Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132s21
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SIXTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 40064 OF 2025
Between:
Mohammed Yousufuddin, Sio. Mohammad Zainuddin, Aged. 55 years, Occ.
Business, Rio.H. No.10-59/'1l'1 , Mahaboob Colony, Bommakal Village,
Karimnagar Rural Mandal and Dist.
...PETITIONER
AND
1 The State of Telangana, Rep. by Principal Secretary, Civil Supplies and
Consumer Affairs, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Peddapally District.
3. The District Civil Supplies Officer, Peddapally Dist.
4. The District Manager, Telangana State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd.,
(TGSCSCL.), Peddapalli Dist.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to a). lssue a Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of Respondent No.3 in
unilaterally withdrawing/cancelling the contract agreement for hiring of private vehicle
bearing Registration No. TS-02-UC-4415, entered into under Agreement dated
01to4t2o25 and valid till 31/03/2026, vide Letter bearing Ref.No.CSl/01/2025 dated
01t12t2025 (served on the Petrtioner on 1911212025), as illegal, arbitrary, mala fide,
violative of the princrples of natural justice, in breach of contractual obligations and
unconstitutional, being violative of Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia,
and consequently quash and set aside the same. Consequenfly, suspend the
operation of the impugned Letter bearing Ref.No.CS1l1'lt2O2S daled 0111212025 b)
Further drrect the Respondents, particularly Respondent No.3, to permit the
Petitioner to continue the hiring agreement daled 011o412025 in accordance with its
terms and conditions till its contractual expiry on 31103/2026, , a) pass such other
order or orders as this Honourable court may deem fit and proper in the facts and
crrcumstances of the case, in the interest of justice and equity_
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. ANNNAMPELLI GANGADHAR
Counsel for the Respondents No 1 To 3: AGP FOR CIVIL SUPPLIES
Counsel for the Respondent No.4: SRI K. DEVENDER, SC FOR TELANGANA
STATE CtVrL SUppLtES CORpORATTON Lrd.,(TGSCSCL)
The Court made the following: ORDER
l
I
I
?
IN THE HIGH COURT FORTHE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION
0.4(J064 0F 2025
DATE: 26.03.2026
Between :
Mohammed Yousufuddin
Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Civil Supplies and Consumer Affairs, Secretariat Buildings,
Hyderabad and 3 others
Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri Annampelli Gangadhar, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitaoner, learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Civil Supplies,
appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.1 to 3 and Sri
K. Devender, learned Standing Counsel for Telangana
State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd., (TGSCSCL),
appearing on behalf of respondent No.4.
SN,]
W. P. No.40064 of 2025
2.
The oe titioner a ooroach ed the Court seekino
Draver as under:
"..(a) to issue a Writ of Mandamus declaring the
action of Respondent No.3 in unilaterally
withd rawing/ca ncelling the contract agreement for
hiring of private vehicle bearing Registration No.
fS-02-UC-4415, entered into under Agreement
dated 01-04-2025 and valid till 31-03-2026, vide
Letter bearing Ref.No.CSl /01/2025 dated 01-122025 (served on the Petitioner on 19-12-2025, as
illegal, arbitrary, mala fide, violative of the
principles of natural justice, in breach of
contractual obligations and unconstitutiona l, being
violative of Articles 74, 19 and 2L of the
Constrtution of India, and consequently quash and
set aside the same. Consequently, suspend the
operation oF the impugned Letter bearing
Ref.No.CS 1/0 t /2025 dated 01-12-2025
b) Further direct the Respondents, particularly
Respondent No.3, to permit the Petitioner to
continue the hiring agreement dated 01-04-2025
in accordance with its terms and conditions till its
contractual expiry on 31-03-2026,
c) Pass such other order or orders as this
Honourable Court may deem fit and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case, in the
interest of justice and equity.
.:5
S N,J
x
W.P. No.4O064 of 2025
3. The cas e of the netitio ncr in hrief as ner thc
vermen s made in the affidavit fil
b
in suDport of the Dresent Writ Petitaon is as underr
The petitioner is the owner of a Swift car bearing
Registration No. TS-02-UC-4415 hired by respondent No.3
under a valid contract agreement dated 01-04-2025 subject
to terms and conditions. As per Condition No.14 of the
Agreement, the contract was valid and subsisting for the
period from 01-04-2025 to 31-03-2026 and shall not be
terminated before expiry period except in accordance to law
and contractual conditions. The petitioner purchased a new
Maruti Breeza vehicle by availing loan facility and made
available to respondent No.3 as per his request.
Respondent No.3 without issuing any show-cause notice,
without giving any opportunity of hearing, issued the
impugned withdrawal letter dated 0l-12-2025. Respondent
No.3 is delaying monthly hire charges to the petitioner
under the influence of respondent N0.4. Aggrieved by the
action of the respondent No.3 in unilaterally withdrawing/
cancelling the contract agreement for hiring of private
5N,J
w.P. No.40064 of 2025
vehicle, the petitioner had approached this Court by filing
the present writ Petition.
PERUSE DTH E RECORD
(A)
T
Su oolv
civil
ne
1m
offi r
ro edi
o
he
rl
Pedda alli
Distri ctv
ide
Ref.No .cs1 /ot t2025 . dated o 1.L2.2025 ts extrac ted
her eund er
Dated 01'12'2025
Ref.No.cSl/01/2025
Civil supplies - Hire vehicle which is under use of DCSO'
Peddapalli is withdrawn w.e.f, 01.12 2025 - Information Reg'
Sub:
-
oOo
inform you that, in view of the
er e
tre v hicle
wl h h
cau
n len
nco
iDi rl
off r P a
of Di tric ivil u
her ebv wi hdraw with effect 01. L2.2 025.
This
rs
to
I
As such, the Hire charges to the above hire vehicle
shall be paid uP to 30.11.2025.
Hence, this for Your information.
sd/_
District Civil SuPPIY Officer,
Peddapalli District
To
The District Ma nager,
TGSCSCL,
Peddapally.
-.=
'1
;-ai= -' -e+L
q
SN,J
,A
W.P. No.4OO54 of 2025
(B) Counter affidavit filed bv resoondent No.3
n
a
nth
affidavit in oarticular
vermen
Dar a
No.7 is extracted
hereu nd er:
"7. In reply to Paras 6 and 7 oF the Writ Affidavit, it is
submitted that the petitioner completely failed to refund or
reimburse the Rs.40,381.49 incurred by the 3'd Respondent for
the fuel despite receiving the hire charges. Due to these
persistent, unrectified violations of the agreement conditions and
the resulting impediments to ofFicial duties, the 3'd respondent
was left with no optlon but to withdraw the hired vehicle vide
Letter No.CS1/Ol/2025, dated 01.12.2025. The allegation that
this was done to accommodate a "benami" vehicle for personal
benefit is a reckless and malicious falsehood. concocted entirely
to mislead this Hon'ble Court".
The learned c ounsel aooearinq on b ehalf of the
ioner maanl
f rth the
submissions
(i)
The petitioner is the owner of Swift car bearing
No.TS-02-UC-4415 which was hired by respondent No.3
under valid contract agreement dated 01-04-2025 for hiring
oF private vehicle, subject to terms and conditions
mentioned therein .
5N'l
W P. No.40064 of 2025
(ii) As per Condition 14 of the Agreement, the
contract was valid and subsisting for the period from 01-042025 to 31-03-2026
(i.i) To the sho ck of the Detit ioner without anv
orior notice unilaterallv the resoonden t No.3 issued
the imo u o ned letter vide Ref.No.CSl/ o 12025. dated
01.12.2025 wherebv the r sDondent No.3 unilaterallv
withdrawn/can celled the hire Aoreem ent dated
01.04.202s
ithout assionino the reas ons for clear
violati on f orincioles of nat ural iustice,
(iv) The action of the respondent No.3 in issuing the
impugned letter dated 0l-12-2-25 is in violation of Articles
14, 19 and 21 oF the Constitution of India and therefore, the
petitioner is entitled for the relief as prayed in the present
writ petition.
6,
The learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Civil Su plaes, aooearino on behalf of re soon dent
Nos.1 to 3 mainlv o ts forth the followinq
submissions
SN,J
W.P. No.40064 of 2025
(i)
The petitioner violated the conditions of the
Agreement resulting impediments in discharge of the official
duties and therefore, the respondent No.3 is left with no
option to withdraw the hired vehicle vide Letter No. CSU01/
2025, dated 0t.t2.2025.
(ii) The petitioner has no fundamental right to
compel the State to continue the petitioner when the
petitioner committed breach of the agreed terms.
(iii) The disputes arising exclusively out of the terms
of a contract fall squarely within the realm of private law.
(iv) The impugned letter dated 01.12.2025 issued by
the Distrlct Civil Supply Officer, Peddapalli District as an
administrative action, which is legal and warrants no
interference of this Court.
7. The learned Assistant Government Pleader for
m nt of
ti s relies on
r
din T 1 o 7 7\ 2 Caa 4 E 7
ca t?6 in Radhakri chnr
Arrr rw a
t nd
1 o 77 Caa alir Lin
att ar.c t/c
C}rla
of Bihar and Others in Civil Aooeal Nos.227 and 228 of
L976 dated 17.03.1977 and olaces reliance in
a rticula
r ar
f the saa
n
SN,]
w.P. No.40054 of 2025
and contended th at the p etitioner is not entitl d for
the r lief as Dr ved for in the orese nt writ o
8.
ition.
A bare perusal of the record clearly indicates that as
per Condition No.i4 of the Agreement OiteO 01.04.2025
executed by the petitioner with the respondents herein ' It
is very clear that the contract is valid and subsisting for the
period from Ot-04-2025 to 31-03-2026 and the same is not
disputed even by the learned Assistant Government Pleader
for Civil Supplies, appearing on behalf of respondent Nos'1
to 3.
I
A bare o e rusal of the order imouqned dated
oL,12.2 O25 issued bv the Di strict Civil Suoolv O rcer,
Pedda alli District cle arlv indicate s that the im uoned
r wher b the res
withdrawn /
ca ncel led
n
nt
the hio
oL.o4.2025 admittedl v as borne
has unil
r ll
aoreement dated
n record is
thout
anv reasons an without i ssulno anv orior notice
rv! lation ofn rtnct
10.
tn
J natu ra I irrcl
The Aoex Court in the I ud oment reoorted in
(2O1Ql 9 See 49S rn I(ranti Associates Private Limited
t
I
SN,]
W.P. No.4OO64 of 2025
& Another v. Masood Ahme d Khan & Others at oaru 47
observed as under :
Pata 47 i Summarising the above discussion, this
Court holds:
I
(a) In India the judiciat trend has always
been to record reasons, even in administrative
decisions, it such decisions affect anyone
I
I
prejudicially(b) A quasi-judicial authority must record
reasons in support of its conclusions,
(c) Insistence on recording of reasons is
meant to serve the wider principle of iustice that
justice must not only be done it must also appear
to be done as well.
(d) Recording of reasons also operates as a valid
restraint on any possible arbitrary exercise of judicial
and quasi-judicial or even administrative power.
(e) Reasons reassure that discretion has been
exercised by the decision-maker on relevant grounds
and by disregarding extraneous considerations.
(f) Reasons have virtually become as
indispensable a component of a decision-making
process as observing principles of natural justice
by judicial, quasi-judicial and even by
ad m i n istrative bod ies.
(g) Reasons facilitate the process of judicial
review by superior cou rts.
SN.]
w.P. No.40064 of 2025
(h) The ongoing judicial trend in all countries
committed to rule of law and constitutional governance
is in favour of reasoned decisions based on relevant
facts. This is virtually the lifeblood of judicial decisionmaking justifying the principle that reason is the soul
of justice.
(i) Judicial or even quasi-judicial opinions
these days can be as different as the judges and
authorities who deliver them. All these decisions
serve one common purpose which ,s to
demonstrate by reason that the relevant factors
have been objectively considered. This is
important for sustaining the litigants' faith in the
j ustice d e I ivery system.
(j ) Insistence on reason is a requirement
for both judicial accountability and transparency.
(k) If a judge or a quasi-judicial authority is not
candid enough about his/her decision-making process
then it is impossible to know whether the person
deciding is faithful to the doctrine of precedent or to
principles of incrementalism.
(l) Reasons in support of decisions must be
cogent, clear and succinct. A pretence of reasons
or "rubber-stamp reasons" is not to be equated
with a valid decision-making process.
(m) It cannot be doubted that transparency is
the sine qua non of restraint on abuse of judicial
powers. Transparency in decision-making not only
(
sN,l
W.P- No.40064 of 2025
makes the judges and decision-makers less prone to
errors but also makes them subject to broader
scrutiny.
(n) Since the requirement to record reasons
emanates from the broad doctrine -of fairness in
decision - ma king,
(o) In all common law jurisdictions judgments
play a vital role in setting up precedents for the future.
Therefore, for development of law, requirement of
giving reasons, for the decision is of the essence and is
virtually a part of "due process".
11. A bare perusal of the record indicates that the
reasons stated in the counter affidavit justifying the
issuance of the impugned proceedings of the District
Civil Supply Officer, Peddapalli District vide Ref. No.
CSL/ OLI 2O25, dated OL.LZ.?OZS (referred to and
extracted above) do not in fact reflect in the
impugned proceedings and this Court opines that the
same is intended only to develop the case of the
respondents which is in fact impermissible under law
ment of h A
Vs- Chief
Election
Commissi oner, New Delhi and Others re
rted in
Sinqh Gill
and Another
ohin
I
S N,]
W.P. No.40064 of 2025
(1978) 1 SCC 405 and in oarticular the observations
at oara No.
of the said iudoment
re extracted
hereunder:-
8. The second equally relevant matter is that when a
statutory functionary makes an order based on certain
grounds, its validity must be judged by the reasons so
mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh
reasons in the shape of affidavit or otherwise.
Otherwise, an order bad in the beginning may, by the
time it comes to court on account of a challenge, get
validated by additional grounds later brought ,out. We
may here draw attention to the observatlons of Bose
l. in Gordhandas Bhanji
"Public orders, oubliclv made, in exercise of a
tatuto
auth I
e construed in h
lioht of exo lanations subseouentlv qiven bv the
officer mak inq the order of what he meant, or of
what was in his mind, or what he antended to,
do. Pu blic orders made bv oublic au thorities are
meant t o have oublic effect and are intended to
effect the a tinqs and conduct of th se to whom
thev are a ddressed and must
construed
o biect ivelv with reference to th e a quaoe used
tn the o er itself. "
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as
they grow older:
12. This Court opines that the pleas put forth by the
respondents in the counter affidavit pertaining to breach of
the agreement had been reflected in the order impugned
SN,J
W.P. No.40064 of 2025
dated 01.12.2025 issued by the District Civil Supply Officer,
Peddapalli and since the petitioner had admittedly not been
put on any prior notice pointing out the said alleged breach
of terms and conditions of the agreement in the absence of
such notice, having been issued to the petitioner, the
unilateral cancellation of the hiring agreement dated
0L.O4.2025 through the impugned order dated 01.12.2025
is arbitrary and unsustainable in law.
13. Takinq into consideration:
(a ) The aforesaid facts and circumstances of
the case,
(b) The submissions made by the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner and the
learned Assastant Government Pleader for Civil
Supplies, appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.1 to
3,
(c) The letter impugned dated OL.12.2O25
issued by the respondent No.3 herein (referred to and
extracted above),
(d) The averments made in the counter
affidavit filed on behalf of respondent No.3 in
SN,]
w.P. No.40064 of 2025
particular para No.7 (referred to and extracted above)
which clearly indicates that the respondent No.3 had
issued the impugned letter dated O1.12.2O25 since
the petitioner violated the agreement conditions and
the fact as borne on record that the respondent No.3
had admittedly arrived at an unilateral decision
without providing reasonable opportunity to the
petitioner to put forth petitioner's case before the
concerned in defence since no show cause notice
admittedly had been issued to the petitioner prior to
passing the impugned letter bearing Ref.No.
CSL I OL / 2025, dated OL.L2.2O25,
(e) The fact as borne on record, the letter
impugned dated 01.12.2025 ol the 3'd respondent is
in clear violation of principles of natural justice.
(f) The observations of the Apex Court in the
judgment reported in (2O1O) 9 SCC 496 in Kranti
Associates Private Limited & Another v. Masood
Ahmed Khan & Others in particular at para 47 and the
observations of the Aiex Court in the Judgment in
Mohinder Singh Gill and Another Vs. Chief Election
*€#?*
SN, J
W.P- No.40064 of 2025
Commissioner, New Delhi and Others (referred to and
extracted above) reported in (1978) 1 SCC 405 and in
particular para No.8 (referred to and extracted
above),
The writ petition is allowed. The order impugned
vide Ref. No.CS1/O1/2O25, dated O1.12.2025 is set
aside. The respondent No.3 is darected to permit the
petitaoner to continue the hiring agreement dated
01.04.2025 as per the terms and conditions of the
hiring agreement for the period of contract for which
the petitioner was prevented to operate the vehicle
due to the issuance of the present impugned order
dated O1.12.2025 by the 3'd respondent to the
petitioner. There shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition, shall stand closed.
i
SD/-C. DEEPIKA
SISTANT REGIST
//TRUE COPY//
SECTIO N OFFICER
To,
The Principal Secretary, Civil
Telangana, Secretariat EiuilOings,
5.
Supplies and
Hyderabad.
S
mer Affairs, State of
The District Collector, peddapaily
District.
The District Civil Supplies Officer, peddapally
I
Dist
I
I#.3S8i:l Hi;en'ji,, Igransana state civir suppries corporation Ltd.,
One CC to SRt. ANNNAMPELLT
GANGADHAR, Advocate
IOPUCI
6. Two CCs to cP FOR C|VIL SUppLtES, High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
7. One CC to SRI K DEVENDER, SC FOR TELANGANA STATE CtVtL
suppLtES coRpoRATtoN Ltd ,(TGSCSCL) [OpUCl
B Two CD Copies
DAN
BS
HIGH COURT
CC TODAY
DATED: 2610312026
":::----,_+,\',r''.1|
/-14-a;- '
li! -\ 1.1 i\\
"c'o;\
?,i
i-
)
)
l] 4 [1AY 2iI7B
.)
ORDER
WP.No.40064 of 2025
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITTON
WITHOUT COSTS
Lo Q\9
q'
o
)
, /,,
:\
-2:.
f1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review