Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:26528-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 2480 of 2025
Meenu Kalmu Alias Kalmumi Manoj Alias Denga S/o Lacchu Aged About 40
Years R/o School Para, Pallevaya, Thana Bharamgarh, District Bijapur
Chhattisgarh (Accused/ Appellant No. 1)
... Appellant
versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through Officer-In-Charge Police Station Jangla District
Bijapur Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
:
Mr. B.P. Rao, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Shaleen Singh Baghel, Govt. Advocate
Hon’ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
30/06/2026
1.
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by VED PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.07.09
14:51:52 +0530
The present criminal appeal has been filed by the appellant against the
impugned judgment of conviction and sentence dated 22.09.2025,
passed by the learned Special Judge (NIA Act/Scheduled Offences
Revenue District Sukma and Bijapur), Place South Bastar, Dantewada,
in NIA Scheduled Offence Case No. 26 of 2023, whereby the appellant
has been convicted and sentenced in the following manner:CONVICTION
2.
SENTENCE
U/s 04 of The Explosive
Substance Act 1908
10 Years Rigorous Imprisonment with
fine of Rs. 10,000/-. In default of
Payment of Fine amount additional
Rigorous Imprisonment for 6 Months.
U/s 05 of The Explosive
Substance Act 1908
05 Years Rigorous Imprisonment with
fine of Rs. 5,000/-. In default of
Payment of Fine amount additional
Rigorous Imprisonment for 3 Months.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that The police of police station
Bhairamgarh received a secret information on 14-04-2023 that the
members of banned Maoist organization are trying to explode the
explosive substance for causing harm to police party, for which they are
searching the appropriate place and gathered at village Fullod. The
police also received information that they also delivered some explosive
substance at their new camp Hiroli Pusnar, so that the members of the
said banned organization may cause harm in a large scale. After
receiving secret information and informing it to the higher police
authorities, the police party, on the oral instruction of Superintendent of
Police, Bijapur along with the independent witnesses proceeded
towards village Fullod along with arms and ammunition. After seeing the
police party, the members of banned organization started running and
then they were intercepted by the police, however four persons were
succeeded in fleeing and the police could arrest only one person. He
disclosed his name as Meenu Kamlu @ Kalmumi Manoj @ Denga and
member of the said banned organization of Bhairamgarh Area
Committee. On being searched, one electric detonator has been
recovered from the pocket of his pant. He could not produce any valid
document for its possession and the said detonator has been seized in
presence of the witnesses. The accused was arrested on spot and his
memorandum statement was recorded, in which he disclosed the
involvement of other members of the said banned organization and also
disclosed that, while fleeing, he thrown the explosive substance and
knife in the field. Thereafter, on his instance the explosive substance
and knife has been seized and F.I.R has been registered.
******* The absconded accused persons could not be arrested despite
efforts made by the police authorities and then the investigation against
the arrested accused was completed and after obtaining necessary
sanction for prosecution from the District Magistrate, the charge sheet
has been filed against the appellant before the learned trial Court for the
offence under Sections 34, 120-B, 147, 148, 149 of IPC and Sections 4
and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908 and Sections 16, 20 and
38 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.
3.
The learned trial Court framed charge against the appellant for the
offence under Section 148 of IPC, Sections
4 and 5 of Explosive
Substances Act, 1908 and Sections 20, 38(2) and 39(2) of the Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967. The appellant denied the charge and
claimed trial.
4.
In order to prove the charge against the appellant, the prosecution has
examined as many as 11 witnesses. Statement of the appellant under
section 313 of CRPC has also been recorded, in which he denied the
circumstances appears against him, pleaded innocence and have
submitted that he has been falsely implicated in the offence.
5.
Considering the evidence produced by the prosecution, the learned trial
Court has acquitted the appellant from the offence under Sections 148
of IPC and Sections 20, 38(2) and 39(2) of Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967, however, the appellant has been convicted for
the offence under Sections 4 and 5 of Explosive Substances Act, 1908
and sentenced him as has been mentioned in the earlier part of this
judgment. Hence, this appeal.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that, the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. There are
material omissions and contradictions in the evidence of prosecution
witnesses, which cannot be made basis to convict him for the alleged
offence. The case of the prosecution has not been supported by any
independent witnesses and the other witnesses have not fully supported
the prosecution's case. All the witnesses are police witnesses, who are
interested with the prosecution agency. There is no evidence on record
that the appellant was the active member of banned organization or any
explosive substance has been seized from his possession. The alleged
explosive substance have been recovered by the police from a field,
which is an open place and only to implicate the present appellant in the
offence, he has been arrested showing the seizure made from him.
Alleged memorandum of the appellant is inadmissible piece of evidence
and the case of the prosecution is based on the said memorandum.
Therefore, there is lack of cogent and clinching evidence against the
appellant and he is entitled for acquittal.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the State opposes the
submissions made by learned counsel for the appellant and has
submitted that the prosecution has proved its case beyond reasonable
doubt. But for minor omissions or contradictions the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses are fully reliable, which are sufficient to hold the
appellant guilty for the alleged offence. When the police proceeded for
search on the secret information, the appellant started running, however
he was being detained and other accused persons were succeeded in
fleeing. From the appellant, one electric detonator has been seized and
on his instance other explosive substances have been seized, which he
thrown during his flee. The witnesses have duly supported the
memorandum and seizure and the seizure of electric detonator has not
been explained by the appellant, as to how he came into possession of
the same. The place, where the electric detonator was seized and the
appellant was found, is highly sensitive area, densely affected the
naxalite activities and in such area, the appellant was found in
possession of electric detonator, for which he was being prosecuted.
The recovery has been duly proved and therefore, he has rightly been
convicted by the learning trial Court after appreciating the evidence
available on record. There is no infirmity or perversity in the impugned
judgment passed by learning trial Court and the appeal of the appellant
does not have any merit and same is liable to be dismissed,
8.
We have heard learned counsel for the appellant and gone through the
evidence of the witnesses from the paper book prepared from original
record.
9.
PW-1 Kamlesh Korsa, though cited by the prosecution as an
independent witness, but he did not support the prosecution case during
his examination-in-chief and was consequently declared hostile. He
admitted his signature over the documents (exhibit P-1 to P-16).
10.
PW-2 Taresh Sahu, who was posted as SDOP, Bhairamgarh at the
relevant time, has fully supported the prosecution case. He categorically
deposed that on 14.04.2023, after receiving credible secret information
regarding the movement of members of the banned Maoist organization
carrying explosive substances, he recorded the Dehati Nalishi (Ex. P14), issued notices to the independent witnesses under Section 160
CrPC, and prepared the secret information panchnama (Ex. P-2). He
further stated that, in the presence of the witnesses, search proceedings
were first conducted by preparing the witnesses' search panchnama
(Ex. P-15) and thereafter the search panchnama of the police personnel
and their vehicles (Ex. P-3), so as to ensure transparency in the search
operation. He deposed that the personal search of the appellant was
thereafter conducted vide Ex. P-4, during which one electric detonator
was recovered from the right pocket of the appellant's pant, whereafter
the recovery panchnama (Ex. P-5) was prepared. On a notice (exhibit
P-7) given to him failed to produce any valid licence or authority for
possessing the electric detonator. He further proved that while in
custody, the appellant voluntarily made a disclosure statement (Ex. P-
8), stating that he had thrown the knife and explosive substance in the
field while fleeing, pursuant to which the appellant led the police party to
the place of concealment and the recovered articles were seized vide
seizure memos (Exs. P-9 and P-10). He also proved the preparation of
the spot map (Ex. P-11), the arrest memo (Ex. P-12), and the
registration of the FIR (Ex. P-16), thereby establishing the entire
sequence of events from receipt of information till the registration of the
crime.
******* Despite a lengthy cross-examination, the core of PW-2's
testimony remained wholly unshaken. He consistently maintained that
the police party had departed from Police Station Jangla at about 7:00–
7:30 a.m. after recording the secret information in the rojnamcha and
preparing the secret information panchnama. He denied all suggestions
that no secret information had been received, that the appellant had not
been apprehended at the spot, that no electric detonator had been
recovered from his possession, or that no memorandum statement had
been made by the appellant leading to the recovery of incriminating
articles. The minor omissions elicited during cross-examination, such as
non-mention of the names of individual police personnel searched, the
registration numbers of the motorcycles, the size of the electric
detonator in the seizure memo, or the fact that the appellant's pant was
not separately seized, are merely procedural irregularities which do not
strike at the substratum of the prosecution case. Likewise, the fact that
the seizure memo records the time of seizure at 9:50 a.m. while the
Dehati Nalishi was recorded at 10:00 a.m. only reflects the sequence of
events and does not create any material inconsistency affecting the
genuineness of the recovery. PW-2 firmly denied the defence
suggestion that the seized articles had in fact been recovered from the
jungle and falsely planted upon the appellant. His testimony inspires
confidence, is consistent with the documentary evidence proved by him,
and stands duly corroborated by the evidence of the other official
witnesses and the documents. In these circumstances, the evidence of
PW-2 constitutes a reliable and trustworthy foundation for holding that
the appellant was found in possession of the electric detonator and that
further recoveries were effected pursuant to his voluntary disclosure.
11.
PW-3 Ramdhar Jurri identified the appellant before the Court and
deposed regarding the appellant's antecedents and his association with
extremist activities. He stated that the appellant was responsible for the
murder of his brother, Baksu Ram Jurri, by firearm and further deposed
that the appellant had also committed the murder of Assistant Head
Constable Bhajji Ram Atami, Sukda Netam in the year 2007, and a
husband and wife belonging to the Kursam family of village Pallevaya in
the year 2006. He further stated that during the period of Salwa Judum,
the appellant was involved in the killing of several villagers and forcibly
took young girls into the banned Maoist organisation for training and
exploitation. PW-3 also deposed that after his release from jail, the
appellant used to threaten the local people as well as the police with
dire consequences. He further stated that the police had recorded his
statement during the course of investigation. Thus, the testimony of PW3 was led by the prosecution to establish the background, conduct and
identity of the appellant as a person actively associated with the banned
Maoist organisation operating in the area.
******* In his cross-examination, nothing material could be elicited so as
to discredit his testimony. The witness consistently stated that he had
disclosed all these facts to the investigating agency during investigation.
Although he admitted that he could not assign any reason if certain facts
were not recorded in his police statement (Ex. D-1), such omission does
not by itself render his substantive evidence before the Court unreliable.
He categorically denied the defence suggestion that, having previously
served in the police department, he was falsely implicating the appellant
due to personal animosity. The evidence of PW-3, therefore, remained
substantially intact and lends corroboration to the prosecution case
regarding the appellant's identity and his association with the banned
Maoist organisation.
12.
PW-4 Devendra Chandravanshi, who was posted as Head Constable in
the Office of the SDOP, Bhairamgarh, substantially corroborated the
prosecution
version
regarding
the
search
operation
and
the
apprehension of the appellant. He identified the appellant in Court and
deposed that, on receiving information regarding the presence of Maoist
cadres in the Jangla area, he accompanied SDOP Taresh Sahu and the
police party to Village Fullod. He stated that when the police party
reached near the village, certain persons, on noticing the police, started
fleeing, whereupon one person was apprehended while the others
escaped. Upon enquiry, the apprehended person disclosed his name as
Meenu. He further deposed that during the search of the appellant, one
electric detonator was recovered from the pocket of his pant. He also
stated that, upon interrogation, the appellant disclosed that he had
thrown away a bag while fleeing, whereafter the SDOP recorded his
memorandum statement and the bag was recovered at the appellant's
instance. According to the witness, the recovered bag contained electric
wire, a knife and other articles.
******* During cross-examination, although PW-4 admitted that certain
particulars such as the identity of the police personnel who
apprehended the appellant, the exact pocket from which the detonator
was recovered, the colour of the appellant's clothes, and the detailed
writing work carried out by the SDOP were not within his personal
knowledge as he was standing at some distance for security purposes,
these admissions do not undermine the substance of his evidence. The
witness consistently maintained that he was a member of the raiding
party, and the appellant was apprehended during the operation, and
also that the recovery proceedings took place at the spot. His statement
that he came to know about the recovery of the detonator from the
SDOP while remaining present at the scene is a natural explanation
considering the security arrangement adopted during anti-Naxal
operations, where every member of the police party cannot be expected
to remain at the exact place where the formal search and
documentation are being conducted. He categorically denied the
defence suggestion that he had never visited the spot and was merely
deposing at the instance of the SDOP.
13.
PW-6 Mahendra Pathak, who was posted as Sub-Inspector in the Bomb
Disposal Squad, Reserve Centre, Bijapur, is a witness who proved the
safe handling and disposal of the explosive substances seized during
the investigation. He deposed that on 07.05.2023, in connection with
Crime No. 07/2023 of Police Station Jangla registered under Sections 4
and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act, the seized explosive articles,
namely 10 gelatin sticks, 6 electric detonators, approximately 5 metres
of red codex wire and green safety fuse wire, were brought to the Bomb
Disposal Squad for disposal. In the presence of two witnesses and by
following all prescribed safety protocols, the explosive substances were
destroyed at the Reserve Centre firing range by burying them in a pit
and causing a controlled explosion. Thereafter, the remnants of the
exploded materials were collected separately in sealed plastic
containers for its examination from the Regional Forensic Science
Laboratory, Jagdalpur. He proved the panchnama (exhibit P-18, P-19
and P-20).
14.
PW-7 Dharmaram Tirkey, who was posted as Station House Officer of
Police Station Jangla from 07.10.2022 to October, 2023, proved the
investigation conducted after registration of the offence and established
the continuity of the chain of investigation. He identified the appellant
before the Court and deposed that, on 14.04.2023, on the basis of the
Dehati Nalishi submitted by SDOP Taresh Sahu, he registered the First
Information Report (Ex. P-16) against the appellant for the offences
punishable under Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act,
1908. During the course of investigation, he addressed communications
to the Tahsildar, Bhairamgarh for preparation of the spot map by the
Patwari (Exs. P-21 and P-26). He further proved that the remnants of
the defused explosive materials were seized from Constable Irpa
Chandru vide seizure memo (Ex. P-22). PW-7 also proved the
forwarding memorandum (Ex. P-23) sent through the Superintendent of
Police, Bijapur, for chemical examination of the seized exhibits to the
Regional
Forensic
Science
Laboratory,
Jagdalpur,
the
acknowledgement of receipt (Ex. P-24), and the forensic examination
report (Ex. P-25). He further deposed that, during investigation, he
recorded the statements of material witnesses, including Devendra
Chandravanshi (PW-4), Taresh Sahu (PW-2), Arjun Tamo, Kamlesh
Korsa (PW-1) and Gokul Sahu, thereby completing the investigation in
accordance with law.
******* In his cross-examination, PW-7 remained firmed and denied all
suggestions put forth by the defence. He denied the suggestion that the
FIR had been registered merely at the dictation of SDOP Taresh Sahu
without following due procedure. He also denied the suggestion that the
articles mentioned in seizure memo (Ex. P-22) had not been seized in
the presence of witnesses or that the witnesses' signatures had been
subsequently obtained at the police station. Likewise, he refuted the
suggestion that the statements of the prosecution witnesses were not
recorded as narrated by them and had instead been fabricated by him.
No material contradiction or omission affecting the fairness or legality of
the investigation could be elicited from his testimony. The evidence of
PW-7 is consistent with the documentary record proved by him and
corroborates the evidence of PW-2 and other prosecution witnesses
regarding the registration of the crime, preservation of the seized
exhibits and their forwarding for forensic examination.
15.
PW-8 Gokul Ram Sahu, a Head Constable who was posted at Police
Station Jangla from 01.01.2023 to 02.02.2024, has substantially
corroborated the prosecution case regarding the apprehension of the
appellant Meenu Kalmu @ Manoj and the recovery of the electric
detonator from his possession. He identified the appellant before the
Court and deposed that on 14.04.2023, while accompanying the Station
House Officer during an area domination operation towards Village
Fullod, the police party reached the nearby forest where one person, on
noticing the police, attempted to flee. The said person was surrounded
and apprehended, and on enquiry disclosed his name as Meenu Kalmu
@ Manoj. He stated that, during the personal search of the appellant
conducted by SDOP Taresh Sahu, one electric detonator was recovered
from the pocket of the appellant, which was seized on the spot. He
further deposed that, during interrogation, the appellant disclosed his
involvement in the murder of a police constable who had gone to
Belchar to attend a marriage and also admitted his involvement in the
murder of Maniram, a resident of Godarapal.
******* In his cross-examination, he remained firm on all material
aspects. He admitted that the police party consisted of about nineteen
personnel and that they had divided themselves into different teams for
the purpose of cordoning the forest area. He denied the suggestion that
he had not apprehended the appellant or that the appellant had been
apprehended by another team and subsequently brought before him. He
stated that the search of the appellant was conducted by SDOP Taresh
Sahu and denied the defence suggestion that no electric detonator had
been recovered from the appellant. The witness also affirmed that his
statement under Section 161 CrPC had been recorded on the very day
the appellant was brought to the police station and denied that he was
deposing at the instance of his superior officers. The minor discrepancy
regarding the time of search, or his lack of knowledge about certain
procedural formalities, is inconsequential and does not erode the
substantive value of his testimony.
16.
PW-11 Jitendra Kumar Chandravanshi, who was posted as Deputy
Superintendent of Police, DRG/Naxal Operations, Kutru, Bijapur during
the relevant period, is the subsequent Investigating Officer who
completed the remaining investigation and proved the statutory
compliances necessary for prosecution of the appellant. He identified
the appellant and deposed that, pursuant to the written order of the
Superintendent of Police, Bijapur dated 23.06.2023 (Ex. P-29), the
investigation of Crime No. 07/2023 of Police Station Jangla, registered
under Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908, Section
34 IPC and Sections 16, 20 and 38 of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967, was entrusted to him. During the course of
investigation, he addressed correspondence dated 06.08.2023 to the
Superintendent of Police, Naxal Cell, DCRB, Bijapur, seeking the
criminal antecedents of the arrested and absconding accused persons
(Ex. P-30). He further proved the communication dated 29.09.2023 (Ex.
P-31) seeking permission to submit a charge-sheet under Section 299
CrPC against the absconding accused persons. He also proved the
correspondence made for obtaining statutory sanction for prosecution
under the Explosive Substances Act, namely the communication sent by
the Superintendent of Police to the District Magistrate, Bijapur (Ex. P32), the sanction order granted by the District Magistrate under Sections
4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act (Ex. P-33), his own
communication dated 11.09.2023 requesting sanction under the
Explosive Substances Act and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act
(Ex. P-34), and the sanction order issued by the competent authority at
Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar (Ex. P-35). He further deposed that, during
investigation, he recorded the statements of witnesses Sukaru Madkam,
Ramdhar Jurri and Kishore Karam in accordance with their narration
and, after completion of the investigation, submitted the charge-sheet
before the competent Court. His evidence, therefore, establishes that all
mandatory statutory requirements and procedural formalities preceding
the prosecution were duly complied with.
******* In his cross-examination, nothing of substance could be elicited
to impeach either his credibility or the fairness of the investigation
conducted by him. He categorically denied the defence suggestion that
the statements of witnesses Sukaru Madkam, Ramdhar Jurri and
Kishore Karam had not been recorded as narrated by them and had
instead been fabricated by him.
17.
Upon a comprehensive appreciation of the entire oral and documentary
evidence available on record, we are of the considered opinion that the
prosecution has succeeded in proving beyond reasonable doubt that the
appellant was found in conscious possession of one electric detonator
and that, pursuant to his voluntary disclosure statement, further
explosive articles were recovered from the place pointed out by him.
The testimony of PW-2 Taresh Sahu, who conducted the search
proceedings, is natural, cogent and inspires confidence. His evidence
has
received
substantial
corroboration
from
PW-4
Devendra
Chandravanshi, PW-7 Dharmaram Tirkey and PW-8 Gokul Ram Sahu,
all of whom consistently supported the material circumstances relating
to the apprehension of the appellant, recovery of the electric detonator,
recording of the memorandum statement, subsequent seizure of
explosive articles and completion of the investigation. The evidence of
PW-6 Mahendra Pathak further establishes that the seized explosive
substances were disposed of strictly in accordance with the prescribed
procedure and their remnants were duly preserved and forwarded for
forensic examination, thereby maintaining the sanctity of the chain of
custody. PW-11 Jitendra Kumar Chandravanshi has further proved that
all statutory sanctions and procedural requirements for prosecution
were duly complied with. The documentary evidence, including the
search panchnamas, seizure memos, memorandum statement, FIR,
forensic documents and sanction orders, fully corroborates the oral
testimony of the prosecution witnesses and leaves no room for doubt
regarding the recovery and possession of the explosive substances by
the appellant.
18.
The defence has primarily assailed the prosecution case on the grounds
that the independent witness did not support the prosecution, that the
recovery proceedings suffer from procedural irregularities, and that the
prosecution witnesses are police officials interested in securing
conviction. We are unable to accept any of these submissions. The socalled discrepancies pointed out by the defence relate only to
insignificant procedural details, such as the registration numbers of
vehicles, description of the electric detonator, colour of the appellant's
clothes, identity of every police personnel participating in the search, or
similar omissions, none of which go to the root of the prosecution case.
These are minor discrepancies naturally arising from lapse of time and
do not affect the core prosecution story regarding the seizure of the
electric detonator from the possession of the appellant and the
consequential recovery of additional explosive substances at his
instance. The defence has also failed to establish any motive on the
part of the investigating agency to falsely implicate the appellant by
planting explosive articles upon him. In the absence of any material
demonstrating mala fides, bias or unfair investigation, the evidence of
the official witnesses cannot be discarded merely because they belong
to the police department.
19.
Furthermore, the learned trial Court has rightly appreciated that the
hostility of an independent witness does not eclipse the otherwise
cogent and convincing evidence of the official witnesses. In Nathusingh
v. State of M.P., (1974) 3 SCC 584, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
categorically held that "the mere fact that they are police officers was
not enough to discard their evidence. No reason was shown for their
hostility to the appellant." The same principle has consistently been
reiterated by the Supreme Court that the evidence of police officials is to
be tested on the same parameters as that of any other witness and
cannot be rejected merely because of their official status.
20.
The aforesaid principle has been further elaborated by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Anil v. State of Maharashtra, (1996) 2 SCC 589,
wherein it was held in paragraph 5 that:“5. ….... There is, however, no rule of law that the
evidence of police officials has to be discarded or
that it suffers from some inherent infirmity.
Prudence, however, requires that the evidence of
the police officials, who are interested in the
outcome of the result of the case, needs to be
carefully
scrutinised
and
independently
appreciated. The police officials do not suffer
from any disability to give evidence and the mere
fact that they are police officials does not by itself
give
rise
to
any
doubt
about
their
creditworthiness.”
21.
Similar principles have been reiterated in State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)
v. Sunil, (2001) 1 SCC 652, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court
authoritatively held that there is no legal presumption that police officers
are untrustworthy witnesses and that the Court cannot approach their
evidence with an initial distrust merely because they are official
witnesses. Their Lordships observed that, unless there are compelling
reasons to doubt the fairness of the investigation, the testimony of
police personnel cannot be discarded solely for want of independent
corroboration.
22.
Likewise, in Ajmer Singh v. State of Haryana, (2010) 3 SCC 746, while
dealing with the objection regarding absence of independent witnesses
during recovery proceedings, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that nonassociation or non-support of independent witnesses is not by itself fatal
to the prosecution and that the Court is required to evaluate whether the
evidence of the official witnesses is otherwise trustworthy and reliable.
In the present case, after carefully scrutinising the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses, we find their testimony to be consistent, reliable
and fully corroborated by the documentary record. Consequently, the
mere fact that PW-1 did not support the prosecution does not in any
manner weaken the otherwise convincing prosecution case. In Ajmer
Singh (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that:“19. …..it is normally expected that there should
be independent evidence to support the case of
the prosecution. However, it is not an inviolable
rule. Therefore, in the peculiar circumstances of
this case, we are satisfied that it would be
travesty of justice, if the appellant is acquitted
merely because no independent witness has
been produced.
20. We cannot forget that it may not be possible
to find independent witness at all places, at all
times. The obligation to take public witnesses is
not absolute. If after making efforts which the
court considered in the circumstances of the case
reasonable, the police officer is not able to get
public witnesses to associate with the raid or
arrest of the culprit, the arrest and the recovery
made would not be necessarily vitiated. The court
will have to appreciate the relevant evidence and
will have to determine whether the evidence of
the police officer was believable after taking due
care and caution in evaluating their evidence.”
23.
It is also significant to note that the appellant has failed to offer any
plausible explanation as to how he came into possession of the electric
detonator recovered during his personal search. The place of
occurrence is a densely forested and highly Naxal-affected area where
the police party had proceeded on specific secret information regarding
the movement of members of the banned organisation carrying
explosive substances. The recovery of the electric detonator from the
appellant, followed by the recovery of additional explosive articles
pursuant to his disclosure statement, constitutes a complete chain of
incriminating circumstances establishing his conscious possession of
explosive substances. The acquittal of the appellant from the offences
under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 and the Indian
Penal Code does not dilute the independent evidence proving the
offences punishable under Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive
Substances Act, 1908. The ingredients of the said offences stand fully
established from the evidence adduced by the prosecution.
24.
In view of the foregoing discussion, we find that the learned Special
Judge has meticulously appreciated the oral and documentary evidence
in its proper perspective and has rightly recorded the finding that the
prosecution has proved the guilt of the appellant for the offences
punishable under Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act,
1908 beyond all reasonable doubt. The findings recorded by the learned
trial Court are based upon proper appreciation of evidence and do not
suffer from any perversity, illegality or misapplication of law warranting
interference by this Court in the exercise of appellate jurisdiction.
25.
Consequently, the conviction and sentence imposed upon the appellant
under Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908 by the
judgment dated 22.09.2025 passed by the learned Special Judge (NIA
Act/Scheduled Offences Revenue District Sukma and Bijapur), Place
South Bastar, Dantewada, in NIA Scheduled Offence Case No. 26 of
2023 are hereby affirmed. The present criminal appeal, being devoid of
merit, is accordingly dismissed.
26.
The appellant shall undergo the remaining part of the sentence awarded
to him.
27.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is undergoing his jail
sentence to communicate the same to the appellant informing him that
he is at liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this Court by
preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the
assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the Supreme
Court Legal Services Committee.
28.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be transmitted to
the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
HEAD NOTE
******* In cases arising from a Naxalite-affected area,
where availability of independent witnesses may not
always be practicable, the testimony of police officials
cannot be rejected merely because they are official
witnesses and may be relied upon if it is found
trustworthy, reliable and credible.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review