Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
APHC010665902025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3332]
TUESDAY, THE 1st DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT:THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
WRIT PETITION NO: 34330/2025
Along with
WRIT PETITION No.9958 of 2026
WRIT PETITION NO: 34330/2025
Between:
1. MARRI SATISH BABU, S/O SINGA RAO, HINDU, AGED ABOUT 45
YEARS,
R/O. K
K-603,
603, MID VALLEY CITY APARTMENTS,
ATMAKURU, MANGALAGIRI
MANGALAGIRI-522503
...PETITIONER
AND
1. STATE BANK OF INDIA, REP BY CHAIRMAN / MANAGING
DIRECTOR CORPORATE OFFICE, STATE BANK BUILDING VIDYA
BHAVAN MARG, NAREEMANI POINT, MUMBAI MAHARASHTRA
STATE 400 021
2. THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER, STATE BANK OF INDIA
LOCATED AT D.NO. 3
3-4-1013/A,
1013/A, 1ST FLOOR, CAC, TSRTC BUS
STATION, KACHIGUDA,
DA, HYDERABAD - 500 027
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue appropriate Writ, Order or Direction mor
more
e particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ calling for the
records relating to and connected with proceedings dated 06
06- 10-2025
vide.
Lr No.F/SAMB(H)/SCPL/SBG/412 dated 06-1006
2025 and Notice Vide
Lr.No.F/SATYA/WD/ANEXII/SBG/486
/WD/ANEXII/SBG/486 'D
dated 24-11-2025
2025 of 2nd
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
Respondent and to quash the same as the same is illegal, arbitrary, violation
of principles of natural justice and contrary to the guidelines given in the
Master circular issued by the RBI in identifying the Wilful defaulters without
considering my representation dated 16-04-2025 and submissions made
during personal hearing on 18-09-2025 in proper perspective and even after
bringing to their notice that the show cause notices vide F/ACH/881 and
F/ACH/331 dated 28/3/2024 and 07/08/2024 said to have been issued was
never issued to me and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
to stay all further proceedings consequent upon the impugned proceedings
vide. Lr No.F/SAMB(H)/SCPL/SBG/412 dated 06-10-2025 and notice Vide
Lr.No. F/SATYA/WD/ANEXII/SBG/486’D’ dated 24-11-2025 of 2nd
Respondent including publication of details of the petitioner in newspaper
pending disposal of the above writ petition and to pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. GHANTA SRIDHAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. S SATYANARAYANA MOORTHY
WRIT PETITION NO: 9958/2026
Between:
1. MARRI NAGARAJA KUMAR, S/O LATE KOTESWARA RAO, AGED
ABOUT 50 YEARS, R/O FLAT NO.501, MALLIKARJUNA ENCLAVE,
SIVALAYAM ROAD, PEDAKAKANI, GUNTUR, ANDHRA PRADESH 522509.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. STATE BANK OF INDIA, REP BY CHAIRMAN / MANAGING
DIRECTOR, CORPORATE OFFICE, STATE BANK BUILDING, VIDYA
BHAVAN MARG, NAREEMANI POINT, MUMBAI, MAHARASHTRA 400021.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
2. THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER, STATE BANK OF INDIA,
LOCATED AT D.NO.3-4-1013/A, 1 ST FLOOR, CAC, TSRTC BUS
STATION, KACHIGUDA, HYDERABAD - 500027
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue appropriate Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ calling for the
records relating to and connected with proceedings dated 23-03-2026 in Ref
F/SCPL/SBG/AN E IX/NOTICE/691 of 2nd Respondent and to quash the
same as the same is illegal, arbitrary, violation of principles of natural justice
and contrary to the guidelines given in the Master circular issued by the RBI
in identifying the Wilful defaulters without considering my representation and
submissions made during personal hearing on 18-09-2025 in proper
perspective and even after bringing to their notice that the show cause
notices vide F/ACH/881 and F/ACH/331 dated 28/3/2024 and 07/08/2024
said to have been issued was never issued to me and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
to stay all further proceedings consequent upon the impugned proceedings
dated 23-03-2026 in Ref;F/SCPL/SBG/ANE of 2nd Respondent including
publication of details of the petitioner in newspaper pending disposal of the
above writ petition and to pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. PHANI BABU YALAMANCHILI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. S SATYANARAYANA MOORTHY
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
COMMON ORDER
These Writ Petitions are filed aggrieved by the proceedings of
respondent no.2-Deputy General Manager, State Bank of India, declaring the
petitioners as wilful defaulters.
2. The contents of the petition, in brief, are that the petitioners joined
as shareholder by spending huge amounts and later became Additional
Directors
(non-executive)
of
Satya
Constructions
Private
Limited
on
11.03.2019. That by the date of their joining, there was outstanding by the
company to State Bank of India, but by suppressing the same the Managing
Director and a Director of the company lured them to join stating that the
company has good prospects and it will flourish within no time. The
petitioners being non-executive directors for a brief period, never took active
part in the day to day affairs of the company. That thereafter they noticed
that the Managing Director and a Director of the Company, who hold cheque
power and used to enter into negotiations, taking advantage of their lead
roles diverted the funds of the company to have wrongful gain, with the
connivance of the bank officials. That having disgusted with their attitude, the
petitioners submitted their resignation on 18.06.2020 to their posts and the
same was accepted on 30.06.2020.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
It is the further case of the petitioners that the loan sanction letter
expressly stipulated that the loans shall be realized from the sale proceeds of
the flats constructed on the land offered as primary security and to prevent
siphoning or diversion of sale proceeds, the arrangement letter imposes a
mandatory condition that the sale proceeds of each flat shall be credited into
Escrow account only after obtaining a No Objection Certificate from the bank
prior to execution of each sale transaction, but, the company has sold 50 flats
without obtaining the mandatory NOC from respondent bank, therefore, the
bank had failed to ensure compliance of essential conditions of the
arrangement letter thereby facilitated the Managing Director of the company
to divert the sale proceeds arising from the sale of flats constructed on the
primary security and the diversion of funds ultimately led to the financial
collapse and bankruptcy of Satya Constructions Private Limited. That the
petitioners are clueless of the said transactions, since not involved in day to
day affairs of the company and even when they approached the bank asking
for details, the bank authorities had refused to provide them any information
on the ground that they are not authorized persons of the company.
It is the further case of the petitioners that solely because of the failure
of the bank in ensuring compliance of contractual obligation and facilitating
the Managing Director in diverting funds resulted in default of payment of the
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
loan amount taken from State Bank of India, Guntur and resultantly the loan
account of the company was declared as Non Performing Asset (NPA) on
30.12.2020 and proceedings Under Securitisation and Reconstruction of
Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest (SARFAESI) Act, 2002
were initiated, which were pending before the Debt Recovery Tribunal,
Visakhapatnam vide O.A.No.297 of 2021, wherein one of the properties given
as collateral security for the outstanding loans was also attached and sold and
the petitioners do not want to come in the way of the Bank in proceeding
against the properties given by them as collateral security.
It is the further case of the petitioners that throughout their tenure as a
share holder or Non-Executive Directors, the petitioners were not benefited
either financially or in any other manner. That the respondent bank instead of
going behind the primary security i.e., unsold flats left as on the date of NPA
had chosen to target the petitioners though unsold property of the company
is available for realization of the loan amount. That the petitioners were
victimized by the people in the management of the company at the helm of
affairs and so also the respondent bank authorities. Therefore, the petitioners
fall back on their employment for protecting their interest and their families
and had taken up contract employment.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
It is their further case that the Central Bureau of Investigation,
Visakhapatnam
had
registered
First
Information
Report
vide
RC
No.036022A0004, dated 28.01.2022 pursuant to the complaint lodged by the
Deputy General manager, SBI SME Branch, Guntur before the Joint Director,
CBI, New Delhi, arraying Satya Constructions Private Limited, its Managing
Director and all Directors, including the petitioners, as accused and on the
requisition of the CBI, Look-Out Circulars were also issued against the
petitioners. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners filed Writ Petition Nos.20943 &
38401 of 2022, which were disposed of vide order dated 06.07.2023 recording
the submissions made by the official respondents therein that cases of the
petitioners have been considered.
It is their further case that identification of a wilful defaulter has to be
made on the basis of the track record of the borrowers but not on the basis of
isolated transactions or incidents, as per the Master Circular, which is with an
object to punish those borrowers who have not acted bonafidely in the
interest of business enterprise but made a concerted effort to divert borrowed
funds. That publication of photograph of a borrower is neither allowed by
express provision nor by necessary implication and the secured creditor, being
a public authority, can make public so much of information that it is
authorized in terms of SARFAESI Act.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
It is their further case that the respondent Bank was fully aware of all
the transactions which are now alleged to be acts of wilful default and despite
noting all transactions they found no occasion to order a forensic audit of the
company, wherein the petitioners are only additional directors (NonExecutive) for a short period and the bank never treated the alleged acts of
wilful default as an act of siphoning of funds though the petitioners had
informed the bank about the misdeeds of the Managing Director of the
company.
It is their further case that for declaring a person as ‘wilful defaulter’,
the lender bank has to independently find that wilful default is intention,
deliberate and calculated and the said conclusion must be based on objective
facts and circumstances of the case, as required under Master circular. In the
instant case, there is no material to show that the petitioners are wilful
defaulters and absolutely no grounds to identity them as wilful defaulters by
virtue of the impugned proceedings and consequently to make publication of
their photographs etc., in the media. That the respondent bank, by leaving
the managing Director and another Director, who did all the day to day affairs
of the company and played active role in defrauding the bank, wants to target
the petitioners only with an ulterior motive and further the bank had not
taken any steps for deportation of the Managing Director of the company.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
It is their further case that, the petitioners received communication
dated 08.04.2025 from respondent no.2 wherein reference was made to
alleged show cause notices stated to have been issued to them pursuant to
the directions of the Wilful Defaulter Identification Committee, vide letter
No.F/ACH/881,
dated
28.03.2024
and
Letter
No.F/ACH/331,
dated
07.08.2024, purportedly recommending to classify the petitioners as wilful
defaulters and to include their names in the Credit Information Companies’ list
of will defaulters. That the petitioners never received any such show cause
notices nor documents on which the respondent bank relied as claimed by the
respondent bank, nor was any such communication ever served on them.
That the petitioners had brought the said fact to the notice of the respondent
authorities in their explanations and also during personal hearing, however,
the bank authorities proceeded and issued the impugned proceedings. That in
pursuant of the letter dated 08.04.2025, the petitioners made a detailed
representation dated 16.04.2025, but without considering the representations
made by the petitioners in proper perspective, the petitioner was issued
another letter dated 01.09.2025 to appear before the Review committee for
personal hearing on 18.09.2025 and accordingly, the petitioners appeared and
submitted their objections. That without considering the representations and
submissions of the petitioners made before the Review Committee, the
respondent bank issued the impugned letter dated 06.10.2025 declaring them
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
as wilful defaulters and in pursuance of the said proceedings dated
06.10.2025, the respondent no.2 also issued notice dated 24.11.2025
demanding the petitioners to pay the outstanding dues within 15 days or else
the ban will publish/display their names, addresses, photographs and other
details in the newspapers in addition to other legal recourses.
It is their further case that para 2.4 of the RBI Master Circular on wilful
defaulters clearly places a duty on banks to ensure proper end-use of funds,
which states that the bank is required to carry out their own due diligence and
maintain strong internal controls to protect their credit exposure and prevent
misuse of funds. But the respondent bank had issued No objection certificate
contrary to the terms of the arrangement letter, evidencing that the
respondent bank was negligent and failed to discharge its statutory and
regulatory obligations. Further, paras 2 and 3 of the Master Circular issued
guidelines by the RBI deals with Mechanism for identification of Wilful
Defaulters and it stipulates that Non-promoter and Non-whole-time directors
are ordinarily not to be classified as wilful defaulters except in rare and
exceptional circumstances where it is conclusively establishes that such
director aware of the acts constituting wilful default or that the wilful default
was occurred with his consent or connivance. Even in such rare cases, the
procedural safeguards including issuance of notice, opportunity of hearing,
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
and review by the higher committee must be strictly followed. In the instant
case, no such procedure was followed and that the petitioners are only
Additional Directors (non-executive) that too for a shorter period of 15
months from 11.03.2019 to 18.06.2020 and moreover the debts were
borrowed prior to their induction and that too they did not derive any benefit
from the company in any manner whatsoever. Hence, the impugned
proceedings are liable to be set aside. Hence, the writ petitions.
3. The respondent Bank filed counter affidavit denying the material
averments of the writ affidavit and further contending that the respondent
bank had issued notice on 08.04.2025, for which the petitioners submitted
their reply dated 16.04.2025 and after considering the reply dated
16.04.2025, the respondent bank had issued a notice on 30.01.2026 calling
upon the petitioners to attend the personal hearing before the Review
Committee on 13.02.2026 and accordingly they attended and submitted their
explanation and after the final report of the Review Committee, the bank had
issued the impugned order and therefore, there is compliance of principles of
natural justice as mandated. That the guarantee agreement executed by the
petitioners on 21.11.2019 categorically provides for declaring them as wilful
defaulters, in the event of default in honouring the guarantee provided for
repayment of dues despite having sufficient means. Further, on 01.10.2019,
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
the petitioners had given all powers to Managing Director and another
Director for executing documents and cheque powers.
It is further stated in the counter affidavit that sub clause (iii) of Rule-3
of the RBI Circular states that every director, in respect of a contravention of
any of the provisions of the Act, who is aware of such contravention by virtue
of receipt by him of any proceedings of the Board or participation in such
proceedings and who has not objected to the same, is liable to be declared as
wilful defaulter. Further, the petitioners had never shown them as a part-time
Director or Non-Executive Director and never informed the bank as such and
moreover the board resolution showing their resignations categorically shows
their names as Directors, as such the petitioners are responsible for the acts
committed by the company. That even assuming for argument sake, if the
petitioners are non-executive directors, then also they are liable for the
actions committed by them for being declared as wilful defaulters.
It is further stated in the counter affidavit that the petitioners
themselves have admitted that their mis-management in the company and
funds were diverted by the company, if that was so the the petitioners, who
are part and parcel being Directors, cannot simply waive their liability by
making allegations against other directors. That the petitioners and other
directors had committed serious fraud and sold away the flats without No
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
Objection Certificate from the respondent bank. That the writ petition is bad
for non-joinder of CBI as a party. That there are no merits in the writ petition
and the same is liable to be dismissed.
4. Heard Sri Ghanta Rama Rao, learned senior counsel, assisted by Sri
Phani
Babu
Yalamanchili,
learned
counsel
for
petitioner,
and
Sri
S.Satyanarayana Moorthy, learned Standing Counsel for respondent bank.
5. Sri Ghanta Rama, learned senior counsel, while reiterating the
contents of the writ affidavit would contend that the petitioners were the
Additional Directors (Non-executive) of the Company for a limited period from
11.03.2019 to 18.06.2020 and they had never participated in the day to day
affairs of the company and therefore, the petitioners do not fall under the
definition of promoter/whole-time as per the Master circular issued by the
Reserve Bank of India and hence, the petitioners cannot be declared as wilful
defaulters. The learned senior counsel would further contend that the
respondent bank without making any independent appropriate enquiries as to
whether the petitioners are in genuine financial difficulties or there exists
events of fraud or malfeasance as required before declaring the petitioners as
wilful defaulters, upon placing heavy reliance on the recommendations of the
wilful defaulter identification committee
issued the impugned proceedings
only with a view to bring pressure on the petitioners for collecting the
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
outstanding loan amount by proceedings against them personally leaving the
prime securities kept at disposal of the bank as security for the loans availed.
6. The learned senior counsel would further contend that the
identification of wilful defaulter has to be made on the basis of the track
record of a borrower and not on the basis of isolated transactions or
incidents, as per the Master Circular of the Reserve Bank of India, however,
the bank by flouting the Master Circular issued the impugned proceedings.
The learned senior counsel would further contend that though arrangement
letter mandates that the sale of the flats raised in the primary security shall
only after obtaining No Objection Certificate from the Bank and that the sale
proceeds shall be credited in the Escrow Account, the respondent bank issued
NOC without the amount being credited in the said account and thus the bank
authorities facilitated the Managing Director and other Director in siphoning
the funds. The learned senior counsel would further contend that as the
petitioners had never participated in the day to day administration of the
Company and further in view of the categorical findings by the CBI in the
charge sheet filed in RC 04(A)/2022-CBI/ACB/VSKP had clearly mentioned
that the petitioners did not receive any funds either out of the loan proceeds
or from the sale proceeds of the flats, the petitioners cannot be said to be the
Additional Directors (Executive) and therefore, they cannot be declared as
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
wilful defaulters. The learned senior counsel would further contend that the
procedure to be followed as per Master Circular of the Reserve Bank of India
has not been followed and there is a flagrant violation of principles of natural
justice. The learned senior counsel would finally contend that the impugned
proceedings and the consequential notice of respondent no.2 are to be set
aside. Accordingly, prayed to allow the writ petitions.
7. On the other hand, Sri S.Satyanarayana Moorthy, learned Standing
Counsel for respondent bank, while reiterating the contents of the counter
affidavit would contend that the guarantee agreement executed by the
petitioners categorically provide for declaring them as wilful defaulter, in the
event of default in honouring the guarantee provided for repayment of dues
despite having sufficient means and therefore, the contention of the
petitioners that since their inclusion as directors was much subsequent to
taking over loans by the Company cannot sustain. He would further contend
that the bank had followed the procedure by issuing notices and opportunity
of personal hearing and therefore there is no violation of principles of natural
justice as alleged by the petitioner.
He would further contend that Rule 3(iii)
of the Master Circular draws no distinction between a director and nonexecutive director and it states that every director, who is aware of
contravention by virtue of receipt of any proceedings of the Board or
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
participation in such proceedings and who has not objected to the same or
where such contravention had taken place with his consent or connivance can
be identified as wilful defaulter. He would further contend that the Board
resolution showing the resignation of the petitioners clearly defines the
petitioners as Directors and further the petitioners had never intimated the
bank that they are only the non-executive Directors, except their self-serving
statements. He would further contend that there is neither violation of
principles of natural justice nor the Master Circular of the Reserve Bank of
India in identifying the petitioners as wilful defaulter and the writ petitions
being devoid of merits are liable to be set aside. Accordingly, prayed to
dismiss the writ petitions.
8. Perused the material available on record and considered the
submissions made by learned counsel for the parties.
9. Admittedly, the petitioners were Additional Directors of M/s. Satya
Constructions Private Limited from 11.03.2019 to 18.06.2020, which was
incorporated as a Private Limited on 01.06.2018.
10. The Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters defines the terms “wilful
default” and “Diversion and siphoning of funds as under:
“A “wilful default” would be deemed to have occurred if any of
the following events is noted:-
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
(a) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/repayment
obligations to the lender even when it has the capacity to honour the
said obligations.
(b) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/repayment
obligations to the lender and has not utilized the finance from the
lender for the specific purposes for which finance was availed of but has
diverted the funds for other purposes.
(c) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/repayment
obligations to the lender and has siphoned off the funds so that the
funds have not been utilized for the specific purpose for which finance
was availed of, nor are the funds available with the unit in the form of
other assets.
(d) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/ repayment
obligations to the lender and has also disposed off or removed the
movable fixed assets or immovable property given by him or it for the
purpose of securing a term loan without the knowledge of the
bank/lender.
2.2 Diversion and siphoning of funds
The terms “diversion of funds” and “siphoning of funds” should
construe to mean the following:
22.1 Diversion of funds, referred to at para 2.1(b) above, would
be construed to include any one of the undernoted occurrences:
(a) utilization of short-term working capital funds for long-term
purposes not in conformity with the terms of sanction;
(b) deploying borrowed funds for purposes/activities or creation
of assets other than those for which the loan was sanctioned
(c) transferring borrowed funds to the subsidiaries/Group
companies or other corporate by whatever modalities
(d) routing of funds through any bank other than the lender bank
or members of consortium without prior permission of the lender
(e) investment in other companies by way of acquiring equities/
debt instruments without approval of lenders
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
(f) shortfall in deployment of funds vis-à-vis the amounts
disbursed/drawn and the difference not being accounted for.
2.2.2. Siphoning of funds, referred to at para 2.1(c) above,
should be construed to occur if any funds borrowed from banks/FIs are
utilized for purposes unrelated to the operations of the borrower, to the
detriment of the financial health of the entity or of the lender. The
decision as to whether a particular instance amounts to siphoning of
funds would have to be a judgment of the lenders based on objective
facts and circumstances of the case.
The identification of wilful default should be made keeping in
view the track record of the borrowers and should not be decided on
the basis of isolated transactions/incidents. The default to be
categorized as wilful must be intentional, deliberate and calculated.”
11. Paragraph 3 of the Master Circular on ‘Wilful Defaulters’ deals with
Mechanism for identification of wilful defaulters, which is reproduced
hereunder:
3. Mechanism for identification of Wilful Defaulters.
The transparent mechanism referred to in paragraphs 2.5(d)
above should generally include the following:
(a) The evidence of wilful default on the part of the borrowing
company and its promoter/whole-time director at the
relevant time should be examined by a Committee headed
by an Executive Director and consisting of two other senior
officers of the rank of GM/DGM.
(b) If the Committee concludes that an event of wilful default
has occurred, it shall issue a Show Cause Notice to the
concerned borrower and the promoter/whole-time director
and call for their submissions and after considering their
submissions issue an order recording the fact of wilful
default and the reasons for the same. An opportunity
should be given to the borrower and the promoter/wholetime director for a personal hearing if the Committee feels
such an opportunity is necessary.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
(c)
The order of the Committee should be reviewed by another
Committee headed by the Chairman/CEO and MD and
consisting, in addition, of two independent directors of the
bank and the Order shall become final only after it is
confirmed by the said Review committee.
(d)
As regard a non-promoter/non-whole time director, it
should be kept in mind that Section 2(60) of the Companies
Act, 2013 denies an officer who is in default to mean only
the following categories of directors:
(i)
Whole-time director
(ii)
where there is no key managerial personnel, such
director or directors as specified by the Board in this behalf
and who has or have given his or their consent in writing to
the Board to such specification, or all the directors, if no
director is so specified:
(iii) every director, in respect of a contravention of any of
the provisions of this Act, who is aware of such
contravention by virtue of the receipt by him of any
proceedings of the Board or participation in such
proceedings and who has not objected to the same, or
where such contravention had taken place with his consent
or connivance.
Therefore, except in very rate cases, a non-whole time director
should not be considered as a wilful default unless it is
conclusively established that
I. he was aware of the fact of wilful default by the
borrower by virtue of any proceedings recorded in the
Minutes of the Board or a Committee of the Board and has
not recorded his objection to the same in the Minutes, or,
II. the wilful default had taken place with his consent
or connivance.
A similar process as detailed in sub paras (a) to (c) above should
be followed when identifying a non-promoter/non-whole time
director as a wilful defaulter.”
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
12. To summarize, a wilful default is strictly defined as an intentional,
deliberate, and calculated evasion of loan obligations where an individual or
entity has an outstanding balance of ₹25 lakh or more. This classification
occurs if a borrower refuses to repay despite having adequate financial
capacity and cash flow, or if they deliberately manipulate the funds by
diverting them to unapproved projects, siphoning off the money completely,
or selling secured assets without the lender's written consent. Conversely,
wilful defaulters are the actual entities or individuals designated under this
framework;
this
encompasses
individual
borrowers,
corporate
firms,
promoters, and directors who directly orchestrate the misuse of funds. It also
extends to third-party guarantors who fail to honour their signed repayment
commitments despite having the financial means to do so when the bank
invokes the guarantee. To ensure absolute fairness and adhere to the
principles of natural justice, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) mandates that
this label can only be finalised after a rigorous two-committee screening
process and by evaluating the borrower's long-term track record rather than
an isolated incident.
13.
The controversy in these writ petitions is confined to the
classification of the petitioners as wilful defaulters on the allegation that they
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
were responsible for, or had knowledge of, diversion and siphoning of the
funds of the borrowing company.
14. The material on record, including the proceedings of the
respondent-Bank and the CBI charge-sheet in RC 04(A)/2022-CBI/ACB/VSKP,
requires the allegation against the petitioners to be considered individually.
The mere fact that the petitioners were directors of the borrowing company
cannot, by itself, establish their personal participation in the alleged diversion
or siphoning of funds.
15. The RBI framework relating to wilful defaulters requires the finding
of wilful default to rest upon objective material. Where an individual director is
sought to be classified as a wilful defaulter, there must be material
establishing his individual knowledge, participation, consent or connivance in
the acts constituting wilful default. The default of the borrowing company and
the individual culpability of a director are distinct matters.
16. In the present case, the respondent-Bank has not placed
satisfactory material establishing that the petitioners had knowledge of the
alleged siphoning or diversion of funds, or that they consented to or connived
in such acts. The fact that they were directors, or that authority had been
conferred upon other persons to conduct the affairs of the company, does not
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
by itself establish knowledge or consent to every subsequent transaction
undertaken by those persons.
17. The circumstance emerging from the CBI investigation assumes
considerable significance. The CBI, which investigated the very transactions
forming the basis of the Bank's allegations, recorded in the charge-sheet that
the petitioners did not receive funds either from the loan proceeds or from the
sale proceeds of the flats. The observations made in the said charge sheet are
extracted hereunder for more clarify:
“It is submitted that Shri Marri nagaraja Kumar and Shri Marri Satish Babu
(petitioners herein) both provided collateral securities for ABL-CRE for Rs.6.40
crores and further entered development agreement as co-owners of land for
“Satya Reglia” Project at Chinakakani, Mangalagiri, Guntur. Both of them did
not receive any funds either out of loan proceeds or from the sale proceeds of
the flats of Mallikhaarjuna N=Clave and Mount Edge Apartment. Both of them
purchased stake of 10% stake in Satya Constructions Private Limited from
Shri Popuri Satyanarayana, for a consideration of Rs. 2 crores but later in the
year 2020 they resigned from the same. However, the project of Satya
Constructions Private Limited i.e. Satya Regalia of Satya Constructions Private
Limited (A1) Company invested an amount of Rs.4 Crores as per the forensic
audit reports. But the same was never took off and the said development
agreement was also got cancelled by them. Hence the role of Shri Marri
Nagaraja Kumar and Shri Marri Satish Babu did not emerge in the
investigation and hence they are not charge-sheeted. Accordingly, their
names are shown in column No.12 of Charge-sheet proforma.”
18.While the CBI proceedings operate in a different field and the
charge-sheet does not, by itself, determine the Bank's proceedings, the said
finding is plainly relevant to the question whether the petitioners personally
siphoned or diverted the funds.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
19. There is a material distinction between establishing that the
borrowing company failed to account for sale proceeds in accordance with the
lending arrangement and establishing that the petitioners themselves
siphoned or diverted those proceeds. The former does not, without further
evidence, establish the latter. In the absence of material showing receipt,
utilisation, participation, consent or connivance on the part of the petitioners,
the necessary individual nexus is not established.
20. The limited tenure of the petitioners in the company and their
assertion that they did not participate in its day-to-day financial affairs are
also relevant circumstances. More importantly, those circumstances are not
displaced by any cogent material demonstrating that the petitioners knowingly
participated in the alleged diversion of funds.
21. Even assuming, for the sake of consideration, that the petitioners
cannot claim the protection applicable specifically to non-executive or nonwhole-time directors, that circumstance by itself does not alter the position.
The observations contained in the CBI charge-sheet that the petitioners did
not receive the loan proceeds or sale proceeds, coupled with the absence of
material establishing their knowledge, participation, consent or connivance, do
not furnish a sufficient basis to classify them individually as wilful defaulters.
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
22. The existence of guarantee documents, even if assumed to create
contractual liability in accordance with law, stands on a different footing.
Contractual liability for the debt cannot be equated with personal participation
in siphoning or diversion of the borrower's funds. A guarantee cannot
substitute for the individual factual finding required for classification as a
wilful defaulter.
23. Thus, the material on record may establish financial default by the
borrowing company or irregularities in dealing with its funds, but it does not
establish, to the requisite standard, that the petitioners themselves siphoned
or diverted the funds or knowingly permitted or connived in such diversion.
The Bank has failed to substantiate the essential allegation that the
petitioners had knowledge of the alleged siphoning or diversion.
24. Wilful default cannot be attributed to an individual merely by reason
of his association with a defaulting company. An individualised finding
supported by objective material is necessary. In the present case, such
material is absent. The observations in the CBI charge-sheet, particularly
regarding non-receipt of the loan and sale proceeds by the petitioners,
reinforce the absence of such individual nexus.
25. Consequently, this Court is of the considered view that the
petitioners cannot be classified or declared as wilful defaulters on the material
RC,J
W.P.Nos.34330/2025 & 9958/2026
presently
available.
classify/declare
the
The
impugned
petitioners
as
proceedings,
wilful
insofar
defaulters,
are
as
they
therefore
unsustainable and are set aside.
26. It is clarified that this order is confined to the individual
classification of the petitioners as wilful defaulters and shall not preclude the
respondent-Bank from pursuing such remedies as may otherwise be available
in law against the borrowing company or any person against whom
independent and legally sustainable material exists.
27. Accordingly, the writ petitions are disposed of. There shall be no
order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
1st September, 2026
____________________________
JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
RR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review