Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
$
%
"
!#
"
!
& %
'
!"#
$
%
&
!
'
(
(
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(
)
(
!"#
#
%
)
(
*
'
)
(
!"#
$
%
&
'
-2-
##,
)
)
(
(
##+
(
(
#! " #"#
(
"#
#"#
(
'
(
%
)
*
*
(
)
.
&
)/01 012 3456250 47 8401 012 9:;0/26 012 <:002; /6
0:=25 >9 74; 7/5:? @/6946:?
#
C>:61
#! "
1/6 920/0/45 /6 7/?2@ 8A 012 920/0/452; 622=/5B 04
#"#
/<9>B52@
9:662@ 8A ;26945@250
920/0/452; 7;4<
-
4;@2;
:?:8>;:B/
/60;/30 04
2D02;5<250
@:02@
4 # 2D02;5/5B 012
:/31>; )260
0 /6 012 3450250/45 47 ?2:;52@ 34>562? 74; 012
920/0/452; 01:0 ;26945@250
5692304; 47
4 # ;232/E2@ : ;294;0 7;4< 012
4?/32 47 (:;1:0:8:@
4?/32
0:0/45 ;2B:;@/5B
/5E4?E2<250 47 012 920/0/452; /5 012 4772532 9>5/61:8?2
-3-
>5@2;
230/45
614;0
G012
47 012
:;5:0:=:
30 47 !F+-H'
4 # /66>2@ 540/32 >5@2;
12;2:702;
6>8</002@ 1/6 ;29?A
:531:A:0
7:</?A
30 !F+- %74;
5 9>;6>:532 47 012 ;294;0
;26945@250
!F+-
4?/32
230/45
920/0/452;
47 012
:992:;2@
345025@/5B 01:0 12
/6
:
:5@
;:<
2<82; 47 (/;4I:8:@ :5@ 12 /6 7;4< : 944;
?2:@/5B 1/6 ?/72 8A @4/5B 344?/2 J4;= :5@ :?64
/5E4?E2@ /5 94?/0/36 7;4< #"!" :5@ 34502602@ 2?230/456
12;2 :;2 54 62;/4>6 3;/</5:? 3:626 :B:/560 012 920/0/452;
0 /6 :?64 345025@2@ 01:0 012 920/0/452; 1:@ :99;4:312@
01/6
4>;0 74; ;2<4E/5B 1/6 5:<2 7;4< 012 ;4J@A 61220 /5
);/0
20/0/45
4 #""+,- #"#
J1/31 3:<2 04 82 :??4J2@
E/@2 4;@2; @:02@ #" "- #"#
0 /6 7>;012; 345025@2@ 8A
012 ?2:;52@ 34>562? 74; 012 920/0/452; 01:0 :0 012 821260 47
/?? J/612;6
012 ;26945@2506 1:E2 ;2B/602;2@ 7:?62 3:626
:B:/560 012 920/0/452;
12 6:/@ 3:626 :;2 925@/5B 2E25 0/??
04@:A 8>0 5452 47 012 3:626 :;2 9;4E2@ 4; 260:8?/612@ 04
614J 01:0 012 920/0/452; /6 B>/?0A 47 :5A 4772532
0 /6
345025@2@ 8A 012 ?2:;52@ 34>562? 74; 012 920/0/452; 01:0
-4-
:BB;/2E2@ 8A 012 /<9>B52@ 4;@2; 012 920/0/452; /5/0/:??A
7/?2@ :
;/</5:?
2E/6/45
20/0/45
4 #""" , #"#
6:/@ 920/0/45 3:<2 04 82 @/69462@ 47 @/;230/5B 012
920/0/452; 04 :99;4:31 012 :99;49;/:02 74;><
334;@/5B?A
01/6 920/0/45 /6 7/?2@
2:;52@ 34>562? 7>;012;
/<9>B52@ 4;@2; 9:662@ 8A ;26945@250
345025@6 01:0 012
4 # :0
552D>;2
/6 /??2B:? :5@ 540 /5 345645:532 J/01 012 ?:J :6 9;4E/@2@
>5@2;
230/45
47 012
30 47 !F+-
0 /6 7>;012;
345025@2@ 01:0 012 ;26945@2506 1:E2 540 34<2 04 : 9;492;
49/5/45 :6 04 J12012; 012 3:62 /560/0>02@ :B:/560 012
920/0/452; /6 0;>017>? 4; 9;4E2@ /5 :5A
4>;0 47 ?:J 64 :?64
012;2 /6 54 <:02;/:? 8274;2 012 ;26945@2506 :>014;/0/26 04
614J 01:0 012 920/0/452; 1:6 25@:5B2;2@ 9>8?/3 92:32 :5@
0;:5C>/?/0A
:6 /0 /6 45?A : <2;2 :99;21256/45 47 012
;26945@2506
0:02
0 /6 :?64 7>;012; 345025@2@ 01:0 012
9;4E/6/456 47
230/45
47 012
30 47 !F+- 3:5 82 /5E4=2@
45?A /5 ;:;2 3:626 J12;2 92;6456 :;2 345E/302@ 01;/32
J/01/5 01;22 A2:;6
5 012 9;26250 3:62 920/0/452; /6 540 :0
-5-
:?? 345E/302@ 74; :5A 4772532
2 :?64 345025@6 01:0 4>0 47
7/E2 3:626 920/0/452; 1:6 8225 :3C>/002@ /5 01;22 3:626
:5@ /5 0J4 3:626K 012 31:;B2 /6 A20 04 82 7;:<2@
0 /6
7>;012;
345025@2@
01:0
;26945@250
4#
1:6
3456/@2;2@ 9;492;?A 012 48L230/456 7/?2@ 8A 012 920/0/452;
:5@ J/014>0 E2;/7A/5B 012 6:<2 :5@ 012;2 82/5B :5A 9;447
47 :5A 6>31 :??2B:0/456
012 /<9>B52@ 4;@2; /6 9:662@
J/014>0 9;492; :99?/3:0/45 47 </5@
0 /6 :?64 345025@2@
01:0 012 920/0/452; /6 012 64?2 2:;5/5B <2<82;
2 /6 :
;269456/8?2 92;645 /5 012 643/20A :5@ B;2:0 1:;@61/9 J4>?@
82 3:>62@ 04 1/< :5@ 1/6 7:</?A /7 12 /6 2D02;52@ 7;4< 452
3/0A 04 012 4012;
0 /6 :?64 345025@2@ 01:0 012 920/0/452; /6 7:?62?A
/<9?/3:02@ J/014>0 012;2 82/5B :5A 2E/@2532 :5@ 01:0 012
614J 3:>62 540/32 /66>2@ 8A ;26945@250
4 # /6 540
:334<9:5/2@ 8A 012 94?/32 ;294;0 :5@ 45?A 8:?@ :??2B:0/456
:;2 <:@2
5 01262 B;4>5@6
12 622=6 04 :??4J 01/6
920/0/45 :5@ 620 :6/@2 012 /<9>B52@ 4;@2;
-6-
+
?2:;52@
@@/0/45:?
4E2;5<250
@E43:02 345025@6 01:0 >945 /66>:532 47 012 540/32 >5@2;
230/45
47 012
30 47 !F+- :5@ ;232/E/5B 012 ;29?A :5@
48L230/456 8A 012 920/0/452; 012 920/0/452; J:6 9;4E/@2@
:5 4994;0>5/0A 47 12:;/5B :5@ :?64 :@@>3/5B 2E/@2532
12;2:702;
;26945@250
4#
>945
25C>/;A
92;>6:? 47 012 @43><2506 <:;=2@ :0
D1/8/0
D1/8/0
:?64
! :5@
# 1:6 34<2 04 : 3453?>6/45 01:0 012 2D02;5<250
/6 523266:;A /5 012 9;26250 3:62 45 1:5@
:66/B52@
8A
9:;:B;:91
46 !" 04 ! J1/31 ;2:@ :6 >5@2;
;26945@250
!" # !
$ "%
&'( ) *+,
#
4#
:;2
12 ;2:6456
74;0134</5B
() *
01,
+ ,, -
4 5 =
;)
:0
$ "%
!
< ;
:5@
./ (
78) 9 :
78) 92 :
;)
"#$
%& '
01,2
;)
+ 0 03
;
)
-7-
&&( !"-." " /
/!
01 /
) >? ) 03
1 ( BD
'
&4( ! -
@ 6 =2
A
"6 " 7!8"
$ "
F6 6 ) )
) =
EJH B
* L
M
&9(
: !
#$
)
#
$ "%
@ 6
B?
G
;
" K
@ J 6
B
;
A"
"-+3
;
$ "+ <
OP
" =7
) = L
&
")$
)
A#
:%= )
MH
S ?=
)Q8
) =
*
! W'
X
Q
I Y
$
C 1 D "
&>(
?@A!" B
FG(
=
N%
I%3%N
"H0+ I J
)Q
@) =
J ' [ )
\E)
#$
S
<
@
=
EJH Q
EJH
* L
=
M
@ 6
K'4L4'49 !
%&'M
# ;$+E%
"
3%G%
I%
+ 1 0
0 Z
) X
#$
)
?=
)^ E G )%B : % &)_ '
;
B
B
BA% &)_ '
;
\
; &)_
<aO
:
;)
" )9
+ 3 01 0 b
)
)Q
;
M) () 3 Q ) R J
#$NVE
;
EJH
$ "%
)
) >? '
)
'
M
;)
# #$ H I
N F
TU B A
#$
C) =
;
$
)$ " E
N
%
Q
) =
& ]
` 32000
& ) BTU) 9
$
#)
-8-
c@
B
1b 0 b
( BD
') 9
<aO
N
) =
E
'
02000
B ) A #$Q8) 9 H S
%
\
% Zb12Z Z230b 30R dD82
!%= e
) `
0 b
) ) A #$Q8) 9 :
F (
=
N%
I%3%N
@) =
J ' [ )
\E)
)^ E G )%B
: %
B
" 3%G%
+ 0 0
&)_ '
) X
#$
)
)Q
" )9
B
RZ 0 b
;
N
%
<aO
E
'
) =
!%= e
) `
+0 0g 0 b
,
12;274;2
32000
\
Q
) =
& ]
%
; &)_
<aO
+1, 03 0 b
)
1bZ2 1b,2 1bf2 Z0,2
') 9
<aO
;)
C !%= e
"< @
B
) A
) ) A #$Q8) 9 :
%
`
= ( BD
)9 :
@) =
N
%&'M
B
)Q
; 6 C !%= e
C
+0 0b
?=
;
;)
c@
<aO
K'OL4'4> !
0 b
Z Z2 Z b2 30b2 30R dD8
\
I
&)_ '
#)
)9
;) X
;)
BA%
& ) BTU) 9 :
)9 :
"< @
"H0+ I J
)Q
12002000
; 6 C !%= e
=
345025@6
)Q ) X
)9
<aO
#$Q8) 9
)Q
C
;) h
01:0
012;2
/6
9;432@>;:? /;;2B>?:;/0A 4; E/4?:0/45 47 :5A 47 012 9;4E/6/456
<4;2 6923/7/3:??A
230/45
47 012
30 47 !F+-
345025@6 01:0 012 920/0/45 /6 540 <:/50:/5:8?2 74; 012
-9-
;2:645 01:0 012 920/0/452; 1:6 540 2E25 J1/692;2@ J/01
;2B:;@ 04 9;432@>;:? /;;2B>?:;/0/26 :5@ 12 1:6 8225
9;4E/@2@ 6>/0:8?2 4994;0>5/0A 47 ;29?A
7/?/5B 48L230/456
12:;/5B :5@ :@@>3/5B 2E/@2532 :5@ 8:62@ 45 J1/31 9;492;
;2:6456 :;2 B/E25 :5@ 012 /<9>B52@ 4;@2; J:6 9:662@
J1/31 @426 540 3:?? 74; :5A /502;72;2532
47 012
30 47 !F+-
6 92;
230/45
F
:5A 92;645 :BB;/2E2@ 8A :5 4;@2;
<:@2 >5@2;
230/456
4;
+ 47 012
:992:? 04 012
4E2;5<250 J/01/5 01/;0A @:A6 7;4< 012 @:02
47 6>31 4;@2;
5 012 9;26250 3:62 54 6>31 :992:? /6 7/?2@
:@</002@?A 8A 012 920/0/452;
30 47 !F+- <:A
12;274;2
012 9;26250
920/0/45 J4>?@ 540 82 6>60:/5:8?2
2:;@ ?2:;52@ 34>562? 74; 012 920/0/452; :5@
?2:;52@
@@/0/45:?
4E2;5<250
@E43:02
J14 :332906
540/32 74; 012 ;26945@2506
F
:E/5B 12:;@ 012
?2:;52@
34>562? 74; 012
9:;0/26 /0 /6 2E/@250 7;4< 012 ;234;@6 01:0 012 920/0/452;
1:6 540 /5E4=2@ 012 9;4E/6/456 47
230/45
!F+- 04 31:??25B2 012 4;@2; 9:662@ >5@2;
F 47 012
30 47
230/45
- 10 -
30 47 !F+- 2D02;5/5B 012 920/0/452; 7;4<
:/31>;
:?:8>;:B/ 04
0 /6 :?64 523266:;A 04 <250/45 01:0 012 540/32 /6
/66>2@ ;29?A /6 :332902@ :5@ 4994;0>5/0A 47 12:;/5B :5@
:@@>3/5B 2E/@2532
5@2; 6>31 3/;3><60:5326
4994;0>5/0A 1:6 8225 B/E25 04 012 920/0/452;
: 7>??
5 3:;27>?
92;>6:? 47 012 B;4>5@6 <:@2 4>0 8A 012 920/0/452; /0 /6
6225 01:0 012 920/0/452; 1:6 540 60:02@ :5A01/5B J/01
;2B:;@
9;432@>;:?
;26945@2506 :>014;/0/26
/;;2B>?:;/0/26
74??4J2@
8A
5@2; 012 3/;3><60:5326
45?A ;2<2@A :E:/?:8?2 04 012 920/0/452; J4>?@ 82 04 7/?2 :5
:992:? :6 34502<9?:02@ >5@2;
230/45
!F+-
230/45 +" 47 012
0 /6 :?64 6225 01:0
F 47 012
30 47
34502<9?:026 012 7/5:?/0A 47 4;@2;6 :5@ /0 61:?? 540 82
3:??2@ /5 C>260/45 2D3290 45 012 B;4>5@ 01:0 012 :>014;/0A
<:=/5B 012 4;@2; 4; :5A 477/32; :>014;/62@ 8A /0 1:@ 540
74??4J2@ 012 9;432@>;2 ?:/@ @4J5 /5 6>8 6230/45 %!' 47
230/45
47 012
30 47 !F+- 4; 01:0 012;2 J:6 54
<:02;/:? :E:/?:8?2 8274;2 012 34532;52@ :>014;/0A 04 9:66
- 11 -
6>31 /<9>B52@ 4;@2; J1/31 /6 540 012 3:62 /5 012 9;26250
920/0/45
1/6 920/0/45 /6 @2E4/@ 47 <2;/06
!"
334;@/5B?A
%:'
12 );/0
9;4322@ 04 9:66 012 74??4J/5B
20/0/45 /6 @/69462@ 47 ;262;E/5B ?/82;0A
04 012 920/0/452; 04 9;272; :5 :992:? /7 :@E/62@
>5@2;
230/45
F 47 012
:;5:0:=:
30 !F+%8'
;@2;2@ :334;@/5B?A
()
&
!
"
/60
!
?
#-
'
4?/32
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review