The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
35. All ‘material facts’ must be pleaded by the party in support of the case set up by him. Since the object and purpose is to enable the opposite party to know the case he has to meet with, MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024 in the absence of pleading, a party cannot be allowed to lead evidence. Failure to state even a single material fact, hence, will entail dismissal of the suit or petition. Particulars, on the other hand, are the details of the case which is in the nature of evidence a party would be leading at the time of trial.”
47. Whether the averments in the election petition constitute material facts or not would depend upon the facts of each case. As stated by this Court in Virender Nath Gautam8, no rule of universal application can be applied in finding out whether the statements of fact made in the election petition amount to material facts or not. It is, therefore, necessary to consider the pleadings with regard to suppression of 319 votes in Para 7(D) of the election petition. [6] (1878) 4 QBD 127 (CA) (1936) 1 KB 697 : (1936) 1 All ER 287 (CA) In Moirangthem Hemanta Singh v. Paonam Brojen Singh & Anr.:2024 SCC OnLine Mani 507, this Court discussed the permissibility of filing of material documents even after 45 days of limitation as stipulated by Section 81(1) of Representation of the People Act, 1951 and held as below: “[18] From the above cited decisions, it is clear that the election petition is to be filed within 45 days as stipulated under Section 81 of RP Act and concise material facts have to pleaded and failure to do shall be liable for its outright rejection at threshold under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. Any amendment has to be made within 45 days as laid down by Section 81. Material particulars are facts required for proving the material facts as evidence and hence not parts of the pleadings. [19] On perusal of the election petition, specially, the contents of para 10, 11 and 12, it is found t…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed
NINGOM Digitally
by
NINGOMBAM
BAM
VICTORIA
VICTORI Date:
2025.09.23
A
17:39:32 +05'30'
Non-reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
Md. Fajur Rahim, aged about 53 years old, S/o Md. Fajur
Rahaman of Irong Chesaba Mathak Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Mayang
Imphal, Kakching District, Manipur – 795132.
…Applicant
- Versus 1. Usham Deben Singh, aged about 55 years, S/o (Late) U.
Pukchao Singh of 3-Keirak Awang Usham Leikai, SubDivision Kakching, P.O. & P.S. Kakching, Kakching District,
Manipur – 795103.
2. Mayengbam Ranjit Singh, aged about 47 years old, S/o Late
M. Manihar Singh of Wabgai Tera Urak, P.O. & P.S.
Kakching, Kakching District, Manipur – 795103.
3. Md. Sikander, aged about 43 years, S/o Md. Ahmad Ali of
Santhel Mayai Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Mayang Imphal, Kakching
District, Manipur – 795132.
4. Sakir Ahmed, aged about 39 years old, S/o Late Hayad Ali of
Sekmaijin Hangul Ngakhapat, Hangul, P.O. Mayang Imphal,
P.S. Mayang Imphal, P.S. Hiyanglam, Kakching District,
Manipur – 795132.
…Respondents
AND
IN THE MATTER OF:
In Election Petition No. 23 of 2022
Md. Fajur Rahim, aged about 53 years old, S/o Md. Fajur
Rahaman of Irong Chesaba Mathak Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Mayang
Imphal, Kakching District, Manipur – 795132.
…Petitioner
- Versus 1. Usham Deban Singh, aged about 55 years old, S/o Late U.
Pukchao Singh of 3-Keirak Awang Usham Leikai, SubDivision Kakching, P.O. & P.S. Kakching, Kakching District,
Manipur – 795103.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
2. Mayengbam Ranjit Singh, aged about 47 years old, S/o Late
M. Manihar Singh of Wabgai Tera Urak, P.O. & P.S.
Kakching, Kakching District, Manipur – 795103.
3. Md. Sikander, aged about 43 years, S/o Md. Ahmad Ali of
Santhel Mayai Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Mayang Imphal, Kakching
District, Manipur – 795132.
4. Sakir Ahmed, aged about 39 years, S/o Late Hayad Ali of
Sekmaijin Hangul Ngakhapat, Hangul, P.O. Mayang Imphal,
P.S. Mayang Imphal, P.S. Hiyanglam, Kakching District,
Manipur – 795132.
…Respondents
B EF O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the applicant
:
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Sr. Adv.;
Mrs. N. Savitri, Adv.
For the respondent
:
Mr. M. Rendy, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
26.05.2025
Date of Order
: 23.09.2025
ORDER [CAV]
[1]
Heard Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mrs. N. Savitri, learned counsel for the applicant and Mr. M. Rendy, learned
counsel for respondent No. 1.
[2]
The present application has been filed by the applicant/election
petitioner praying for grant of leave for allowing to file the certified copies of
the (i) Notice dated 16-02-2022 and Annexure-1 enclosed in the said notice;
(ii) Final Result Sheet dated 10-03-2022 of the 12th Manipur Legislative
Assembly from the 36-Wabgai Assembly Constituency; and (iii) Copy of the
letter dated 28-03-2022 which are annexed as Annexure-A/1, A/4 and A/7
respectively in the election petition.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
[3]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for the applicant has
submitted that at the time of filing the election petition, the certified copies of
the above-mentioned documents were not available/in the possession of the
applicant/election petitioner and as such the same were filed in the form of
xerox copy of the original copies. As the concerned authority issued certified
copies of the (i) Notice dated 16-02-2022 and Annexure-1 enclosed in the
said notice; (ii) Final Result Sheet dated 10-03-2022 of the 12th Manipur
Legislative Assembly from the 36-Wabgai Assembly Constituency; and (iii)
Copy of the letter dated 28-03-2022 which are annexed as Annexure-A/1,
A/4 and A/7 respectively in the election petition, the applicant craves leave
of the Hon’ble Court to allow the applicant/election petitioner to file the
certified copies of the above mentioned documents.
[4]
Mr. M. Rendy, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 states that
the contents of the miscellaneous application filed by the applicant for
allowing to file the certified copies, is opposed on the following grounds:—
(i)
That, the stage of the present election petition is examination
of P.W.’s.
(ii)
That Order VII Rule 14(3) C.P.C. says that:
A document which ought to have been produced in Court by
the plaintiff when the plaint is presented, or to be entered in the
list to be added or annexed to the plaint but is not produced or
entered accordingly, shall not, without the leave of the Court,
be received in evidence on his behalf at the hearing of the suit.
In the present case, documents were already filed as
photostat copies. It is about production of documents as
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
additional documents with a leave of the Court not for
substitution of the already filed documents.
(iii)
That, Order XIII Rule 1(1) C.P.C. says that:
Original documents to be produced at or before the
settlement of issues:–
The parties or their pleader shall produce on or before the
settlement of issues, all the documentaries evidence in original
where the copies thereof have been filed along with the plaint
or written statement.
Issues already framed and trial also already started by
filing list of witnesses.
(iv)
That, the stage of filing original/certifies copies by the petitioner
already over. No room for grant of leave for filing certified
copies of the petitioner’s documents.
(v)
That, no explanation about the production of the documents
sought for at the belated stage.
(vi)
That, the documents were not furnished at the relevant time
before the settlement/framing of the issues.
(vii)
That, the proposed of filing of documents mentioned in the
petition is not clearly mentioned that it is an additional
documents or substitution of earlier documents.
[5]
In the case of Jitu Patnaik v. Sanatan Mohakud: (2012) 4
SCC 194, Hon’ble Apex Court distinguished between material facts and
material particulars or evidences in the election petition, as below:
43. Order 6 Rule 2 CPC, to the extent it is relevant, reads as under:
“2. Pleading to state material facts and not evidence.—(1)
Every pleading shall contain, and contain only, a statement in
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
a concise form of the material facts on which the party pleading
relies for his claim or defence as the case may be, but not the
evidence by which they are to be proved.
(2)-(3) *
*
*”
44. Section 83(1)(a) of the 1951 Act is as follows:
“83. Contents of petition.—(1) An election petition—
(a) shall contain a concise statement of the material facts on
which the petitioner relies;”
45. A bare perusal of the above provisions would show that the first
part of Order 6 Rule 2 CPC is similar to sub-section (1)(a) of Section
83 of the 1951 Act. It is imperative for an election petition to contain
a concise statement of the material facts on which the election
petitioner relies. What are the material facts? All basic and primary
facts which must be proved at the trial by a party to establish the
existence of a cause of action or defence are material facts. The
bare allegations are never treated as material facts. The material
facts are such facts which afford a basis for the allegations made in
the election petition. The meaning of “material facts” has been
explained by this Court on more than one occasion. Without
multiplying the authorities, reference to one of the later decisions of
this Court in Virender Nath Gautam v. Satpal Singh8 shall suffice.
46. In Virender Nath Gautam8 this Court referred to the leading case
of Philipps v. Philipps9 and the subsequent decision in Bruce v.
Odhams Press Ltd.10 that referred to Philipps9 and observed in
paras 34 and 35 of the Report as follows: (Virender Nath case8, SCC
p. 629)
“34. A distinction between ‘material facts’ and ‘particulars’,
however, must not be overlooked. ‘Material facts’ are primary
or basic facts which must be pleaded by the plaintiff or by the
defendant in support of the case set up by him either to prove
his cause of action or defence. ‘Particulars’, on the other hand,
are details in support of material facts pleaded by the party.
They amplify, refine and embellish material facts by giving
distinctive touch to the basic contours of a picture already
drawn so as to make it full, more clear and more informative.
‘Particulars’ thus ensure conduct of fair trial and would not take
the opposite party by surprise.
35. All ‘material facts’ must be pleaded by the party in support
of the case set up by him. Since the object and purpose is to
enable the opposite party to know the case he has to meet with,
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
in the absence of pleading, a party cannot be allowed to lead
evidence. Failure to state even a single material fact, hence,
will entail dismissal of the suit or petition. Particulars, on the
other hand, are the details of the case which is in the nature of
evidence a party would be leading at the time of trial.”
47. Whether the averments in the election petition constitute material
facts or not would depend upon the facts of each case. As stated by
this Court in Virender Nath Gautam8, no rule of universal application
can be applied in finding out whether the statements of fact made in
the election petition amount to material facts or not. It is, therefore,
necessary to consider the pleadings with regard to suppression of
319 votes in Para 7(D) of the election petition.
[6]
(2007) 3 SCC 617
(1878) 4 QBD 127 (CA)
(1936) 1 KB 697 : (1936) 1 All ER 287 (CA)
In Moirangthem Hemanta Singh v. Paonam Brojen Singh &
Anr.:2024 SCC OnLine Mani 507, this Court discussed the permissibility of
filing of material documents even after 45 days of limitation as stipulated by
Section 81(1) of Representation of the People Act, 1951 and held as below:
“[18]
From the above cited decisions, it is clear that the
election petition is to be filed within 45 days as stipulated under
Section 81 of RP Act and concise material facts have to pleaded and
failure to do shall be liable for its outright rejection at threshold under
Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. Any amendment has to be made within 45
days as laid down by Section 81. Material particulars are facts
required for proving the material facts as evidence and hence not
parts of the pleadings.
[19]
On perusal of the election petition, specially, the
contents of para 10, 11 and 12, it is found that the applicant/ election
petitioner has pleaded all instances of concealment of material
information in the affidavit Form-26 by the returned candidate.
However, one page of the affidavit with respect to non-movable
property has been missing and the same is said due to inadvertence.
By the present application, the election petitioner seeks leave of this
Court for inserting this particular (Annexure R-1 to the application)
as page 95A in between pages 95 and 96. This Court is of the firmed
opinion that missing document from the affidavit Form-26 (Annexure
R-1) is a material document only and the fact relating to this
document has already been pleaded in the election petition.
Accordingly, first point is answered in favour of the applicant.
[20]
It is the settled position of law that only material facts are
to be pleaded in an election petition as stipulated under Section
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
83(1)(a) of RP Act and such a petition has to be filed within 45 days
of the declaration of the election result in terms of Section 81 of the
Act. However, material particulars which are explanatory
facts/documents of the material facts pleaded in the election petition
are in the nature of evidence and are not required to be pleaded in
the petition. It is held in para 18 above that missing document from
the affidavit Form-26 [Annexure R-1] is only a material particular and
as such the same is not required to be filed within 45 days in terms
of Section 81 of the Act. Second point is also decided in favour of
the applicant.”
[7]
In the present case, the documents proposed to be brought on
record are the certified copies of the documents that have already been filed
along with the election petition as photocopies, ie, Annexures- A/1, A/4 &
A/7. By the present application, no new documents are sought to be brought
on record. Since the certified copies of these documents were not available
at the time of filing of the election petition, photocopies of these documents
were annexed. After obtaining certified copies of the documents from the
authorities, the same are proposed to be brought on record by way of the
present application. All the material facts within the meaning of Section 83(1)
of RP Act have already been pleaded in the election petition. The certified
copies are intended to authenticate the photocopies of documents already
on record and the same can be filed beyond 45 days, as they do not
introduce any new material facts.
[8]
In the circumstances, the application MC[El.Pet.] No. 47 of
2024 is allowed and the certified copies of Annexures A/1, A/4 & A/7 are
brought on record. No cost.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
victoria
MC(El.Pet.) No. 47 of 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review