Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment Reserved on: 22.09.2026
Judgment Delivered on: 24.09.2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010452752026
+
LPA 761/2026, CM APPL. 65152/2026 & CM APPL. 65153/2026
MASTER SHUBH CHOWDHARI
THROUGH HIS FATHER
....Appellant
versus
EQUESTRIAN FEDERATION OF INDIA & ORS. ...Respondents
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Appellant
: Ms. Manini Brar with Mr. O.P. Harsh Singh
Munday and Mr. Siddhant Chhabra,
Advocates.
For the Respondents :
Mr. Tanmaya Mehta, Ms. Niyati Kohli, Mr.
Rishabh Parikh, Mr. Pinank Mehra and Ms.
Isha Kakkar, Advocates for R-1&2.
Mr. Kartik Yadav, Ms. Sumedha Chadha,
Mr. Duvva Pawan Kumar, Mr. Sai Krishna
Kumar and Ms. Shradha Gupta, Advocates
for R-3.
Mr. Kapil Modi with Mr. Shiv Verma and
Mr. Shorya Goel, Advocates for R-4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
JUDGMENT
TEJAS KARIA, J
1.
The present Appeal has been preferred by the Appellant challenging
the judgment dated 17.09.2026 (“Impugned Judgment”) rendered in
W.P.(C) 12662/2026 (“Writ Petition”), whereby the Writ Petition preferred
by the Appellant was dismissed.
FACTUAL MATRIX
2.
Respondent No. 1, the Ad Hoc Committee has been entrusted with the
governance of the Equestrian Federation of India (“EFI”), the National
Federation responsible for conducting national-level selections for
participation in international equestrian events, including Show Jumping at
the Youth Olympic Games, Dakar, Senegal, 2026 (“YOG 2026”).
Respondent No. 2, the Indian Olympic Association is responsible for
selecting athletes to represent India at the Olympic Games, Asian Games
and other international sports competitions, and managing Indian teams at
these events.
3.
On 08.05.2026, an information brochure was issued in respect of
YOG 2026. The brochure stipulated that the selection process would
commence with the notification of eligibility criteria by the Fédération
Équestre Internationale (“FEI”), and that entries from National Olympic
Committees were required to be received by 25.09.2026. Thereafter, the FEI
issued eligibility criteria for Show Jumping, requiring a rider to incur not
more than eight penalties in any one of the specified competitions to be
issued a Certificate of Capability (“COC”), which constituted a precondition
for participation in the national-level selection trials.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
4.
On 08.11.2025 and 10.11.2025, the Youth Olympics qualifying
rounds, namely Competition 3, Category A of the FEI Jumping World
Challenge, were conducted at Bengaluru, Karnataka, and Meerut, Uttar
Pradesh, respectively, on courses laid out in accordance with the FEI
Regulations, 2026 (“Regulations”). Six of the seven riders who obtained
COCs, including the Appellant, qualified in these rounds based on a
minimum jump height of 130 cm. The Appellant was issued a COC dated
20.05.2026 based on his result at Bengaluru, Karnataka, on 08.11.2025. The
COC, bearing the signature of the President of EFI, was received by him on
10.06.2026.
5.
On 08.05.2026, EFI uploaded on its website the selection criteria for
YOG 2026 (“Selection Criteria”). Clause 5 thereof provided that, where
more than one athlete obtained a valid COC within the FEI deadline, EFI
would assess the athletes with reference to the technical difficulty and level
of competitions completed, consistency of international performance,
recency of results relative to YOG 2026, stability of the horse-rider
combination, and championship readiness. On 20.05.2026, the FEI
confirmed that seven Indian riders, including the Appellant, had obtained
valid COCs for YOG 2026.
6.
By e-mail dated 10.06.2026 (“E-mail”), EFI informed the seven
riders holding valid COCs that they had been included in the long list of
riders under consideration for YOG 2026. The riders were required to
submit their latest competition results and performance records by
25.07.2026. The E-mail further stated that the final selection would be based
on an objective assessment of recent performances, consistency of results,
competitiveness at CSI1*/CSI2* events, and overall merit.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
7.
By e-mail dated 10.07.2026 (“Clarification E-mail”), EFI issued a
clarification to the Selection Criteria, stating that only results obtained at
CSI1*/CSI2* events at a minimum height of 130 cm would be considered
for MER and performance consistency.
8.
Between 12.07.2026 and 19.07.2026, the Appellant participated in the
Portugal Summer Tour 2026 at Esposende, Portugal, in the Medium Class
(130 cm) category and completed five rounds.
9.
On 17.07.2026, EFI constituted a Show Jumping Selection Committee
(“Selection Committee”). Prior to the cut-off date of 25.07.2026, the
Appellant submitted the aforesaid results to the Selection Committee,
together with a performance summary addressing recency, consistency,
competitiveness at the CSI2* level, and overall merit, including his earlier
shortlisting to represent India at the Asian Youth Games 2025, Bahrain.
10.
On 06.08.2026, the Selection Committee rendered its decision
(“Selection Decision I”), placing Respondent No. 3, Mr. Shresht Raju
Mantena, at Rank No. 1; Respondent No. 4, Ms. Vaasvi Khaitan, at Rank
No. 2; and the Appellant at Rank No. 3, by giving priority to results at 135
cm over those at 130 cm. On 10.08.2026, Selection Decision I and the
announcement of selection were uploaded on EFI’s website. Aggrieved
thereby, the Appellant instituted W.P.(C) No. 11935/2026 on 14.08.2026.
11.
On 16.08.2026, EFI issued a notification (“Addendum”) titled
“Addendum to the Selection of One Show Jumping Rider to Represent India
at the Youth Olympic Games”, recording its intention to reconsider Selection
Decision I.
12.
Vide order dated 18.08.2026 passed in W.P.(C) No. 11935/2026, the
learned Single Judge recorded the submission on behalf of EFI that the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
Appellant’s representation was pending, as well as the Appellant’s
contention that the Selection Committee had not been properly constituted.
EFI was directed to decide the representation within two weeks and
communicate the decision to the Appellant. It was further directed that, if
the representation were decided against the Appellant, the names of the
other applicants would be withheld for three days to enable him to institute a
fresh writ petition. The said writ petition was disposed of in the aforesaid
terms, with liberty reserved to the Appellant to approach the Court again in
the event of any further grievance.
13.
Following the order dated 18.08.2026, the strength of the Selection
Committee was increased from three members to five. The Appellant
thereafter submitted a representation dated 19.08.2026 (“Representation”)
to the Selection Committee, referring to the Selection Criteria and the emails dated 10.06.2026 and 10.07.2026. Between 21.08.2026 and
25.08.2026, correspondence was exchanged concerning the grant of a
personal hearing to the Appellant before the Selection Committee.
14.
As recorded in the Minutes dated 24.08.2026 (“Minutes”), the
Selection Committee adopted the period from 08.05.2026 to 25.07.2026 for
assessing the results of the eligible riders. On 24.08.2026, the window for
EFI to notify India’s selection to the FEI commenced; the said window
closes on 25.09.2026.
15.
On 24.08.2026, the Appellant’s father, Mr. Kunal Chowdhari,
appeared before the Selection Committee, relied upon the Representation,
and requested that his son be selected as the principal rider on the basis of
merit.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
16.
On 27.08.2026, EFI issued Selection Decision II (“Selection Decision
II”), which was communicated to the Appellant and the other participating
athletes. Thereunder, Respondent No. 3 was placed at Rank No. 1, the
Appellant at Rank No. 2, and Respondent No. 4 at Rank No. 3. Selection
Decision II accorded equal weightage to results at 130 cm and 135 cm.
17.
Aggrieved by Selection Decision II, the Appellant instituted the Writ
Petition on 29.08.2026, challenging the said decision. Vide the Impugned
Judgment, the learned Single Judge dismissed the Writ Petition upon
holding that Selection Decision II was neither mala fide, arbitrary, perverse,
nor contrary to the notified criteria, and that no legal infirmity warranting
interference had been established. Aggrieved by the Impugned Judgment,
the Appellant preferred the present Appeal.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
18.
Ms. Manini Brar, learned Counsel for the Appellant made the
following submissions:
18.1. The Impugned Judgment failed to adjudicate the principal issue
raised by the Appellant that whether Selection Decision II was
rendered in conformity with the Selection Criteria notified by EFI.
Once notified, the Selection Criteria were required to be applied
strictly by assessing the consistency of each rider’s latest results
with reference to the lowest number of penalties incurred. They
could not be altered during the course of the selection process to
substitute a criterion based solely on the number of rounds
attempted, irrespective of the penalties incurred.
18.2. The Selection Criteria were notified in three stages. Clause 5 of
the Selection Criteria uploaded on EFI’s website on 08.05.2026
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
provided that, where more than one athlete held a valid COC, EFI
would assess the athletes based on technical difficulty,
consistency of international performance, recency of results,
stability of the horse-rider combination, and championship
readiness. The E-mail informed the riders that the final selection
would be based on an objective assessment of recent
performances,
consistency
of
results,
competitiveness
at
CSI1*/CSI2* events, and overall merit. The Clarification E-mail
further clarified that only results obtained at CSI1*/CSI2* events
at a minimum height of 130 cm would be considered. None of
these criteria refers to the number of rounds attempted.
18.3. The operative portion of Selection Decision II does not refer to
the Selection Criteria. Paragraph 5 of the Minutes, titled
“Proceedings 3 – Review of submissions and results”, contains
only a general reference to “overall merit”, which constitutes
merely one component of the notified criteria. No reasons have
been recorded for placing Respondent No. 3 at Rank No. 1, the
Appellant at Rank No. 2, or the remaining riders at their
respective ranks.
18.4. In Selection Decision I, Respondent No. 3 was ranked first on the
basis that results obtained at 135 cm were accorded precedence
over those obtained at 130 cm, notwithstanding that the jump
height at YOG 2026 is fixed. The Appellant challenged Selection
Decision I in W.P.(C) 11935/2026, following which EFI
reconsidered the selection. Although EFI accepted in Selection
Decision II that priority could not be accorded based on jump
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
height, Respondent No. 3 was again placed at Rank No. 1 after
excluding his results carrying penalties of 20 and 12 points.
18.5. Without recording any explanation, EFI excluded Respondent No.
3’s result dated 21.06.2026 in the CSI1* Grand Prix at Cluny at
135 cm, in which he incurred 20 penalties, as well as his result
dated 27.06.2026 in the CSI1* Gold Tour at Budapest, Hungary at
135 cm, in which he incurred 12 penalties (4+8). Both were
completed rounds at the CSI1* level and above the prescribed
minimum height of 130 cm. Completion of the 20-penalty round
is further evident from the video of that round placed on record.
In contrast, the Appellant did not incur more than eight penalties
in any of the five results obtained by him at 130 cm in Esposende,
Portugal, between 12.07.2026 and 19.07.2026.
18.6. The consistency of recent results could not be assessed without
considering all results obtained during the period from 08.05.2026
to 25.07.2026, being the assessment period fixed by the Selection
Committee itself. EFI could not selectively exclude the
unfavourable results of Respondent No. 3 while relying upon his
remaining results to place him above the Appellant.
18.7. The learned Single Judge erred in holding that the Selection
Criteria contemplated only results involving not more than eight
penalty points. No such limitation forms part of the Selection
Criteria. The eight-penalty threshold applies exclusively at the
eligibility stage for obtaining a COC. At the selection stage, all
results were required to be considered, as only such a
comprehensive assessment could determine a rider’s consistency.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
Selection Decision II could not rely upon the FEI eligibility
standard, which serves a purpose distinct from that of the
Selection Criteria.
18.8. The learned Single Judge further erred in holding that a rider
securing the lowest average penalty points need not necessarily
rank above a rider having a greater number of qualifying results.
Under the Regulations, every rider negotiates a fixed course of the
same height and length on a single occasion and is ranked first by
penalties and thereafter by time. Since penalties determine the
winner at the Games, the rider selected to represent India ought to
be the rider with the lowest overall penalties, namely, the lowest
average. Consistency could not be assessed by counting
“qualifying results”, as no such concept appears in the Selection
Criteria and each course at the Games may be attempted only
once.
18.9. The number of rounds attempted could not have been accorded
priority because: (i) the riders were neither required to submit, nor
did they submit, a fixed number of results capable of enabling a
“best of” comparison; (ii) the number of rounds was never
notified as a selection criterion; and (iii) at YOG 2026, each rider
is permitted only one attempt at the course in each competition,
rendering the number of rounds irrelevant. Had the Appellant
been informed that the number of rounds would be preferred over
consistency measured by penalties and time, he could have
submitted results from additional rounds, including those
involving higher penalties, as Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 had done.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
Instead, in accordance with the notified Selection Criteria, the
Appellant submitted his latest results carrying low penalties to
demonstrate consistency.
18.10. Even on the basis of the results considered in Selection Decision
II, Respondent No. 3 incurred 22 penalties across five rounds (8,
4, 0, 6 and 4), resulting in an average of 4.4 penalties per round.
The Appellant incurred 14 penalties across four rounds (4, 0, 6
and 4), resulting in an average of 3.5 penalties per round. The
Appellant, therefore, incurred fewer penalties and demonstrated
greater consistency and ought consequently to have been placed at
Rank No. 1.
18.11. The explanations given by EFI neither formed part of Selection
Decision II nor found support in the record. Selection Decision II
was required to be assessed solely based on the reasons recorded
therein and not on supplementary reasons subsequently advanced.
In any event:
i.
It is incorrect that Respondent No. 3 competed at a higher
technical level. Under the FEI Jumping Rules, technical
difficulty is set by the CSI level, CSI5* being highest and
CSI1* lowest. The Appellant’s results were at CSI2*, while
Respondent No. 3’s were at CSI1*. ‘Grand Prix’ only
describes the final-day event with higher prize money and
has nothing to do with technical difficulty.
ii.
The contention that Respondent No. 3 competed more often
at 135 cm is irrelevant, since priority to height was never a
criterion. Selection Decision II itself records equal
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
weightage to 130cm and 135cm. Giving priority to height
was the very reason the Appellant challenged Selection
Decision I in W.P.(C) 11935/2026 and for which EFI
reconsidered Selection Decision I.
iii.
The contention that Respondent No. 3 performed better in a
common competition is also irrelevant, since this was never
a criterion. Had it been, all riders would have had to
compete in the same events. In fact, on 24.08.2026, a
proposal that the top three riders compete in one common
event was rejected, since some riders were based in India
and some abroad.
18.12. Selection Decision II disregarded the criteria actually notified,
namely,
merit,
competitiveness,
technical
difficulty,
and
consistency. The Appellant competed at a higher technical level
and incurred fewer penalties than Respondent No. 3. In terms of
overall merit, the Appellant was the only rider under consideration
to have been shortlisted for the Asian Youth Games 2025,
Bahrain, and was recommended to EFI by the Portugal Equestrian
Federation following his performance at Esposende, Portugal.
18.13. Clause 33.3 of the Interim Constitution of EFI (“Interim
Constitution”), relied upon by EFI its reply before the learned
Single Judge, mandates that objective criteria be published in
advance. In Chirag Khandal v. Equestrian Federation of India
& Ors., Neutral Citation: 2023:DHC:2254, this Court held that
selection norms cannot be altered after the commencement of the
selection process. The introduction, after the competitions had
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
concluded and the results had been submitted, of the number of
rounds as a ranking criterion amounted to changing the rules of
the game after the game had been played.
18.14. In Manjeet v. Indian Olympic Association & Ors., 2026 SCC
OnLine Del 362, this Court held that a selecting body cannot
assume the role of a “Super Selector” by devising criteria
extraneous to the governing qualification system. By applying a
criterion absent from both the Selection Criteria and the
Regulations, EFI acted as a “Super Selector”.
18.15. The retrospective and undisclosed application of the number of
rounds as the determinative criterion violated the principles of
natural justice and resulted in unequal treatment of similarly
situated riders, without any rational nexus to the object of the
selection. Had the Appellant been informed, at any stage prior to
the selection, that a criterion other than those notified would be
treated as determinative, he could have submitted his results
accordingly. The deprivation of that opportunity caused
irreversible prejudice to the Appellant.
18.16. Following the institution of W.P.(C) No. 11935/2026 by the
Appellant, the strength of the Selection Committee was increased
from three members to five. Neither the reason for, nor the
authority under which, such enlargement was effected is apparent,
and the reconstituted Selection Committee was not constituted in
accordance with the rules governing EFI.
18.17. Respondent No. 3, who was placed at Rank No. 1 in both
Selection Decisions I and II, is associated with a major corporate
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
group that sponsors show jumping competitions and owns horses
and stables. It was submitted that these circumstances indicate
that Selection Decision II was directed towards securing the
selection of Respondent No. 3, rather than identifying the most
meritorious rider, and was therefore arbitrary and mala fide.
Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 were impleaded only because the
outcome of the proceedings affects them; no personal allegations
were made against either of them.
18.18. The relief sought by the Appellant does not necessitate a fresh
competition. The results of all riders were submitted before the
cut-off date of 25.07.2026 and have already been verified against
the FEI database. The exercise required is limited to assessing
those results in accordance with the Selection Criteria and ranking
the riders by reference to consistency of performance, measured
based on penalties incurred in the latest competitions.
18.19. The window within which EFI is required to notify its selection to
the FEI commenced on 24.08.2026 and closes on 25.09.2026.
Once the selection is notified to the FEI, it cannot be altered save
in the event of illness or injury of the selected rider. The
impending deadline therefore warrants expeditious completion of
the limited exercise sought by the Appellant and does not
constitute a ground for declining relief.
18.20. Accordingly, the Impugned Judgment and Selection Decision II
are liable to be set aside, and the Appellant ought to be declared
first in the order of merit under the Selection Criteria.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF EFI
19.
Mr. Tanmaya Mehta, learned Counsel for EFI made the following
submissions:
19.1. The selection of sportspersons to represent the country falls
within the exclusive domain of the National Sports Federation and
its duly constituted expert Selection Committee. In the exercise of
its writ jurisdiction, this Court does not sit in appeal over the
assessment of comparative sporting merit made by such experts,
nor may it substitute its own evaluation for theirs. Judicial
interference is warranted only where the selection process is
shown to be mala fide, perverse, arbitrary, or contrary to binding
criteria. None of these grounds is established in the present case.
In support of the aforesaid proposition, reliance was placed upon
the following decisions:
i. Dalpat Abasaheb Solunke v. B.S. Mahajan, (1990) 1 SCC
305;
ii. Basavaiah v. H.L. Ramesh, (2010) 8 SCC 372; and
iii. Sushil Kumar v. Union of India, 2016 SCC OnLine Del 3660.
19.2. Selection
Decision
II
was
rendered
following
a
fair
reconsideration undertaken pursuant to the order dated 18.08.2026
in W.P.(C) No. 11935/2026, whereby EFI was directed to decide
the Appellant’s Representation within two weeks and, in the event
of an adverse decision, to withhold disclosure of the names of the
other riders for three days. Even prior to the said order, the Ad
Hoc Committee had suspended Selection Decision I by issuing
the Addendum and had invited representations from all riders.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
19.3. On 24.08.2026, the Selection Committee heard the Appellant’s
father and the representatives of the other riders, considered the
written representations, including that of the Appellant, verified
each rider’s results against the FEI database, and recorded its
reasons in the Minutes of the same date. The Ad Hoc Committee
accepted the recommendation by Resolution dated 27.08.2026,
communicated the decision to all COC holders, and withheld its
public disclosure for three days.
19.4. The contention that Selection Decision II is unreasoned is without
merit. The Minutes record the assessment window, the heights
and formats considered, the treatment accorded to two-phase
competitions, and the order of merit, together with each rider’s
qualifying performances.
19.5. The Appellant does not dispute the Selection Criteria dated
08.05.2026, 10.06.2026, and 10.07.2026, and has himself relied
upon them as the governing criteria. The Selection Committee
applied those criteria on 24.08.2026. Having never challenged their
validity, the Appellant cannot be permitted to do so at this stage.
19.6. Nothing in the Selection Criteria provides that riders are to be
ranked by calculating the arithmetic average of their penalties. It
is the Appellant, rather than EFI, who seeks to introduce an
unnotified criterion derived from the competition format of the
Games themselves.
19.7. The notified criterion is consistency, which necessarily connotes
the repetition of a standard of performance across competitions.
Consistency cannot be assessed based on a solitary result or by
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
employing an average that rewards a rider for competing on fewer
occasions. The Appellant himself pleaded before the learned
Single Judge that “consistency of performance essentially means
repeatedly low penalties, at or below 8 points”. The Selection
Committee applied precisely that standard, based on which
Respondent No. 3 recorded a greater number of qualifying
performances than the Appellant.
19.8. The Selection Committee adopted a clear methodology: (i) it
fixed the assessment period from 08.05.2026, when the Selection
Criteria were published, to 25.07.2026, the cut-off date, while also
taking into account each rider’s COC result; (ii) it considered all
results at CSI1*/CSI2* level and above, at heights of 130 cm and
above, according equal weightage to results at 130 cm and 135 cm
and thereby accepting the Appellant’s objection to Selection
Decision I; (iii) it excluded two-phase competitions in which a
rider completed only the first phase; (iv) it treated a completed
round involving not more than eight penalties as a qualifying
performance, consistently with the FEI standard for issuance of a
COC and the standard relied upon by the Appellant himself; and
(v) it verified every rider’s results against the FEI database. This
methodology was applied uniformly to all seven COC holders. On
that basis, Respondent No. 3
recorded
five qualifying
performances, the Appellant four, and Respondent No. 4 three. As
a direct consequence of the reconsideration, the Appellant
advanced from third position in Selection Decision I to second
position in Selection Decision II.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
19.9. The grievance concerning the exclusion of Respondent No. 3’s
20-penalty result in the Grand Prix at Cluny is untenable, since a
round carrying 20 penalties did not qualify under the standard
applied to any rider. Similarly, the Appellant’s own nonqualifying results, including two-phase rounds in which he
completed only the first phase, were excluded. The Appellant
cannot seek the exclusion of his own non-qualifying results while
simultaneously insisting upon the inclusion of the non-qualifying
results of Respondent No. 3.
19.10. The Appellant’s computation of average penalties is self-serving.
It considers only four rounds carrying an aggregate of 14
penalties, while omitting his own eight-penalty round. In his
Representation, the Appellant had himself calculated five rounds
carrying an aggregate of 22 penalties, yielding an average of 4.4
penalties per round, the very figure he now attributes to
Respondent No. 3. The computation has thus varied across
pleadings, and, in any event, the methodology of averaging
penalties formed no part of the Selection Criteria.
19.11. The Appellant’s contention that he would have submitted
additional rounds is equally untenable. By the E-mail, all riders
were required to submit their latest results by 25.07.2026. In any
event, the Selection Committee did not confine itself to the results
submitted but verified each rider’s complete record against the
FEI database, which records every start by every rider. The
Appellant’s international results within the assessment period
were confined to a single tour at Esposende, Portugal. Respondent
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
No. 3, by contrast, competed in Italy, France, and Hungary, and
secured qualifying results at both 130 cm and 135 cm, including
in Grand Prix events. The Selection Committee was entitled to
regard these circumstances as demonstrating greater consistency,
competitiveness, and technical level, all of which formed part of
the notified criteria.
19.12. The allegations of bias and mala fides are unsupported by the
record. The Ad Hoc Committee functions under the supervision of
this Court and has no interest in the selection of any particular
rider. Although the Appellant’s achievements are matters of
record, they fall outside the relevant assessment period and are
not material to the criteria governing the present selection. The
averments concerning the family of Respondent No. 3 are
irrelevant, and the draft e-mail attributed to the Portugal
Equestrian Federation does not purport to recommend the
Appellant in preference to any other rider.
19.13. The Selection Committee was constituted in the ordinary course
by Resolution of the Ad Hoc Committee dated 17.07.2026. After
the Appellant objected on 18.08.2026 that it had not been properly
constituted, its strength was increased to five members, including
experienced riders and officials, so that the reconsideration could
be undertaken by a broader body. No rule requires the constitution
of a Selection Committee to be notified to riders in advance or
limits its membership to three persons. The Appellant
participated, through his father, in the proceedings before the
reconstituted Selection Committee without objecting to its
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
composition and cannot now assail that composition merely
because the outcome was adverse to him.
19.14. The reconsideration was sought by the Appellant himself through
W.P.(C) No. 11935/2026 and the Representation. He participated
in that process, and his objection to the preference accorded to
jump height was accepted. The purpose of the reconsideration was
to ensure that the rider selected to represent the country was
identified in accordance with the prescribed criteria and comparative
merit. Selection Decision II cannot be invalidated merely because
the ultimate outcome was not in the Appellant’s favour.
19.15. The decision in Manjeet (supra) is distinguishable, since it
concerned a selection contrary to a binding international qualification
system. In the present case, FEI itself clarified, by the e-mail
placed before the Selection Committee on 06.08.2026, that a COC
only creates a long list, and selection among COC holders is for
the country to decide. The Regulations for YOG 2026 govern the
competition at the games, not the criteria for national selection.
19.16. The assertion that Selection Decision II was intended to exclude
the Appellant is misconceived. The Appellant has been placed as
Reserve No. 1 and, under Paragraph 5(vii) of the Minutes, the
selected rider and both reserve riders are required to continue
competing and submitting their results to EFI until the Games,
thereby ensuring that the eventual representative remains in
suitable form. The Appellant’s prayer that he be declared the
selected rider is, therefore, untenable.
19.17. Accordingly, the present Appeal is liable to be dismissed.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
20.
We have heard learned Counsel for the Parties and perused the
material placed on record.
21.
The principal grievance urged by the Appellant is that Selection
Decision II ranked the riders by reference to the number of qualifying
performances recorded by each of them, although that consideration finds no
express mention in the Selection Criteria notified on 08.05.2026, 10.06.2026
and 10.07.2026. According to the Appellant, the riders ought instead to have
been ranked based on the average penalties incurred across the results
submitted by them.
22.
At the outset, it is necessary to distinguish the notified Selection
Criteria from the methodology adopted by the Selection Committee to
operationalise those criteria. The Selection Criteria notified on 08.05.2026
required an assessment of the technical difficulty and level of competitions
completed, consistency of international performance, recency of results
relative to YOG 2026, stability of the horse-rider combination, and
championship readiness. The E-mail informed riders holding valid COCs
that the final selection would be based on an objective assessment of recent
performances, consistency of results, competitiveness at CSI1*/CSI2*
events, and overall merit, and required the submission of results by
25.07.2026. The Clarification E-mail confined eligible results to those
obtained at CSI1*/CSI2* events at a minimum height of 130 cm. None of
these communications prescribed the precise assessment window, the
treatment of incomplete or two-phase rounds, or the penalty threshold by
which consistency was to be evaluated. The absence of such particulars does
not, however, render every subsequently adopted methodology impermissible.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
23.
The methodology actually adopted by the Selection Committee, as
recorded in the Minutes, comprised four components: first, an assessment
period extending from 08.05.2026 to 25.07.2026, together with the COC
result; second, equal weightage to results obtained at 130 cm and 135 cm,
thereby removing the earlier preference for greater height; third, exclusion
of two-phase competitions in which only the first phase had been completed;
and fourth, treatment of a completed round involving not more than eight
penalties as a qualifying performance, being the FEI standard for issuance of
a COC. This methodology was applied uniformly to all seven COC holders.
24.
As regards the assessment period, the Appellant does not dispute the
window from 08.05.2026 to 25.07.2026 and has himself relied upon it as the
period fixed by the Selection Committee. The E-mail, which informed the
riders of their inclusion in the long list and called for the submission of
results by 25.07.2026, was itself referable to the criteria published on
08.05.2026. The Appellant participated in that very process, competed at
Esposende, Portugal, between 12.07.2026 and 19.07.2026, and submitted
those results, together with a performance summary, before the cut-off date.
He cannot, therefore, now contend that the assessment period within which
he submitted his results was either unknown to him or arbitrarily fixed.
25.
As regards the threshold of eight penalties, the same was not
introduced for the first time in Selection Decision II. It is the very standard
upon which the Appellant relied, both in his Representation and in the
submissions advanced before us, wherein it was pleaded that consistency of
performance connotes repeatedly low penalties at or below eight points.
Having invoked that standard to demonstrate his own consistency, it is not
open to the Appellant to contend that its application for determining a
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
qualifying performance renders Selection Decision II arbitrary. The
submission that the threshold pertains exclusively to the eligibility stage is
equally unpersuasive, since the Selection Criteria do not preclude reliance
upon an established, objective external benchmark for assessing consistency
and championship readiness at the selection stage. More significantly, the
threshold was applied uniformly to every rider, including the Appellant,
whose own 12-penalty result dated 18.07.2026 was excluded on the same
basis. A standard applied without exception to all riders cannot be
characterised as one-sided.
26.
The central contention of the Appellant is that the riders ought to have
been ranked by average penalties rather than by the number of qualifying
performances. We are unable to accept this contention. Consistency
ordinarily denotes the repetition of a prescribed standard of performance
across a body of results; it cannot be reduced to an arithmetical average
derived from however few results a rider elects to submit. An average based
on a limited sample may unduly favour a rider who competes less
frequently. We also note that the Appellant’s own computation has not
remained consistent. In his Representation, he tabulated five results
aggregating 22 penalties, yielding an average of 4.4 penalties, which is the
very figure he now attributes to Respondent No. 3. Before us, however, he
relies upon four results aggregating 14 penalties, yielding an average of 3.5
penalties, after excluding one of his own results. This variation reinforces
our conclusion that the average urged by the Appellant is not an objective
standard emanating from the Selection Criteria, but a construct advanced to
support a particular outcome.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
27.
The reliance placed upon Manjeet (supra) and Chirag Khandal
(supra) does not advance the Appellant’s case. Manjeet (supra) concerned a
selecting body that departed from a binding international qualification
system and thereby assumed the role of a super selector. In the present case,
it is undisputed that the FEI itself clarified before the Selection Committee
on 06.08.2026 that COCs merely constitute a long list and that selection
from amongst COC holders rests with the National Federation. EFI was,
therefore, entitled to adopt a reasonable methodology within the framework
of the criteria already notified. Chirag Khandal (supra) proscribes alteration
of an existing criterion after commencement of the selection process. Here,
the notified criteria of recency, consistency, competitiveness, and overall
merit remained unchanged and were applied in Selection Decision II. The
assessment period, treatment of jump height, and qualifying threshold were
not new criteria superimposed upon the process, but constituted the manner
in which the notified criteria were operationalised, uniformly, in respect of
all seven riders.
28.
The grievance that Selection Decision II was devoid of reasons is not
borne out by the record. The Minutes specify the assessment period, the
heights and competition formats considered, the treatment of two-phase
competitions, and the order of merit, together with the number of qualifying
performances recorded by each rider. These particulars constitute an
adequate statement of reasons. To the extent that further explanations were
advanced for the first time before the learned Single Judge, we agree that
Selection Decision II must be tested on the basis of the reasons
contemporaneously recorded and not upon reasons subsequently supplied.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
Since the Minutes themselves disclose a sufficient basis for the ranking, this
principle does not assist the Appellant.
29.
As regards the enlargement of the Selection Committee from three
members to five, no material has been placed before us to demonstrate that
such enlargement contravened any provision of EFI’s Interim Constitution.
The Appellant has not relied upon any rule which either limits the strength
of the Selection Committee or requires its composition to be notified in
advance. The enlargement followed the Appellant’s own objection in
W.P.(C) No. 11935/2026 that the Selection Committee which rendered
Selection Decision I had not been properly constituted. The Appellant
thereafter participated, through his father, in the proceedings before the
reconstituted Selection Committee without raising any objection to its
composition. Having sought and participated in the reconsideration, he
cannot assail the composition of the Selection Committee merely because
the outcome was adverse to him.
30.
The principles governing the scope of judicial review in matters of
this nature are well settled. This Court in Anush Agarwalla v. Ad-Hoc
Committee for Governance of Equestrian Federation of India and Others,
2026 SCC OnLine Del 4965, held that it does not sit in appeal over the
assessment of an expert selection committee constituted to select
sportspersons to represent the country, nor may it substitute its own
evaluation of comparative sporting merit for that of the selectors.
Interference is warranted only where the selection is shown to be mala fide,
perverse, or contrary to criteria binding upon the selecting body. The
relevant extract from the said decision is reproduced hereunder:
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
“32. It is well settled that Courts do not sit in appeal over the
decisions of selection committees, nor do they reassess the relative
merits of candidates. The determination as to who should represent
the country in an international sporting event is ordinarily best left
to experts in the field. In matters concerning selection for
international competitive events, the Court would not ordinarily
interfere with the selection criteria framed by the concerned expert
body, or with the manner in which relative merit is evaluated, unless
the decision is shown to be arbitrary, irrational, perverse or
contrary to law.”
31.
For the reasons recorded hereinabove, none of these grounds is
established. The methodology adopted in Selection Decision II bears a
rational nexus to the notified Selection Criteria, was applied uniformly to all
seven
COC
holders,
and
is
supported
by
reasons
recorded
contemporaneously.
32.
We note that the Selection Criteria did not define the assessment
period or the qualifying threshold with precision, and that this lack of
specificity has occasioned repeated litigation between the Parties. That
circumstance, however, does not alter our conclusion that the selection is not
vitiated by any infirmity warranting judicial interference.
33.
An athlete representing the country at an international sporting event
must possess not only physical ability but also mental and emotional
fortitude. It is, therefore, incumbent upon the selecting body to ensure that
the selection process does not create avoidable uncertainty for the athletes
concerned. Disputes arising from ambiguity in that process may themselves
adversely affect an athlete’s preparation for the event. EFI shall,
accordingly, ensure that future selection criteria and timelines are framed
and implemented with sufficient clarity and precision to obviate disputes of
this nature.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
34.
For the foregoing reasons, we find no merit in the challenge to the
Impugned Judgment dated 17.09.2026. The learned Single Judge correctly
held that Selection Decision II was neither mala fide, arbitrary, perverse, nor
contrary to the notified criteria, and rightly declined to interfere therewith.
35.
Accordingly, the present Appeal is dismissed. All pending
Applications stand disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
TEJAS KARIA, J
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
SEPTEMBER 24, 2026
N / Sz
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
12:32:49
LPA 761/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review