Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 27th February 2026
(49)
+
MAC.APP. 286/2016
MEERUT CITY TRANSPORT SERVICE LIMITED ....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Shadab Khan, Advocate.
versus
NEERAJ VERMA & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Jatinder Kamra, Advocate
(through VC)
(50)
+
MAC.APP. 300/2016
MEERUT CITY TRANSPORT SERVICE LIMITED ....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Shadab Khan, Advocate.
versus
YOGESH VERMA & ANR
Through:
....Respondents
Mr. Jatinder Kamra, Advocate
(through VC)
(51)
+
MAC.APP. 1/2019
NEERAJ VERMA & ORS
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Jatinder Kamra, Advocate
(through VC)
versus
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
MEERUT CITY TRANSPORT SRVICE LTD
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Shadab Khan, Advocate for
R1.
(52)
+
MAC.APP. 7/2019
YOGESH VERMA & ANR
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Jatinder Kamra, Advocate
(through VC)
versus
MEERUT CITY TRANSPORT SERVICES LTD .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Shadab Khan, Advocate for
R1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
MAC.APP. 286/2016 and MAC.APP. 300/2016 have been filed
assailing the final judgment and award dated 27 th February 2016 passed
by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts,
Delhi (‘MACT’) in MACT No.31/2014. The cross appeals, being
MAC.APP. 1/2019 and MAC.APP. 7/2019, have been filed by the Legal
Representatives (‘LRs’) of the deceased.
2.
The accident occurred on 20th November 2013 at about 08:00 P.M.
Smt. Meenu Verma (deceased) and Smt. Madhu Verma (deceased)
suffered fatal injuries while they were crossing the road towards the
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
petrol pump on Delhi-Meerut Highway, across from the carriageway
where their car was parked. As per the evidence on record, they were
crossing the road in order to attend nature’s call at the petrol pump, while
their husbands, the claimants herein i.e. Neeraj Verma and Yogesh Verma
were waiting in the car.
3.
While crossing the road, a bus bearing registration no.UP-15AT-
5682 came at a high speed and in a rash and negligent manner and
crushed both the ladies. FIR No.504/2013 was registered at PS Partapur,
Meerut, U.P. and claim petition was filed.
4.
The owner of offending vehicle i.e. Meerut City Transport
Services Ltd. represented by Mr. Shadab Khan, Advocate, has challenged
the award on the ground that both deceased were completely negligent
or, in the alternative, at least contributory negligence ought to be
attributed to both them, considering that they were crossing the highway
at 08:00 P.M. at night and were not crossing road via the zebra crossing
or through a designated area on the highway.
5.
Mr. Jatinder Kamra, counsel for claimants, resists this contention
by stating that the evidence on record would show that they were
crossing the road via the zebra crossing and through an allocated cut on
the divider, going to answer nature’s call and the bus driver did not slow
down or stop the bus upon seeing the two deceased crossing the road.
Moreover, the bus driver attempted to run away but was apprehended
and thereafter FIR was registered, charge-sheet was filed and criminal
proceedings were initiated.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
6.
The only claim made in the cross appeal relates to grant of 40%
future prospects in line with principles enunciated in National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680, considering that Smt.
Meenu Verma and Smt. Madhu Verma were 34 and 28 years of age
respectively.
7.
Mr. Shadab Khan draws attention to the site plan to contend that
there was no reason why the deceased should cross over the other side of
the road at 08:00 P.M. in the night, when naturally the bus driver could
not have spotted them to take precautions in advance.
8.
Mr. Kamra, on the other hand referring to the site plan, states that
deceased had already crossed the road and they were almost next to the
petrol pump and were walking along the petrol pump when the collision
occurred with the bus. The bus driver ought to have slowed down to save
them. The site plan is extracted as under:
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
Analysis
9.
Perusing the site plan, it does seem that that Mr. Kamra’s
submission is tenable, considering that the movement of the two
deceased, as per the arrows in the site plan would show that the deceased
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
had crossed the road and that they were walking along the petrol pump
when the bus, moving almost parallel, managed to crash into both
deceased at point ‘X’. Further, it is submitted by Mr. Kamra that this was
a populated area, where there was a hotel and marriage hall adjacent to
the said petrol pump, making it incumbent upon the bus driver to be
careful and slow down, considering that there could be chances of
pedestrians crossing or persons using the road abutting these particular
properties.
10.
Mr. Shadab Khan referred to the testimony of R1W1/Amit Kumar,
who is the driver of the offending vehicle. He states that he was taking all
major precautions and driving in normal speed and when the bus reached
the petrol pump. Suddenly two women crossed the road in a negligent
manner without taking care of the side traffic while there was a divider
and no pedestrians were supposed to cross the road and other vehicles
were also running on the road. The driver tried to save the women and
passengers, however, they hit the bus and lost their consciousness.
11.
In the cross-examination of the driver as R1W1, there is only a
suggestion put to R1W1 that the accident had taken place due to driver’s
negligence, which he denied. There is nothing, however, which the Court
can glean from his testimony.
12.
However, the testimony of two husbands is to be considered, since
they were practically eyewitnesses.
13.
Mr. Neeraj Kumar Verma (PW1), husband of Smt. Meenu Verma
stated that the ladies were crossing from a designated cut on the road
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
when suddenly a speeding bus driver in high speed crushed both of them.
The driver did not bother to stop the bus even after crushing two people
under its wheel. The police party patrolling near the petrol pump
provided a helping hand and caught hold of the erring bus. He stated that
due to high-speed driving and non-adherence of traffic rules to slow
down near public utilities, the driver of the offending bus was guilty of
negligence.
14.
Cross-examination of PW1 did not elicit anything in addition to
what had been stated. However, he stated that there was a road divider at
the spot of accident and that the deceased were crossing the road going
on the opposite side to attend nature’s call. He stated that there was a
zebra crossing from where the deceased were crossing the road and the
site plan had not been prepared in his presence. He denied the suggestion
that there was no zebra crossing at the spot from where the road was
being crossed.
15.
Considering that part of the testimony is that there was a zebra
crossing and that the deceased were not loitering on the road but going to
attend nature’s call at the petrol pump where such facilities are available,
per se the Court does not see any wrong act having been committed by
both the deceased. It is presumed that they took full care while crossing
the road since that is the basic instinct of survival of any human being.
16.
Moreover, they had crossed over and were going along the petrol
pump when the bus collided with them and they received fatal injuries.
The MACT in its award dated 27th February 2016 deals with this issue in
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
paragraph 12 & 13. It notes that the bus was in high speed and could
have stopped well in time once having seen the deceased. The testimony
of PW1 is in consonance with the version given to the police and there
were two eye-witnesses. Mr. Yogesh Verma, husband of Smt. Madhu
Verma also gave a similar testimony regards the accident.
17.
Moreover, the FIR No.504/2013 at P.S. Partapur was registered
and the possession of bus in question was taken and mechanically
examined. It is stated by Mr. Kamra that the FIR has resulted in a
charge-sheet.
18.
In these circumstances, the Court is not inclined to allow the
appeal of the owner of bus in that there is contributory negligence on the
part of the deceased and no negligence on the part of the driver.
Therefore, the reasoning of the MACT is sustained.
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 1/2019
19.
As far as late Smt. Meenu Verma is concerned, she was aged 34
years on the date of the accident.
20.
Mr. Shadab Khan, counsel for registered owner, has raised an
issue that deceased was not an earning member, since the testimony of
PW1/Sh. Neeraj Verma, husband of late Smt. Meenu Verma, would bear
out in the cross-examination that there was no documentary proof as to
the earning of the deceased of Rs.16,500/- and Rs.10,000/- earnings from
the tuitions, as was mentioned in the affidavit.
21.
Mr. Kamra, counsel for claimant, points out to the testimony given
in the affidavit where Sh. Neeraj Verma has stated that the deceased was
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
working as salaried employee at M/s Perfect Marketing at the time of the
accident and was additionally earning money from tuitions.
22.
He further stated that she was highly qualified as an M.A. and was
computer literate. The educational and merit certificates were exhibited
as Ex.PW1/3 colly.
23.
Mr. Kamra, counsel pointed out to the Income Tax Returns
(‘ITRs’), which were produced and proved by PW2, the Inspector from
Income Tax Office. PW2 brought the ITRs for Assessment Years 20112012 till 2014-2015. Considering the accident had taken place on 20th
November 2013, clearly the ITRs for the Assessment Year 2014-2015
were filed later after the death of Smt. Meenu Verma by the husband,
which is permitted in law.
24.
The MACT, therefore, took the income on the basis of the ITRs
for Assessment Year 2013-2014, which according to this Court was the
correct step.
25.
Moreover, as regards the income from tuition, in the absence of
specific documentary proof, although PW-5, a parent of children
studying at Springfield Public School, Shalimar Garden, deposed that
they were receiving tuition from Smt. Meenu Verma, the income was
assessed solely on the basis of the ITR, which is an authoritative
document.
26.
Accordingly, the pleas raised by counsel for owner cannot be
sustained.
27.
The MACT award is upheld, except to the extent of interest being
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
awarded at 12%, which is on the higher side.
28.
Interest awarded by MACT is usually in the range of 6% to 9%.
Reliance can be placed on the judgment of Kaushnuma Begum (Smt) &
Ors. V New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. (2001) 2 SCC 9, wherein
relying on the power of the Tribunal under Section 171 of MV Act to
grant simple interest on compensation from the date of filing the claim,
Supreme Court noted that interest rates on fixed deposits given by
nationalized banks are to be used for granting interest. In this case, the
interest at 9% is reasonable, considering the long-term fixed deposit
interest rates offered by nationalized banks for the year 2013 i.e. the date
of filing the claim, was about 9%.
29.
Mr. Kamra, counsel, further submits that no future prospects were
granted on the income assessed at Rs. 2,98,752/- after deduction of
personal expenses, with reference to the MACT Award.
30.
To align the compensation with the principles enunciated in
Pranay Sethi (supra), and considering that the deceased was 34 years of
age on the date of accident and was employed in a private capacity,
future prospects at 40% are awarded.
31.
In view of the principles laid down in United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur, (2021) 11 SCC 780, compensation under the head
of loss of love and affection shall be Nil, as the same is subsumed within
loss of consortium. Compensation towards loss of consortium is awarded
at Rs. 40,000/- each to four claimants (husband, two children, and
mother), totaling Rs. 1,60,000/-. Further, Rs. 15,000/- is awarded towards
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
loss of estate and Rs. 15,000/- towards funeral expenses.
32.
The revised compensation in respect of late Smt. Meenu Verma is
as under:
S.no. Heads of Compensation
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by
this Court
1.
Annual Income (A)
Rs. 2,98,752/-
Rs. 2,98,752/-
2.
Future Prospects @40% (B)
Nil
Rs. 1,19,501/-
3.
Less Personal expenses of the
deceased (C) 1/3rd
Rs. 99,584/-
Rs. 1,36,418/-
4.
Annual Loss of Dependency (A+BC=D)
Rs. 1,99,168/-
Rs. 2,81,835/-
5.
Multiplier (F)
6.
Total loss of dependency (E x F = G) Rs. 31,86,688/-
Rs. 45,09,360/-
7.
Compensation for loss of consortium
(I)
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 1,60,000/-
8.
Compensation for loss of love and
affection (J)
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Nil
9.
Compensation for loss of estate (K)
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
10.
Compensation towards funeral
expenses (L)
Rs.25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
11.
Total compensation
Rs. 34,11,688/-
Rs.46,99,360/-
12%
9%
(Rs.40,000x4)
(G+H+I+J+K+L = M)
12.
Rate of Interest Awarded
MAC.APP. 300/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016
33.
As regards late Smt. Madhu Verma, Mr. Shadab Khan, counsel for
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
appellant, raises an issue regarding calculation of benchmark income of
the deceased. The deceased was working as a guest teacher of TGT
English with Sarvodaya Kanya Vidhyalaya, Khajoori Khas, in respect of
which there was evidence of not only PW1, the husband, Sh. Yogesh
Verma, but also of PW3, Smt. Promila Rani, Vice-Principal,
Government, Sarvodaya Vidhyalaya.
PW3 in testimony stated that
deceased was getting an honorarium of Rs.700/- per day, payable
according to the notification of Government of National Capital Territory
of India, Directorate of Education dated 30th August 2013.
34.
On this basis, the MACT took a calculation of 23 working days of
potential earning at Rs.700/- per day working out to Rs.16,100/- per
month as a guest teacher.
35.
As regards the additional income that she was earning from
tuitions, the testimony of PW4/Kailash Chand, whose four children used
to be tutored by the deceased, it was clear from the testimony that
Rs.1,000/- per child was being paid and, therefore, an additional income
of Rs.4,000/- was clearly being received at the time of the accident by the
deceased.
36.
Accounting for potentiality of earning, the MACT took Rs.7,000/-
per month, considering this was a variable income, which could have
involved more children taking private tuitions.
A total income of
Rs.23,100/- was considered and on the basis of which the loss of
dependency was worked out.
37.
Mr. Kamra, counsel points out to the experience certificate
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
available on the record of the Court, which also bears out that she was
engaged as guest teacher on other occasions as well.
38.
Mr. Shadab Khan, counsel pointed out to the payment receipt,
issued by Sarvodaya Kanya Vidhyalaya, to show that in September 2013
she had worked for 2 days, October 2013 for 18 days and November
2013 for 12 days. The maximum time worked in the previous three
months was 32 days, for which she got Rs.22,400/-. PW3 stated that the
maximum limit payable as per the notification of Directorate of
Education, was Rs.17,500/- per month.
39.
Accordingly, the Court is of the opinion that through guest teacher
roles deceased Smt. Madhu Verma could have earned a maximum of
Rs.17,500/- per month, according to the notification of the Directorate of
Education.
40.
As regards the tuition fee, no doubt that she had received
Rs.4,000/- from PW4. The assessment of Rs.7,000/- by MACT regarding
the tuition is not amiss considering parents are keen to get a good teacher
for private tuitions for children. Income is assessed on the basis of
potentiality of earning, which is a broad and just estimate the Court has
to draw, considering that it is a beneficial legislation.
41.
However, the MACT was possibly correct in stating that there are
23 working days in a month and, therefore, the maximum earning could
have been Rs.16,100/- per month.
42.
Therefore, the MACT was correct in its assessment of considering
the benchmark income as Rs. 16,100/-, earning from guest teacher role
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
and Rs. 7,000/- from tuitions, totaling to Rs. 23,100/-.
43.
The MACT did not grant that future prospects, as per principles
enunciated in Pranay Sethi (supra); the deceased was 28 years of age
and, therefore, 40% of future prospects would be awarded, in addition to
the multiplier of 17, as has been applied by the MACT.
44.
As regards the interest as stated above, 9% interest would be
awarded from the date of filing of claim and not 12% interest awarded by
the MACT, which is on the higher side, taking into account, decision of
Supreme Court in Kaushnuma Begum (supra) and that the long-term
fixed deposit interest rates offered by nationalized banks for the year
2013 i.e. the date of filing the claim, was about 9%.
45.
Mr. Shadab Khan, counsel states that 1/3rd deductions should not
have been provided, instead 50% ought to have been taken, considering
that she had only one dependent child, as per the principles in Sarla
Verma & Ors. v Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr (2009) 6 SCC 121.
46.
However, Mr. Kamra, counsel points out, and rightly so, that as
per the principles in Pranay Sethi (supra), 50% deduction was in a case
of a bachelor; here the wife was contributing also to the household
income and was legitimately assumed to be only spending 1/3rd on
herself and the rest was being contributed to the family, which included
the dependent child.
47.
Accordingly, the plea as regards the deduction of 50% for personal
and living expenses is untenable; the MACT was correct in taking the
deduction as 1/3rd towards personal and living expenses.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
48.
In view of the principles laid down in Satinder Kaur (supra),
compensation under the head of loss of love and affection shall be Nil, as
the same is subsumed within loss of consortium. In light of principles
enunciated in Pranay Sethi (supra), compensation towards loss of
consortium is awarded at Rs. 40,000/- each to four claimants (husband,
one child, and parents), totaling Rs. 1,60,000/-. Further, Rs. 15,000/- is
awarded towards loss of estate and Rs. 15,000/- towards funeral
expenses.
49. Therefore, revised computation in respect of late Smt. Madhu
Verma is as under:
S.no. Heads of Compensation
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by
this Court
1.
Monthly Income (A)
Rs. 23,100/-
Rs. 23,100/-
2.
Future Prospects @40% (B)
Nil
Rs.9,240/-
3.
Less Personal expenses of the
deceased (C) 1/3rd
Rs.7,700/-
Rs. 10,780/-
4.
Monthly Loss of Dependency (A+BC=D)
Rs. 15,400/-
Rs. 21,560/-
5.
Annual Loss of Dependency (D x
12=E)
Rs. 1,84,800/-
Rs. 2,58,720/-
6.
Multiplier (F)
7.
Total loss of dependency (E x F = G) Rs. 31,41,600/-
Rs. 43,98,240/-
8.
Compensation for loss of consortium
(H)
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 1,60,000/-
Compensation for loss of love and
affection (I)
Rs. 50,000/-
9.
(Rs.40,000x4)
Nil
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
10.
Compensation for loss of estate (J)
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
11.
Compensation towards funeral
expenses (K)
Rs.25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
12.
Total compensation
Rs. 33,16,600/-
Rs. 45,88,240/-
12%
9%
(G+H+I+J+K=L)
12.
Rate of Interest Awarded
Directions
50.
As per order dated 07th April 2016, the entire compensation
amount was directed to be deposited by this Court. 60% of the awarded
amount was to be released.
51.
Claimants in respect of both the deceased i.e. Smt. Meenu Verma
and Smt. Madhu Verma will, therefore, be entitled to the enhanced
compensation, as computed in the respective tabulations provided above,
along with 9% interest per annum, calculated from the date of the filing
of the petition till the date of deposit. The original compensation along
with 12% interest, already deposited, will also be re-computed at 9% and
will be duly adjusted.
52.
It is directed that a lump sum amount of Rs.5,00,000/- each shall
be released immediately to the respective claimants of the two families,
as per the apportionment directed by the MACT and the rest of the
amount will be preserved in the FDRs, as per the award.
53.
Accordingly, the appeals stand disposed of with the above
directions. Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
54.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to the appellant.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
55.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 27, 2026/mk/zb
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
MAC.APP. 286/2016 & MAC.APP. 300/2016 and MAC.APP. 01/2019 & MAC.APP. 07/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review