Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL Digitally signed by SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHARMA
Date: 2023.04.18 17:23:03 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CRP(CRP Art. 227) No. 13 of 2020
Mayanglambam Sushil Kumar Singh S/o (L) M.Sudhir
Singh by occupation retired IPS Officer of Babupara,
Opp. Telephone Bhawan, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur 795001.
…….Petitioner
-Versus1. Union of India represented by the Secretary to the
Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, North
Block, New Delhi - 110001.
2. The State of Manipur represented by Chief Secretary
(in charge of Home), Government of Manipur, Old
Secretariat (South Block), PO & PS Imphal – 795001.
3. The Department of Personnel and Administrative
Reforms, through the Commissioner –cum- Secretary,
Government of Manipur, Imphal – 795001.
4. The Department of Home through the Commissionercum-Secretary, Government of Manipur, Imphal –
795001.
5. The Director General of Police, Government of
Manipur, Imphal – 795001.
…… Respondents
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |2
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. M. Ibohal, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. RK Umakanta, GA
Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma, Sr. PCCG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
16.03.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
30.03.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
(M.V. Muralidaran, Acting CJ)
This Civil Revision Petition has been filed by the
petitioner challenging the order dated 4.10.2018 passed in
O.A.No.042/ 00173/2014; order dated 6.1.2014 passed in
Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013 in O.A.No.230 of 2012 on the
file of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench and
the order dated 9.12.2013 passed by the Deputy Secretary (DP),
Government of Manipur.
2.
Though the petitioner challenged the aforesaid
orders in this revision, during the course of argument, the
petitioner restricted the challenge only with regard to the order
dated 6.1.2014 passed in the Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013,
which was closed based on the order dated 09.12.2013.
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |3
3.
Brief facts which led to the filing of the present civil
revision petition are as follows:
The petitioner has filed O.A.No.230 of 2012 before
the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench (Circuit
Bench at Imphal) [hereinafter referred to as “Tribunal”] to direct
the respondents to grant him IPS Junior Administrative Grade
scale w.e.f. 1.9.1998 i.e. after 9 years from the date and year of
allotment and selection grade scale and supertime scale from the
date when his immediate junior W.Meenakumar Singh (since
deceased) was promoted.
By the order dated 4.3.2013,
O.A.No.230 of 2012 was disposed of and the matter was remitted
to the respondents for fresh adjudication by taking into
consideration the order passed by the department by giving year
of allotment retrospectively from 1989 and was given seniority to
the post of IGP between Rakesh Ranjan and Meenakumar Singh
and the said exercise was directed to be completed within a
period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of the
order.
Thereafter,
the
petitioner
has
filed
O.A.No.042/
00173/2014 before the Tribunal seeking direction on the
respondents to grant him IPS Junior Administrative scale w.e.f.
1.9.1998 i.e. after nine years from the date and year of allotment
and direction to the respondents to grant IPS selection grade of
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |4
Rs.14300-400-18300 with effect from the date when his
immediate junior Meenakumar Singh was granted the same and
also to grant the petitioner regular supertime scale of Rs.3740067000 with effect from 6.1.2007 when his immediate junior
Meenakumar Singh was promoted to the post of IGP and grant
him all monetary benefits therefrom. The petitioner also sought
a direction to grant regular grade pay of Rs.10,000/- in Pay Band4 with effect from 6.1.2007. By the order dated 4.10.2018, the
said OA was dismissed.
Thereafter, the petitioner has filed
Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013 alleging non-compliance of the
order made in O.A.No.230 of 2012 and by the order dated
6.1.2014, the contempt petition was closed recording the order
dated 9.12.2013 passed by the Government of Manipur, whereby
the claim made by the petitioner for rectification of date of
appointment in the IPS, JAG scale, selection grade and
supertime scale to 1989 was held to be not tenable. Challenging
the same, the petitioner has filed the present civil revision
petition.
4.
Respondents 2 to 5 filed affidavit-in-opposition
stating that the order dated 9.12.2013 was passed in due
compliance
of
the
order
dated
4.3.2013
made
in
O.A.No.230/2012 and the Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013 was
disposed of as complied vide order dated 6.1.2014. The order
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |5
dated 9.12.2013 was accepted as compliance by the Tribunal
and the contempt petition was closed. Both the orders dated
9.12.2013 and 6.1.2014 have not been challenged by the
petitioner.
After taking into consideration the order dated
9.12.2013, the order dated 4.10.2018 came to be passed. It is
stated that the Tribunal after perusing the order dated 9.12.2013
was satisfied that the said compliance order was a speaking
order passed by considering the case afresh and, as such, was
of the view that nothing survives in the contempt proceedings as
the order of the Tribunal has been complied with. It is stated that
the Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms
(Personnel Division), being the controlling department for
organized services inclusive of the IPS, is competent to pass the
order dated 9.12.2013 while exercising its power under Rule 24(i)
of the Business of the Government of Manipur (Allocation) Rules,
2009. The petitioner has effective remedy under the act and
rules, including the Contempt of Courts Act as well as under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is stated that the civil
revision petition suffers from delay and laches and the
unreasonable delay in filing the civil revision petition has not been
properly explained.
Hence, they prayed for dismissal of the
revision.
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |6
5.
Assailing the impugned order dated 6.1.2014
passed in Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013, the learned counsel
for the petitioner argued that the Tribunal was not legally justified
and competent to close the contempt petition based on the
erroneous and unsustainable order dated 9.12.2013 passed by
the authority concerned. Therefore, the same is liable to be set
aside.
6.
The learned counsel further submitted that as
against the order dated 6.1.2014 passed in Contempt Petition
No.31 of 2013, a revision will lie before the High Court under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India for redressal of the
grievance of the petitioner.
7.
Adding further, the learned counsel submitted that
the petitioner has got the order dated 6.1.2014 only in the first
week of December, 2019 after his persistent and relentless
search as the Tribunal had not had its regular sitting at Imphal
Camp and thereafter, filed the present civil revision petition.
Therefore, the delay in filing the civil revision petition is neither
wilful nor wanton.
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioner urged that the
petitioner’s claim for enjoyment of Junior Administrative Grade
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |7
scale w.e.f. 1.9.1998, IPS selection grade scale and IPS regular
supertime scale etc. in his connected Original Application is
continuing one and hence, the cause of action of his present civil
revision petition cannot cease to exist only on the ground of
delay/laches, which is beyond his control. Besides it, his claim
if decided according to law shall give him a lawful monetary
benefit and, hence, shall be his property within the meaning of
Article 300A of the Constitution of India and, therefore, cannot be
defeated by the illegal procedure adopted by the Tribunal. In
support, the learned counsel placed reliance upon the decisions
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of (1) L.Chandra
Kumar etc. v. Union of India and others, (1997) 3 SCC 261
and (2) Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Syed Ahmad Ishaque and
others, (1955) 1 SCR 1104.
9.
Per contra, the learned Government counsel
appearing for the contesting respondents 2 to 5 submitted that
the Tribunal after perusing the order dated 9.12.2013 was
satisfied that the said order was a speaking order passed by
considering the case afresh and, as such, was of the view that
nothing survives in the contempt proceedings as the order of the
Tribunal has been complied with and, accordingly, closed the
contempt petition.
The learned Government counsel would
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |8
submit that there is no error and/or infirmity in the order dated
6.1.2014 passed in the contempt petition. Hence, the claim of
the petitioner questioning the competency of the Tribunal is
totally baseless.
10.
The learned Government counsel further submitted
that the Department of P&AR, being the controlling department
for organized services inclusive of the IPS, is competent to pass
the order dated 9.12.2013 exercising its power under Rule 24(i)
of the Business of the Government of Manipur (Allocation) Rules,
2009. Further, the petitioner has an effective remedy under the
relevant act and rules, including Contempt of Courts Act as well
as under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, and the present
revision would not lie. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss
the civil revision petition.
11.
We have considered the submissions made by
learned counsel for the parties and also perused the materials
available on record.
12.
In this civil revision petition, the petitioner has
restricted his challenge to the order dated 6.1.2014 passed in the
Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013, which was closed based on the
compliance order dated 9.12.2013 issued by the competent
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
Page |9
authority. The Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013 has been filed
alleging violation of the order of the Tribunal dated 4.3.2013
passed in O.A.No.230 of 2012, which was filed to issue a
direction on the respondents therein to grant the petitioner IPS
Junior Administrative Grade Scale with effect from 1.9.1998 i.e.
after 9 years from the date and year of allotment and selection
grade scale and supertime scale from the date when his
immediate junior W.Meenakumar Singh (since deceased) was
promoted.
13.
The order dated 6.1.2014 passed in Contempt
Petition No.31 of 2013 reads thus:
“None appeared on behalf of the petitioner.
Mr.s.Sharma, learned Govt. counsel, Manipur
assisted by Mr.K.N.Deka, learned counsel is
present for the contemners.
This Tribunal vide order dated 04.03.2013
passed
in
OA.No.230/2012
directed
the
respondents to adjudicate the representation of
the petitioner within three months afresh. It was
submitted by Mr.Sharma that vide order dated
09.12.2013, the Govt. of Manipur, Department
of Personnel and Administrative Reforms
(Personnel Division) considered the case
afresh and passed speaking order that, “in view
of the above facts and circumstances stated
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 10
above, the Governor of Manipur is pleased to
dispose of the claims of Shri Sushil Kumar
Singh, IPS (Retd) contained in his application
dated 13.03.2013 for rectification of date of
appointment in the IPS, JAG Scale, Selection
Grade and Supertime Scale to 1989 as not
tenable.
In view of the passing of the aforesaid order,
nothing survives in this proceeding as the order
has been complied with. Accordingly, CP is
closed. Notices are discharges. Copy of the
order dated 09.12.2013 shall be kept in record.”
14.
It would be appropriate to quote the order dated
9.12.2013 issued by the competent authority hereinunder for
ready reference:
“GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS
(PERSONNEL DIVISION)
ORDERS BY THE GOVERNOR MANIPUR
Imphal, dated the 9th December, 2013
No.18/166/2012
Central
-
CAT/DP:
Administrative
Whereas
Tribunal,
the
Guwahati
Bench, Circuit Bench at Imphal in its Order
dated 04-03-2013 passed inOriginal Application
No 230 of 2012 filed by Shri M.Sushil Kumar
Singh has directed the State Government of
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 11
Manipur to adjudicate the case of the applicant
afresh by taking into consideration the Order
passed by the Department by giving year of
allotment retrospectively from 1989 and being
given seniority to the post of Inspector General
of Police between Shri RakeshRanjan and W
Meenakumar Singh;
2. And whereas Shri M Sushil Kumar Singh IPS
(Retd) submitted an application dated 13-032013 for rectification of date of grant of IPSJAG Scale wef 1998 and Selection Grade Scale
and Supertime Scale and his rank pay from the
date
of
his
immediate
junior
Shn
W.
Meenakumar Singh. IPS in pursuance of the
Hon'ble CAT's Order dated 04-03-2013 passed
in OA No 230 of 2012;
3. And whereas the State Government has
considered the application dated 13- 03-2013 of
ShriM.Sushil Kumar Singh, IPS (Retd.) with
reference to the Hon'ble CAT's Order dated 0403-2013 passed in OA No 230 of 2013 and has
observed the following:(a) that, the cases of Shri Th.Ibobi
Singh, IFS and Shri M Sushil Kumar
Singh, IPS are dissimilar as the case
of Shri Th.Ibobi Singh, IFS was
allowed due to delay in Triennial
Cadre review of the IFS Cadre
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 12
Strengths of Joint Manipur-Tripura
Cadre in terms of Hon’ble CAT's Order
dated 20- 01-1999 passed in OA No
15 of 1995;
(b) that State Government had already
granted relief to Shri M Sushil Kumar
Singh, IPS by issuing necessary
Orders for rectifying the allotment year
for promotion of Inspector General of
Police in the IPS Supertime Prerevised
Scale
of
Rs.18,400-450-
22400/- [PB-4Rs.37,400-Rs.67,000/plus Grade Pay of Rs.1000/- notionally
with effect from 06-01-2007 i.e. with
effect from the date on which his junior
Shri W.Meenakumar Singh, IPS (MT
89) was promoted and regularly with
effect
from
01-09-2010
as
per
direction of the Hon'ble CAT's Order
dated 31-08-2010 passed in O.A. No
68 of 2010;
In view of the above facts and
circumstances
stated
above,
the
Governor of Manipur is pleased to
dispose of the claims of Shri M.Sushil
Kumar Singh, IPS (Retd.) contained in
his application dated 13-03-2013 for
rectification of date of appointment in
the IPS, JAG Scale, Selection Grade
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 13
and Supertime Scale to 1989 as not
tenable.
By Order & in the name of the Governor
(Yumnam Robita)
Deputy Secretary (DP)
Government of Manipur”
15.
Relying upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the cases of Hari Vishnu Kamath and L.Chandra
Kumar, supra the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that the order dated 9.12.2013 passed by the Deputy Secretary
(DP) is erroneous and unsustainable in law and based on the
aforesaid order dated 9.12.2013, the Tribunal erred in closing the
contempt petition, which needs to be interfered with by this Court
exercising jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India. In effect, it is the plea of the petitioner that since the High
Court has power to supervise the decisions of the Tribunal, the
present civil revision petition is very well maintainable before this
Court and, thus, the order dated 6.1.2014 requires to be set
aside.
16.
In Hari Vishnu Kamath, supra, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held as under:
“Looking at the substance of the matter, when
once it is held that the intention of the
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 14
Constitution was to vest in the High Court a
power to supervise decisions of Tribunals by the
issue of appropriate writs and directions, the
exercise of that power cannot be defeated by
technical
considerations
of
form
and
procedure. …..”
In L.Chandra Kumar, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
17.
Court held:
“……. The Tribunals created under Article 323A
and Article 323B of the Constitution are
possessed of the competence to test the
constitutional validity of statutory provisions and
rules.
All decisions of these Tribunals will,
however, be subject to scrutiny before a
Division Bench of the High Court within whose
jurisdiction the concerned Tribunal falls. The
Tribunals will, nevertheless, continue to act like
Courts of first instance in respect of the areas of
law for which they have been constituted. It will
not, therefore, be open for litigants to directly
approach the High Courts even in cases where
they question the vires of statutory legislations
(except where the legislation which creates the
particular Tribunal is challenged) by overlooking
the jurisdiction of the concerned Tribunal. …..”
18.
In the case on hand, admittedly, the petitioner is
stated to be prejudiced by the order dated 6.1.2014 passed in
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 15
Contempt Petition No.31 of 2013. The contempt petition was
closed by recording the compliance order dated 9.12.2013
rejecting the application of the petitioner dated 13.3.2013, which
was filed pursuant to the direction dated 4.3.2013 passed in
OA.No.230 of 2012.
19.
As rightly argued by the learned Government
counsel, if really the petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated
9.12.2013, he ought to have availed the remedy in the manner
known to law. Similarly, if really the petitioner is aggrieved by the
order passed in the contempt petition, he has to work out his
remedy as per law. However, the petitioner has failed to avail of
those remedies and invoked the jurisdiction under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India, which in our considered view is not the
correct course of action. When the petitioner has an effective
and efficacious remedy under the relevant act and rules, the
invocation of the revisional jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India is unacceptable.
20.
It is settled law that the Administrative Tribunals are
alternative institutional mechanisms designed to be no less
effective than the High Court, but, at the same time, not to negate
the judicial review jurisdiction of the Constitutional Courts. The
Administrative Tribunals are not assigned a status equivalent to
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 16
that of the High Court and, for the purpose of judicial review or
judicial superintendence, they are subordinate to the High Court.
The High Courts are creatures of the Constitution and their
Judges hold constitutional office having been appointed under
the Constitution of India. The Tribunals are creatures of statute
and their members are statutorily appointed and hold a statutory
office.
There is no anathema in the Tribunal exercising
jurisdiction of the High Court and in that sense being
supplemental or additional to the High Court, but at the same
time not enjoying a status equivalent to the High Court and also
being subject to judicial review and judicial superintendence of
the High Court.
21.
While the powers of judicial review conferred on the
High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and the
power of judicial superintendence conferred on it under Article
227 of the Constitution of India are, no doubt, wide, its exercise
is hedged by self imposed limitations. The High Court would not
exercise its power of judicial review akin to that of an appellate
Court to hear and adjudicate the writ petition on its merits. In the
exercise of its powers of judicial review, the High Court would not
substitute its views for that of the Administrative Tribunal to come
to a different conclusion or to examine the order on its merits and
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 17
hold that the Administrative Tribunal erred in not punishing the
contemnors.
In the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article
226/227 of the Constitution of India, the High Court would also
not take upon itself the task of imposing punishment itself or to
direct the Tribunal to do so.
22.
In the light of the above legal position when we
examine the instant case, as stated supra, the validity of the
order dated 09.12.2013 passed by the authority concerned, in
compliance of the order of the Tribunal dated 4.3.2013 in
O.A.No.230 of 2012, should ordinarily be subject to challenge in
independent legal proceedings before the Tribunal and not by
invoking its jurisdiction to punish for contempt.
23.
Once there is an order passed by the authority
concerned on the basis of the directions issued by the Tribunal,
there arises a fresh cause of action to seek redressal in an
appropriate forum. In other words, the only remedy available to
the petitioner to question the validity of the order passed in
compliance of the order of the Tribunal, is to subject it to
challenge in independent legal proceedings before the Tribunal
and not by invoking jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 18
24.
The order dated 09.12.2013 of the authority
concerned cannot be questioned under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India. That apart, the petitioner questioned the
order passed in the contempt petition after a lapse of 6 years and
such an unreasonable delay in filing the present civil revision
petition has not been satisfactory explained.
25.
While the jurisdiction which this Court exercises
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is no doubt wide and
its power of judicial superintendence under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India can always be exercised to render
substantial justice, that would not mean that the High Court would
take upon itself the task of examining whether the Tribunal was
justified in discharging the respondents holding that order has
been complied with. In view of the above, we see no reason to
entertain this civil revision petition.
26.
Tribunal
It is pertinent to note that the direction given by the
in
O.A.No.230/2012
dated
4.3.2013
has been
implemented by issuance of the order dated 09.12.2013 and, as
stated supra, the said order dated 09.12.2013 is only amenable
to legal proceedings before the Tribunal, subject to satisfying the
delay and latches.
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
P a g e | 19
27.
For the foregoing reasons, the civil revision petition
fails and the same is dismissed. No costs. It is open to the
petitioner
to
challenge
the
order
dated
09.12.2013
in
independent legal proceedings before the Tribunal in the manner
known to law and if any challenge is made, the Tribunal is at
liberty to dispose of the same purely on merits and in accordance
with law.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
CRP (CRP Art.227) No. 13 of 2020
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review