Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1087 of 2025
With
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1135 of 2025
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HASMUKH D. SUTHAR
============================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
============================================
METABEN MANSUKHBHAI NINAMA
Versus
SHANUBHAI RUNALBHAI AMALIYAR & ORS.
============================================
Appearance:
MR SOHIL S DADI(12049) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
ANAND S TAILOR(9021) for the Defendant(s) No. 1
MASUMI V NANAVATY(9321) for the Defendant(s) No. 3
MR VIBHUTI NANAVATI(513) for the Defendant(s) No. 3
NOTICE SERVED for the Defendant(s) No. 2
============================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HASMUKH D. SUTHAR
Date : 27/01/2026
COMMON ORAL JUDGMENT
Since both these appeals are arising out of the same
accident and the grounds and issue involved in both the appeals
are common, they have been heard together and are being
decided by this common judgment. The First Appeal No.1087 of
2025 arises out of MAC Petition No.256 of 2019 and the First
Appeal No.1135 of 2025 arises out of MAC Petition No.255 of
2019.
C/FA/1087/2025
1)
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the common judgment
and award dated 09.01.2025 passed by learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal (Aux.), Dahod (which shall hereinafter be
referred to as "the Tribunal" for short), in Motor Accident Claim
Petition Nos.255 of 2019 and 256 of 2019, the appellants –
original claimants preferred present appeals under Section 173
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (which shall hereinafter be
referred to as "the Act" for short).
2)
Heard learned Advocate Mr. M. M. Hakim, on behalf of Mr. S. S.
Dadi for the appellants – original Claimants and learned
Advocate Mr. Vibhuti Nanavati, for the respondent no.3 –
Insurance
Company.
Perused
the
original
record
and
proceedings.
3)
It is the case of the appellants that on 01.04.2019, the claimants
were standing on Chakaliya Chokdi, Godi Road and waiting for
any vehicle to reach to their home, however at about 13:00
hours, one Tempo bearing Reg. No.GJ-20-V-9564, came in full
speed and dashed with the claimants, as a result of which the
claimants sustained serious accidental injuries on vital parts of
the body. Therefore, FIR being I-CR No.29/2019, came to be
registered with Dahod Town Police Station. Therefore, the
appellants have filed MAC Petitions seeking compensation,
wherein, the learned Tribunal after appreciating the evidence
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
produced on record was pleased to partly allowed both the claim
petitions.
4)
Learned Advocate Mr. M. M. Hakim on behalf of learned
Advocate Mr. S. S. Dadi for the appellants has submitted that
the learned Tribunal has committed in appreciating the evidence
on record and also erred in assessing disability of the claimant –
Mansukhbhai Kehjibhai Ninama (MAC Petition No.255 of 2019)
as he suffered amputated of left leg which resulted into 80%
disability body as a whole and the learned Tribunal ought to
have considered 100% functional disability body as a whole. He
has further submitted that the learned Tribunal erred in
awarding meagre amount towards pain, shock and suffering and
loss of amenities and not awarding any amount towards artificial
limb. Similarly, the learned Tribunal has also committed error by
awarding inadequate compensation to the claimant – Metaben
Mansukhbhai Ninama (MAC Petition No.256 of 2019) and erred
in awarding meagre amount towards pain, shock and suffering
and special diet, attendant charges and transportation charges.
Hence, he has requested to allow the present appeals.
5)
Learned Advocate Mr. Vibhuti Nanavati for the respondent –
Insurance Company has opposed the present appeals and
submitted that the learned Tribunal has not committed any error
and in absence of any evidence or material the Tribunal has
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
properly awarded compensation. Hence, he has requested to
dismiss the present appeals.
FIRST APPEAL NO.1135 of 2025
(MAC PETITION NO.255 of 2019)
6)
Perusing the record the record it appears that in order to prove
the claim the claimant has filed affidavit in lieu of examination –
in – chief at Exhibit 17, wherein, all the facts of the accident
have been narrated and supported the claim petition. The
claimant
has
further
produced
complaint
at
Exhibit
37,
panchnama at Exhibit 38, MLC at Exhibit 39, Medical Bills at
Exhibits 34, 52 and 53 and Disability Certificate at Exhibit 54.
The
involvement
of
the
vehicle,
coverage
of
policy
and
negligence are not disputed hence the opponent no.1 - driver of
the offending vehicle held sole negligent in causing the accident
and no further discussion is required. A perusal of Disability
Certificate at Exhibit 54, reveals that the claimant sustained
multiple accidental injuries and suffered amputated stump left
side above knee with around 15-20 cm stump size. The claimant
was doing agriculture masonry work and the learned Tribunal
has considered 50% disability on the ground that the Doctor has
opined and admitted that 50% disability body as a whole can be
taken into consideration. The learned Tribunal has considered
50% disablement but this Court is of the view that considering
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
the nature of injuries as amputation of stump above knee and
below hip with stump size of 15-20 cm and also considering that
the claimant is engaged in masonry work 85% functional
disablement
is
required
to
be
considered
to
award
just
compensation to the claimant. The learned Tribunal has reduced
the disability to 50% merely on the opinion of the Doctor which
is physical disablement which never be considered as functional
disablement. Hence, this Court is of the considered opinion that
to award just compensation 85% functional disability of the
claimant is considered.
7)
Now coming to the income part, as per the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Govind Yadav Vs.
National Insurance Co. Ltd., reported in 2012(1) TAC 1
(SC), that if no proof of income is produced on the record then
Tribunal has to consider prevalent minimum wages. In absence
of evidence of monthly income of the claimant. In the present
case the accident occurred on 01.04.2019 and during that time
the appellant – injured was doing senting work (masonry work),
whereas, the Tribunal has assessed the income of the applicant
as Rs.8,000/- per month which is required to be enhanced as
per the rate of minimum wages of the prevalent time and hence,
the income of the injured is reassessed as Rs.8,500/- per
month. Further, the learned Tribunal has considered the age of
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
the claimant at the time of accident was 50 years and 02
months and on the basis of the same considered multiplier of 11
as per the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Sarla
Verma (Smt) & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation &
Anr. [2009 (6) SCC 121] which are just and proper. However,
the Tribunal has considered 25% addition towards future
prospectus but considering the age of the applicant 10%
addition towards future prospectus is required to be considered.
Further,
the
Tribunal
Medical
Expense
and
has
awarded
Rs.45,000/-
Rs.4,27,780/towards
towards
special
diet,
attendance charges and transportation charges which are just
and proper.
8)
Therefore,
recalculating
the
income
of
the
claimant
as
Rs.8,500/- and future prospect of 10% = Rs.850/- which comes
to Rs.9,350/-. Now total income under the head of loss of future
income is required to be considered as Rs.9,350/- x 12 x 11 x
85%/ 100 = Rs.10,49,070/-. Therefore, the appellant is entitled
to get additional amount of Rs.3,89,070/- towards loss of
future income. Similarly, considering the nature of injuries,
period of treatment and recovery, age and disablement of the
claimant, this Court is of the view that the learned Tribunal has
committed error while considering pain, shock and suffering only
Rs.50,000/- which is required to be enhanced to Rs.1,50,000/-
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
i.e. additional amount of Rs.1,00,000/- towards Pain, shock
and suffering. The Tribunal has also committed error in not
awarded any compensation towards loss of amenities, however,
considering the disablement Rs.1,50,000/- is awarded towards
loss of amenities. Further, as this Court has reassessed the
income of the claimant amount of Rs.48,000/- towards actual
loss of income is enhanced to Rs.51,000/- i.e. additional amount
of Rs.3,000/-. Moreover, considering the disability of the
claimant this Court is of the opinion that Rs.1,00,000/- is
awarded towards artificial limb.
9)
As
discussed
above,
the
appellant
is
entitled
to
get
compensation computed as under:
Heads
Awarded by
Reassessed by this Court
Tribunal
Loss of future income
Rs.6,60,000/-
Rs.10,49,070/including additional
amount of Rs.3,89,070/-
Pain, shock and
Rs.50,000/-
sufferings
Rs.1,50,000/including additional
amount of Rs.1,00,000/-
Medical Expenses
Special diet,
Rs.4,27,780/Rs.45,000/-
Rs.4,27,780/Rs.45,000/-
Rs.48,000/-
Rs.51,000/-
attendant and
transportation
Actual loss of income
including additional
amount of Rs.3,000/-
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
Artificial Limb
NIL
Rs.1,00,000/including additional
Loss of Amenities
amount of Rs.1,00,000/Rs.1,50,000/-
NIL
including additional
amount of Rs.1,50,000/Total compensation
Rs.12,30,780/-
Rs.19,72,850/including total additional
amount of Rs.7,42,070/-
10)
In
view
of
above,
as
the
Tribunal
has
awarded
total
compensation of Rs.12,30,780/-, however, as discussed above
the
appellant
Rs.7,42,070/-
is
entitled
with
to
get
proportionate
additional
amount
of
costs
interest
as
and
awarded by the learned Tribunal.
FIRST APPEAL NO.1087 of 2025
(MAC PETITION NO.256 of 2019)
11)
To prove her claim, the claimant has tendered affidavit at Exhibit
20, wherein, all the facts of the accident have been narrated and
supported the claim petition. The claimant has further produced
complaint at Exhibit 54, panchnama at Exhibit 55, MLC at Exhibit
56, Medical Bills at Exhibits 36 and Disability Certificate at
Exhibit 24. The involvement of the vehicle, coverage of policy
and negligence are not disputed hence the opponent no.1 driver of the offending vehicle held sole negligent in causing the
accident and no further discussion is required.
C/FA/1087/2025
12)
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
Now coming to the income part, as per the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Govind Yadav Vs.
National Insurance Co. Ltd., reported in 2012(1) TAC 1
(SC), that if no proof of income is produced on the record then
Tribunal has to consider prevailing rate of minimum wages in
absence of evidence of monthly income of the claimant. In the
present case the accident occurred on 01.04.2019 and during
that time the appellant – injured was doing senting work
(masonry work), whereas, the Tribunal has assessed the income
of the deceased as Rs.8,000/- per month which is required to be
enhanced as per the rates of minimum wages of the year 2019
and hence, the income of the injured is reassessed as
Rs.8,500/- per month. Further, the learned Tribunal has
considered the age of the claimant at the time of accident was
49 years and 03 months and on the basis of the same 25%
addition towards future prospectus and multiplier of 13 were
considered as per the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of
Sarla Verma (Smt) & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
& Anr. [2009 (6) SCC 121] which are just and proper.
Further, the Tribunal has considered disability of the injured as
11% which is admitted and hence no interference is required.
Further, the learned Tribunal has awarded Rs.15,000/- towards
pain,
shock
and
suffering,
Rs.38,900/-
towards
Medical
C/FA/1087/2025
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
Expenses and Rs.30,000/- towards special diet, attendant and
transportation and considering the nature of injuries, age and
disability of the claimant the said amounts are just and proper.
However, as discussed above, the actual loss of income is
required to be reassessed as Rs.8,500/- for two months which
comes to Rs.17,000/-. Therefore, the appellant is entitled for
additional amount of Rs.1,000/- towards actual loss of income
as the income of the appellant is reassessed.
13)
Therefore,
recalculating
the
income
of
the
claimant
as
Rs.8,500/- and future prospect of 25% = Rs.2,125/- which
comes to Rs.10,625/-. Now total income under the head of loss
of future income is required to be considered as Rs.10,625/- x
12 x 13 x 11%/ 100 = Rs.1,82,325/-. Therefore, the appellant is
entitled to get additional amount of Rs.10,725/- towards loss
of future income.
14)
As
discussed
above,
the
appellant
is
entitled
to
get
compensation computed as under:
Heads
Awarded by
Tribunal
Reassessed by this Court
Loss of future income
Rs.1,71,600/-
Rs.1,82,325/including additional
amount of Rs.10,725/-
Pain, shock and
sufferings
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
Medical Expenses
Rs.38,900/-
Rs.38,900/-
C/FA/1087/2025
15)
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
Special diet,
attendant and
transportation
Actual loss
Rs.30,000/-
Rs.30,000/-
Rs.16,000/-
Rs.17,000/including additional
amount of Rs.1,000/-
Total compensation
Rs.2,71,500/-
Rs.2,83,225/including total additional
amount of Rs.11,725/-
In
view
of
above,
as
the
Tribunal
has
awarded
total
compensation of Rs.2,71,500/-, however, as discussed above
the
appellant
is
entitled
to
get
additional
amount
of
Rs.11,725/- with proportionate costs and interest as awarded
by the learned Tribunal.
16)
Hence, present appeals are partly allowed. The common
judgment and award dated 09.01.2025 passed by learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal (Aux.), Dahod, in MAC Petition Nos.255
of 2019 and 256 of 2019 stand modified to the aforesaid extent.
Rest of the judgment and award remains unaltered. The
respondent No.3 – Insurance Company shall deposit said
additional amount of Rs.7,42,070/- in MAC Petition No.255
of 2019 and Rs.11,725/- in MAC Petition No.256 of 2019
along with interest as awarded by the Tribunal, before the
Tribunal within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt
of this order. Record and proceedings be remitted back to the
concerned Tribunal forthwith.
C/FA/1087/2025
17)
JUDGMENT DATED: 27/01/2026
The learned Tribunal is directed to recover or deduct the deficit
court fees on enhanced amount and thereafter disburse the
amount accordingly.
18)
Award to be drawn accordingly.
(HASMUKH D. SUTHAR,J)
ANKIT JANSARI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review