Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.04.27
TELEN KOM Date:
15:04:29 +05'30'
Item No.35
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Cril.Petn.No.38 of 2021
With
MC(Cril.Petn.)No.01 of 2023
Md. Karimuddin Moulvi aged about 65 years S/o (L) Abdul Jalil, , a
permanent resident of Haoreibi Chandakhong PO & PS Lilong, Thoubal
District, Manipur
…Petitioner
- Versus -
1. The State of Manipur represented by Chief Secretary ( In charge of
Home). Government of Manipur, South Block (old Secretariat), PO & PS
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
2. The Director General of Police, Manipur PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
3. The Superintendent of Police, Thoubal PO & PS Thoubal, Thoubal
District, Manipur.
4. The Officer-in-charge, Lilong police Station, PO & PS Lilong, Thoubal
District, Manipur.
5. Md. Waris Khan aged about 27 years s/o Karimuddin at lilong Haoreibi
Chandakhong PO & PS Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V.MURALIDARAN
ORDER
15.03.2023
Heard Mr. M. Ibohal, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. RK
Umakanta, learned Public Prosecutor for the respondent State.
2. This criminal petition has been filed by the petitioner under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash FIR No.96(09)2021 registered under
Sections 380, 452, 506, 406 and 120B IPC against the petitioner/A1 on
the file of Lilong Police Station, Thoubal District, Manipur.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the FIR
No.96(09)2021 has been registered by the fourth respondent police
against the petitioner and three others based on the complaint lodged by
the fifth respondent who is none other than the son of the petitioner
alleging that he is the proprietor of M/s.Ereicha Indane Gramin Vitrak
and the accused are working in the said gas agency and they had stolen
some gas cylinders and concealed at unknown place. The accused had
also not reported for duty and have been hiding at unknown place
possessing all the keys of the showroom and godown and they have also
taken the complainant’s car bearing registration No.MN01AA2618 and
kept in an unknown place.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the
petitioner and his wife along with his four sons, including the
complainant, formed and established a joint family business by way of
partnership in the name and style of M/s.Ereicha Indane Gramin Vitrak
at Lilong and the dealership/distributorship under the Indian Oil
Corporation is a multiple dealership although it was issued in the name
of the fifth respondent/complainant. While so, the complainant claimed
multiple dealership as his own sole business and conspired with the
fourth respondent to exclude the petitioner, his wife and three sons.
Therefore, the petitioner lodged a complaint petition before the Manipur
Human Rights Commission for a direction on the fourth respondent not
to interfere in the family business and, by the order dated 2.9.2021, the
Manipur Human Rights Commission had also directed the fourth
respondent not to interfere in the family business.
5. The learned counsel further submitted that on the pretext of the
direction of the Deputy Commissioner, Thoubal, the fourth respondent
and his subordinate officers raided the business house and seized some
empty cylinders and also the four wheeler on 8.9.2021. Aggrieved by
the said action, on 24.9.2021, the petitioner complained the matter to the
Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur to take action against the
Deputy Commissioner. When the petitioner’s complaint was pending
under enquiry, based on the false complaint dated 3.9.2021 lodged by
the
fifth
respondent,
the
fourth
respondent
registered
FIR
No.96(09)2021. On 6.10.2021, the petitioner has lodged a complaint to
the Director General of Police, Manipur to take necessary action against
the fourth respondent.
6. The learned counsel added that the action of the fourth
respondent is violative of the petitioner’s right to life/personal liberty
guaranteed by Article 21 read with Article 14 of the Constitution of India
and further violative of the right to freedom of business etc. of the
petitioner guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g) read with Article 300A of the
Constitution of India.
7. By placing on record the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Lalita Kumari v. Government of UP, AIR 2012 SC 1515 :
(2013) 14 SCR 713, the learned counsel for the petitioner argued that
the fourth respondent/Officer-in-Charge of Lilong Police Station by
violating the directions issued in the said case and taking law into his
own hands for other ulterior motives/purposes than his duty under law
and protection of the rights of the petitioner and his wife and three sons
named in the complaint, harassing the petitioner and his family members.
Despite knowing the factual scenario, the fourth respondent has
registered the FIR against the petitioner, his wife and three sons based
on the false complaint lodged by the fifth respondent thereby causing
miscarriage of justice, abuse of due process of law. Therefore, the
impugned FIR is liable to be quashed.
8. Per contra, the learned Public Prosecutor appearing for the
respondent police submitted that only based on the complaint lodged by
the fifth respondent, the fourth respondent registered the FIR against the
petitioner and others. He would submit that the fourth respondent never
went to the house of the petitioner to make any seizure and the
investigating officer of the case on being sure of the presence of some
of the LPG cylinders stolen by the accused persons were kept in the
outhouse of the petitioner, the investigating officer visited the spot and
seized the LPG cylinders and, therefore, there is no illegality in making
such seizure.
9. The learned Public Prosecutor further submitted that the fact
that the petitioner was in possession of huge number of LPG cylinders
without any valid document is evident enough that he had stolen said
cylinders from the complainant which is being under investigation. In
fact, the present petition has been filed only with an intention of hindering
the investigation of the case.
10. Contending that the petitioner is not entitled to any of the reliefs
as no harassment has been meted out to the petitioner by any of the
respondents and does not have any genuine grievance which needs
redressal, the learned Public Prosecutor prayed for dismissal of the
criminal petition.
11. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused
the materials available on record.
12. The fifth respondent lodged a complaint dated 3.9.2021 before
the fourth respondent against his father and brothers alleging that the
accused persons who were working in his gas agency had stolen some
gas cylinders and concealed the same at unknown place and they had
also taken away all keys of the godown and showroom and not returned
to the office. Moreover, the accused persons kept concealing the
complainant’s car at unknown place.
Based on the said complaint
lodged by the fifth respondent, the fourth respondent registered the FIR
No.96(09)2021 and now the case is pending at investigation stage.
13. The petitioner claimed that he and his wife as well as his four
sons established the joint family business by way of partnership in the
name and style of M/s.Ereicha Indane Gramin Vitrak by taking the
dealership in the name of fifth respondent Md. Waris Khan.
Taking
advantage of the dealership issued in favour of the fifth respondent, he
is claiming exclusive ownership over the business and conspiring with
the fourth respondent, the complainant is giving trouble to the petitioner,
his wife and three sons.
14. The petitioner contended that he and his two sons never
worked under the complainant as alleged by him.
Only the fourth
respondent and his team raided the business house/godown and seized
empty gas cylinders and also the four wheeler. In order to harass the
petitioner and others, the fifth respondent has lodged the complaint.
Taking the law in his own hand, the fourth respondent is acting against
the petitioner.
15. The claim of the petitioner that whether M/s.Ereicha Indane
Gramin Vitrak is a joint family business or the sole business of the fifth
respondent cannot be decided in this jurisdiction.
It is a private
commercial dispute between the petitioner and fifth respondent which
can be decided elsewhere in an appropriate proceedings.
16. Since the petitioner invoked the jurisdiction under Section 482
Cr.P.C. to quash the FIR registered against him, at best, the Court can
look into whether the respondent police by following the established
procedure and as per the guidelines issued by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the celebrated judgment in the case of Lalita Kumari, supra has
commenced the investigation.
17. In Lalita Kumari, supra, the 5-Judge Constitution Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that investigation of offences and
prosecution of offenders are the duties of the State. For “cognizable
offences”, a duty has been cast upon the police to register FIR and to
conduct investigation except as otherwise permitted specifically under
Section 157 of the Code. If a discretion, option or latitude is allowed to
the police in the matter of registration of FIRs, it can have serious
consequences on the public order situation and can also adversely affect
the rights of the victims, including violating their fundamental right to
equality.
18. After elaborately discussing the issue involved, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, at paragraph 110, held:
“110. Therefore in view of various counter claims regarding
registration or non-registration, what is necessary is only that the
information given to the police must disclose the commission of
cognizable offence. In such a situation, registration of an FIR is
mandatory. However, if no cognizble offence is made out in the
information given, then the FIR need not be registered immediately
and perhaps the police can conduct a sort of preliminary
verification or inquiry for the limited purpose of ascertaining as to
whether cognizble offence has been committed.
But, if the
information given clearly mentions the commission of a cognizable
offence, there is no other option but to register an FIR forthwith.
Other considerations are not relevant at the stage of registration of
FIR, such as, whether the information is falsely given, whether the
information is genuine, whether the information is credible etc.
These are the issues that have to be verified during the
investigation of the FIR. At the stage of registration of FIR, what is
to be seen is merely whether the information given ex facie
discloses the commission of a cognizable offence.
If, after
investigation, the information given is found to be false, there is
always an option to prosecute the complaint for filing a false FIR.”
19. Finally, the Hon’ble Supreme in the said judgment issued the
following conclusion/directions:
“111. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we hold:
(i)
Registration of FIR is mandatory under Section 154
of the Code, if the information discloses commission
of a cognizable offence and no preliminary inquiry is
permissible in such a situation.
(ii)
If the information received does not disclose a
cognizable offence but indicates the necessity for an
inquiry, a preliminary inquiry may be conducted only
to ascertain whether cognizable offence is disclosed
or not.
(iii)
If the inquiry discloses the commission of a
cognizable offence, the FIR must be registered. In
cases where preliminary inquiry ends in closing the
complaint, a copy of the entry of such closure must
be supplied to the first informant forthwith and not
later than one week, it must disclose reasons in brief
for closing the complaint and not proceeding further.
(iv)
The police officer cannot avoid his duty of registering
offence, if cognizable offence is disclosed. Action
must be taken against erring officers who do not
register the FIR if information received by him
discloses a cognizable offence.
(v)
The scope of preliminary inquiry is not to verify the
veracity or otherwise of the information received but
only to ascertain whether the information reveals
any cognizable offence.
(vi)
As to what type and in which cases preliminary
inquiry is to be conducted will depend on the facts
and circumstances of each case. The category of
cases in which preliminary inquiry may be made are
as under:
(a)
Matrimonial disputes/family disputes
(b)
Commercial offences
(c)
Medical negligence cases
(d)
Corruption cases
(e)
Cases
where
delay/laches
there
in
is
abnormal
initiating
criminal
prosecution, for example, over 3 months
delay in reporting the matter without
satisfactorily explaining the reasons for
delay.
The aforesaid are only illustrations and not exhaustive of all
conditions which may warrant preliminary inquiry.
(vii)
While ensuring and protecting the rights of the
accused and the complainant, a preliminary inquiry
should be made time bound and in any case, it
should not exceed 7 days. The fact of such delay
and the causes of it must be reflected in the General
Diary entry.
(viii)
Since the General Diary/Station Diary/Daily Diary is
the record of all information received in a police
station, we direct that all information relating to
cognizable
offences,
whether
resulting
in
registration of FIR or leading to an inquiry, must be
mandatorily and meticulously reflected in the said
Diary and the decision to conduct a preliminary
inquiry must also be reflected, as mentioned above.”
20. At this juncture, drawing this Court’s attention to paragraph
2.11 of the affidavit-in-opposition, the learned Public Prosecutor
submitted that as the evidences collected in the enquiry show the
commission of cognizable offences by the petitioner and his associates,
the enquiry officer submitted a report that cognizable offence is disclosed
by the report dated 3.9.2021 of Md. Waris Khan. Accordingly FIR
No.30(9)2021 u/s 380/452/506/406/120-B IPC was registered and
investigation has been set into motion. The further submission of the
learned Public Prosecutor is that for the purpose of exercising power
under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the FIR or a complaint, the High
Court would have to proceed entirely on the basis of the allegations made
in the complaint or the documents accompanying the same per se and it
has no jurisdiction to examine the correctness or otherwise of the
allegations.
21. It is apposite to mention that nothing has been produced by
the respondent police to establish and/or prove that before registering
the FIR, a preliminary enquiry was conducted. While ensuring and
protecting the rights of the accused and the complainant, a preliminary
enquiry should be made in a time bound manner as directed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Lalita Kumari, supra. However,
in the case on hand, prima facie, there is absolutely no record to show
that a preliminary enquiry was conducted and thereafter, FIR was
registered and the investigation was set in motion.
22. The allegation/complaint, inter alia, levelled against the
petitioner and other accused persons is that they have stolen gas
cylinders and concealed at unknown place. As stated supra, the
petitioner and the complainant are father and son and the son as
complainant has lodged the criminal complaint against his father and
brothers. Since the complaint was made against the blood relatives, the
complaint requires a preliminary enquiry, which in the instant case has
not been done by the respondent police. Nor any proof to show that
preliminary enquiry was before registering the FIR was produced before
this court. What the law says is that if the information does not disclose
a cognizable offence but indicates the necessity for an enquiry, a
preliminary enquiry may be conducted to ascertain whether information
reveals any cognizable offence. If the enquiry discloses a cognizable
offence, the FIR must be registered.
23. The argument of the learned Public Prosecutor is that the
petitioner is alleging that the informant or complainant of the FIR in
collusion with the police registered the FIR, which is not a ground for
quashing the FIR and such allegation may be put as defence in the trial,
but not a ground for invoking the inherent power of jurisdiction under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. Further, the learned Public Prosecutor argued that
it is clear and undisputed fact that there was recovery of gas cylinders
and vehicle for the gas agency/distributor from the petitioner which
clearly points towards the commission of offence of stealing properties
by the petitioner and his associates.
24. Prima facie, this Court is not concerned with the merits of the
allegations made by the petitioner in this petition and the denial of the
prosecution. However, this Court is duty bound to see whether any
preliminary enquiry was conducted by the respondent police upon receipt
of the complaint from the fifth respondent. As stated supra, there is
nothing on record to show that preliminary enquiry was conducted by the
respondent police.
25. Since the complaint involves a dispute pertaining to an gas
cylinder agency, which is commercial in nature, this Court is of the view
that before registering the FIR in question, the respondent police ought
to have conducted the preliminary enquiry in the facts and circumstances
stated in the complaint as directed in Lalita Kumari case.
26. At this juncture, it is to be pointed out that though the complaint
was lodged on 3.9.2021, the FIR was registered only on 30.9.2021 with
a delay of nearly 27 days and the said delay has not been properly
explained by the respondent police. As per the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Lalita Kumari, supra, preliminary enquiry should be
made in a time bound manner and in any case, it should not exceed 7
days. If really, the respondent police conducted any enquiry based on
the complaint, they ought to have produced the General Diary entry or
any shred of material in proof thereof. However, in the case on hand, no
General Diary entry or preliminary enquiry report has been produced to
show that before registering the FIR, the respondent police conducted
the preliminary enquiry as per the guidelines/directions issued in the
case of Lalita Kumari, supra.
27. For all the reasons stated above, this Court directs the
respondent police to strictly adhere to the guidelines/directions issued by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Lalita Kumari, supra.
Till
such compliance is made, the respondent police is directed not to harass
the petitioner and his family members.
28. The Criminal Petition No.38 of 2021 and the Miscellaneous
Case No.1 of 2023 are disposed of in the terms aforesaid.
29. Before parting with the case, this Court wants to issue a
direction to the Director General of Police, State of Manipur to issue
appropriate circular to all Station House Officers in all the Police Station
in the State of Manipur that before registering any complaint or First
Information Report, all Station House Officers should follow the
Judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Latta Kumari –Vs- Govt. of UP and others and the respective District
Superintendent of Police are directed to monitor with the help of
respective Deputy Superintendent of Police. This should be followed
strictly by all the Station House Officers with letter and spirit.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
NFR/FR
[[
John kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review