Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:697
Serial No.06
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP. No. 20 of 2021
Date of Order :05.08.2024
Messrs Motilal Oswal Financial Services Ltd.,
A Non-banking Financial Company
Incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956,
Having its registered office at The Motilal
Oswal Tower, Rahimutullah Sayani Road,
Prabhadevi, Mumbai-400025, Maharashtra,
Though the authorized signatory
Shri. Bhagwati Prasad Bajoria,
Son of (Late) K.L.Bajoria,
Resident of Mani Bhawan, Lower Police Bazaar,
Shillong-793001, Meghalaya.
…Petitioner
-VersusMessrs Green Valley Industries Ltd.,
A company incorporated under the
Companies Act, 1956, having its registered
Office at Nongsning, P.O. Chiehruphi,
P.S.Khliehriat, District East Jaintia Hills,
Meghalaya.
…Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.Chakrawarty, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. E.Laloo, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. K.Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.Thapa, Adv.
Ms. B.Kharwanlang, Adv.
:
2024:MLHC:697
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This application under Rule 27 of the Administration of Justice
(Khasi Syiemship) Order 1950, read with Article 227 of the Constitution of
India has been filed against the impugned order dated 24-11-2021, in Misc.
Case No. 1 (T) of 2020 arising out of T.S. No. 3 (T) of 2020, whereby the
application of the petitioner under Section 8 of the Arbitration &
Conciliation Act, 1996, was dismissed with cost of ₹50,000/- (Rupees
Fifty Thousand) only.
2.
The brief facts are that the petitioner which is a non-banking
financial company had provided a loan of ₹25,00,00,000/- (Rupees
Twenty-Five Crores) only to the respondent in the years 2011 and 2012,
and on the failure of the respondent to refund the said loan amount with
interest thereon, the parties had entered into a settlement agreement dated
31-08-2018 for settlement of the loan at an amount of ₹16,50,00,000/(Rupees Sixteen Crores and Fifty Lakhs) only which was then paid by the
respondent to the petitioner. The petitioner thereafter, allegedly on
2024:MLHC:697
realizing that the respondent had fraudulently induced the petitioner to
enter into the said settlement dated 31-08-2018, as such, terminated the
same by serving a legal notice to the respondent. The respondent, it
appears, then instituted a Title Suit being T.S. No. 3 (T) of 2020 along with
Misc. case No. 4 (T) 2020, in the Court of the Additional Deputy
Commissioner at Khliehriat. The petitioner then was served with a notice
dated 10-08-2020, passed in the Misc. Case whereby an ad interim
injunction had been granted restraining the petitioner from acting in any
manner in breach or contravention of the settlement agreement dated 3108-2018, and from invoking the securities pledged with the petitioner by
the respondent or to create any third party rights interest in respect of the
shares of the respondent pledged with the petitioner.
3.
The petitioner on receipt of the notice thereof, duly entered
appearance and filed an application on 09-09-2020, under Section 8 of the
Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996, praying for referring the parties to
arbitration and the same was numbered as Misc. Case No. 01 (T) 2020 in
the Court of the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Khliehriat. The
respondent then filed its reply/show cause to the said application under
Section 8 and subsequently by another application dated 03-03-2021, in
the aforementioned Misc. case No. 1 (T) 2020 raised a preliminary
objection
regarding
the
jurisdiction
of
the
Additional
Deputy
2024:MLHC:697
Commissioner at Khliehriat to take up the matter under Section 8 of the
Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996, to which the petitioner filed a show
cause in reply thereto in March 2021. The said matter was then heard by
the Court of the Additional Deputy Commissioner Khliehriat and by the
impugned order dated 24-11-2021, the petitioner’s application under
Section 8 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act,1996, was dismissed with
cost of ₹50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand)n only. Being aggrieved thereby,
the petitioner is before this Court.
4.
Mr. S.Chakrawarty, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. E.Laloo,
learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the suit had been instituted
at the time when the judiciary had not been separated from the executive
and the initial order of ad interim injunction had been passed by the Court
of the Additional Deputy Commissioner and not the Court of any of the
Assistants to Deputy Commissioner as should have been the case. He
submits that the petitioner being under the notion that the Court of the
Additional Deputy Commissioner was the competent court had filed the
Section 8 application before the said court, inasmuch as, the law provides
that such application should be filed before the judicial authority trying the
matter which is covered by an arbitration agreement. He further submits
that apart from the ad interim injunction order being passed by the Court of
the Additional Deputy Commissioner, the petitioner had no information of
2024:MLHC:697
the endorsement of the main title suit i.e., T.S. No. 3 (T) of 2020 to any of
the Subordinate Courts of the Assistants to Deputy Commissioner, nor did
the Court of the Additional Deputy Commissioner endorse the said
application under Section 8 to the Subordinate Court for disposal. He
therefore contends that the Additional Deputy Commissioner had grossly
erred in failing to endorse the said application under Section 8 for disposal
to the proper Subordinate Court even after the respondents had filed an
application raising preliminary objections regarding the jurisdiction of the
Court of the Additional Deputy Commissioner. He lastly submits the entire
confusion being caused due to the fact that the suit was initially instituted
when the judiciary had not been separated from the executive and on
separation, the title suit being endorsed to the Court of Assistant Deputy
Commissioner not to the petitioner’s knowledge, the Additional Deputy
Commissioner had failed to appreciate the circumstances by dismissing the
application and imposing cost of ₹50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand) only.
As such, he submitted that the learned Court of the Additional Deputy
Commissioner had acted in excess of jurisdiction vested in it by law, and
that the impugned order being bad in law is liable to be set aside and
quashed.
5.
Mr. K.Paul, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. S.Thapa, learned
counsel for the respondent in reply thereto, has fairly submitted that it is
2024:MLHC:697
correct that the suit had been instituted at the time when the judiciary had
not been separated from the executive in East Jaintia Hills, and that the ad
interim order of injunction dated 10-08-2020, had been passed in this
period. The learned Sr. counsel to assist the Court has also supplied
certified copies of the entire order sheets reflecting the proceedings and the
progress of the case to substantiate his submissions. He further submits
that the petitioner however, continued to persist with the Section 8
application inspite of the objection raised by the respondent and as such,
the same had resulted in the impugned order being passed. Learned Sr.
counsel does not dispute the fact that the Section 8 application needs
adjudication, but submits that it is not a case for a simple referral to
arbitration, inasmuch as, there are many intervening circumstances that
deserves consideration.
6.
Upon hearing learned Sr. counsel for the parties and having
examined the materials on record, it is first to be noted that in the scheme
of the Administration of Justice as given under the Administration of
Justice Rules, 1937 in the erstwhile United Khasi and Jaintia Hills, the
same provided for the Courts of the Deputy Commissioner and his
Assistants; and in the normal course, when any suit is instituted and put up
before the Deputy Commissioner or the Additional Deputy Commissioner
both being vested with the same powers, the same was endorsed to the
2024:MLHC:697
Court of the Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner for trial and disposal.
What can be seen in the instant case is that on the institution of the suit ie.,
T.S. No. 3 (T) 2020 along with the Misc. case, the Additional Deputy
Commissioner without endorsing the same to the Court of the Assistants,
proceeded to take up the matter and pass the ad interim injunction order
dated 10-08-2020. The suit thereafter, on the separation of the judiciary
from the executive on 11-08-2020, as can be seen from the order sheets,
was then transferred by the Additional Deputy Commissioner to the Court
of the Additional Deputy Commissioner (Judiciary) Khliehriat, East Jaintia
Hills, who then in turn, by order dated 07-10-2020, transferred the same to
the Court of the Assistant to Deputy Commissioner, Khliehriat, East Jaintia
Hills.
7.
At this juncture, it is relevant to note that on 09-09-2020, the
petitioner had filed the application under Section 8 of the Arbitration &
Conciliation Act, 1996, before the Court of the Additional Deputy
Commissioner as the suit was pending therein, but as discussed earlier,
though the main title suit was thereafter endorsed or transferred to the
Court of the Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner, the Section 8
application remained before the said Court of the Additional Deputy
Commissioner and was disposed of by the impugned order, even though
the respondent had raised objections as to jurisdiction. It is relevant also to
2024:MLHC:697
note herein that the Court of the Assistant to Deputy Commissioner, on the
title suit being transferred to it on 07-10-2020, had only issued notice on
04-02-2021 to the parties, perhaps as can be seen from the order sheets,
due to the covid pandemic. From the circumstances therefore, it can be
seen that what was a simple matter initially, had by the events that
unfolded, assumed a different character which complicated the entire
situation, and has resulted in the proceedings being unduly delayed. It may
be added herein also that when the matter was pending before this Court,
the parties had attempted to settle the same, but as nothing transpired, has
also contributed to the matter being held up.
8.
Looking into the totality of the facts and circumstances as narrated
above, therefore, without any further deliberation, in the considered view
of this Court, justice will be served if the application under Section 8 of the
Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996, filed by the petitioner be taken up
afresh by the Court of the Assistant to Deputy Commissioner, Khliehriat,
East Jaintia Hills wherein the main suit i.e., T.S. No. 3 (T) 2020 is pending,
for disposal on merits.
9.
Consequently, the impugned order shall stand set aside and quashed,
and Misc. Case No. 4 (T) 2020 restored to file and placed before the
Assistant to Deputy Commissioner trying the main suit.
2024:MLHC:697
10.
The parties are put to notice to appear before the Court of the
Assistant to Deputy Commissioner, East Jaintia Hills, Khliehriat on 28 th
August, 2024 for commencement of the proceedings for hearing of Misc.
Case No. 4 (T) 2020, which is to be taken up expeditiously for disposal.
11.
As ordered above, the instant civil revision application stands closed
and disposed of.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2024.08.05 17:22:59 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review