The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that the Impugned Order dated 20.05.2017 fails to appreciate that the information sought is covered by the privilege between the client and the advocate. The exception of fraud was not prima facie established to warrant piercing this privilege, especially when a plausible explanation of service in CLB proceedings was available on record. Conclusion:
27. The Impugned Order dated 20.05.2017, insofar as it directs the Advocates for the Petitioner to file personal affidavits disclosing the source of the documents, and all consequential proceedings arising therefrom including the Order dated 22.07.2017 issuing notice for contempt/noncompliance against the counsels, is quashed.
28. The Petition is allowed accordingly and the pending Applications, if any, are disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 2nd December, 2025
Pronounced on: 12th January, 2026
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017, CRL.M.A. 12975/2017,
CRL.M.A. 13878/2017
MCDONALDS INDIA LTD
Office at: 202-206, Tolstoy House
No. 15, Tolstoy Marg,
New Delhi, 110001
Through Mr. Vivek Kumar
Authorized Representative
Through:
Versus
1. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
Through PS Economic Offences Wing
Lodhi Colony/Qutub Instt. Area
New Delhi
2. DEEPAK KHOSLA
S/o R.P. Khosia
R/o D-367 Defence Colony
New Delhi 110024
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Siddharth Aggarwal, Sr.
Adv., Ms. Stuti Gujral, Adv., Mr.
Vishwajeet Singh Bhati, Adv.,
Mr. Tasnimul Hassan, Adv., Ms.
Priti Verma, Mr. Vipin Kumar,
Advocates.
.....Respondent No. 1
.....Respondent No. 2
Mr. Amol Sinha, ASC for State
along with Adv. Kshitiz Garg,
Adv. Ashvini Kumar, Adv. Nitish
Dhawan, Adv. Chavi Lazarus,
Adv. Manan Wadhwa, Adv. Luv
Mahajan.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
1.
The present Petition has been preferred under Articles 226 and 227 of
the Constitution of India read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C), by the Petitioner Company, McDonalds India
Pvt. Ltd. to quash and set aside the Impugned Order dated 20.05.2017
directing the Advocate for Petitioner to disclose the source of documents
filed in the proceedings before the Ld. Additional Sessions Judge, as well as
all proceedings consequential thereto, including the Order dated 22.07.2017
issuing Notice to the Advocates in the proceedings.
2.
The central issue arising for consideration in this Petition is whether a
Revisional Court, while exercising jurisdiction, can compel the Advocates
representing a party, to file personal affidavits disclosing the “source” of
documents placed on the judicial record.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that a Criminal Complaint, C.C. No.
473636/2016 titled Deepak Khosla v. Connaught Plaza Restaurants (P)
Ltd., was filed by Respondent No. 2/Complainant against the Petitioner
Company and others for offences under Ss. 409, 420, 423, 463, 465, 467,
468, 471, 474, 477-A / 34 / 120-B IPC, read with Ss. 191, 192,196, 201,202
Indian Penal Code. Application was
filed by the Complainant under
Sections 91 and 94 of the Cr.P.C, directing search and seizure at the
premises of the Petitioner and others, which was allowed by Ld. ACMM
vide Order dated 20.02.2017.
4.
The Petitioner Company challenged this Order by filing a Criminal
Revision Petition No. 83/2017 before the Court of the Ld. Additional
Sessions Judge (ASJ). During these proceedings, the Petitioner filed copy of
two Applications originally filed by the Complainant in 2011 in a different
forum/proceeding, to demonstrate the lack of urgency or basis for the search
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
warrants. On 04.03.2017, the Ld. ASJ granted an ex-parte stay on the
operation of the search and seizure directions.
5.
Respondent No. 2/Complainant filed an Application under Section
340 Cr.P.C. before the Ld. ASJ, alleging that the said 2011 Applications
were not part of the Trial Court record at the time of the hearing on
04.03.2017. Respondent No. 2 alleged that these documents were
surreptitiously placed on record or obtained through illegal means,
potentially leaked from police or Court records, amounting to fraud and
perjury.
6.
The Ld. ASJ, while considering the Applications under Section 340
Cr.P.C and Section 121 Indian Evidence Act, Vide the Impugned Order
dated 20.05.2017 directed the Advocates for the Petitioner Company to file
their respective personal Affidavits disclosing the date and time when the
typed copies of the Applications were filed/placed on record and the
“source” of the contents of the said Applications. Aggrieved by this
direction, the Petitioner Company has filed the present Court.
7.
The Impugned Order is challenged by the Petitioner primarily on the
grounds that the Ld. ASJ erred in embarking upon a preliminary inquiry
under Section 340 Cr.P.C against the legal representatives of the accused,
and that a potential accused cannot be compelled to give evidence against
himself in a preliminary inquiry, being violative of Article 20(3) of the
Constitution.
8.
This direction also violates Section 126 Indian Evidence Act, 1872
(IEA). A legal professional is statutorily barred from disclosing any
communication made to him in the course of his employment or the
contents/condition of any document he has become acquainted with during
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
such employment. The privilege belongs to the client and cannot be waived
without the client's express consent. Further, the exceptions to Section 126
IEA are not attracted. The documents in question were shared with counsel
for the legitimate purpose of legal defense in anticipation of litigation.
9.
The Petitioner alleges that the conduct of Respondent No. 2 is
motivated to target the opposing counsels, thereby intimidating them and
denying the Petitioner a legal representation of its choice.
10.
The Petitioner asserts that the 2011 Applications were legitimately in
their possession, having been served upon them in 2013 during proceedings
before the Company Law Board in CP No. 110/2013.
11.
The Respondent No. 2 has vehemently opposed the Petition on the
grounds that Section 126 IEA is not an unconditional bar. It is submitted that
in view of the Proviso (1) and (2) to Section 126, the privilege does not
protect communications made in furtherance of an illegal purpose or facts
showing that a crime/fraud has been committed since the employment
began.
12.
Respondent No. 2 has alleged that the documents were obtained
illegally and were placed on the judicial record surreptitiously, to mislead
the Court. This constitutes a “fact observed” by the advocate showing a
crime/fraud committed after their engagement, which falls within the
exception to privilege.
13.
Reliance is placed on Donald Weston v. Pearey Mohan Dass, 13 IND
CAS 335 to contend that there is no privilege against the Court. The Court is
entitled to ask an advocate whether a charge is made on instructions and the
source of such instructions/documents to maintain the purity of judicial
proceedings.
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
14.
It is submitted that advocates, being officers of the Court, owe a
primary duty to the Court. If they place a document on record, they must be
accountable for its source, especially when the authenticity or the manner of
its filing, is questioned.
15.
Respondent No. 2 has further submitted that the direction to file
affidavits is an interlocutory step to determine whether the claim of privilege
is sustainable or if the fraud exception applies.
16.
It is asserted that the privilege belongs to the client, but the client did
not claim it before the Ld. ASJ; rather, the advocates unilaterally refused to
comply. There is no merit in the Petition which is liable to be set aside.
Submissions Heard and Record Perused.
17.
The core question before this Court is whether the Ld. Revisional
Court was justified in directing the Advocates for the Petitioner to file
Affidavits disclosing the source of the documents filed by them in Court.
18.
Section 126 of the Indian Evidence Act enacts a prohibition against
the disclosure of professional communications. It states:
“126 - Professional communications:
No barrister, attorney, pleader or vakil, shall at any time be
permitted, unless with his client's express consent, to
disclose any communication made to him in the course and
for the purpose of his employment as such barrister,
pleader, attorney or vakil, by or on behalf of his client, or to
state the contents or condition of any document with which
he has become acquainted in the course and for the purpose
of his professional employment, or to disclose any advice
given by him to his client in the course and for the purpose
of such employment:
Provided that nothing in this section shall protect from
disclosure –
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
(1)any such communication made in furtherance of any
illegal purpose ;
(2)any fact observed by barrister, pleader, attorney or
vakil, in the course of his employment as such, showing
that any crime or fraud has been committed since the
commencement of his employment.
It is immaterial whether the attention of such barrister,
pleader, attorney or vakil was or was not directed to such
fact by or on behalf or his client.
Explanation - The obligation stated in this section continues
after the employment has ceased.”
19.
The rationale, as observed by the House of Lords in Three Rivers DC
v. Bank of England and accepted by Indian Courts, is that a man must be
able to consult his lawyer in confidence, and this confidence must be
inviolable to ensure the proper administration of justice.
20.
In Superintendent and Remembrancer of Legal Affairs v. Satyen
Bhowmick (1981) 2 SCC 109, the Supreme Court held that where contents
of a document are privileged, no action can be taken against counsel for
refusing to disclose the same.
21.
However, this privilege is not absolute. The Proviso to Section 126
carves an exception to the communications made in furtherance of any
illegal purpose in respect of any fact showing that any crime or fraud has
been committed since the commencement of employment.
22.
When a client hands over a document to their Advocate for the
purpose of legal defense, the act of handing over and the information
regarding the origin of that document, is part of the professional
confidentiality. The primary responsibility for the documents filed in Court
lies with the Party i.e. the Client. To compel an advocate to disclose that
“Client X gave me this document”, is to compel the disclosure of the
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
“source” of the documents is protected by Section 126 IEA. Such documents
filed by the Counsel are at the behest of the client and for and on his behalf.
By directing disclosure by the Advocate of the Petitioner to file the Affidavit
regarding the proceedings in the Court, the Ld. ASJ has compelled the
advocates to breach their professional duty, which falls squarely within the
ambit of “communication made to him in the course and for the purpose of
his employment” and is protected by the Client-Advocate privilege under
S.126 IEA.
23.
The Respondent No. 2’s contention that there is “no privilege against
the Court” is a misapplication of the principle. While the Court can ask for
the truth, it cannot compel a lawyer to disclose what the law expressly
protects, absent a clear finding that the lawyer is conspiring in a fraud
committed during the employment.
24.
Respondent No. 2 relies heavily on the Proviso, alleging that the
possession of the documents serves an illegal purpose or is evidence of a
crime like theft of court records. However, for the Proviso to apply, there
must be prima facie material to suggest that the communication itself was
for an illegal purpose, which is not so. These documents were filed to
demonstrate that there was no urgency to stay the impugned Order of Search
and Seizure.
25.
While a Court has the power to inquire into offences affecting the
administration of justice, such an inquiry must be conducted within judicial
contours. In the present case, the Petitioner has explained that the copies of
2011 Applications were served upon them in 2013, during proceedings
before the Company Law Board in CP No. 110/2013, thereby demolishing
the allegation of theft or illegal procurement, made by the Respondent No. 2.
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
26.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that the Impugned Order
dated 20.05.2017 fails to appreciate that the information sought is covered
by the privilege between the client and the advocate. The exception of fraud
was not prima facie established to warrant piercing this privilege, especially
when a plausible explanation of service in CLB proceedings was available
on record.
Conclusion:
27.
The Impugned Order dated 20.05.2017, insofar as it directs the
Advocates for the Petitioner to file personal affidavits disclosing the source
of the documents, and all consequential proceedings arising therefrom
including the Order dated 22.07.2017 issuing notice for contempt/noncompliance against the counsels, is quashed.
28.
The Petition is allowed accordingly and the pending Applications, if
any, are disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 12, 2026/R
KUMAR BHATT
17:41:26
W.P.(CRL) 2294/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review