Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
29.09.2026
Court No.35.
D/L. 05.
(Rakib/
Suman(PA)
CRM (M) 2513 of 2026
In Re: An Application for Bail under Section 483 of the Bharatiya
Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023/ Section 439 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 in connection with Nandigram PS Case
No. 188
of
dated
08.11.2007
under
Sections
147/148/149/324/307/302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 read
with Sections 25/27 of the Arms Act, 1959.
And
In the matter of : Milan Pradhan
……Petitioner.
Mr. Milon Mukherjee, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Sanjay Banerjee
Mr. Zohaib Rauf
Mr. Ajitesh Pandey
Ms. Sriparna Das
Mr. Sk. Anwar Ali
Mr. Jayanta Narayan Das
Mr. S. Ghosh
Mr. Prasant Bagchi
Ms. Sumitra Neogi
Mr. Abid Jamal
Mr. Manojit Bhattacharya
Ms. Anjana Banaejee
Ms. Srabani Mukhopadhyay
Mr. Samirul Sardar
Mr. Mrinmoy Bhattacharyya
Mr. Abhi Bhattacharya
Mr. Arka Chakrabotry
Mr. Anish Mukherjee
Mr. Kundan Bharti
Mr. Manish Ojha
Mr. Asfak Ahammed
......for the Petitioner.
Mr. Rajdeep Majumdar, Ld. AAG,
Mr. Kallol Mondal, Ld. PP
Mr. Moyukh Mukherjee
Ms. Arushi Rathore
……for the State.
1.
Mr. Mukherjee, learned Senior Advocate appearing on
behalf of the petitioner, submits that in 2007, owing to
the Government’s proposed acquisition of land for
creating a chemical hub at Nandigram, there was mass
agitation, which led to several criminal cases being
registered at the Nandigram and Khejuri Police Stations.
The petitioner was falsely implicated in those cases for
political reasons and with an ulterior motive.
2.
According
to
him,
the
petitioner
is
a
respectable
businessman of the area and was deeply involved in the
historic anti-land acquisition movement in Nandigram in
2007. He is a member of the Indian National Congress
and an office-bearer of the West Bengal Pradesh Congress
Committee.
3.
It was submitted that the petitioner filed his nomination
papers for contesting the elections on 15-09-2026. He
was pressurized to withdraw his nomination on 18-092026 and was thereafter arrested in connection with
cases arising out of the 2007 land agitation, which were
engineered to suppress farmers seeking to protect their
land.
4.
It was only after petitioner filed his nomination papers
that the police authorities executed such a warrant for
the first time in 19 years.
5.
Learned Senior Advocate relied upon the judgment in
Rakesh Kumar Singh in CRM (M) 776 of 2026 and
referred to the relevant paragraphs of the judgment
which are as follows:
“....the case of Mohd. Tahir Hussain involved the
murder of an Intelligence Officer of the Union Home
Ministry, and even in such a grave matter, custody
parole was granted for contesting elections.
At the same time, the possibility of misuse of
interim bail on the pretext of contesting elections
cannot be ruled out. Mohd. Tahir Hussain
cautions against opening a “Pandora’s box,” as
elections occur frequently in the country and may
lead to a flood of bail applications from accused
persons who are not serious contenders.
In the present case, however, it cannot be said that
the petitioner lacks seriousness in contesting the
election. Mr. Mazumder submits that while the
names of other candidates of the opposition party
in West Bengal have already been declared, the
candidate for the Kolkata Port constituency has not
yet been announced due to the pendency of the
present bail application. A letter from the President
of the State unit of the party has also been
produced, indicating that the petitioner’s name has
been proposed for candidature.
In view of the aforesaid facts, this Court is of
the opinion that the petitioner is not seeking bail
merely as a pretext for contesting the election.”
6.
Reference was also made to the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Arvind Kejriwal v. Directorate of
Enforcement reported in (2024) 9 SCC 577, and
reliance was placed on paragraphs 15 and 17 thereof:
“15. Arvind Kejriwal was arrested, as noted
above, on 21-3-2024. More importantly, legality
and validity of the arrest itself is under challenge
before the Supreme Court and we are yet to finally
pronounce on the same. The fact situation cannot
be compared with harvesting of crops or plea to
look after business affairs. In this background,
once the matter is sub judice and the questions
relating
to
legality
of
arrest
are
under
consideration, a more holistic and libertarian view
is justified, in the background that the 18th Lok
Sabha General Elections are being held.
17. We would reject the argument that the
reasoning recorded by us in paras 6, 7 and 13,
results in grant of privilege or special status to
politicians. As observed in paras 6, 7 and 13,
several peculiarities of the case have weighed with
us. In Siba Shankar Das v. State of Odisha [Siba
Shankar Das v. State of Odisha, 2024 SCC OnLine
SC 410] , this Court accepting the appeal, deleted
the condition imposed by the High Court stipulating
that the appellant shall not be involved in any
political activities, directly or indirectly. Imposition
of this condition, the order holds, would breach
fundamental rights. No such condition should be
imposed. A coordinate Bench of this Court in State
of A.P. v. Nara Chandra Babu Naidu [State of A.P.
v. Nara Chandra Babu Naidu, (2024) 9 SCC 584] ,
in an appeal filed by the State, by an interim order
has
deleted
the
condition
restraining
the
respondent therein from organising or participating
in public rallies and meetings, thereby permitting
him to participate in the political process. This
petition seeking special leave to appeal is still
pending.”
7.
Mr. Majumdar, learned Additional Advocate General,
opposes the prayer for bail and at the outset refers to the
applications under Section 321 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure. He submits that in some cases, the learned
Magistrate allowed such applications which in other
cases the application under Section 321 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure was not pressed. Concerning the
issue relating to withdrawal of all the criminal cases, two
public interest litigations were preferred before the
Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta, being WPA (P) 68 of
2021, Nilanjan Adhikary v. State of West Bengal and
Others, and WPA(P) 67 of 2021, Dipak Mishra v. State
of West Bengal and Ors. It was contended that, by an
order dated 05.03.2021, the Division Bench was pleased
to observe as follows:
“...Be that as it may, having considered the
stereotype orders which are impugned in these writ
petitions and looking into the contents of those
orders, we are, prima facie, satisfied that exercise of
judicial power in terms of Section 321 Cr. P.C. to
grant consent to a prosecutor to withdraw has, prima
facie, not been appropriately exercised. We make this
cautious observation because the formation of opinion
of a prosecutor to withdraw a particular case from
prosecution is, itself, an activity which is regulated
by the statute and the judicial precedents governing
the field. Only when the judicial authority is satisfied
that the public prosecutor has acted in terms of the
sound
and
withdrawal
well-settled
of
principles
prosecution,
touching
would
the
the
judicial
authority consider whether consent ought to be
granted to enable such withdrawal. We, therefore,
are of the view that the impugned orders deserve to
have a deeper look at our hands and we are satisfied
that the consequence of the orders impugned in these
writ petitions should stand stayed until a final
decision is taken in these writ petitions.”
8.
By the same order, the Division Bench was pleased to
stay the orders passed by the learned Magistrate allowing
the applications under Section 321 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure. The writ petitions were finally
disposed of by a judgment and order dated 10.02.2025,
allowing the writ petitions and setting aside the orders of
withdrawal passed by the learned Magistrate, as well as
the State’s decision to exercise the power under Section
321 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Court’s
attention was drawn to paragraphs 48, 68 and 89 of the
said judgment, which are set out below:
“48. Writ petitioner in the second writ petition has
assailed steps taken by the State in respect of 6
police cases relating to Nandigram Police Station. The
6 police cases of Nandigram Police Station are FIR No.
111/09 dated May 10, 2009, 75/07 dated April 30,
2007, 80/07 dated May 2, 2007, 188/07 dated
November 8, 2007, 156/07 dated October 10, 2007
and 221/07 dated November 15, 2007. In all the 6
police cases, chargesheets had been filed. Nandigram
Police Station case No. 111/09 dated May 10, 2009
involves 3 dead persons, Nandigram Police Station
case No. 75/07 dated April 30, 2007 involves one
dead person, Nandigram Police Station May 2, 2007
involves one dead person, Nandigram Police Station
case No. 188/07 dated November 8, 2007 involves 3
dead persons, Nandigram Police Station case No.
156/07 dated October 10, 2007 involves one dead
person, Nandigram Police Station case No. 221/07
dated November 15, 2007 involves one dead person.
68. Out of the 10 criminal cases involved in the
present 2 writ petitions, 9 of the criminal cases
involve murder. All 10 involve heinous crimes. Yet one
of the grounds for undertaking an exercise under
section 321 of the criminal procedure code is lack of
evidence. This so-called lack of evidence was not
present when chargesheets were filed in respect of all
the 10 criminal cases. Materials in the case diary do
not suggest that, there are lack of evidence. Failure of
the prosecution to establish such evidence at the trial
cannot
be
equated
with
lack
of
evidence.
Significantly, the Cabinet memorandum refers to right
of private defence being employed. Consequently, the
State is aware of the persons who allegedly set up
the plea of private defence. It is for the Courts at a
trial to decide whether such a plea relating to
homicide is acceptable or not. It is not for the State to
adjudicate such plea or act thereon.
89. Accused in the 10 criminal cases must stand
trial. Murders did take place. Post-mortem reports
available with the case diaries establish such fact.
Therefore, as on date, in the society there are persons
who are guilty of such murders. Allowing the
prosecution to withdraw under Section 321 of the
Criminal Procedure Code will not be in public interest.
In fact, it would cause public harm and injury.”
9.
It is further contended that the petitioner was arrested in
the presence case being Nandigram Police Station Case
No. 188 of 2007.
10. Learned Additional Advocate General appearing on behalf
of the State further emphasised that the petitioner
cannot claim bail as a matter of right merely because he
is a candidate contesting an election; his prayer must be
considered on the same footing as that of any other
person. In this regard, the Court’s attention was drawn to
Mohd. Tahir Hussain v. State (NCT of Delhi), in
Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 856 of 2025. It was
submitted that the question whether a person can claim
release on bail or interim bail for canvassing and
contesting in an election arose before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. The Court’s attention was drawn to the
judgments delivered by Hon’ble Justice Pankaj Mithal
and Hon’ble Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah. As the
Hon’ble Judges differed, the matter was referred to a
Larger Bench. The State also drew attention to the final
order of the Larger Bench, submitting that the petitioner
therein had modified his prayer before that Hon’ble
Larger Bench and sought custody parole for a limited
period, which was allowed subject to payment of costs.
11. On behalf of the State further relied upon Ritlal Yadav v.
State of Bihar, reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Pat 4204,
on the same issue and submitted that the prayer of the
petitioner therein was turned down by the Hon’ble Patna
High Court and that its decision was affirmed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
12. Learned Additional Advocate General also referred to the
order of bail passed in MAT/1651/2026 wherein the
order of the Hon’ble Single Bench was subject matter of
challenge relating to the order of shown arrest being
stayed.
13. I have taken into account the submissions of the
respective
parties,
before
proceeding
further,
it
is
necessary to consider the judgments relating to the grant
or
refusal
of
bail
or
interim
bail
in
the
factual
circumstances of each case.
14. In Arvind Kejriwal (supra), the petitioner was in custody
when he prayed for bail or interim bail to campaign in the
elections to be held for the 18th Lok Sabha General
Election.
15. In Rakesh Kumar Singh (supra), the petitioner was in
custody when he prayed for bail to contest the elections.
Interim bail was granted after the Court considered a
letter from the President of the political party then in
opposition.
16. In Mohd. Tahir Hussain (supra), the bail application
was filed when the petitioner was in custody and
intended to contest the elections.
17. In Ritlal Yadav (supra), the petitioner was in custody
and prayed for release to file his nomination for
contesting the election.
18. This Court is considering a prayer for bail or interim bail.
As such, the judgments referred to by the State
concerning withdrawal of prosecution under Section 321
of the Code of Criminal Procedure have no relevance to
the present prayer.
19. The petitioner’s case is factually distinct from the cases
considered in the judgments relied upon by both parties.
The petitioner was taken into custody after filing his
nomination on 15.09.2026; he was not in custody when
he filed the nomination papers. The petitioner claims that
he has been arrested in connection with cases that are 19
years old, arising from violence that erupted and
continued
throughout
between
villagers
apprehensive of eviction, displacement and loss of their
land for the establishment of a chemical hub, and the
police administration, while acting on behalf of the
Government, behaved in an oppressive manner. The
events at Nandigram form part of the history of West
Bengal, particularly the farmers’ struggle to protect the
land acquisition to which they were deeply attached. The
Calcutta High Court took suo moto cognizance of the
Nandigram violence which dealt with indiscriminate
police firing on protesters without provocation resulting
in death of 14 civilians. The CBI was directed to initiate
criminal enquiry/investigation to such police action.
20. The
following
issues
arise
for
disposing of the bail application:
consideration
while
(i)
The petitioner is a political activist who was
associated with the land movement at Nandigram in
2007. His political involvement is also evident from
his participation in the present election as the
candidate of a political party.
(ii)
The petitioner is accused in several murder cases.
All the cases relate to the year 2007 and are
associated
with
two
police
stations,
namely,
Nandigram Police Station and Khejuri Police Station.
(iii) Petitioner’s
case
is
distinguishable
from
the
judgments relied upon by the respective parties. In
none of those cases was a contesting candidate
arrested after filing his nomination papers. In
Rakesh Kumar Singh (supra), a Coordinate Bench
granted interim bail, but the circumstances were not
similar. The Court specifically observed in that case
that the petitioner was not claiming bail on the
pretext of contesting the election.
(iv) The police authorities and both police stations had
opportunities to execute the processes in these
cases, which are more than 19 years old. In some of
the judgements relied upon, an accused person
already in custody filed nomination papers and
sought release on parole to canvass and contest the
election.
(v)
The Hon’ble Supreme Court’s observation in Arvind
Kejriwal (supra) that a holistic approach must be
adopted applies to the present petitioner as well.
21.
Relying upon the aforesaid judgments and the concept of
interim bail as has been detailed in paragraphs 8 to 13 in
the judgement of Arvind Kejriwal (supra), I am of the
opinion that petitioner may be granted an opportunity to
contest the election and to that effect he may be released on
interim bail.
22. Accordingly, the petitioner, namely, Milan Pradhan shall be
released
on
interim
bail
upon
furnishing
bond
of
Rs.20,000/- (Rupees Twenty Thousand only), with two
sureties of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees Ten Thousand only) each,
one of whom must be local to the satisfaction of the learned
Additional
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate,
Haldia,
Purba
Medinipur.
23. If on bail, the petitioner shall provide his mobile phone
number to the Officer-in-Charge of Nandigram police
station who would regularly call the petitioner between
10.30 am - 11.30 am and 8.30 pm - 9.30 pm twice regularly
to check the whereabouts of the petitioner.
24. The said interim bail will be valid for three weeks till 20th of
October, 2026.
25. Petitioner
will
surrender
himself
before
the
learned
Jurisdictional Court being learned Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Haldia on 21st of October, 2026.
26. With the aforesaid observations, CRM (M) 2513 of 2026 is
disposed of.
27. All parties shall act in terms of server copy of the order
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
28. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all
requisite formalities.
(Tirthankar Ghosh, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review