Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1052
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
FA No. 2 of 2021
Date of Decision: 20.11.2024
Smti. Mecilda Lyngdoh
W/o (L) Francis Wahlang
R/o Nongkhlaw Syiemship,
P.O. Mairang, West Khasi Hills
District, Meghalaya
:::Appellant
-VsSmti. Jacinta Jyrwa
W/o (L) Francis Wahlang
R/o Mawiong, Shillong
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
:::Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. A.R. Passah, Adv.
Mr. S. Syiem, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. K.S. Kharshiing, Adv.
:
2024:MLHC:1052
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This Appeal has been filed under Section 384 of the Indian
Succession Act, 1925, for setting aside and quashing the order dated
06.08.2021, passed by the learned Judge, District Council Court, in
Succession Case No. 174 of 2012, granting a Succession Certificate in
favour of the respondent No. 1, with regard to the debts and securities left
behind by the appellant late husband namely Francis Wahlang.
2.
The appellant is stated to be the legally wedded wife of (L) Francis
Wahlang, who were married on 28.11.1983, under the Christian Marriage
Act, but however, there were no children born out of the wedlock. On the
death of (L) Francis Wahlang, the appellant had approached the office of
the Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL), where the deceased was
working, to claim the debts and securities left behind by her late husband,
and was instructed to obtain a Succession Certificate as there were other
claimants. The appellant then came to learn that the respondent No. 1, had
already obtained a Succession Certificate from the learned Court below
2024:MLHC:1052
vide order dated 06.12.2012, with regard to the debts and securities left
behind by her deceased husband.
3.
The appellant then applied for revocation of the Succession
Certificate issued to the respondent No. 1, whereafter the Court below by
order dated 17.05.2013, was pleased to stay the operation of the Succession
Certificate issued to the respondent No. 1. Thereafter, the respondent No. 2,
who claimed to be the sister of the deceased also filed an application for
revocation of the Succession Certificate, on the ground that the same had
been fraudulently obtained. The matter then proceeded for trial and issues
were framed, witnesses examined, and hearing was concluded. Thereafter
by order dated 06.08.2021, the revocation petition filed by the appellant
was rejected and the Succession Certificate granted in favour of the
respondent No. 1 vide order dated 06.12.2012, upheld.
4.
Being aggrieved thereby the appellant has preferred the instant
Appeal on and amongst others the following grounds.
a) That the learned Court below failed to appreciate the fact that the
appellant was the legally wedded wife of the deceased (L) Francis
Wahlang.
b) That the learned Court below erred in law in holding that despite
the appellant being the legally wedded wife of the deceased, she
was not entitled to the debts and securities.
2024:MLHC:1052
c) That the learned Court below failed to appreciate the fact that she
was still the legally wedded wife, even if the deceased may have
cohabited with the respondent.
d) That as the deceased and the respondent No. 1 were not legally
married, it is not the respondent No. 1 who shall be entitled to the
debts and securities, but only the children of the respondent No. 1
would be entitled to share the same.
e) That the learned Court below failed to appreciate that since the
appellant and the deceased are legally married, the debts and
securities left behind by the deceased husband should be shared
equally between the appellant and the children of the respondent
No. 1.
5.
When the matter was taken up for hearing, the respondent No. 2,
through her counsel has submitted that she was not interested or inclined to
contest the matter, and it was prayed that her name be struck off from the
array of parties, which was allowed by this Court vide order dated
30.08.2022.
6.
It has been submitted by Mr. A.R. Passah, learned counsel for the
appellant that the appellant had established the fact before the Lower Court
that she was the legally wedded wife, inasmuch as, the respondent herself
2024:MLHC:1052
had admitted the same in her evidence. A Marriage Certificate he submits
existed which had been tendered in her evidence and marked as Papermark
2, and the marriage was corroborated by the other witnesses and by the
findings of the Court below, that the appellant is the legally wedded wife. It
is further submitted that despite the Court below, returning of finding that
the appellant is the legally wedded wife of the deceased, the dismissal of
the revocation application on the ground that the appellant never took care
or looked after her deceased husband is perverse, moreso, as there was no
issue framed on this point and in absence of such issue, the parties had not
led evidence in support of their case on this issue.
7.
On another issue, it is submitted by the learned counsel that though
the children from the second wife, even if there is no marriage contracted,
would be entitled to debts and securities, the question of whether the
respondent had children from the deceased is questionable, inasmuch as, all
the Birth Certificates had been obtained after the demise of (L) Francis
Wahlang. The learned counsel submits that even PW2, one Smti. Bity
Jyrwa, had deposed before the Trial Court that the eldest daughter of the
respondent is not the daughter of (L) Francis Wahlang, which therefore cast
serious doubts on the parentage of the children, and this aspect was never
dwelt upon by the Court below and no findings were returned in this
regard.
2024:MLHC:1052
8.
It has also been contended that the claim of the respondent on the
basis of cohabitation and customary practice that once a man and a woman
cohabit together for long period, a presumption of marriage can be drawn
will not be applicable in the instant case, as the appellant was the surviving
spouse of the deceased and that even among the Khasis bigamy is a
practice frowned upon. He therefore submits that the appellant is entitled to
the family pension and the respondent has no right over the same. In
support of his arguments, the learned counsel has relied upon the following
cases:
i)
Rajkumari & Anr. vs. Krishna & Ors. reported in
(2015) 14 SCC 511
ii)
Smti.
Mahalakshmamma
vs.
The
Secretary
Department of Rural Development & Ors. (Karnataka
High Court) 2023 Kar 447
iii)
Judgment dated 07.05.2015, of the Gauhati High
Court passed in Intest Case No. 8 of 2006.
9.
Mr. K. S. Kharshiing, learned counsel on behalf of the respondent
has at the outset submitted that the purported marriage between the
deceased and the appellant/objector Smti. Mecilda Lyngdoh, is not proved,
inasmuch as, the original certificate of marriage was never produced in
evidence. He further submits that the appellant had admitted that she had
2024:MLHC:1052
no issue from the deceased (L) Francis Wahlang, and also that she was not
living together with him nor did she take care of him during his illness till
his demise, nor did she perform his last rites. In her cross-examination he
submits, the appellant was not able to prove any of her assertions, even of
her marriage and about the situation and condition of the deceased. He
submits that the appellant did not know the date, time or place of death of
the deceased and whether the deceased was cremated or buried. On the
other hand he submits, the respondent was residing with her deceased
husband since the year 1991, and that as per Khasi custom, a man and
woman residing together with children born out of this cohabitation are
considered a married couple, and the children legitimate.
10.
The learned counsel submits that the respondent had proved by
evidence both oral and documentary that since 1991, she had cohabited
with the deceased as husband and wife, and that the four children for which
Birth Certificates have been exhibited, were born out of this union. It is
also submitted that the respondent had performed the last rites of her
deceased husband and the cremation was supervised by her mother-in-law,
and all the funeral expenses were borne by the respondent and the mother
of the deceased. He therefore contends that, the appellant has miserably
failed to prove her case and as such, is not entitled to any relief as claimed.
In support of his case, the learned counsel has placed reliance on the
2024:MLHC:1052
decision rendered in the case of Vidhyadhari & Ors. vs. Sukhrana Bai &
Ors. reported in (2008) 2 SCC 238.
11.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties. A perusal of the impugned
judgment under appeal shows that both the appellant and the respondent
had tendered oral and documentary evidence along with other witnesses,
and from a re-appreciation of the evidence, apart from the fact that the copy
of the original Marriage Certificate was never produced, the other
contentions that has been put forward by the respondent, as can be seen
from the findings of the learned Court below stand unrebutted. These are
the factum of cohabitation of the respondent and the deceased since the
year 1991, the fact that the respondent and the deceased had two sons and
two daughters, for which Birth Certificates have been produced and that the
respondent performed the last rites along with the mother of the deceased.
12.
The picture that emerges therefore, is that though the appellant is the
legally wedded wife, their marriage being solemnized on 28.11.1983, they
however, ceased to cohabit after a certain period of time, and it has been
established by evidence that the deceased then cohabited with the
respondent from the year 1991 onwards, till his demise on 03.01.2012, and
out of this union, four children were born. The learned Court below after
digesting the evidence, then held that simply by the solemnization of
marriage, when the parties had separated and were not living together as
2024:MLHC:1052
husband and wife, the same will not be a license for inheriting the debts
and securities left behind by the deceased. Further on the finding that the
respondent had taken care of the deceased during his illness, and also
performed the last rites, the learned Court below allowed the Succession
Certificate granted in favour of the respondent on 06.12.2012 to stand.
13.
In this backdrop on the findings of the learned Court below, this
Court is to examine whether on these sets of facts, the appellant could be
considered ineligible to inherit the debts and securities left behind by the
deceased. It is now settled law that a legally wedded wife will not
automatically be entitled to a Succession Certificate to the exclusion of the
second defacto wife and her children, who are legitimate for the purpose of
a share in the debts and securities. However, the fact that a legally wedded
wife would also be entitled, notwithstanding the fact that they may, or may
not have been cohabiting as long as the same has not been annulled, cannot
be ignored. This Court therefore, in view of the fact that both of the parties
herein have a valid claim on the debts and securities of the deceased, and to
balance the equities on the said rival claims, in the facts and circumstances
as they prevail, hereby orders as follows:1) As the appellant is the legally wedded wife of the deceased,
who will have the first claim on the family pension, it is
ordered that the appellant shall be entitled to the family
2024:MLHC:1052
pension of the deceased commencing from the month of
January, 2025.
2) The respondent who also holds a valid claim through the
children shall be entitled to the terminal benefits, as has been
given in the schedule of debts and securities of the application
for Succession Certificate, which includes DCRG, leave
encashment, GPF, GSLI and shall also be allowed to draw the
accumulated arrears of family pension from the date of the
demise of the deceased till December, 2024.
14.
The above directions have been given notwithstanding the fact that
family pension and its entitlement thereto, is governed by applicable rules
and does not form a part of terminal benefits of the deceased person, for
which Succession can be applied for. However, the family pension being a
part of the employment dues payable to the legitimate heirs, as earlier
observed, this order has been passed to balance the equities.
15.
The impugned order, in view of the discussions made herein above,
is set aside.
16.
The instant Appeal resting on different facts and circumstances, from
the cases cited by the parties, the same are not elaborated.
17.
The instant Appeal accordingly stands closed and disposed of.
2024:MLHC:1052
18.
Lower Court records to be transmitted back.
Judge
Meghalaya
20.11.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2024.11.20 14:04:33 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review