Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:437
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHASH UPADHYAY
WRIT PETITION (S/S) NO.2261 OF 2017
2nd January, 2026
Manoj Kumar
...Petitioner.
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Others
Counsel for the petitioner
Counsel for the respondents
:
:
Counsel for respondent no.4
:
…Respondents.
Mr. Anil Kumar Joshi, learned counsel.
Mr. Navin Tewari, Brief Holder for the
State of Uttarakhand.
Mr. S.S. Negi, learned counsel holding
brief of Mr. B.S. Negi, learned counsel.
JUDGMENT: (per Mr. Subhash Upadhyay, J.)
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner
and learned counsel for the State of Uttarakhand.
2.
This writ petition has been filed with the
following prayers:
“i) Issue a writ order or direction in the nature of mandamus
commanding the respondents to pay the salary to the
petitioner from the date of including the school S.R.D.
Bahuguna Inter College, Sevelakala, Dehradun under the
Grant-In-Aid i.e. 28.2.2014.
ii) Issue any other or further writ, order or direction which
this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the
circumstances of the case.
iii) To award the cost of the petition in favour of the
petitioner.”
3.
The facts narrated in the writ petition are as
follows:
The
petitioner
was
appointed
as
an
Assistant Teacher on 03.07.2012 at the SRD
Bahuguna Inter College, Sevelakala, Dehradun.
The
said
institute
is
recognized
2026:UHC:437
by
the
Uttarakhand Education Board and was run by
the
Committee
of
Management.
The
Government of Uttarakhand took a decision to
include the said institute into grant-in-aid and a
notification dated 28.02.2014 was issued to the
said effect.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the salary to the petitioner was not paid
w.e.f. 28.02.2014 and as such he submitted a
representation on 01.04.2017 for the payment
of salary and when no decision was taken on
the said representation then the present writ
petition was filed.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
as per Section 50 of the Uttarakhand School Education
Act, 2006, the liability in respect of salary of the teaching
and non-teaching staff is of the State Government.
Section 50 of the Uttarakhand School Education Act, 2006
reads as under:
“Section 50- Liability in respect of salary:(1) The State
Government shall be liable for payment of salaries of
teachers and employees of every institution receiving
maintenance grant from the State Government due in
respect of any period from the date of the commencement of
this Act
(2) The State Government may recover any amount in
respect of which any liability is incurred by it under sub-
2026:UHC:437
section (1) by attachment of the income from the property
belonging to or vested in the Institution as if that amount
were an arrear of land revenue due from the institution
receiving maintenance grant from the State Government.
(3) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to derogate from
the liability of the institution for any such dues to the
teacher or employee.”
5.
Learned counsel for the respondents, however,
submits that the posts were not sanctioned vide order
dated 28.02.2014 which is a condition prerequisite and
the institute was thereafter taken under token grant vide
GO dated 01.02.2016 as such petitioner is not liable to be
paid salary w.e.f. 28.02.2014.
6.
In reply, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that there is no provision of token grant and vide
notification dated 28.02.2014 when the institute was
taken into grant-in-aid the posts were also created in the
institute. He submits that after filing of the writ petition,
the
Government
notification
dated
of
Uttarakhand
28.02.2019
issued
wherein
the
another
earlier
Government Order by which the institute was taken into
token grant was obliterated and the Government Order
dated 28.02.2014 was never cancelled.
7.
He
circumstances,
further
the
submits
State
that
Government
in
similar
has
issued
notifications wherein the institutes which were earlier
taken into grant-in-aid were put into token grant and the
said order of putting the said institute into token grant
2026:UHC:437
was challenged in WPMS No.1820 of 2017. The said
decision of the State Government of taking institutes into
token grant was declared to be in contravention to the
provisions of Section 50 of the Uttarakhand School
Education Act. The said order was put into challenge in
SPA No.166 of 2019, however, the same was dismissed
vide order dated 17.08.2022 and the respondents have
complied with the orders passed by the Court.
8.
Learned counsel for the State was granted an
opportunity to clarify as to how the case of the petitioner
is distinguishable from the order passed by the Writ Court
as affirmed in the special appeal and it has been
submitted that the case reliance on which has been
placed by the petitioner is distinguishable as in the said
case it is the institute which has come before the Court
whereas in the present case the petitioner’s institute had
accepted
the
subsequent
Government
Order
and,
thereafter, the petitioner has been adjusted vide order
dated 26.11.2019 and is paid salary from the said date.
The submission made in paragraph no.5 of the affidavit
reads as under:
“5.
…However, it is to be clarified that writ petition was
filed in the Hon'ble High Court by Manavta Higher Primary
School, Gandhinagar, Nainital Institution regarding grant-inaid recognition and financial assistance to its institution,
whereas the petition No. 2261/SS/2017 has been filed by
the petitioner himself regarding grant of financial benefits,
salary etc. to him from the date of issue of Government
Order No. 156 dated 28.02.2014. The said Government
Order was related to creation of posts for inclusion of non-
government recognized schools in the grant list.
2026:UHC:437
In the case involving Manavta Higher Primary School,
Gandhinagar, Nainital, a token grant was granted to the
school. The aforesaid school filed a petition seeking financial
assistance. However, the petitioner's school, Shri Ravi Dutt
Bahuguna Inter College, Dehradun, was included in the list
of high school grants by the Uttarakhand Government
through Government Order No. 302, dated 28.02.2019,
cancelling the token grant allowed to the school. Paragraph
2 of Government Order No. 302, dated 28.02.2019, clearly
states, "In view of the school fulfilling all the criteria for
inclusion in the high school grant list, the current financial
year has been extended by cancelling the token grant
allowed through Government Order No. 1657/GGPT.4/20166(33)/2015, dated 21.12.2016 approval is granted for
inclusion in the list of salary grants at the high school level,
based on the budget provision available under the relevant
standard item, from the year 2018-19. (Annexure-2, page10 of Miscellaneous Application No. 15456/2025)
Shri Ravi Dutt Bahuguna Inter College, Dehradun,
while accepting the financial grant, submitted the file for
financial adjustment of the working teachers, in which, after
examining the desired educational and training qualification
of the petitioner, the petitioner has been adjusted to the
concerned post by the order letter dated 26.11.2019 of the
then Chief Education Officer, Dehradun.”
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the record.
10.
The undisputed facts in the present case are
that the writ petitioner was appointed in the year 2012 as
an Assistant Teacher and his services have been absorbed
vide order dated
26.11.2019 passed by the Chief
Education Officer, Dehradun as Assistant Teacher LT
Grade Mathematics. Thus, there is no dispute that the
petitioner possessed the requisite qualification for the
post and his initial appointment in the year 2012 by the
Committee of Management was as such in accordance
with law.
11.
The issue involved in the present writ petition is
2026:UHC:437
that as to whether the writ petitioner was entitled for
salary w.e.f. 28.02.2014 when the institute was taken
into grant-in-aid or is entitled for salary from the date of
issuance of absorption order dated 26.11.2019. In the
writ petition filed by an institute i.e. Manavta Higher
Primary School, Gandhinagar, the said institute was taken
into grant-in-aid on 04.02.2014, however, the same was
placed under token grant vide order dated 23.12.2016.
The said action of the respondent was put to challenge
and the Co-ordinate Bench of the Court allowed the writ
petition.
12.
The Hon’ble Court considered the concept of
token grant and held in paragraph no.6 as hereunder:
“6.
Even on repeated query of this Court seeking
explanation as to what is meant by a "token grant", the
learned State Counsel could not give any satisfactory reply.
The most glaring aspect of it all is that there is nothing like a
"token grant" as is now being given to the school vide order
dated 23.12.2016. To what purpose this "token grant" has
been given and under which provision has it been given, has
not been explained, except that it is mentioned in the
Government Order dated 04.01.2017.”
13.
Further in paragraph no.15 the Court held as
under:
“15. Under Section 50 of the Uttaranchal School Education
Act, 2006, it is the liability of the State Government to pay
salary of teachers and employees of every institution which
is under its grant-in-aid. This Court has absolutely no doubt
in its mind that as the present school, with which we are
concerned, has come under grant-in-aid on orders passed by
the executive head of the State ie. the Governor, hence, the
State Government cannot back track on its commitment and
its order.”
14.
The said order was put to challenge in special
appeal no.166 of 2019 and the Division Bench of this
2026:UHC:437
Court in paragraph no.7 held as under:-
“7) Having heard learned counsels and perused the record,
including the impugned judgment, we are not inclined to
interfere with the same. Firstly, the respondent school was
granted recognition, which recognition has not been
withdrawn or recalled. Secondly, on the basis of the said
recognition, the State Government has passed the order
dated 04.02.2014, sanctioning grant-in-aid in respect of the
respondent school. Even that order has not been recalled till
date, and continues to remain in force.”
15.
Coming to the facts of the present case, a
perusal of the grant-in-aid order dated 28.02.2014
reveals that the said Government Order has been issued
by which not only the said institute was placed under
grant-in-aid but post of Head Master and Assistant
Teacher was also created.
16.
The said fact is evident from a bare reading of
the order dated 28.02.2014 wherein while referring to the
various posts created at serial no.2 and serial no.6
whereby posts of Head Master and Assistant Teacher
were created, the following averment has been made:
dz0 la0
inuke
osru ¼#0 esa½
2-
iz/kkuk/;kid
¼gkbZLdwy½
lgk;d v/;kikd
¼b.Vj@gkbZLdwy½
15]600&39]100
xzsM is 5400
9300&34800 xzsM
is 4600
5-
17.
inksa dh la[;k
02 in ¼dz0la0&04 ,oa 09 ij vafdr fo|ky;
gsrq½A
27 in ¼dz0la0&02 04] 07 ,oa 09] ij vafdr
fo|ky; A
In the enclosure to the said Government Order
the name of the institute Ravidutt Bahuguna is shown at
serial no.9. Thus, there is no dispute that at the time of
issuance of the Government Order posts were also
created in the petitioner’s institute. Thus, the salaries for
2026:UHC:437
the aforementioned posts were to be paid by the State
Government and the said order of grant-in-aid has been
passed in the name of His Excellency the Governor of
Uttarakhand. The order of placing the institute into token
grant was obliterated by the order dated 28.02.2019 in
pursuance
of
which
the
petitioner’s
services
were
absorbed on 26.11.2019. The order dated 28.02.2019
reads as under:“la[;k @xxiv&4@2019&6¼15½@2014
izs"kd]
vkj ehuk{kh lqUnje~]
lfpo]
mÙkjk[k.M 'kkluA
lsok esa]
funs'kd]
ek/;fed f'k{kk]
mÙkjk[k.M] nsgjknwuA
ek/;fed f'k{kk vuqHkkx&4
nsgjknwu% fnukad 28 Qjojh] 2019
fo"k;% Jh jfo nÙk cgqx.q kk måekåfoå lsoykdyka] ektjk] nsgjknwu dks
gkbZLdwy Lrj ij osru vuqnku lwph esa lfEefyr fd;s tkus ds
lEcU/k esaA
egksn;]
mi;qZä fo"k;d 'kklukns'k la[;k & 156 @ 14 & xxiv & 4 &
6¼15½@2014 fnukad 28 Qjojh] 2014 ds lanHkZ esa vius i=kad
la[;k&ek/;fed@4259@2018&19 fnukad 11 ebZ] 2018 dk lanHkZ xzg.k
djus dk d"V djsaA
2bl lEcU/k esa eq>s ;g dgus dk funs'k gqvk gS fd lanHkZxr
fo|ky; dks gkbZLdwy Lrj ij osru vuqnku lwph esa lfEefyr fd;s tkus
gsrq fo|ky; }kjk leLr ekudksa dh iwfrZ fd;s tkus ds –f"Vxr 'kklukns'k
la[;k&1657@xxiv&4@2016&6¼33½@2015 fnukad 21 fnlEcj] 2016 ds
ek/;e ls vuqeU; Vksdu vuqnku dks foyksfir djrs gq, pkyw foÙkh; o"kZ
2018&19 ls laxr ekud en esa miyC/k ctV çkfo/kku ds lkis{k gkbZLdwy
Lrj ij osru vuqnku dh lwph esa lfEefyr fd;s tkus dh Loh—fr çnku
dh tkrh gSA
3mä of.kZr 'kklukns'k la[;k & 156 @ 14 & xxiv & 4 &
6¼15½@2014 fnukad 28 Qjojh] 2014 esa mfYyf[kr 'ks"k% 'krsZa ;Fkkor
jgsaxhA
Hkonh;]
2026:UHC:437
¼vkj ehuk{kh lqUnje~½
lfpo A””
18.
The said order dated 28.02.2019 in unequivocal
terms specifies that the GO dated 28.02.2014 is not
cancelled and on the contrary it provides that the other
conditions of the Government Order dated 28.02.2014
would remain intact. The claim of the petitioner for
payment of salary w.e.f. 28.02.2014 i.e. from the
issuance of the GO thus cannot be denied by the
respondents for their own fault.
19.
The
28.02.2014
State
had
Government
sanctioned
vide
the
posts
GO
and
dated
the
respondents were required to go ahead with the process
of formal absorption of the services of the petitioner.
However,
the
respondents
decided
to
place
the
petitioner’s institute into token grant as was done in
similar other cases. The said decision of the respondents
to place the similarly situated institute under token grant
was found to be improper and the writ petition filed by
the aforesaid institute was allowed.
20.
Thus, the mere fact that the institute wherein
the petitioner is imparting education has not come before
the Court would not disentitle the petitioner to claim relief
for which he is otherwise entitled, as per law.
21.
In view of the above, the Court is of the
2026:UHC:437
considered view that the respondents are liable to
consider the case of the petitioner for grant of salary
w.e.f. the issuance of the GO dated 28.02.2014.
22.
The respondents are directed to consider the
case of the petitioner for payment of salary w.e.f.
28.02.2014 and to grant the arrears of salary w.e.f. the
said date i.e. from the date when the institute was taken
into grant-in-aid. The said decision shall be taken by the
respondents in the light of the observation made above
and in the light of the order passed by the Court in writ
WPMS No.1820 of 2017 as affirmed by the Court in
Special Appeal No.166 of 2019.
23.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a
period of two months from the date of production of
certified copy of the order.
24.
With the above observations, the writ petition
stands disposed of.
25.
As
a
sequel
thereto,
the
miscellaneous
applications, if any pending, shall stand closed.
___________________
SUBHASH UPADHYAY, J.
Dt:02.01.2026
Sukhbant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review