Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
\
[ 3300 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
I
AT HYDE
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT
ON NO:31630 oF 2025
Master Syed Mesum Hussain, S/o. Smt. Sara Syeda and Syed Mussadiq
Hussain, Aged about 14 years (Minor), Occ Student, Legal Custodian
(Smt.Sara Syeda) Rep. by the GPA Holder Sri Syed Mohammed Askari, F/o
Smt. Sara Syeda, aged about 63 years, Occ Retired Employee, Rl/o. H.No.175-403, Dabeerpura, Hyderabad.
PETITIONER
AND
1. Union of lndia, Rep by its Secretary, Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi
2. The Consulate General of the Federal Republic of Germany, 9 Boat Club
Road, Raja Annamalai Puram, Chennai 600028 and also P.O.Box 3110,
Chennai 600 028, lndia, Phone 91-44-2430-1600, Fax 91-44-2434-9293'
Email info@chennai.diPlo.de
CT of R2 is amended as per C.O.d1.29.12.2025 in lA No.2/2025.
3. Syed Mussadiq Hussain, S/o. Syed Muftaqi Hussain, aged about 46 years,
O-cc Private Employee, FUo. H.No.17-4-387, Dabeerpura, Hyderabad.
,..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to issue a writ, order or direction, more particularly one in the nature of writ of
Mandamus, declaring the action of the 2nd respondent in insisting for fumishing of
NOC (No dbi""tion [ertificate) from the 3rd respondent for obtaining VISA to travel
Germiny to pursue the petitioners education during his minority while staying with
his mother in Germany is illegal, arbitrary and violation of Articles 21, 19 and 14 o1
constitution of lndia and ilso violative of principles of natural justice and
:-"-l!:Et'
consequently direct the 2nd respondent to consider the application of the petitioner
without insisting for NOC (No Objection Certificate) from the 3rd respondent.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
2nd respondent to consider the application of the petitioner and process the
petitioners Visa, without insisting for NOC (No Objection Certificate) from the 3rd
respondent, pending disposal of writ petition
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI KALUVALA VENKATA VARA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI N. BHUJANGA R,AO,
DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
Counsel for the Respondent 3: Mr J PRABHAKAT REPRESENTING Mr AZIZ
HUSSAIN
The Court made the following: ORDER
(.^\)
wp_31630_2025
NBlC J
n
ITIGII
IN
FORTHE S
oF'
ANA
TICE
WRIT PETITION No.31630
Between:
Master Syed Mesum Hussain
.. . Petitioner
AND
Union of India, and others
The petitioner, Master Syed Mesum Hussain, is the son of Mrs' Sara
Syeda and tlle 3'd respondent, Syed Mussadiq Hussain, bom out of their
wedlock. The present writ petition has been filed on behalf of the petitioner
through his grandfather, Mr. Syed MohammedAskari, acting as his General
Power of Attomey holder.
a
1.1. According to the averments made in the writ affrdavit, the
marriage of Mrs. Sara Syeda with the 3d respondent was solemnized on
03.06.2010 in accordance with Islamic rites and customs. Out of the said
wedlock, the petitioner, Master Syed Mesum Hussain, was born on
16.07 .2O1l.It is alleged that the 3d respondent failed to take
proper care of
Mrs. Sara Syeda and their son and neglected his familial responsibilities,
wp-31630_202s
NBI(, J
resulting in disputes between the spouses. Subsequently, the 3'd respoqdent
pronounced "Talaq," leading to their separation. Thereafter, Mr. Syed
Mohammed Askari, the father of Mrs. Sara Syeda, has been taking care of
both Mrs. Sara Syeda and the petitioner.
1.2. It is stated that the 3'd respondent instituted proceedings under
the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, in G.W.O.P. No. 7l I of 2011 before the
Family Court, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, when the petitioner was about
one and a halfyears old. During the pendency ofthe said proceedings, Mrs.
Sara Syeda filed M.C. No. 146 of 2013 seeking maintenance against the 3d
respondent before the Additional Metropolitan Sessions Judge-cum-
Additional Family Court-cum-XXIII Additional Chief Judge, Hyderabad.
The said maintenance case was allowed, and maintenance was award0d at
the rate of Rs.5,000/- per month to Mrs. Sara Syeda and Rs.2,500/- per
month to the petitioner.
1.3. It is further stated that Mrs. Sara Syeda remarried a German
citizen in August 2024 in accordance with Muslim Personal Law and has
continued to look after the educational and welfare needs of the petitioner.
She now intends to take the petitioner to Germany for his education. It is
stated that educational institutions in Germany require the child to be present
at least three months prior to admission. Accordingly, the petitioner applied
to the 2nd respondent{onsulate of Germany for issuance of visa.
1.4. The grievance of the petitioner is that the 2nd respondent has
insisted upon production of a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the 3d
respondent. Hence, the present writ petition.
2.
Heard Mr. Kaluvala Venkata Vara Prasad, leamed counsel for the
petitioner; Mr. N. Bhujanga Rao, leamed Deputy Solicitor General of India
wP_31530_2025
NBK, J
appearing for respondent Nos. I and 2; and Mr. J. Prabhakar, learned Senior
Counsel representing Mr. Aziz Hussain, leamed counsel on record for
respondent No. 3. Perused the record.
3.
Leamed counsel for the petitioner contended that matrimonial
disputes arose between Mrs. Sara Syeda and the 3rd respondent, culminating
in the latter pronouncing
*Talad' and abandoning Mrs. Sara Syeda and the
petitioner. Consequently, Mrs. Sara Syeda was constrained to institute M'C.
No. 146 of 2013 seeking maintenance, wherein the trial Court awarded
maintenance in favour of both Mrs. Sara Syeda and the petitioner. Leamed
counsel submitted that the 3'd respondent pronounced
*Talaq" more than a
a
decdde ago and has failed to care for or maintain the petitioner during all
these years. It was contended that Mrs. Sara Syeda has single-handedly
discharged all parental responsibilities and ensured the welfare and
upbringing of the child. Leamed counsel further submitted that Mrs. Sara
Syeda subsequently remarried a German citizen in August 2024 in
accordance with Muslim Personal Law and now intends to take the
petitioner to Germany for his education. Accordingly, an application for a
visa was submitted before the German Consulate. Learned counsel argued
that, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the insistence on a No
Objection Certificate (NOC) from the 3d respondent for processing the
petitioner's visa application is wholly unwarranted and liable to be
disptnsed with. He therefore prayed for a direction to respondent No' 2 not
to insist upon an NOC from the 3d respondent while considering the
petitioner's visa application.
4.
Leamed Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the 3d
relying upon the counter affrdavit, contended that the 3d respondent is the
natural father and legal guardian ofthe petitioner and that the petitioner's
wp_31630-2025
NBK, J
mother had no authority to confer guardianship or execute a General Power
of Auorney in favour of any third party. It was further contended'that
relocating the petitioner to Germany at the age of 15 years would not be in
his best interests. Leamed Senior Counsel submitted that language and
cultural ba:riers may adversely affect the petitioner's education and
integration into society. He further contended that, although matrimonial
disputes had arisen and divorce proceedings had taken place, visitation
rights had been granted in favour of the 3'd respondent by the competent
Court. It was argued that there are inconsistencies in the stand taken by the
petitioner's mother and the GPA holder regarding the divorce. It was also
contended that the petitioner's mother had obtained the petitioner's Transfer
Certificate from his school on 02.04.2024, wherein the name of the father
was left blank, and that during the academic year 20234024,thepetitioner
remained absent from school for 51 days. Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the petitioner's mother could have awaited the outcome of
the visa application before relocating to Germany. He also pointed out that
she had contracted a second marriage with a German citizen. Finally, it was
contended that the petitioner ought to have approached the competent
Family Court for appropriate relief and that this Court lacks jurisdiction to
entertain the present writ petition.
5.
Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India submitted that the 3rd
respondent divorced Mrs. Sara Syeda, as evidenced by the Divorce
Certificate dated 04.09.2018 issued by the Telangana State Waqf Boar*'H'
further submitted that the 3rd respondent had filed G.W.O.P. No. 7ll of 2012
before the Family Court at Hyderabad seeking a declaration that he be
recognized as the lawful permanent guardian of the petitioner and also
seeking custody of the child. It was submitted that, by order dated
-
wp_31630_2025
rl
NSK, J
28.02.2014, the Family Court partly allowed the petition by granting
visitation rights to the 3'd respondent, permitting him to meet the petitioner
on every third Saturday of the month at the offrce of the District Legal
Services Authority. The prayer seeking custody of the child, however, was
rejected. Learned Deputy Solicitor General further submitted that the Family
Court's order granting visitation rights until the child attains majority cannot
operate as an impediment to the petitioner's educational pursuits. He argued
that the apprehensions expressed by the 3d respondent regarding the
petitioner's relocation to Germany, including concems relating to language
and education, are speculative and unsupported by any material on record
andiherefore do not merit consideration.
6.
Having considered the rival submissions, this Court finds that it is
undisputed that matrimonial disputes arose between Mrs. Sara Syeda and
the 3'd respondent, culminating in their divorce, as evidenced by the Divorce
Certiflrcate dated 04.09.2018 issued by the Telangana State Waqf Board. It
is also a matter of record that the 3d respondent instituted G.W.O.P. No' 7ll
of20ll seeking custody ofthe petitioner and a declaration ofpermanent
guardianship. The said proceedings were partly allowed only to the extent
of granting visitation rights, permitting the 3'd respondent to meet the
petitioner once every month, namely on every third Saturday, at the offtce
of t[e District Legal Services Authority. The prayer for custody of the child
was expressly rejected. Consequently, the custody of the petitioner has
continuously remained with his mother, Mrs. Sara Syeda.
7.
It is further bome out from the record that, in M.C. No. 146 of 2013,
the Additional Metropolitan Sessions Judge-cum-Additional Family Court-
cum-XXI[ Additional Chief Judge, Hyderabad, awarded monthly
wp_31630_2025
NBK, J
maintenance in favour of both the petitioner and his mother. These facts are
not in dispute.
.
8.
At this juncture, it is pertinent to note that the petitioner was born on
16.07.2011 and is presently about 14 years of age- The order passed in
G.W.O.P. No. 71 I of 2012 on28.02.2014 was rendered nearly twelve years
ago. The visitation rights granted to the 3'd respondent cannot be invoked in
a manner detrimental to the educational future prospects of the child.
Although the Family Court directed that the visitation arrangement would
continue until the child affains majority, the 3'd respondent has had the
benefit of the said arrangement since 2014, when the petitioner was
approximately two years old.
g.
The petitioner's mother now intends to take him to Germany for the
purpose of pursuing his education for his bright future. The contentiJn of
the 3'd respondent that English is not widely spoken or taught in Germany
and that the petitioner may face difficulties in adapting to a diflerent
educational system is based on mere conjecture and cannot constitute a valid
ground to impede the petitioner's educational advancement.
10. In the above circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the divorce between Mrs. Sara Syeda and the 3'd respondent, evidenced
by the Divorce Certificate dated 04.09.2018, has attained finality. Further,
the order dated 28.02.2014 passed by the Family Court effectively
recognized the continued custody of the petitioner with his mother by
declining the prayer of the 3'd respondent for custody, while grantingrhim
limited visitation rights.
11. The petitioner, who is presently about 14 years of age, seeks to pursue
his education in Germany while residing with his mother. The educational
i
a''
wp_31630_2025
NEIC J
aspirations ofthe petitioner cannot bejeopardized, and therefore this Court
is ofthe considered opinion that this is a fit case to exercise the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, to
direct the lst respondent-Ministry of External Affairs to correspond with the
2'd respondent-Consulate of Germany for consideration of the petitioner's
Visa application, without insisting on NOC from the 3'd respondent.
this Court directs the lst respondent-Ministry of
12.
Extemal Affairs to forthwith communicate to the 2nd respondent{onsulate
General of the Federal Republic of Germany a certified copy of this Order,
together with such appropriate communication as may be necessary, for its
consideration while processing the Visa application of the petitioner's minor
son, without being constrained by the requirement of a No Objection
Certificate from the 3d respondent, in view ofthe findings recorded herein.
13. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed, as above. There shall be no
order as to costs. Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
SD/.V.KAVITHA
DEPUTY REG
//TRUE COPY//
I
\
ECTION OFFICER
To,
, New Delhi
Boat Club
ermany,
G
2. The Consulate Genera I of the Federal RePublic and
also P.O.Box 3'110,
Road, Raja Annamalai Puram, Chennai 600028
Chennai 600 028, lndia' Phone 91-44-2430-1600, Fax 91-44-2434-9293,
Email info@chennai.diPlo.de
and Syed Mussadiq
e. rr,r"rGi svEJ M".rr'Hu"Ein, s/o. smt. sara Syeda
Student' Legal Custodian
(Minor),
Hussain, Aged about
-Occ
Askari' F/o
(Smt.Sara Syeda) Rep. oy tfi" e eli Holder Sri .Syed Mohammed
b;i. a;t; sveoa, agei "6o,iis v""o, occ Retired Emplovee' R/o' H'No'175-403, DabeerPura, HYderabad'
t" aaimlunninvEtlrnra vnnn PRASAD', Advocate toPu-cl ..
1. The Secretary, Ministry of Extemal Affairs, Union
I
it};*
4. O;; CC
5.OneCCtoSRlf.f.BHUJANGARAO,DeputySolicitorGeneraloflndia
loPUcl
6. Two CD Copies
BN
.TKS
CC TOD
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2310612026
€ STAT€'
q
ORDER
WP.No.31630 of 2025
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
o)
b
01JUL2Uz$
o
o
,
a
*
.+
.c,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review