Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 683 of 2025
Date of Decision:19.05.2026
__________________________________________________
Manoj Kumar Sharma
...Petitioner.
Versus
Vinod Suri & another
...Respondents
Coram
The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
For the petitioner:
Ms. Chehak Khurana Bhalla,
Advocate.
For the respondents:
Ms. Shweta Sharma, Advocate.
4._________________________________________________
Romesh Verma, Judge(oral)
The present petition arises out of the order dated
07.10.2025, as passed by learned Rent Controller-II, Solan,
District Solan, H.P., whereby the application filed by the
present respondent/landlord under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC
has been allowed.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that present respondent
filed an Execution Petition No. 484 of 2013 against Vikas
Kumar. During the pendency of the execution, third party
objections were filed by the present petitioner under Order
21 Rule 97 CPC. Pursuant thereto, issues were framed by
the learned Rent Controller on 22.12.2018 and thereafter
evidence was led by the respective parties.
3.
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
The present respondent, namely Vinod Suri, tendered
his affidavit in evidence on 18.04.2019, a copy whereof has
been placed on record as Annexure P-11 at running page 48
of the petition. He was thereafter cross-examined on
04.07.2019. After the conclusion of his cross-examination, the
respondent/decree holder moved an application under Order
18 Rule 17 CPC seeking his re-examination.
4.
In the application, it has been stated that on the
previous date of hearing, the decree holder, Vinod Suri, was
cross-examined by counsel for the objector, Manoj Kumar,
who claims to be a tenant under the decree holder qua the
shop in question. The decree holder has, however, always
categorically maintained that Manoj Kumar was never a
tenant in the premises and has been occupying the same in
the capacity of a trespasser.
5.
It has been further stated that during the cross-
examination,
Vinod
Suri
was
confronted
with
certain
documents prepared by the police, and certain conclusions
were sought to be drawn therefrom, necessitating clarification
of the contents of those documents by way of his reexamination. It has been stated that the re-examination of
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
Vinod Suri is necessary at this stage to clarify the statement
made by the decree holder, Vinod Suri, qua the status of
Manoj Kumar in respect of the tenanted premises.
6.
The said application was contested by the petitioner
by filing a reply thereto. It was averred in the reply that the
application was an afterthought and had been filed with an
ulterior motive to prejudice the rights of the petitioner. It was
further stated that there was a delay in filing the application
and, therefore, the same, being devoid of merit, deserves to
be rejected.
7.
The learned Rent Controller, vide the impugned
order dated 07.10.2025, allowed the application filed by the
present respondent by permitting the decree holder to reexamine himself on the points mentioned in the application.
8.
Feeling
dissatisfied
the
objector/petitioner
has
approached this Court by filing the present petition under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
9.
It was contended by Ms. Chahak Khurana, learned
counsel for the petitioner, that the impugned order passed by
the learned Rent Controller is erroneous and liable to be
quashed and set aside. She has submitted that the
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
application filed by the present respondent under the
provisions of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC does not disclose
sufficient material to warrant its allowance, and that the
learned Rent Controller has passed a non-speaking order
without referring to the entire factual matrix of the case.
10.
She has further submitted that, in view of the
mandate laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, an application
under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC cannot be allowed in a routine
or casual manner, rather, a case has to be specifically made
out for the same. However, in the present case, the
respondent/ decree holder has failed to make out such a
case.
11.
The provision of Order 18 Rule 17 of the CPC reads
as follows:
“17. Court may recall and examine witness.—The Court
may at any stage of a suit recall any witness who has
been examined and may (subject to the law of evidence
for the time being in force) put such questions to him as
the Court thinks fit.”
12.
The said provision empowers the Court to recall any
witness, who has been examined and to put such questions
to him as the Court thinks fit. The legal proposition in this
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
regard has been discussed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Special Leave Petition Nos. 12012-12013 of 2025, titled
Shubhkaran Singh vs. Abhayraj Singh and Others,
decided on 15 May 2025.
13.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has held that the power
under the provisions of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC is to be
exercised sparingly and only in appropriate cases, and not as
a general rule merely on the ground that recalling the witness
and conducting further examination would not cause
prejudice to the parties. It has been observed that such an
approach is neither the scheme nor the intention of Order 18
Rule 17 CPC.
14.
It has been further held that Order 18 Rule 17 CPC
is primarily a provision enabling the Court to clarify any issue
or doubt by recalling a witness either suo motu or at the
request of a party, so that the Court itself may put questions
and elicit answers. Once a witness is recalled for the purpose
of such clarification, the Court may, of course, permit the
parties to assist it by putting certain questions.
15.
The Apex Court has held that the power under Order
18 Rule 17 CPC is not intended to be exercised routinely or
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
merely for the asking. If used in such a manner, it would
defeat the very purpose of the various amendments
introduced to expedite the trial. The Hon’ble Supreme Court,
in the said case, has held as follows:
“ 9. In this connection, we may refer to the following
observations in Sultan Saleh Bin Omer v. Vijayachand
Sirmal [A.I.R. 1966, A.P. 295.], which accords with the
above view:
“A close reading of this rule makes it obvious
that the right under that Rule to put question at
any stage or a suit or recall any witness for
that purpose, is given to the Court. The court
can put questions to the witness recalled, and
no cross-examination is ordinarily allowed
upon the answers to the questions put by the
Judge without leave…….. It cannot therefore
be said that an opportunity to a party to recall
any witness for the purpose of examining
cross-examining or re-examining is governed
by O. 18, R. 17 C.P.C. ………..”
10. We are of the opinion that if circumstances warrant,
an opportunity to a party to re-call a witness for
examining, cross- examining or re-examining can be
granted by a Court in the exercise of its inherent
jurisdiction under Section 151 C.P.C.
11. This Court in the case of Vadiraj Naggappa
Vernekar v. Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate,
reported at (2009) 4 SCC 410 more particularly para 28
held as under:
“28. The power under the provisions of Order
18 Rule 17 CPC is to be sparingly exercised
and in appropriate cases and not as a
general rule merely on the ground that his
recall and reexamination would not cause
any prejudice to the parties. That is not the
scheme or intention of Order 18 Rule 17
CPC.” (Emphasis supplied)
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
12. In
the
case
of K.K.
Velusamy
v.
N.
Palanisamy reported at (2011) 11 SCC 275, this Court
discussed the power of the Court under Order 18 Rule
17 of CPC. It was held that this power is only for
clarification i.e. to enable Court to clarify any issue or
doubt, it may have in regard to evidence led by parties
by recalling any witness so that the Court itself can put
questions to such witness and elicit answers. The
relevant paras 9, 10 and 19 read as under:
“9. Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code is not a
provision intended to enable the parties to
recall any witnesses for their further
examination-in-chief or cross- examination or to
place additional material or evidence which
could not be produced when the evidence was
being recorded. Order 18 Rule 17 is primarily a
provision enabling the court to clarify any issue
or doubt, by recalling any witness either suo
motu, or at the request of any party, so that the
court itself can put questions and elicit answers.
Once a witness is recalled for purposes of such
clarification, it may, of course, permit the parties
to assist it by putting some questions.
10. Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code is not a
provision intended to enable the parties to
recall any witnesses for their further
examination-in-chief or cross-examination or to
place additional material or evidence which
could not be produced when the evidence was
being recorded. Order 18 Rule 17 is primarily a
provision enabling the court to clarify any issue
or doubt, by recalling any witness either suo
motu, or at the request of any party, so that the
court itself can put questions and elicit answers.
Once a witness is recalled for purposes of such
clarification, it may, of course, permit the parties
to assist it by putting some questions.
xxx xxx xxx
19. We may add a word of caution. The power
under Section 151 or Order 18 Rule 17 of the
Code is not intended to be used routinely,
merely for the asking. If so used, it will defeat
the very purpose of various amendments to the
Code to expedite trials. But where the
application is found to be bona fide and where
the additional evidence, oral or documentary,
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
will assist the court to clarify the evidence on
the issues and will assist in rendering justice,
and the court is satisfied that non-production
earlier was for valid and sufficient reasons, the
court may exercise its discretion to recall the
witnesses or permit the fresh evidence. But if it
does so, it should ensure that the process does
not become a protracting tactic. The court
should firstly award appropriate costs to the
other party to compensate for the delay.
Secondly, the court should take up and
complete the case within a fixed time schedule
so that the delay is avoided. Thirdly, if the
application is found to be mischievous, or
frivolous, or to cover up negligence or lacunae,
it should be rejected with heavy costs.”
(Emphasis supplied)”
16.
The Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 1684 of 2016,
tiled Ram Rati vs. Mange Ram (D) through LRs and
others, dated 23.02.2016, while relying upon the judgment of
Vadiraj Nagappa Vernekar (dead) through LRs vs.
Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate (2009) 4 SCC 410, has
held that the provision of order 18 Rule 17 CPC is to be
sparingly exercised and in appropriate cases, and not as a
general rule, merely on the ground that his recall and reexamination would not cause any prejudice to the parties.
The power is discretionary and should be used sparingly in
appropriate cases to enable the court to clarify any doubts it
may have in regard to the evidence led by the parties. The
Apex Court in the said judgment has held as follows:
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
“12. In Vadiraj Naggappa Vernekar (Dead) Through
LRs. v. Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate1, this
principle has been summarized at paragraphs- 25, 28 and
29:
“25. In our view, though the provisions of Order 18
Rule 17 CPC have been interpreted to include
applications to be filed by the parties for recall of
witnesses, the main purpose of the said Rule is to
enable the court, while trying a suit, to clarify any
doubts which it may have with regard to the
evidence led by the parties. The said provisions
are not intended to be used to fill up omissions in
the evidence of a witness who has already been
examined.
xxx xxx xxx
28. The power under the provisions of Order 18
Rule 17 CPC is to be sparingly exercised and in
appropriate cases and not as a general rule
merely on the ground 1 (2009) 4 SCC 410 that his
recall and re-examination would not cause any
prejudice to the parties. That is not the scheme or
intention of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC.
29. It is now well settled that the power to recall
any witness under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC can be
exercised by the court either on its own motion or
on an application filed by any of the parties to the
suit, but as indicated hereinabove, such power is
to be invoked not to fill up the lacunae in the
evidence of the witness which has already been
recorded but to clear any ambiguity that may have
arisen during the course of his examination.”
13. In K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy2, the principles
enunciated in Vadiraj (supra) have been followed, holding
at paragraphs- 9 and 10:
“9. Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code enables the
court, at any stage of a suit, to recall any witness
who has been examined (subject to the law of
evidence for the time being in force) and put such
questions to him as it thinks fit. The power to
recall any witness under Order 18 Rule 17 can be
exercised by the court either on its own motion or
on an application filed by any of the parties to the
suit requesting the court to exercise the said
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
power. The power is discretionary and should be
used sparingly in appropriate cases to enable the
court to clarify any doubts it may have in regard to
the evidence led by the parties. The said power is
not intended to be used to fill up omissions in the
evidence of a witness who has already been
examined. (Vide Vadiraj Naggappa Vernekar v.
Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate.)
10. Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code is not a
provision intended to enable the parties to recall
any witnesses for their further examination-inchief or cross-examination or to place additional
material or evidence which could not be produced
when the 2 (2011) 11 SCC 275 evidence was
being recorded. Order 18 Rule 17 is primarily a
provision enabling the court to clarify any issue or
doubt, by recalling any witness either suo motu,
or at the request of any party, so that the court
itself can put questions and elicit answers. Once
a witness is recalled for purposes of such
clarification, it may, of course, permit the parties
to assist it by putting some questions.”
16. Some good guidance on invocation of Section 151 of
the CPC to reopen an evidence or production of fresh
evidence is also available in K.K. Velusamy (supra). To
quote paragraph-14:
“14. The amended provisions of the Code
contemplate and expect a trial court to hear the
arguments immediately after the completion of
evidence and then proceed to judgment.
Therefore, it was unnecessary to have an express
provision for reopening the evidence to examine a
fresh witness or for recalling any witness for
further examination. But if there is a time gap
between the completion of evidence and hearing
of the arguments, for whatsoever reason, and if in
that interregnum, a party comes across
some evidence which he could not lay his hands
on earlier, or some evidence in regard to the
conduct or action of the other party comes into
existence, the court may in exercise of its inherent
power under Section 151 of the Code, permit the
production of such evidence if it is relevant and
necessary in the interest of justice, subject to such
terms as the court may deem fit to impose.”
11 ( 2026:HHC:20397 )
17. Vadiraj (supra) and K.K. Velusamy (supra) have also
found affirmation by this Court in Bagai Construction
Through its Proprietor Lalit Bagai v. Gupta Building
Material Store3.
18. The settled legal position under Order 18 Rule 17 read
with Section 151 of the CPC, being thus very clear, the
impugned orders passed by the trial court as affirmed by
the High Court to recall a witness at the instance of the
respondent “for further elaboration on the left out points”,
is wholly impermissible in law.”
17.
Similarly, the Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 1172 of
2009, titled Vadiraj Nagappa Vernekar (dead) through LRs
vs. Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate (2009) 4 SCC 410
has held as under:
“16. In our view, though the provisions of Order 18 Rule
17 CPC have been interpreted to include applications to
be filed by the parties for recall of witnesses, the main
purpose of the said rule is to enable the Court, while
trying a suit, to clarify any doubts which it may have with
regard to the evidence led by the parties. The said
provisions are not intended to be used to fill up omissions
in the evidence of a witness who has already been
examined. As indicated by the learned Single Judge, the
evidence now being sought to be introduced by recalling
the witness in question, was available at the time when
the affidavit of evidence of the witness was prepared and
affirmed. It is not as if certain new facts have been
discovered subsequently which were not within the
knowledge of the applicant when the affidavit evidence
was prepared. In the instant case, Sadanand Shet was
shown to have been actively involved in the acquisition of
the flat in question and, therefore, had knowledge of all
the transactions involving such acquisition. It is obvious
that only after cross- examination of the witness that
certain lapses in his evidence came to be noticed which
impelled the appellant to file the application under Order
18 Rule 17 CPC. Such a course of action which arises out
of the fact situation in this case, does not make out a case
for recall of a witness after his examination has been
completed. The power under the provisions of Order 18
Rule 17 CPC is to be sparingly exercised and in
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
appropriate cases and not as a general rule merely on the
ground that his recall and re-examination would not cause
any prejudice to the parties. That is not the scheme or
intention of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC.
17. It is now well settled that the power to recall any
witness under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC can be exercised by
the Court either on its own motion or on an application
filed by any of the parties to the suit, but as indicated
hereinabove, such power is to be invoked not to fill up the
lacunae in the evidence of the witness which has already
been recorded but to clear any ambiguity that may have
arisen during the course of his examination. Of course, if
the evidence on re-examination of a witness has a
bearing on the ultimate decision of the suit, it is always
within the discretion of the Trial Court to permit recall of
such a witness for re-examination-in- chief with
permission to the defendants to cross-examine the
witness thereafter. There is nothing to indicate that such
is the situation in the present case. Some of the principles
akin to Order 47 CPC may be applied when a party
makes an application under the provisions of Order 18
Rule 17 CPC, but it is ultimately within the Court's
discretion, if it deems fit, to allow such an application. In
the present appeal, no such case has been made out.”
18.
The said exposition of law clearly shows that the
provisions of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC cannot be exercised in a
routine manner. Merely because re-examination or recalling of a
witness would not cause any prejudice to the parties would not
entitle the applicant to seek relief under the said provision.
19.
Now coming to the factual matrix of the case, a perusal
of the application demonstrates that the case set up by the
respondent/decree holder is that, during the cross-examination
of Vinod Suri, he was confronted with certain documents
prepared by the police, and some confusion remained qua the
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
clarification of the contents of those documents. However, the
application is silent and does not disclose which documents are
being referred to or what clarification is being sought by the
respondent/decree holder.
20.
Similarly, the learned Rent Controller has not assigned
any reasons for allowing the application. The only observation
made by the learned Rent Controller is that the proposed reexamination is confined to certain matters which may assist the
Court in reaching a just decision. However, nothing has been
clarified by the learned Rent Controller as to what clarification is
sought to assist the Court in arriving at a just decision.
21.
The learned Rent Controller has, in a cursory manner,
allowed the application, which is not sustainable in law as the
same is in conflict with the mandate laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court while dealing with the provisions of Order 18 Rule
17 CPC.
22.
Consequently, there is merit in the present petition and
the same is allowed and the impugned order dated 07.10.2025
is ordered to be quashed and set-aside.
23.
At this stage, the Court has been informed that the
Execution Petition No. 484 of 2013 preferred by the respondent
( 2026:HHC:20397 )
was filed on 24.08.2011. She submits that despite passing of
more than 15 years, the decree holder has not been able to get
the fruits of the decree as passed in his favour. The case file
reveals that the case is hanging fire for several years and on the
one pretext or the other the case is being adjourned just to
prolong the execution petition. Therefore, this Court directs the
learned Executing Court to decide the Execution Petition,
positively within a period of one month from the date of
appearance of respective parties. The parties undertake to
remain present before Executing Court on 15.06.2026.
24.
Before parting, it is made clear that any observation made
here-in-above shall not be taken as an expression of opinion on
the merits of the main case and the same shall be adjudicated
upon uninfluenced by any observation made here- in-above,
which are only for the purpose of the instant petition. Records
be sent back henceforth.
Pending miscellaneous application (s), if any, shall
also stand disposed off.
th
19 May, 2026
(Nisha)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review