Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:39180
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.11000 of 2023
Date of Decision: 15.09.2026
_______________________________________________________
Sh. Mehar Chand & others
…….Petitioners
Versus
Himachal Pradesh Financial Commissioner & others … Respondents
_______________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Vinod K. Soni and Mr. Tanuj Thakur,
Advocates.
For the Respondents: Mr. Rajan Kahol & Mr. Vishal Panwar,
Additional Advocate Generals with Mr. Ravi
Chauhan & Mr. Anish Banshtu, Deputy
Advocates General, for the respondentState.
Mr. C.N. Singh, Advocate with Mr.
Jagatnarayan Singh and Mr. Anshul
Gandhi, Advocate, for respondents No.3
and 4.
____________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, Judge(oral):
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with order dated
05.04.2023 passed by the Financial Commissioner (Appeals),
Himachal Pradesh at Shimla, in Revision Petition No. 3 of 2012
(Annexure P-4), reversing order dated 01.12.2011 passed by the
Divisional Commissioner, Kangra in case No. 223 of 2007, whereby
order dated 18.03.1998 passed by Collector (ADM) Kangra at
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:39180
Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh, in Appeal No. 40 /97 was set aside,
petitioners have approached this Court
in the instant proceedings
filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying therein for
following main reliefs:“ (i) That the impugned order dated 5.4.2023(Annexure P4) passed by the learned Financial Commissioner,
may kindly be quashed and set aside in the interest of
justice and fair play;
(ii) That the order dated 1.12.2011 (Annexure P-3) passed
by the learned Divisional Commissioner may kindly
be upheld.”
2.
For having bird's-eye view, facts essential for the
adjudication of the case at hand, as emerge from the pleadings
adduced on record by the respective parties, are that Sh. Kuldeep
Chand, predecessor-in-interest of respondent No. 4, submitted an
application dated 29.07.1993 before learned Land Reforms Officer
( for short ‘LRO'), Palampur, District Kangra, averring therein that he
had filed LR-V on 06.12.1975, but same was misplaced from the
Tehsil Office, Palampur and as such, he be permitted to file LR-V form
afresh. The Land Reforms Officer decided the LR-V form vide order
dated 04.03.1995 passed in Case No. 91/LR, by allowing aforesaid
Kuldeep Chand to resume 0-74-60 hectares of land from various
tenants in three Mohals i.e., predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners
herein, whereas qua rest of the land under tenants, ownership rights
were also conferred on such tenants.
2026:HHC:39180
3.
Being aggrieved with aforesaid order dated 04.03.1995
passed by Land Reforms Officer, predecessor-in-interest of the
petitioners preferred an appeal before learned Collector (ADM)
Kangra at Dharamshala (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Collector’),
taking grounds that predecessor-in-interest of respondent No. 4 is
already having more land than the limit prescribed under Section 104
and as such, is not entitled to resume any land from the tenants. It
also came to be stated at the behest of predecessor-in-interest of the
petitioners that respondent No. 4 suppressed facts, while filing LR-V
form and he has not disclosed that he is having land in Nagrota Tehsil
also. However, learned Collector, after having heard parties and
perused case file, dismissed the appeal vide order dated 18.03.1998.
4.
Being dissatisfied
with the aforesaid order dated
18.03.1998 passed by learned Collector, in Appeal No.40/97,
petitioners herein preferred an appeal before learned Commissioner,
bearing Appeal No. 168 of 1998. Learned Commissioner, accepted
the appeal, vide order dated 01.12.2011, observing that the record of
filing the LR-V form in the year 1975 was not available on file and it
was not clear whether the LR-V form was actually filed by the
respondents in the year 1975 or not. Besides above, afore Authority
further observed that since the date of filing of LR-V form is vital for
the adjudication of the matter, finding on this issue is required to be
2026:HHC:39180
given by the LRO. In the aforesaid background, predecessor-ininterest of respondent No. 4 filed Revision Petition No. 3 of 2012
before the Financial Commissioner (Appeals), Himachal Pradesh,
which came to be allowed vide order dated 05.04.2023 (Annexure P4). Learned Financial Commissioner, while accepting the revision
petition, set aside the order dated 01.12.2011, as a consequence
thereof, order dated 18.03.1998 passed by Learned Collector (ADM)
Kangra at Dharamshala in Revision No. 40/97 came to be upheld. In
the aforesaid background, petitioners herein have approached this
Court in the instant proceedings, praying therein
to dismiss the
petition and restore order dated 01-12-2011 passed by learned
Divisional Commissioner, Kangra at Dharamshala in Case No. 223 of
2007.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone
through the record of the case carefully.
6.
Precisely, the grouse of the petitioners, as has been
highlighted in the petition and further canvassed by Mr. Vinod Kumar
Soni and Mr. Tanuj Thakur, Advocates, representing the petitioners,
is that learned Financial Commissioner, while passing impugned
order, failed to take note of the fact that no record whatsoever ever
came to be produced with regard to filing of LR-V form for resumption
of land from the tenants, if any, at the behest of the petitioner on
2026:HHC:39180
06-12-1975. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that since
there was no record with regard to filing of LR-V on 06-12-1975,
coupled with the fact that there is a tampering of date on the receipt
allegedly issued to predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners in the
year 1975, there was no occasion, if any, for learned Financial
Commissioner to upset the findings of the Commissioner, which are
based upon proper appreciation of record as well as evidence
adduced on record by the respective parties. Learned counsel
representing the petitioners further submitted that though LR-V form is
available on the record produced before this Court, but same cannot
be said to have been submitted in the year 1975, rather such
document came to be adduced on record by private respondent No. 4
alongwith his application filed on 29-07-1993. Lastly, learned counsel
representing the petitioners further argued that even if it is presumed
that LR-V form was submitted by the predecessor-in-interest of
respondent No. 4 in the year 1975, no plausible explanation worth
credence ever came to be adduced on record qua delay of 18 years in
filing application in the year, 1993 seeking permission to file fresh LRV Form. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that on account
of delay, which never came to be explained, application filed by the
predecessor-in-interest of the private respondent ought to have been
rejected.
2026:HHC:39180
7.
To the contrary, Mr.
Rajan Kahol, learned Additional
Advocate General representing the respondent-State and Mr.
C.N.Singh,
Advocate,
representing
the
private
respondents,
supported the impugned order passed by Financial Commissioner.
They submitted that plea of limitation, as is being sought to be raised
in the instant petition, never came to be raised at the behest of the
petitioners during the pendency of proceedings before the Collector,
Divisional
Commissioner
and
thereafter
before
the
Financial
Commissioner and as such, same deserves outright rejection.
Learned counsel representing the respondents further argued that
bare perusal of the record made available to this Court, clearly reveals
that predecessor-in-interest of the private respondent had submitted
LR-V form on 29-12-1975, which at the relevant time was endorsed by
the concerned Patwari. Thus, no illegality can be said to have been
committed by the Financial Commissioner, while setting aside the
order dated 01-12-2011 passed by learned Divisional Commissioner.
8.
Having heard learned counsel representing the parties
and perused material available on record vis-à-vis reasoning assigned
in the impugned order dated 05-04-2023 passed by learned Financial
Commissioner (Appeals), this Court finds no illegality or infirmity in the
same and as such, no interference is called for.
2026:HHC:39180
9.
In the case at hand, predecessor-in-interest of the private
respondent filed an application dated 29-07-1993 before the Land
Reform Officer, Palampur, specifically stating therein that he had filed
LR-V
form
on
06-12-1975,
but
due
to
some
unavoidable
circumstances, said LR-V form was misplaced by the Tehsil office
and as such, he be permitted to file fresh LR-V form. The then Land
Reforms Officer, after perusing the record, decided the form LR-V of
the present petitioners vide order dated 04-03-1995, passed in Case
No. 91/LR and permitted the predecessor-in-interest of the private
respondent to resume 0-74-60 hectares of land from various tenants
in three mohals. If the afore order passed by Land Reforms Officer, as
available on record file, is perused in its entirety, it clearly suggests
that aforesaid authority before passing aforesaid order examined the
entire record( available at pages No. 7 to 26 of the file made available
to this Court). Since the predecessor-in-interest of the private
respondent had appended a photocopy of the receipt of form LR-V in
the shape of form LR-VI containing signature of Land Reforms Officer
along with the date 06/12, Land Reforms Officer, after verifying this
record, proceeded to permit the predecessor-in-interest of the private
respondent to resume the land. After passing of aforesaid order by the
Land Reforms Officer, the matter came to be examined by Learned
Collector (ADM) Kangra at Dharamshala. The aforesaid authority
2026:HHC:39180
again examined the record and proceeded to dismiss the appeal.
However, learned Collector in Appeal No. 40 of 1997 filed by the
predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners, set aside the order dated
04-03-1995 on the ground that record of filing the LR-V form in the
year 1975 was not available in the file and it is not clear as to whether
LR-V form was actually filed by the respondent in the year 1975 or
not.
10.
True it is that at the time of making application at the
behest of the predecessor-in-interest of the private respondent, LR-V
form, if any, submitted was not available that’s why predecessor-ininterest of the respondent sought permission from the Land Reforms
Officer, to file fresh application. However, while doing so, he made
available certain documents suggestive of the fact that he has
submitted LR-V in the year 1975 and he also produced on record
receipt issued on form LR-VI, having date 06/12. Since aforesaid
documents adduced on record by predecessor-in-interest of private
respondent had signatures of the then
Land Reforms Officer and
same were also verified by the Patwari concerned on 29-11-1975, no
illegality can be said to have been committed by the Collector
(Additional District Magistrate) Kangra inasmuch as he proceeded to
uphold the order dated 04-03-1995 passed by Land Reforms Officer,
in case No.91/LR. Since predecessor-in-interest of the private
2026:HHC:39180
respondent successfully established before the authorities below that
application for resumption was filed well within limitation, coupled with
the fact that it was also established on record that LR-V form for
resumption was filed in the year 1975, no illegality can be said to have
been committed by the Land Reforms Officer, in permitting the
petitioners to resume the land.
11.
Interestingly, plea of limitation, as is being sought to be
raised in the instant proceedings never came to be raised before the
Land Reforms Officer and thereafter Collector and Commissioner.
Moreover, this Court is of the view that once predecessor-in-interest
of the private respondents is able to establish on record that he had
filed the application before 31-12-1975, plea of limitation sought to be
raised in the instant proceedings is of no consequence. It is not the
case of the petitioners that in the year 1993, the revenue authorities
permitted the predecessor-in-interest of the private respondent to file
fresh Form LR-V seeking their permission to resume the land, rather it
is the admitted case of the parties that in 1993, predecessor-ininterest of the private respondent filed an application, specifically
stating therein that though he had filed LR-V Form in the year 1975 (
on 29-12-1975), but same has been misplaced and as such, he may
be permitted to file
fresh one. The Land Reforms Officer, after
verifying the records, found the claim of the predecessor of the
2026:HHC:39180
respondent to be genuine and as such, permitted him to resume the
land.
12.
In the case at hand, predecessor-in-interest of the private
respondent had attached a photocopy of receipt of Form LR-V in the
shape of LR-VI Form, on which the signature of the Land Reforms
Officer stood appended along with the date. The record of the trial
court shows that Form LR-V of the present petitioner was duly verified
by the Patwari concerned on 29-11-1975. The record further reveals
that Land Reforms Officer had provided a proper opportunity of being
heard to all the interested parties, but none of the petitioners had ever
raised any issue regarding the late filing of the LR-V form.
13.
Interestingly, in the first appeal filed before the learned
Collector, though the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners
attempted to set up a case that present petitioners had wrongly set up
Form LR-V in connivance with the revenue staff, but they failed to
specifically lay challenge to Form LR-V on the ground of limitation.
Section 104 of the Act read with Rule 21 of the Himachal Pradesh
Tenancy and Land Reforms Rules, 1975, clearly prescribes the period
for the submission of application for the resumption of land by
landowner other than those mentioned in sub-section (8) of Section
10 up to 31st December 1975. Since, in the case at hand, the
predecessor-in-interest of the private respondent was not covered
2026:HHC:39180
under the protected category protected under Section 104(8) of the
Act, he was bound to file application for the resumption of land from
tenants on or before 31st December 1975. In the instant case, record
made available to this Court clearly reveals that Form LR-V was duly
submitted on 29-11-1975 and same was verified by the Patwari
concerned on 29-11-1975. The receipt of Form LR-V in the shape of
Form LR-VI clearly shows that the signature of the Land Reform
Officer was appended thereupon. Since Form LR-V was submitted
well within the period of limitation prescribed under the rules, coupled
with the fact that Land Reform Officer, after verifying the records,
proceeded to permit the predecessor-in-interest of the private
respondents to resume the land, learned Divisional Commissioner,
while setting aside the order passed by the Collector was not correct
in returning the finding that no record was available.
14.
Consequently, in view of the detailed discussion made
above, this Court finds no merit in the present petition and
accordingly, same is dismissed, as a consequence thereof, the
impugned order passed by the Financial Commissioner is upheld.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
September 15, 2026
(shankar)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review