Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010123462026
2026:UHC:5893-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
THE HON’BLE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA
AND
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE MR. SUBHASH UPADHYAY
WRIT PETITION (S/B) NO. 449 of 2026
16th July, 2026
Dr. Manoj Kumar
-----Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Others
----Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:Ms. Prabha Naithani, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Mr. M.S. Bisht, learned Brief Holder for the State.
Mr. Gaurav Nagpal, learned counsel holding brief of Mr. Ramji
Srivastava, learned counsel for the private respondents.
---------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT : (per Mr. Manoj Kumar Gupta C. J.)
1.
The present writ petition has been filed
assailing the order dated 03.01.2026, passed by the
Secretary, Department of Medical Health and Medical
Education,
Government
of
Uttarakhand,
thereby,
rejecting the representation filed by the petitioner in
pursuance of the liberty granted to the petitioner vide
order dated 16.01.2026, while deciding his previous
writ petition (WPSB No. 36/2026).
2.
The background facts are clear from our
previous order dated 16.01.2026 in WPSB No.36/2026,
which is as follows:“1) The petitioner by means of present writ petition has assailed the Office
Memorandum dated 24.12.2025, passed by the Secretary, Department of
Medical Health & Medical Education, Government of Uttarakhand,
whereby the representation of the petitioner for grant of relaxation in
upper age limit for participation in the selection process for the selection
of Medical Officers in the Uttarakhand Medical and Health Services has
UKHC010123462026
2026:UHC:5893-DB
been rejected. The petitioner has also prayed for quashing of Clause 8 of
the advertisement dated 13.11.2025, whereby upper age limit of 42 has
been prescribed for participation in the selection process to the extent there
is no provision for relaxation of age.
2) The case of the petitioner is that he is working since 19th July 2024, as
Medical Officer, on contractual basis in pursuance of appointment order of
the even date. The initial period of contract was one year and it was
subsequently extended on 11.03.2025 upto 28.02.2026, or till regular
appointment is made. On 13.11.2025 the Uttarakhand Medical Service
Selection Board issued an advertisement for holding selection on the post
of Medical Officer (Ordinary Grade). The said advertisement was in
respect of 287 vacant posts including back log vacancies through direct
recruitment in the Uttarakhand Provincial Medical and Health Service
Cadre. The petitioner who had worked on contractual basis for more than
01 year 03 months was overage on the prescribed cutoff date. On
27.11.2025, the petitioner submitted a representation to the Secretary,
Medical Health and Family Welfare, Government of Uttarakhand for
providing relaxation in upper age limit to the petitioner to enable him to
participate in the selection process. The petitioner claimed relaxation on
the ground that he had been working on contractual basis as Medical
Officer since July 2024, and like him there were several other persons who
were also working on contractual basis and, consequently, the petitioner as
well as other such persons should be granted relaxation in the upper age
limit to enable them to participate in the selection process. The further
case of the petitioner is that power in this regard is vested in the State
under the Uttarakhand Public Service (Relaxation in Age Limit for
Recruitment) Rules, 2003 (hereinafter referred to as “Relaxation Rules
2003”), notified on 18.02.2003. Rule 3 thereof enables the State
Government to grant relaxation in upper age limit for appointment to
public services in respect of any particular candidate or class of
candidates. As the representation of the petitioner remained pending while,
on the other hand, the selection process was in progress and, therefore, the
petitioner filed Writ No. 531 (S/B) of 2025 before this Court praying for
quashing of Clause 8 of the advertisement and for directing the
respondents to consider his candidature for grant of age relaxation as per
the provisions contained in the Relaxation Rules 2003. The said writ
petition was disposed of by this Court by order dated 9th December 2025
directing the State to decide the representation of the petitioner dated
27.11.2025, within a period of two weeks, in accordance with law. It was
further provided that in case the representation is allowed, the petitioner
would be permitted to participate in the selection process in pursuance of
advertisement dated 13.11.2025.
3) In pursuance of the aforesaid direction the representation of the
petitioner for relaxation in upper age limit has been considered and
rejected by the impugned order dated 24.12.2025.
4) Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the representation has
been rejected solely placing reliance on Rule 10 of the Uttarakhand
Provincial Medical and Health Service Rules 2014 and Uttarakhand
Recruitment in Service Age Limit Rules 2014, and the first amendment
made therein vide Notification dated 25.02.2014. The Relaxation Rules
2003 which have overriding effect over the service rules have not been
considered.
5) Learned counsel for the State, on the other hand, submits that the
Uttarakhand Recruitment in Service Age Limit Rules 2014 prescribes
upper age limit of 42 years and, therefore, the representation has been
rightly rejected. He further submits that even under the Relaxation Rules
UKHC010123462026
2026:UHC:5893-DB
2003, no candidate seeking relaxation in age has any indefeasible right to
claim relaxation and, therefore, no interference is warranted.
6) Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Uttarakhand Medical
Service Selection Board, Dehradun (respondent No. 3 herein) also makes
the same submission.
7) The recruitment to the post aforesaid is governed by the Uttarakhand
Medical and Health Service Rules 2014. Rule 10 thereof is as follows :
“10. Age –
A candidate for direct recruitment must have attained the age of 21
years and must not have attained the age of more than 35 years on
January 1 of the year in which recruitment is to be made, if the
posts are advertised during the period January 1 to June 30 and on
July 1 if the posts are advertised during the period July 1 to
December 31, the age must be maximum 35 years. Provided that
the upper age limit in the case of candidates belonging to the
Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes and
such other categories as may be notified by the Government from
time to time shall be greater by such number of years as may be
specified.”
8) The State Government framed Uttarakhand Recruitment in Service
Upper Age Limit Rules 2014 in exercise of power under Article 309 of the
Constitution 5 2026:UHC:558-DB and thereby it was provided that in all
services and posts where under the relevant service Rules upper age limit
is 35 years, the same would stand enhanced to 40 years. The said Rule 2 of
the Age Limit Rules 2014 was amended on 25th February 2014, and
thereby the upper age limit was enhanced from 40 years to 42 years. The
Notification dated 25.02.2014, is as follows :
mRrjk[k.M ‘kklu dkfeZd vuqHkkx & 2
la[;k 107@XXX(2)/2014 55(41) 2004
nsgjknwu% fnukad 25 Qjojh 2014
vf/klwpuk
jkT;iky ^Hkkjr dk lafo/kku* ds vuqPNsn 309 ds
ijUrqd ds }kjk iznRr ‘kfDr;ksa dk iz;ksx djds] mRrjk[k.M
lsokvksa esa HkrhZ ¼vk;q lhek½ fu;ekoyh] 2014 esa la’kks/ku djus ds
mn~ns’; ls fuEufyf[kr fu;ekoyh cukrs gS%&
mRRjk[k.M lsokvksa esa HkrhZ ¼vk;q lhek½ ¼izFke la’kks/ku½ fue;koyh] 2014
laf{kIr uke vkSj izkjEHk
1 ¼1½
bl
fu;ekoyh
dk
laf{kIr
uke
mRrjk[k.M lsokvksa esa HkrhZ ¼vk;q lhek½ ¼izFke
la’kks/ku½ fu;ekoyh] 2014 gSA
¼2½ ;g rqjUr izo`Rr gksxhA
fu;e 2 dk la’kks/ku
2 mRRkjk[k.M lsokvksa esa HkrhZ ¼vk;q lhek½
fue;koyh 2014 esa uhps LrEHk & 1 esa fn;s x;s
fo|eku fu;e 2 ds LFkku ij LrEHk & 2 esa
fn;k x;k fu;e j[k fn;k
s
UKHC010123462026
2026:UHC:5893-DB
LrEHk & 1
LRkEHk & 2
fo|eku fu;e
,rn~}kjk izfrLFkkfir fu;e
2& bl fu;ekoyh ds v/khu ,slh leLr 2& bl fu;ekoyh ds v/khu
lsokvksa rFkk inksa ds lEcU/k esa ftu ij ,slh leLr lsokvksa rFkk inksa
HkrhZ ds fy, vf/kdre vk;q lhek 35 Ok”kZ ds lEcU/k esa ftu ij HkrhZ ds
gS] gsrq vf/kdre vk;q&lhek 40 o”kZ fy, vf/kdre vk;q lhek 40
o”kZ gS] vf/kdre vk;q lhek 42
gksxh;
o”kZ gksxh;
ijUrq
;g
fd
bl
la’kks/ku ls iwoZ tkjh foKkiuksa
esa vk;q lhek ;Fkkor jgsxhA
9) It appears that on the basis of the Rules 2014 and the amendment
carried out therein, respondent No. 3 while issuing the advertisement
prescribed the upper age limit of 42 years for the selection in question. The
said age limit is as per the service rules read with the Uttarakhand
Relaxation in Service Age Limit Rules 2014 and, thus, we find no good
ground to hold that the prescription of age limit under Clause 10 of the
advertisement is in any manner illegal or arbitrary. The submission of
learned counsel for the petitioner that in respect of various social
categories and other special category persons like Physical Handicapped
or Women there is provision for relaxation and, thus, Rule 10 to the extent
it does not provide for similar relaxation in favour of general category
candidates is discriminatory, is without any substance. The relaxation
under Clause 10 is in respect of social category candidates for which there
is reservation and relaxation provided under service rules and various
Government Orders.
10) Coming to the second submission that the decision of the State
Government does not take into consideration the Relaxation Rules, we
find substance therein. Rule 3 of the Relaxation Rules has overriding
effect over any service rule prescribing the upper age limit. Rule 3 of the
Relaxation Rules is as follows :
“3. Relaxation of age limit for recruitment –
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any rule
regulating the maximum age for recruitment to any service or post
in connection with the affairs of the State, the Governor may grant
relaxation in the maximum age limit in favour of any candidate or
class of candidates. Provided that in cases where recruitment is
made through a Commission, that body shall be consulted before
the relaxation is granted.”
11) Undoubtedly, no candidate has any indefeasible right to claim
relaxation in age but when the relaxation rule vests power in the State
Government to grant relaxation, and the petitioner who is already working
as Medical Officer, though on contractual basis, was claiming relaxation,
any order passed by the State Government should reflect application of
mind to the facts of the case and also that the State Government has
examined the claim being conscious of the fact that it has power to grant
relaxation. However, in the instant case, we find that the impugned order
has been passed wholly oblivious of the power of the State Government to
UKHC010123462026
2026:UHC:5893-DB
grant relaxation in the upper age limit. In view thereof, the impugned order
cannot be sustained and is, accordingly, quashed. The State Government is
directed to pass a fresh order taking into consideration the facts of the case
of the petitioner and the power vested in the State Government under the
Relaxation Rules 2003, within a period of two weeks from today.
12) As it is submitted that the interview is scheduled on 19th of this
month, therefore, it is further provided that the petitioner will be permitted
to appear in the interview provisionally but his result shall not be declared
and it would abide by the decision that would be taken by the State
Government on the representation of the petitioner in light of the direction
aforesaid.
13) The writ petition stands disposed of accordingly.
14) Pending application, if any, also stands disposed of.”
3.
It is not disputed before us that as per the
advertisement the prescribed upper age was 42 years
for unreserved category candidates. The candidates
belonging to the reserved category were entitled to age
relaxation as per the applicable Government Order. The
petitioner was admittedly overage. The respondents
while deciding the representation have taken into
consideration the Service Rules, 2014,
and the
amendments made in the Uttarakhand Recruitment in
Service Upper Age Limit Rules, 2003, as amended vide
Notification dated 25.02.2014, and have thereafter
observed that the said upper age limit of 42 years for
unreserved category was made applicable on a uniform
basis for all candidates appearing in the selection. It is
also
been
observed
that
even
in
the
previous
recruitments the same age was prescribed. In view of
UKHC010123462026
2026:UHC:5893-DB
these facts, the respondents have declined to grant any
age relaxation to the petitioner.
4.
The reasons given by the respondents while
declining to accept the prayer of the petitioner for age
relaxation cannot be said to be illegal or a result of
non-application
of
mind
to
the
relevant
factors,
therefore, we found no good ground to interfere with
the said order.
5.
Accordingly, the petition is dismissed.
6.
Pending
application,
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
(MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA, C. J.)
(SUBHASH UPADHYAY, J.)
Dated: 16.07.2026
KKS/PP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review