Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:660-DB
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 55 of 2024
Date of Decision: 31.07.2025
1. Meghalaya Energy Corporation Limited (MeECL),
Represented by the Director of Corporate Affairs
Meghalaya Energy Corporation Limited (MeECL), Lum
Jingshai, Short Round Road, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
2. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Meghalaya
Energy Corporation Limited (MeECL), Lum
Jingshai, Short Round Road, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
….. Appellants
-VERSUS1. MeECL Progressive Worker’s union, Shillong
Represented by its president, Shri. Mantiphranglang Lyngdoh Giri
S/o Kiron Lamin, R/o Khliehriat,
East Jaintia Hills District, Meghalaya
2. The State of Meghalaya represented by the Chief Secretary
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
….. Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, Sr.Adv with
Ms. R. Colney, Adv
Mr. P. Yobin, Adv (R:1)
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA (R:2)
2025:MLHC:660-DB
(Judgment and Order)
Per. B. Bhattacharjee, Judge:
By this writ appeal, the appellants have challenged the judgment dated
15.07.2024 passed in WP(C) No.153 of 2021 whereby the relevant appellants’
authorities were directed to take necessary action to implement and ensure
that the members of the writ petitioner/union are paid equal pay for equal
work.
1.
The respondent No.1 in the present writ appeal, which is a union of
regular casual/contractual workers known as MeECL Progressive Worker’s
Union, filed WP(C) No.153 of 2021 claiming payment of wages on a par with
minimum pay scale of regular employees of the appellants. The claim was
opposed by the appellants herein. The learned Single Judge vide impugned
judgment dated 15.07.2024 allowed the prayer by issuing the following
direction: “29. In view of the above, to the extent indicated, the prayer made in
this petition is allowed. The relevant respondent authorities in the
MeECL are hereby directed to take necessary action to implement the
directions given herein, that is, to ensure that the members of the
petitioner/Union, whose names can be found at Annexure-A/3 are being
paid equal pay for equal work. The same to be completed preferably
within a period of 2 (two) months from the date of receipt of the certified
copy of this judgment and order.”
2.
Assailing the impugned judgment Mr. A. Kumar, learned Senior
counsel, submits that the writ petition was not maintainable as each of the
members of the writ petitioner/union had a distinct cause of action which was
separate and independent and hence, clubbing of multiple causes of action into
one single writ petition was not permissible. He submits that the writ petition
concerned various persons working in 31 different posts and thus, the same
could not have been decided without considering the merits and demerits of
2025:MLHC:660-DB
individual claim of each of the members of the union. He contends that the
learned Single Judge erred in passing the impugned judgment without there
being any material particulars or proof establishing that the persons at various
posts were undertaking identical work of regular employees and that a bald
averment in the writ petition was not sufficient to establish equal work. He
submits that matters of equal pay for equal work requires analysis of various
factors like the source of appointment, qualification, quality of work, quantity
of work, sensitivity, responsibility and accountability attached with work and
involves a tedious factual exercise which is not undertaken in a writ
proceeding as the scope for factual determination is extremely narrow. He
submits that mere common nomenclature of a post is not sufficient to prove
equal work and the courts should not interfere with the complex issues of
evaluating the nature of duties and responsibilities of posts and of fixing the
pay scales which is a task for the expert bodies falling within the executive
domain.
3.
The learned Senior counsel further submits that the doctrine of equal
pay for equal work is not an abstract doctrine and has no mechanical
application in every case. He submits that the onus of proof of parity in the
duties and responsibilities under the principle of equal pay for equal work lies
on the person who claims it and in the present case the writ petitioner/union
has miserably failed to discharge the onus. He submits that the members of
the writ petitioner/union are not regular employees and were appointed on
purely temporary basis. The nature of appointment and duties assigned to the
members of the writ petitioner/union are different from the nature of
appointment and duties of the regular employees. He submits that the
members of the writ petitioner/union are all contractual hires and recruited
beyond the sanctioned posts purely on the need basis and the service condition
of the members of the writ petitioner/union is guided by the terms and
conditions provided in the respective contract agreement, not by the
2025:MLHC:660-DB
provisions of the Service Regulation of the appellant corporation. He contends
that the learned Single Judge wrongly applied the principles of the decision of
the Apex Court in State of Punjab & ors v. Jagjit Singh & ors, (2017) 1 SCC
148 without determining the facts of the case in order to appreciate whether
the members of the writ petitioner/union satisfied the relevant requirements
such as, nature of work done by them as compared to nature of work done by
regular employees, the qualifications and responsibilities. He submits that the
parameters delineated in paragraphs 42.1, 42.5, 42.6, 42.8, 42.14 and 42.15
were overlooked by the learned Single Judge while rendering the impugned
judgment. He submits that since the appellant had categorically denied all the
claims of the writ petitioner/union in its counter affidavit, the impugned
judgment is not tenable in the eye of law and the same requires to be interfered
with. In support of his contention the learned Senior counsel places reliance
on the decisions of the Apex Court in Binod Kumar v. State of Jharkhand,
2022 SCC online Jhar 107; P. Radhakrishna Naidu v. Govt. of A.P., (1977) 1
SCC 561; Mota Singh v. State of Haryana, 1980 Supp SCC 600; Union of
India v. Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers Assn., 2023 SCC online SC 173;
State of M.P v. R.D. Sharma (2022) 13 SCC 320.
4.
Mr. P. Yobin, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.1/writ
petitioner/union, on the other hand, submits that the writ petition was filed by
a registered trade union espousing the common and collective cause of its
members and hence, the contention of the appellant that the writ petition was
not maintainable due to multiplicity of cause of action is not legally tenable.
He submits that the grievances raised in the writ petition squarely fell within
the purview of representative action maintainable under Article 226 of the
Constitution. The learned counsel submits that the decision of Jagjit Singh &
ors (supra) was correctly applied by the learned Single Judge wherein it was
held that temporary workers including daily wagers, casual, ad hoc and
contractual appointees, when discharging similar duties and responsibilities
2025:MLHC:660-DB
as regular employees, shall be entitled to minimum pay at par with the regular
scale. He contends that there is no dispute that the members of the writ
petitioner/union are discharging similar and identical duties to that of their
regular counterparts. He submits that in the facts and circumstances of the
present case, the contention of the appellant that the question of pay parity
falls within the administrative domain is totally misplaced as the question of
job evaluation or pay fixation was not an issue in the writ petition. The prayer
in the writ petition was limited to the grant of minimum pay scale applicable
to the regular posts and the learned Single Judge was correct in passing
necessary direction to enforce minimum pay parity. The learned counsel
further submits that the writ petition was not filed seeking regularisation of
service but for redressal of the grievance of the members of the union against
discriminatory and arbitrary classification with regard to payment of salary.
He, therefore, submits that there is no illegality of irregularity in the impugned
judgment of the learned Single Judge and the present appeal, being devoid of
merit, is liable to be dismissed. In support of his submission, the learned
counsel places reliance on the decision of 1965 SCC online SC 128, Workmen
of M/S Dharam Pal Prem Chand (Saugandhi) v. Dharam Pal Prem Chand
(Saugandhi).
5.
No submission has been advanced on behalf of the respondent No.2
being only a formal respondent.
6.
We have given our careful consideration to the submissions made on
behalf of the rival parties and also the materials available on record. It is clear
that the learned Single Judge has entirely placed reliance on the decision of
Jagjit Singh & ors (supra) while rendering the impugned judgment dated
15.07.2024.
7.
The Apex Court in Jagjit Singh & ors (supra) after extensive survey
of case laws pertaining to employees engaged on regular basis as well as
2025:MLHC:660-DB
temporary basis, who were claiming higher wages under the principle of equal
pay for equal work, at paragraph 60, held: “60. Having traversed the legal parameters with reference to the
application of the principle of “equal pay for equal work”, in relation
to temporary employees (daily-wage employees, ad hoc appointees,
employees appointed on casual basis, contractual employees and the
like), the sole factor that requires our determination is, whether the
employees concerned (before this Court), were rendering similar duties
and responsibilities as were being discharged by regular employees
holding the same/corresponding posts. This exercise would require the
application of the parameters of the principle of “equal pay for equal
work” summarised by us in para 42 above. However, insofar as the
instant aspect of the matter is concerned, it is not difficult for us to
record the factual position. We say so, because it was fairly
acknowledged by the learned counsel representing the State of Punjab,
that all the temporary employees in the present bunch of appeals were
appointed against posts which were also available in the regular
cadre/establishment. It was also accepted during the course of their
employment, the temporary employees concerned were being randomly
deputed to discharge duties and responsibilities which at some point in
time were assigned to regular employees. Likewise, regular employees
holding substantive posts were also posted to discharge the same work
which was assigned to temporary employees from time to time. There
is, therefore, no room for any doubt, that the duties and responsibilities
discharged by the temporary employees in the present set of appeals
were the same as were being discharged by regular employees. It is not
the case of the appellants, that the respondent employees did not
possess the qualifications prescribed for appointment on regular basis.
Furthermore, it is not the case of the State that any of the temporary
employees would not be entitled to pay parity on any of the principles
summarised by us in para 42 hereinabove. There can be no doubt, that
the principle of “equal pay for equal work” would be applicable to all
the temporary employees concerned, so as to vest in them the right to
claim wages on a par with the minimum of the pay scale of regularly
engaged government employees holding the same post.”
8.
Thus, it is obvious from the above that with reference to the
2025:MLHC:660-DB
application of principle for equal pay for equal work, the prime factor which
requires consideration in the present case is whether the members of the writ
petitioner/union were rendering similar duties and responsibilities as are being
discharged by regular employees holding same/corresponding posts in terms
of the parameters summarised in para 42 of Jagjit Singh & ors (supra). The
legal positions summarised in para 42 were in different parts and numbered
as para 42.1 to 42.17. While the learned Single Judge had taken note of para
42, 42.3, 44.3, 44.4, 44.5, 44.6, 58, 60 and 61, the contents of para 42.1,42.5,
42.6, 42.8, 42.14 and 42.15 relied on by the learned Senior counsel, were not
considered. The said paragraphs, being relevant, are referred below: “42.1. The “onus of proof” of parity in the duties and responsibilities
of the subject post with the reference post under the principle of “equal
pay for equal work” lies on the person who claims it. He who
approaches the court has to establish that the subject post occupied by
him requires him to discharge equal work of equal value, as the
reference post (see Orissa University of Agriculture & Technology
case, UT Chandigarh, Admn. V. Manju Mathur, SAIL case and
National Aluminium Co.Ltd case).
42.5. In determining equality of functions and responsibilities under the
principle of “equal pay for equal work”, it is necessary to keep in mind
that the duties of two posts should be of equal sensitivity, and also,
qualitatively similar. Differentiation of pay scales for posts with
difference in degree of responsibility, reliability and confidentiality,
would fall within the realm of valid classification, and therefore, pay
differentiation would be legitimate and permissible (see Federation of
All India Customs and Central Excise Stenographers case and SBI
case). The nature of work of the subject post should be the same and
not less onerous than the reference post. Even the volume of work
should be the same. And so also, the level of responsibility. If these
parameters are not met, parity cannot be claimed under the principle
of “equal pay for equal work” (see State of U.P. v. J.P. Chaurasia and
Grih Kalyan Kendra Workers’ Union case).
42.6. For placement in a regular pay scale, the claimant has to be a
regular appointee. The claimant should have been selected on the basis
2025:MLHC:660-DB
of a regular process of recruitment. An employee appointed on a
temporary basis cannot claim to be placed in the regular pay scale (see
Orissa University of Agriculture & Technology case).
42.8. If the qualifications for recruitment to the subject post vis-à-vis
the reference post are different, it may be difficult to conclude that the
duties and responsibilities of the posts are qualitatively similar or
comparable (see Mewa Ram Kanojia case and State of W.B. v. Tarun
K. Roy). In such a case the principle of “equal pay for equal work”
cannot be invoked.
42.14. For parity in pay scales under the principle of “equal pay for
equal work”, equation in the nature of duties is of paramount
importance. If the principal nature of duties of one post is teaching,
whereas that of the other is non-teaching, the principle would not be
applicable. If the dominant nature of duties of one post is of control and
management, whereas the subject post has no such duties, the principle
would not be applicable. Likewise, if the central nature of duties of one
post is of quality control, whereas the subject post has minimal duties
of quality control, the principle would not be applicable (see U.T.
Chandigarh, Admn. V. Manju Mathur).
42.15. There can be a valid classification in the matter of pay scales
between employees even holding posts with the same nomenclature i.e.
between those discharging duties at the headquarters, and others
working at the institutional/sub-office level (see Hukum Chand Gupta
case), when the duties are qualitatively dissimilar.”
9.
Coming to the case at hand, there is no dispute to the fact that the writ
petition concerns various persons working in 31 different posts including that
of Mali, Sweeper, Cleaner, Chowkidar, Jugali, Teacher, Carpenter, Meter
Reader cum Bill-Clerk and many more, but there was no disclosure in the writ
petition about the total number of members of the writ petitioner/union and
the details of the posts held by them. No material has been placed before the
Court to show the total sanctioned strength of each of the different posts held
by the members of the writ petitioner/union and how many of them were
accommodated in the posts which were also available in the regular
2025:MLHC:660-DB
cadre/establishment.
10.
Although, at para 5 of the writ petition a chart has been placed to show
the name of the posts held by the members of the union vis-a-vis the name of
the posts available in regular cadre and the primary nature of works involved,
nothing is provided in details about the responsibilities connected with the
discharge of duties and the duty hours attached to each of the respective posts.
There is no averment in the writ petition giving the details of the requisite
qualification prescribed for regular appointment to each of the 31 posts in
question and also the respective qualification of all the members of the writ
petitioner/union. In absence of details of requisite qualification for regular
employee, it cannot be concluded that the duties and responsibilities in the
posts are qualitatively similar and have equal sensitivity.
11.
The appellants (respondent Nos.2&3) in their affidavit-in-opposition
in WP(C) No.133 of 2021 did not make any admission with regard to the
qualification and eligibility of the members of the writ petition/union insofar
as regular appointment is concerned. It was asserted at para 2 of para-wise
reply (page 378 of memo of appeal) that the contractual employees of the
corporation are appointed on a need basis for a period of one year on the basis
of the contract agreement. The pay of contractual employees is being fixed
and paid from time to time on the basis of the notification issued by the Labour
Department, Government of Meghalaya, in line with the Minimum Wages Act
depending on their skill and ability. Further, at para 4 (page 380 of memo of
appeal) it was stated that the contractual employees, especially, the
Electrician, Meter Reader cum Bill Clerk and Jugali posts are large in number
and the maximum members of the union are being recruited beyond the
sanctioned post purely on the need basis, depending on the requirement of the
job. The claim that the service regulation of the corporation is applicable to
the contractual employees is false and incorrect and the terms and conditions
provided in the contract agreement is binding upon the contractual employees.
2025:MLHC:660-DB
The Apex Court in Orissa University of Agriculture & Technology &
12.
anr v. Manoj K. Mohanty, (2003) 5 SCC 188 at para 10 held: “10. The High Court before directing to give regular pay scale
to the respondent w.e.f. September 1997 on the principle of “equal pay
for equal work” did not examine the pleadings and facts of the case in
order to appreciate whether the respondent satisfied the relevant
requirements such as the nature of work done by him as compared to
the nature of work done by the regularly appointed Junior Assistants,
the qualifications, responsibilities etc. When the services of the
respondent had not been regularized, his appointment was on
temporary basis on consolidated pay and he had not undergone the
process of regular recruitment, direction to give regular pay scale
could not be given that too without examining the relevant factors to
apply the principle of “equal pay for equal work”. It is clear from the
averments made in the writ petition extracted above, nothing is stated
as regards the nature of work, responsibilities attached to the
respondent without comparing them with the regularly recruited
Junior Assistants. It cannot be disputed that there were neither
necessary averments in the writ petition nor was any material placed
before the High Court so as to consider the application of the principle
of “equal pay for equal work”.”
Further, in Steel Authority of India Limited & ors v. Dibyendu
13.
Bhattacharya, (2011) 11 SCC 122, a three Judge Bench of the Apex Court
held: “22. It is the duty of an employee seeking parity of pay under Article
39(d) of the Constitution of India to prove and establish that he had
been discriminated against, as the question of parity has to be decided
on consideration of various facts and statutory rules, etc. The doctrine
of “equal pay for equal work” as enshrined under Article 39(d) of the
Constitution read with Article 14 thereof, cannot be applied in a
vacuum. The constitutional scheme postulates equal pay for equal work
for those who are equally placed in all respects. The court must
consider the factors like the source and mode of
recruitment/appointment, the qualifications, the nature of work, the
value thereof, responsibilities, reliability, experience, confidentiality,
2025:MLHC:660-DB
functional need, etc. In other words, the equality clause can be invoked
in the matter of pay scales only when there is wholesome/wholesale
identity between the holders of two posts. The burden of establishing
right and parity in employment is only on the person claiming such
right.”
14.
The writ petition filed by the writ petitioner/union in the instant matter
is absolutely silent on the source and mode of recruitment/appointment of its
members and their respective qualifications. There is also no disclosure of
responsibilities held by each of the members of the writ petitioner/union and
their reliability, experience, confidentiality and functional need. No material
has been placed by the writ petitioner/union to establish wholesome/wholesale
identity between the posts held by the members of the writ petitioner/union
and their counterparts in regular employment.
15.
The decision of Jagjit Singh & ors (supra) was passed by the Apex
Court on the basis of the admission made by the State of Punjab that all the
temporary employees involved in the case were appointed against posts which
are also available in the regular cadre/establishment. It was also accepted that
during the course of employment, the temporary employees concerned were
being randomly deputed to discharge duties and responsibilities which at some
point of time were assigned to regular employees and likewise, the regular
employees holding substantive post were also posted to discharge the same
work which was assigned to temporary employees from time to time.
However, in the present matter there is no such admission by the appellants
before the writ court. In such a situation, the learned Single Judge was not
correct in placing reliance on the decision of Jagjit Singh & ors (supra)
without there being any material to establish wholesome/wholesale identity
between the posts held by the members of the writ petitioner/union and their
counterparts in regular employment.
16.
In the case of Workmen of M/S Dharam Pal Prem Chand (Saugandhi)
2025:MLHC:660-DB
(supra) relied on by the learned counsel for the respondent No.1/writ
petitioner/union, the Apex Court was considering the validity of a referral of
a dispute by Delhi Administration under section 10(1)(d) and 12(5) of the
Industrial Dispute Act, 1947 in order to determine the jurisdiction of the
Industrial Tribunal, Delhi, to take up the matter under reference. The decision
does not deal with the plea of clubbing of multiple cause of action in one writ
petition raised on behalf the appellant and, hence has no application in the
instant matter.
For the reason and discussion made above, we are inclined to allow
17.
the prayer made in this writ appeal. Resultantly, the impugned judgment dated
15.07.2024 in WP(C) No.153 of 2021 is hereby set aside and quashed. The
writ petition stands dismissed. No costs.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
Meghalaya
31.07.2025
“Shrity,PS”
CH MOMIN
Date: 2025.07.31 17:42:27 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review