The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Accordingly, the order impugned dated October 12, 2021 passed by the CEO of the State Waqf Board is set aside. It will be open to the State Waqf Board, whenever constituted, to comply with the directions issued to such Board in accordance with law and upon hearing the appellant herein. However, if the State Waqf Board is not constituted within the next three months, it will be open to the appellant or any other person aspiring to be the joint mutawalli of the waqf estate to apply to this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution for appropriate directions. Since the unauthorised appointment of the joint mutawalli by the CEO’s order of October 12, 2021 has been annulled, the appellant has to be put on terms. Till such time that a joint mutawalli is appointed to jointly administer the waqf estate along with the appellant herein, the appellant will not alienate any of the waqf properties or create any third party rights in respect thereof without the express previous leave of this Court. The appellant will be entitled to receive rents from continuing tenants but will have no right to install any new tenant, if any existing tenant is evicted or otherwise vacates any portion of the premises. The appellant will also maintain true and faithful accounts and have the same audited on an annual basis, if not already done.
14. In the light of the above, the judgment and order impugned dated June 17, 2022 stands set aside and the writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above. There is no doubt that the appellant cannot object to a joint mutawalli being appointed as such issue has been settled by the Supreme Court‘s order referred to above; but the appellant will still have a say in the appointment which the Board may take into consideration at the time of making the relevant appointment without permitting the appellant herein to use the right to object as to the selection as a ruse to stall or thwart the appointment.
15. WA No. 27 of 2022 succeeds to the extent indicated above. There will, however, be no order as to costs. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 27/2022
Date of order: 20.07.2022
Md. Sulaiman
vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
:
Mr. S. Jindal, Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. K. Khan, Sr. Adv With
Mr. S.A. Shiekh, Adv
Mr. T.T. Diengdoh, Sr. Adv With
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The most startling feature of this matter is the aggressive conduct
of the Chief Executive Officer of the Waqf Board in the State who
appears to be more keen to support the cause of the private respondent
than the private respondent himself.
2.
Ordinarily, in matters of the present kind when there is a fight
between two private parties and the order of an authority is assailed, the
authority does not take a stand, even to sustain its order so that the
indifference and impartiality of the relevant authority is not called into
question. However, the order passed by the CEO of the State Waqf Board
has been sought to be aggressively sustained by the CEO himself without
the private respondent, the person likely to be affected if the order
impugned is annulled, taking as much interest in the matter as the CEO
of the Waqf Board.
3.
The appeal is directed against a judgment and order of June 17,
2022 by which the appellant’s writ petition has been dismissed on the
ground that the appellant may not have had the locus standi to question
the propriety of an order dated October 12, 2021 passed by the CEO of
the Meghalaya State Waqf Board. By the relevant order of October 12,
2021, the CEO appointed Md. Zakaria, the private respondent herein, to
be the successor to the joint mutawalliship of the Haji Elahi Baksh Waqf
Estate from Haji Kammu Mia’s line. The primary ground urged by the
appellant-writ petitioner in the petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution was that the CEO did not and could not have had the
authority to pass the order as the direction contained in this Court’s order
of September 20, 2021, which is referred to in the CEO’s order dated
October 12, 2021, required the Waqf Board – and not its CEO – to pass
the relevant order.
4.
It may do well to notice the order dated September 20, 2021
passed on the private respondent’s writ petition. The operative part of the
order is found at paragraph 6 thereof:
“6. The petitioner is directed to remain present before the Chief
Executive Officer of the respondent Meghalaya State Wakf Board
along with a copy of this order as well as the order dated 28-112019 passed in WP(C) No. 294/2015, on 27-09-2021 at 11 am to
enable the respondent to comply with this order.”
5.
As it is evident from the order itself, the private respondent herein
was to merely present himself before the CEO of the Waqf Board but it
was for the Waqf Board to comply with the order dated November 28,
2019, not its CEO.
6.
The previous order dated November 28, 2019 also contained a
direction by which the private respondent’s writ petition was disposed of
by requiring “the Waqf Board to provide opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner and also to consider his name along with other descendants of
late Haji Kammu Mia while making appointment of mutawalli.” Thus,
there could have been no two opinions regarding the consistent directions
issued by this Court for the State Waqf Board to make the appointment.
7.
In terms of the Auqaf Act, 1995, the duties and authority of the
State Waqf Board are quite distinct from the duties and authority of its
CEO. Section 14 of the Act provides for the composition of a Waqf
Board, inter alia, for every State. It is submitted on behalf of the State that
at present there is no Waqf Board in place in the State, nor is there any
Waqf Tribunal.
8.
It may do well to notice the circumstances in which the disputes
arose pertaining to the office of mutawalli of the relevant waqf estate.
The waqfnama executed in November, 1936 provided, in its first clause
that a son of a waqif and a son-in-law of the waqif would be the joint
mutawallis “during their lifetime.” It is necessary to notice the next two
clauses from the waqfnama:
“2. On the death of either of the joint matwalis, the survivor shall
be the sole matwali for the time being, and shall have power to
nominate his successor from the family line of the Settlor.
“3. Each successive matwali thereafter shall have the right to
nominate his successor from the same source.”
9.
On a plain reading of the relevant clauses, it is evident that the
joint mutwalliship was to be at the inception and for the surviving original
joint mutawalli to continue in office as the sole mutawalli upon the death
of the other joint mutawalli. Thereupon, the office of the mutawalli would
devolve on such successor from the family line of the waqif as chosen by
the mutawalli in office. It does not appear, on a plain reading of clauses
(2) and (3) of the waqfnama, that joint mutawalliship was contemplated
after the initial joint mutawallis died or that the waqif desired that there
should be one person from his male line and another person from his
female line of descendants who should jointly be mutawallis of the waqf
estate. However, a question arose as to whether a descendent from the
female line of descendent of the waqif could also be a mutawalli of the
relevant waqf estate. Upon the matter reaching the Supreme Court, the
following opinion was expressed in an order dated September 26, 2019.
“13. …
In the present case, since Respondent No. 2 (the appellant-writ
petitioner herein) has shown a disinclination to nominate a
successor to the deceased Kammu Mia, as provided for under
the terms of the waqf deed, we direct Respondent No. 1 to
appoint a competent person from amongst the said Kammu
Mia’s descendants, as it thinks fit, to succeed to joint mutawalliship. This is provided that the said successor shall thereafter
have the right to nominate his successor, per Clause 3 of the
Waqf deed. We also direct that the said successor shall, in the
event of the death of Respondent No. 2, nominate a successor
from Respondent No. 2’s family line, which includes
descendants through the female line, so as to avoid any further
dispute in this regard.”
10.
Thus, upon the order of the Supreme Court of September 26, 2019
being passed and, thus far remaining unchallenged, notwithstanding
whatever the waqfnama may provide for, the office of mutawalli in the
said waqf estate has now to be joint with one descendant from the
descendants of the waqif through his son and another from the
descendants of his daughter, the wife of Kammu Mia.
11.
Accordingly, it is no longer open to the appellant to question the
joint mutawalliship as such issue has attained finality in terms of the order
passed by the Supreme Court and the same remaining unchallenged for a
considerable period of time. However, as to the appointment of the joint
mutawalli, it is for the State Waqf Board to make the appointment as
directed by the Supreme Court and by at least two subsequent orders of
this Court. While it may happen that the State Waqf Board has not been
constituted or is not in place, but merely because the Board is not in
existence will not empower the CEO of the Board to assume the authority
of the Board without obtaining the previous leave of the Court.
12.
At the end of the day it may be only a pyrrhic victory for the
appellant herein since the appellant can no longer contest the appointment
of a joint mutawalli to administer the waqf estate. However, the appellant
will have a right to make a representation pertaining to the selection of
the joint mutwalli and such right may be exercised before the Waqf Board
in terms of the previous orders.
13.
Accordingly, the order impugned dated October 12, 2021 passed
by the CEO of the State Waqf Board is set aside. It will be open to the
State Waqf Board, whenever constituted, to comply with the directions
issued to such Board in accordance with law and upon hearing the
appellant herein. However, if the State Waqf Board is not constituted
within the next three months, it will be open to the appellant or any other
person aspiring to be the joint mutawalli of the waqf estate to apply to
this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution for appropriate
directions. Since the unauthorised appointment of the joint mutawalli by
the CEO’s order of October 12, 2021 has been annulled, the appellant has
to be put on terms. Till such time that a joint mutawalli is appointed to
jointly administer the waqf estate along with the appellant herein, the
appellant will not alienate any of the waqf properties or create any third
party rights in respect thereof without the express previous leave of this
Court. The appellant will be entitled to receive rents from continuing
tenants but will have no right to install any new tenant, if any existing
tenant is evicted or otherwise vacates any portion of the premises. The
appellant will also maintain true and faithful accounts and have the same
audited on an annual basis, if not already done.
14.
In the light of the above, the judgment and order impugned dated
June 17, 2022 stands set aside and the writ petition is allowed to the extent
indicated above. There is no doubt that the appellant cannot object to a
joint mutawalli being appointed as such issue has been settled by the
Supreme Court‘s order referred to above; but the appellant will still have
a say in the appointment which the Board may take into consideration at
the time of making the relevant appointment without permitting the
appellant herein to use the right to object as to the selection as a ruse to
stall or thwart the appointment.
15.
WA No. 27 of 2022 succeeds to the extent indicated above. There
will, however, be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
20.07.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review