Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary
List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA. No. 10 of 2022
Date of Decision: 08.09.2022
Smti. Meris Tang
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Anr.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. J. Shylla, Adv.
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv.
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, AAG. with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. J. Shylla, learned counsel for the petitioner who has
submitted that an FIR dated 14.01.2022 was lodged before the Ladrymbai
Police Out Post, East Jaintia Hills District by one Shri Md Rafiqul Ali
informing the police that he is the owner of one Bolero pickup Truck No.
AS-01-JC-3947 which was driven by one Shri. Bidya Dawa Dutta. The
informant has also informed that he received a phone call from the
Ladrymbai Police Out Post that a suspected burnt body found from a place
called Moowakhu Dkhiah West, East Jaintia Hills suspected to be that of
his driver since the vehicle was found abandoned at another place.
2.
The informant along with the relative of the driver went to
Khliehriat CHC and identified the dead body as that of the deceased driver.
It is prayed that necessary action be taken as per law. Accordingly, the
police registered a criminal case being Khliehriat P.S. Case No. 5 (1) of
2022 under Section 302/34 IPC.
3.
The accused Shri. Lodestar Tang, son of the petitioner herein was
strongly suspected to be involved in the crime and was arrested on
03.04.2022. It is also mentioned that on an earlier occasion, the said accused
had approached this Court for grant of anticipatory bail, but the same was
rejected vide order dated 24.02.2022.
4.
On investigation launched by the Investigating Officer and on
completion of the investigation, the Investigating Officer had submitted the
charge sheet on 02.05.2022 wherein the accused, son of the petitioner and
three other persons namely, Shri. Shidorki Dkhar, Shri. Kyrshan Timung
and Shri. Pher Dhar were named as accused. It is also submitted that of the
four, only the accused, son of the petitioner and Shri. Shidorki Dkhar were
arrested while Shri. Kyrshan Timung and Shri. Pher Dhar were never
arrested. The matter was committed before the Session Court at Khliehriat
and is pending for attendance of all the accused persons.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has also submitted that the
petitioner has moved a bail application before the Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Khliehriat, but the same was rejected vide order dated 11.07.2022.
Again, a bail application was moved before the Sessions Court at Khliehriat,
but this too was rejected vide order dated 19.07.2022. The petitioner has
then preferred this instant application before this Court with a prayer for
grant of bail to the accused Shri. Lodestar Tang.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that a perusal
of the charge sheet would show that there is no direct evidence linking the
accused, son of the petitioner to the alleged crime, but only circumstantial
evidence is relied upon by the I/O to implicate the said accused in the case.
The accused infact has stated before the I/O that on the date of the alleged
commission of the crime, he was not in the vicinity of the place of
occurrence, but was far away in his village.
7.
The next contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that
the prosecution has given a lists of twenty-two witnesses to be examined in
the case and also considering the fact that two of the accused persons have
not yet been apprehended, therefore there is every likelihood that the trial
will take a considerable amount of time which will affect the personal
liberty and right to life of the accused person and which will also hamper
the opportunity to prepare his defence in the case.
8.
The accused person even if released on bail would not be able to
tamper with the evidence or witnesses as the period of investigation is
already over and there is no possibility for tampering with any material
witness or even the witnesses.
9.
In view of the fact that the accused person is the only earning
member of his family with his wife and child depending on him for their
livelihood, it is prayed that bail may be granted with any conditions that this
Court may deem fit to impose.
10.
Per contra, Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, learned AAG has submitted that
the factum of the incident which has led to the death of the victim of the
crime has to be considered, inasmuch as, facts will reveal that a gruesome
murder has occurred, in which the victim who was a driver of the Bolero
pickup Truck while on his way from Silchar to Guwahati passing through
East Jaintia Hills District of Meghalaya on 12.01.2022 in the evening on
reaching Moowakhu NRL Petrol Pump Ladrymbai, they stopped for taking
rest. It was about midnight at that time when suddenly a group of four
unknown persons came knocking at the door of the driver and forcefully
entered inside the vehicle and snatched the vehicle’s key after which they
drove the vehicle for some distance and thereafter, they took out one person
named, Shri. Sanjoy Chettri who was the handyman of the said vehicle
while the deceased driver was tied with shoe laces. The culprits then
demanded money from them and threatened to kill them if they do not reveal
where they had hidden the money.
11.
Shri. Sanjoy Chettri managed to free one of his hands and fled
away, however he fell into a deep pit where he was there the whole night.
In the morning, he managed to climb out of the pit and came to the highway
where he boarded one unknown Sumo vehicle and reached Shillong and
from there, he managed to reach home safely.
12.
The culprits in the meantime continued to torture the deceased
driver by stabbing him with knives on his hand and when they could not get
the money from him, they poured diesel over his body and burned him alive.
Thereafter, they left the place of occurrence and went back to their village.
13.
The learned AAG has submitted that on investigation, these facts
were revealed to the I/O who has also examined a number of witnesses
including the eye witness, Shri. Sanjoy Chettri who has confirmed and
narrated the incident as it happened.
14.
It is also submitted that the accused person, Shri. Lodestar Tang
is a habitual offender and a number of criminal cases were registered against
him which are pending trail. The said accused was also examined by the
police and on being questioned, he has stated that he was the person who
had forcefully open the door of the said Bolero pickup Truck and had
snatched the key and taken away the said Truck along with the deceased
driver and his handyman as well as his three friends and they had stopped
the vehicle at bypass Jalyiah where they had demanded money from the said
driver and had tortured him. This accused has also admitted that he was the
one who had poured the diesel over the deceased driver and has set him on
fire. Thereafter, he had went back to his village.
15.
In view of the fact that a very strong prima facie case has been
made out against the accused and his accomplices, the learned AAG has
submitted that this is not a fit case for grant of bail to the accused person.
16.
Due consideration has been given to the submission and
contention of the rival parties and the petition at hand was also perused by
this Court. The admitted facts as it is having not been controverted or denied
by the petitioner, inasmuch as the fact that a murder has occurred in which
the victim driver of the said Bolero pickup Truck was gruesomely murdered
has not been denied. What the petitioner denies is the involvement of her
son who has been implicated and arrested in connection with a case
registered in this regard.
17.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has emphasized on the fact
that the accused, son of the petitioner was arrested and implicated in the
case only on circumstantial evidence and also because of the fact that he
was an accused in some criminal cases and therefore, it is always the modus
operandi of the police to suspect such kind of person whenever any crime
occurs within the district.
18.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has also argued that the
statement made by the accused while in police custody cannot be relied
upon by this Court as the same is not admissible in law.
19.
True, the fact that a gruesome murder has occurred, would shock
the conscience of the citizen and when the matter is brought before a Court
of law, the gravity and nature of the offence would be stressed upon before
the Court to inflict the most severe of punishment to the perpetrator(s) and
in this manner, whenever the alleged accused or perpetrator seeks redressal
by way of a prayer for grant of bail or pre-arrest bail, the attention of the
Court would be drawn to the facts of the incident in an attempt to oppose
such prayer for grant of bail.
20.
The Court would not be moved with emotion whenever such a
scene is played before it, however while considering an application for bail,
the time tested and well settled principles has to be taken into account that
is, the nature and gravity of the offence, the period of imprisonment for
commission of the offence and the antecedent of the accused person being
some of the factors which has to be considered by the Court.
21.
In the case in hand, the narrative would reveal that a very
gruesome murder had indeed taken place, though initially, the investigation
would proceed without the identity of the perpetrator(s) known, however in
course of investigation, the accused, son of the petitioner and three others
have been suspected to be involved in the crime. On being apprehended, the
accused, son of the petitioner has not denied his complicity in the matter
and as stated, he has admitted to his culpability in his statement before the
police.
22.
In the case of Indresh Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Another, the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order dated 12.07.2022 in
Criminal Appeal No. 938 of 2022 while deciding a case of cancellation of
bail has observed that “…. statements under Section 161 of Cr.P.C may not
be admissible in evidence, but are relevant in considering the prima facie
case against an accused in an application for grant of bail in case of grave
offence….” Applying this to the case in hand, the same would be applicable
as prima facie, the involvement of the accused, son of the petitioner in the
said murder of the driver has been established.
23.
In conclusion, this Court considering all aspect of the matter, has
deemed it fit and proper to reject this application at this juncture. The same
is dismissed.
24.
Bail application disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
08.09.2022
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review