Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 09.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 17.09.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 18.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010409292026
+
W.P.(C) 12662/2026 & CM APPL. 58741/2026
MASTER SHUBH CHOWDHARI
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Saurabh Kripal, Senior
Advocate with Ms. Manini
Brar, Mr. Divyansh Singh and
Mr. O.P. Harsh Singh Munday,
Advocates.
versus
EQUESTRIAN FEDERATION OF INDIA
& ORS.
Through:
....Respondents
Mr. Tanmay Mehta, Ms.
Niyati Kohli, Mr. Rishabh
Parikh and Ms. Isha Kakkar,
Advocates for R-1.
Ms. Kumudavalli Seetharaman
and Ms. Geetika Vyas,
Advocates for R-2.
Mr. Balbir Singh, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Kartik
Yadav, Ms. Sumedha Chadha,
Mr. Duvva Pavan Kumar, Ms.
Shradha Gupta, Mr. Chirag
Madan and Mr. G. Sai Krishna
Kumar, Advocates for R-3.
CORAM:
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
JUDGMENT
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
1.
The petitioner, Shubh Chowdhari, a young equestrian athlete,
has approached this Court by way of the present writ petition,
praying for grant of following reliefs:
“A. Quash and set-aside the Selection Decision II dated 27
August 2026 and dated 06.08.2026 issued by Respondent No.1
or its committees, and any other notification, public
announcement or communication issued by any Respondents,
or any government authority or ministry on the basis of these
decisions.
B. Direct Respondent No.1 to carry out a fresh selection of the
horse rider and reserve rider, based on already submitted
results by the competing riders for the Show Jumping
competition at the Youth Olympic Games 2026 in accordance
with the selection criteria previously published by it on 10 June
2026 and 10 July 2026, inter alia such that consistency of
performance based on penalty in the latest competitions is used
for ranking the best athlete.
C. Declare that the Petitioner is in fact first in the list of riders
who qualify as per the selection criteria published by
Respondent No.1, and is therefore the selected rider for the
Youth Olympic Games 2026.
D. Direct all Respondents and any other government authority
or ministry involved in the process of selection of riders for the
Show Jumpings competition and / or in the process of sending
them to the Youth Olympic Games 2026 give effect to the
directions of this Hon‟ble Court and selection of the Petitioner
as the eligible rider.
E. Grant ex-parte, ad interim reliefs to give effect to the prayers
made above; and or.”
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
The facts of the case, as discernible from the petition, are that
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
in May 2025, an information brochure was issued for participation in
the Youth Olympic Games 2026 [hereafter „YOG, 2026‟], according
to which the selection process was to commence with notification of
the eligibility criteria for each discipline by the concerned
international federation. In respect of Horse Jumping, the Fédération
Équestre Internationale (FEI) issued an invitation proposal pathway
prescribing minimum eligibility requirements, including a Certificate
of Capability (COC) confirming that an athlete had fulfilled the
minimum requirements for participation in the YOG, 2026. The FEI
also issued regulations for the Horse Jumping competition at the
YOG, 2026. The regulations provided that each participant would
attempt each obstacle course only once in a round, that the course
would remain the same for all participants, including in respect of the
height and spread of jumps and the length of the course, and that the
height of the jumps would remain between 120 cm and 125 cm. The
classification of athletes was to be based on penalties, followed by
the time taken to complete the course. In September 2025, a Youth
Olympics Qualifier round was held in Bangalore, where the
competing athletes participated on courses laid out in accordance
with the FEI Regulations for the YOG, 2026. Based on the results of
this competition, the petitioner herein received his COC on
10.06.2026.
3.
Thereafter, the respondent no. 1, i.e. Equestrian Federation of
India (EFI) issued selection criteria, vide emails dated 10.06.2026
and 10.07.2026. The criteria referred to objective assessment of
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
recent performances, consistency of results, competitiveness at
CSI1*/CSI2* events and overall merit. Further, the clarification
issued on 10.07.2026 stated that only CSI1*/CSI2* events with a
minimum jump height of 130 cm would be considered for Minimum
Eligibility Requirements (MERs) and performance consistency.
According to the petitioner, the criteria did not prescribe any priority
based on the number of rounds attempted or the height of the jumps.
4.
On the basis of the said criteria, the petitioner submitted his
competition results before the cut-off date of 25.07.2026. He
participated in the Tour Portugal Summer Tour 2026 at Esposende,
Portugal, in July 2026, completing five rounds at the 130 cm level.
These results, according to the petitioner, represented his most recent
competitive form after the notification of the selection criteria. The
petitioner states that he achieved all relevant performances at or
below eight penalties, which, according to him, demonstrated
consistency of performance. He further states that all five rounds
submitted by him were completed at 130 cm in CSI2* competitions.
He relies on the FEI classification of events into star levels, which,
according to him, already takes into account the height of obstacles
and the technical challenges involved. He also states that he was the
only competing athlete who had previously been shortlisted to
represent India at the Asian Youth Games, 2025 in Bahrain. The
petitioner alleges that, had he known that the number of rounds
attempted would be given priority over consistency of performance in
terms of penalties and time, he would have submitted results for a
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
greater number of rounds, even if they involved higher penalties.
According to him, he had instead focused on submitting recent results
with low penalties to demonstrate consistency.
5.
The petitioner states that a new Selection Committee was
appointed on 17.07.2026 and allegedly held a meeting on 06.08.2026,
wherein respondent no. 3, Sresth Raju Mantena, was recommended to
represent India at the YOG, 2026, while respondent no. 4, Vaasvi
Khaitan, was recommended as reserve rider [hereafter „Selection
Decision-I‟]. According to him, the Selection Committee introduced
a priority based on jump height, placing riders who had competed at
135 cm above those who had competed at 130 cm, while disregarding
certain high-penalty results and substituting them with lower-penalty
results obtained below the qualifying height of 130 cm. The
petitioner alleges that, in effect, jump height became the decisive
criterion, while penalties and consistency of performance were
disregarded, despite the fact that the height of the jumps in the
international rounds was fixed. Aggrieved thereby, on 14.08.2026,
the petitioner approached this Court by filing W.P.(C) 11935/2026,
challenging the Selection Decision-I and the announcement of results
dated 10.08.2026, inter alia, on the ground that undue priority had
been given to jump height in a competition where the height of the
jumps was fixed. It is stated that on 16.08.2026, EFI issued an
addendum indicating that it proposed to reconsider Selection
Decision-I in view of the writ petition and other representations. On
18.08.2026, this Court took note of EFI‟s decision to reconsider the
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
selection and granted it two weeks to do so. This Court further
directed that any fresh decision would be withheld for three days to
enable the petitioner to file a fresh writ petition in the event the
decision was adverse to him. Thereafter, the number of members of
the Selection Committee was increased from three to five. The
petitioner states that the reason for, and authority behind, this change
were not clear. On 19.08.2026, he submitted a detailed representation
to the Selection Committee, relying upon the selection criteria
previously notified on 10.06.2026 and 10.07.2026. Between
21.08.2026 and 25.08.2026, correspondence took place regarding the
petitioner‟s hearing before the Selection Committee. On 24.08.2026,
the window for EFI to notify the selection to the FEI opened, and the
same was to remain open until 25.09.2026. On 25.08.2026, the
petitioner‟s father appeared before the Selection Committee, referred
to the representation already submitted, and requested that the
petitioner be selected as the main rider on merits.
6.
On 27.08.2026, the Ad-Hoc Committee for the Governance of
EFI issued the fresh selection decision, comprising the Minutes dated
24.08.2026 of the Selection Committee, which is impugned before
this Court [hereafter „Selection Decision-II‟], whereby respondent
no. 3 was retained at rank 1, being recommended to represent India at
YOG, 2026, while the petitioner herein was upgraded to rank 2, from
previous rank 3, and recommended as reserve rider. According to the
petitioner, EFI admitted that Selection Decision-I was erroneous and
that jump height could not be given priority. However, the petitioner
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
alleges that EFI again placed respondent no. 3 at rank 1 by omitting
his results involving penalties as high as 20 points, despite penalties
being the principal assessment criterion under the FEI regulations and
the previously notified selection criteria. The petitioner states that,
even among the rounds considered by EFI, his penalties were lower
and his performance more consistent on average than that of
respondent no. 3, and that he ought therefore to have been placed at
Rank 1. He alleges that Selection Decision-II contains no explanation
for the ranking of respondent no. 3 at rank 1, the petitioner at rank 2,
or the other riders.
7.
Aggrieved thereby, the present writ petition has been filed by
the petitioner.
SUBMISSIONS BEFORE THE COURT
8.
The learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner
argues that the impugned selection decision dated 27.08.2026 is
contrary to the selection criteria notified by EFI and is liable to be set
aside. It is argued that the FEI in May, 2026, had issued the
regulations governing horse show jumping at the YOG, 2026.
Thereafter, the EFI had initially notified its selection criteria on
08.05.2026. Where more than one athlete fulfilled the eligibility
requirements or possessed the COC issued by the FEI, the athletes
were to be assessed on the basis of technical difficulty and level of
competitions, consistency of international performance, recency of
results relative to YOG 2026, horse-rider combination stability and
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
championship readiness. The selection criteria was thereafter clarified
by EFI on 10.06.2026, which referred to – objective assessment of
recent performances, consistency of recent results, competitiveness at
CSI1*/CSI2* level, and overall merit. Vide email dated 10.07.2026,
it was clarified that “CSI1*/CSI2* within minimum 130 cm height
only will be considered for MERs/performance consistency. The
learned senior counsel contends that the impugned Selection
Decision-II does not refer to the notified selection criteria, much less
explain how this criteria was applied while evaluating the petitioner
and respondent no. 3. The only vague reference is to “overall merit”,
which was merely one component of the overall criteria and could
not substitute the other notified parameters. It is submitted that EFI
failed to consider the recent results for assessing consistency, despite
having expressly notified “recent performances” and “consistency” as
relevant criteria.
9.
It is further contended that the relevant results, as per the
notified criteria, were those involving a minimum height of 130 cm,
at CSI1*/CSI2* level, and consisting of completed rounds, whether
one-phase or two-phase. In the case of respondent no. 3, the results
dated 27.06.2026 and 21.06.2026, involving 12 and 20 penalty points
respectively, were omitted without any explanation. Both results were
at heights of 130 cm and above, including 135 cm, at CSI1* level,
and were completed rounds falling within the category of results
eligible for consideration. In contrast, the petitioner had no penalty
above eight points in any of his results at a height of 130 cm. The
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
learned senior counsel submits that there can be no meaningful
assessment of “consistency” in recent results unless all relevant
results within the period fixed by the Selection Committee are
considered; and that EFI could not selectively omit the unfavourable
results of respondent no. 3 while relying upon selected results to
place him above the petitioner. Therefore, it is argued that the EFI
was required to apply the criteria which it had itself notified in
advance, and that it could not disregard relevant results or selectively
choose results so as to arrive at a pre-determined conclusion.
10.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner also argues that
EFI could not have prioritised the number of rounds attempted by an
athlete, since – (i) the athletes were neither required nor directed to
submit a fixed number of results so as to enable a “best of”
comparison; (ii) the “number of rounds” was never notified as a
selection criterion; and (iii) in the Youth Olympic Games, each rider
attempts the jumps for each competition only once and thus, number
of rounds has no relevance to the actual format of the said Games. It
is submitted that if the number of rounds was intended to be a
relevant factor, the petitioner would have submitted more results.
However, the number of rounds was neither notified nor
communicated to the athletes as a relevant factor and could not,
therefore, be used subsequently to justify the selection of respondent
no. 3 over the petitioner.
11.
Conversely, the learned counsel appearing for respondent
no. 1/EFI argues that the present petition is devoid of merit and that
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
the impugned Selection Decision-II does not warrant interference. It
is stated that, by order dated 18.08.2026 passed in W.P.(C)
11935/2026, this Court directed EFI to decide the petitioner‟s
representation within two weeks and, in case of an adverse decision,
restrained the uploading of the names of other applicants for three
days. EFI complied with these directions. Even prior thereto, the AdHoc
Committee
had
suspended
Selection
Decision-I
dated
06.08.2026 by issuing an Addendum dated 16.08.2026 and inviting
representations from all riders. The Selection Committee thereafter
reconvened on 24.08.2026, heard the petitioner‟s father and
representatives of the other riders, considered the written
representations, including that of the petitioner dated 19.08.2026, and
re-tabulated and verified the results against the FEI database. Its
reasons were recorded in the Minutes, and its recommendation was
accepted by the Ad-Hoc Committee through Resolution dated
27.08.2026. The decision was communicated to all COC holders,
while its public disclosure was withheld for three days in compliance
with this Court‟s order. The grievance that no reasons were recorded
is, therefore, contrary to the Minutes. The learned counsel further
submits that selection of sportspersons to represent the country falls
within the domain of the concerned National Sports Federation and
its expert selectors. A writ court does not sit as an appellate authority
over sporting merit or substitute its own assessment for that of the
experts. Interference would be permissible only if the selection is
shown to be mala fide, perverse, or contrary to binding criteria, none
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
of which has been established by the petitioner.
12.
The learned counsel appearing for EFI further submits that the
selection criteria for YOG, 2026 was uploaded on the EFI website on
08.05.2026. Where more than one athlete held a valid CoC, the
criteria, inter alia, required assessment on the basis of technical
difficulty and level of competitions, consistency of international
performance, recency of results relative to YOG, 2026. The email
dated 10.06.2026 reiterated that selection would be based on an
objective assessment of recent performances, consistency of results,
competitiveness at CSI1*/CSI2* events and overall merit, with
25.07.2026 fixed as the cut-off date for submission of results. The
email dated 10.07.2026 further clarified that only CSI1*/CSI2*
results at a minimum height of 130 cm would be considered. The
petitioner does not dispute the aforesaid criteria. It is argued that this
very criteria was applied by the Selection Committee during
reconsideration and while passing the impugned Selection DecisionII.
13.
The learned counsel contends that none of the criteria dated
08.05.2026, 10.06.2026 or 10.07.2026 provided that riders would be
ranked on the basis of the arithmetic average of their penalties or that
penalties would be the principal determinant of the order of merit.
According to EFI, it is the petitioner herein who seeks to introduce an
unnotified criterion by relying upon the format of the competition at
the Games. It is stated that one of the notified criteria was
“consistency”, and that consistency cannot be assessed merely on the
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
basis of an average which may reward a rider for participating in
fewer competitions. The learned counsel submits that the petitioner
himself has pleaded that consistency of performance essentially
means repeatedly securing low penalties, at or below eight points.
This was precisely the basis adopted by the Selection Committee. On
that basis, respondent no. 3 had more qualifying performances than
the petitioner. It is submitted that the Selection Committee adopted a
uniform methodology for all seven CoC holders. It (i) fixed the
assessment window from 08.05.2026, being the date of publication of
the Selection Criteria, to 25.07.2026, being the notified cut-off date,
and also counted the CoC result of each rider; (ii) considered all FEI
CSI1*/CSI2* and higher results at 130 cm and above, giving equal
weightage to 130 cm and 135 cm classes; (iii) excluded two-phase
competitions where the rider had jumped only the first phase and had
not completed the full course; (iv) treated a completed round
involving not more than eight penalties as a qualifying performance,
which was also the standard prescribed by the FEI for a CoC and
relied upon by the petitioner himself; and (v) re-tabulated and
verified every rider‟s results against the FEI database. These
principles were applied uniformly to all the riders. On this basis,
respondent no. 3 had five qualifying performances, the petitioner had
four, and respondent no. 4 had three, and the petitioner, who had
stood third under the previous decision, consequently moved up to
second upon reconsideration.
14.
The learned counsel submits that the petitioner‟s allegation
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
regarding the omission of respondent no. 3‟s round involving 20
penalties is untenable, inasmuch as a round involving 20 penalties
was not a qualifying performance under the applicable standards and
was not counted for any rider. Similarly, the petitioner‟s own results
which did not satisfy the same standards, including two-phase
competitions in which he had completed only the first phase, were
also excluded. It is argued that the petitioner cannot insist that his
own non-qualifying results be excluded while requiring respondent
no. 3‟s non-qualifying results to be counted against him. The
petitioner‟s tabulation of average penalties is, therefore, selective and
is based upon a criterion which was never notified. It is contended
that the petitioner‟s plea that he would have submitted more rounds is
also not tenable. All riders were asked by the email dated 10.06.2026
to submit their latest competition results and performance records by
25.07.2026. In any event, the Selection Committee did not confine
itself to the results submitted by the riders but independently verified
the same against the FEI database, which records every start by every
rider. The petitioner‟s international results during the assessment
window [i.e. 08.05.2026 to 25.07.2026] consisted of a single tour at
Esposende, Portugal. Respondent no. 3, on the other hand,
participated in competitions in Italy, France and Hungary and secured
qualifying results at CSI events in France and Hungary, at both 130
cm and 135 cm. Both of respondent no. 3‟s qualifying competitions
were Grand Prix events, whereas the petitioner participated in a
medium tour. The Selection Committee was, therefore, entitled to
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
consider respondent no. 3‟s results as demonstrating greater
consistency, competitiveness and technical level, all of which were
expressly included in the notified criteria.
15.
In rebuttal, the learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner argues that the explanations advanced by EFI are neither
supported by the record nor consistent with the selection criteria
notified by the EFI. It is argued that the explanation of EFI that
respondent no. 3 participated in competitions of greater technical
difficulty than the petitioner is factually incorrect. Technical
difficulty is determined by the CSI level of the competition. Under
the FEI Jumping Rules, CSI5* represents the highest level, while
CSI1* represents a lower level of technical difficulty. Even in the
results considered by the Selection Committee, the petitioner‟s
performances were at the CSI2* level, whereas the performances of
respondent No. 3 were at the CSI1* level. It is, therefore, submitted
that the petitioner had participated in competitions of a higher CSI
level than respondent no. 3. The reference to “Grand Prix” by EFI is
misplaced. “Grand Prix” is merely the name given to the competition
conducted on the final day of an event, generally carrying higher
prize money. It does not, by itself, determine the technical level or
difficulty of the competition. Further, the EFI‟s explanation that
respondent no. 3 had participated in more 135 cm events cannot be
accepted, since priority to higher jump height was admittedly not a
notified selection criterion. In fact, the impugned selection decision
itself records that equal weightage was to be given to the 130 cm and
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
135 cm classes and that all results above 130 cm were to be
considered. The learned senior counsel further contends that the
explanation of EFI that respondent no. 3 had performed better than
the petitioner in a common competition is also irrelevant, since
performance in a common competition was never prescribed as a
selection criterion. If such a criterion was intended to be applied, all
athletes ought to have been required to participate in the same
competitions. EFI cannot, therefore, rely upon performance in a
common competition as an additional criterion after the selection
process has concluded, particularly when the athletes were never
informed that such a comparison would determine their ranking.
16.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner argues that EFI is
bound by its own notified selection criteria and cannot introduce new
considerations at the stage of selection or during the hearing of the
petition. He submits that Clause 33.3 of the Interim Constitution of
the EFI, relied upon by EFI itself in its reply, expressly provides that
selection shall be made strictly on the basis of objective criteria
published in advance and disclosed to all potential candidates. The
learned senior counsel stresses upon the fact that the criteria notified
by EFI referred to technical difficulty, consistency, recency of results,
horse-rider
combination,
championship,
competitiveness
at
CSI1*/CSI2* level and overall merit; and it did not refer to the
number of rounds, performance in a common competition,
participation in Grand Prix events, or priority based on higher jump
height. EFI could not, therefore, justify the impugned selection
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
decision by relying upon considerations which were neither notified
in advance nor disclosed to the participating athletes. Therefore, it is
prayed that the present writ petition be allowed.
17.
The learned counsel appearing for respondent no. 3, Sresth
Raju Mantena, submits that the present petition is the second
challenge raised by the petitioner, who has been placed as Reserve
Rider No. 1, to the selection of respondent no. 3 to represent India in
the Show Jumping discipline at the YOG, 2026. Without prejudice to
the objection that the relief sought is beyond the scope of judicial
review under Article 226 of the Constitution, the learned counsel
argues that the composition of the Show Jumping Selection
Committee was enhanced from three to five members vide
Addendum dated 16.08.2026 and all the five members are national
show-jumping riders possessing the requisite expertise and technical
knowledge of equestrian sport. It is argued that the Selection
Committee had heard the parents of all the concerned athletes holding
a CoC, considered their written representations and recorded its
deliberations in comprehensive minutes. The grievance that the
petitioner was not afforded an opportunity of hearing or that the
decision was taken without reasons is, therefore, incorrect. It is stated
that the recommendation of the Selection Committee was thereafter
accepted by EFI. It is contended that the criterion applied by the
Selection Committee while selecting respondent no. 3 was traceable
to the following – (i) the email dated 10.06.2026; (ii) the email dated
10.07.2026; (iii) paragraph 5 of the Selection Criteria dated
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
08.05.2026; and (iv) the FEI standard of not more than eight penalties
for a qualifying performance, and the petitioner herein has not
challenged the validity of the said Selection Criteria. It is, therefore,
submitted that the criteria applied by the Selection Committee was
neither new nor introduced after the commencement of the selection
process. It is stated that as per Selection Criteria, since more than one
athlete fulfilled the mandatory eligibility requirement, the Selection
Committee proceeded under Clause 5 of the Selection Criteria, which
required assessment on the basis of – technical difficulty, consistency
of international performance, recency of results relative to YOG
2026, horse-rider combination stability, and championship readiness.
It is submitted that, for assessing technical difficulty and horse-rider
combination stability, the Selection Committee fixed the minimum
height at 130 cm. For assessing recency and consistency, it fixed the
qualifying period from 08.05.2026 to 25.07.2026. For assessing
championship readiness, it considered qualifying scores involving not
more than eight penalties, in accordance with the applicable FEI
standard. The same methodology was applied uniformly to all the
riders. In respect of respondent no. 3, such results involved 8, 4, 0, 6
and 4 penalties, totalling 22 penalties over 05 qualifying
performances. In respect of petitioner, such results involved 4, 0, 6
and 4 penalties respectively, totalling 14 penalties over 04 qualifying
performances; and in respect of respondent no. 4, 03 qualifying
performances were considered, involving 8, 4 and 0 penalties. On the
basis of the aforesaid uniform methodology, respondent no. 3, having
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
05 qualifying performances, was selected. Further, it is argued that
the Selection Committee did not give preference to 135 cm results
over 130 cm results, and equal weightage was given to 130 cm and
135 cm, and all results above 130 cm were duly considered. It is
further submitted that the Selection Committee excluded two-phase
competitions where the rider had completed only the first phase and
had not completed the full course. This principle was applied equally
to all riders and was not used selectively against the petitioner. The
learned counsel further contends that the notified criteria did not
provide for ranking the athletes on the basis of the arithmetic average
of their penalties. The criteria referred to “consistency of
international performance” and not to an average penalty calculation.
It is argued that the petitioner is seeking to introduce a new criterion
by insisting that the riders be compared only on the basis of average
penalties. Such a criterion was never notified and cannot be
substituted for the assessment undertaken by the expert Selection
Committee. It is also argued that consistency cannot be assessed
merely by calculating the average of a limited number of results,
particularly where one rider has participated in fewer competitions,
more so since an average rewards a rider for competing less. On the
petitioner‟s arithmetic, a rider who jumps one clear round and stops
would defeat a rider who jumps five qualifying rounds across three
countries. Therefore, the number and spread of qualifying
performances are relevant to assessing whether a rider has
consistently performed at the required level. The learned counsel
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
further submits that the petitioner‟s reliance on one of the results of
respondent no. 3 involving 20 penalties is misplaced, as the
performance involving 20 penalties did not qualify under the
applicable eight-penalty standard and was not counted for any rider.
The same methodology was applied to the petitioner‟s own results
which did not satisfy the qualifying requirements, including his Small
Class rounds which were below the notified minimum height of 1.30
m, one of which, on 18.07.2026, carried 12 penalties and was
consequently not counted. Therefore, it is prayed that the present
petition be dismissed.
18.
This Court has heard arguments addressed on behalf of the
petitioner as well as the respondents, and has perused the material
available on record.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
19.
The principal issue which arises for consideration, on the basis
of case put forth by the petitioner, is whether the Selection
Committee, while undertaking the fresh selection, correctly applied
the notified Selection Criteria to the performances of the eligible
riders, and whether the Selection Committee rightly assessed the
relevant parameters, particularly, the consistency of performance and
recency of results. The question before this Court is also whether the
Selection Committee was required to adopt the method suggested by
the petitioner, i.e. to take into account every performance during the
relevant period, and/or assess the riders on the basis of their average
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
penalty points.
20.
Before examining the rival contentions, it would be appropriate
to take note of the successive communications through which the
Selection Criteria were placed before the eligible riders. The criteria
dated 08.05.2026 sets out the following parameters:
●
●
●
●
●
21.
Technical difficulty and level of competitions completed
Consistency of international performance
Recency of results relative to YOG 2026
Horse–rider combination stability
Championship readiness
Thereafter, the email dated 10.06.2026 stipulated that the final
selection would be based on the following:
“3. The final selection of the rider who will represent India at
the Youth Olympic Games 2026 will be based on an objective
assessment of recent performances, consistency of results,
competitiveness at CSI1*/CSI2* events, and overall merit.”
22.
The subsequent email dated 10.07.2026 clarified that –
CSI1/2* with minimum 130 cm height only will be considered for
MER‟s / performance consistency.
23.
In the opinion of this Court, a conjoint reading of the aforesaid
shows that the selection was to be based on the technical difficulty
and level of the competitions, consistency of international
performance, recency of results, horse–rider combination stability,
championship readiness, competitiveness at CSI 1*/2* events and
overall merit. However, the criteria does not prescribe any particular
formula for assessing these factors. Though the criteria identifies the
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
relevant factors for assessment, it, evidently, leaves it to the wisdom
of the experts of the Selection Committee to determine the manner in
which those factors are to be evaluated and weighed.
24.
This Court notes that the initial grievance of the petitioner was
directed against Selection Decision-I. According to the petitioner,
although the email dated 10.07.2026 prescribed a minimum height of
130 cm, the Selection Committee had also considered results at 135
cm and had accorded preference to the higher-height results. It was
on this basis that respondent no. 3 was placed at rank no. 1,
respondent no. 4 at rank no. 2, and the petitioner at rank no. 3 since
the petitioner had not participated in any 135 cm event during the
relevant period, i.e., from 08.05.2026 to 25.07.2026. The petitioner
accordingly had approached this Court by way of W.P.(C)
11935/2026. During the subsequent reconsideration by the Selection
Committee, the Selection Decision-I was reviewed and it was decided
that equal weightage would be given to results at both 130 cm and
135 cm. Thus, the earlier distinction between the two categories, to
the extent it had resulted in preference being given to 135 cm results,
was removed while passing the Selection Decision-II.
25.
In the Selection Decision-II, as regards the submission that
only 130 cm results should be considered, it was specifically
observed that the email dated 10.07.2026 used the expression
“minimum height of 130 cm”. The expression “minimum” indicates
the lower qualifying limit; it does not mean that results at no height
other than 130 cm could be considered. Consequently, in the fresh
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
selection, the Selection Committee considered the qualifying results
of all eligible riders in both the 130 cm and 135 cm categories,
without according preference to either category. On this basis, the
petitioner was found to have four qualifying results, whereas
respondent no. 3 was found to have five qualifying results.
26.
The issue, therefore, is now whether the fresh assessment, as
undertaken, was consistent with the notified Selection Criteria of the
EFI.
27.
One of the arguments of the petitioner is that, while assessing
consistency and recent performance, the Selection Committee ought
to have considered all performances during the relevant period,
including those in which the rider had secured more than eight
penalty points. In support of this submission, the petitioner has
pointed out that, out of his five results in the 130 cm category during
the relevant period, he had secured not more than eight penalty points
in each event. It is further pointed out that respondent no. 3 had six
results in the 130 cm and 135 cm categories, out of which two results
involved more than eight penalty points.
28.
This contention, however, overlooks the Selection Criteria
dated 08.05.2026, which contemplated the consideration of
qualifying performances and did not include scores involving more
than eight penalty points. The Selection Committee applied this
requirement uniformly to all the eligible riders. Thus, such scores
were not excluded only in the case of respondent no. 3, but were not
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
considered in the case of any athlete. Therefore, the said argument is
not of any help to the petitioner.
29.
The petitioner has raised another principal objection to the
manner in which the comparative merit of the riders was assessed.
According to the petitioner, even if the five qualifying scores of
respondent no. 3 and the four qualifying scores of the petitioner are
taken into consideration, consistency and merit cannot be assessed
merely on the basis of the number of qualifying scores. It is
contended that the penalty points secured in each of the qualifying
events must be considered and that the average of such penalty points
should be taken into account for assessing the consistency of recent
performances. The petitioner has illustrated this submission by
referring to the penalty points secured by the two riders in their
respective qualifying events. According to the petitioner, he secured
4, 0, 6 and 4 penalty points in his four qualifying events, aggregating
to 14 penalty points. The average would, therefore, be 3.5 penalty
points per event. Respondent no. 3, on the other hand, secured 8, 4, 0,
6 and 4 penalty points in his five qualifying events, aggregating to 22
penalty points, resulting in an average of 4.4 penalty points per event.
It is, therefore, contended that, if the average penalty points are taken
into consideration, the petitioner would have a better record than
respondent no. 3, and this should be the method for assessing the
eligible riders, and not just the number of events/rounds in which
they secured qualifying scores.
30.
This Court has already taken note of the Selection Criteria
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
dated 08.05.2026 and the subsequent emails dated 10.06.2026 and
10.07.2026. The criteria inter alia referred to technical difficulty and
the level of competitions completed, consistency of international
performance, recency of results relative to YOG 2026, championship
readiness, and overall merit. It is however significant to note that
none of these communications states that the average of penalty
points secured by a rider in the qualifying events would be the basis
for determining consistency or comparative merit. There is also no
stipulation that the rider securing the lowest average penalty points
would necessarily be placed above a rider who had secured a greater
number of qualifying results. The criteria does not prescribe any
particular method/formula, weighting or comparative index for
assessing consistency or overall merit.
31.
The petitioner‟s proposed method may certainly be one
possible method of assessing the performances of riders. However,
clearly, the expressions “consistency of international performance” or
“recency of results” are broad enough in scope. Consistency may be
assessed by considering the number of qualifying performances, the
level and difficulty of the events, the ability to repeatedly complete
qualifying rounds, the recency of such performances, the height at
which the performances were achieved, and the overall record of the
horse–rider
combination.
Similarly,
“overall
merit”
cannot
necessarily be reduced to a single numerical calculation.
32.
For instance, a rider who secures four qualifying results with a
lower average of penalty points, say 2 points, may not, on that sole
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
ground, be considered more suitable than a rider who secures eight
qualifying results with a slightly higher average of penalty points, say
4 points. As to which factor should carry greater weight is a matter
which requires knowledge of the sport, its technical demands and the
requirements of the particular championship.
33.
Likewise, the number of qualifying performances and the
ability to produce such performances repeatedly, in separate
international events in different countries, may also be relevant
considerations while assessing the suitability of a rider for a
particular championship, which evidently, found favour with the
Selection Committee which passed the impugned Selection DecisionII.
34.
The Selection Committee was constituted to assess the
comparative merit and suitability of the riders for representing the
country at YOG 2026. The members of such a Committee are
expected to possess the requisite knowledge and experience of the
sport. The criteria laid down by EFI identify the broad factors to be
considered, but leave the assessment of those factors to the experts in
the Committee. The Court cannot assume that, merely because one
method of assessment, as suggested by the petitioner, is possible, the
Selection Committee was bound to adopt that method only.
35.
In this regard, it is also necessary to bear in mind the limited
scope of judicial review in matters involving the selection of
sportspersons to represent the country. A Court of law is not an
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
expert in equestrian sport. It also does not possess the technical
knowledge required to determine whether consistency is better
assessed by the number of qualifying performances, the average
penalty points, the level of the competitions, the height of the course,
or a combination of these factors. These are matters which fall within
the domain of the Selection Committee and the sports authorities.
36.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held that a Court
exercising judicial review does not sit as an appellate authority over
the decision of a duly constituted Selection Committee and cannot
substitute its own assessment of the comparative merit of candidates.
In Union Public Service Commission v. M. Sathiya Priya: (2018) 15
SCC 796, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that the manner in which
candidates are assessed in the light of the relevant records and the
norms to be applied in making the assessment are matters for the
Selection Committee, which possesses the requisite expertise, and
interference by courts is warranted only where the process of
assessment is vitiated by bias, mala fides or arbitrariness.
37.
Likewise, in Tajvir Singh Sodhi v. State of Jammu &
Kashmir: (2023) 17 SCC 147, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court reiterated
that it is not appropriate for courts to substitute their judgment for
that of an expert selection body, and the Courts cannot enter into the
merits of the selection process unless there are proven allegations of
malfeasance or violation of statutory rules, in cases of inherent
arbitrariness. The relevant observations are as under:
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
“37. Thus, courts while exercising the power of judicial review
cannot step into the shoes of the Selection Committee or
assume an appellate role to examine whether the marks
awarded by the Selection Committee in the viva voce are
excessive and not corresponding to their performance in such
test. The assessment and evaluation of the performance of
candidates appearing before the Selection Committee/Interview Board should be best left to the members of the
committee. In light of the position that a Court cannot sit in
appeal against the decision taken pursuant to a reasonably
sound selection process, the following grounds raised by the
writ petitioners, which are based on an attack of subjective
criteria employed by the Selection Board/interview panel in
assessing the suitability of candidates, namely, (i) that the
candidates who had done their postgraduation had been
awarded 10 marks and in the viva voce, such PG candidates
had been granted either 18 marks or 20 marks out of 20; (i) that
although the writ petitioners had performed exceptionally well
in the interview, the authorities had acted in an arbitrary
manner while carrying out the selection process, would not
hold any water.
38.
The same principle has been applied by this Court in matters
concerning the selection of sportspersons. In Shumel v. Union of
India: 2010 SCC OnLine Del 4706, it was held that, in matters
concerning the selection of the best possible candidate to represent
India in an international sporting event, the Court ought not to
interfere with the selection criteria laid down by the concerned
National Sports Federation. The decision as to how the relative merits
of different candidates are to be evaluated is best left to the experts.
39.
The aforesaid principle was reiterated in Sushil Kumar v.
Union of India: 2016 SCC OnLine Del 3660, wherein this Court held
that a writ court would not interfere with the exercise of discretion by
a National Sports Federation or substitute its own judgment, except
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
where the discretion is shown to have been exercised in an arbitrary,
capricious or perverse manner, or contrary to settled principles or
practices.
40.
In Sujeet v. Union of India: 2023 SCC OnLine Del 5801, this
Court observed as under:
“17. It is well settled that writ courts must not substitute their
opinions to the opinions arrived at by the experts unless the
court is satisfied that the decision taken by the experts is
perverse or illegal. The function of the Court is only to see that
the decision has been arrived at in a good faith and the experts
have acted reasonably. It is not the function of the courts to sit
in judgment over the decision arrived at by the experts, if the
said decision has been taken in good faith and is not perverse,
as it would be risky for the Courts to tread an unknown path
while upsetting such decisions.”
41.
Recently, the Division Bench of this Court in Anush
Agarwalla v. Ad-Hoc Committee for Governance of Equestrian
Federation of India and Others: 2026 SCC OnLine Del 4965 has
observed that Courts do not sit in appeal over the decisions of
selection committees, nor do they reassess the relative merits of
candidates. The relevant observations are set out below:
“32. It is well settled that Courts do not sit in appeal over the
decisions of selection committees, nor do they reassess the
relative merits of candidates. The determination as to who
should represent the country in an international sporting event
is ordinarily best left to experts in the field. In matters
concerning selection for international competitive events, the
Court would not ordinarily interfere with the selection criteria
framed by the concerned expert body, or with the manner in
which relative merit is evaluated, unless the decision is shown
to be arbitrary, irrational, perverse or contrary to law.”
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
42.
The above principles are applicable in the present case too, as
it concerns the selection of a rider to represent the country at an
international sporting event. The task of the Court, while adjudicating
upon a challenge to the decision of the Selection Committee, is
primarily to examine that the Selection Committee acts within the
framework of the criteria and does not act arbitrarily or with mala
fides. Undisputedly, it is not the function of the Court to determine
which of two or more reasonable/possible methods of assessing
sporting merit is preferable.
43.
In the present case, the Selection Committee, while passing the
impugned Selection Decision-II, considered the qualifying results of
the eligible riders in the 130 cm and 135 cm categories and did not
accord preference to one height over the other. It applied the
qualifying threshold uniformly and considered the number of
qualifying performances achieved by the riders, 130 cm and 135 cm
categories, between 08.05.2026 and 25.07.2026. Pertinently, the
petitioner also does not contend that the qualifying threshold was
applied differently to different riders. The petitioner‟s grievance is
essentially that performances which were otherwise qualifying should
have been further compared by adopting a particular mathematical
method, i.e. average of penalties. In this Court‟s view, this argument
of the petitioner is a challenge to the manner in which the Selection
Committee weighed the relevant factors, rather than a demonstration
that the Committee ignored the notified Selection Criteria altogether.
44.
On a broad assessment of the record placed before this Court,
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
this Court finds that the Selection Committee did not disregard the
criteria dated 08.05.2026 or the subsequent clarifications dated
10.06.2026 and 10.07.2026. The petitioner has not been able to
demonstrate that the Committee adopted a method which was
expressly prohibited by the criteria, or applied a different standard to
respondent no. 3, or excluded any relevant factor in a manner which
rendered the decision manifestly arbitrary or perverse.
45.
It is also not in dispute that the selection criteria were not
challenged by any of the athletes, including petitioner, before the
selection process was undertaken. All the eligible riders participated
in the process with complete knowledge of the selection criteria. The
petitioner cannot, after the outcome of the process, seek to replace the
notified criteria with a different method of assessment merely
because the latter may produce a result more favourable to him.
46.
This Court is also conscious that even if the petitioner may
have raised his grievance bona fide and that the selection has serious
consequences for his opportunity to represent the country,
nevertheless, a writ court has to examine only the legality of the
decision-making process and not undertake a fresh assessment of the
comparative sporting merit of the riders. The Court cannot enter into
the technical question of whether the average of penalty points is a
better indicator of consistency than the number of qualifying
performances. That question falls within the expertise of the
Selection Committee.
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
47.
To conclude, the material placed before the Court does not
establish that the impugned Selection Decision-II was mala fide,
arbitrary, perverse, contrary to the notified criteria or based on
irrelevant considerations. The Selection Committee had reconsidered
its earlier decision, heard the representations and submissions of the
concerned eligible riders/their parents, verified the results and
recorded its brief reasons. The recommendation was thereafter
accepted by the Ad-Hoc Committee of EFI. For the said reasons, this
Court finds no merit in the petitioner‟s challenge to the manner in
which the Selection Committee assessed the qualifying performances,
consistency and comparative merit of the riders.
48.
On the grounds raised in the present petition, the impugned
Selection Decision-II does not suffer from any legal infirmity
warranting interference by this Court.
49.
The petition is, accordingly, dismissed. Pending applications, if
any, also stand disposed of.
50.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
SEPTEMBER 17, 2026/A
W.P.(C) 12662/2026
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
20:41:13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review