Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No.14
16.09.2026
Court. No. 12
Sandip
MAT 1550 of 2026
With
CAN 1 of 2026
Mithun Biswas
VS
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Mrityunjoy Chatterjee,
Mr. Manas Das,
Mrs. Suchismita Chakraborty
Mr. Baidurya Ghosal
Mr. Robiul Islam,
Mr. Jayed Hossain,
Ms. Asmita Mitra
1.
… for the Appellant.
… for the State.
… for the private Respondent Nos.5 &16.
The appeal arises out of an order dated September 10,
2026 passed in W.P.A. 24535 of 2026.
2. By the order impugned, Her Lordship extended the time
period to convene the meeting for removal of the Pradhan
of Khairamari gram panchayat.
3. The writ petition was moved by the respondent nos. 5 to
16, who were aggrieved by the inaction on the part of the
prescribed authority, in holding the meeting for removal of
the Pradhan, by making repeated cancellations.
4. It appears from the record that members of the said gram
panchayat submitted a no confidence motion seeking
removal of the Pradhan of the said panchayat before the
prescribed authority on August 11, 2026, which was
received by the prescribed authority on the same date.
5. The prescribed authority by a notice dated August 14,
2026, fixed the date of the meeting for removal of Pradhan
on August 25, 2026. Subsequently, by a notice dated
August 24, 2026 the meeting was cancelled due to nonavailability of police assistance.
6. The appellant has challenged a direction of the learned
Single Judge upon the prescribed authority, to convene the
meeting and conclude the proceeding in accordance with
law, beyond the period of 30 days from receipt of the
requisition notice.
7.
The issue as to whether a meeting could be postponed on
the ground of non-availability of police assistance is no
more res integra. We have already held that the said
ground was not one of the exceptions provided under
Section 12(4) of the West Bengal Panchayat Act, 1973,
permitting cancellation of a meeting. We do not find that
the Prescribed Authority had recorded any satisfaction that
the meeting could not be held peacefully and the law and
order situation would go beyond his control, in the event
the meeting was held in the absence of the police.
8. In the regard, the decision of Tafijul Hoque vs
Mobarak Hossain and Ors. decided in MAT 1105
of 2026 reported in 2026:CHC-AS:1396-D is referred
to and the following paragraphs are quoted below:“17. Before we proceed further, it is necessary to
state the provisions of Section 12 of the
Panchayat Act:
“[12. Motion of no confidence or removal of
Pradhan or Upa-Pradhan.] --(1)Subject to other provisions of this
section, the Pradhan or the Upa-Pradhan
of a Gram Panchayat may, at any time, be
removed from his office by the majority of
the existing members of the Gram
Panchayat, referred to in clause (i) of subsection (2A) of section 4, expressing their
lack of confidence against the Pradhan or
the Upa-Pradhan or recording their
decision to remove the Pradhan or the Upa-
Pradhan, at a meeting specially convened
for the purpose.
(2)For the purpose of removal of the
Pradhan or the Upa-Pradhan, one-third of
the existing members referred to in subsection (1) subject to a minimum of three
members shall sign a motion in writing
expressing their lack of confidence against
the Pradhan or the Upa-Pradhan or
recording their intention to remove the
Pradhan or the Upa-Pradhan, indicating
party affiliation or independent status of
each of such members and either deliver
the motion in person through any of the
members or send it by registered post to
the prescribed authority; one copy of the
motion shall be delivered to the concerned
office bearer either by hand or by
registered post at the Gram Panchayat
office and another copy shall be sent by
registered post at his residential address.
(3)The prescribed authority on receipt of
the motion shall satisfy himself that it
conforms to the requirements of subsection (2) and on his satisfaction shall
specially convene, by issue of notice,
within five working days of the receipt of
the motion, a meeting of the Gram
Panchayat to be held in its office fixing
date and hour of the meeting and sending
such notice at least before clear seven
days to each of its existing members for
consideration of the motion and for taking
a decision on it.
(4)The meeting referred to in sub-section (3)
shall be held on a working day which shall
not be later than fifteen working days from
the date of receipt of the motion by the
prescribed authority and the meeting so
convened shall not be adjourned or
cancelled except in pursuance of an order
or direction of a competent court or for any
other reason beyond control of the
prescribed authority.
(5)Such meeting shall be presided over by
an officer, as may be authorized by the
prescribed authority, in the manner as
may be directed by order by the State
Government or as may be prescribed and
the presiding officer before commencement
of the meeting shall ensure that notice has
been duly served to every member in the
manner laid down in this behalf; quorum
required for such meeting shall be more
than fifty percent of the existing members
referred to in sub-section (1) and the
presiding officer shall not be entitled to
vote at the meeting although he may
advise on one or more points of law
without expressing his own views.
(6)If there is no consensus decision in the
meeting, voting shall be held by open
ballot wherein each participating member
shall put his full signature or his left
thumb impression to be attested by the
leader, referred to in section 213A, of the
same political party to which the member
belongs or by the said presiding officer on
the reverse side of the ballot paper.
(7)The minutes of the meeting shall be
written by the Secretary or in his absence,
by any other official as authorized by the
presiding officer. Such minutes shall record
in brief names of the members present, the
procedure followed, names of the members
who voted for or against the motion and
the decision adopted unanimously or by
the majority of its existing members and
shall be signed by him as well as by the
presiding officer
(8)After the minutes of the meeting is
signed by the presiding officer, it shall be
read over to all the attending members
who shall thereafter put their signatures or
left thumb impressions, as the case may
be, on the minutes in confirmation of the
proceedings recorded. Then the presiding
officer shall again put his signature on the
same document after recording the names
of members, if any, who have declined to
sign or left earlier and thereafter he shall
collect a copy of the minutes before leaving
the premises.
(9)(a)The Executive Assistant or in his
absence the Secretary of the Gram
Panchayat shall, within three working
days of the meeting, forward a copy of the
minutes of the meeting to the prescribed
authority.
(b)The presiding officer shall also submit a
separate report in writing along with a
copy of the minutes of the meeting within
the aforesaid time to the prescribed
authority.
(10) On receipt of the minutes of the
meeting and the report under sub-section
(9), the prescribed authority shall, within
next five working days, take such action
as he may deem fit and the entire process
commencing from submission of motion to
the prescribed authority upto the action
finally taken by him shall be completed
within thirty days.
(11)If the motion is not carried by the
majority of its existing members or the
meeting cannot be held for want of
quorum, no notice of any subsequent
motion for the removal of the same office
bearer shall be taken into cognizance
within a period of one year from the date
appointed for such meeting.
(12)Notwithstanding anything contained in
sub-section (1), no meeting for removal of
the Pradhan or the Upa-Pradhan under
this section shall be convened within a
period of one year from the date of election
of the Pradhan or the Upa-Pradhan either
at the first meeting following reconstitution
of Gram Panchayat or for filling casual
vacancy in the said office.]”
18. Section 12[4] of the Panchayat Act has two
parts – the first part clearly mandates a
mandatory time limit for holding a meeting,
which shall not be later than ‘fifteen working
days’ from the date of receipt of the motion by
the Prescribed Authority. We shall discuss in
the succeeding paragraphs, the intention of the
legislature in using the expression ‘shall not be
later than’, in the first part of Section 12[4] of
the Panchayat Act. The latter part of Section
12[4] speaks about two contingencies i.e. the
meeting so convened shall not be either
adjourned or cancelled except [i] in pursuance
of an order or direction of a competent court or
[ii] for any other reason beyond the control of
the Prescribed Authority.
***
***
23. As soon as a notice of motion is issued to
remove a Pradhan, the clock starts ticking,
inasmuch as, on the one hand the sword of
Damocles starts hanging over the Pradhan, who
had been elected democratically and would
naturally want to complete his term, and on the
other hand, the majority members who lost
confidence in the Pradhan for whatever reason,
sign a motion in terms of Section 12[2] of the
Panchayat Act, expressing their lack of
confidence in him and desire to remove him.
Therefore, the fate of the Pradhan is to be tested
in a meeting which is required to be held upon
being convened by the Prescribed Authority. It
is needless to mention here that, those
members who signed the motion /the
requsitionists, having lost confidence in the
Pradhan, also started to fervently wait for their
desired object of removing the Pradhan, who,
according to them, ought to be removed for the
better functioning of the gram panchayat, or for
any other reason.
***
***
25. There is another aspect of the matter. The
people (voters) have not been mentioned in
these provisions, but their rights are also
substantially affected in such circumstances.
Those
residents,
within
the
territorial
jurisdiction of the said Panchayat in respect of
which the motion to remove the Pradhan is
pending, have a right to have a suitable
Pradhan, duly elected under Section 9 of the
Panchayat Act by their elected representatives.
They have a hope that under the Pradhan’s
leadership, the Panchayat will work effectively
and within the framework of the Panchayat Act,
for betterment of the locality.
Once the
members lose confidence in the Pradhan, he
does not have a right to continue in office. All
that remains, is a removal in a meeting usually
by raising of hands. The gram panchayat suffers
in the midst of creation of rival groups. Thus,
the motion has to be tested at the earliest, and
positively within the statutory period prescribed
in this regard.
***
***
40. The issue as to whether the provisions of
Section 12(4) of the Panchayat Act are
mandatory or not is longer res integra. A
Coordinate Bench of this Court [where one of us
was a member] in Pradhan, Nurpur Gram
Panchayat and Another vs. Gobinda Ghosh
and Others reported in 2026 SCC OnLine Cal
8718, had occasioned to deal with an identical
issue. It was, inter alia, held:
8. “It is the democratic right of the
requisitionists to bring a motion of no
confidence against the Pradhan, but
such right has to be exercised in terms
of Section 12(2) of the said Act. The
Prescribed Authority thereafter, has to
act upon compliance of Sections 12(3) to
12(10). In this case, the Prescribed
Authority initially scheduled the meeting
on 12-6-2026 and just a day before the
meeting,
the
Prescribed
Authority
postponed the same for an indefinite
period by citing the reasons beyond his
control. Along with the said notice of
postponement, the e-mail received from
the Inspector-in-Charge of the concerned
Police Station was attached.
9. In our view, if the Prescribed Authority
felt that the situation was beyond his
control and he was not in a position to
hold the meeting, the specific reasons as
to why he was of the view that, without
adequate police force the meeting could
not be held, and whether he was
apprehensive of law and order problems
and/or violence, should have been
reflected in the notice of postponement.
Secondly, there is nothing on record
which would show that the Prescribed
Authority had serious intention of
holding the meeting on any subsequent
date. The time limit prescribed under
Section 12(4) to hold the meeting of no
confidence is 15 working days from the
date of receipt of the notice.
10. Admittedly, the notice of motion was
received on 2-6-2026 and the meeting
was first fixed on 12-6-2026. However,
the Prescribed Authority could have
decided on the date within the time limit
prescribed under Section 12(10), which
provides that the entire process of
issuing notices, holding the meeting and
communicating the result of the meeting
to the appropriate authority has to be
completed within 30 days from the date
of receipt of the notice of motion.
11. We do not find any honest intention of
the Prescribed Authority to take such
steps within the statutory period. Thus,
the writ court could not have extended
the time beyond the period of 30 days.
Such direction would amount to
rewriting the statute. Extension of the
time limit prescribed by law is not
within the power of a writ court, in
exercise of power of judicial review.
12. Under such circumstances, we are not
in agreement with Mr Islam to the extent
that the requisition which was brought
forth by the requisitionists should be
treated as valid and alive. The
requisition had lost its force, the moment
the time limit prescribed by law had
expired.
13. The contention of Mr Bhattacharya
that Section 12(11) bars further
requisition is not accepted. Section
12(11) comes into operation only when
the notice of no confidence brought
against the Pradhan, fails on account of
lack of quorum or the motion is not
carried through.
14. We are also surprised to find that the
Prescribed Authority had adopted a
method of ignoring the requisition and
not holding the meeting, on the ground
that adequate police force was not
available. The law does not prescribe
that such meetings have to be held in
the presence of the police authorities.
Thus, such a plea of the Prescribed
Authority is not in conformity with the
expression “reason beyond the control”.
15. Unless there are specific instances to
demonstrate that non-availability of the
police force would result in a chaotic or
unsafe situation, the postponement of
the meeting deserves to be set aside.
Section 12(10) of the said Act provides
that the entire process from the receipt
of the requisition till the completion of
the meeting, should be concluded within
30 days. By the order impugned, the
time has been extended by further 10
days from the date of communication of
the order of Her Lordship dated 1-72026.
16. Mr Islam informs us that the meeting
has been scheduled on 15-7-2026. In
our view, the notice by which the
meeting has been fixed on 15-7-2026 is
also set aside.
***
***
43. The decision of the learned Single Judge is
also not in consonance with Section 12[4] of the
Panchayat Act. The learned Single Judge has
completely misconstrued the law and failed to
appreciate the legislative intent behind the
incorporation of the expression that the meeting
shall not be held later than ‘fifteen working
days’ from the date of receipt of the motion by
the Prescribed Authority.
45. In Selina Bibi [supra], the meeting was
adjourned due to the restrictions imposed by
the State in view of the Covid–19 pandemic
situation. This, in our view, certainly amounts
to ‘reasons beyond control’ for which a meeting
can be adjourned by the Prescribed Authority.
46. In Pravati Murmu [supra], no ratio has
been laid down and therefore, the said judgment
cannot be treated as a binding precedent. The
facts are also not available. We are unable to
consider the circumstances under which the
court allowed the meeting which was held at an
extended date.
***
***
48.The Prescribed Authority is the Block
Development
Officer
and
he
is
the
administrative head of his Block.
It is
unfortunate that an administrative head of a
Block is unable to perform his statutory duty for
lack of police assistance. This cannot be an
excuse for not performing statutory duties. The
apprehension of the Prescribed Authority of lawand-order problems at the time of the meeting
or afterwards, must be based on some materials
on record. ‘Police assistance’ is not a precondition for holding a meeting under Section
12(4). The Prescribed Authority can neither
rewrite the statutory provision and nor can he
choose not to perform his / her statutory duties
on flimsy grounds. If it is found that there is an
apprehension of law-and-order problem in the
block, an inference may be drawn that the
administration of the Block is not running well.
The statute also does not provide for police
assistance. Unless, subjective satisfaction of the
Prescribed Authority that, the situation at the
meeting will lead to violence and he will be
unable to hold the meeting in fear of violence,
are available from the records, we cannot hold
that inability of the police to provide assistance,
is a valid ground, available in law, to postpone
the meeting.
49. It is also surprising to note that the Officerin-charge of the concerned police station
refused to accede to the request of the Block
Development Officer.
We express our
displeasure and anguish to that effect. The
entire action/decision of the police authority as
well as the Prescribed Authority / Block
Development Officer are highly reprehensible.
The intention of the legislature cannot be
defeated in the casual manner adopted by the
Prescribed Authority.
50. It is to be remembered that, the legislature
has empowered the Prescribed Authority to
cancel or adjourn the meeting for ‘any other
reason beyond his control’. That does not mean
that the Prescribed Authority can use such
power as a device to adjourn or cancel a
meeting in every case. Since, the first part of
Section 12(4) is mandatory in nature the
Prescribed Authority must keep in mind that all
endeavours are required to be taken by him to
conclude the meeting within the time frame
given by the statute. The latter part of Section
12(4) of the Panchayat Act, can be invoked only
in exceptional circumstances, such as flood or
covid pandemic, other natural calamities,
violence or other circumstances of like nature,
which are beyond the control of the Prescribed
Authority. The Prescribed Authority must
substantiate existence of such reasons either in
his cancellation or adjournment order or from
contemporaneous
records,
demonstrably
disclosing the genuine reason(s) which forced
him to postpone the meeting. Moreover, the
postponement in this case, was until further
orders. i.e. indefinitely, without fixing another
convenient date.”
9. In view of the above, the requisitionists shall be at liberty
to bring another motion in accordance with law and the
prescribed authority is directed to comply with the
provisions of law, without fail. The requisition and the
subsequent actions are set aside. The order impugned is
set aside. The appellant will not evade service of the
requisition notice. The same shall be affixed at a
conspicuous place in the panchayat office, apart from
being served at the office and sent to the residence by post.
10. We make it clear that the meeting to be fixed pursuant to
the motion to be brought by the requisionists should not be
postponed on the ground of non-availability of police
assistance. The police authorities shall not refuse police
assistance, if requested. The Superintendent of Police,
shall ensure assistance through the local police station, if
required.
11. Accordingly, the appeal and the connected applications are
disposed of.
12. The
superior
authority
of
the
concerned
Block
Development Officer must deliberate upon the reason
behind the action of the prescribed authority in repeatedly
postponing meetings and/or cancelling the meetings for
removal of the Pradhan. An enquiry as to whether there is
any extraneous reason for such action is required to be
conducted. The authority should take up the issue
seriously, as we have repeatedly passed directions on the
Block Development Officers.
13. Service of copies of our orders upon the Secretary,
Department of Panchayat and Rural Development, have
been effected. The prescribed authorities are ignorant of
the law and also appear to have total disregard for the
decisions of the Division of this Court. If necessary,
decisions to transfer the concerned prescribed authority
and other similar officials who have acted contrary to the
statute and the orders from the High Court, should be
seriously contemplated.
14. The Secretary of the Department is requested to forward a
report in compliance of these direction and observations
passed by us, to the office of the Registrar General, High
Court at Calcutta.
15. Urgent photostat certified copy of the order, if applied for,
be given to the parties, upon usual undertakings.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review