Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010488532022
+
CS(COMM) 916/2022, I.A. 22331/2022 & I.A. 2915/2023
Date of Decision: 05.10.2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
METIS EDUVENTURES PRIVATE LIMITED INDIA
REGISTERED ADDRESS AT:
2 A/3, KUMDAN MANSION ASAF ALI ROAD,
NEW DELHI-110002
ALSO AT
1002, 10TH FLOOR, TOWER C,
UNITECH CYBER PARK,
SECTOR 39, GURGAON 122002
(Through:
.....PLAINTIFF
Ms. Ekta Sarin and Ms. Sugandha Yadav, Advs.)
versus
CAREER POWER COACHING CENTRE PRIVATE LIMITED
263, BISHNOI COLONY HISAR 125001 (HARYANA)
M/S METIS EDUVANTURES, 193,
RED SQUARE MARKET,
NEAR MIRAJ CINEMA, HISAR, HARYANA
ALSO AT:
SCO-166, RED SQUARE MARKET,
NEAR BIKANER SWEET, HISAR,
HARAYANA 125001.
ARUN KUMAR
DIRECTOR OF
CAREER POWER COACHING CENTRE
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
PRIVATE LIMITED
263, BISHNOI COLONY HISAR 125001
ALSO AT
HOUSE NO. 15B, ASHOK VIHAR
AZADNAGAR, HISAR, HARYANA,
125001
KULDEEP
PROPRIETOR OF
M/S METIS EDUVANTURES,
R/O SHYAM FURNITURE HOUSE,
NEAR KHALERI PALACE, AZAD
NAGAR, HISAR, HARYANA -125001.
.....DEFENDANTS
(Through:
None.)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
JUDGEMENT
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. (ORAL)
1.
The plaintiff has instituted the present commercial suit seeking a
decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendants from passing off
their services as those of the plaintiff through use of the mark ‘CAREER
POWER’ and its device, from using the trade name ‘METIS
EDUVANTURES’, and from infringing the copyright in the artistic work
comprised in the plaintiff’s device mark, along with ancillary reliefs of
rendition of accounts, delivery up, damages and costs.
2.
Vide orders dated 04.10.2024 and 03.04.2025, defendant nos.4 and 2,
respectively, were proceeded against ex parte, and neither of them has filed
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
a written statement. Insofar as defendant nos.1 and 3 are concerned, the suit
already stands decreed against them, with their consent, vide this Court’s
order dated 03.04.2025. As a result, there is no defendant who is contesting
the suit.
3.
The matter is taken up today on the plaintiff’s request for
pronouncement of judgment under Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’) against defendant nos.2 and 4.
4.
The plaintiff, Metis Eduventures Private Limited India, is a company
incorporated on 16.02.2012, having its registered office at Asaf Ali Road,
New Delhi. It is engaged in developing, conducting and offering training
and other courses, including instruction methodology, courseware and
operational systems, and has developed specialised coaching programmes
for aspirants of the Staff Selection Commission, banking and other
competitive examinations. These programmes are delivered through
coaching institutes, either owned by the plaintiff or franchised and licensed
by it, which operate under the mark ‘CAREER POWER’.
5.
According to the plaintiff, the mark ‘CAREER POWER’ and its
device, which comprises the words ‘CAREER POWER’ in a blue and red
colour scheme with a blue underline, together with a stylised figure of a
person in red and blue placed within a white box, were adopted in the year
2010, when the first branch was opened in Noida. The plaintiff pleads use
since 2010. It claims to operate more than 70 branches across the country
and to carry on business through the websites www.careerpower.in and
www.adda247.com, besides having a substantial following on YouTube,
Instagram and Facebook.
6.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
The mark is not registered. The plaintiff’s first application for
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
registration of the device mark, dated 08.10.2012 in Class 41, was refused.
Its second application, dated 28.05.2019 in Class 41, filed on a ‘proposed to
be used’ basis, was advertised in Trade Marks Journal No.2044-0 dated
21.03.2022 and was opposed by defendant no.3 vide application dated
11.05.2022. The suit is, therefore, founded on the plaintiff’s common law
rights in the mark, actionable in passing off, and on the copyright claimed by
the plaintiff as the author of the artistic and literary work in the device mark.
7.
Defendant no.1, Career Power Coaching Centre Private Limited, is a
company incorporated on 04.01.2021, having its office at Hisar, Haryana,
and defendant no.3, Mr. Arun Kumar, is its director. Defendant no.2, M/s
Metis Eduvantures, is described in the plaint as a proprietorship concern,
having its principal place of business at Hisar, Haryana.
8.
The plaintiff entered into a Franchise Agreement and a Brand
Licensing Agreement, both dated 31.12.2018, with defendant no.4, whereby
a non-exclusive, non-transferable and non-assignable licence was granted to
use the plaintiff’s intellectual property for imparting classroom training. The
plaint states that defendant no.2 was thereafter reconstituted as a partnership
under a Partnership Deed dated 15.02.2019, of which defendant no.4 and
defendant no.3 were among the ten partners. On 01.04.2019, the plaintiff
entered into a Brand Licensing and Brand Supply Agreement with these
franchisees, valid until 31.03.2021 under Clause 20.1 and renewable at the
sole discretion of the plaintiff upon thirty days advance notice under Clause
20.6.
9.
The plaintiff pleads that no notice of renewal was ever received, and
the agreement accordingly came to an end on 31.03.2021. Under its terms,
the licensees had agreed that, upon termination for any reason, the licence
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
would immediately terminate, they would immediately cease use of the
trademark ‘CAREER POWER’ and the associated know-how, return all
material bearing the plaintiff’s intellectual property, and not apply for or use
any trademark identical or similar to the plaintiff’s mark.
10.
Insofar as the trading name is concerned, the plaint specifically avers
that defendant no.2 adopted the name ‘Metis Eduvantures’, which is
visually, phonetically and conceptually identical to the plaintiff’s corporate
name, and that the plaintiff did not object to it earlier only because
defendant no.2 was its licensee and was conducting its operations on the
plaintiff’s behalf.
11.
The plaintiff issued a cease and desist notice dated 03.06.2022 to all
the parties to the agreement, which remained unanswered. It also came to
light that defendant no.3 had applied for registration of the impugned device
mark Class 41 on a ‘proposed to be used’ basis. In December 2022, the
plaintiff came across the Facebook and Instagram pages titled ‘Career Power
Hisar’, operated by defendant no.1, which displayed the impugned device
mark and linked to the plaintiff’s own website. The present suit came to be
filed thereafter.
12.
On 23.12.2022, summons were issued in the suit and notice was
issued in the application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC, being I.A.
22331/2022. The Court noted the plaintiff’s reliance on Clause 6 of the
agreement and on a decision of a co-ordinate Bench in the following terms:
“23. Counsel for the plaintiff has drawn attention of the Court to Clause 6
of the aforesaid Agreement to show that (i) the parties to the Agreement
acknowledged the fact of the plaintiff being the sole owner and proprietor
of the intellectual property forming subject matter of the present suit; and
(ii) the franchisee/licensee did not have the right to use the intellectual
property of the plaintiff on termination of the Agreement.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
xxx
xxx
xxx
26. Counsel for the plaintiff has relied upon the judgment of a Coordinate
Bench dated 16th October, 2018 in CS(COMM) 236/2016 titled Ritanand
Balved Education Foundation v. Ranchhod M Shah & Ors., wherein it has
been observed that an action of passing off is based on confusion and
deception and would apply with greater force in the field of education.
xxx
xxx
xxx
31. Based on the averments in the plaint and submissions made on behalf
of the plaintiffs, a prima facie case is made out on behalf of the plaintiff.
Balance of convenience is in favour of the plaintiff and against the
defendants. Irreparable harm would be caused to the plaintiff as well as to
the public unless the defendants are restrained by way of an ad interim
injunction.”
13.
By the same order, the defendants and all those acting on their behalf
were restrained, until the next date of hearing, from advertising, marketing
or offering on third-party websites, including www.facebook.com, services
bearing the impugned marks or any mark identical or deceptively similar to
the plaintiff’s mark ‘CAREER POWER’ and its device, in relation to
education, providing training, entertainment, sporting and cultural activities.
Defendant nos.1 and 3 were also directed to take down the Facebook page
titled ‘Career Power Hisar’. The ad interim injunction has continued
thereafter.
14.
On 23.11.2023, the Court took note of an affidavit dated 17.07.2023
filed on behalf of defendant nos.1 and 3, in which it was deposed that the
Facebook page ‘Career Power Hisar’ and the listings on third-party websites
had been taken down, and that the name of their coaching centre had been
changed, after the injunction order, to ‘CPC’ in January 2023, and was later
modified to ‘CP Hisar’.
15.
Vide Order dated 03.04.2025, the suit was decreed against defendant
nos.1 and 3 on their consent. The relevant part of the order reads as under:
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
“3. Accordingly, a decree of permanent injunction is passed in favour of
the plaintiff and against the defendants no.1 and 3 in terms of prayer
clauses contained in paragraph no.89(a) to (d) of the plaint.
4. It is further directed that the defendant no.1 shall change its corporate
name in a manner so as to not include the mark „CAREER POWER‟ or
any other mark deceptively similar to the plaintiff‟s trade mark.
xxx
xxx
xxx
6. The defendant no.3 also undertakes to withdraw the opposition bearing
no.1163738 filed by him against the trade mark application bearing
no.4189642 filed on behalf of the plaintiff within two (2) weeks from today.
7. Mr. Sunil Kumar Bhardwaj, counsel appearing on behalf of the
defendants no.1 and 3, submits that it has been inadvertently noted in the
order passed on 4th October, 2024 that he is representing the defendant
no.2 as well. However, he has no instructions to appear for the defendant
no.2.
8. To be noted, the defendant no.4 was proceeded against ex-parte on 4th
October, 2024.
9. Since no appearance has been entered on behalf of the defendant no.2
despite service, the defendant no.2 is also proceeded against ex-parte.”
16.
On 08.09.2025, the plaintiff did not press I.A. 2913/2023, which had
been filed under Order XXXIX Rule 2A CPC, on the statement that
defendant nos.1 to 4 had complied with the injunction order dated
23.12.2022. Learned counsel for the plaintiff further stated that she was
pressing for a decree against defendant nos.2 and 4.
17.
Learned counsel for the plaintiff submits that a decree in terms of the
reliefs prayed for in paragraph 89(a) to (d) of the plaint ought to be passed
against defendant nos.2 and 4, namely, permanent injunction against passing
off of the plaintiff’s services offered under the mark ‘CAREER POWER’
and its device, against passing off of the plaintiff’s trading name ‘METIS
EDUVENTURES PRIVATE LIMITED’, against unfair competition,
dilution and tarnishment, and against infringement of copyright.
18.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
It is contended that the failure of defendant nos.2 and 4 to enter
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
appearance and present their written statements must be construed as an
admission of the plaintiff’s rights. Reliance is placed upon the decision in
Inter Ikea Systems BV v. Imtiaz Ahamed,1 to submit that a party who
chooses not to participate in the proceedings cannot be allowed to enjoy an
advantage for such conduct.
19.
Learned counsel, on instructions, gives up the reliefs of damages and
costs, and confines the claim against defendant nos.2 and 4 to the reliefs of
permanent injunction contained in paragraph 89(a) to (d) of the plaint.
20.
I have heard learned counsel for the plaintiff and perused the record.
21.
Defendant no.4 was served by publication and was taken to be duly
served on 04.10.2024. He has never entered appearance and was proceeded
against ex parte on the same date. Defendant no.2 was also taken to be
served on 04.10.2024. Even if its time to file a written statement is reckoned
from that date, the outer limit of 120 days under the proviso to Order VIII
Rule 1 CPC, as applicable to commercial disputes, expired in the first week
of February 2025. No written statement was filed, and defendant no.2 was
proceeded against ex parte on 03.04.2025.
22.
The present suit is a commercial suit. The consequence of not filing a
written statement within the outer limit of 120 days in such a suit is no
longer open to debate. In SCG Contracts (India) (P) Ltd. v. K.S.
Chamankar Infrastructure (P) Ltd.,2, the Supreme Court held as under:
“8. A perusal of these provisions would show that ordinarily a written
statement is to be filed within a period of 30 days. However, grace period
of a further 90 days is granted which the Court may employ for reasons to
be recorded in writing and payment of such costs as it deems fit to allow
such written statement to come on record. What is of great importance is
2016 SCC OnLine Del 6717.
(2019) 12 SCC 210.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
the fact that beyond 120 days from the date of service of summons, the
defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written statement and the Court
shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record. This is further
buttressed by the proviso in Order VIII Rule 10 also adding that the Court
has no further power to extend the time beyond this period of 120 days.”
23.
The right of defendant nos.2 and 4 to file a written statement,
therefore, stands forfeited, and the case squarely falls within Order VIII Rule
10 CPC.
24.
Order VIII Rule 10 CPC, as it applies to commercial disputes, reads
as under:
“10. Procedure when party fails to present written statement called for by
Court.—Where any party from whom a written statement is required under
rule 1 or rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed
by the Court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment
against him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and
on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up.
Provided further that no Court shall make an order to extend the time
provided under Rule 1 of this Order for filing of the written statement.”
25.
The provision has to be read with Order VIII Rule 5(2) CPC, which
provides that where the defendant has not filed a pleading, it shall be lawful
for the Court to pronounce judgment on the basis of the facts contained in
the plaint, except as against a person under a disability, but the Court may,
in its discretion, require any such fact to be proved.
26.
The scope of these provisions was explained by the Supreme Court in
Balraj Taneja v. Sunil Madan,3 which arose from a decree passed by this
Court under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC in a suit for specific performance. The
Supreme Court first noticed the two distinct provisions which operate on the
failure to file a written statement:
“There are thus two separate and distinct provisions under which the
Court can pronounce judgment on the failure of the defendant to file
(1999) 8 SCC 396.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Written Statement. The failure may be either under Order 8 Rule 5(2)
under which the Court may either pronounce judgment on the basis of the
facts set out in the plaint or require the plaintiff to prove any such fact; or
the failure may be under Order 8 Rule 10 CPC under which the Court is
required to pronounce judgment against the defendant or to pass such
order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit.”
27.
After examining Order XII Rule 6 CPC and Section 58 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872, the Supreme Court held that the Court cannot act
mechanically, and laid down the test to be applied before pronouncing
judgment against a defendant who has not filed a written statement:
“In view of the above, it is clear that the Court, at no stage, can act blindly
or mechanically. While enabling the Court to pronounce judgment in a
situation where no Written Statement is filed by the defendant, the Court
has also been given the discretion to pass such order as it may think fit as
an alternative. This is also the position under Order 8 Rule 10 CPC where
the Court can either pronounce judgment against the defendant or pass
such order as it may think fit.
xxx
xxx
xxx
29. As pointed out earlier, the court has not to act blindly upon the
admission of a fact made by the defendant in his written statement nor
should the court proceed to pass judgment blindly merely because a
written statement has not been filed by the defendant traversing the facts
set out by the plaintiff in the plaint filed in the court. In a case, specially
where a written statement has not been filed by the defendant, the court
should be a little cautious in proceeding under Order 8 Rule 10 CPC.
Before passing the judgment against the defendant it must see to it that
even if the facts set out in the plaint are treated to have been admitted, a
judgment could possibly be passed in favour of the plaintiff without
requiring him to prove any fact mentioned in the plaint. It is a matter of
the court‟s satisfaction and, therefore, only on being satisfied that there is
no fact which need be proved on account of deemed admission, the court
can conveniently pass a judgment against the defendant who has not filed
the written statement. But if the plaint itself indicates that there are
disputed questions of fact involved in the case regarding which two
different versions are set out in the plaint itself, it would not be safe for the
court to pass a judgment without requiring the plaintiff to prove the facts
so as to settle the factual controversy. Such a case would be covered by the
expression “the court may, in its discretion, require any such fact to be
proved” used in sub-rule (2) of Rule 5 Order 8, or the expression “may
make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit” used in Rule 10
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Order 8.”
28.
The Supreme Court also emphasised that a decision under Order VIII
Rule 10 CPC must be a judgment in the sense of Section 2(9) and Order XX
Rule 4(2) CPC:
“It should be a self-contained document from which it should appear as to
what were the facts of the case and what was the controversy which was
tried to be settled by the Court and in what manner. The process of
reasoning by which the Court came to the ultimate conclusion and decreed
the suit should be reflected clearly in the judgment.
xxx
xxx
xxx
Whether it is a case which is contested by the defendants by filing a
written statement, or a case which proceeds ex-parte and is ultimately
decided as an ex-parte case, or is a case in which the written statement is
not filed and the case is decided under Order 8 Rule 10, the Court has to
write a judgment which must be in conformity with the provisions of the
Code or at least set out the reasoning by which the controversy is
resolved.”
29.
These principles were reiterated in C.N. Ramappa Gowda v. C.C.
Chandregowda,4 where the Supreme Court explained that the object of the
provision is to expedite the disposal of the suit and not to penalise the
defendant:
“25. We find sufficient assistance from the apt observations of this Court
extracted hereinabove which has held that the effect of non-filing of the
written statement and proceeding to try the suit is clearly to expedite the
disposal of the suit and is not penal in nature wherein the defendant has to
be penalised for non-filing of the written statement by trying the suit in a
mechanical manner by passing a decree. We wish to reiterate that in a
case where written statement has not been filed, the court should be a little
more cautious in proceeding under Order 8 Rule 10 CPC and before
passing a judgment, it must ensure that even if the facts set out in the
plaint are treated to have been admitted, a judgment and decree could not
possibly be passed without requiring him to prove the facts pleaded in the
plaint.
26. It is only when the court for recorded reasons is fully satisfied that
there is no fact which needs to be proved at the instance of the plaintiff in
(2012) 5 SCC 265.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
view of the deemed admission by the defendant, the court can conveniently
pass a judgment and decree against the defendant who has not filed the
written statement. But, if the plaint itself indicates that there are disputed
questions of fact involved in the case arising from the plaint itself giving
rise to two versions, it would not be safe for the court to record an ex
parte judgment without directing the plaintiff to prove the facts so as to
settle the factual controversy. In that event, the ex parte judgment although
may appear to have decided the suit expeditiously, it ultimately gives rise
to several layers of appeal after appeal which ultimately compounds the
delay in finally disposing of the suit giving rise to multiplicity of
proceedings which hardly promotes the cause of speedy trial.”
30.
In the context of commercial suits, a co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in Nirog Pharma (P) Ltd. v. Umesh Gupta,5 has held that the provision
should be invoked where the defendant fails to pursue its case, while
cautioning that the plaint and documents must be of an unimpeachable
character:
“11. Order VIII Rule 10 has been inserted by the legislature to expedite
the process of justice. The courts can invoke its provisions to curb dilatory
tactic, often resorted to by defendants, by not filing the written statement
by pronouncing judgment against it. At the same time, the courts must be
cautious and judge the contents of the plaint and documents on record as
being of an unimpeachable character, not requiring any evidence to be led
to prove its contents.
xxx
xxx
xxx
28. The present suit is also a commercial suit within the definition of the
Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate
Division of High Courts Act, 2015 and it was the clear intention of the
legislature that such cases should be decided expeditiously and should not
be allowed to linger on. Accordingly, if the defendant fails to pursue his
case or does so in a lackadaisical manner by not filing his written
statement, the courts should invoke the provisions of Order VIII Rule 10 to
decree such cases.”
31.
As regards the need for ex parte evidence in suits of this nature, where
the plaintiff confines itself to the relief of injunction, a co-ordinate Bench of
(2016) 235 DLT 354.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
this Court in Satya Infrastructure Ltd. v. Satya Infra & Estates (P) Ltd.,6
observed as under:
“4. The next question which arises is whether this Court should consider
the application for interim relief and direct the plaintiffs to lead ex parte
evidence. The counsel for the plaintiffs states that the plaintiffs are willing
to give up the reliefs of delivery, of rendition of accounts and of recovery
of damages, if the suit for the relief of injunction alone were to be heard
today.
5. I am of the opinion that no purpose will be served in such cases by
directing the plaintiffs to lead ex parte evidence in the form of affidavit by
way of examination-in-chief and which invariably is a repetition of the
contents of the plaint. The plaint otherwise, as per the amended CPC,
besides being verified, is also supported by affidavits of the plaintiffs. I fail
to fathom any reason for according any additional sanctity to the affidavit
by way of examination-in-chief than to the affidavit in support of the plaint
or to any exhibit marks being put on the documents which have been filed
by the plaintiffs and are already on record. I have therefore heard the
counsel for the plaintiffs on merits qua the relief of injunction.”
32.
Applying these principles, the first circumstance which deserves
notice is that there is no contesting defendant left in the suit. Defendant
nos.1 and 3, who alone had appeared and filed a reply to the interim
injunction application, have suffered a decree on 03.04.2025 in terms of the
very same reliefs, i.e. paragraph 89(a) to (d) of the plaint, which are now
sought against defendant nos.2 and 4. In Asma Lateef (supra) the Supreme
Court cautioned that where even one of several defendants has filed a
written statement, the Court should ordinarily prefer the second alternative
under Rule 10. That caution is meant to avoid a situation where a decree
against a defaulting defendant may conflict with the outcome of a trial on
the defence raised by a contesting co-defendant. No such possibility exists
here. The co-defendants have not set up any defence that survives for trial.
There is, therefore, no defence on record and no version other than the
2013 (54) PTC 419 (Del).
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
plaintiff’s, which leaves nothing to be tried.
33.
Additionally, the plaint has been verified and is supported by the
affidavit of the plaintiff’s authorised signatory. Defendant nos.2 and 4 have
filed no affidavit of admission and denial of the plaintiff’s documents, and
those documents are, therefore, deemed to be admitted in terms of Order XI
Rule 4 CPC as applicable to commercial suits. A co-ordinate Bench of this
Court, in Ashok Kumar Gupta v. Arif Khan,7 decreed a similar suit in the
following terms:
“24. The plaint has been duly verified and is also supported by the
affidavit of the plaintiff. In view of the fact that no written statement has
been filed on behalf of the defendant, all the averments made in the plaint
have to be taken to be admitted. Further, since no affidavit of
admission/denial has been filed on behalf of the defendant in respect of the
documents filed with the plaint, in terms of Rule 3 of the Delhi High Court
(Original Side) Rules 2018, the same are deemed to have been admitted.
therefore, in my opinion this suit does not merit trial and the suit is
capable of being decreed in terms of Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC.”
34.
In these circumstances, this Court satisfied that no fact remains which
needs to be proved by evidence, and that directing the plaintiff to lead ex
parte evidence would serve no purpose other than to repeat the contents of
the verified plaint. The suit is, therefore, capable of being decided on the
basis of the pleadings and documents on record. Nonetheless, consistent
with Balraj Taneja (supra) and Asma Lateef (supra), the Court must still
examine whether the facts so admitted entitle the plaintiff to the reliefs
claimed.
35.
It was recorded on 08.09.2025 that defendant nos.1 to 4 had complied
with the injunction order dated 23.12.2022. That compliance, however, was
made under the compulsion of an interim order which will not survive the
CS(COMM) 608/2023, decided on 28.02.2025.
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
disposal of the suit. Defendant nos.2 and 4 have not appeared to give any
undertaking to the Court, and there is nothing on record to assure the Court
that the use will not resume once the interim order ceases to operate. In fact,
their persistent absence despite service is itself a reason why the plaintiff’s
rights must be secured by a final decree.
36.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the suit is decreed in favour of
the plaintiff and against defendant nos.2 and 4 in terms of paragraph 89(a) to
(d) of the plaint.
37.
Defendant nos.2 and 4, their principal officers, servants, agents,
affiliates, and all others acting for and on their behalf, are permanently
restrained from using, advertising, marketing or offering services, including
on third-party websites such as www.facebook.com, under the impugned
mark or any other mark identical or deceptively similar to the plaintiff’s
mark ‘CAREER POWER’ and its device, which is the subject of
Application No.4189642 in Class 41, in relation to education, providing of
training, entertainment, sporting and cultural activities, so as to pass off their
services as those of the plaintiff, in terms of paragraph 89(a) of the plaint;
38.
Defendant nos.2 and 4, and all others acting for and on their behalf,
are
permanently
restrained
from
using
the
name
‘METIS
EDUVANTURES’, or any other name identical or deceptively similar to the
plaintiff’s trading name ‘METIS EDUVENTURES PRIVATE LIMITED
INDIA’, in relation to the aforesaid services, so as to pass off their business
as that of the plaintiff, in terms of paragraph 89(b) of the plaint;
39.
A decree of permanent injunction is also passed against defendant
nos.2 and 4 in terms of paragraph 89(c) and (d) of the plaint, restraining
unfair competition, dilution and tarnishment of the plaintiff’s mark, and
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
infringement of the copyright in the artistic and literary work in the
plaintiff’s device mark.
40.
The decree passed against defendant nos.1 and 3 on 03.04.2025 shall
continue to operate in its own terms.
41.
The Registry is directed to draw up the decree sheet.
42.
The suit, along with the pending applications, stands disposed of.
(PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 05, 2026/P/NK
Signed By:PRIYA
16:07:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review