Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (WA) No.5/2022
Date of Order: 08.03.2022
Mofiqul Islam & ors
Coram:
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant (s)
For the Respondent (s)
: Mr. SA Sheikh, Adv with
Mr. SK Hassan, Adv
: Mr. A Kumar, Advocate General with
Ms. R Colney, GA
Ms. S Laloo, GA
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The short question raised in this appeal, arising out of the rejection
of a writ petition filed by the appellants herein, is as to whether the writ
petitioners fall within the purview of clause 1(c) of the directions contained
in a Division Bench order of this Court of November 2, 2017.
2.
There is no dispute that the appellant-writ petitioners participated
in a selection process initiated under an advertisement issued on December
10, 2008 by the Deputy Inspector of Schools pursuant to a notification of
November 24, 2008. At five of the centres at which the recruitment
examination was conducted – Shillong Sadar, Jowai, Amlarem, Tura and
Dadenggre – widespread irregularities were reported which resulted in this
Court directing an inquiry into the matter by the Central Bureau of
Investigation. Though it was discovered that mass irregularities did take
place, in the appellate order of November 2, 2017, certain directions were
issued for stop-gap measures and for a fresh selection process to be
conducted.
3.
The principal directions which are relevant for the present purpose
are contained in the several sub-clauses of clause 1 of the order dated
November 2, 2017:
“1. (a) The whole of selection process under the advertisement
dated 10.12.2008, as issued by the Deputy Inspector of Schools in
pursuance of Notification dated 24.11.2008, is held vitiated in
relation to Shillong Sadar, Jowai, Amlarem, Tura and Dadengre
Centres; and is annulled subject to the proviso that only the
candidates who have been treated as untainted/unblemished both
in the reports of CBI and HLSC and are in service, may be allowed
to continue as stop-gap arrangement until fresh selection takes
place.
(b) The prayer of other untainted/unblemished candidates of the
said five Centres for induction in service stands rejected.
(c) However, all the untainted/unblemished candidates of the said
five Centres, whether in service or not, shall be allowed to
participate in the fresh selection process, if otherwise eligible in
accordance with the presently applicable Rules/Guidelines,
without necessity of their applying afresh. In this regard it is also
provided that none of such untainted/unblemished candidates shall
be treated as age-barred if he/she was within the age prescribed by
the notification dated 24.11.2008.
(d) None of the candidates who has been found tainted/blemished,
whether in the report of CBI or in the report of HLSC or both as
also none of the candidates who had been recommended by the
public representative shall be taken or retained in service even in
stop-gap arrangement and the service of every such candidate, who
is yet continuing, whether by way of regular appointment or in ad
hoc arrangement, shall stand terminated with immediate effect.”
4.
The appellants herein had participated in the selection process but
had not been selected. As such, the appellants do not fall under clause 1(a) of
the said appellate order. Clause 1(c) of the relevant order permitted “all the
untainted/unblemished candidates of the said five Centres, whether in service
or not ... to participate in the fresh selection process, if otherwise eligible in
accordance with the presently Rules/Guidelines, without necessity of their
applying afresh.”
5.
The relevant sub-clause went on to clarify that the unsuccessful
but unblemished and untainted candidates at the five centres would be
considered in course of the fresh selection process irrespective of whether
such candidates, at the time of the selection, were age-barred.
6.
As is evident from the relevant direction, the unsuccessful but
untainted and unblemished candidates at the five centres were not even
required to apply afresh; as per the relevant direction, their candidatures
would automatically have to be considered. The only caveat to the relevant
direction was that such unsuccessful but untainted and unblemished
candidates at the relevant five centres had to have the requisite qualifications
to be offered the appointment and the qualifications would be reckoned as on
the date of the judgment. It may be observed, in this context, that it was open
to the appellate court to allow all the candidates who were qualified to
participate in the 2008 selection process to be eligible for consideration in the
fresh selection process; but the Division Bench consciously shrunk the
number of candidates who would be eligible to be considered for the fresh
selection process by using of the words “if otherwise eligible in course with
the presently applicable Rules/Guidelines ...” In other words, if the essential
qualifications for the post stood altered between 2008 and 2017, it would be
the altered qualifications relevant in 2017 which would be the benchmark
and not the extant qualifications of 2008.
7.
In the impugned order dated December 16, 2021 the reasoning
furnished for rejecting the writ petition is found at paragraph 7 thereof:
“7. From the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners
and from the pleadings in the petition itself, it is undisputed that
the petitioners were unsuccessful in the initial selection process
and their names did not figure in any select list. The directions of
this Court in the Division Bench on perusal, has clearly directed
that untainted/unblemished candidates of the said five Centres
whether in service or not, shall be allowed to participate in the
fresh selection process. Purport of this direction in the considered
view of this Court is to afford opportunity to those candidates who
lost their employment opportunity on being selected due to the
illegalities which were detected in the earlier selection process for
which if otherwise, they would have been in employment today. It
is perhaps in this backdrop that the Division Bench had allowed
such candidates to tender fresh candidature notwithstanding the
prescribed age limit if they were within the age limit on the date of
the selection held on 24-11-2008.”
8.
It is the third sentence of the relevant paragraph which appears not
to be in consonance with the appellate order of November 2, 2017,
particularly the directions contained in clause 1(c) thereof. The directions
contained in the relevant appellate order cannot be understood to have
afforded an opportunity only to those candidates who lost their posts despite
being selected. Clause 1(a) is confined to those who were selected and were
found to be untainted and unblemished. However, clause 1(c) is explicit in
the use of the expression “all the untainted/unblemished candidates of the
said five Centres, whether in service or not ...” Such persons, who fall within
the purview of such quoted expression, had been allowed to participate in the
fresh selection process, subject to such persons being eligible for
consideration in accordance with the rules and guidelines applicable at the
time of the delivery of the judgment in 2017.
9.
Thus, if the appellant-writ petitioners had participated in the
recruitment process of 2008 and had been candidates at any of the said five
centres and had also been found to be untainted and unblemished,
irrespective of whether they were successful or were not, they would be
entitled to be considered in course of the fresh selection; but subject to
meeting the eligibility criteria in vogue in 2017.
10.
Accordingly, the judgment and order impugned dated December
16, 2021 cannot be sustained and the same is set aside. WP(C) No. 434 of
2021 is allowed with the observation that the writ petitioners, who are the
appellants herein, will be liable to be considered in course of the fresh
selection process to be held in terms of the order dated November 2, 2017 as
long as such writ petitioners meet the eligibility criteria which were relevant
as on November 2, 2017, irrespective of whether they may fall short of the
eligibility criteria as of now or as on the date when the fresh selection
process commences. It is also made clear that in view of clause 1(c) of the
order dated November 2, 2017, the age-disqualification will not apply to the
writ petitioners.
11.
It is recorded that the State has not disputed that the writ
petitioners had participated in the 2008 selection process; that each of them
were candidates at one of the five relevant centres; that the writ petitioners
were unsuccessful and had not been selected for appointment in the 2008
process; and, that the writ petitioners were found to be untainted and
unblemished in the sense that they were not found to have indulged in the
irregularities at any of the said five centres that resulted in the selection
process being annulled.
12.
WA No.5 of 2022 is allowed as above. There will, however be no
order as to costs.
13.
MC (WA) No.5 of 2022 is disposed of.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
08.03.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review