Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 13th March 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 817/2017
MEENA DEVI GOSWAMI & ORS
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Anshuman Bal, Adv.
versus
RELIANCE GEN INS CO LTD & ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. A.K. Soni, Adv. (through VC)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed by the claimant, assailing award dated 31 st
July 2017 (hereinafter, ‘impugned award’) passed by the Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal [‘MACT’], Karkardooma Courts, which dismissed the claim
petition filed by legal representatives [‘LRs’] of Late Bhudev Prasad
(‘deceased’) under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (‘MV Act’)
seeking compensation of Rs.2,00,00,000/-. MACT held that the issue of
negligence could not be proven against the driver of offending vehicle and
therefore, granted compensation of Rs.50,000/- for no fault liability under
Section 140 of MV Act.
2.
The accident occurred on 16th February 2015 at about 8:15 p.m., when
the deceased was travelling on a motorcycle from the side of Tronica City
towards his house in Bhajan pura, Delhi. When he reached near Sonia Vihar
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
MAC.APP. 817/2017
in front of K.K. Transport, the deceased collided with a Tempo bearing no.
DL-1LE-5831 parked in the middle of the road without any back light or
indication, as alleged by the claimants, resulting in death of deceased. FIR
91/2015 was registered under Sections 279/304A of Indian Penal Code, 1860
(‘IPC’) at P.S. Sonia Vihar, Delhi.
3.
Mr. Anshuman Bal, counsel for claimant, has placed reliance upon the
testimony of Mobin Khan (‘PW2’), who was stated to be an independent
eyewitness. PW2 stated that the deceased was ahead of him on the
motorcycle, and a Tempo (alleged offending vehicle) was parked in the middle
of the road without any back light or indication in complete darkness, as a
result of which the motorcyclist/deceased met with the accident, fell on the
road and died. The police came at the spot and made inquiries of the accident,
and his statement was recorded. On this basis, it has been claimed that the
testimony of an independent eyewitness ought to have some merit and, at best,
an award for contributory negligence ought to have been made rather than
dismissing the claim petition itself and awarding compensation for no fault
liability.
4.
Reliance has been placed on the decision of Supreme Court in Jumani
Begam v. Ram Narayan (2020) 5 SCC 807, which was a case involving a
rear end collision. The Supreme Court differed with the conclusion arrived at
by the High Court that there was contributory negligence and concluded that
substantive evidence of the eyewitness before the MACT could not have been
dismissed and contributory negligence should not have been awarded by the
MACT.
5.
This Court has perused the relevant documents. In the cross-
examination, PW2 states that he was driving at a speed of 35-40 kmph and
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
MAC.APP. 817/2017
the deceased was driving his motorcycle ahead of him after overtaking him.
This would indicate that the motorcycle driven by deceased was in high speed.
PW2 stated that headlights of the Tempo coming towards them were on and
they were dazzled by the headlights and in an attempt to avoid the Tempo
coming from front, the deceased swerved his motorcycle and collided in the
rear of the Tempo which was parked on the left side. He stated that the police
arrived at the place of accident about 10-15 minutes later. He was questioned
whether the deceased was wearing a helmet, to which he stated that he had
not removed the helmet and had not seen the helmet at the place of accident.
6.
In the opinion of the Court, the cross-examination of PW2, would bear
out that not only was the deceased driving at quite some speed, more than at
least 50-60 kmph, in order to overtake PW2, but he was also not wearing a
helmet and had swerved to the left in order to avoid an oncoming Tempo. For
this purpose, it is important also to examine the Site Plan, which is extracted
as under:
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
MAC.APP. 817/2017
7.
It is quite clear from the Site Plan that there were red lights in that area
where the collision occurred at point number no. A. Moreover, it is also
obvious that the Tempo was already parked on the left side of the road and
there was enough space on the carriageway on the other side, where the
oncoming Tempo must have been moving. There was no reason for the
deceased to not have noticed the Tempo parked on the left side of the road,
since there seemed to be enough ambient light there, along with its own
motorcycle headlights. It does show that the deceased was possibly negligent
in driving at a speed where he could not control his movements to negotiate
with the traffic on the road.
8.
Considering that the police arrived at the site immediately thereafter,
within 10-15 minutes and the site plan was produced thereafter, the site plan
itself cannot be questioned and has not been questioned.
9.
Moreover, the driver of Tempo gave his testimony as R1W1 and stated
that he had not parked the Tempo in the middle of the road without any back
light and indication and was moving on the road in a slow speed. When the
driver heard the sound of something crashing in the back portion of his
vehicle, he got down to see what had happened behind. In his crossexamination, only a suggestion was made that the vehicle was parked in the
middle of the road, and the accident was caused due to his negligence. No
other substantive cross-examination was made of the driver by the claimants.
10.
Nothing further can be elicited from the testimonies to substantiate the
contention of claimants that there was negligence on part of driver of Tempo
in parking his Tempo without any indicators or otherwise, that there could
have been contributory negligence.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
MAC.APP. 817/2017
11.
The Court has also perused the impugned order of the MACT, in which
paragraph 7.1 determines the issue of negligence. Notably, the MACT
records that a final report has been filed under Section 173 of Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (‘CrPC’). The final report also suggested that the
deceased was driving the motorcycle at the time of accident at a high speed.
12.
Therefore, MACT has correctly noted that mere parking on left side of
the road does not amount to a rashness and negligence on the part of driver,
in the totality of the facts and circumstances. The issue of presence of the red
light and headlights of the motorcycle have also been noted by the MACT.
13.
At this stage, Mr. Bal, counsel for the appellant, made an oral
submission that, in the alternative, the present claim petition may be treated
as one filed under Section 163A of the MV Act, and the appellant may be
granted compensation on the basis of no fault liability under the said
provision.
14.
However, Mr. Soni, counsel appearing for the respondent, opposes the
same and contends that the statutory scheme of the Act clearly indicates that
a claimant cannot pursue a claim together under section 140 and section 163A.
He submits that compensation can either be sought under section 140 of the
Act, which provides for compensation on the principle of no fault liability, or
under Section 163A, which provides for compensation on a structured
formula basis.
15.
Considering that the claimant has already received compensation under
section 140 of the MV Act, the contention of Mr. Bal to treat the claim petition
as one filed under Section 163A of the MV Act ought to be rejected.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
16.
The Court concurs with the contention of Mr. Soni.
17.
The Supreme Court in Deepal Girishbhai Soni v. United India
MAC.APP. 817/2017
Insurance Co. Ltd. (2004) 5 SCC 385 has explained the nature and scope of
Section 140 and 163A of the MV Act. The Supreme Court elucidated that
Section 140 of the Act provides for interim compensation. However, by
introducing Section 163A, Parliament intended to create a mechanism for
awarding a predetermined amount of compensation without requiring a
prolonged trial or proof of negligence in causing the accident. The legislative
intent behind the amendment was to provide a speedy and efficacious remedy
to heirs of the deceased or the victim himself, which was not available under
Section 166 of the Act.
18.
The Supreme Court further clarified that the effect of Section 140 and
163A does not provide for similar scheme.
19.
In paragraph 51 of Deepal Girishbhai Soni (supra), the Court
observed that Section 163A clearly indicates that the rights and obligations of
the parties are intended to be determined finally under the said provision.
Under Section 163A of the MV Act, compensation is awarded on the basis of
the structured formula provided in the Second Schedule.
20.
Section 140 of the Act provides for interim compensation on the
principle of no fault liability and permits adjustment. Section 163A on the
other hand does not provide for any adjustments, and final compensation is
awarded under the same.
21.
As per Section 163B of the MV Act, a claim can be filed in either
Section 140 or Section 163A. Section 163B is extracted as under for ease of
reference:
“163B-Where a person is entitled to claim compensation
under section 140 and section 163A, he shall file the claim
under either of the said sections and not under both.”
(emphasis added)
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
MAC.APP. 817/2017
22.
Legislative intent behind the said provision is clear that the claimant
cannot simultaneously invoke the benefit of both provisions. The same was
also observed by the Supreme Court in the judgment of Deepal Girishbhai
Soni (supra) in paragraph 52, which is extracted as under:
“52. It may be true that Section 163-B provides for an
option to a claimant to either go for a claim under Section
140 or Section 163-A of the Act, as the case may be, but
the same was inserted ex abundanti cautela so as to
remove any misconception in the minds of the parties to
the lis having regard to the fact that both relate to the
claim on the basis of no-fault liability. Having regard to
the fact that Section 166 of the Act provides for a complete
machinery for laying a claim on fault liability, the
question of giving an option to the claimant to pursue their
claims both under Section 163-A and Section 166 does not
arise. If the submission of the learned counsel is accepted
the same would lead to an incongruity”
(emphasis added)
23.
Further, in paragraph 56 of Deepal Girishbhai Soni (supra), the
Supreme Court held that purposive interpretation needs to be given to the Act.
“56. It is now well settled that for the purpose of
interpretation of statute, same is to be read in its entirety.
The purport and object of the Act must be given its full
effect. The object underlying the statute is required to be
given effect to by applying the principles of purposive
construction.”
(emphasis added)
24.
In paragraph 57 of the said judgment, the Supreme Court concluded
that compensation awarded under Section 163A and Section 166 is final in
nature and provide for independent statutory mechanism for determining
compensation.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
MAC.APP. 817/2017
25.
In the present case, the claimant/appellant filed a claim petition before
MACT under Sections 166 and 140 of the MV Act. Therefore, at this stage,
the appellant cannot contend that the petition be treated as one filed under
Section 163A, as he has already elected and exhausted his remedy by filing a
claim under Sections 166 and 140.
26.
Accordingly, the submission of Mr. Bal, counsel for claimant, that the
present claim petition be treated as one filed under Section 163A of the MV
Act is unwarranted.
27.
In view of the facts and circumstances, as stated above, the appeal
stands dismissed.
28.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
29.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
MARCH 13, 2026/ak/bp
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
17:21:20
MAC.APP. 817/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review