the
following conditions being satisfied: (i)
that the relief, as claimed originally has,
by reason of subsequent events, become
inappropriate or cannot be granted; (ii)
that taking note of such subsequent event
or changed circumstances would shorten
litigation and enable complete justice
being done to the parties; and (iii) that
such subsequent event is brought to the
notice of the court promptly and in
accordance with the rules of procedural
law so that the opposite party is not taken
by surprise. In Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v.
Motor &General Traders, 1975 1 SCC 770,
this Court held that a fact arising after the
lis, coming to the notice of the court and
having a fundamental impact on the right
to relief or the manner of moulding it and
brought diligently to the notice of the
court, cannot be blinked at. The court may,
in such cases, bend the rules of procedure
if no specific provision of law or rule of fair
play is violated, for it would promote
substantial justice provided that there is
an absence of other disentitling factors or
just circumstances. The Court speaking
through Krishna Iyer, J., affirmed the
proposition that the court can, so long as
the litigation pends, take note of updated
facts to promote substantial justice.
However, the Court cautioned: (i) the
event should be one as would stultify or
render inept the decretal remedy, (ii) rules
of procedure may be bent if no specific
provision or fair play is violated and there
is no other special circumstance repelling
resort to that course in law or justice, (iii)
such cognizance of subsequent events and
developments should be cautious, and (iv)
the rules of fairness to both sides should
be scrupulously obeyed."
16. The normal rule is that in any litigation, the
rights and obligations of the parties are
adjudicated upon as they obtained at the
commencement of the litigation. Whenever there
are subsequent events of fact or law, which have a
material bearing on the rights of the parties to
relief or the aspects of moulding appropriate
relief to the parties, the court is not precluded
from taking cognisance of the subsequent
changes of fact and law to mould the relief (vide
Ramesh Kumar v. Kesho Ram, 1992 Supp2 SCC
623)”
8.
Therefore, the very premise of the application
that the appeal was not maintainable because Anita Devi
had sold the land is without any basis.
9.
Order 22 Rule 10 of the CPC deals with the
devolution of the interest during the pendency of the
suit and enables the person upon whom the interest has
devolved to come on record. Therefore, the normal rule
is that the suit is to be continued by a person by whom it
was filed or by the person against whom it was filed.
The exception is that the transfree can come on record
with the leave of the Court. It was laid down by the
Patna High Court in Mahanth Sukhdeo Das v. Kashi
Prasad Tiwari, 1958 SCC OnLine Pat 73: AIR 1958 Pat 630,
that the plaintiff can continue with the suit even if the
property is transferred. It was observed:
76. Then, there is a further consideration. Even
assuming that the contention of Mr Das was
correct, the plaintiffs cannot be unsuited in the
present appeal. The effect of the operation of the
Act is that during the pendency of this litigation,
the interest of the plaintiffs devolved upon the
State. Notwithstanding this devolution, they will
be entitled to continue this litigation. Sub-rule (1)
of rule 10 of Order XXII of the CPC provides that in
cases of an assignment, creation or devolution of
any interest during the pendency of a suit, the
suit may, by leave of the Court, be continued by or
against the person to or upon whom such interest
has
come
or
devolved.
Ordinarily,
notwithstanding the devolution of the interest,
the suit may be continued by or against the
original party.
****
79. The litigation will continue in his name for
the benefit of his successors. Their Lordships
further held that no doubt rule 10 gives the Court
a discretion in allowing or refusing an application
by the successors-in-interest to continue the
litigation, but leave should not be unreasonably
refused. In this case, notice of this appeal was
served upon the State, and the State has not
preferred to appear in this appeal and to be added
as a party.
80. The plaintiffs, therefore, can continue this
appeal, and the result of this appeal will be
binding upon the State. A co-sharer in possession
of bakasht lands can at best claim only his share
in such lands, and he cannot justifiably maintain
that the entire bakasht lands have been
statutorily settled with him. Putting the defence
at the highest, the plaintiffs' interests have
devolved upon the State, and so far as the interest
of the defendants is concerned, they have now
obtained a statutory settlement of their share in
the bakasht lands.
10.
A similar view was taken in Uchhab Patra v.
Brundaban Mallik, 1968 SCC OnLine Ori 144: AIR 1969 Ori
142, wherein it was observed:
Though the aforesaid rule enables the transferee
to continue the suit, it is no bar to the transferor
continuing the suit for the benefit of his
successor. The position of law was settled in Rai
Charan Mandal v. Biswanath Mandal [A.I.R. 1915
Cal. 103.]. Their Lordships observed that the
plaintiff who has instituted a litigation may
prosecute it to its conclusion notwithstanding a
devolution of his interest in the property. The
litigation will continue in his name for the benefit
of his successor. Order 22, Rule 10 of the Code of
Civil Procedure is an alternative procedure that
guards against the danger that the original
plaintiff, being no longer interested in the
proceedings, may not vigorously prosecute them
or may even collude with the adversary. The same
view was taken in Joti Lal Sah v. Sheodhayan
Prashad Sah [A.I.R. 1936 Pat. 420.]
11.
Karnataka High Court also took a similar view
in Ambaji Vs. Shoranappa 1974 STPL 511 Karnataka,
wherein it was observed:
5. Let me recall the effect of an assignment of
interest pending suit or appeal. Where, during the
pendency of a suit or appeal, the property in suit
is transferred or otherwise dealt with by any party
to the suit, the transferee is bound by the result of
the litigation, whether he is joined as a party or
not. The transferee is not under any legal
obligation to apply to be added as a party. He may
leave the proceedings to be carried on by the
transferor, but Order 22, Rule 10 CPC enables him
to apply for being added on as a party to continue
the suit. In a proper case, the Court may allow
such a transferee to be made a party.
12.
This Court also recognised this principle in
Shakti Chand vs Chamaru ILR 1974(HP) 1154, wherein it
was observed:
The law does not require that if property is
transferred during the pendency of an appeal, and
the transferors are already on the record, it is still
necessary that the transferee should be brought
on the record. A discretion has been vested in the
court, and all that is necessary to see is that the
discretion is properly exercised. The mere
circumstance that the property has been
transferred during the pendency of the appeal
does not give a right to the transferee to be
brought on the record.
13.
Thus, the appeal filed by Anita Devi cannot be
said to be incompetent on the date of institution of the
suit.
14.
The judgments in Rikhu Dev (supra),
Dhurandhar Prasad Singh (supra), Jaskirat Datwani
(supra) and Government of Orissa (supra) deal with the
scope of Order 22 Rule 10 of the CPC and are not
relevant.
15.
In view of the above, the present application
fails, and it is dismissed.
16.
The observations made hereinbefore shall
remain confined to the disposal of the present
application and will have no bearing whatsoever on the
merits of the case.
RSA No. 4241 of 2013
List the matter for hearing in due course.
(Rakesh Kainthla)
Judge
05th June, 2026
(ravinder)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review