Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 17th July, 2026
Pronounced on: 01st October, 2026
Uploaded on: 01st October, 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010556122024
+
RFA 566/2024, CM APPL. 50213/2024, CM APPL. 50215/2024,
CM APPL. 65220/2024, CM APPL. 9147/2025
M/s METAL CANS COMPANY
Through its Partner Shri Ajay Kumar,
Having its office at C-100 (Khasra No.1024)
Road No. 6, Mahipalpur,
New Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Ms. Geeta Luthra, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Vipul Gupta, Mr. Pranjal Pandey,
Mr. Anuj Singh, Ms. Janvi Desai,
Mr. Rishabh Dahiya, Ms. Prashansika
Thakur, Ms. Spriha Jha, Advocates.
Versus
1.
BHUVAN MOHAN
S/o Shri Ishwari Prasad
Chandiwala Estate, Maa Anandmal Ashram Marg,
Kalkaji, New Delhi-110019.
....Respondent No.1
2.
M/S SUKESHI INTERNATIONAL
Through its Partner, Ms Sujata Gupta
D-317, Sector-47, Nodia,
Uttar Pradesh.
.....Respondent No.2
Through: Mr. Suhail Dutt, Senior Advocate
with
Mr.
Sankalp
Goswami,
Mr. Sagar Suri, Mr. Kabir S. Ghosh,
Advocates for R-1
Mr. Sarthak Ghonkrokta, Advocate
for R-2
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
1.
E N T
The present First Regular Appeal under Section 96 read with
Order XLIII Rule 1 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟), has been filed on
behalf of the Appellant assailing the Judgment and Decree dated 18.05.2024,
whereby the Suit of the Plaintiff bearing CS(OS) No. 55542/2016, for
Possession, has been decreed under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC.
2.
The facts, in brief, are that the Plaintiff is the owner of property
measuring 2,200 sq. yds., bearing Khasra No. 1024, now renumbered as C100, Road No. 6, Mahipalpur, New Delhi–110037 (hereinafter referred to
as the “suit property”). He claimed to have let out a portion admeasuring
about 800 sq. yds., comprising a tin shed and a pucca room, to Defendant
No. 2, M/s Sukeshi International, for running a factory, on rent of ₹3,250
per month with effect from 01.05.1993, exclusive of water and electricity
charges. The Plaintiff also alleged that unauthorised construction had been
raised on the premises in violation of the Municipal byelaws, without
obtaining his consent.
3.
In the year 2011, the Defendant No. 1, M/s Metal Cans Company,
expressed its intent to become a direct tenant under the Plaintiff with the
consent of M/s Sudha Devi, partner of the Defendant No. 2, which was
agreed by both the Defendants. Thereafter, the Defendant No. 1 started
paying rent @Rs.1,00,000/- per annum, to the Plaintiff by cheque, for the
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
entire premises. Defendant No. 1 admitted and acknowledged the Plaintiff as
its landlord. Mr. B.R. Kapurai, the Chief Executive of the Defendant No. 1,
gave cheque No. 759764 in the year 2011 in the sum of Rs.1,00,000/- along
with the covering letter. Another cheque dated 10.05.2013 for Rs.1,00,000/was given for the next year. The rent was increased to Rs.1,25,000/- and
was paid vide cheque dated 08.04.2014, for the period till 31.03.2014.
4.
The Plaintiff further stated that he did not intend to keep the
Defendant No. 1 as a tenant and thereby, served a Notice under Section 106
of the Transfer of Property Act (hereinafter referred to as „TPA‟) dated
27.06.2014, terminating the tenancy w.e.f. 31.12.2014. The Defendant No. 1
failed to vacate the suit property despite Notice.
5.
Hence, the Suit was filed for Recovery of Rs.93,750/- for Arrears of
Rent; Rs.10,00,000/- as Damages for user and occupation charges;
Mandatory Injunction to remove the unauthorised construction and
Permanent Injunction to restrain the Defendants from creating third party
rights in the suit property.
6.
The Defendant No. 1, M/s Metal Cans Company/Appellant, in its
Written Statement submitted that the suit property had been given by Ms.
Sujata Gupta, partner of M/s Sukeshi International at the rent of Rs.3,250/per month, in the year 1983, which was increased to Rs.3,500/- per month
and that he has been paying the rent. A preliminary objection was taken that
since the rent was Rs.3,500/- as paid by it to M/s Sukeshi International till
July, 2012. The Suit was barred under Section 50 of the Delhi Rent Control
Act, 1958 (for short „DRC Act‟).
7.
The defendant No.1 asserted that it is in possession of the factory
shed, since last 32 years. In fact, the Defendant No. 1 had paid a sum of
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
Rs.2,65,000/- in the year 1983, to the Defendant No. 2, which was a huge
amount then. The arrangement of tenancy was made in perpetuity and the
Defendant No. 2 could not seek eviction of the Defendant No. 1, from the
suit property. The Plaintiff is also estopped from claiming that the suit
property had earlier been let out to M/s Sukeshi International/Defendant No.
2.
8.
However,
the
Defendants
admitted
making
a
payment
of
Rs.3,25,000/- to the Plaintiff, but it was denied that there was any Oral
Agreement between the Plaintiff and the Defendant No. 1 of any sort. The
Defendant No. 1 thus, sought the dismissal of the Suit of the Plaintiff.
9.
The Defendant No. 2, M/s Sukeshi International, (which was added
subsequently as Defendant No. 2 vide Order dated 15.12.2016,) in its
Written Statement corroborated the assertions in the Plaint. It was stated
that since the Defendant No. 1 wanted to become a direct tenant under the
Plaintiff, an Oral Agreement between the Plaintiff and the Defendant No. 1,
was entered into whereafter, the amount/rent was being paid directly to the
Plaintiff, which was accepted by the Plaintiff, on yearly basis.
10.
The Plaintiff in the Replication to the two Written Statements,
reiterated the assertions as made in the Plaint and it was explained that the
Defendant No. 2 had ceased to have any concern with the suit premises as
the Defendant No. 1 had been accepted as a tenant.
11.
The Issues framed vide Order Dated. 12.09.2022, are as under:i) Whether the suit is barred in terms of section 50 of Delhi
Rent Control Act? OPD
ii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of possession
of suit property i.e. plot of land with tin shed situated at
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
Khasra No. 1024, renumbered as C-100, Road No.6,
Mahipal Pur, New Delhi-110037. OPP
iii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for the
arrears of rent for a sum of Rs. 93,750/-? OPP
iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for damages
to the tune of Rs. 10,00,000/- w.e.f. 01.01.2015 to
31.05.2015 and further damages till the vacation of the suit
property? OPP
v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of mandatory
injunction directing the defendant to remove unauthorized
construction over the suit property? OPP
vi) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of permanent
injunction restraining the defendant from subletting or
parting with the suit property? OPP
vii) Relief.
12.
During the trial, the Plaintiff filed Applications under Order XII
Rule 6 and Order XXXIX Rule 10 CPC. The Defendants also filed an
Application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, which was subsequently
withdrawn. By a common Judgment dated 18.05.2024, the Plaintiff’s
Applications under Orders XII Rule 6 and XXXIX Rule 10 CPC, were
decided.
13.
While allowing the Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, the
Trial Court held that the Plaintiff’s ownership of the suit property, had not
been effectively disputed. It noted that Defendant No. 1 admitted its status
as a tenant, though it claimed to be a tenant of Defendant No. 2. The
Defendant No. 2, however, corroborated the Plaintiff’s case; it was held that
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
a landlord–tenant relationship existed between the Plaintiff and Defendant
No. 1.
14.
It further observed that, even if the last paid rent was ₹3,500 per
month, rent had not been paid since 2012 and interest at 15% per annum was
payable under Section 26 of the DRC Act. Relying on Raghbir Singh v.
Sheela Wanti, AIR 2009 NOC 1851 (Del.), it treated the interest liability as
part of the rent and calculated the monthly amount at ₹4,025. Consequently,
it was held that the suit was not barred under Section 50 of the DRC Act.
The Ld. Trial Court also found that the notice under Section 106 of the TPA,
had been duly served and decreed the suit for possession.
15.
The Application under Order XXXIX Rule 10 CPC, was also allowed.
The Plaintiff was held entitled to use and occupation charges at ₹3,00,000
per month from the date of filing of the suit until Defendant No. 1 delivered
vacant possession.
16.
Aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 18.05.2024, allowing
the Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, Defendant No. 1 has
preferred the present appeal.
17.
The grounds of challenge, are that The Trial Court has overlooked
material admissions made by the Plaintiff in his examination-in-chief and
cross-examination, which, according to the Appellant, contradicted his
pleadings. The Plaintiff admitted that the Lease executed with Defendant
No. 2 in April 1983, had not been revoked or cancelled; that he had not
issued an attornment letter to Defendant No. 1, and that no witness was
present when the alleged oral tenancy was created. The Appellant also relied
on the Plaintiff’s alleged lack of knowledge about the property and
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
contended that the unregistered Agreement to Sell relied upon by him, did
not confer title.
18.
The Plaintiff’s case regarding the tenancy, was challenged as
inconsistent. While the plaint alleges a direct tenancy between the Plaintiff
and Defendant No. 1, the Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC is said to
proceed on the basis of a tenancy through Defendant No. 2. The Appellant
further contended that, in his replication to Defendant No. 1’s Written
Statement, the Plaintiff denied that Defendant No. 2 had any connection
with the suit property.
19.
The finding that the rent exceeded ₹3,500 per month, thereby ousting
the jurisdiction of the Rent Controller under Section 50 of the Delhi Rent
Control Act, was also questioned. The Plaintiff allegedly arrived at rent of
₹4,025 by adding 15% interest to the last admitted rent of ₹3,500. Furhter,
the Appellant contended that Raghuvir Singh (supra), on which reliance has
been placed by the Ld. trial Court, is based on misreading of the judgement
since the interest that may be recoverable as rent, is limited to Section
14(1)(a) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 and the interest cannot be
added to the agreed rent, to calculate the rate of rent in order to cross the
statutory threshold of Section 50 of the DRC Act.
20.
The Appellant further asserted that the Plaintiff had failed to establish
that the rent exceeded ₹3,500 per month, since the plaint records the last rent
paid to M/s Sukeshi International as ₹3,500.
21.
The Appellant also disputes the application of Section 27 DRC Act in
proceedings under the Transfer of Property Act, particularly when the
landlord–tenant relationship itself was disputed. It is further contended that
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
he was denied an opportunity to lead evidence, to establish that no liability
was owed to the Plaintiff.
22.
It was further asserted that no notice under Section 8 of the Act
seeking enhancement of rent, was served and that Defendant No. 2 accepted
the rent dispatched by the Appellant on 24.04.2024.
23.
The Appellant further alleged that the Trial Court did not consider his
specific denials concerning ownership, the landlord–tenant relationship,
service of notice, the Plaintiff’s locus, and non-payment.
24.
Finally, the Appellant challenges the award of ₹3,00,000 per month
when the Plaintiff had sought ₹2,00,000 per month. He also alleges that the
suit was undervalued because possession was valued at only ₹1,25,000
despite the claimed monthly rent.
25.
The Appellant accordingly, seeks setting aside of the impugned
judgment.
Submissions heard and the record perused.
26.
For a decree of possession under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, the Plaintiff
was required to establish the three basic facts; firstly the landlord–tenant
relationship between the parties, secondly, that the rent exceeded ₹3,500 per
month, and thirdly, that the tenancy has been validly terminated by giving a
Notice under Section 106 of TPA.
27.
In the present case, the Plaintiff asserted that he was the owner of the
suit property and had inducted Defendant No. 2, M/s Sukeshi International,
as a tenant in 1983 at a rent of ₹3,250 per month, payable from 01.05.1993,
as admitted by Defendant No. 2 in its Written Statement.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
28.
However, the Appellant set up a defence that he is in occupation of
the suit property since 1983 and was a tenant of Defendant No.2 and not of
the plaintiff. However, the case of the Plaintiff was also that with the
consent of Defendant No.2, Defendant No.1 became the direct tenant of the
plaintiff. Thus, the Defendant no.1 may have been in the suit premises as
tenant of Defendant No.2 since 1983, but he became a direct tenant under
the Plaintiff, in the year 2011 at an annual rent of ₹1,00,000. Defendant
No.2 has also corroborated in his Written Statement that the Defendant No.1
became the direct tenant of the Plaintiff.
29.
Defendant No. 1 has admitted that he paid the Plaintiff three cheques
of ₹1,00,000; ₹1,00,000 and ₹1,25,000, in 2011, 2013 and 2014 respectively
He also did not deny having paid him ₹3,25,000 in all.
30.
The Appellant had tried to explain the payment of Rs.3,25,000/- in all,
to the Plaintiff by asserting that it had been given towards a personal loan,
but there are no particulars of when the loan was taken. The defence of the
loan having been returned by the Appellant to Plaintiff, is nothing but
moonshine, intended only to wriggle out of the payments made by him, to
the Plaintiff.
31.
His own admissions established that he became a direct tenant of the
Plaintiff, as has been stated by the Plaintiff. This is further corroborated by
the Written Statement of the Defendant No. 2, who has endorsed the stand
taken by the Plaintiff.
32.
There was no reason explained by the Defendant No.1 for paying this
annual amount to the Plaintiff. Rather, the payment of these amounts, is a
necessary incident of the tenancy. Such conduct of the defendant no.1
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
corroborates the Landlord-tenant relationship between the plaintiff and
Defendant No.1, as rightly held by the Ld. Trial Court.
33.
The defence had been taken by Defendant No.1 that he had paid
Rs.2,65,000/- in the year 1983, to the Defendant No. 2, and his tenancy was
in perpetuity. However, the Defendant No.2 itself was a tenant of the
plaintiff and could not have created any tenancy in perpetuity, in favour of
the Defendant No.1. Further, the Appellant admittedly made payments
directly to the Plaintiff in 2011, 2013 and 2014. These payments, read with
the stand taken by Defendant No. 2 in its Written Statement, support the
Plaintiff’s case that the Appellant became his direct tenant. The Appellant’s
plea of a perpetual tenancy, therefore, does not displace that conclusion.
34.
Furthermore, once, the defendants had been inducted as a tenant, they
are estopped from challenging the title of the Plaintiff under Section 116 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The very fact that admittedly, the rent
@1,00,000/- p.a., has been admittedly paid to the Plaintiff, further
corroborates that his status in the suit property is that of a tenant. Having
accepted his status as a tenant, he cannot question the title of the Plaintiff.
Therefore, the learned ADJ in the impugned Order, has rightly held that the
Plaintiff was the owner and the Defendant No. 1 was the tenant and there
existed a relationship of landlord and tenant inter se the parties.
35.
The next question is whether the rent exceeded ₹3,500 per month,
thereby attracting the bar under Section 50 of the DRC Act.
36.
First and foremost, when it has been shown that he had been paid
Rs.1,00,000/- p.a. as rent to the Plaintiff, it comes to approximately
Rs.8,300/- per month, which is beyond Rs.3,500/- per month and therefore,
the bar of Section 50 of the DRC Act, is not attracted.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
37.
Secondly, even if the rate of rent as Rs.3,500/- per month, as claimed
by the Defendant No. 1, is admitted to be correct, then too, Section 26 (1)
DRC Act provides that every tenant shall pay the rent within the fixed time
and in the absence of the contract, by 15th day of the next following month.
In case of default in payment of rent, the rent shall be payable with the
simple interest @15% p.a.
38.
The learned Trial Court relied upon Raghbir Singh v. Sheela Wanti &
Anr. (supra), wherein the High Court held:
“Where the rent is not paid by month to month, the interest
over the rent, as levied by the statute, becomes part of the
legally recoverable rent and it cannot be said that unless
there is an amendment in Section 14 (1) (a) or Section 15,
the provisions of Section 26 would not apply. The rent due
would mean that the rent due as per law and where the law
specifically provides that if rent is not paid for the month
when it is due, it has to be paid with interest of 15% per
annum, then the rent due would include the rent plus the
interest over it.”
39.
The learned District Judge, rightly added interest @15% p.a., to the
defaulted rent and calculated the rent to be ₹4,025 p.m., then too the rate of
rent becomes more than Rs.3,500/- since admittedly, no rent has been paid
since 2012. Thus, the impugned judgment correctly held that even if the
Appellant‟s case were accepted, the suit would not be barred by Section 50
of the DRC Act.
40.
The third contention raised by the Appellant, was that no Notice
under Section 106 of the TPA, was ever served upon him.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
41.
Though, the Plaintiff had asserted that he had served a legal Notice
dated 27.06.2014, but even if it is accepted that the Notice was not served
upon the Appellant/Defendant, then too, the filing of the Suit for Recovery
of Possession, amounts to sufficient notice to the Defendants, about the
termination of the tenancy and the intent of the Plaintiff, to seek possession,
as is held in the in Nopany Investments (P) Ltd. v. Santokh Singh (HUF),
(2008) 2 SCC 728. The same principle was reiterated in Sevoke Properties
Ltd. v. West Bengal State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd., (2019) 6 SCC.
42.
Though, the impugned Order dated 18.05.2024, was a common Order
deciding the Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC and the Application
under Order XXXIX Rule 10 CPC but the learned counsel for the Appellant
had stated on 17.07.2026 that the challenge was confined to the Order in the
Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC and he would take his appropriate
remedies in respect of the Order in the Application under Order XXXIX
Rule 10 CPC.
Conclusion:
43.
Therefore, in view of the foregoing discussion, the impugned
Judgment dated 18.05.2024 rightly decreed the suit for possession.
44.
There is no merit in the Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed. The
pending Applications are also disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
OCOTBER 01, 2026/RS
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:25:36
RFA 566/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review