Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment Reserved on: 15.12.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 19.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: As per digital signature~
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
Maruti Traders
..... Appellant
Versus
Itron India Pvt. Ltd.
..... Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Appellant :
Mr. Ramesh Singh, Sr. Adv. with
Ms.Monisha Handa, Ms. Hage Nanya
and Mr. Arnav Chaudhary, Advocates
For the Respondent :
Mr. Abhijit Mittal and Ms. Shaivya
Singh, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT
VINOD KUMAR, J.
1.
This appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act 1996 (hereinafter ‘the Act’) is directed against a
judgment dated 18.07.2024 passed by learned Single Judge in
OMP (COMM) 89/2024, vide which he dismissed the objections
filed by the appellant under Section 34 of the Act challenging the
Award dated 14.11.2023 published by the Arbitral Tribunal (in
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
short ‘AT’). For the sake of convenience the appellant would also
be referred to as ‘Maruti’ and respondent would also be referred
to as ‘Itron’.
DISPUTE
2.
The respondent-Itron is a company having its registered
office at Flat No. 507, Bhikaji Cama Bhawan, Bhikaji Cama
Place, New Delhi-110066. The appellant-Maruti Traders is a
proprietorship concern owned by Mr. Sanjeev Rungta, having its
registered office at 229, 2nd Floor, Rishabh Complex, MG Road,
Raipur, Chhattisgarh-492001. Respondent-Itron was desirous of
selling its products like water meter etc. in the territory of
Chhattisgarh and therefore it authorized appellant as non
exclusive Reseller for marketing and selling its products in the
territory of Chhattisgarh from time to time through four letters
dated 01.01.2009, 01.01.2010, 01.08.2011 and 01.01.2012. It
appears that the parties had some discussions about the
modalities of the business dealings between them which were
recorded in minutes of meeting dated 29.04.2017 held at Raipur.
Later on, a Reseller agreement back dated 01.02.2017 was sent
by Itron to Maruti for its sigantures. The clause 2.01 of the
agreement authorized Maruti as non exclusive Reseller for
marketing the products of Itron. Further Itron retained its right to
sell the products directly to customers within the territory and to
appoint other Resellers of the products. It appears that Maruti
was not happy with some of the clauses of the agreement
including clause 2.01. Therefore the appellant-Maruti on
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
16.08.2017 sent a letter through registered post objecting to
various clauses including clause 2.01. Itron remained silent on
this offer. The case of appellant-Maruti is that there was a clear
understanding between the parties that Itron’s products (mainly
the water meters) would be sold to various entities/contractors
through the appellant-Maruti for identified projects in the State of
Chhattisgarh. In other words, as per the appellant this was a
dealership agreement which required that respondent-Itron would
sell its products in the territory of Chhattisgarh through the
appellant-Maruti only for the agreed period between 01.02.2017
to 31.01.2020.
3.
The grievance of appellant-Maruti is that without a
mandatory notice for termination of the contract, respondentItron directly started selling its products to various entities for
projects/works identified by appellant-Maruti in the territory of
Chhattisgarh. Therefore, Maruti made a request to respondentItron to return legitimate share and anticipated returns to it under
the contract agreement. The respondent-Itron refused to return
and compensate the appellant-Maruti, which gave rise to this
dispute.
APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATOR
4.
The appellant invoked arbitration clause 27.01 of the
agreement vide its letter dated 29.11.2021. The arbitration clause
as contained in Reseller agreement dated 01.02.2017, is
reproduced as under:
"Clause 27-Arbitration
27.01 Any claims, dispute, difference or controversy
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
("Dispute") arising out of, or in relation to, this
Agreement, including any Dispute with respect to the
existence of validity hereof, the interpretation hereof, the
activities performed hereunder, the duties or obligations
of the Parties or the breach hereof, shall be submitted to
arbitration at the request of any party upon written notice
to that effect to the other party and such arbitration of any
party upon accordance with the (Indian) Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 and the rules and regulations made
thereunder by a panel consisting of three (3) arbitrators.
The parties shall have the right to appoint one arbitrator
each, and the arbitrators so appointed shall appoint a
third arbitrator who shall act as the presiding arbitrator.
27.02 The languages of the arbitration shall be English.
The seat of the arbitration shall be New Delhi, India."
5.
Both the parties proceeded to nominate their Arbitrators as
per the agreement. The said Arbitrators, by consent, appointed
the third Arbitrator. Thus the AT consisted of three Arbitrators.
The AT proceeded with the arbitration.
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
6.
On the basis of facts already narrated, the appellant-Maruti
raised the following claims before the AT:
CLAIM BRIEF PARTICULARS
AMOUNT
NO
(in Rs.)
Payment of Compensation of Share
Component of M/s Maruti Traders
against the direct sales of ITRON's
1.
products (water meters) to the 12,92,57,630
customers/agencies in the state of
Chhattisgarh by Respondent.
2.
3.
Payment of compensation of loss of
anticipation returns due to reduction
of business during year 2017 to 2020
Compensation in respect of PreArbitration interest, Pendente lite
interest@ 15% with effect from
6,89,50,000
-
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
applicable date on the amount
awarded for Claim No.1&2 and post
award interest on Awarded Amount
Cost of Arbitration I Litigation
4.
-
STATEMENT OF DEFENCE
7.
The respondent filed statement of defence submitting that
respondent-Itron is engaged in business of manufacturing, trading
and supplying comprehensive range of gas and water metering
solutions (in short ‘Itron Products’). It was stated that actually no
business was conducted by Maruti in the territory of Chhattisgarh
for the year 2009-2010. Even for the period of 2011-2017, very
little business was conducted by Maruti. Further, it is stated that
there was no formal agreement between the parties during that
period. It was merely authorization to Maruti to work as non
exclusive dealer for sale/resale of Itron products. As Maruti was
a non exclusive dealer, this itself denotes that Itron was free not
only to appoint other dealers in the given territory but was also
free to do any business on its own. The stand of Itron before the
AT was that on non exclusive basis, Maruti cannot claim
complete control of the entire business of Itron in the territory.
Further, after 31.12.2012 there was no formal authorization in
favour of Maruti until execution of Reseller agreement dated
01.02.2017, which was also executed on non exclusive basis.
Therefore, in statement of defence, Itron submitted that Maruti
was not entitled to any claims raised by it.
ISSUES
8.
The Arbitral Tribunal after considering the submissions of
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
the parties framed the following issues:
1. Whether the claims of the Claimant relating to the
period prior to 28.11.2018 are barred by limitation?
OPR
2. Whether the Respondent is in breach of the terms and
conditions of the Reseller Agreement? OPCI
3. Whether the Claimant is entitled to claim as Prayer (c)
of its Statement of Claim pertaining to payment of
Rs.12,92,57,630/- under Claim NO.1? OPCI
4. Whether the Claimant is entitled to claim as per
Prayer (d)of its Statement of Claim pertaining to
payment of Rs. 6.895Crores under Claim NO.2? OPCI
5. Whether the Claimant is entitled to claim as Prayer (e)
of its Statement of Claim pertaining to an Award in
favour of Claimant and payment of Pre-Arbitration
and pendente lite interest by the Respondent under
Claim NO.3? OPCI
6. Whether the Claimant is entitled to claim as Prayer (f)
of its Statement of Claim pertaining to payment of cost
of arbitration including the fees and expenses of
Techno-legal consultants, advocates engaged by
Claimant and incidental expenses under Claim No.4?
OPCI
7. Whether the Claimant is entitled to Prayer (g) of its
Statement of Claim pertaining to payment of post
award interest@ 15% per annum or any other rate of
interest on the amount claimed under Claim Nos. 1, 2,
3 and 4 or any other amount determined by the
Arbitral Tribunal in the Award?
THE IMPUGNED AWARD AND THE IMPUGNED
JUDGMENT
9.
The parties led their respective evidences before the AT.
After hearing the parties, the AT passed the impugned award
dismissing all the claims of the appellant.
10.
The appellant challenged the said award by way of
objections under Section 34 of the Act, which were dismissed by
learned Single Judge vide impugned judgment in OMP (Comm)
89/2024. Aggrieved by the aforesaid impugned award and the
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
impugned judgment, Maruti has filed the present appeal under
Section 37 of the Act before us being the Commercial Appellate
Division Bench of Delhi High Court as per Section 13 (1A) of
the Commercial Courts Act 2015.
SUBMISSIONS OF PARTIES IN THIS APPEAL UNDER
SECTION 37 AND OUR ANALYSIS
11.
Before discussing the submissions of parties, we would
like to refer to various judgments of the Supreme Court viz.
MMTC Limited vs. Vedanta Limited (2019) 4 SCC 163;
Konkan Railway Corpn. Ltd. V. Chenab Bridge Project (2023)
9 SCC 85; Punjab State Civil Supplies Corpn. Ltd. V. Sanman
Rice Mills, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2632; UHL Power Company
Limited vs. State of Himachal Pradesh (2022) 4 SCC 116;
Bombay Slum Redevelopment Corporation Private Limited vs.
Samir Narain Bhojwani (2024) 7 SCC 218; and a very recent
judgment of the Supreme Court in Jan De Nul Dredging India
Pvt. Ltd. vs. Tuticorin Port Trust (Arising out of S.L.P. (C) No.
8803 of 2021) decided on 07.01.2026, in which it has been
consistently held that the appellate powers under Section 37 of
the Act are limited to the scope of Section 34 and cannot exceed
beyond it. In Punjab State Civil Supplies Corpn. Ltd. (Supra),
the Supreme Court of India elaborated upon the scope of powers
under Section 37 as under:
“20. In view of the above position in law on the subject,
the scope of the intervention of the court in arbitral
matters is virtually prohibited, if not absolutely barred
and that the interference is confined only to the extent
envisaged under Section 34 of the Act. The appellate
power of Section 37 of the Act is limited within the domain
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
of Section 34 of the Act. It is exercisable only to find out if
the court, exercising power under Section 34 of the Act,
has acted within its limits as prescribed thereunder or has
exceeded or failed to exercise the power so conferred. The
Appellate Court has no authority of law to consider the
matter in dispute before the arbitral tribunal on merits so
as to find out as to whether the decision of the arbitral
tribunal is right or wrong upon reappraisal of evidence as
if it is sitting in an ordinary court of appeal. It is only
where the court exercising power under Section 34 has
failed to exercise its jurisdiction vested in it by Section 34
or has travelled beyond its jurisdiction that the appellate
court can step in and set aside the order passed under
Section 34 of the Act. Its power is more akin to that
superintendence as is vested in civil courts while
exercising revisionary powers. The arbitral award is not
liable to be interfered unless a case for interference as set
out in the earlier part of the decision, is made out. It
cannot be disturbed only for the reason that instead of the
view taken by the arbitral tribunal, the other view which is
also a possible view is a better view according to the
appellate court.”
12.
In light of the aforesaid law, it has to be seen as to whether
or not there is any patent illegality or perversity in the impugned
award. Perusal of the award would show that the AT noted that
the entire period of business dealings between the parties can be
trifurcated in following three parts:
(1) 01.01.2009 till 31.12.2012.
(2) 01.01.2013 till 01.02.2017.
(3) 01.02.2017 for next three years.
13.
The business dealings from the period 01.01.2009 till
31.12.2012 are based upon four authorization letters dated
01.01.2009, 01.01.2010, 01.08.2011 and 01.01.2012. Through
these letters, the respondent-Itron authorized the appellant-Maruti
Traders to work for Itron as non exclusive dealer and there is no
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
prohibition upon Itron to either sell its products directly to the
customers or through any other agents or dealers. Further, the AT
was of the opinion that none of these letters contained any
arbitration clause and therefore, the AT did not have jurisdiction
to pass any award on the transactions during this period. Further,
the AT also opined that the use of words “non exclusive” itself is
enough to show that these letters did not put any embargo upon
Itron to directly sell the Itron products or to sell the same
thtorugh any other dealer.
14.
The second category of transactions is from 31.12.2012 till
31.01.2017. The AT observed that vide letter dated 01.01.2012,
the authorization in favour of Maruti Traders to work as its dealer
was from 01.01.2009 to 31.12.2012. However, from 01.01.2013
till execution of the Reseller agreement on 01.02.2017, there was
no evidence of authorization by Itron in favour of Maruti
Traders. Therefore, there was a complete vacuum between
01.01.2013 and 31.12.2017. Therefore, the AT was of the
opinion that it cannot arbitrate on any dispute relatable to that
period. Learned Single Judge discussed in detail the submissions
of the parties and looked into the evidence on record and then
agreed with the AT which held that it did not have any authority
to hold arbitration on the dispute prior to execution of Reseller
agreement. So the AT as well as learned Single Judge of this
court have rightly rejected claims for the period prior to
01.02.2017.
15.
We also agree with this view of AT and learned Single
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
Judge as Counsel for the appellant could not show any arbitration
clause in any of the letters or Reseller agreement which may
convince this court that the disputes prior to execution of Reseller
agreement dated 01.02.2017 were subject to any arbitration
agreement.
16.
Now we take up the claims post Reseller agreement dated
01.02.2017, as the main thrust of arguments of the Counsel for
the appellant was upon the opinion of the AT and learned Single
Judge on this aspect.
17.
The arguments of learned Counsel for the appellant was
that Itron could not have sold its products directly to customers in
the State of Chhattisgarh in view of the Reseller agreement dated
01.02.2017 and such direct sale amounted to repudiation or
breach of the Reseller agreement.
18.
Learned Counsel for the respondent-Itron countered the
above submission addressed on behalf of appellant-Maruti and
relied upon clause 2.01. of the Reseller agreement, which clearly
states that Maruti was appointed as its dealer on non exclusive
basis and Itron retained its right to directly sell its products to the
customers and also to appoint other Resellers.
19.
The plea of Maruti Traders was that it disagreed with
clause 2.01 and sent a registered letter dated 16.08.2017 to Itron
through which Maruti returned one copy of the Reseller
agreement with its signatures thereon, simultaneously conveying
its disagreement with clause 2.01 and asking for a change
thereof. The plea on behalf of Maruti was that since Itron did not
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
reject this offer and remained silent, it signifies acceptance of
Maruti’s objection to clause 2.01. The AT discussed the effect of
letter dated 16.08.2017 and it was of the opinion that the request
for change of clause 2.01 was only a counter offer by Maruti
Traders. In order to become enforceable, such offer was required
to be accepted by the Itron. The AT relied upon Section 7 of the
Indian Contract Act, 1872, which mandates that acceptance of an
offer should be absolute, unqualified and should be expressed in
some usual and reasonable manner. The AT after perusing the
language of letter dated 16.08.2017 and contemporaneous
conduct of parties held that there was no acceptance of this offer
and accordingly, the agreement dated 01.02.2017 remained
unaltered. Learned Single Judge agreed with this opinion of the
AT.
20.
The question of law which arises before this court is
whether silence of Itron on receiving an objection from Maruti
Traders through letter dated 16.08.2017 would amount to
acceptance of such counter offer and if so its effect. This court
has perused the view of AT and learned Single Judge on this
point. First, we would like to reproduce clause 2.01 of the
Reseller agreement, which is as under:
“2.01 Itron hereby appoints Reseller, and Reseller accepts
such appointment, as Itron's authorized non-exclusive
Reseller for marketing and selling the Products to
Customers in the Territory defined in Annex A in
accordance with the terms and conditions of this
Agreement. Itron retains the right to sell Products directly
to Customers within the Territory and to appoint other
Resellers of Products.”
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
21.
Itron had sent two signed copies of Reseller agreement to
Maruti for execution with one to be retained by Maruti and the
other to be returned to Itron after putting its signatures thereon.
The appellant-Maruti Traders under the cover of its letter dated
16.08.2017, while returning one copy of Reseller agreement with
its signatures thereon, conveyed its disagreement with aforesaid
clause 2.01 and asked for a change thereof. Here we would like
to reproduce the letter dated 16.08.2017:
“We are in receipt of two copies of the RESELLER
AGREEMENT. Thanks for the same.
While going through the Agreement, we observe some
points in which some
clarification is needed & we are also not agree with these
points: (1) Clause 3-3.01 - (iv):
It is written that "at its own expense, delivering the
defective Products to ITRON".
We request you to delete "at its om1 expense".
(2) Clause 2-2.01:
It is written that ITRON retains the right to sell Products
directly to Customers within a the Territory and to appoint
other resellers of Products"
We request you to delete the same.
(3) Clause 4-4.01:
It is written that "ITRON shall not be liable to the Reseller
for any failure to deliver on a particular date".
We request you to please clarify that if any order is taken
with late delive1y charges & if late delivery from ITRON
part occurs, then who will bear the late delivery charges.
We are enclosing herewith the original Agreement duly
sealed with signature but all above three be cleared or
need to be changed.”
22.
In this letter the appellant-Maruti is seeking deletion of the
portion of Clause 2.01 in which it was mentioned that Itron
retained the right to sell products directly to customers within the
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
territory and to appoint other Resellers of products. The deletion
which Maruti had sought was a very material proposal.
Therefore, mere silence of Itron on this point would not amount
to acceptance of this counter offer. The AT opined that neither
Itron changed clause 2.01 nor conveyed its view on the change
suggested by Maruti. Therefore, it looked into the letter dated
16.08.2017 and contemporaneous conduct of the parties. Para (S)
(T) and (U) of the Award dated 14.11.2023 are reproduced as
under:
“(S) As far as the contemporaneous conduct of the parties
is concerned, we may notice that the Reseller Agreement
though dated 01.02.2017 was admittedly executed in
August, 2017. It is the own case of the claimant that the
respondent, even prior to August 2017 was indulging in
direct sales and which necessitated the meeting dated
29.04.2017. A perusal of the minutes of the said meeting
relied by the claimant, and though disputed by the
respondent shows that the respondent in the said meeting
offered to give 2-3% commission to the claimant for the
direct quotations submitted by it but which was not
acceptable to the claimant. Therefrom it is evident that it
was in the knowledge of the claimant when it signed and
returned the Reseller Agreement to the respondent that the
respondent was not willing to accept the claimant as the
only seller of water meters of the respondent in the State
of Chhattisgarh and the respondent on its own also,
independent of the claimant, was dealing with the
customers of water meters in the State of Chhattisgarh.
The minutes of the meeting of 29.04.2017 as per the
claimant also do not show the respondent to have in the
said meeting also agreed to such exclusivity of the
claimant. Rather, the respondent thereafter, in the Reseller
Agreement forwarded to the claimant for execution,
reserved unto itself the right of such direct sales.
(T) In the aforesaid state of affairs, the factum of the
claimant having executed and returned the Reseller
Agreement to the respondent cannot be treated as
anything but an unequivocal/ absolute acceptance of the
Reseller Agreement by the claimant in the manner
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
required by the respondent. The letter dated 16.08.2017,
in law, constitutes merely a request of the claimant to the
respondent and that in the absence of acceptance of such
request by the respondent, the assent and intent of the
claimant to function in terms of the Reseller Agreement.
(U) Thus, we hold, that notwithstanding the letter dated
16.08.2017, a contract in terms of the Reseller Agreement
came into existence between the claimant and the
respondent.”
23.
Learned Single Judge agreed with the AT observing that
even the conduct of parties did not indicate that Itron had
accepted this offer for deletion or modification in clause 2.01.
We have already reproduced the letter in question and we find
that appellant has not brought any material which could show
that Itron had accepted the deletion or modification in clause 2.01
as argued by learned Counsel for the appellant-Maruti.
24.
Learned Counsel for the appellant argued that it was held
in Rickmers Verwaltung GMBH vs. The Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd. (1999) 1 SCC 1 that a contract can be spelt
from correspondence; further in McDermott International Inc.
vs. Burn Standard Co. Ltd. (2006) 11 SCC 181 that a contract
can be described from conduct and correspondence exchanged
between the parties; further in Nabha Power Ltd. (NPL) vs.
Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. (PSPCL) and Ors.
(2018) 11 SCC 508 that terms can be implied in a contract on
basis of business efficacy principle; further in Kollipara
Sriramulu vs. T. Aswathanarayana and ors. (1968) 3 SCR
387 that want of a formal contract not necessary if otherwise
essential terms and conditions settled. We fully agree with the
law laid down in these judgments. That is why the AT and
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
learned Single Judge read the four letters dated 01.01.2009,
01.01.2010, 01.08.2011 and 01.01.2012, minutes of meeting
dated 29.04.2017, Reseller agreement dated 01.02.2017 and
emails exchanged between the parties, to understand the nature of
contractual relationship between the appellant and respondent.
25.
Learned Counsel for the appellant argued that the AT and
learned Single Judge ignored the fact that the appellant-Maruti
Traders were entitled to consideration, which was the difference
between the special price offered by Itron to the appellant and the
final price quoted by the appellant to the respondent.
26.
However, nothing is on record which could have enabled
AT to determine the price of the products and the commission
which would be paid to the appellant-Maruti. Infact, the AT has
mentioned in the impugned award that there was no pleadings or
any evidence for water meters having been placed by the Maruti
upon Itron during the period from 01.01.2009 to 31.12.2012
through its (i.e. Maruti’s) efforts.
27.
The AT specifically noted in para 1 (page 1447) of the
award that even in the absence of any terms and conditions of
such dealership settled, Maruti could have, under Section 70 of
the Contract Act, claimed compensation from Itron for the
benefit enjoyed by Itron. However, Maruti Traders in Statement
of Claims did not invoke the said provision of law. The AT was
of the opinion that as the claimant-Maruti had not invoked the
said provision of law it cannot adjudicate any claim on that basis.
Further, it was noted by the AT that claimant-Maruti Traders had
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
not pleaded or proved the expenses, if any, incurred by it for
representing itself as the dealer of Itron, for selling its products
and compensation equivalent to which Maruti Traders could be
said to be entitled to. The AT was of the opinion that a mere
pleading that claimant-Maruti Traders invested its time, effort
and money for having water meters of respondent in the list of
approved vendors is not enough and that it was not possible to
estimate the value thereof without the same being pleaded or
proved.
28.
Learned Single Judge looked into this aspect and fully
agreed with the AT. We have also perused the views of the AT as
well as learned Single Judge and we are of the opinion that the
aforesaid findings are based upon the absence of evidence on that
point and therefore, we find no infirmity in the said findings.
29.
Learned Counsel for the appellant-Maruti Traders argued
that when Itron started selling its products to various entities
directly, Maruti raised objections to it which led to discussion
between the parties in which Itron agreed to make payment of 23% of commission to Maruti Traders. To understand this
submission we would like to reproduce the minutes of meeting
dated 29.04.2017 held at Raipur, in which the representatives of
the parties participated. The same is reproduced as under:
“Minutes of Meeting held at Raipur on 29.04.2017 at our
Office & following points were discussed and finalized:1. Regarding direct quotation given by ITRON to ADCC
for Korba Project. Mr. Pawan Mathur has offered 2-3%
commission to us. We have informed that this 2-3%
commission is not justified as we have occurred the
expense which is more than 2-3% commission.
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
2. ITRON will divert all the enquiries for water meter to us
for necessary quotation and supply.
3. Distributorship for the state of Chhattisgarh process
will be complete immediately which is still pending.
4. Mr. Debasis will visit in Raipur Smart City program
going to be held in May 2017.
5. Sanjeev Rungta & Debasis will visit Bhilai regarding
supply of material of the work order already placed to
IHP. Supply will be routed through Maruti Traders,
Raipur.
6 Similarly Sanjeev Rungta will make every effort to take
the order at Korba Project. This project order also with
IHP.
7. Although Bhilai & Korba Project meter specification is
diluted. Sanjeev Rungta will try to get the order. Company
will support in price. In both the cases material will be
routed through Maruti Traders, Raipur.”
30.
Referring to the aforesaid minutes of meeting, learned
Counsel for the appellant argued that through these minutes of
meeting, Itron agreed to pay 2-3% commission to Maruti Traders
in respect of the direct quotation given by Itron to ADCC for
Korba project. Further, it was agreed that Itron will divert
inquiries for water meters to Maruti Traders for necessary
quotations and supply. Further, the process of distributorship for
State of Chhattisgarh would be completed immediately, which is
still pending. Further, Mr. Sanjeev Rungta, the proprietor of
Maruti, would make more effort to take orders at Korba project
and would also try to get the orders from Bhilai project apart
from Korba project.
31.
It is argued by learned Counsel for the appellant-Maruti
that these minutes prove that Itron had agreed to the proposal of
Maruti Traders to make it exclusive dealer and had also agreed to
pay 2-3% of commission against direct sale of water meters to
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
Korba project, which means that the Itron had agreed to delete or
modify clause 2.01 and had agreed that Maruti would be its
exclusive dealer and that Itron would deal with its customers only
through the appellant-Maruti.
32.
The AT considered this submission in para ‘S’ of the
judgment and opined that a perusal of minutes of the said
meeting relied by the claimant-Maruti Traders, though disputed
by Itron, shows that Itron in the said meeting offered to give 23% commission to Maruti Traders for direct quotations submitted
by it to its customers but it was not acceptable to the claimantMaruti. It was held that these minutes did not show that Itron had
agreed to the exclusive dealership of Maruti Traders. Thus this
plea was rejected. Learned Single Judge in the impugned
judgment discussed this issue in para 27.11 of impugned
judgment and held as under:
“27.11
The perusal of the minutes of the meeting dated
29.04.2017, which preceded the Reseller agreement,
showed that the respondent had offered the petitioner, in
the said meeting, 2-3% commission for direct quotations
submitted by the respondent, but that this offer was not
acceptable to the petitioner. This indicate that though the
petitioner was aware that respondent was independently
dealing with the dealers in the State of Chhattisgarh,
respondent did not agreed to exclusivity of the petitioner.”
33.
Perusal of the minutes of meeting reproduced above leave
us in no doubt about the correctness of the view of the AT as well
as learned Single Judge as discussed above and we find no
illegality or perversity in the same.
34.
A few minor points have also been raised by learned
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
Counsel for the appellant. Learned Counsel for the appellant
argued that the AT did not frame an issue that there was no
arbitration agreement prior to 01.02.2017. We are of the opinion
that even if no issue was framed, it is the duty of the AT to
restrict itself only to those disputes or claims, which are covered
under the arbitration clause. Any claim which is beyond the
arbitration agreement cannot be arbitrated. Here the question is
not as to whether a particular issue was framed or not, the
question before this court is as to whether the findings of the AT
and learned Single Judge in respect of claims, which arose prior
to 01.02.2017, are correct or not. As we find no infirmity in the
said views, we find no substance in the submissions of learned
Counsel for the appellant.
35.
It is argued by learned Counsel for the appellant that the
AT framed 7 issues but it did not decide any of the issues which
were framed. In our opinion, this is a hyper technical objection.
The issue no.1 is on the point of limitation. As learned Arbitrator
has not decided it against the appellant, no grievances can be
raised by the appellant. The issue no.2 is as to whether Itron had
committed breach of terms and conditions of Reseller agreement.
The AT has gone deep into this plea and had held that nothing
binds Itron from directly selling its products. When there was no
breach of agreement, the AT decided issue nos. 3 and 4 vide
which payment of Rs.12,92,57,630/- and Rs.6.895 crores were
claimed. Issue no.5 is in respect of pre arbitration and pendente
lite interest. As the appellant was not entitled to amounts
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
mentioned in issue nos. 3 and 4, no action arose to award pre
arbitration and pendente lite interest. Same is the status of cost of
arbitration as claimed in issue no.6 and post award interest as
mentioned in issue no.7. The AT has specifically mentioned in
para (CC) and (DD) under the head IX of Analysis and Reasons
as under:
“(CC) Having found that the claimant is not entitled to
any amount towards compensation or otherwise from the
respondent, Issues No. 2 to 6 are decided against the
claimant and in favour of the respondent.
(DD) As far as Issue No. 1 with respect to limitation is
concerned, once it has been found on merits that the
claimant is not entitled to any amount from the
respondent, the need for adjudicating this issue does not
arise. As regards Issue No.7, since the Claimant is not
entitled to any sum from the Respondent, the question of
grant of any interest also does not arise.”
36.
Thus it cannot be said that the AT did not decide the issues
framed by it.
37.
In view of above discussion, we find no patent illegality or
perversity in the impugned award and the impugned judgment.
Accordingly, there is no substance in the present appeal. The
appeal is hereby dismissed.
VINOD KUMAR, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
January 19, 2026
VB
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
12:45:20
FAO OS (COMM) 184/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review