Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial Nos.01 & 03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (WA) No.12/2023 in
WA No.29/2023 with
MC (WA) No.32/2023
WA No.13/2023
Mingran T. Sangma
Vs.
Date of order: 30.08.2023
Abal M. Sangma & ors
State of Meghalaya
Vs.
Abal M. Sangma
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance in MC (WA) No.12 of 2023 in
WA No.29 of 2023 with MC (WA) No.32 of 2023:
For the Applicant/Appellant
: Mr. P.T. Sangma, Adv
Ms. J.T. Sangma, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. M.F. Qureshi, Adv with
Mr. L. Koch, Adv for R/1
Mr. N. Syngkon, GA with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
Appearance in WA No.13 of 2023
For the Appellant
: Mr. N. Syngkon, GA with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
For the Respondent
: Mr. M.F. Qureshi, Adv with
Mr. L. Koch, Adv for R/1
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
In MC (WA) No.12 of 2023, the applicant seeks leave to appeal
against a judgment and order of May 2, 2023 passed in WP (C) No.83
of 2015 to which the applicant herein was not a party.
2.
The applicant claims to be seriously prejudiced by the relevant
order to the extent that such order has directed a fresh investigation to
be conducted into an incident of 2015 at the behest of the father of a
person who was killed in what, according to the State and the applicant,
was an encounter between the State police and Garo National Liberation
Army insurgents.
3.
WA No.13 of 2023 is the State’s appeal against the same order.
4.
Since there is already an appeal that has to be looked into,
notwithstanding the fact that the order directing an investigation may
not be seriously prejudicial to the applicant in MC (WA) No.12 of 2023,
leave is given to such applicant to prefer the appeal as a person
aggrieved.
5.
The appeals are taken up for immediate consideration.
6.
According to both the appellants, particularly the State, pursuant
to information received by the police personnel in Tura, they took steps
to deal with a situation where suspected militants with new recruits
were apparently in hiding in Romba Adinggre. The police personnel
took appropriate steps to gather adequate men and fire-power to reach
the spot and at about 5 am on March 4, 2015, they identified a countrystyle hut to be where the militants had gathered.
7.
The State submits that after the hut was surrounded, warnings
were issued to the occupants to come out without arms but such
warnings fell on deaf ears. According to the State, three persons
suddenly broke open the bamboo door of the hut and rushed out firing at
the police personnel. It was in such circumstances that the State claims
that the police had no option but to open fire and one of the militants
who was in the most advanced position sustained bullet injuries as a
result of the police firing and died immediately. The State’s version also
speaks of two others who had rushed out together with the deceased, but
there does not appear to be any trace of such persons.
8.
Apart from the criminal cases instituted by the police authorities
pertaining to the incident, the father of the deceased lodged a complaint
to the effect that it was a fake encounter in which his son had been
gunned down mercilessly by the police. Pursuant to the investigation of
such case, nothing untoward was discovered and a final report was
submitted under Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Aggrieved by the investigation into the allegations levelled by him, the
father of the deceased then instituted WP (C) No.83 of 2015 in this
Court. An interim order was passed on June 28, 2017 on such petition,
the operative part whereof is found at paragraph 4 of such order:
“4. In such circumstances, I am of the considered view that there
is only one way out and that is further enquiry by a Judicial
Officer from the judicial side. Accordingly, learned District
Judge, Tura is entrusted with the job to conduct a thorough
enquiry and to submit the report before this Court within 5(five)
months.”
9.
It appears that the District and Sessions Judge, Tura conducted
an inquiry and filed a report running into some 25 pages and appended
photographs of the place of occurrence along with markings thereon.
10.
The conclusion drawn by the relevant District and Sessions
Judge appears from the following passage towards the end of the final
paragraph of the report:
“36. ...It can be seen that the source information about GNLA
militants taking shelter was most probably a correct information
as the deceased was found trying to escaped by running away
and shooting with his gun at the same time and the subsequent
recovery of the Demand Note in his pocket and also the
recovery of 2 (two) Blank Demand Notes as well as the
detonator from his Bachelor’s Dormatory. However the
presence of two other persons with the deceased who are said to
have escaped could not be established.”
11.
Such report of the relevant District and Sessions Judge was
considered in great detail by the writ court in course of the final hearing
of the petition. It is evident that the State opposed the prayer for an
inquiry by the Central Bureau of Investigation on the ground that the
Criminal Investigation Department of the State had investigated into the
matter and even a further independent inquiry by the District and
Sessions Judge, Tura revealed that it was a genuine encounter based on
accurate information.
12.
However, what weighed with the writ court appears from
paragraphs 46 to 48 of the impugned judgment and order dated May 2,
2023:
“46. This Magistrate, being EW27, Labenn Ch. Marak, who is
also the Block Development Officer (BDO), Rongram reached
the PO at about 10:00 to 11:00 am on the same day and along
with I/C Bamon and other police personnel entered the house,
the door which is made of bamboo was not broken and inside
the room, some bottles of foreign liquor was found as well as
some papers and part of a detonator were also found. This
witness has also noted that at the spot where the deceased son of
the petitioner was found lying face down, there was a slope
below the house of the deceased and indications of a person who
might have tumbled or skidded through the slope, such skid
mark or slip mark showing signs of only a single person running
towards the place where the deceased was lying. When he
checked the body, he found many entry wounds as well as
gracing bullet wound on the body of the deceased, the maximum
target and wounds on the body being at the back and buttock
area. This witness also saw one old pistol which appears to be a
country-made pistol with a jammed magazine just about a few
meters from the body of the deceased. I/C Bamon picked up the
pistol from the shallow water of a nearby stream and checked it
in front of him. He tried to take out the magazine, but could not
do it, as it was very hard to take it out and he has to use stone to
remove the magazine. There were two bullets in the magazine
and the pistol seems rusted.
“47. While appreciating the evidence of the witnesses and also
the Forensic Science Laboratory Report, the learned District and
Sessions Judge has relied on the said FSL Report that the
country made pistol is found serviceable and the gun powder
residue which was detected in the liquid in a plastic container is
the handwash of the deceased and also gun powder residue
detected in two cotton swabs found at the residence of the
deceased to come to the conclusion that the deceased had fired
from the said gun which was seized. The fact that the deceased
had also failed to surrender but had ran out shooting in the
direction of the police in a bid to escape, upon which the police
has retaliated by firing upon him has also confirmed the
conclusion of the learned Enquiry Officer that a genuine
encounter had taken place. There is however, an observation that
police should have exercised restraint once they have seen the
suspect have fallen, which only goes to show that it was
accepted that excessive use of force by the police had taken
place.
“48. On an analysis of the observations made above, what is
clear is that there are two versions of the sequence of events
which occurred on the said date, that is, on 04.03.2015, one, on
the part of the witnesses who are the residents of the village and
another from the police personnel who were also part of the
operation. Evidently, what is noticed is that proper investigation
to find out the actual truth have not been adequately dealt with
by the Investigating Officer, inasmuch as in the investigation
conducted by the CID into the two respective FIRs, one filed by
the Circle Inspector B.N. Marak and the other filed by the
petitioner herein, the Investigating Officer therein have filed his
final report indicating that there is no credible evidence to
proceed with the investigation, the findings thereto being
contrary to the prima facie evidence, even at this stage, when
there are present two viewpoints proffered by two sets of
witnesses as to what exactly happened at the place of occurrence
on the said day, the IO ought to have put in more diligent effort,
failure to do so would only invite an adverse inference and
rectification of such failure is therefore well within the scope of
the powers of this Court under Article 226.”
13.
Upon appreciating the evidence including the account of an
Executive Magistrate who arrived at the place of occurrence within
hours of the deceased being killed, the writ court was satisfied that there
were two versions of the same incident. Further, the Executive
Magistrate’s description of the defunct country-made pistol that was
discovered near the body of the deceased, who still lay on the ground
head down, and the completely contrary report of the Forensic Science
Laboratory in such regard, quite naturally raised a degree of suspicion,
to allay which an independent investigation appears to have been called
for.
14.
Indeed, the writ court observed that notwithstanding the
evidence of the Executive Magistrate who was present at the place of
occurrence shortly after the shooting took place, the District and
Sessions Judge’s reliance on the FSL report without discrediting the
ocular evidence of the Executive Magistrate was somewhat irregular.
Indeed, even if such aspect has not been harped on in the order
impugned, the same is implicit from the discussion in the paragraphs
quoted above.
15.
There was further material for the writ court to be prompted to
call for an independent investigation notwithstanding receipt of the
report from the District and Sessions Judge, Tura. For a start, the
Executive Magistrate present at the spot immediately after the incident
reported that the bamboo door of the hut was not broken. Such an
observation goes against the fundamental premise of the State police
that the militants broke open the door and rushed at the police
personnel. Secondly, several of the bullet injuries found on the person
of the deceased were on his back and his buttocks. Even if it is accepted
that such injuries were suffered once he had fallen on the ground and
may have been as a result of the overenthusiasm of the police personnel
to ensure that the suspected militant was dead; there was enough
material for the writ court to conclude that it was an overkill or
excessive action. Most importantly, the police’s version hinges on three
persons rushing out and shooting at the police personnel. If the rest of
the police story is to be believed that they had surrounded the entire area
and issued warnings, there was little possibility of the two others to
escape.
16.
The observations herein will not prejudice the further
investigation that has been directed but the only object of the present
exercise is to emphasise on the anomalies that weighed with the writ
court to observe that there were different versions of the same incident.
17.
At any rate, even if it is accepted for argument’s sake that it was
a genuine encounter and the State police acted reasonably and
rationally, there remains a slur on the conduct of the State police since,
at the end of the day, it may be said that the State police itself
investigated into an allegation of a fake encounter brought against it and
gave itself a clean chit. It would be so much better for the State police if
the investigation, as has been directed by the order impugned, is
conducted by an independent external agency and the State police is
given a clean chit by such agency.
18.
As far as the individual who has been granted leave to prefer an
appeal is concerned, the order impugned does not prejudice such person
any more than it affects the State. If such person was a part of the police
team on the relevant date, the independent investigation by the Central
Bureau of Investigation will bring things to light and if no wrongdoing
was committed by such person, there is no need for any apprehension
on his part.
19.
Considering the nature of the incident, the material that was
available before the writ court and the grounds that have been clearly
indicated for requiring a fresh investigation into the incident to be
conducted by an independent agency, the judgment and order impugned
do no call for any interference.
20.
A final ground is urged on behalf of the State to the effect that
the parameters laid down by the Supreme Court for a CBI investigation
despite the State opposing the same have not been met in the present
case.
21.
The fact that the police’s version is that the action taken on the
relevant date was against extremists, the fact that the father of the victim
and the local villagers have a different account of the incident than
depicted by the police and the fact that serious anomalies were noticed
by the writ court from the account of an Executive Magistrate which
does not tally with the official version rendered by the police, were
good grounds for the writ court to require another agency to investigate
into matter. There is no need for the State to harbour any misgiving
since, if the police action was justified, the fresh investigation, whether
by CBI or by any other agency, would reveal the same.
22.
Accordingly, both the appeals, WA No.29 of 2023 and WA
No.13 of 2023, are dismissed. It is made abundantly clear that none of
the observations in the judgment impugned or in this order will
prejudice the State or persuade the investigating agency in any manner
whatsoever. The investigating agency is left free to conduct its own
investigation and the State and its allied agencies should cooperate in
the matter so that the investigation can be concluded as early as possible
and, preferably, within six months from date.
23.
A copy of this order will immediately be forwarded to the office
of learned DSGI attached to this Court for the same to be forwarded to
the appropriate CBI personnel for necessary action.
24.
MC (WA) No.12 of 2023 and MC (WA) No.32 of 2023 are
disposed of.
25.
There will be no order as to costs.
(H. S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
30.08.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review