Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 12th August, 2026
Uploaded on: 17th August, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011622762012
+
CRL.A. 1253/2012
MITHAI LAL
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. P. Sureshan, Adv.
versus
ANIL KUMAR VERMA & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ritesh Kumar Bahri, APP for
State with Mr. Randeep Kr, Mr.
Rishabh , Mr. Lalit Luthra and Mr.
Rajender Pal, Advs. with SI Sachin
PS. R.K. Puram.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE VIKAS MAHAJAN
VIKAS MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been preferred by the father of the deceased
namely, Mithai Lal challenging the judgment dated 28th July, 2012 passed
by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge-03, South District, Saket Courts,
New Delhi whereby all the four respondents-accused persons were acquitted
of the charges under Sections 498-A/304-B/34 IPC.
3.
The case of the prosecution is that on 09th June, 2009 at 06:30 p.m.,
DD No. 32A was received at P.S. R.K. Puram regarding death by hanging of
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
a woman at S-146, 184 Sector-1, R.K. Puram, New Delhi.
Basis this
information, SI R.K. Meena proceeded to the spot and after necessary
formalities, sent the body of the deceased to the mortuary.
4.
On 10th June, 2009, the Executive Magistrate reached Safdarjung
Hospital Mortuary where he recorded the statement of Mithai Lal, father of
the deceased Ms. Sunita. On the basis of this statement, the Executive
Magistrate directed the SHO to register the FIR and investigate the matter.
This led to the registration of FIR No. 241/2009 under Sections 304-B/498A/34 IPC at P.S. R.K. Puram on 10.06.2009.
5.
Two persons namely, Anil Kumar Verma, husband of the deceased,
his father, Ram Niwas, were arrested. Subsequently, another accused Sunil
Kumar, brother of Anil Kumar Verma, was also arrested on 10.07.2009. The
mother-in-law of the deceased, Leelawati, was declared as a proclaimed
offender (PO).
6.
After completion of investigation, charge sheet was filed against the
three arrested accused and the charges were framed against them under
Sections 498-A/304-B/34 IPC, to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed
trial.
7.
Subsequently, Leelawati was arrested on 08th March, 2010 and a
supplementary charge sheet was filed against her and the charges were
framed under Sections 498-A/304-B/34 IPC against her as well to which she
also pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
8.
As per the post-mortem report, the cause of death of deceased Sunita
was opined to be on account of Asphyxia due to ligature hanging.
9.
The prosecution examined 15 witnesses, of which following four were
the public witnesses:
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
(i) PW-1 Mithai Lal (father of deceased);
(ii) PW-3 Ganga Prasad (uncle of deceased);
(iii) PW-4 Rupmati (mother of deceased); and
(iv) PW-5 Asha (aunt of deceased).
10.
On the basis of the evidence that had come on record, the learned
Trial Court acquitted the accused persons of the charges under
section 498-A/304-B IPC.
11.
We have heard the learned counsel for the appellant, as well as, the
learned APP for the State and have gone through the impugned judgment, as
well as, the records of the case.
12.
Before proceeding further, we may note that the present is an appeal
against acquittal. The principles governing the exercise of appellate
jurisdiction while dealing with an appeal against acquittal under Section
378, CrPC have been succinctly summarized by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in HD Sundara and Ors. vs. State of Karnataka, (2023) 9 SCC 581, in the
following terms:
“8…..
8.1. The acquittal of the accused further strengthens the
presumption of innocence;
8.2. The appellate court, while hearing an appeal against
acquittal, is entitled to reappreciate the oral and
documentary evidence;
8.3. The appellate court, while deciding an appeal against
acquittal, after reappreciating the evidence, is required to
consider whether the view taken by the trial court is a
possible view which could have been taken on the basis of
the evidence on record;
8.4. If the view taken is a possible view, the appellate court
cannot overturn the order of acquittal on the ground that
another view was also possible; and
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
8.5. The appellate court can interfere with the order of
acquittal only if it comes to a finding that the only
conclusion which can be recorded on the basis of the
evidence on record was that the guilt of the accused was
proved beyond a reasonable doubt and no other
conclusion was possible.
(emphasis supplied)
13.
Additionally, the Supreme Court also underscored that in many cases
the Trial Judge who eventually passes the order of acquittal has an
advantage of looking at the demeanour of witnesses and observing their
conduct in the Court, especially in the witness box. The relevant observation
reads thus:
“10. There is one more aspect of the matter. In many cases, the
learned trial Judge who eventually passes the order of acquittal
has an occasion to record the oral testimony of all material
witnesses. Thus, in such cases, the trial court has the additional
advantage of closely observing the prosecution witnesses and
their demeanour. While deciding about the reliability of the
version of prosecution witnesses, their demeanour remains in
the back of the mind of the learned trial Judge. As observed in
the commentary by Sarkar on the Law of Evidence, the
demeanour of a witness frequently furnishes a clue to the weight
of his testimony. This aspect has to be borne in mind while
dealing with an appeal against acquittal.”
(emphasis supplied)
14.
Having noted the scope of interference by the appellate court in an
appeal against acquittal, we now advert to the evidence and the judgment of
the Trial Court to find out whether the view on the evidence taken by the
Trial Court is a plausible view.
15.
It is pertinent to note that the Trial Court, in its judgment, tabulated
the relevant allegations made by the parents of the deceased, her uncle and
aunt regarding the demand of dowry, which are extracted hereinbelow for
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
the ease of ready reference:
PW-1 Mithai Lal PW-3 Ganga Pd.
(Father)
(Uncle)
Mithai Lal had
given sufficient
dowry articles in
marriage.
PW-4 Rupmati
PW-5 Asha
(Mother)
(Aunt)
We had given Sufficient dowry
dowry articles as was given.
per demand of in
laws of Sunita.
Had paid Rs.
1,21,000/in
cash.
After
Sunita’s
bidai, I recd.
Call from Ram
Niwas
that
balance amt. of
dowry of Rs. 1
lakh was nor
paid to him. I
told that since
Rs.
1,21,000/had been paid in
in
cash
in
marriage,
no
further amount
was payable.
I
attended
Reception where
Ram
Niwas
demanded
balance amount
of dowry from me
which led to hot
talks and I left
the
reception
without a glass
of water.
After 1 ½ months Later on, I came After 1 ½ months After sometime,
of marriage I to know from of
marriage she came to
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
came to know
from Sunita that
accused persons
were demanding
Rs. 1 lakh from
Sunita otherwise
she would be
thrown out of the
house.
Around 15 days
before
the
incident
my
daughter came
and she looked
sad and told me
that
accused
persons
are
demanding
dowry.
Mithai Lal that
still demands of
money
were
made by the inlaws of Sunita.
Sunita informed
on phone that her
in-laws
were
demanding Rs. 1
lakh more.
know
from
Sunita’s mother
about
dowry
demand of Rs. 1
lakh more by
her-in-laws.
She came with
Anil to our house
and looked sad
and informed that
her in laws were
demanding Rs. 1
lakh
more
otherwise
she
would not be kept
in
the
matrimonial
house.
Even
after
reaching
her
matrimonial
home,
she
informed about
her harassment
for dowry.
Sunita met me
about 15 days
before he death
when she cried in
front of me for
being harassed
by her in-laws
for
dowry
demand.
Around 3 days
before her death,
she telephoned
me and told that
the
accused
persons
were
harassing her for
dowry.
16.
Referring to the aforesaid, the Trial Court observed that the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
depositions of various witnesses, who were the close relatives of the
deceased were not in sync with each other.
17.
PW-3 Ganga Prasad in his statement has stated that after bidai of
Sunita, he received a telephone call of accused Ram Niwas wherein he had
demanded Rs. 1 lakh, but the Trial Court found this allegation to be missing
in his statement under Section 161 CrPC. In his cross-examination, the
witness stated that he had told about this demand to his brother Mithai Lal,
but PW-1 Mithai Lal did not state any such thing, which he, being the father
of the bride, could not have missed especially when such demand was made
on the very first night after bidai. Even the wife of Mithai Lal i.e PW-4
Rupmati did not make any deposition to that effect.
18.
Similarly, PW-3 Ganga Prasad also deposed about the demand at the
time of “reception” of the deceased and her husband Anil. However, no
other witness deposed about any such demand. On this basis, the Trial
Court held that the allegation of such demands was doubtful.
19.
Both the parents of the deceased i.e. PW-1 and PW-4 have deposed
that after 1½ months of marriage, their daughter Sunita told them that her
in-laws are demanding Rs. 1 lakh. The Trial Court noted that there is no
allegation
of
the parents
that
the
demand
was
made by
the
respondents/accused persons directly from them. Further, the deposition of
other two witnesses i.e. PW-3 and PW-5 was found to be hearsay and thus,
held to be inadmissible.
20.
As regards the deposition of PW-1 Mithai Lal to the effect that 15
days before her death, their deceased daughter had come, who looked sad
and on being asked, she told that the accused persons were demanding
dowry. In this regard the Trial Court observed that there is no detail as to the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
amount demanded. PW-1 in his cross-examination, however, stated that the
factum of her harassment by her husband and in-laws 15 days prior to her
death was informed by his daughter to his wife; thus, the Trial Court held
the testimony to that effect as hearsay.
21.
The mother of the deceased i.e. PW-4 also deposed that 15 days
before her death, Sunita came along with her husband Anil to her house and
looked sad and on being asked, she told that her in-laws were demanding Rs.
1 lakh more but she pacified her daughter and requested her to bear for some
time and sent her back. The Trial Court has found the said approach to be
not normal as none of the parents of the deceased have stated that they had
spoken to the husband of the deceased with regard to the said demand
especially when as per PW-4, the husband of the deceased had also come
along with the deceased and was available in their own house. Thus, the
Trial Court held that the conduct of the parents was unnatural which raises
doubt about the said demand.
22.
It is also in the statement of PW-4 that she used to talk on phone with
her daughter and in the last 15 days before her death, she had spoken to her
on 05 to 06 occasions, but there is nothing in her deposition to suggest that
her daughter had told her about any dowry demands of the accused persons
during such calls; rather, it is in the testimony of PW-4 that her daughter had
never complained about her husband. Accordingly, the Trial Court found
that the allegations of dowry demands are not very convincing.
23.
There is yet another allegation of dowry demand by the accused
persons. As stated by PW-1 Mithai Lal, three days before the death of the
deceased Sunita, she had telephoned PW-1 that accused persons were
harassing her, but he did not divulge in his deposition as to what that
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
demand was, nor did he depose as to what was his response or what steps he
took in respect thereof. The prosecution has also not placed on record any
call detail records of the phone calls between the deceased and her father.
The Trial Court thus, observed that it cannot be accepted that the parents of
the deceased would not take any stern action or would not even have talked
with the accused persons as to why their daughter was being harassed for
dowry demands. Accordingly, it was held that the above deposition does not
inspire confidence, particularly when the mother of the deceased did not
testify as to any such demand three days prior to the death of her daughter.
24.
The father of deceased PW-1 Mithai Lal also stated that he had not
called for any panchayat or discussed the matter with any of his relatives
with regard to the demands being made by the accused persons. Likewise,
PW-4 also admitted in her cross-examination that Shyam Ji and Pyare Lal
were mediators in the marriage of their daughter Sunita with Anil Kumar,
but neither the said mediators nor any other person was involved to resolve
compliant of dowry demand mentioned by deceased Sunita. The Trial Court,
thus, recorded a finding that the allegations regarding dowry demand are
vague, and none of the allegations qua demands deposed by the public
witnesses withstand the test of even probability; leave alone beyond
reasonable doubt.
25.
The relevant extract from the Trial Court judgment where the aspect
of dowry demand has been dealt with, is reproduced hereinbelow:
“31. The aforesaid table shows the averments made by the
parents of the deceased, her Chacha and her aunt regarding
dowry demand. A perusal of the various depositions show that
there is no sync in them. PW-2 Ganga Prasad deposed that
after bidai of Sunita, he received telephone call of accused Ram
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
Niwas wherein he demanded Rs. 1 lakh. However, such a
statement is found missing from the statement of this witness
recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and is thus an
improvement. In his cross examination this witness has stated
that he had told about this demand to his brother Mithal Lal.
However, Mithai Lal PW-1 did not state any such thing. If any
such demand is made by the father-in-law of the deceased on
the very first night after “bidai” of a bride, no father, rich or
poor, can take the situation lightly and forget the same so as
not to depose about it in Court. Not only this, even his wife PW-4
Rupmati does not depose about it. PW-3 Ganga Prasad also
deposed about it. PW-3 Ganga Prasad also deposed about the
demand on ‘Reception’ on the deceased and accused Anil. Again,
no other witness deposes about going to ‘Reception’ or of such
an incident. It cannot be believed that the parents of the
deceased would sit silently even after knowing such demands,
in such quick succession after marriage. The only inference
that can be drawn is that such a demand becomes doubtful.
Both the parents of the decease have then deposed that after 1 ½
months of marriage, in-laws of the deceased demanded Rs. 1
lakh from Sunita. The deposition of other two witnesses in this
regard are hear-say, hence not admissible, it is not the case of
the prosecution that the said demand was made by the accused
persons from the parents of the deceased. The father of the
deceased has also deposed that 15 days before her death, her
daughter came and looked sad and on being asked she told that
accused persons are demanding dowry. He does not say what
was the amount demanded. In his cross-examination, he stated
that his wife had told him about that demand and therefore the
deposition to this effect becomes hearsay. His wife deposed that
15 days before her death, her daughter came alongwith her
husband Anil to her house and looked sad and on being asked
she told that her in-laws were demanding Rs. 1 lakh more and
she pacified her daughter to bear and she sent her back. This
deposition, if tested, on the touched stone of normal
circumstances, does not pass such test. It is but natural for the
parents for the deceased of the deceased to have talked about
this demand with the husband of the deceased but none of the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
witnesses had deposed to this effect that they ever talked about
it with the husband of the deceased. This conduct of the parents
of the deceased in not talking about the demand of the accused
with the husband of the deceased, who was available in their
own house, is unnatural and raises about doubt, about such
demand. She also stated in her cross-examination that she used
to talk on phone with her daughter and in the last 15 days before
her death, she had talked about 5-6 times with her daughter.
There is no deposition that her daughter had told her mother
about the dowry demands of the accused on the telephones calls
made by her. PW-4 also stated in her cross-examination that her
daughter had never complained to her against her husband.
Thus, the allegations of dowry demands are not very convincing.
The next instance of dowry demand of the accused persons as
stated by PW-1 Mithai Lal is said to be 3 days before the death
of the deceased when the deceased Sunita is said to have
telephoned her father that accused persons were harassing her.
Even this deposition does not inspire confidence in as much as
no such deposition is made by the mother of the deceased.
Apart from it, what was that demand, has not been stated by the
father of the deceased. Mithai Lal has not deposed as to what
he did after receiving the said call from his daughter. The
prosecution has also not placed on record any call detail
records of the phones of the deceased and her father. It cannot
be accepted that the parents of the deceased would not take any
stern action or would not even talk with the accused persons as
to why their daughter was being harassed for dowry demands.
It was accepted by PW-1 that he did not hold any Pachayat or
meeting against the accused persons for their dowry demands to
make them understand that they should not make such demand.
PW-4 Roopmati had accepted that neither she nor any other
persons not the mediator was sent by them to the house of her
daughter Sunita to look into the complaint of dowry demand by
her husband and her in-laws. She had also stated in her crossexamination that her daughter was free to talk to her parents at
any time and she was never stopped from visiting her parents by
her in-laws. The allegations regarding dowry demand are thus
vague. Thus, none of the alleged demands deposed by the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
public witnesses against the accused persons stand on the test
of even probability what to speak of ‘beyond reasonable doubt’.
Even the amount of more than Rs. 5 lacs stated to have been
spent by the father of the deceased in the marriage of Sunita and
Anil does not appear to be truthful keeping in view the financial
condition of the father of the deceased, who used to live in a
Jhuggi and had only Rs. 60,000/- to Rs. 65,000/- in his bank
account at the time of marriage of Sunita. It is hard to accept
that a person who was earning Rs. 500-600/- per month 15 years
ago, would be able to give dowry of more than 135 gms of gold
and silver jeweller of 500-600 gms to her daughter in her
marriage. PW-4 had admitted in her cross-examination that no
list of Shagun given to her daughter at the time of her marriage
was maintained in any Register. PW-1 & PW-3 had admitted that
no list of dowry articles were prepared at the time of marriage
and the same was given to the Police on their asking. Taking the
entire deposition of the public witnesses as a whole into
consideration, conscience of this Court is not satisfied that
there were dowry demands made by the accused persons.”
(emphasis supplied)
26.
The law is well settled that one of the essential ingredients of dowry
death under Section 304-B IPC is that the accused must have subjected the
woman to cruelty in connection with demand for dowry soon before her
death and this ingredient has to be proved by the prosecution beyond
reasonable doubt. It is only then that the Court will presume under Section
113-B of the Indian Evidence Act that the accused has committed the
offence of dowry death.1 Mere making demand of dowry is not sufficient to
constitute the offence under Section 304-B IPC.
27.
Likewise, the offence under Section 498-A, IPC is made out against
the husband or his relative if the woman has been subjected to cruelty. The
Rajeev Kumar vs. State of Haryana, (2013) 16 SCC 640.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
“cruelty” as exposited in the Explanation to the said Section means:
(i)
Any wilful conduct which is of such nature and is likely
to drive the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or
danger to life, limb or health (whether mental or physical); or
(ii)
Harassment of woman where such harassment is with a
view to coercing her or any person related to her to meet any
unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on
account of failure by her or any person related to her to meet
such demand.
28.
Clearly, the ‘cruelty’ or ‘harassment’ of the woman by her husband or
his relative for or in connection with either ‘demand of dowry’, or ‘unlawful
demand for any property or valuable security’ is the common constituent of
both the offences under Section 304-B and 498-A, IPC.
29.
None of the witnesses have even mentioned or narrated any specific
incident of cruelty or harassment. The Trial Court has also held that the
element of subjecting the deceased to cruelty in connection with dowry was
completely missing, as both the parents i.e. PW-1 and PW-4 had admittedly
not convened any meeting or panchayat, nor did they involve the mediator
for counselling of the accused persons when such dowry demands were
made. The relevant extract from the judgment reads thus:
“32….. There is another aspect of this mater. Both Section 498-A
and Section 304B IPC require that not only there should be
dowry demand but there should also be cruelty or harassment
meted out by the husband or his relatives of the wife of such
husband. Mere making of dowry demand is not the only prerequisite for proving an offence u/s 304-B IPC.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
35….. In these circumstances, cruelty for dowry demand was
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
held to be proved in the cited case, which is completely for
dowry demand was held to be proved in the cited case, which is
completely missing in the present case, as the father of the
deceased PW-1 Mithal Lal had stated that no Panchayat or any
other meeting was held regarding the dowry demands of the
accused persons for their counseling. To the same effect, is the
deposition of PW-4 Roopmati, who had stated that neither she
nor any one else not the mediator was sent to the house of the
accused persons regarding their dowry demands and hence the
said judgment is distinguishable on facts.”
(emphasis supplied)
30.
The Trial Court further held that the evidence was completely lacking
to constitute even an offence of abetment of suicide under Section 306 IPC.
Further, even the presumption for abetment of suicide by a married woman
as provided under Section 113A of the Evidence Act could not be drawn as
the foundational facts of the deceased being subjected to cruelty or
harassment at the hands of the accused persons is not proved. The relevant
observation of the Trial Court in this regard reads thus:
“37. A question arises as to whether the accused persons can
be convicted for the offence of abetment of suicide under Section
306 IPC. No evidence has come on record which could point
out that it were the accused persons, who were instrumental in
abetting the suicide of Sunita, who had died within three and
half months of her marriage by hanging. Even the statutory
presumption for abetment of suicide by a married woman
provided under Section 113A of Evidence Act does not help the
prosecution in this regard because even for drawing this
presumption it was to be proved that the husband or her relative
had subjected her to cruelty ant it was only and then only that a
presumption for abetment of suicide can be drawn against the
accused persons. The evidence led on behalf of the prosecution
falls too short for even drawing this presumption as there is no
evidence led to the effect that the deceased had been committed
with cruelties or harassment at the hands of the accused
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
persons.”
(emphasis supplied)
31.
After having perused the evidence of the public witnesses namely,
PW-1, PW-3, PW-4 and PW-5, we are convinced that the present is not a
case where the only view possible is that of the guilt of the accusedrespondent. As already noted, there are contradictions in the statements of
the said witnesses in so far as the allegations qua dowry demands are
concerned. The said allegations are bereft of sufficient details to convict the
accused. No specific incidents or the manner in which the deceased was
harassed or subjected to cruelty by the respondents, have been mentioned.
The conduct of the parents and other close family members of the deceased
do not appear to be the natural reaction which parents ought to have had, in
as much as at no point of time, they either made any complaint to the police
or attempted to hold any panchayat or meeting with the accused persons to
persuade them to desist from making any such demands. The marital
alliance between the deceased and her husband Anil Kumar was finalised
through the mediators, who were never involved by the family of the
deceased to resolve the issue by making the respondents understand.
Further, it is also in the testimony of PW-4 that her daughter had never
complained to her against her husband.
32.
We are thus, of the considered opinion that the view on the evidence
taken by the Trial Court is a possible view. The impugned judgment,
therefore, does not suffer from any infirmity or perversity warranting
interference in the present appeal.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
33.
The Appeal is devoid of merit, and is accordingly, dismissed.
VIKAS MAHAJAN
JUDGE
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
AUGUST 12, 2026/dss
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:47:28
CRL.A. 1253/2012
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review