The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. Whereas, after hearing the parites and considering his representation/objection and all related documents, the undersigned, it satisfied that the public premise, namely Government land covered by C.S. Dag No.272 and 377 of Revenue Village No.8Mantripukhri, Imphal East District is under unauthorized occupation of Habib Shah, Secretary, Committee Mantripukhri Masjid. Therefore, his representation/objection is hereby rejected. Now, therefore, I Khumanthem Diana Devi, Deputy Commissioner, Imphal East in exercise of the powers conferred upon me under Section 3 of The Manipur Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1978, do hereby direct Habib Shah, Secretary, Committee Mantripukhri Masjid to remove the illegal structures constructed upon the land covered by C.S. Dag No.272 and 377 of Revenue Village No.8Mantripukhri, Imphal East District and deliver vacant position within 10 (ten) days from the date of issue of this order.” [26] not A reading of the impugned eviction order, it is clear that only Mantripukhri Masjid, but also other encroachers/unauthorized occupants of public premises at Revenue Village No.8-Mantripukhri were identified by the respondent officials and they were served show cause notices and upon hearing them, the second respondent passed the eviction order. [27] As could be seen from the records, the process for eviction has been initiated by the re…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RAJKUMAR RAJKUMAR
BIDYASUN BIDYASUNDER
SINGH
2023.02.17
DER SINGH Date:
17:04:35 -08'00'
Item No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
PIL NO. 8 OF 2023
Md. Jiaulhaque
... Petitioner/s
-VersusState of Manipur and 2 others
... Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
14.02.2023
(M.V.Muralidaran,J)
Calling into question the impugned eviction order dated
30.1.2023 passed in Eviction Case No.4 of 2023 by the respondent,
the petitioner has filed the present public interest litigation.
[2]
Heard Mr. Osbert Khaling, learned counsel for the
petitioner; and Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG, Manipur for the
state respondents.
[3]
Assailing the impugned order, the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the impugned eviction order is in gross
violation of fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution of India.
Since the Masjid Mantripukhri is the property of the Wakf Board,
Manipur, the second respondent ought not to have issued the
impugned order. In fact, in the letter of the Sub-Divisional Officer,
Porompat addressed to the second respondent qua details of wakf
properties under Porompat Sub-Division, the Mantripukhri Masjid has
been listed and classified as Homestead having Dag No.272 measuring
0.08 acres.
[4]
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted
that in Mantripukhri Masjid more than 3000 people offer their prayers
regularly as it is one of the most prominent and oldest Masjid in
Manipur existing since 1918. The said Masjid being a religious place
of great significance in the history of the State and as the same has
been in its original place since 1918 it is of heritage nature and is,
thus, a cultural monument for the tenets of Islam.
[5]
The learned counsel for the petitioner added that
conceding or not conceding to the fact where the show cause notice
claims the land in question as Sarkar Khas land, then by the automatic
operation of law of adverse possession, it allows the transfer of
ownership to any person who has been in peaceful and continuous
possession and the said possession with regard to Mantripukhri Masjid
is “nec vi, nec clam, nec precario” and “animus possidendi”.
[6]
The learned counsel for the petitioner urged that there is
visible discrimination on the basis of religion and there is gross
violation of Articles 14, 15, 21, 25 and 26 of the Constitution of India
where it is evident that there is no equal application of law. He would
submit that subsequent to the passing of the impugned order dated
30.1.2023, the petitioner submitted a representation on 2.2.2023 to
the second respondent requesting to revoke the eviction order within
two days in the interest of public and for maintenance of public
tranquility as around 3000 worshippers offer their prayers in the said
Masjid. Arguing so, the learned counsel for the petitioner prayed for
setting aside the impugned order of eviction dated 30.1.2023.
[7]
Questioning the very locus of the petitioner in filing the
writ petition, the learned Additional Advocate General appearing for
the respondents contended that the petitioner has no locus standi to
file the instant public interest litigation. He would submit that the
impugned order of eviction has been passed against the Masjid in
question after hearing its Committee Secretary. Since the petitioner
is a third party to the proceedings and he is no way connected with
the claim made by Mantripukhri Masjid in their representation, he
cannot question the eviction order under the guise of a public interest
litigation.
[8]
Qua the claim of the petitioner that the land covered in
C.S. Dag No.272 belongs to Mantripukhri Masjid, the learned
Additional Advocate General submitted that the revenue records
reveal that the land in question, namely C.S. Dag No.272 is Sarkari
Khas land and the Masjid in question has encroached upon the same
and put up superstructure on it. Since the Masjid is in unauthorized
occupation of public premise, the same needs to be vacated.
Therefore, the second respondent has passed the impugned order of
eviction and the same does not warrant any interference.
[9]
We have considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
[10]
The petitioner has filed the instant petition as a public
interest litigation. It is a fact that the petitioner is a practising lawyer.
Time and again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that public interest
litigation in the hands of a practising advocate is not maintainable.
[11]
In
Dattaraj
Nathuji
Thaware
v.
State
of
Maharashtra, (2005) 1 SCC 590, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
not endorsed the public interest litigation in the hands of a practising
advocate. Paragraph 20 of the said decision is relevant and the same
is extracted hereunder:
"20. It is a disturbing feature which needs immediate
remedial measure by the Bar Councils and the Bar
Associations to see that the process of law is not
abused and polluted by its members. It is high time
that the Bar Councils and the Bar Associations ensure
that no member of the Bar becomes party as
petitioner or in aiding and/or abetting files frivolous
petitions carrying the attractive brand name of
"public interest litigation". That will be keeping in line
with the high traditions of the Bar. No one should be
permitted to bring disgrace to the noble profession.
We would have imposed exemplary cost in this
regard but taking note of the fact that the High Court
had already imposed costs of Rs 25,000, we do not
propose to impose any further cost."
[underlining added]
[12]
In paragraph 4 of the affidavit filed in support of the
petition, the petitioner stated that he is a social worker and an
advocate and also respected member of the society and has taken up
various social issues in numerous capacities. He has worked in lot of
cases with regard to minority, women and labour issues and the
muslim community to uplift and protect the lower rungs of the society
by providing legal aid service.
Nothing has been produced by the
petitioner to show that he worked a lot for the upliftment of the
muslim community in the State of Manipur. There is no averment set
out in the petition that the petitioner is a worshiper in Mantripukhri
Masjid.
[13]
In State of Uttaranchal v. Balwant Singh Chaufal,
(2010) 3 SCC 402, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“181. We have carefully considered the facts of
the present case. We have also examined the law
declared by this Court and other courts in a
number of judgments. In order to preserve the
purity and sanctity of the PIL, it has become
imperative to issue the following directions:
(1) The Courts must encourage genuine and
bona fide PIL and effectively discourage and
curb the PIL filed for extraneous considerations.
(2) Instead of every individual Judge devising
his own procedure for dealing with the public
interest litigation, it would be appropriate for
each High Court to properly formulate rules for
encouraging the genuine PIL and discouraging
the
PIL
filed
with
oblique
motives.
Consequently, we request that the High Courts
who have not yet framed the rules, should
frame the rules within three months. The
Registrar General of each High Court is directed
to ensure that a copy of the rules prepared by
the High Court is sent to the Secretary General
of this Court immediately thereafter.
(3) The Courts should prima facie verify the
credentials of the petitioner before entertaining
a PIL.
(4) The Courts should be prima facie satisfied
regarding the correctness of the contents of the
petition before entertaining a PIL.
(5) The Courts should be fully satisfied that
substantial public interest is involved before
entertaining the petition.
(6) The Courts should ensure that the petition
which involves larger public interest, gravity
and urgency must be given priority over other
petitions.
(7) The Courts before entertaining the PIL
should ensure that the PIL is aimed at redressal
of genuine public harm or public injury. The
Court should also ensure that there is no
personal gain, private motive or oblique motive
behind filing the public interest litigation.
(8) The Courts should also ensure that the
petitions filed by busybodies for extraneous and
ulterior motives must be discouraged by
imposing exemplary costs or by adopting similar
novel methods to curb frivolous petitions and
the
petitions
filed
for
extraneous
considerations.”
[14]
It is clear that the concept of public interest litigation has
evolved to bring justice to people who are “handicapped by ignorance,
indigence, illiteracy” and observed that Courts are required to be
cautious while entertaining such litigation. We are of the view that the
petitioner had no reason to file the instant public interest litigation
when the subject matter was evidently a title claim between
Mantripukhri Masjid and the respondent State, as the respondent
State claims that the land in question is Sarkari Khas land and
Mantripukhri Masjid is an encroacher.
[15]
In Esteem Properties Private Limited v. Chetan
Kamble and others, (2022) 11 SCC 661 a Larger Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that although the jurisprudence in this
regard has matured, many claims filed in the Courts are sometimes
immature. Thousands of frivolous petitions are filed, burdening the
docket of both the Supreme Court and the High Courts. Noble
intentions behind expanding the Court’s jurisdiction to accommodate
socially relevant issues, in recent decades, have been critically
analyzed. Observing so, the Larger Bench held that in our view, PIL
litigation has had a beneficial effect on the Indian jurisprudence and
has alleviated the conditions of the citizens in general.
In Chetan Kamble, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
further held as under:
“28. One of the measures this Court can adopt to
ensure that frivolous or private interests are not
masqueraded as genuine claims, is to be cautious
when examining locus standi. Generally, PIL,
being a summary jurisdiction, has limited powers
to examine the bonafides of parties. It is usually
on the pleadings that the Court should take a
prima facie view on the bonafides of the party. If
the Court concludes that the litigation was initiated
under the shadow of reasonable suspicion, then
the Court may decline to entertain the claims on
merits. In these cases, Courts have multiple
options – such as dismissing the PIL or appointing
an amicus curiae, if the cause espoused in the
case requires the immediate attention of the
Court. [refer T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v.
Union of India. (2006) 5 SCC 28].”
[16]
It is settled law that public interest litigation is a weapon
which has to be used with great care and circumspection and the
judiciary has to be extremely careful to see that behind the beautiful
veil of public interest, an ugly private malice, vested interest and/or
publicity-seeking is not lurking. It is to be used as an effective weapon
in the armoury of law for delivering social justice to citizens. The
attractive brand name of public interest litigation should not be used
for suspicious products of mischief. It should be aimed at redressal
of genuine public wrong or public injury and not be publicity-oriented
or founded on personal vendetta.
Court must be careful to see that
a body of persons or member of the public, who approaches the Court
is acting bona fide and not for personal gain or private motive or
political motivation or other oblique considerations. The Court must
not allow its process to be abused for oblique considerations by
masked phantoms who monitor at times from behind. Some persons
with vested interest indulge in the pastime of meddling with judicial
process either by force of habit or from improper motives, and try to
bargain for a good deal as well as to enrich themselves. Often they
are actuated by a desire to win notoriety or cheap popularity. The
petitions of such busybodies deserve to be thrown out by rejection at
the threshold, and in appropriate cases with exemplary costs.
[18]
In the light of the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
referred above, we are of the view that the present litigation has been
initiated under the shadow of reasonable suspicion.
[19]
The present public interest litigation has been filed by a
practising advocate, who is not even an office-bearer of Mantripukhri
Masjid. That apart, the petitioner is not a worshipper of Mantripukhri
Masjid and no averment in this regard has been set out in the affidavit.
In the light of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court referred
above, we are of the view that public interest litigation in the hands
of a practising lawyer is not maintainable.
[20]
Admittedly,
the
Chairman
or
the
Secretary
of
Mantripukhri Masjid Committee has not challenged the impugned
eviction order. Before issuing the impugned order, on 10.1.2023, the
Additional Deputy Commissioner-II, Imphal East issued notice to all
the encroachers/unauthorized occupants of the public premises
mentioned therein to show-cause why they shall not vacate from the
public premise(s) and called for written representation/objection from
them to be submitted to the second respondent.
[21]
On a perusal of the notice dated 10.1.2023, it is seen
that the said notice indicates that pucca buildings have been put up
by the Masjid in Dag No.272 measuring an extent of 0.08 acre and
Dag No.377 measuring an extent of 0.02 acre belonging to the
Government which have been classified as Sarkari Khas. Pursuant to
the said notice, the Secretary, Committee Mantripukhri Masjid has
submitted a written representation on 13.1.2023 praying to stop all
the proceedings including the notice dated 10.1.2023 and the
proposed eviction.
Upon receipt of the said representation, the
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Imphal East issued summon calling
the Secretary, Committee Mantripukhri Masjid to appear before the
second respondent for enquiry on 24.1.2023 at 2.00 p.m. along with
all relevant documents including allotment orders, jamabandi etc. in
support of their claim.
[22]
It is beyond any cavil that that hearing on the
representation of Mantripukhri Masjid was conducted on 24.1.2023 by
the second respondent.
During the hearing, one Habib Shah,
Secretary, Committee Mantripukhri Masjid appeared in person along
with his counsel and claimed that the land covered by C.S. Dag No.272
is a wakf property and he requested for exemption from eviction on
compassionate ground. Upon considering the claim put forth by the
representative of Mantripukhri Masjid and finding that the Masjid has
failed to produce any documents such as allotment order, jamabandi
etc., the second respondent held that the land in question is a
Government land where the Masjid had unauthorisedly put up
construction land and the same needs to be vacated.
[23]
At this juncture, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the Masjid in question is a wakf property and is in
existence since 1918 and Mantripukhri Masjid is registered with the
Wakf Board and therefore, the Masjid cannot be evicted.
Merely
because the Masjid is very old and listed in the wakf properties, the
respondent authorities have no power to take action against the said
Masjid.
[24]
On a perusal of the survey report on the wakf properties
of Imphal East, Manipur produced by the learned counsel for the
petitioner, it is seen that names of 8 wakfs and its creation have been
mentioned in the said report and Mantripukhri Masjid found place at
Serial No.7. Further perusal of the said report reveals that in remarks
column the right derived by the wakfs has been stated. Except Serial
No.7, the remarks of the all other wakfs have been stated and remarks
of Serial No.7 kept blank. Thus, the aforesaid indication clearly shows
that without having right or the origin of acquiring right over the land
in question, Mantripukhri Masjid has been constructed in Dag No.272.
Anyhow, the right and title of Mantripukhri Masjid over the land in
question cannot be decided in this public interest litigation exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
[25]
As rightly argued by learned Additional Advocate General
the aggrieved person would be Mantripukhri Masjid and the said
Masjid has not challenged the impugned eviction order. Since the
impugned eviction order speaks about the opportunity given to
Mantripukhri Masjid, it cannot be contended that without hearing the
Masjid, the eviction order came to be passed by the second
respondent.
For proper appreciation, the impugned order is quoted
hereunder:
“Whereas, consequent upon serving of notice of even
No.
dated
10th
January,
encroachers/unauthorized
to
(nine)
occupants
of
public
premises at Revenue Village No.8-Mantripukhri falling
within Right of way (ROW) of NH-02 (Sangakphamto
Koirengel) for show cause as to why he/she shall not
vacate the public premises and for submission of a
written representation/objection, if any, to the Office
of the undersigned on or before 11:30 am on 17 th
January, 2023.
2. Whereas, Habib Shah, Secretary, Committee
Mantripukhri
Masjid,
had
submitted
a
written
representation/objection within the timeline given:
C.S. Dag Name
of
the
encroacher/encroachment
in the Notice dated
No.
10.01.2023
272, 377 Masjid
Sl. No. in
Notice dated
10.01.2023
3. Whereas, as reasonable opportunity to be heard is
to be given, Summons/Hearing Notice of even no.
dated 19th January, 2023 for appearance in person or
by a representative or pleader duly authorized to
appear on his behalf along with all relevant
documents including allotment orders, jamabandi etc.
to support his objection/representation at the hearing
on 24th January (Tuesday) at 2.00 PM presided by the
undersigned was served to the objector/aggrieved
party/encroacher;
4. Whereas, in the hearing, Habib Shah, Secretary,
Committee Mantripukhri Masjid, appeared in person
along with his counsel and stated as submitted earlier
in their written representation that the land covered
by C.S. Dag No.272 is now a Wakf Property and
requested for exemption/relaxation from eviction on
compassionate ground. They also submitted some
old photos of the construction of the Masjid along with
documents supporting the claim that th eland in
question is a Wakf property. However, the parties
failed to produce any documents such as allotment
order, jamabandi, etc. and hence, it is a fact that the
land in question
is a government land.
It was
regrettably informed that the said structure was
constructed on Government land and therefore, the
objector is an encroacher/unauthorized occupant of
public premise and needs to be vacated as this
process has been taken up for providing Right of Way
(ROW) of NH-02 (Sangakpham to Koirengel) for public
purpose.
They also submitted that encroachment
done on land covered by C.S. Dag No.377 has been
voluntarily removed. It is stated that due verification
of the area of public premise covered by C.S. Dag
No.272 of Revenue Village No.8-Mantripukhri under
unauthorized
occupation
has
been
done
by
Directorate of Settlement & Land Records, (DSLR)
Manipur;
5. Whereas, after hearing the parites and considering
his
representation/objection
and
all
related
documents, the undersigned, it satisfied that the public
premise, namely Government land covered by C.S.
Dag No.272 and 377 of Revenue Village No.8Mantripukhri,
Imphal
East
District
is
under
unauthorized occupation of Habib Shah, Secretary,
Committee Mantripukhri Masjid.
Therefore, his
representation/objection is hereby rejected.
Now, therefore, I Khumanthem Diana Devi, Deputy
Commissioner, Imphal East in exercise of the powers
conferred upon me under Section 3 of The Manipur
Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants)
Act, 1978, do hereby direct Habib Shah, Secretary,
Committee Mantripukhri Masjid to remove the illegal
structures constructed upon the land covered by C.S.
Dag No.272 and 377 of Revenue Village No.8Mantripukhri, Imphal East District and deliver vacant
position within 10 (ten) days from the date of issue of
this order.”
[26]
not
A reading of the impugned eviction order, it is clear that
only
Mantripukhri
Masjid,
but
also
other
encroachers/unauthorized occupants of public premises at Revenue
Village No.8-Mantripukhri were identified by the respondent officials
and they were served show cause notices and upon hearing them, the
second respondent passed the eviction order.
[27]
As could be seen from the records, the process for
eviction has been initiated by the respondent officials for the purpose
of providing Right of Way of NH-02 Sangakpham to Koirengel for
public purpose. Thus, for public purpose only, the eviction process
has been initiated by the respondent authorities and, therefore, the
same
cannot
be
questioned
by
the
unuathorised
occupants/encroachers. Since after giving reasonable opportunity of
hearing to the unauthorized occupants/encroachers, including the
Masjid in question, the impugned eviction order has been passed, the
same cannot be questioned by the petitioner who is a practicing
advocate under the aid of public interest litigation to stall the public
purpose of providing Right of Way.
[28]
The growing trend across the country is construction of
temples, churches and mosques on public roads by causing
inconvenience to vehicular traffic as well as pedestrian movement.
Temples, churches and mosques are also constructed by encroaching
upon public lands on roadsides and public premises and without
obtaining
proper
permission.
A
secular
Government
cannot
encourage such attitude of the people in respect of illegal
construction of religious institutions. Even a deity cannot commit an
act of encroachment. Therefore, the concerned officials of the State
Government should ensure demolition of all unauthorized structures
constructed on Government lands and waterbodies.
[29]
For all the reasons state above, we are of the view that
the present public interest litigation is not maintainable mainly on the
ground that the petitioner has no locus standi to file the same.
Further, the petitioner is not an aggrieved person and the aggrieved
Masjid has not challenged the impugned eviction order. The silence
made by Mantripukhri Masjid clearly shows that they have no legal
right over the land in question.
[30]
Finding no merit in the instant public interest litigation,
the same is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Bidya
FR/NON-FR
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review