Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 09.04.2026
Judgment delivered on: 22.04.2026
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
MODI WOODSPACE PRIVATE LIMITED
.....Appellant
versus
THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS
.....Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Appellant :
Mr. Rohan Rohatgi and Ms. Muthu Praba,
Advocates.
For the Respondents :
Mr. Gaurav Barathi, SPC with Mr. Chirantan
Priyadarshan, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TUSHAR RAO GEDELA
JUDGMENT
TUSHAR RAO GEDELA, J.
1.
Present appeal has been filed under Section 91 of the Trade Marks
Act, 1999, challenging the impugned order dated 21.05.2025 passed by the
respondent/the Registrar of Trade Marks, in application no.6087367 filed
by the appellant.
2.
Shorn off all unnecessary details, the facts germane to the present
dispute, are as under:
a. The appellant filed a trademark application no.6087367 for the
mark KAMA CASA (word) in Classes 20 and 35 on a
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
‘Proposed to be used basis’ on 29.08.2023. Subsequently, vide
the examination report dated 19.10.2023, the Trade Marks
Registry raised objections under Section 11(a) of the
Trademarks Act, 1999 (hereinafter referred to as the “the
Act”). Pursuant thereto, the appellant filed its response dated
27.10.2023 to the Examination Report issued by the
respondent.
b. On 24.07.2024, the first hearing notice was served upon the
appellant scheduling the date of hearing on 01.10.2024, to
which the appellant filed an application under Form TM-M
seeking extension of time, which was allowed. Similarly,
various other hearing notices were served, however, the
hearing was adjourned for some reason or the other.
c. Finally, by the fourth hearing notice dated 04.03.2025, the
hearing was scheduled on 15.04.2025. The counsel for the
appellant had appeared on 15.04.2025 and addressed
arguments. Vide the impugned order dated 21.05.2025, the
respondent recorded its refusal of the trademark application
filed by the appellant.
d. The present appeal has been filed against the said impugned
order.
3.
In order to make good his submissions, Mr. Rohan Rohatgi, learned
counsel for the appellant contended that the fundamental flaw committed
by the Registrar lies in comparing the composite mark “KAMA CASA” of
the appellant with two separate and distinct registered marks “KAMA” on
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
the one hand and “CASA” on the other. He also submitted that the
appellant had applied for the wordmark “KAMA CASA”, whereas the two
cited marks “KAMA” and “CASA” are both device/label marks. He stated
that there is no principle of law which permits the comparison of two
distinct device marks with one composite wordmark to refuse registration
of the wordmark.
4.
Even otherwise, learned counsel would submit that the device marks
are to be considered as a composite mark and, to that extent, cannot be
made the basis for refusal of registration of the composite wordmark
“KAMA CASA”. He stated that a mere visual inspection would clearly
show the distinction between both sets of marks.
5.
That apart, he relied upon the written submissions dated 03.02.2026
filed by the appellant in support of the contentions raised in the present
appeal. Alongwith the said written submissions, learned counsel placed on
record a search report of the Trademark Registry running into 19 number of
pages. While referring to the said search report, learned counsel
emphasized that there are numerous registrations containing the word
“CASA” in the same or similar Classes which already stand registered with
the Registrar of Trade Marks. He would stoutly contend that in case other
marks containing the word “CASA” have already been registered, there is
no impediment or rational basis for refusing registration of the wordmark
“KAMA CASA”. He fairly admitted that the said search report was not
placed before the Registrar for his consideration and has been filed along
with the written submission in support of the present appeal.
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
6.
He also relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Registrar
of Trademarks vs. Ashok Chandra Rakhit Ltd., reported in AIR 1955 SC
558 and judgment dated 28.02.2023 of this Court in Ticona Polymers Inc.
vs. Registrar of Trademarks: Neutral Citation no.2023/DHC/001489, in
support of the proposition that a mark cannot be dissected into its
individual parts while examining its entitlement to registration. He also
relied upon the judgment of this Court in CA(COMM.IPD-TM) 121/2021
titled “Grey Matters Educational Trust vs. Examiner of Trademarks”
decided on 21.04.2024 and the judgment of the Supreme Court in Pernod
Recard India P Ltd vs. Karanveer Singh Chhabra reported in 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1701, particularly paragraphs 42, 43, 44, 50, 51 and 52.
7.
Mr. Gaurav Barathi, learned SPC opposed the contentions addressed
on behalf of the appellant. By inviting attention to the written submissions
filed on behalf of the respondent, learned SPC contended that even if the
words “KAMA” and “CASA” have been separately registered as device
marks, it would be relevant to note that both the cited marks and that of the
appellant are in the same Class. He would also contend that a mere visual
inspection would bring to fore the similarity which would clearly cause
deception or confusion in the minds of traders as also consumers. By
referring to Section 11 of the Act, learned counsel would state that the
relative grounds for refusal clearly stipulate that if there are marks which
are already registered, then any subsequent mark seeking registration, if is
similar, in its identity with an earlier mark and similarity of goods or
services covered by the applied mark or is identical or similar to an earlier
registered mark, the subsequent mark, must necessarily be refused
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
registration. He relies upon the judgment of this Court in Rajkumar
Sharma vs. Sandeep Kumar & Anr., Neutral Citation: 2023/DHC/000647
and the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Mohammad Talha
vs. M/s Karim Hotels Pvt. Ltd., Neutral Citation: 2025:DHC:9713-DB.
8.
This Court has heard the arguments of Mr. Rohan Rohatgi for the
appellant as also Mr. Gaurav Barathi, learned SPC for the respondent and
perused the records of the case.
9.
In order to appreciate the merits, it would be apposite to first
consider the reasons for refusal recorded in the impugned order. The same
reads thus:
“Above application has been filed for registration of the trademark
KAMA CASA on 29/08/2023 which was examined on 19/10/2023 and
examination report was communicated to the applicant at his address for
service. A reply to the office objection(s) had been filed on behalf of the
applicant but the same was not found satisfactory and the application
was set down for hearing and eventually hearing took place before me on
15/04/2025.
Drishya Saini Attorney appeared before me and made his/her
submissions. I have heard arguments and gone through the records.
The mark applied for registration is identical with /similar to
earlier trademarks on record, as mentioned in the Examination report
and by similarity of marks as well as similarity of goods and services
covered under such marks, there exists a likelihood of confusion in the
mind of public. As such the registration of the mark is objectionable
under Section 11(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1999
Adv. Drishya Saini Appeared on behalf of the Applicant.
Submission Heard against Section 11 (1) of Trade Marks Act, 1999.
Similar valid marks with similar classification of goods vide
application no. 3954013 (KAMA), 4969425, 4988481 (CASA) are
already on Record. Present mark is deceptively similar to the cited
marks. It is phonetically, visually and structurally similar to the prior
marks already existing on the register.
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
The Applied mark contains the terms “KAMA” and “CASA”, both
of which already present in earlier marks registered under class 20. The
Adoption of the combined form “KAMA CASA” is likely to cause
confusion or deception among the public and trader as to the source of
origin of the goods.
The composite nature of the marks does not sufficiently
differentiate if from the cited prior marks in terms of overall commercial
impression.
The Present Application is filed on Proposed to be used basis
whereas the The cited marks have been in Use Since the year 2018, 2013
and 2007 Respectively.
Hence, The objection under Section 11 (1) of The Trade Marks Act,
1999 cannot be waived.
Accordingly The Present Trademark application is refused under
provision of Section 11 (1) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
After perusal of all the documents on record and submission made
by the applicant / authorised agent, it is concluded that applied mark is
not registrable because of the reason stated as above. Hence application
no 6087367 cannot be accepted and refused accordingly.”
10.
It is apparent that the Registrar has invoked the provisions of Section
11(1) of the Act, which set out relative grounds for refusal of registration.
The Registrar appears to have refused the trademark application predicated
on the fact that the mark applied for contains the terms “KAMA” and
“CASA” both of which were present in earlier marks registered under Class
20. Thus, on that basis the Registrar held that the adoption of the combined
form “KAMA CASA”, is likely to cause confusion or deception among
public and traders as to the source of origin of the goods. It was further
noted that the composite nature of the mark does not sufficiently
differentiate it from the cited prior marks in terms of overall commercial
impression. Lastly, it was held that while on the one hand, the application
of the appellant was on a “proposed to be used basis”, the cited marks had
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
already been in use since the years 2018, 2013 and 2007, respectively.
Predicated thereon, the Registrar passed the impugned order.
11.
It is clear that it was incumbent upon the Registrar to have
considered the mark of the appellant as a whole and not by breaking it into
two separate and distinct parts. In other words, the mark of the appellant
“KAMA CASA”, which is a word mark, ought to have been considered as
a composite mark and not broken into “KAMA” and “CASA”. In case such
dissection is permitted, it would lead to anomalous and incongruous results.
Such dissection is also impermissible under the Anti Dissection Rule,
which applies to the registration of trademarks etc., in that a mark, for the
purposes of registration, has to be considered as a composite mark and
cannot be compared with two separate marks which may have been
registered earlier, to refuse registration under Section 11(1) of the Act. This
would be very anti thesis to the prudence of registration.
12.
A Coordinate Bench of this Court in Grey Matter Educational Trust
(supra) held that when the cited marks are viewed as a whole and
compared, the same cannot be said to be similar or deceptively similar to
the mark of the appellant. The Court also held that the Anti Dissection Rule
is a well-established principle of trademark law that requires trademarks to
be viewed as a whole rather than being broken down into their individual
components.
13.
At this stage, it would be relevant to examine the visual comparison
between the two sets of marks which led the Registrar to pass the impugned
order. The same is extracted hereunder:
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
Appellant’s Mark
Cited Marks
KAMA CASA
14.
Two things emerge from the aforesaid comparison. First, that the
appellant’s mark is a wordmark, whereas the cited marks are device marks;
and second, the cited marks, being device marks, cannot be dissected to
perceive only the words “KAMA” and “CASA” without the device element
placed upon each such device mark. Having regard to the aforesaid two
distinctions, it is unfathomable as to how and on what basis, the Registrar
compared the composite wordmark “KAMA CASA” of the appellant with
two or three cited device marks containing words “KAMA” and “CASA”
separately, each with its own distinctive device elements. Even if the Class
is common, there is no similarity or deceptive similarity between the two
sets of marks.
15.
Apart from the above, this Court has also perused the search report
placed on record by the appellant along with its written submissions in
respect of the word “CASA”. This Court finds that in the same or similar
Classes as that of the appellant, there are numerous trademarks containing
the word “CASA” and yet were proceeded with and registered. It was fairly
pointed out by the learned counsel for the appellant, that the search report
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
was not placed before the Registrar while the application of the appellant
was being processed.
16.
In that view of the matter, it is deemed appropriate to remit the
matter to the Registrar to also take into consideration the search report filed
by the appellant in the present appeal and to pass a fresh order after
considering the Search Report too.
17.
Since this Court is remitting the matter to the Registrar of
Trademarks for de novo consideration of the application bearing
no.6087367 for registration of the mark “KAMA CASA”, the observations
made hereinabove shall not be treated as an expression of opinion on the
merits of the application but a consideration only for the purpose of
remitting the matter.
18.
Thus, as a result, the impugned order dated 21.05.2025 is quashed
and set aside and the application bearing no.6087367 is revived for fresh de
novo consideration by the Registrar in the above terms.
19.
The said de novo consideration shall be completed within four
months from date.
20.
Appeal allowed and disposed of with no orders as to costs.
TUSHAR RAO GEDELA
(JUDGE)
APRIL 22, 2026/anj/rl
Digitally Signed
By:YASHRAJ
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 56/2025
11:25:00
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review