The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In our view, the father has not made out any case that his son’s custody with the mother is in anyway illegal or unlawful. As observed above, a coordinate bench has already noticed upon an interaction with the child that it is comfortable with the mother and, it is therefore clear that the welfare of the child is not at risk. There is, thus, absolutely no justi cation for entertaining this writ petition. The petition is, therefore, DISMISSED. Notice is discharged.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
Reserved On
: 10/11/2025
Pronounced On : 05/12/2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION (HABEAS CORPUS) NO. 16418 of
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.S.SANJAY GOWDA
Sd/-
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE D. M. VYAS
Sd/-
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
MANSUKHBHAI ANANDBHAI NAVADIYA
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR BM MANGUKIYA(437) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MS BELA A PRAJAPATI(1946) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MS MONALI H BHATT, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
VISHAL K ANANDJIWALA(7798) for the Respondent(s) No. 4,5
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.S.SANJAY GOWDA
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE D. M. VYAS
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.S.SANJAY GOWDA)
1.
Mansukhbhai
Anandbhai
referred to as the ‘father’) has
Navadiya
(hereinafter
led this petition seeking
for a direction to the respondents to secure the custody of
his minor son Harshvardhan and to produce him before
the Court.
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
2.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
It is the admitted case of the father that he married
the Komalben-mother (hereinafter referred to as the
‘mother’) on 8.12.2015 and out of this wedlock, a son,
named Harshvardhan, was born on 25.8.2019 and he is
presently aged about 6 years.
3.
It is also admitted that the father and the mother got
separated in the year 2022. The father, in fact, alleges
that his wife (the mother) had deserted him.
4.
It is also admitted by the father that the mother (his
wife) has initiated multiple proceedings against him,
namely proceedings seeking for maintenance under
Section
of
the
Code
of
Criminal
Procedure,
applications for recovery of arrears of maintenance,
applications
under
the
Protection
of
Women
from
Domestic Violence Act and also a criminal complaint
which has resulted in the registration of an FIR for the
o8ences punishable under Sections 498A, 232, 506(2)
and 114 of the Indian Penal Code read with Sections 3
and 7 of the Dowry Prohibition Act.
5.
The
father
contends
that
respondent
No.4-
Bharatbhai Labhubhai Moradiya has forcefully taken his
son and his wife and has detained them illegally.
6.
From the petition’s averment itself, it is clear that
there is a marital discord between the father and the
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
mother and there are multiple proceedings between them
relating to the grant of maintenance and there are also
the criminal cases under the provisions of the D.V. Act
and the Dowry Prohibition Act. Signi cantly, it is also
admitted that the father and the mother are residing
separately since the year 2022.
7.
The mother has
led an a8idavit-in-reply, in which
she has also admitted that she and her son are living
separately from the father since 2022. She has also
contended that it was the father who had deserted her
and her son, and he did not even bother to inquire about
the welfare of the son though when they got separated,
her son was only aged about 2 years.
8.
It is also alleged that the father has not bothered
towards the upkeep of the son and has not paid any sums
as maintenance to her. It is speci cally stated by the
mother that the present petition seeking for the writ of
Habeas Corpus is only to harass her and to ensure that
she does not press her claim for maintenance.
9.
The Apex Court in the case of Tejaswinin Gaud and
others v. Shekhar Jagdish Prasad Tewari and others
reported in (2019) 7 SCC 42, has held as follows:
“14. Writ of habeas corpus is a prerogative process for
securing the liberty of the subject by a8ording an
e8ective means o mmediate release from an illegal
or improper detention. The writ also extends its
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
inCuence to restore the custody of a minor to his
guardian when wrongfully deprived of it. The
detention of a minor by a person who is not entitled
to his legal custody is treated as equivalent to illegal
detention for the purpose of granting writ, directing
custody of the minor child. For restoration of the
custody of a minor from a person who according to
the personal law, is not his legal or natural
guardian, in appropriate cases, the writ court has
jurisdiction.
19.
Habeas corpus proceedings is not to justify or
examine the legality of the custody. Habeas corpus
proceedings is a medium through which the custody
of the child is addressed to the discretion of the
court. Habeas corpus is a prerogative writ which is
an extraordinary remedy and the writ is issued
where in the circumstances of the particular case,
ordinary remedy provided by the law is either not
available or is ine8ective; otherwise a writ will not
be issued. In child custody matters, the power of the
High Court in granting the writ is quali ed only in
cases where the detention of a minor by a person
who is not entitled to his legal custody. In view of
the pronouncement on the issue in question by the
Supreme Court and the High Courts, in our view, in
child custody matters, the writ of habeas corpus is
maintainable where it is proved that the detention
of a minor child by a parent or others was illegal
and without any authority of law.
20.
In child custody matters, the ordinary remedy lies
only under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship
Act or the Guardians and Wards Act as the case may
be. In cases arising out of the proceedings under
the Guardians and Wards Act, the jurisdiction of the
court is determined by whether the minor ordinarily
resides within the area on which the court exercises
such jurisdiction. There are signi cant di8erences
between the enquiry under the Guardians and
Wards Act and the exercise of powers by a writ
court which is of summary in nature. What is
important is the welfare of the child. In the writ
court, rights are determined only on the basis of
a8idavits. Where the court is of the view that a
detailed enquiry is required, the court may decline
to exercise the extraordinary jurisdiction and direct
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
the parties to approach the civil court. It is only in
exceptional cases, the rights of the parties to the
custody of the minor will be determined in exercise
of extraordinary jurisdiction on a petition for habeas
corpus.”
This view of the Supreme Court has been reiterated in
subsequent judgment rendered by the Apex Court in the
case of Nirmala v. Kulwant Singh and others reported in
(2024) 10 SCC 595. The Supreme Court has, in fact, has
held thus:
“22.
This Court in the case of Tejaswini Gaud and others
(supra) after considering the earlier cases, observed
thus:
“19. Habeas corpus proceedings is not to justify or
examine the legality of the custody. Habeas corpus
proceedings is a medium through which the
custody of the child is addressed to the discretion
of the Court. Habeas corpus is a prerogative writ
which is an extraordinary remedy and the writ is
issued where in the circumstances of the
particular case, ordinary remedy provided by the
law is either not available or is ine8ective;
otherwise a writ will not be issued. In child
custody matters, the power of the High Court in
granting the writ is quali ed only in cases where
the detention of a minor by a person who is not
entitled to his legal custody. In view of the
pronouncement on the issue in question by the
Supreme Court and the High Courts, in our view,
in child custody matters, the writ of habeas corpus
is maintainable where it is proved that the
detention of a minor child by a parent or others
was illegal and without any authority of law.
20. In child custody matters, the ordinary remedy lies
only under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship
Act or the Guardians and Wards Act as the case
may be. In cases arising out of the proceedings
under the Guardians and Wards Act, the
jurisdiction of the court is determined by whether
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
the minor ordinarily resides within the area on
which the court exercises such jurisdiction. There
are signi cant di8erences between the enquiry
under the Guardians and Wards Act and the
exercise of powers by a writ court which is
summary in nature. What is important is the
welfare of the child. In the writ court, rights are
determined only on the basis of a8idavits. Where
the court is of the view that a detailed enquiry is
required, the court may decline to exercise the
extraordinary jurisdiction and direct the parties to
approach the civil court. It is only in exceptional
cases, the rights of the parties to the custody of
the minor will be determined in exercise of
extraordinary jurisdiction on a petition for habeas
corpus.
21. In the present case, the appellants are the sisters
and brother of the mother Zelam who do not have
any authority of law to have the custody of the
minor child. Whereas as per Section 6 of the Hindu
Minority and Guardianship Act, the
rst
respondent father is a natural guardian of the
minor child and is having the legal right to claim
the custody of the child. The entitlement of father
to the custody of child is not disputed and the child
being a minor aged 1½ years cannot express its
intelligent preferences. Hence, in our considered
view, in the facts and circumstances of this case,
the father, being the natural guardian, was
justi ed in invoking the extraordinary remedy
seeking custody of the child under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.”
23. It can thus be seen that this Court has held that the
habeas corpus is a prerogative writ which is an
extraordinary remedy. It has been held that recourse to
such a remedy should not be permitted unless the
ordinary remedy provided by the law is either not
available or is ine8ective. It has been held that in child
custody matters, the power of the High Court in granting
the writ is quali ed only in cases where the detention of a
minor by a person who is not entitled to his legal custody.
It has further been held that in child custody matters, the
writ of habeas corpus is maintainable where it is proved
that the detention of a minor child by a parent or others
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
was illegal and without any authority of law.
24. This Court further held that in child custody matters, the
ordinary remedy lies only under the Hindu Minority and
Guardianship Act or the Guardians and Wards Act as the
case may be. It has been held that there are signi cant
di8erences between the enquiry under the Guardians and
Wards Act and the exercise of powers by a writ court
which is summary in nature. It has further been held that
what is important is the welfare of the child. It has been
further held that where the court is of the view that a
detailed enquiry is required, the court may decline to
exercise the extraordinary jurisdiction and direct the
parties to approach the civil court.
25. In the facts of the said case, this Court found that the
child being a minor, aged 1½ years, cannot express its
intelligent preferences and in the facts and circumstances
of said case, the father being the natural guardian was
justi ed in invoking the extraordinary remedy seeking
custody of the child under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India.
26. The same legal position has been reiterated by this Court
in the cases of Jose Antonio Zalba Diez Del Corral alias
Jose Antonio Zalba (supra) and Rajeswari Chandrasekar
Ganesh vs. State of Tamil Nadu and others.
27. It can thus be seen that no hard and fast rule can be laid
down insofar as the maintainability of a habeas corpus
petition in the matters of custody of a minor child is
concerned. As to whether the writ court should exercise
its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India or not will depend on the facts and
circumstances of each case.”
10. In the light of the said declaration of law, a parent of
a minor child does not have a legal right to invoke the
extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court under Art
226 and seek for a writ of habeas corpus and it is solely
within the domain of the High Courts to the exercise the
habeas corpus jurisdiction in their discretion and the
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
same would be dependent on the facts of each case.
11. However, learned counsel Mr. B.M. Mangukiya
appearing on behalf of the father has strenuously
contended
that
the
Court
is obliged
to
take
into
consideration the welfare of the child and a writ petition
led seeking for issuance of writ of Habeas Corpus would
have to be entertained. He submits that the mother is in a
live-in-relationship
with
respondent
No.4
and
this
relationship would have a detrimental e8ect on the minor
son. He submits that in view of this peculiar situation,
this would be an appropriate case for this Court to issue a
writ of Habeas Corpus to cause the production of his
minor son and also to handover the custody of the child to
him.
12. It is contended that the welfare of the child would be
safeguarded if the custody of the child is given to him and
on the contrary, if the mother is allowed to retain the
custody of the child, it would be detrimental to the
welfare of the child.
13. It may be pertinent to state here that after the
conclusion of the oral arguments, though the Learned
Counsel for the father had been granted time to
le his
written arguments, the learned counsel has not chosen to
le any written arguments.
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
14. It may be pertinent to state that during pendency of
this writ petition, this Court had directed the mother to
appear personally along with her minor son. A co-ordinate
Bench of this Court had interacted with mother and the
minor
son
and
had
observed
that
the
child
was
comfortable with the mother.
15. It must be stated here that the custody of a 6-yearold boy with his biological mother would always be lawful
custody and can never be construed as an illegal
con nement of a minor. In fact, it is not even the case of
the father that the mother secured the custody of his son
unlawfully or in violation of any provision or any order of
the Court. The father in his petition merely asserts that
his wife has deserted him way back in the year 2022. The
mother, on the other hand, contends to the contrary, that
the father had deserted her and her son. It is, therefore,
clear that the custody of the biological mother of the 6
year old son cannot be termed as illegal or unlawful in
any manner.
16. As observed above, the Apex Court has categorically
held that the Habeas Corpus proceedings are not meant
to examine the legality of the custody and it is a medium
through which the custody of a child is addressed at the
discretion of the Court. It has also been held that Habeas
Corpus is a prerogative writ which is an extraordinary
remedy and cannot be invoked for the mere asking of the
R/SCR.A/16418/2024
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 05/12/2025
either of the parents and the normal and proper remedy
would be to approach the appropriate Court under the
relevant law and make out a case that welfare is better
served if the custody is handed over to the parent
claiming custody.
17. In our view, the father has not made out any case
that his son’s custody with the mother is in anyway illegal
or unlawful. As observed above, a coordinate bench has
already noticed upon an interaction with the child that it
is comfortable with the mother and, it is therefore clear
that the welfare of the child is not at risk. There is, thus,
absolutely no justi cation for entertaining this writ
petition. The petition is, therefore, DISMISSED. Notice is
discharged.
18. It is needless to state that it would be always open
for the father to initiate appropriate proceeding(s) under
the relevant law seeking for the custody of his minor son.
Sd/(N.S.SANJAY GOWDA,J)
Sd/(D. M. VYAS, J)
OMKAR
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review