Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 13182 of 2021
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1290 of 2024
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1659 of 2025
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 16404 of 2024
==========================================================
ASHWINKUMAR VISHNUBHAI JADAV
Versus
DIRECTOR GENERAL AND INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE,
GUJARAT STATE & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR KASHYAP B TRIPATHI FOR MS SHUBHA B TRIPATHI(5597) for the
Petitioner(s) No. 1
MR ADITYA PATHAK AGP for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2,3
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIKHIL S. KARIEL
Date : 07/07/2025
COMMON ORAL ORDER
1.
Heard learned Advocate Mr. Sudhanshu A. Jha and learned Advocate
Ms. Mamta R. Vyas for the petitioners and learned AGP Mr. Aditya Pathak
for the respondents.
2.
By way of these petitions, the petitioners have challenged the decision
of the respondents in declaring the petitioners as unfit for appointment,
more particularly on the ground that the petitioners were suffering from the
disability of colour blindness.
3.
At the outset, it requires to be noted that the selection in which the
petitioners had participated was between the year 2009 to 2018 in all the
matters and whereas the learned Advocates would submit that since this
Court having decided group of petitions where the recruitment was of the
year 2009, vide decision dated 01.04.2024 in Special Civil Application No.
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
10195 of 2021 and allied matters, the said decision is produced on record.
4.
Having perused the said decision and having heard the learned
Advocates for the respective parties, it would clearly appear that in similar
set of facts, more particularly in case of a recruitment of the year 2009, this
Court had allowed the writ petitions. Considering the identical nature of the
facts and the prayers, the observations in the said decision, more particularly
at Paragraph Nos. 3 to 7 is reproduced hereinbelow :
"3. Considering the submissions made by the learned
advocates for the parties, it would appear that insofar as
principal issue is concerned i.e. whether the disability of colour
blindness could be a disability for employment, this Court,
seeks to rely upon the decision of Division Bench of this Court
in Letters Patent Appeal no.1136 of 2018 in Special Civil
Application no.7595 of 2013 dated 2 nd November, 2018. It
requires to be observed here that the Hon’ble Division Bench,
had inter alia observed that since there was no specific
provision in the rules, which provided for disqualification on
the ground that the candidate suffers from colour blindness,
the orders, whereby the candidature / appointments of the
petitioners had been rejected/ cancelled, were all set aside and
the petitioners therein were directed to be appointed from the
date on which they would have been ordinarily appointed as
per the select list. It also requires to be mentioned here that
the said law has been reiterated in number of decisions of this
Court both of learned Co-ordinate Benches, as well as,
Division Benches and whereas since the issue is no more res
integra, this Court deems it appropriate to follow the law laid
down by the Division Bench and whereas observation at para12 are being reproduced hereinbelow for benefit.
“12.
In the light of the law laid down in the
above decisions, it clearly emerges that in case any
candidates are sought to be disqualified on the ground that
they suffer from colour blindness, there has to be a specific
provision in the rules providing for such disqualification. In
the facts of the present case, a perusal of the relevant rules
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
clearly indicates that no such disqualification has been
provided for the post in question. Under the circumstances,
it is not permissible for the respondents to adopt a stand
that the appellants herein are not qualified for the post of
Lok Rakshak. The learned Single Judge was, therefore,
not justified in holding that every kind of deficiency or
incapacity is not to be mentioned in the recruitment rules,
and therefore, merely because it has not been specifically
provided in the rules, it cannot be presumed that the
petitioner therein should be treated as medically fit in spite
of negative opinion after the examination.”
4.
As far as the principal issue is concerned, while the same
is a settled position, the bone of contention in the present
group of petitions is with regard to the petitioners having been
approached this Court after a considerable delay. While it is the
case of the petitioners that the petitioners should be treated
similarly to the other candidates, who had approached this
Court questioning their non-appointment and whereas reliance
is placed by the learned advocates for the petitioners upon
observations of the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in
Letters Patent Appeal no.538 of 2020 dated 2 nd February, 2021,
more particularly whereby the Hon’ble Division Bench has
inter alia observed that since the candidate therein belonged to
the Scheduled Tribe and was residing in a remote area,
therefore, he should not be deprived of employment if he is
otherwise found to be qualified, simply on the issue that the
candidate was suffering from colour blindness.
Importantly, the petitioners would rely upon a decision
of the respondent authorities dated 14 th September, 2022,
whereby a candidate i.e. one Chaudhary Sanjaykumar Ambalal
had been appointed, more particularly, the candidate having
been disqualified in a recruitment process of the year 2009.
Learned advocates would point-out that the said candidate had
initially approached this Court by preferring Special Civil
Application no.15651 of 2021 and whereas, vide an order
dated 18th October, 2021, this Court had inter alia accepted the
request of the petitioner to approach the respondents by
preferring representation for agitating his grievances. It is
submitted by learned advocates that the order dated 14 th
September, 2022 referred to hereinabove by the respondents,
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
was an order passed upon the representation by the very
petitioner, which was directed to be decided by this Court.
Learned advocates for the petitioners would point-out that the
petitioner therein, having not succeeded in getting an
appointment in the year 2009, more particularly his candidature
having been cancelled on the ground of being afflicted with
colour blindness, yet, the respondent authorities themselves
had deem it appropriate to appoint the said petitioner in the
year 2022. Learned advocates for the petitioners would further
submit that the respondent authorities having taken a stand to
appoint a candidate, who had been disqualified the selection of
the year 2009, it would not be open for the respondents to take
a different view in the present group of petitions.
5.
Per contra, the present group of petitions are
vehemently opposed by Mr. Sahil Trivedi, learned AGP on
behalf of the respondent – State. Learned AGP would submit
that while this Court has been taking a view time and again in
various petitions, that the affliction of colour blindness would
not be a disqualification for appointment as a Lok Rakshak,
Police Constable and whereas, one of the earliest decisions
being decision of the Division Bench, which is referred to
hereinabove, yet, what requires to be noted is that the decision
of Division Bench was also of the year 2018 whereas, the
petitioners have approached this Court six years thereafter.
Mr. Trivedi, learned AGP, would further submit that in Special
Civil Application no.10838 of 2021 vide a decision dated 5 th
August, 2021, learned Co-ordinate Bench, had rejected the case
of an applicant, whose candidatature had been rejected on the
ground that the candidate had been afflicted with colour
blindness, more particularly, the recruitment process being of
the year 2009. Learned AGP would submit that the Coordinate Bench had rejected the petition on the ground of
inordinate delay. Learned AGP would further rely upon
decision of Division Bench of this Court in Letters Patent
Appeal no.397 of 2020, whereby a decision dated 16 th October,
2009 in Special Civil Application no.12147 of 2019 by the Coordinate Bench, more particularly rejecting the petition of
similar nature on the ground of inordinate delay had been
confirmed by the Division Bench. Relying upon the said
decisions, learned AGP would request this Court not to
entertain the present petitions.
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
6.
Heard learned advocates for the respective parties and
perused the documents on record. As noted hereinabove,
insofar as the decision on merits is concerned, the same is no
more res integra inasmuch as, the law on the issue having been
settled by decision of the Division Bench referred to
hereinabove i.e. in Letters Patent Appeal no.1136 of 2018 in
Special Civil Application no.7595 of 2013 dated 2 nd November,
2018, in the considered opinion of this Court, the same is
required to be followed.
7.
As noted hereinabove, the only issue which arises for
consideration of this Court that, would this Court entertain a
writ petition, more particularly after such a considerable delay
at the end of petitioner himself.
8.
At the outset, in this regard, it is to be noted that the
issue that the petitioners are not required to be appointed since
they have come to this Court belatedly, may not be open for
the respondent themselves to contend, the reason being that in
writ petition i.e. Special Civil Application no.15651 of 2021, as
referred to hereinabove vide decision dated 18 th October, 2021,
this Court had acceded to the request of learned advocate for
the petitioner for permitting the petitioner to approach the
respondents by preferring a representation and whereas the
respondents were directed to decide the representation in
accordance with law within a specific period of time. It would
appear as noted hereinabove that vide order dated 14 th
September, 2022 the respondents, had appointed the said
petitioner in spite of noting that the petitioner had not cleared
the selection process of the year 2021. In the considered
opinion of this Court, the respondents having deemed it
appropriate to appoint a candidate whose candidature had
been rejected in spite of selection, more particularly, the
process having started in the year 2009, and whereas it also
appears pursuant to the order dated 14 th September, 2022 that
the order does not notice any special circumstance for taking a
view in question, therefore, now it would not be open for the
respondents to take a stand that even if the petitioners having
approached this Court belatedly, more particularly, the
selection pertaining to the year 2009, therefore, their cases
ought not to be entertained by this Court. The State having
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
taken a particular view in case of a particular employee, the
same stand is required to be reiterated by this Court in case of
the present petitioners, who are otherwise similarly situated to
the employee/ beneficiary of order dated 14th September, 2022.
9.
Insofar as the decisions of learned Co-ordinate Bench in
Special Civil Application no.10838 of 2021 and Letters Patent
Appeal no.397 of 2020, it requires to be observed that while
the Hon’ble Division Bench, as well as, learned Co-ordinate
Bench had taken a view that the case of the petitioners/
employees therein ought not to be entertained on the ground
of delay, yet, it would appear that in a later decision, Hon’ble
Division Bench, more particularly vide decision dated 2 nd
February, 2021 in Letters Patent Appeal no.538 of 2020 had
inter alia taken a view that merely on the ground of delay, a
candidate should not be deprived of employment, more
particularly since in similar petitions, where the petitioners
have challenged their non-appointment on the ground that
they detected with the affliction of colour blindness had been
interfered by the learned Co-ordinate Benches and Division
Benches of this Court, therefore, the later decision of the
Hon’ble Division Bench in the considered opinion of this
Court, is required to be followed, more particularly since it
appears that the present petitioners are otherwise similarly
situated to the petitioners, who had approached this Court and
whereas the only difference being that the petitioners have
approached this Court belatedly.
At this stage, it would also be worthwhile to note that
the aspect of belated approaching this Court, may not
otherwise prejudice the respondents at all except for the
benefits of seniority, this Court in almost all the cases has not
awarded any back-wages to the petitioners and whereas the
only benefit apart from directing appointment, which has been
granted to the employee is to be treated as being appointed at
the relevant point of time, when persons similarly situated to
the petitioners had appointed and whereas the period of
service prior to the date of service, has been directed not to be
treated as period in actual service. Thus, it would appear that
this Court, more particularly starting from decision dated 2 nd
November, 2018 in Letters Patent Appeal no.1136 of 2018
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
while directing appointment, had also balanced the equities by
ensuring that the interest of the State is also protected,
therefore, in the considered opinion of this Court, delay may
not have any real bearing on the issue in question and whereas
as noted hereinabove, since the State itself has deemed it
appropriate to appoint the employee in the year 2022, whose
candidature had been rejected pursuant to the selection of the
year 2009, therefore, it may not be open for the State to agitate
the issue of delay in the present group of petitions.
7.
Considering the above discussion, observations and
conclusions, in the opinion of this Court, the petitions would
succeed. The petitioners are entitled for appointment from
the date when they would have ordinarily appointed on being
selected and whereas the period from the date of appointment
till the date of actual joining, would not be treated as the
period in actual service except for retiral benefits and fixation
of seniority. Furthermore, it is clarified that the promotions
given if any to persons junior to the petitioners in the merit list
shall not be disturbed. The respondents to pass appropriate
orders appointing the present petitioners subject to the above
conditions more particularly if nothing adverse is found against
the petitioners within the period of eight weeks from the date
of receipt of this order. Rule made absolute to the
aforesaid extent."
5.
Having regard to the observations of this Court in the above quoted
order and considering the similarity of the facts, the present petitions would
also succeed. It is directed that the petitioners are entitled for appointment
from the date when they would have ordinarily appointed on being selected
and whereas the period from the date of appointment till the date of actual
joining, would not be treated as the period in actual service except for retiral
benefits and fixation of seniority. To clarify while the date of appointments
of the petitioners would be from the date they would have been ordinarily
appointed upon being selected and the benefits from the date of
appointment to the date of actual joining would be treated as notional.
C/SCA/13182/2021
ORDER DATED: 07/07/2025
Furthermore, it is clarified that the promotions given if any to persons
junior to the petitioners in the merit list shall not be disturbed. The
respondents to pass appropriate orders appointing the present petitioners
subject to the above conditions more particularly if nothing adverse is found
against the petitioners within the period of eight weeks from the date of
receipt of this order.
6.
With the above observations and directions, the present petitions
stand disposed of as allowed.
(NIKHIL S. KARIEL,J)
Y.N. VYAS
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review