The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. In the present case, admittedly, neither the 2026:HHC:7754 petitioner had ticked in the application form in the affirmative that she belonged to a landless family nor any valid certificate depicting this fact was otherwise appended with the application form. That being the case, the Screening Committee was under no obligation to accept any fresh certificate from the petitioner relating to land holding and as obviously the taking on record of the said certificate would have prejudiced the selected candidates, who had been prudent enough to submit the applications along-with all supporting documents, the prayer of the petitioner cannot be allowed because now the private respondent, who is serving, cannot be thrown out of job for the acts of omission and commission of the petitioner.
14. In light of above observations, as this court finds no merit in the present petition, the same is dismissed. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of accordingly. (Ajay Mohan Goel) Judge March 19, 2026 (Shivank Thakur)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:7754
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT
SHIMLA
CWP No. 18002 of 2025
Decided on : 19.03.2026
Minakshi
…Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?1 Yes
For the petitioner
: Mr. Rocky, Advocate.
For the respondents
: Mr. Pushpinder Jaswal, Additional
Advocate
General,
for
the
respondents-State.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge (Oral)
By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has, inter
alia, prayed for the following reliefs:“i.
Quash and set aside the action of the
respondents in not awarding marks to the petitioner
for her land-holding certificate during the selection
process for the post of Clerk (HI) under the Special
Recruitment Drive.
1Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:7754
ii.
Quash and set aside the appointment order
dated 17.07.2025 of respondent No.3.
iii.
Direct the respondents to reconsider the
candidature of the petitioner by awarding due marks
for land holding in accordance with the applicable
recruitment criteria and to re-draw the final merit list
accordingly.
iv.
Direct the respondents to offer appointment to
the petitioner to the post of Clerk (HI) if she is found
to be higher in merit upon correct computation of
marks.”
2.
Brief facts necessary for the adjudication of this
petition are that the petitioner participated in the process
initiated by the Office of Deputy Commissioner, Shimla, vide
Annexure P-1, dated 02.07.2022, to fill up posts mentioned
therein, including two posts of Clerk. The drive was to fill up the
posts from amongst persons with disability. According to the
petitioner, in terms of the evaluation criteria contained in the
advertisement, the petitioner was entitled for one mark, as she
was falling within the definition of a “landless family/family
2026:HHC:7754
having land less than one hectare”, but one mark was wrongly
not granted in her favour, which had resulted in her not being
selected against the post in issue.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that in
terms of Annexure P-1, one post of Clerk was reserved for Deaf
and hard of hearing category and one post was reserved for
Locomotor disability category. The petitioner had applied under
the Deaf and hard of hearing category. Learned counsel further
submitted that despite the fact that the petitioner had appended
the requisite documents demonstrating that she qualified as a
candidate falling under the category of “landless family”, yet the
respondents erroneously did not grant one mark to her on this
count, which had resulted in her non-selection. Learned
counsel also submitted that as the non-selection of the
petitioner was totally arbitrary, the petition be allowed and the
selection of the candidate, i.e., the private respondent, be held
to be bad and respondents be directed to offer appointment to
the petitioner. Learned counsel made this prayer on the
contention that if one mark is added to the present score of the
petitioner, then her score comes to 14.4, which will be more
2026:HHC:7754
than the score of the selected candidate, who secured 14.14
marks.
4.
On the other hand, learned Additional Advocate
General took the Court through the reply filed by the
respondents-State and submitted that when the credentials of
the petitioner were scrutinized by the Special Selection
Committee, it was found during verification that the petitioner
had not attached any landless certificate issued by the
competent Authority with her application form at the time of
applying for post in issue and on this count, the subsequent
submission of said certificate by her at a belated stage before
the Selection Committee, was not taken into consideration, as it
would have prejudiced other qualified and eligible candidates,
who had submitted all the requisite documents/certificates
along-with
the
application.
Learned Additional Advocate
General submitted that the Selection Committee acted in a fair
manner and scrutinized the merit of the candidates on the
strength of the documents, which were appended with the
application form and as the petitioner had not appended any
landless certificate issued by a competent Authority with the
2026:HHC:7754
application form, one mark on this count was rightly not
awarded to her. He submitted that the landless certificate was
to be issued by Tehsildar concerned, who is the competent
Authority to issue such certificate and petitioner did not append
a valid certificate issued by Tehsildar with the application form.
5.
When this case was listed 02.03.2026, this Court
directed the respondents to produce the original record,
including application form. which was submitted by the
petitioner along-with requisite documents. The same was
produced by the State before the Court on 18.03.2026 and on
the said date, the following order was passed by the Court:“Learned
Deputy
Advocate
General
has
produced the relevant record in terms of the previous
order, which stands perused by the Court. A perusal
of the same, inter alia, demonstrates that against the
column of ‘landless persons’, there are ticks both
against ‘Yes’ as well as ‘No’ and there is a whitener
mark upon both of them. It is evident with the naked
eyes that the tick upon ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ is similar as
upon other columns, meaning thereby that prima
facie it does not appear that there is any
2026:HHC:7754
interpolation by a third person on the document.
From this, it is evident that the petitioner had not
positively
ticked
the
relevant
column
in
the
Employment Form to reflect her as a person
belonging to landless person.
Besides this, record demonstrates that there
was
no
Landless
Certificate
issued
by
the
Competent Authority, i.e. Tehsildar, appended by the
petitioner alongwith Application Form.
Faced with this situation, learned Counsel for
the petitioner submits that the case be taken up
tomorrow. As prayed for, list on 19.03.2026. Let the
record be produced for the perusal of the Court
tomorrow.”
6.
Today, learned counsel for the petitioner fairly
submitted that as per his instructions, the petitioner had ticked
both ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ against the Column of a ‘landless persons’
and then applied white fluid also upon the same, but according
to him, this was done because there was no clarification in the
form whether or not a candidate was supposed to tick the said
Clause or not.
2026:HHC:7754
7.
The original application form which was submitted
by the petitioner along-with the requisite documents, which has
again been made available for the perusal of the Court today,
by the learned Additional Advocate General, demonstrates that
under the heading "Details of list of documents attached alongwith the Form”, at Sr. No. 2, against the Column "Landless
Family/Family”, having land less than one hectare to be
certified by the concerned Revenue Officer, the petitioner had
ticked both ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ and then applied a whitener thereon.
The documents appended with the application form further
demonstrate that the petitioner had appended a report, issued
by the Patwari of Patwar Circle Ropri, Tehsil Lad Bhadol,
District Mandi, H.P., to the effect that from the parental side of
the petitioner, the land holding was about 3-10-14 bighas. This
report, appended by the petitioner along-with her application
form, by no stretch of imagination, can be said to be a
certificate issued by the Competent Authority, as per the
requirement of the advertisement to assess as to whether the
candidate belongs to a “landless family” or not.
8.
Not only this, coupled with the fact that the
2026:HHC:7754
petitioner had ticked both the Columns of ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ in the
application form against the Clause relating to ‘landless family’,
despite being married, the report appended was of the parental
side.
9.
Now, when she appeared before the Selection
Committee, she produced a certificate of land holding issued by
Tehsildar, Hamirpur and the same was relating to the family of
the husband of the petitioner. The same was to the effect that in
terms of the affidavit/self-declaration furnished by Mrs.
Meenakshi wife of Mr. Nikhil Patiyal, the family of the applicant,
including the applicant herself, was owning land in Muhal
Ghanal Kalan, Tehsil Hamirpur, District Hamirpur, H.P., which
was less than one hectare.
10.
As
observed
hereinabove,
along-with
the
application form, no certificate of land holding issued by the
Competent Authority was produced by the petitioner. The
certificate which was produced before the Selection Committee,
was not taken into consideration by the said Committee on the
ground that as the petitioner had not uploaded any certificate
with the main application form, consideration thereof would
2026:HHC:7754
adversely affect those candidates who had already submitted
their application forms along-with all the requisite certificates.
11.
This Court is of the considered view that the reason
and the rational, on the basis of which, the Selection
Committee did not take into consideration the certificate of land
holding, subsequently produced by the petitioner, is justified in
the peculiar facts of the case.
12.
The posts advertised were that of a Clerk. The
posts were reserved for persons with disabilities. Even amongst
persons with disability, one post was reserved for person with
Locomotor disability and one was falling under the category of
Deaf and hard of hearing. For such like candidates, the
weightage was spelled out in the advertisement, which included
one mark for those belonging to landless family, which also was
requested to be certified by the concerned Revenue Authority. It
was further mentioned in Annexure P-1 that the application
along-with relevant supporting documents should reach the
office of the Deputy Commissioner, Shimla on or before
20.07.2022.
13.
In the present case, admittedly, neither the
2026:HHC:7754
petitioner had ticked in the application form in the affirmative
that she belonged to a landless family nor any valid certificate
depicting this fact was otherwise appended with the application
form. That being the case, the Screening Committee was under
no obligation to accept any fresh certificate from the petitioner
relating to land holding and as obviously the taking on record of
the said certificate would have prejudiced the selected
candidates, who had been prudent enough to submit the
applications along-with all supporting documents, the prayer of
the petitioner cannot be allowed because now the private
respondent, who is serving, cannot be thrown out of job for the
acts of omission and commission of the petitioner.
14.
In light of above observations, as this court finds no
merit in the present petition, the same is dismissed. Pending
miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
March 19, 2026
(Shivank Thakur)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review