Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
Reserved On
: 18/09/2026
Pronounced On : 13/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3494 of 2026
With
CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR STAY) NO. 1 of 2026
In R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3494 of 2026
With
CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR STAY) NO. 2 of 2026
In R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3494 of 2026
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MOOL CHAND TYAGI
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
MOHAMMAD YUSUF MOHAMMAD PUNJANI
Versus
GUJARAT STATE WAQF BOARD & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR R R MARSHAL, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH
MS CHINTANIKA P LUKHI(10189) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
SHREY H DAVE(8444) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
JAY P PATEL for the Appellant(s) No.1
MR MANISH S SHAH(5859) for the Defendant(s) No. 1,2
NOTICE NOT RECD BACK for the Defendant(s) No. 4,6,7,8,9
NOTICE SERVED for the Defendant(s) No. 3
RIZWAN SHAIKH(7146) for the Defendant(s) No. 5
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MOOL CHAND TYAGI
CAV JUDGMENT
1.
The captioned appeal is filed against the impugned
judgment dated 28.07.2026, passed by the learned WAQF
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
Tribunal, Gandhinagar (herein after referred to as the “learned
Tribunal”) in WAQF Appeal No.19 of 2026, whereby the learned
Tribunal has issued numerous directions against the appellant
and the WAQF Board.
2.
The appellant herein are the original appellant and the
respondents herein are the original respondents before the
learned Tribunal, therefore, the parties herein are referred to
as per their status before the learned Tribunal.
3.
The succinct facts, which lead to the filing of the
captioned appeal are summarized as under :-
3.1
The appellant is the duly appointed Muttavalli of B/100 –
Junagadh Suryawad Memon Jamat, Porbandar. The appellant
came to be appointed as Muttavalli pursuant to Resolution No.
181 passed in the General Meeting convened on 30.12.2023.
3.2
Respondent No. 1 issued two notices bearing Nos. 17679
and 17680, both dated 16.12.2025, purportedly under Section
70 of the Act, upon taking cognizance of the applications
submitted by respondent nos. 6 to 9.
3.3
The appellant, in compliance with the aforesaid notices,
submitted a common reply dated 22.12.2025 along with all
documents and particulars sought for therein.
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
3.4
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
Thereafter, to the utter shock and surprise of the
appellant, he received a communication dated 10.06.2026
issued by the respondent Nos. 3 and 4 stating that they had
been appointed by Respondent No. 2 vide order dated
26.05.2026. The appellant had neither been served with nor
informed about the said order at any point of time. Further, no
opportunity of hearing was afforded to the appellant before
passing the said order. Upon inquiry by the appellant regarding
the
authority
under
which
the
communication
dated
10.06.2026 had been issued, the respondent No.3 furnished a
soft copy of the order dated 26.05.2026. It was only then that
the appellant became aware of the existence of the said order,
whereby respondent nos. 3 and 4 had been appointed as
Election Officer and Assistant Election Officer, respectively.
Thus, the order dated 26.05.2026 was passed behind the back
of the appellant and without adherence to the principles of
natural justice.
3.5
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the order dated
26.05.2026
passed
by
the
respondent
No.
and
the
consequential communication dated 10.06.2026 issued by
respondent nos. 3 and 4, the appellant preferred Waqf Appeal
No. 19 of 2026 under Section 83 of the Act before the learned
Tribunal. The learned Tribunal, vide judgment and order dated
28.07.2026, allowed the appeal and quashed and set aside the
order dated 26.05.2026 passed by the respondent no. 2- Chief
Executive Officer, Waqf Board along with all consequential
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
proceedings arising therefrom. However, while granting the
aforesaid relief, the learned Tribunal issued further directions
for taking possession of the books of accounts, records and
movable as well as immovable properties of the Waqf. The
learned Tribunal also directed the Waqf Board and its Chief
Executive Officer to initiate criminal proceedings against the
appellant and six other members. Being aggrieved and
dissatisfied with the judgment dated 28.07.2026 passed by the
learned Tribunal in WAQF Appeal No. 19 of 2026, the appellant
has preferred the present appeal challenging the legality,
propriety and validity of the impugned directions contained
therein.
4.
Heard learned advocates for the parties.
5.
Mr. R.R. Marshal, learned Senior Advocate assisted by Ms.
Chintanika Lukhi and Mr. Shrey Dave, learned counsels
appearing for the appellant vehemently submitted that the
learned Tribunal had exceeded the jurisdiction vested in it by
law inasmuch as by issuing directions for taking possession of
the books of accounts, records, and the movable as well as
immovable properties of the Wakf and lodging F.I.R. It is
submitted that the learned Tribunal had gravely erred in
directing the Wakf Board and its Chief Executive Officer to
initiate criminal proceedings against the appellant and six
other members without following the due process of law.
According to the learned Senior Advocate, such directions are
wholly
without
jurisdiction,
beyond
the
scope
of
the
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
proceedings before the learned Tribunal and could not have
been issued in the absence of any adjudication or finding
warranting such action. He, therefore, submitted that the
impugned directions deserve to be quashed and set aside.
6.
It is submitted that the impugned judgment passed by
the learned Tribunal is internally inconsistent and selfdefeating. The learned Tribunal has categorically held that the
Waqf Board had failed to follow the procedure prescribed
under Section 71 of the Act and on such ground, interfered
with the action of the Board. However, having arrived at such a
finding,
the
learned
Tribunal
itself
proceeded
to
issue
directions to respondent nos. 2 and 3 to initiate proceedings
against the appellant and other members without following the
very procedure contemplated under Section 71 of the Act. It is
submitted that having found fault with the Waqf Board for noncompliance with the statutory procedure, the learned Tribunal
could not have itself issued directions, which are contrary to
the mandate of the said provision. According to the learned
Senior Advocate, such directions are legally unsustainable and
suffer from a patent internal inconsistency, besides being
beyond the scope of the jurisdiction exercised by the learned
Tribunal. He, therefore, submitted that the said directions
deserve to be quashed and set aside.
7.
It is further submitted that the jurisdiction and function of
the learned Tribunal are essentially adjudicatory in nature. The
learned Tribunal is not vested with any supervisory jurisdiction
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
over the affairs of the Waqf. It is submitted that the
supervisory powers and functions are vested with the Waqf
Board under the statutory scheme. Therefore, while exercising
its adjudicatory jurisdiction, the learned Tribunal ought not
have assumed unto itself supervisory powers and issued
directions to the Waqf Board and its Chief Executive Officer to
initiate proceedings against the appellant and other members.
Such directions are wholly beyond the scope of the jurisdiction
vested in the learned Tribunal and, therefore, cannot be
sustained in the eyes of law. In support of his submissions, he
has placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the case of M.P. Wakf Board v. Subhan Shah
(Dead) by L.Rs. & Ors., (2006) 10 SCC 696, wherein the
scope and nature of the jurisdiction of the Waqf Tribunal have
been considered. He has also placed reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of S.V.
Cheriyakoya Thangal v. S.V.P. Pookoya & Ors., Civil
Appeal No. 4629 of 2024 arising out of SLP (C) No. 3182
of 2019, in support of the submission that the jurisdiction of
the Tribunal is circumscribed by the statutory provisions and
cannot be enlarged beyond the authority conferred upon it by
law.
8.
Per contra, Mr. Manish Shah, learned advocate appearing
for the respondent nos. 1 & 2 vehemently submitted that the
learned Tribunal has been vested with wide and ample powers
under Sections 83 and 85 of the Act to adjudicate disputes
relating to Waqf and
Waqf property and to pass such
appropriate orders as may be necessary for securing the
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
proper administration and management of the Waqf and
protection of its properties. It is submitted that the jurisdiction
conferred upon the learned Tribunal is not narrowly confined to
adjudication of the dispute brought before it, but extends to
passing appropriate consequential and incidental directions
necessary for effectuating the object and purpose of the Act. It
is submitted that the directions issued by the learned Tribunal
were issued in furtherance of the proper administration and
protection of the Waqf and its properties and were within the
statutory jurisdiction conferred upon the Tribunal. Learned
advocate further submitted that merely because the learned
Tribunal has issued consequential directions for securing the
books of accounts, records and properties of the Waqf and for
taking appropriate action in accordance with law, the same
cannot be said to amount to an exercise of supervisory
jurisdiction or an assumption of powers not vested in it by the
statute. It is, therefore, submitted that the contention of the
appellant
that
the
learned
Tribunal
had
exceeded
its
jurisdiction is misconceived and deserves to be rejected. In
support of his submissions, he has placed reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Board of
Wakf, West Bengal & Anr. v. Anis Fatma Begum & Anr.,
(2010) 14 SCC 588 and submitted that the jurisdiction of the
Waqf Tribunal is of wide amplitude and that the learned
Tribunal is competent to pass appropriate orders in matters
concerning the administration and management of the Waqf.
9.
Mr. Rizwan Shaikh, learned advocate appearing on behalf
of the respondent no.5 vehemently submitted that having
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, the learned
Tribunal has committed no error in issuing the directions
contained in the impugned order. He submitted that, as per
the bye-laws governing the Waqf, the election of the Trustees
is required to be conducted every year. However, in the
present case, the last election of the Trustees was conducted
in the year 1996 and, thereafter, no election has been held till
date. He, therefore, submitted that the directions issued by the
learned Tribunal were justified in the facts and circumstances
of the case and were intended to ensure proper administration
and management of the Waqf in accordance with its bye-laws.
10.
It is submitted that the respondent nos.5 to 9 had
addressed several complaints to the Waqf Board with regard to
the administration and management of the Waqf. However,
despite receipt of such complaints, the Wakf Board failed to
take any effective action. It is submitted that the inaction on
the part of the Waqf Board was deliberate and that the Waqf
Board was acting in connivance with the appellant. It is
submitted that a complaint was also addressed to the Hon'ble
Chief Minister; however, even thereafter, no effective action
was taken by the authorities. It is further submitted that the
Central Waqf Council had also directed the Waqf Board to
conduct an inquiry into the maladministration and mismanagement of the Waqf and to take appropriate steps in
accordance with law. Pursuant to the said directions, the Waqf
Board entrusted the inquiry to Mr. Siraj Mandavia. However,
when Mr. Siraj Mandavia visited the Waqf premises for
conducting the inquiry, he was allegedly misbehaved and
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
assaulted by the Trustees. It is submitted that Mr. Siraj
Mandavia thereafter, submitted a report to the Waqf Board
regarding the alleged misbehavior and assault. Despite receipt
of the said report, the Waqf Board failed to take any action in
the matter. It is submitted that, on the basis of a complaint
lodged by one Salim Yusuf Surya, the Wakf Board appointed an
Inquiry Officer. The said order was challenged by the appellant
by preferring WAQF Appeal No. 36 of 2021 before the learned
Tribunal. The learned Tribunal, vide order dated 12.05.2022,
set aside the said order on the ground that the same had been
passed in contravention of Sections 33 and 71 of the Act. It is
submitted that, thereafter, no further action was taken against
the appellant or the Trust. The aforesaid circumstances
demonstrate that, despite repeated complaints and directions
for conducting an inquiry into the affairs of the Waqf, the Waqf
Board failed to discharge the statutory duties and functions
cast upon it under the Act. It is, therefore, submitted that the
conduct and inaction of the Waqf Board give rise to a serious
apprehension of collusion between the appellant and the Waqf
Board. It is submitted that in the aforesaid circumstances,
where the statutory authority had failed to discharge its duties
and take appropriate steps for proper administration and
protection of the Waqf and its properties, the learned Tribunal
was
justified
in
exercising
its
jurisdiction
and
issuing
appropriate directions. It is, therefore, submitted that the
learned Tribunal has committed no error or illegality in passing
the
impugned
judgment
and
issuing
the
consequential
directions contained therein. It is accordingly urged that the
impugned judgment does not suffer from any infirmity
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
warranting interference by this Court in exercise of its
appellate jurisdiction and that the present appeal deserves to
be dismissed
11.
In rebuttal, learned Senior Advocate Mr. R.R. Marshal
submitted that having regard to the peculiar facts and
circumstances of the present case, the impugned order, to the
extent it contains the directions impugned in the present
appeal, deserves to be quashed and set aside. It is submitted
that instead of permitting the proceedings to continue on the
basis of the impugned directions, the matter may be remanded
to the Board with an appropriate direction to ensure that the
election of the Trustees is to be conducted within a reasonable
time and strictly in accordance with the applicable bye-laws
and the provisions of the Act. It is submitted that such course
would adequately safeguard the interest of the Wakf and
would also ensure that its administration is conducted in
accordance with law.
12.
Having considered the submissions advanced by the
learned advocates for the respective parties and having
carefully gone through the record of the learned Tribunal, it
emerges that numerous complaints were made with regard to
the functioning and administration of the Waqf including
allegations of mismanagement of the Waqf properties and
misappropriation of Waqf funds.
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
13.
It
also
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
emerges
from
the
record
that
numerous
complaints were made against the Trust before the Waqf
Board from time to time. Complaints were also addressed to
the Hon'ble Chief Minister, raising grievances with regard to
the functioning and administration of the Waqf and alleging
inaction on the part of the Wakf Board despite receipt of such
complaints. It further emerges from the record that, on the
basis of a complaint made by one Salim Yusuf Surya, the Waqf
Board had initiated proceedings against the appellant and
passed an order in that regard. However, the said order came
to be passed without following the procedure prescribed under
Section 71 of the Act and the Rules framed thereunder. The
said order was challenged by the appellant by preferring Waqf
Appeal No. 36 of 2021 before the learned Tribunal. The said
appeal came to be allowed by the learned Tribunal vide order
dated 12.05.2022, holding that the order passed by the Waqf
Board was not in conformity with the procedure prescribed
under the Act. Thus, the record indicates that, on an earlier
occasion also, the proceedings initiated by the Waqf Board in
relation to the affairs of the Waqf were set aside on account of
non-compliance with the statutory procedure. At the same
time, the aforesaid circumstances, by itself, cannot dispense
with the requirement of following the procedure prescribed by
law. The question that arises for consideration in the present
appeal
is
whether,
notwithstanding
the
aforesaid
circumstances and the alleged inaction on the part of the Waqf
Board, the learned Tribunal was justified in issuing the
impugned directions and whether such directions fall within
the jurisdiction conferred upon the Tribunal under the Act.
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
14.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
It also emerges from the record that the order passed by
the Wakf Board pursuant to the complaints made by the
respondent nos.2 to 9 came to be challenged before the
learned Tribunal, inter alia, on the ground that the Waqf Board
had failed to follow the procedure prescribed under Section 71
of the Act and the Rules framed thereunder and had not
conducted the inquiry in the manner prescribed by law. The
aforesaid circumstances prima facie indicate that either the
Waqf Board has failed to adhere to the statutory procedure
while conducting inquiries under the Act or that the Board has
otherwise not been functioning in accordance with the powers
and procedure prescribed by the Act. So far as the former
possibility is concerned, once the order impugned in Waqf
Appeal No. 36 of 2021 came to be set aside on the ground of
non-compliance with the procedure prescribed under the Act, it
would be difficult to accept that the procedure required to be
followed while conducting an inquiry under the Act was
thereafter unknown to the Waqf Board. In the facts and
circumstances of the present case, therefore, a prima facie
inference can be drawn that the Waqf Board has failed to
discharge its statutory functions in accordance with the
provisions of the Act. The record prima facie reflects that the
Waqf Board has failed to properly exercise the powers vested
in it under Section 32 and other relevant provisions of the Act
and has not discharged the statutory duties and obligations
entrusted to it by the Legislature.
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
15.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
At this stage, it is required to be borne in mind that the
Waqf Board is a statutory authority entrusted with the duty of
proper supervision, administration and protection of Waqf
properties. When the material on record prima facie indicates
repeated non-compliance of the statutory procedure and
failure to take appropriate action despite complaints of
maladministration and mismanagement of the Waqf, the
learned Tribunal bonafidely issued directions with a view to
safeguarding the interests of the Waqf and its properties and
passed the following orders:“
The order dated 26.05.2026 passed by the Chief Executive
Officer, Gujarat State Waqf Board, Gandhinagar, whereby
Mr. Hussainbhai Dal was appointed as the Election Officer
and Mr. Arifbhai Rathod (Mir) was appointed as the
Assistant Election Officer for the smooth administration of
B-100/Junagadh, Suryawad Memon Jamaat Trust, is hereby
declared illegal and is accordingly quashed and set aside.
Consequently, all proceedings undertaken pursuant to or
in furtherance of the said order dated 26.05.2026 shall
also stand quashed and set aside.
The Gujarat State Waqf Board, Gandhinagar, is hereby
directed to forthwith undertake an inquiry into the alleged
financial irregularities by taking possession of all books of
accounts relating to the income and expenditure, along
with the audit reports of the Porbandar Suryawad Memon
Jamaat Trust in accordance with the provisions of the Wakf
Act, 1995. The inquiry shall be undertaken in light of the
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
written complaints submitted by the stakeholders of
Porbandar Suryawad Memon Jamaat viz. (1) Salim Yusuf
Surya, (2) Afzal Yusuf Afini, (3) Yasin Junaid Aghadi, (4)
Mohammad Shafi Gulamhussain Bera and (5) Farooq
Nurmohammad Baghad. The aforesaid books of accounts,
records and audit reports shall be produced before the
panel Chartered Accountant/Government Auditor of the
Gujarat State Wakf Board for examination and audit and
the entire exercise shall be completed within a period of
30 days from the date of the order.
The Gujarat State Wakf Board, Gandhinagar, is hereby
directed to forthwith lodge a criminal complaint before the
competent police authority against the defendant and
such other persons as may be found responsible in respect
of the allegations of financial embezzlement and other
irregularities in the affairs of the Trust, as raised in the
complaints submitted before the Wakf Board.
The Chief Executive Officer of the Gujarat State Waqf
Board is hereby directed to forthwith lodge a complaint
before the competent police authority against the persons
found responsible, in accordance with law in respect of the
allegations concerning financial irregularities in the affairs
of the Porbandar Suryawad Memon Jamaat Trust.
The Gujarat State Wakf Board, Gandhinagar, is hereby
directed to place the entire matter before the Board for
consideration in accordance with law, having regard to the
fact that the disputants in the present proceedings and (1)
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
Taufiq Abdul Sattar Hamdani, (2) Abdul Jabar Mohammad
Punjani, (3) Abdul Habib Abdul Gani Chitalwala, (4) Altaf
Ali Mohammad Sakrani, (5) Ibrahim Ahmed Punjani and (6)
Yunus
Siddique
Chitalwala
were
not
unanimously
appointed as successor trustees by all the members of the
Porbandar Suryawad Memon Jamaat in the Aam Sabha and
that the tenure of the existing trustees had expired in the
year 1996. The Gujarat State Wakf Board shall, after
considering the matter and passing an appropriate order,
take
necessary
steps
for
appointment
of
successor
trustees of the Porbandar Suryawad Memon Jamaat in
accordance with the constitution/bye-laws of the Wakf.
Such appointment shall be completed within a period of 60
days from the date of the order and shall be in conformity
with the relevant provision of the constitution of the Wakf,
which provides that the members of the Porbandar
Suryawad Memon Jamaat shall meet every year and
conduct elections and that the Managing Committee shall
appoint a Secretary. Upon completion of the aforesaid
process, the names and particulars of the duly appointed
successor trustees shall be recorded in the Wakf Register
in accordance with Section 42 of the Wakf Act, 1995.
It is alleged that the disputants in the present proceedings
and (1) Taufiq Abdul Sattar Hamdani (2) Abdul Jabar
Mohammad
Punjani,
(3)
Abdul
Habib
Abdul
Gani
Chitalwala, (4) Altaf Ali Mohammad Sakrani (5) Ibrahim
Ahmed Punjani and (6) Yunus Siddique Chitalwala have
been in unauthorised occupation and possession of the
properties of the Porbandar Suryawad Memon Jamaat
Wakf for several years and that, despite such allegations,
no effective action has been taken by the Gujarat State
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
Wakf Board, Gandhinagar against the aforesaid persons. In
the interest of proper administration and protection of the
Wakf
properties,
the
Gujarat
State
Wakf
Board,
Gandhinagar is hereby directed to appoint, forthwith, an
Administrator in accordance with the provisions of Section
38 of the Wakf Act, 1995 for the administration and
management of the Porbandar Suryawad Memon Jamaat
Wakf. The Administrator so appointed shall administer and
manage the affairs of the Wakf in accordance with law
until the appointment of successor trustees is duly
completed by the Gujarat State Wakf Board, Gandhinagar.
The
disputant
in
the
present
proceedings,
namely,
Mohammad Yusuf Mohammad Punjani is hereby directed
to hand over and submit to the Gujarat State Wakf Board,
Gandhinagar within a period of seven days from the date
of the order, all books of accounts, audit reports and other
records relating to the income and expenditure of the
Porbandar Suryawad Memon Jamaat Wakf for the period
from the year 1993 up to 23.07.2026. He shall also
peacefully hand over possession of all movable and
immovable properties of the Wakf to the Chief Executive
Officer, Gujarat State Wakf Board, Gandhinagar. In the
event of failure to comply with the aforesaid directions,
the Gujarat State Wakf Board, Gandhinagar shall take
appropriate action in accordance with law against the
disputant and (1) Taufiq Abdul Sattar Hamdani, (2) Abdul
Jabar Mohammad Punjani, (3) Abdul Habib Abdul Gani
Chitalwala, (4) Altaf Ali Mohammad Sakrani, (5) Ibrahim
Ahmed Punjani and (6) Yunus Siddique Chitalwala, as may
be permissible under the provisions of the Wakf Act, 1995
for ensuring the proper administration and management
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
of the Wakf.
A certified copy of this order shall be forthwith forwarded
to the Gujarat State Wakf Board, Gandhinagar, for
information and necessary action in accordance with law.”
16.
The directions issued by the learned Tribunal, at the first
blush, may appear to have been issued in the interest of the
Trust and with a view to ensuring proper administration and
management of the Trust, its properties and accounts.
However, while considering the legality and sustainability of
such directions, this Court cannot lose sight of the fundamental
principle that the learned Tribunal is a creature of the statute
and derives its jurisdiction and powers therefrom. It is,
therefore, required to act strictly within the four corners of the
Act and cannot assume unto itself powers which have not been
conferred upon it by the Legislature. The jurisdiction vested in
the learned Tribunal is essentially adjudicatory in nature. It is
not a supervisory authority over the Waqf Board nor has the
Act conferred upon it any general power of superintendence
over the functioning of the Waqf Board or its statutory
authorities.
The
supervisory
and
administrative
powers
contemplated under the Act are vested in the Waqf Board,
whereas the learned Tribunal is required to exercise the
jurisdiction specifically conferred upon it by the statute.
Consequently, however well-intentioned a direction may be,
the same cannot be sustained merely on the ground that it is
intended to secure proper administration of the Waqf, if such
direction travels beyond the statutory jurisdiction vested in the
learned Tribunal.
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
17.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to the
judgment relied upon by the learned advocate appearing for
respondent Nos.1 and 2 rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the case of Board of Wakf, West Bengal & Anr. (supra). In
paragraph 10 of the said judgment, the Hon’ble Apex Court has
observed as under:
“10. Thus, the Wakf Tribunal can decide all disputes,
questions or other matters relating to a wakf or wakf
property. The words “any dispute, question or other
matters relating to a wakf or wakf property” are, in our
opinion, words of very wide connotation. Any dispute,
question or other matters whatsoever and in whatever
manner which arises relating to a wakf or wakf property
can be decided by the Wakf Tribunal. The word “wakf” has
been defined in Section 3(r) of the Wakf Act, 1995 and
hence once the property is found to be a wakf property as
defined in Section 3(r), then any dispute, question or other
matter relating to it should be agitated before the Wakf
Tribunal.”
18.
In the aforesaid case, the dispute before the Hon’ble
Apex Court primarily concerned the rights and interests in
respect of Waqf property and the jurisdiction of the Waqf
Tribunal in relation thereto. The controversy in the present
case, however, stands on an entirely different footing. The
principal issue before this Court is not merely with regard to
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
any right, title or interest in Waqf property, but concerns the
administration and management of the Waqf and more
particularly, the extent of the statutory jurisdiction and powers
exercisable by the learned Tribunal vis-à-vis the Waqf Board.
The decision relied upon by learned advocate for respondent
Nos.1 and 2, therefore, cannot be read as conferring upon the
learned Tribunal a general or supervisory jurisdiction over the
functioning of the Wakf Board nor can the observations made
therein be construed as authorizing the Tribunal to issue
directions in exercise of powers not otherwise vested in it by
the Act. The factual and legal matrix in the present case being
materially distinguishable the ratio laid down in the said
decision would not govern the controversy involved herein or
sustain the impugned directions issued by the learned
Tribunal.
19.
Learned Senior Advocate Mr. R.R. Marshal has placed
reliance upon the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of M.P. Wakf Board (supra). In paragraph
28 of the said judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
observed as under:
“28. The Tribunal had been constituted for the purposes
mentioned in Section 83 of the 1995 Act. It is an
adjudicatory body. Its decision is final and binding but then
it could not usurp the jurisdiction of the Board. Our
attention has not been drawn to any provision which
empowers the Tribunal to frame a scheme. In absence of
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
any power vested in the Tribunal, the Tribunal ought to
have left the said function to the Board which is statutorily
empowered therefor. Where a statute creates different
authorities
to
exercise
their
respective
functions
thereunder, each of such authority must exercise the
functions within the four corners of the statute.”
20.
Further,
the
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
in
the
case
S.V.Cheriyakoya Thangal (supra) has observed as under:-
“
Though arguments have been made at length, we are
inclined to hold that the impugned order cannot be
sustained in the eyes of law as the Waqf Board has rightly
exercised the jurisdiction in exercise of power conferred
under Section 32(2)(g) read with the definition under
Section 3(i) which defines a ‘Mutawalli’.We have also
perused Section 83 sub- Sections (5) and (7) of the Act
which deals with the powers of the Tribunal. The Waqf
Tribunal is deemed to be a civil court having the same
powers that can be exercised by the civil court under the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. In other words, a dispute
can be tried like a suit by the Waqf Tribunal. Under subsection (7) of Section 83 of the Waqf Act, the decision of
the Tribunal shall be final and binding upon the parties
and it shall have force of a decree made by a civil court.
The word ‘competent authority’ as mentioned in the
definition clause contained in Section 3(i) makes the
position further clear that it is the Waqf Board which has
got the jurisdiction and not the Waqf Tribunal. After all,
of
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
the Waqf Tribunal is only an adjudicating authority over a
dispute while the Waqf Board is expected to deal with any
issue
pertaining
to
administration.
The
power
of
superintendence cannot be confined to routine affairs of a
Waqf but it includes a situation where a dispute arises
while managing the property and that would certainly
include a right of a person to be a Mutawalli after all, it is
the Mutawalli who does the job of administering and
managing the Waqf.
In such view of the matter, we are of the view that
the impugned order cannot be sustained in relegating the
matter to an adjudicating authority by treating it as a
competent authority, which is none other than the Waqf
Board.”
21.
Thus, in view of the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of M.P. Wakf Board (supra) and S.V.
Cheriyakoya
Thangal
(supra),
emerges
that
Waqf
is
the
the
legal
position
that
Tribunal
is
essentially
an
adjudicatory forum and not a supervisory authority. The
jurisdiction of the learned Tribunal is circumscribed by the
provisions of the Act and it is required to act within the four
corners thereof. It is a settled principle of law that where
jurisdiction is conferred upon an authority under a special
statute subject to the fulfillment of certain conditions, such
conditions must necessarily be complied with for the valid
exercise of such jurisdiction; in the absence of compliance with
the statutory conditions, the jurisdiction does not arise. The
statutory scheme of the Act makes it abundantly clear that the
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
primary
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
power
and
responsibility
for
the
management,
administration and control of the affairs of a Waqf are vested in
the Waqf Board. The Waqf Board is empowered to take
appropriate measures for remedying mismanagement and
maladministration and, where warranted in accordance with
law, to issue appropriate directions, including orders of
supersession. The Act further empowers the Waqf Board to
issue such directions as may be necessary for the proper,
effective and smooth administration of the Waqf. In particular,
Sections 32 and 67 of the Act deal with the powers of the Waqf
Board in relation to the administration, management and
control of Waqfs. Section 70 of the Act specifically empowers
the Waqf Board to conduct an inquiry into the administration of
a Waqf. Where a complaint is received
regarding
the
administration of a Waqf, the Waqf Board may initiate an
inquiry and, upon being satisfied that there are reasonable
grounds for believing that the affairs of the Waqf are being
mismanaged, may take such action as it deems appropriate in
accordance with the provisions of the Act. Thus, the statutory
scheme
itself
adjudicatory
draws
jurisdiction
a
clear
of
the
distinction
Waqf
between
Tribunal
and
the
the
supervisory, administrative and regulatory powers vested in
the Waqf Board. The learned Tribunal, while exercising its
jurisdiction under Section 83 of the Act, cannot assume to itself
the powers which the Legislature has specifically entrusted to
the Waqf Board.
22.
In the present case, it emerges from the record that,
despite the provisions contained in the bye-laws of the Wakf
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
requiring elections to the office of Trustees to be conducted
every year, no such elections have been conducted since the
year 1996. It further emerges that numerous complaints were
submitted to the Waqf Board by respondent Nos.5 to 9 herein
as well as by other independent persons concerning the
administration and management of the Waqf; however, the
Waqf Board has not taken effective steps in respect thereof. It
also emerges from the record that, on an earlier occasion,
when an inquiry was undertaken by the Waqf Board, the same
was conducted without following the procedure prescribed
under the Act and the Rules framed thereunder. The aforesaid
circumstances do not present a satisfactory picture with regard
to the functioning of the Waqf Board. The material on record
prima facie indicates that the Waqf Board has not discharged
its statutory functions in the manner contemplated by the Act,
particularly
in
relation
to
the
proper
administration,
management and protection of the Waqf and its properties. At
the same time, the aforesaid lapses on the part of the Waqf
Board cannot, by themselves, confer upon the learned Tribunal
a jurisdiction which is otherwise not vested in it by the statute.
The failure of a statutory authority to discharge its duties in
accordance with law cannot be a ground for another statutory
authority to assume powers which have not been conferred
upon it. The remedy for such failure must necessarily be
worked out within the statutory framework. This Court,
therefore, expects and trusts that the Waqf Board shall
henceforth discharge its statutory functions with due diligence
and strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Act and
the Rules framed thereunder. The Waqf Board shall take
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
appropriate and timely steps, in accordance with law, for
ensuring proper administration, management and protection of
the Waqf and its properties and shall consider the complaints
placed before it in accordance with the procedure prescribed
by law. The Board is expected to discharge the statutory and
pious duty entrusted to it under the Act in its true letter and
spirit.
23.
Now, turning to the impugned judgment and order, there
can be no doubt that the directions issued by the learned
Tribunal appear to have been intended for the benefit and
proper administration of the Waqf. However, as discussed
herein above, the jurisdiction of the learned Tribunal is
essentially adjudicatory in nature and not supervisory. The
learned Tribunal, while exercising its adjudicatory jurisdiction,
could not have assumed the supervisory and administrative
powers specifically vested in the Waqf Board under the Act. In
view of the aforesaid discussion and having regard to the facts
and
circumstances
of
the
present
case,
the
impugned
judgment and order, to the extent it travels beyond the
adjudicatory jurisdiction of the learned Tribunal and issues
directions falling within the supervisory and administrative
domain of the Waqf Board, cannot be sustained in law. The
same is, therefore, liable to be quashed and set aside to that
extent.
24.
Accordingly, the matter is remanded to the Gujarat State
Waqf Board, Gandhinagar with a direction to undertake and
C/FA/3494/2026
(GJHC240576362026)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 13/10/2026
complete the requisite proceedings in accordance with law
within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order. The learned Waqf Board shall conduct an
inquiry into the complaints received by it strictly in accordance
with the procedure prescribed under the Waqf Act, 1995 and
the Rules framed thereunder, after affording due opportunity
to all concerned persons. The Waqf Board shall thereafter take
such consequential and appropriate action, as may be
permissible under the Act including such steps as are
necessary for the proper administration, management and
protection of the Waqf, its properties and accounts. The entire
exercise
shall
be
undertaken
expeditiously,
strictly
in
accordance with law and without being influenced by any
observations made by this Court. The present appeal stands
allowed. Rule is made absolute to the aforesaid extent. Record
and proceedings be sent back to the concerned Court
forthwith. No order as to costs.
25.
In view of the order passed main appeal, the connected
applications
does
not
survive
and
stands
disposed
of,
accordingly.
(MOOL CHAND TYAGI, J)
GIRISH
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review