The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. ln thc light ol thc abovc. this Court is unhesitant to hold thal the rcsponder.tt rcgistering authoritics arc not entitlcd to reluse rcgrsrration of a documenl on thc ground that thc iink documenl rcfcrred to rn the rcspcctivc docllmcnt rs a validated documcnt or [o rcfusc rcgistralion of such docurncnt bv placing reltance on cnclorscmcn[. dnlcd 02.O ].20118. rssucd bv rhc Commisstoncr and InspccLor (lCncral ol Stamps :ur cl Rcgrstrarion. Accordrngll , thc rmpugnr--d orders in thc respc('tive Writ Pctitions arc set aside and Writ l)etitions are allowed u'ith a iurther direction to the respondenl r(-.gistcring authorltlcs to rcucrvc Lh( r(LLIrnctl clotumcnts anci to proccss thc s:Imc sublccl to lhi' t:OndLlton ol-thc sard docum('nts comptving r,,''i th tht: pror isions of the llegistra[ron Act, 1908 and rhc lndian StamP Act, I899 " B. In K.GoPt's CA SC (1 supra), thc FIon'ble Suprcmc Court hcld as undcr ,,The registcring olficcr is noL conccrncd with rhe dtle held by the executant. llc h:rs no adjudicalorv powcr to clccidc r,,"'hcther the cxecLltanL has anl titic. I'l e n if an cxt'cuLant cxccut('s a salL clccd or a lcasc in rL-spc( t oI :r litttd trt rcspccl ol ,,r'hich hc has no t.itle, thc rcgistering ofllcer cannol refuse to register the documcnt if all thc proccdural compliances arc made and thc ncccssary stamp duty as $,cll as rcgistrt.irron char gt sl lcc ;Lr c p:rid. We …
10. From [he abovc, it is clear rhat as pcr abor,.c pzrragraph No.2, no nc\^. plot shall bc rcgislcrcd unless it has bcen approvcd by thc compcLcnt authorll)' or is in an aurhorized Iayout. Therefore, in the instanr case, thc said conditton is not applicable as it is not a new plot I 1. In vicu' of thc abovc, follou,ing thc judgment of thc Hon'ble Supreme Court in K.Gopi v. The Sub Registrar (supra) and thc ordcr passed b,r, thrs Court in W.P.No. 163 I0 oi 20 19 and batch datcd 1l .1 .2023 and in terms thercof, this rr,rit pclition is disposed of. dircctins lhc respondent authoritics to rcceivc. rcgrstcr and rclcase the documcnt bcaring I). No. ltr2/2023 prcscntcd bv thc pctirioncr in rcspect of the subjecl. propert\r, r.r,ithout rcference to thc Intimation of Relusal Ordcr N<t.274 ol 2023 datcd 15.12.2023. surbjccr ro rhe condition [hat Lhc said documcnt complics u'ith the provisions of thc RcgistraLion Act. 1908 and the Ir.rdian Stamp Act. 1899. Miscellancous pctirlons. il an-r,, pcnding shall stand closcd. Thcrc shall bc no ordcr as to costs. //TRUE COPY// SD/. M. OSMAN ALI BAIG To, The Principal Secretary, Stamps & Registration Telangana, Secretariat, Hyderabad. artment, The State of
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO: 29024 OF 2026
Between:
Mohammed Sohel Baba, S/o. Mohammed Javeed, Aged about: 25 years,
Occ: Business, R/o. H. No.3-13111 , Bandlaguda, Ramachandrapuram, Sanga
Reddy District, T.S - 502319.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Stamps and
Registration Department, Secretanat, Hyderabad.
2. The District Registrar, Sanga Reddy District.
3. The Sub - Registrar, Sanga Reddy (R.O), Sanga Reddy District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Anide 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to lssue a Writ, Order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
I\,4andamus declaring the action of Respondent No.3 in issuing the lntimation of
Refusal vide Refusal Order No. 274 ol 2023 dated 1511212023 as illegal, arbitrary
and contrary to the provisions of Registration Act, 1908 and to the order passed by
the Honourable Apex Court in K. Gopi Vs. The Sub- Registrar and orders passed by
this Honourable Court and set-aside the same and consequently direct the
Respondent No.3 to register and release the Sale Deed (P 16212023) dated
1OlO3l2O23 presented by the Petitioner in respect of House constructed on Plot No.
244, admeasuting 150 Sq. Yards or 125.4 Sq. Meters with an plinth area 200 Sq.
Feet, in Sy. No. '1003/Part, Roof covered with ACC, situated at Ameenpur
Municipality and Ameenpur Mandal, Sam Reddy District without reference to Refusal
Order No. 274 of 2023 dated 1511212023
I.A. N O:1 OF 2026
Petitron under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
Respondent No. 3 to register and release the Sale Deed (P 16212023) dated
1010312023 presented by the Petitioner in respect of House constructed on Plot No.
244, admeasuring 150 Sq. Yards ot 125.4 Sq. Meters with an plinth area 200 Sq.
Feet, in Sy. No. 1003/Part. Roof covered with ACC, situated at Ameenpur
Municipality and Ameenpur l\,4andal, Sanga Reddy District without reference to
Refusal Order No 274 of 2023 daled 1511212023 forthwith pending disposal of the
above Writ Petition
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S. SRIDHAR
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms. S. SRAVANTHI, ASST. GP FOR
STAMPS & REGISTRATION
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION No.29O24 OF 2026
3'd SEPTEMBER, 2026
Between:
Mohammed Sohcl tsaba
Pctit.ior:cr
AND
St-at c ol Tc langan a.
rcp. bY its Princrpal Sccretar\,
Starrps and Rcgistration Dcpartn'rcnt,
Sccrc t;rria t, I l,r'dcrabad
and i2) cl1 I)crs.
Rc s ponc cn ts
ORDER:
Wjth thc conscnt o[ bot h Lhc partrcs, this Writ Pctitron is
iakr:n up.r ior disposal at LI'r(' aclmissiorl slagc itsclf
2.
This writ petition is filcd dcclanng the action of rhc
RcspLrndcnI No.3 rrr rssuing intrrnaLion ttf Rclusal Ordcr i,idc
Rcfusal Ordcr No.274 of 2023 dntcd 15.1'2.2023 as arbrtrarv
and illegal and r:onsequen[h- dircct thc rcspondent No.3 to
rcgistcr and rclcasc thc Salc Dr:cd (P.No.162/2023) datcd
10.3.2023 prcscntr.d b-v thc pctitirtncr in rcspcct of House
constructed on l)iot No.244. admcasunng 150 sq.r.ards n,irh
,
phnth arca o1 200 lt. ln Sr.No.10037part, ru,of covcrcd .,r,ith
ACIC situzrted at .,\rnr:cr-rpur MunicipaUt,r' and mandal. Sanga
I?eddr rtsLrict \\ ltl.roLlt rclcrcncc to thc Refusal Ordcr dated
I 5 1.t 202:l
al. Hcard Sn S. Sridhar. learncd counscl [or thc petitioncr
anrl Ms.S.Sravantlrl. lcarncd Assistant Clor,'t:rnment Irlcader
elpl)errrlng lor t hc r<'spondcnts and perused the t ccord
4.
l'he lr:arnt'd crrunscl for the peutioner submils Lhat
origin a th one
C. Bhoopal Rcddr. u,as
thc abso.ute or'vner and
poss('ssor o1' I)lrrt No...1 1.1. admcasuring 15f.) sq,-r' rrds sitr-ratcd at
Amet'npur M unicipalit.r and mandal. SzLnga Reddl' districl
havinq purchersed thc samc undr:r rcgistercd sale dced dated
3.3.2() 12 bczLrinq document No.2993 of 2012 and thcrealier the
saicL C'.13hoooir1 Rcddr has c:onstructccl a housc' on thc said plot
No..2,l-1 erncl solcl Lhc samc to one .Janupula Ramachandra
Reddr undcr sale dcccl. shich uas validated bv Lhe rcspondcnt
I'Jo..) ridc Filr' \o.(1 11r)+()8/2022 clatcd 1 2.2O2-3. I'hcrcaftr:r.
thc saLcl .Jan,-rptrla Ilernrach:rn<:lra Rcddr has offcred to sell the
said propertv in lavour of p<:titioner and the petitioner has
agreod to p r rrchersc thc same lor a r.alid considcration
Accrrrdinqi-r . sait. dt.ccl datcc'l 1O.3.2023 u as exccutcd and
prcscntcd bcforc thc rcspondent No.3, honevcr, the rcsponclent
No.3 has refused to receive the sale deed vide Refusal Order
No.271 of 20'23. The lcarned counscl furthcr submitted that
lhc issuc involvcd in this writ pctition is squarelv covered bY
[hr: orc]er passcd bl this Court in W.P.No.163 10 of 2019 and
batch darcd 11.1 .2023 and also rcccnt 3udgmcnt ol the Hon'ble
Supremc Court in K.Gopi v. The Sub-Registrart and
requested to pass stmilar order in this *-rit petition also
5.
Lcarned Govcrnmcnt l)lcader appcaring for
the
rcspor)dcnLs has not dispulr:,i thC submission of thc lezLrncd
<:oun scl for thc pctiLioncr
(>. A pcrusal ol thc impugncd Rcfusal Order datcd
15.12.2023. discloscs that thc rcgistration ol thc sale decd
prescntcd b,v the pctit'ioncr u.as rcfuscd on the ftrllor"'ing
reason s
'' RcgJ s
tratio r.r of thc clorrr-tmcnt is rclusr:d as it is a part oI an
nnauthorizcd lavout and is in violation ol thc Commissioner and
lnspcctor (icncral, Rcgislration antl Stamps Memo No.G2/237 12019
d.rte.l 26.8.2020 and 29. l2 l02O
r\s pcr thr: instructions ol thc (lommissroncr and Inspecror
(it'ncr:rl ol- Rcgrstraljon and Stamps ltn dorscmcn t No.CI(i
' zozs scc on ne sc 740
l,'lAlL/AIti 2008 clatecl ?.1.2008 rtnregtstercd ar)cl Validated document
r annot bc ac ceptt cl as a r;rlicl iink documcnt for rcgist-a.tion"
7.
ln thrs c{)ntc\t. 11 ls lo cr<traot thc rclcvar t portion o[ thc
orcier in \\.I).\o. I tr3l 0 ol 2019 and btr[ch dated 1 1.01.2023,
lvh'ch is as ttnc1t: r
-1.1 I'hr: ir, ur': o1 -'tt' l( gtstcrtnq altthoritr to tcfus| rcglstrallon 1s
onl., . rl art-l a,l Lhc gt orln(is or ol)J(] cttons thztl arc cnttmcratcd under
rhc proi'1sr,rns of Lht' I{e gisLration Act. 19O8 ancl t'.rc I?ulcs made
tfrclcundcr tn p:Lrticttlar Sec ttons 19.20.21. 2.1 r\. 14. .15 ancl rulc 5[i
o' the 'l el:'rnqiln:r llulcs rnclcr thc llcgistration .\ct. 1908, arc cxlsLil.tg
irr rt spcct .)1 ,rn\ sLl( h clocurnent prcsentcd for tlrc rcgislration
I-\c( pt. th(' grrrr-Lnds or Lrblcc Llons lhat arc (ln Ltmcr,ltcd ulldcr the
pr-or isrons of thr,' llc-qtstrirtrorr Ac1 . i908' Lhe rt:gtstcling authoritics
h,rr,- no iILrLhor::r :o r( lLlsr rcglsLrallon ol:l clo' umer I on :Lnv othcr
qrountl. As alrt';rclr L:orccl alrorc. tlle grolln(i rlrl rvhicl- thc lmpugncd
rcfusal orcllrs t ;rl1 tll,'st llati:11 ol \\'11L l)e 11(1olis :uc 1;asscd rs rhat
rhc tnh rlor"-lrn,:-tl sliott: lil th( r'csl)cct1\'e doclLtrlclllr; ls a laltciatcd
arrcl an rLnlegtstcrt-'cl docrtmenl. l3r iooking Into a \aliflt] ol'thc tink
dr,cLrnrct..t. tlt( r ('qLSl('rrllq ;,rrtlllorilv ts tudtrccLlv verrll'r:rg rvheIl-rcr thc
c\e( rll.{-rts Ol Lhr' rcsptctlr(' docllmcnLs alc hilrilLg rali I ritlc ol lo1 to
c\e( -LrL' lh(' (lo( llncl)ls In qttcsllon As hcl<1 ttt lhc abovc rcfi:rrccl
Naidu (l slLpra), the
Ju lgrncnt rr Lh,' cilsc oi Dr. Yadla Ramesh
rc,3rs,-cring;1111lrrrt[r LS nr)t ('n[itle(i lo go lnto rhe tirle oIthe parties to
th,-r (iocLrm('lrl l: ts ,l si'llli cl la\\ tha]t [hc tcrtdt'c und'r a docLLlncnt
$i 1 :rrt gtl a llcitt rlL. thatr hls vcndor and tn c:ts( ir-!'cndor ls not
hirrrIls a ri.r I ttl,i r)'. Ir th( lllol)er[\ "r l'tich rs Lh('sl.l)j"ot matlcr of a
p;rr1ri'irlar <li,r -rne trl. tll( \endcc rLncler lhc saial (lorlr nent does not
gcl irlr\ LrLir ot ct. sLlcll ;)r(lp( rL\ and mcrc registr,rtion oI such
drrr:rrrncr.r: ir ill rrot l.l.rr r' ,rr: cilcct o11 thc propc:t\ u'htr:h is the sublecl
nr.rtt( r' of thc siric] doc!mL ni
for
14. As righrl)' con(lcdcd bl thc lea-rrrcd Govcrnmenl Pleader
StampsandRegistration.Lheregistcrlngauthollticsarenotentitledto
ground that the tltle of the
refusc registration of a dtlcumcnl on mcrc
Validatcd
excclttants ol rhc rcspccLivc doc:unrcnt rs bascd Llpon thc
docltm.nt. though thc samc is comprrlsorrl-r. rcgisterablc documcnt
cannoL bc acccptcd and st-tch a grotlnd is not available to
registcring al.lthorities Lo refusc rcgistration of a document on thal
the
ground.
19. ln thc light ol thc abovc. this Court is unhesitant to hold thal the
rcsponder.tt rcgistering authoritics arc not entitlcd to reluse
rcgrsrration of a documenl on thc ground that thc iink documenl
rcfcrred to rn the rcspcctivc docllmcnt rs a validated documcnt or [o
rcfusc rcgistralion of such docurncnt bv placing reltance on
cnclorscmcn[. dnlcd 02.O ].20118. rssucd bv rhc Commisstoncr and
InspccLor (lCncral ol Stamps :ur cl Rcgrstrarion. Accordrngll , thc
rmpugnr--d orders in thc respc('tive Writ Pctitions arc set aside and
Writ l)etitions are allowed u'ith a iurther direction to the respondenl
r(-.gistcring authorltlcs to rcucrvc Lh( r(LLIrnctl clotumcnts anci to
proccss thc s:Imc sublccl to lhi' t:OndLlton ol-thc sard docum('nts
comptving r,,''i th tht: pror isions of the llegistra[ron Act, 1908 and rhc
lndian StamP Act, I899 "
B. In K.GoPt's CA SC (1 supra), thc FIon'ble Suprcmc Court
hcld as undcr
,,The registcring olficcr is noL conccrncd with rhe dtle held by the
executant. llc h:rs no adjudicalorv powcr to clccidc r,,"'hcther the
cxecLltanL has anl titic. I'l e n if an cxt'cuLant cxccut('s a salL clccd or a
lcasc in rL-spc( t oI :r litttd trt rcspccl ol ,,r'hich hc has no t.itle, thc
rcgistering ofllcer cannol refuse to register the documcnt if all thc
proccdural compliances arc made and thc ncccssary stamp duty as
$,cll as rcgistrt.irron char gt sl lcc ;Lr c p:rid. We mzly notc herc thaL
urrrler thc scht'mc ,)1 r.l..e l()08 r\cL. it ts trot tht' [un ]1Ion ol thc SLlbIlcqrstr:rr or Raqls[c111lq :\rtthttrttr to asccrtaln rvhclht'r tht' r'enclor has
ilrir' to th( proJ)( r i\ rt hti h hc is sccking lo Lransf cr. Once thc
-L:grstcrlnq alt:ltotil' ts slttrsllctl that thc partics to tlc docum('I1t arc
fr( seni 1)( 1.rra Iltnl irtrd ltlc partlcs aclmtt cxcculion thcrr:of bcforc
hrnr. sLLblei L Lo mal<trtq ploccclur:rl t'ompltalccs as nal'rated above, lhe
-lhc cxecutton ancl -egistration of a
umcnt must bt' r,.'gistcred
rlo, umcnt lr;r\,' lltc cl-i.ct o1-lranslerring ttnl-l thosc ri3ht's. rI anv' that
tht ('\ccLli.L:rt f()s!( sscs. il lil( c\c(Lltaltl ltas rr right tillc or
(:1o(
1nt( rcsL in tlt(
propcrlv. thc rcgisLerecl documcnt crrtlnot cffe ''L atlr
trarts[cr.'
!)
ln thrs rt'qarc1 . r[ 1s to be not(]d thc: circt. lar instruclions
iss ;cc1 bv rl re Cornrnissioncr and Inspcctor (lencral (R&S),
1'clangana. Ilvdcri'rbircl viclc I{cmo \o.G2,t 2t7 12019 dated
29 1'2.2O2O. rvhic:h rearcls as ut-rder:
'rit llcgistt.,rtto:,s .trr lli t:tl<clt rtp i;l resl)cct of ()llcll
lllol'i strLr('LLLrc\ ll l11( 'ralnt' llas 1)et:n ar:qttlrcd bl, th('prcscnl o\\rlcl
through a t.tltd Ieglslereci clocLtmctlI earltcr'
L::l iou c', t': . r: ' r-t 'ii plot slitrll irc r('grs1,ar('(1 ltnlc;s lL has bcen
appror ctl b'. 'h r'rr:ltpl r-':tL Lrt It.) l.] 1\ or ls ]-l il l.r aLrl horlz('d laVOLlt.
\ .,.r ploL r,, otLlti tlr':tt.t tt 1i('sh plot \!'hlch is bt:ir,g bror-rght lor
rcgi.rtlatrolt lor lht lirsl ttllt' or bt'tt.tg solcl tlr dcr clop :rs for thc llrst
er
LI IN(
iiril \s clarrirccl iar1i,.'r. th.rc is no rcstriction orr reS,lstration of plots
rr a ,iho:-izr', 1 la .r'.rls Dlors I-cgrtlarlzccl undct-carltt:r l'liS Schemc and
br.rL,irrrqs, str clLtrcs , o\,-11(l ttrtcltr-car]tcr ilPS i 1l]lS St hcrrtcs
'
10. From [he abovc, it is clear rhat as pcr abor,.c pzrragraph
No.2,
no nc\^. plot shall bc rcgislcrcd unless it has bcen
approvcd by thc compcLcnt authorll)' or is in an aurhorized
Iayout. Therefore, in the instanr case, thc said conditton is not
applicable as it is not a new plot
I 1.
In vicu' of thc abovc, follou,ing thc judgment of thc
Hon'ble Supreme Court in K.Gopi v. The Sub Registrar
(supra) and thc ordcr passed b,r, thrs Court in W.P.No. 163 I0 oi
20 19 and batch datcd 1l .1 .2023 and in terms thercof, this
rr,rit pclition is disposed of. dircctins lhc respondent authoritics
to rcceivc. rcgrstcr and rclcase the documcnt bcaring
I). No.
ltr2/2023 prcscntcd bv thc pctirioncr in rcspect of the
subjecl. propert\r, r.r,ithout rcference to thc Intimation of Relusal
Ordcr N<t.274 ol 2023 datcd 15.12.2023. surbjccr ro rhe
condition [hat Lhc said documcnt complics u'ith the provisions
of thc RcgistraLion Act. 1908 and the Ir.rdian Stamp Act. 1899.
Miscellancous pctirlons. il an-r,, pcnding shall stand
closcd. Thcrc shall bc no ordcr as to costs.
//TRUE COPY//
SD/. M. OSMAN ALI BAIG
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
CTION OFFICER
To,
The Principal Secretary, Stamps & Registration
Telangana, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
artment, The State of
2. The Distrrct Registrar, Sanga Reddy District.
3. The Sub - Registrar, Sanga Reddy (R.O), Sanga Reddy District
4 One CC to SRI S. SRIDHAR, Advocate IOPUC]
5 Two CCs to GP FOR STAMPS & REGISTRATION High Court for the State
of Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
Two
6.
CD Copres
BN
TKS
.*_
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0310912026
I
HE SIA 6
1/
ORDER
o
t)
WP.No.29024 of 2026
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
i-
-l.r
nlolre
1 0 sEP 2026
* .L (sp
AT H
*
,(\
tv
vz
o
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review