The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. In conspectus of the above this Court is of the view that the lack of synergy between the Railway authorities and the Legal Metrology Department being the respondent No. 5 herein, cannot be allowed to cause prejudice to the service users. The accuracy of an in-motion weighbridge is a statutory requirement and its failure strikes at the root of fair trend and revenue assessment.
25. Upon consideration of the submissions made by the parties and the documents placed on record, the following directions are hereby issued: i.) The railway authorities must maintain accurate records of the weighment process including the weight recorded and any discrepancies noted. ii.) The railways shall ensure that in-motion weightbridge is calibrated and certified by a competent authority at least once every six months. iii.) The leaseholders shall be given prior notice of the weightment process and shall be entitled to be present during the weightment. iv.) In event of a dispute, the matter shall be referred to the railway authorities for resolution and their decision shall be final and binding. v.) A digital or physical log for the last stamping and/or calibration of the in-motion weighbridge must be made available for inspection upon request by the leaseholder in the event of a dispute. vi.) In cases of significant variation the leaseholder may apply for reweighment at the next available weighbridge, subject to payment of the requisite fees which shall be refundable if the initial reading is found to be erroneous. vii.) The in-motion weighbridge should be certified by the respondent No. 4 in strict adherence to the prescribed rules.
26. In view of the above directions, the Writ petition is disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
6.4.2026
ct no. 10
Sl. 04
AGM
WPA 24843 of 2025
Mohd Abdul Wadood
-VersusUnion of India & Ors.
Mr. Saptarshi Roy.
Ms. Kakali Das Chakraborty.
…for the Petitioner.
Mr. Swapan Kumar Pal.
…for the respondent no. 5.
Mr. Dipankar Das Gupta.
Mr. Dipankar Ghosh.
… For the State respondents.
Mrs. Aparna Banerjee.
Mr. Sujit Bhuiya.
… for the Railway Authorities.
1. Heard the parties through their respective learned
counsels.
2. The reports filed by the railway authorities and the
respondent No. 5 are taken on record.
3. The grievance of the petitioner, who operates as a
leaseholder,
pertains
to
the
recurring
non-
functionality and lack of proper maintenance of the
in-motion weighbridge hereinafter referred to as
(IMWB for the sake of brevity and convenience)
located at Shalimar, Paddmapukur.
4. The
petitioner
submits
that
upon
fulfilling
all
eligibility criteria, he submitted the Bid in response
to
the
E-Auction
and
has
been
declared
the
successful bidder under the E-Auction Parcel Leasing
Policy (Station FMC-11/2022, FMC-12/2022 and
other
circulars
as
subsequently
amended
and
introduced.
5. The petitioner submits that the he is the leaseholder
of two leased parcel vans (LVPHS) operating on a
round
trip
basis
between
Shalimar
(SHM)/Cherlapally Railway Station (CHZ), Shalimar
via Train Number 18045/18046 (East Coast Express)
for a period of two years. It is further submitted that
the erratic functioning of the weighbridge leads to
significant financial loss, particularly in the form of
punitive charges or risk of termination for alleged
overloading.
6. The
petitioner
submits
that
the
in-motion
weighbridge at the site i.e. Shalimar, Paddmapukur
is frequently found to be out of order and produces
inconsistent readings which are not in conformity
with
the
standards
prescribed
by
the
Legal
Meteorology Act, 2009.
7. Despite repeated representations, the mandatory
periodical
recalibrations
and
stamping
by
the
Respondent No. 5 has not been conducted in
coordination with the Railway authorities. Such
failure to maintain the equipments, results in
“inmotion errors,” for which the petitioners, being the
leaseholder,
suffers, immensely and is
unfairly
penalised under the Railways act and the relevant
marketing circulars.
8. In the instant case, the faulty readings recorded by
the in-motion weighbridge at Paddmapukur have
been caused due to lack of proper maintenance and
regular verification by Respondent No. 5 and the
Railways authorities.
9. At the time of transportation of the consignment
comprising various perishable eggs at Shalimar, the
Railway authorities conducted in-motion weighing of
the parcel van without providing any notice to the
petitioner
and/or
representation,
any
which
opportunity
runs
to
contrary
make
a
to
the
conditions laid down in the Freight Marketing
circular No. 7/2021.
10.
Subsequently the railway authorities informed the
petitioner
with
regard
to
the
overloading
and
detached the parcel van from the train, keeping it
under sealed custody at Shalimar, and thereby
debarring the petitioner from unloading on the
ground of “overloading”.
11.
Due to such faulty tare reading of the electronic
weighbridge, the petitioner has suffered monetary
loss and the consignment of perishable eggs has
been found to be damaged.
12.
The petitioner further submits that as per the
clauses
mentioned
in
the
Freight
circular
the
Railways authorities are required to weigh the
consignment
at
the
originating
station
commensurate with the weight declared in the
manifest,
any
deviation
therefrom
constitute
a
breach of the prescribed procedure.
13.
Thereafter
the
consignments
are
taken
for
reweighment at the termini, which reveals that the
weight
exceeded
the
statutory
tolerance
limit,
contrary to the weighment at the originating station.
14.
The petitioner submits that due to such alleged
overloading, he has suffered the financial loss and
damage to the consignment. The current weighment
protocol lacks transparency as the detention occurs
because leaseholders are often not informed of the
weighment time, thereby depriving them of the
opportunity to witness the process.
15.
The learned counsel appearing for respondent no.
5 submits that every half yearly interval, the inmotion
weighbridges
are
inspected,
tested
and
accordingly certified by the functioning capacity.
16.
Respondent No. 5 submits that the railway
authorities are the authorised persons to maintain
and
repair
faulty
in-motion
weighbridges.
The
certifications of the equipment can be carried out
provided
the
railways
facilitates
the
necessary
technical environment for testing.
17.
The learned counsel appearing for the railway
authorities submits that in the instant case the
faulty in-motion weighbridge at Paddmapukur has
already been rectified and the grievances raised by
the petitioner have been redressed, as such, the Writ
petition has become infructuous as the cause no
longer survives.
18.
It is further submitted that maintenance is
governed by a contract with a third party vendor and
that the weighbridge is subject to regular inspections
and
certification
by
the
railway
accordance
with
statutory
contended
that
certification
authorities
requirement.
by
the
It
in
is
railway
authorities required testing the availability of which
depends on operational feasibility.
19.
In the instant case the reweighment has also been
conducted manually at the request of the petitioner.
The
consignments
have
been
received
by
the
petitioner unconditionally and no complaint has been
lodged regarding any damage at the time of delivery.
Accordingly, there is no evidence of any damage
having been caused to the consignments.
20.
The delay in release of the consignment occurred
due
to
the
time
taken
for
reweighment
and
subsequent manual verification of the weight of the
consignment which has been conducted at the
behest of the request made by the petitioner.
21.
In this context, the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner vehemently opposes the same and
draws attention to paragraphs 21 to 23 of the Writ
petition
to
weighment
demonstrate
procedure
that
and
due
to
defective
miscalculation,
the
petitioner has sustained loss causing grave financial
hardship.
22.
The petitioner relies upon a judgment of the
Division Bench of this Court wherein it has been
observed that in MAT 591 of 2022 with IA No. CAN
1 of 2022, Union of India & Ors. Versus Gopal
Shrinarayan Shah & Anr.:
“ Having heard the parties and anxiously
considering the materials placed, this Court finds
that the Orders of the Hon’ble Court dated 26 th
August, 2021, 11th February, 2022, 31st March,
2022, 7th April, 2022 and, lastly the 8 th of April,
2022 disclose detailed application of mind to the
principal facts in issue namely: a) The
correctness of the in-motion Weigh Bridge at
Padmapukur to be checked on an as-is-where-is
basis by the Controller of Legal Metrology; and b)
Weighment of the empty general coach carrying
the consignments.
This Court notices that the directions passed by
the Hon’ble Court on the above two issues do not
in any manner affect, impact or infringe the
power of the Railways to weigh or re-weigh
consignments as provided under Sections 78 and
79 of the Railways Act.
This court finds that the germane issue before
the Hon’ble Court was not the power to carry out
the weighment in terms of the statute but
specifically the correctness of the weighment
carried out in the facts of each case connected to
Issues a) and b) as recorded above.
23.
Due to lack of upkeep and maintenance of in-
motion weighbridge at Shalimar, Paddmapukur the
parcel
vans
are
shown
as
overloaded
due
to
malfunctioning of the static weighbridges, resulting
in erratic readings and exposing them to penal
action.
24.
In conspectus of the above this Court is of the
view that the lack of synergy between the Railway
authorities and the Legal Metrology Department
being the respondent No. 5 herein, cannot be allowed
to cause prejudice to the service users. The accuracy
of
an
in-motion
weighbridge
is
a
statutory
requirement and its failure strikes at the root of fair
trend and revenue assessment.
25.
Upon consideration of the submissions made by
the parties and the documents placed on record, the
following directions are hereby issued:
i.)
The
railway
authorities
must
maintain
accurate records of the weighment process
including
the
weight
recorded
and
any
discrepancies noted.
ii.)
The railways shall ensure that in-motion
weightbridge is calibrated and certified by a
competent authority at least once every six
months.
iii.) The leaseholders shall be given prior notice
of the weightment process and shall be entitled
to be present during the weightment.
iv.)
In event of a dispute, the matter shall be
referred to the railway authorities for resolution
and their decision shall be final and binding.
v.)
A digital or physical log for the last
stamping and/or calibration of the in-motion
weighbridge
must
be
made
available
for
inspection upon request by the leaseholder in
the event of a dispute.
vi.)
In
cases
of
significant
variation
the
leaseholder may apply for reweighment at the
next available weighbridge, subject to payment of
the requisite fees which shall be refundable if the
initial reading is found to be erroneous.
vii.) The
in-motion
weighbridge
should
be
certified by the respondent No. 4 in strict
adherence to the prescribed rules.
26.
In view of the above directions, the Writ petition is
disposed of.
27.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be given to the learned counsel for the
parties on usual undertakings
(Smita Das De, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review